Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:29871-
CGHC010365622023
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
FA(MAT) No. 319 of 2023
1. Raju Kushwaha S/o Shri Dinesh Kushwaha Aged About 25
Years Caste- Koiri , Occupation- Agriculture, R/o VillageSohga,
Post-
Karji,
Police
Station-
Darima,
Tahsil-
Ambikapur,, District : Surguja (Ambikapur), Chhattisgarh
... Appellant
versus
1. Smt. Lalita Kushwaha W/o Raju Kushwaha Aged About 21
Years
Caste-
Koiri,
Occupation-
Service
(Employment
Assistant), R/o Village- Sambalpur (Semra), Post- Latori,
Police Station- Jaynagar, Tahsil- Surajpur,, District : Surajpur,
Chhattisgarh
... Respondent
For Appellant
:
Mr. Puneet Ruparel, Advocate
DB: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Parth Prateem Sahu,J
& Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sachin Singh Rajput, J
Order on Board
Per Parth Prateem Sahu, J
10.07.2026
1. This appeal is filed by appellant-husband against the
judgment dated 05.10.2023 of learned Family Judge,
Ambikapur refusing the grant of decree of divorce to the
husband.
2. Factual matrix of case, in short, is that marriage of the parties
took place in accordance with Hindu rites and rituals on
11.5.2017. After the marriage, respondent-wife did not want
to do domestic works and used to quarrel with him and his
parents if asked to do domestic works. She had been residing
2-3 days in a week with appellant and rests of days in her
parental home. She used to go to her parental home without
any intimation and used to return after several visits of
appellant to take her back home. At the time of Durga pooja,
when appellant and his father visited parental home of
respondent to take her back, she refused to come, he was
attacked and assaulted by his father-in-law and also
attempted to administer poison to his father. They somehow
managed to save themselves and flee from there. A meeting
of community at the parental home of respondent was
convened in respect of disputes between them and in which
she was advised by elderly members of community to live
peacefully in her matrimonial home and to visit her parental
home with the permission of her husband and in-laws. On the
advise of elderly members of community, she returned back
to her matrimonial home but after 2-3 days she again went
back to her parental home without intimating anyone.
Appellant was patiently bearing torturous behaviour of
respondent wife with a hope that one day his wife would
change her attitude and give a conducive atmosphere to lead
a peaceful married life, but unfortunately there was no change
in her attitude. On 15.08.2018, respondent wife came back
from her parental home with appellant to her matrimonial
home, however, after staying for 2-3 days, she again went
back to her parental home. Appellant thereafter several times
went to respondent to bring her back but she flatly denied to
come back saying that she does not want to live with him and
asked him to perform second marriage. On 16.11.2018,
respondent wife gave birth to a girl child, but after delivery of
child, she went to her parental home without intimating
anyone and there she along with her family members killed
the child and gave false information of her death to appellant
over mobile phone.
Thereafter, all the efforts made by
appellant to bring respondent wife back to her matrimonial
home have ended in vain. Respondent wife has deserted the
appellant and living willingly in her parental home. A divorce
petition under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
(henceforth ‘the Act of 1955’) was filed by appellant, which
came to be registered as Civil Suit No.19A/2019, however,
based on compromise arrived at between the parties under
which respondent wife had agreed to live with appellant,
appellant had withdrawn the same on 26.2.2020. Thereafter,
appellant started residing with respondent in her parental
house, however, after few days, he was assaulted and ousted
by respondent and her family members regarding which a
written report was lodged by appellant on 11.7.2020 in
concerned police station but no action was taken by police
stating that dispute relates to non-cognizable offence.
Thereafter, appellant went to house of respondent wife many
a times, as also requested her over telephone to come back,
but she flatly denied to come back, leaving no option with the
appellant but to file application for dissolution of marriage by
way of a decree of divorce.
3. Respondent – wife filed reply to application denying the
averments made therein and it was pleaded that respondent
is an educated woman, after marriage she had been leading
happy married life with appellant-husband.
