Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:22563]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous (Petition) No. 9341/2022
Rajkumar Chaudhary S/o Shri Dayanand Chaudhary, R/o P.S
Bhaloth, Dist. Buhana, Jhunjhunu, At Present R/o C-81 Durgapuri
Machada, P.S. Harmada Dist. Jaipur City, at present Social
Security Officer, Employee State Insurance Corporation, Regional
Office, Jaipur.
----Petitioner
Versus
State Of Rajasthan, Through PP
----Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Saurabh Jain
Ms. Gayatri Korani
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Rajesh Choudhary-GA cum AAG
Mr. Gaurav Gupta-Asstt.G.A
JUSTICE ANOOP KUMAR DHAND
Order
27/05/2026
1.
The instant criminal misc. petition has been preferred against
the impugned order dated 02.09.2022 passed by the Court of
Special Judge, Prevention of Corruption Act Cases No. 1, Jaipur
Metropolitan-II in Case No. 20/2021 by which the application
submitted by the petitioner under Section 207 Cr.P.C. for supplying
the clone copy of the CD recording has been rejected.
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the issue
involved in the instant petition has already been set at rest by the
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court at the principal seat, Jodhpur in
the case of Kishan Agarwal Vs. State of Rajasthan and Anr.
while deciding the S.B. Criminal Misc. (Petition) No. 7905/2025 on
19.02.2026. Counsel submits that under these circumstances, the
[2026:RJ-JP:22563]
(2 of 8)
[CRLMP-9341/2022]
order impugned is not sustainable in the eyes of law and the same
is liable to be quashed and set aside.
3.
Per contra, learned State counsel opposes the arguments
raised by counsel for the petitioner but he is not in a position to
controvert the submissions made by counsel for the petitioner.
4.
Heard and considered the submissions made at Bar and
perused the material available on record.
Looking to the fact that the controversy involved in the
present petition has already been set at rest by the Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court in the case of Kishan Agarwal (Supra), held
as under:-
“The grievance of the petitioner in the present case is
with regard to denial of access to the electronic
material relied upon by the prosecution, namely cloned
copies of the conversation with the hash value of the
electronic record. Further the petitioner has sought the
production of the original recording device and supply
of complete recording and other material documents
with regard to the seized amount. The controversy
involved, therefore, requires examination of the legal
position governing disclosure of electronic records and
the rights of the accused in that regard.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in Sidhartha Vashisht
@ Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) reported in
(2010) 6 SCC 1, has emphasised that the liberty of an
accused cannot be curtailed except in accordance with
due process of law and that fairness in trial necessarily
includes fair disclosure of material collected during
investigation. The Court observed that the statutory
scheme under Section 207 Cr.P.C., places an obligation
upon the prosecution to furnish documents forming
part of the investigation record so as to enable the
accused to effectively defend the case. Similarly, in
V.K. Sasikala v. State, reported in (2012) 9 SCC
771, the Hon’ble Apex Court held that the right of the
accused to access documents forwarded to the Court
by the investigating agency flows from the broader
doctrine of a free and fair trial under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India, and such access must be ensured
where denial would prejudice the defence.
[2026:RJ-JP:22563]
(3 of 8)
[CRLMP-9341/2022]
The judgments passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court
in Sidhartha Vashisht (supra) and V.K. Sasikala
(supra) were considered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
the case of P. Gopalkrishnan @ Dileep v. State of
Kerala and Ors., reported in (2020) 9 SCC 161,
wherein it was held that contents of electronic storage
devices constitute electronic records and are
“documents” within the meaning of Section 3 of the
Evidence Act. The Hon’ble Supreme Court further
observed that, insofar as documents on which the
prosecution proposes to rely are concerned, the
investigating officer has no option but to forward all
such documents to the Magistrate along with the police
report. It was also held that Section 207 CrPC does not
empower the Court to withhold any document
submitted with the police report except where such
document is voluminous.
The Court further recognized the right of the
accused to get the cloned copies of the contents of the
memory card and pendrive as being mandated by
Section 207 CrPC and being part of his right to a fair
trial enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution of
India. The Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:"31........... Considering the aforementioned
Reports, it can be concluded that the contents
of the memory card would be a “matter” and
the memory card itself would be a
“substance” and hence, the contents of the
memory card would be a “document”.
32. It is crystal clear that all documents
including “electronic record” produced for the
inspection of the Court alongwith the police
report and which prosecution proposes to use
against the accused must be furnished to the
accused as per the mandate of Section 207 of
the 1973 Code. The concomitant is that the
contents of the memory card/pendrive must
be furnished to the accused, which can be
done in the form of cloned copy of the
memory card/pendrive. It is cardinal that a
person tried for such a serious offence should
be furnished with all the material and
evidence
in
advance,
on
which
the
prosecution proposes to rely against him
during the trial. Any other view would not
only impinge upon the statutory mandate
contained in the 1973 Code, but also the right
of an accused to a fair trial enshrined in
Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
[2026:RJ-JP:22563]
(4 of 8)
[CRLMP-9341/2022]
41. We are conscious of the fact that Section
207 of the 1973 Code permits withholding of
document(s) by the Magistrate only if it is
voluminous and for no other reason. If it is an
“electronic record”, certainly the ground
predicated in the second proviso in Section
207, of being voluminous, ordinarily, cannot
be invoked and will be unavailable. We are
also conscious of the dictum in the case of
Superintendent and Remembrancer of Legal
Affairs, West Bengal vs. Satyen Bhowmick &
Ors. wherein this Court has restated the
cardinal principle that accused is entitled to
have copies of the statements and documents
accompanying the police report, which the
prosecution may use against him during the
trial.
44. In conclusion, we hold that the contents
of the memory card/pen drive being
electronic record must be regarded as a
document. If the prosecution is relying on the
same, ordinarily, the accused must be given a
cloned copy thereof to enable him/her to
present an effective defence during the trial.
However, in cases involving issues such as of
privacy of the complainant/witness or his/her
identity, the Court may be justified in
providing only inspection thereof to the
accused and his/her lawyer or expert for
presenting effective defence during the trial.
The court may issue suitable directions to
balance the interests of both sides.”
The principle thus laid down by the Apex Court
governs the set of facts of the present case as well, as
the petitioner herein also seeks access to complete
electronic material relied upon by the prosecution.
The Co-ordinate Bench of this High Court, in
Ganpat Sharma (supra), while relying upon the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in P.
Gopalkrishnan @ Dileep (supra), observed that
supply of an uncertified CD, not prepared through
hash-value authentication, does not fulfill the statutory
mandate. The Court held as under:
“C. Non-Compliance with Section 230
BNSS – Supply of Documents
12. Section 230 of the BNSS mandates that in
cases instituted on a police report, the Court
shall, without delay, and in no case beyond
fourteen days, furnish to the accused copies of
all documents forwarded with the police report
under Section 193(6) BNSS.
[2026:RJ-JP:22563]
(5 of 8)
[CRLMP-9341/2022]
13. From the record, it emerges that although
the order sheet dated 17.09.2025 records that
copies of the charge-sheet “along with CD”
were supplied, there is prima facie substance
in the grievance that all documents forming
part of the police report were not furnished,
and that the supply was effected through the
investigating
agency
without
judicial
verification or grant of reasonable time to the
accused to ascertain completeness.
14. More importantly, where the prosecution
case substantially rests upon electronic
evidence, compliance with Section 230 BNSS
assumes heightened significance. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court in P. Gopalakrishnan @ Dileep
v. State of Kerala, (2020) 9 SCC 161, has
categorically held that the original memory
card constitutes a document, and the accused
is entitled to receive its authenticated clone
copy prepared in accordance with law. Supply
of an uncertified CD, not prepared through
hashvalue authentication, does not fulfill the
statutory mandate.
15. The furnishing of incomplete or legally
unrecognised copies strikes at the very root of
the accused’s right to effectively invoke the
remedy of discharge under Section 250 BNSS.”