She always
treated parents of her husband and other family members
with full respect. Prior to marriage, she has been appointed as
Assistant Secretary in Gram Panchayat Sambalpur and after
marriage she has been attending the office from her
matrimonial home. During her stay in matrimonial home, she
never went on duty without intimating her husband or his
parents. There was no dispute between them for a period of
one year after marriage. Appellant or his parents were never
misbehaved or beaten in her parental home. It was further
pleaded that during her pregnancy, as advised by the doctor,
she was not doing much agriculture work, therefore, she was
abused and taunted by appellant and his father after
consuming liquor. They asked her to bring Rs.1,00,000/- from
her parental home, they used to treat her with cruelty and
tortured her in many ways. Being fed up with the persistent
ill-treatment, she had gone to her parental home and narrated
her parents cruel behaviour she was subjected to by her
husband and his father. Whereupon, a meeting of elder
members of the community was convened on 16.7.2018 in
which appellant and his father was advised not to harass her
in any manner after consuming liquor, to take her back to
home and take full care of her. It was further pleaded that
appellant left her at her house for the delivery of child,
however, after delivery of child, appellant or any of his family
members did not come to see the child. Suddenly the child
fell sick and died. It was further pleaded that on 24.2.2020 a
meeting of community was convened in which she and
appellant have agreed to live together happily in future and
pursuant thereto, the appellant had withdrawn the civil suit
filed by him for grant of divorce. Thereafter they resided
together in her parental home and after such resumption of
marital life, respondent became pregnant and gave birth to a
child on 13.11.2020.
In the month of July, 2020, when
appellant desired to go to his house, respondent asked him to
take her with him, but he did not take her with him saying that
he will take her next time. After about a week, appellant
returned back to her parental home, he was heavily drunk and
started hurling abuses. When they tried to stop him, he got
enraged and started giving filthy abuses to her and other
members of her family. Hearing this, neighbourers gathered
and on being asked by them not to hurl filthy abuses, he left
for his house on motorcycle and next day got lodged false
report in the police station. After delivery of child, appellant
did not come to meet her or their daughter and till date she is
maintaining her daughter by residing in her parental home. It
was pleaded that respondent wife has never denied to reside
with appellant. On the basis of aforementioned averments, it
was pleaded that application filed by appellant for grant of
divorce be dismissed with cost.
4. On the basis of pleadings of the parties, learned Family Court
framed 02 issues, afforded opportunity of leading evidence to
both the parties and on the basis of evidence, oral and
documentary, available on record, has held that appellant
failed to establish any of the grounds as envisaged in Section
13 of the Act of 1955 for grant of decree of divorce.
Accordingly, by impugned judgment and decree, application
filed by appellant-husband under Section 13 of the Act of
1955 for grant of decree of divorce has been dismissed.
5. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of appellant-husband
would argue that the factual aspects pleaded before the
learned Court supported by the evidence adduced on behalf
of appellant-husband, have not been properly considered and
as such, the judgment impugned is erroneous and not
sustainable in the eyes of law. He argues that after marriage,
the respondent used to avoid doing household works and
used to quarrel with him, his father and mother as well as
misbehave with them and used to go to her parental home
without informing him or her in-laws.
On 16.7.2018, upon
intervention and advise of elderly members of community,
respondent came back to her matrimonial home and after
staying for 2-3 days she again went back to her parental
home without any intimation to appellant. Appellant had
though instituted divorce proceeding seeking dissolution of
marriage, but there was again a settlement between the
parties, therefore, appellant with the bona fide intention of
giving another opportunity, withdrew divorce petition and
started residing in parental home of respondent wife.
However, instead of reciprocating this genuine attempt of
appellant to save the marriage, respondent wife continued to
treat him with hostility and ultimately subjected him to physical
assault and forcibly drove him out of her house. A police
report regarding this incident was also lodged by appellant.
He next contended that respondent wife along with minor
daughter is living separately from appellant since long in her
parental home, thereby appellant has been depriving of his
love and affection towards his minor daughter. Respondent
never shows any inclination to live with appellant, who tried
his best to establish marital life, but on each and every
occasion, she refused to go with appellant-husband. He
submits that the conduct and attitude of respondent wife
clearly indicate that she has no genuine and real interest to
lead marital life with the appellant and she wants to put an
end permanently to cohabitation. So, appellant had no other
option but to file the petition for divorce on the above grounds
as there was no possibility of reunion and the nuptial knot
between them had been irretrievably broken down. However,
application for grant of decree of divorce preferred by
appellant, which ought to have been allowed, has been
erroneously dismissed by learned Family Judge. Hence, he
prays that impugned judgment and decree be set aside and
decree of divorce be granted in favour of appellant.
6. We have heard learned counsel for appellant and perused the
record of the Family Court.
7. The question which is involved in this appeal for consideration
is whether learned Family Court is justified in rejecting divorce
application filed by appellant-husband under Section 13 of the
Act of 1955?
8.
It is trite that the relief of divorce under the Act of 1955 is
governed entirely by the statute. Either spouse may seek
dissolution of the marriage by invoking Section 13 of the Act,
but such relief can be granted only upon establishing one or
more of the grounds specifically enumerated therein. A
decree of divorce cannot be founded on mere allegations,
suspicion, conjectures, or the subjective dissatisfaction of
either party. The ordinary wear and tear of matrimonial life,
normal differences, trivial irritations, and day-to-day discord,
which are inherent in every marital relationship, do not by
themselves constitute a ground for dissolution of marriage.
The statutory ground pleaded must be established by cogent,
credible, and convincing evidence. It is, therefore, the duty of
the Court to carefully scrutinize the pleadings and evidence
on record to ascertain whether the petitioner has successfully
discharged the burden of proving the ground relied upon for
seeking dissolution of the marriage.
9. In case at hand, appellant-husband has sought a decree of
divorce contending in his application that respondent-wife
used to frequently visit her parental home without permission
and intimation to the petitioner and his family members. She
was not doing household works and on being asked to do,
she used to quarrel with appellant and his parents. She flatly
denied to come with appellant to her matrimonial home and
upon intervention by elderly members of community, she
returned to her matrimonial home but after staying for 2-3
days, she again went back to her parental home without
intimation. On 26.02.2020, in order to save marriage,
appellant withdrew divorce petition and started residing with
respondent wife in her parental home, but after some days,
he was assaulted by her mother, father and brother and
forcibly ousted hi, from the house. A report regarding said
incident was also lodged with police. Respondent-wife left the
house of the appellant-husband, went to her parental house
and she never came back despite all possible efforts made by
appellant husband.
10. Above are the grounds stated by appellant in the petition and
to establish the claim of divorce, appellant examined himself
as PW-1, his father Dinesh Kushwaha as PW-2, neighbourer
Shivshankar as PW-3 and Kalawati as PW-4. Besides oral
evidence, copies of order sheets of Civil Suit No.13A/2019
filed by appellant for grant of decree of divorce, application
filed under Section 13 of the Act of 1955, written statement
filed by respondent, compromise deed arrived at between the
parties, judgment dated 26.2.2020 in CS No.13A/2019,
written complaint submitted by appellant in Police Station
Jainagar on 27.7.2020, are exhibited as Ex.P-1 to Ex.P-8
respectively.
11. On the contrary, stand of respondent-wife is that her
behaviour was always respectful for appellant and his family
members. On account of her pregnancy, she was not in a
position to do agriculture work as she was doing earlier and
therefore, her husband and father-in-law, after consuming
liquor, used to abuse and taunt her and ask her to bring
Rs.1,00,000/- from her house. They were torturing her in
various manner and being fed up with which, she came back
to her parental home and only after intervention of elderly
members of community, she went back to her matrimonial
home on the condition that appellant or his father will not
harass her and take care of her. On 30.8.2018 appellant left
her at her parental home and did come back even after
informing him about delivery of child. Her husband is habitual
drunkard, if he stops consuming alcohol and mends his ways,
no dispute would arise between them. She never denies to
live with appellant. Respondent examined herself as DW-1
and one Kanti Singh as DW-2.
12. We have already gone through respective cases of the parties
as pleaded in their respective pleadings. Now, to consider
whether appellant-husband has been able to establish
ingredients required to be proved for grant of a decree of
divorce against respondent-wife, we will proceed to look into
the evidence adduced by the parties before the trial Court.
13. PW-1 Raju Kushwaha is the appellant-husband. He has
reiterated all the contents of his petition under Section 13 of
the Act of 1995. He has deposed that after the marriage,
respondent came to reside with him and after residing for four
days, left for her parental home along with her brother. She is
employed as Rozgar Sahayikan and she has been attending
her duties from her parental home.
Whenever he tried to
bring back respondent from her parental home, she used to
quarrel with him. His father-in-law used to say that he will not
send his daughter to her matrimonial home. Sometimes she
came back to matrimonial home with him. Once the father
and mother of respondent had assaulted him on his visit to
their house. His father was assaulted once. He has further
deposed that a community meeting was convened at his
instance and on being advised, respondent came to live with
him, but after 2-3 days she again left for her parental home.
Since 2017 respondent has been residing in her parental
home. A false report was also lodged by respondent against
him in Police Station Jairamnagar. He further deposed that
respondent during her stay in matrimonial home did not do
household works, rather compelled his parents to do
household works. He further submits that on account of
compromise arrived at between the parties, he withdrew
divorce petition filed earlier with a hope that respondent will
correct herself, but there is no change in her. Respondent did
not inform him about delivery of their child, got herself
discharged from hospital in haste as a result their newly born
daughter died. Respondent does not want to lead a married
life with him and therefore, he be granted decree of divorce
against respondent.
In the cross-examination, he has
admitted that respondent became pregnant for the second
time while residing with him and for convenience, she was
attending her duties by residing in her parental home. He
further admitted that he used to drink liquor sometime and
respondent does not like his habit of drinking liquor. He has
denied the suggestion that he resided in parental home of
respondent for six months or he used to quarrel with
respondent after consuming liquor. He has also denied the
suggestion that he has kept another girl with him.
14. PW-2 Dinesh Kushwaha is the father of appellant husband.
This witness broadly reiterates the version as to what was
stated by appellant (PW-1). He has deposed that daughter of
respondent is not born from his son. He has admitted that
after the compromise between the parties, appellant resided
with respondent in her parental home, however, after a few
days, he was assaulted and ousted from the house by
respondent and her parents.
15. PW-3 Shivshankar Singh has stated that his house is very
close to the house of appellant (PW-1). He has deposed that
respondent is in the habit of leaving matrimonial home and
used to frequently visit her parental home. However, he has
stated that dispute of appellant and respondent was never
taken place in his presence. He has admitted that after the
compromise, appellant and respondent have lived properly
and he never attended any meeting in which compromise was
arrived at between the parties.
16. PW-4 Kalawati is the neighbourer of appellant. She stated
that conduct and behaviour of respondent towards appellant
and other family members was not good, she did not do any
domestic work and did not cook food and serve to anyone.
She also stated about convening of a meeting of panchayat
with respect to dispute of appellant and respondent.
She
further deposed that whenever appellant had gone to parental
home of respondent to bring her back, she had come. She
has also deposed about filing of divorce petition by appellant,
its withdrawal pursuant to compromise between the parties
and staying of appellant at the parental home of respondent.
In cross-examination, she admitted that she never went along
with appellant to bring respondent wife. No dispute between
appellant and respondent had ever taken place in her
presence.
17. On the other hand, respondent examined herself and one
witness on her behalf. DW-1 Lalita Kushwaha is the wife
herself, while reiterating the version of her written statement
in her testimony, has denied all adverse allegations levelled
by appellant in her divorce petition as also statement. She
has deposed that she had never gone to her parental home
without consent of her in-laws. She denied that she was not
doing any household work in her matrimonial home.
She
deposed that whenever her husband or in-laws had come to
her parental home, they were always respected and she
never misbehaved with them. She denied the suggestion that
she is living separately from her husband without any reason,
her husband attempted to bring her back several times but
she refused to go with him. She also denied that she had ever
misbehaved or behaved in a disrespectful manner with
appellant or his parents. She denied that her brother and
father assaulted the appellant and ousted him. She denied
the suggestion that she does not want to live with her
husband and stated that she wants to live with appellant and
on being asked, she stated that she will go to her marital
home when her husband stop consuming liquor.
18. DW-2 Kanti Singh is a resident of village Sambhalpur i.e.
placing of posting of respondent wife. She shown her inability
to speak about conduct and behaviour of respondent with her
in-laws. She stated that she was present in the meeting of
Kushwaha society convened in respect of dispute between
appellant and respondent. She deposed that at the time of
delivery
of
respondent,
appellant
was
informed
by
respondent’s brother over telephone in her presence, but they
did not come.
19. Factual scenarios emerging from the evidence brought on
record by appellant-husband, as discussed herein-above,
would show that appellant filed divorce petition on 23.11.2020
seeking decree of divorce mainly on the grounds that
respondent-wife never respected appellant and his family
members; she was not doing domestic work; she did not
inform about birth of child; after she left her matrimonial house
for delivery of first child; he was assaulted and ousted from
the house by respondent and her parents; and that in spite of
best efforts by the appellant, respondent refused to live with
him.
20. When statements of respondent-wife made as DW1 before
the family Court is evaluated, it is found that she has
consistently deposed that she wants to live with her husband
and she would return to her matrimonial home when her
husband (appellant) stops consuming alcohol. There was
cohabitation between appellant and respondent as a result
she became pregnant and delivered second child on
13.11.2020. Divorce petition is filed after delivery of child i.e.
on 23.11.2020.
21. Marriage is an institution where bitter sweet instances happen
every now and then. It is a delicate relationship which is to be
nurtured with effort and love from both the parties. Normal
wear and tear of married life cannot be magnified to claim
dissolution of marriage. Conduct of the spouse has to be such
that it becomes intolerable for them to live with each other.
In the instant case, the instances pointed out by appellanthusband, though denied in written statement and evidence by
respondent wife, even if taken to be true, these instances are
in the nature of behaviour and attitude of respondent-wife and
pertaining to ordinary wear and tear, which is normal to most
marriages, if not all, not enough to dissolve the marriage by
way of a decree of divorce. If appellant-husband is granted a
decree of divorce on the grounds as pleaded in the present
case, it would amount to allowing his claim on mere asking.
22. In case of Gurbux Singh vs Harminder Kaur reported in
(2010) 14 SCC 301, referring to decision in case of Samar
Ghosh vs Jaya Ghosh, reported in (2007) 4 SCC 511, Hon’ble
Supreme Court has observed that while trivial irritations,
quarrels, normal wear and tear of married life which happens
in day to day life in all families would not entitle a party to a
decree of divorce; however, continuing and subsisting
unjustifiable and reprehensible conduct which affects the
physical and mental health of the other spouse may lead to
mental cruelty. In case at hand, Appellant-husband has not
been able to plead much less prove that respondent wife is
guilty of a conduct, which has made it difficult for him to live
with her.
23. For the foregoing discussions, we are of the opinion that the
learned District Judge has rightly recorded a finding that the
appellant failed to prove the grounds pleaded in the petition.
The said finding appears to be based on proper appreciation
of the evidence available on record and does not call for any
interference.
24. Consequently, the appeal being meritless is liable to be and is
SYED
ROSHAN
ZAMIR
ALI
Digitally
signed by
SYED
ROSHAN
ZAMIR ALI
hereby dismissed. A decree be drawn up accordingly.
Sd/- Sd/Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
roshan/-
Sd/-
Sd/(Sachin Singh Rajput)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review