A similar view was reiterated in Jaideep Mittal
v. State of Rajasthan (supra), wherein the
importance of ensuring fair access to electronic records
forming part of the prosecution material was
underscored. The Court held as under:
“6. It is imperative to underline that a
Coordinate Bench of this Court, in
Sanwarmal Raigar v. State of Rajasthan
(S.B.Criminal Misc. Petition No. 3313/2020
decided on 03.08.2022),underscored the
significance of ensuring the integrity and
authenticity of electronic evidence and it
has been held that the denial of access to
cloned copies of electronic evidence could
potentially compromise the accused’s right
to a fair trial. In this backdrop, the present
petition warrants a meticulous examination
of the principles laid down in the
aforementioned precedent.
7. Further, in the matter of Sanjay Singh
Kachhwaha
v.State
of
Rajasthan(S.B.
Criminal
Misc.
Petition
No.
8014/2022decided on 12.12.2022), the
[2026:RJ-JP:22563]
(6 of 8)
[CRLMP-9341/2022]
Coordinate Bench of this Court has
reiterated the necessity of providing the
accused with all the material evidence in its
pristine form to safeguard the sanctity of
the trial process. The Court emphasized that
the denial of such access amounts to a
violation of the procedural safeguards
granted to the accused, thereby vitiating
the fairness of the trial.
8. In light of these judicial pronouncements,
this Court observes that the impugned order
of the learned trial court fails to align with
the principles of natural justice and
established
legal
precedents.
The
perfunctory rejection of the petitioner's
application without substantive reasoning is
antithetical to the procedural rights afforded
to the accused under the criminal-justice
system. Therefore, in the interest of justice
and to uphold the constitutional mandate of
a fair trial, this Court finds it appropriate to
allow the petition, directing the learned trial
court to ensure the provision of a cloned
copy of the CD, the original recording
device, and the Hash value to the petitioner.
This direction is imperative to avert any
miscarriage of justice and to maintain the
integrity of the judicial process.”
The legal position governing disclosure of
electronic records, as noticed herein-above, obligates
fair access and supply of authentic copies of
prosecution material relied upon and collected during
investigation. The furnishing of incomplete or legally
unrecognised copies, or denial of authenticated copies,
not only impinges upon the petitioner’s right to a fair
trial as enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution of
India, but also strikes at the very root of the accused’s
right to effectively invoke the remedy of discharge.
Electronic
records,
unlike
conventional
documentary evidence, possess inherent forensic
attributes essential for examining their integrity and
authenticity. The cloned copy with the hash value of the
electronic evidence assumes particular significance, as
it is necessary to authenticate the chain of the
electronic record. In the absence of such safeguards, it
cannot be readily concluded that the electronic material
has been preserved and produced in an authenticated
manner. Denial of cloned copies of such electronic
records,
particularly
when
their
integrity
and
authenticity are intrinsically linked to recognized
[2026:RJ-JP:22563]
(7 of 8)
[CRLMP-9341/2022]
forensic attributes, would inevitably cause prejudice to
the accused’s right to effectively defend his case.
The summary of the charge-sheet available
illuminates that a CD was provided to the petitioner in
compliance with Section 207 Cr.P.C., which is in
absence of hash value. The facts stated in the
application clearly state that the clone copy has not
been provided nor the hash value. The order of the
learned trial Court also does not state that any such
clone copy with hash value of the recordings was given
to the petitioner. Merely supply of a CD is not sufficient,
in view of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court
as well as this Court. The petitioner was entitled to get
the cloned copies of the original recording with hash
value, relied upon by the prosecution, so that he may
know the authenticity of the electronic record.
This Court finds that the learned trial Court has
failed to properly appreciate the significance of the
electronic evidence and the settled legal principles
governing its disclosure. The issue relates to the
accused’s entitlement to access electronic material
relied upon by the prosecution. The petitioner has not
requested for any new documents, but has only asked
for material which cannot be properly verified. If a
document is not verified, the defence would not be able
to use it at the appropriate stage. Hence, the dismissal
of the application relying upon the judgments of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Orissa v. Debendra
Nath Padhi was not justified.
In light of the judicial pronouncements referred to
hereinabove, this Court observes that the impugned
order passed by the learned trial Court does not stand
in conformity with the settled legal position, the
principles of natural justice, and the requirements
governing fairness of trial.
Hence, this Court is inclined to partly allow the
application filed before the trial Court to the extent of
obtaining the clone copy of the original digital
recording. The question regarding the calling of the
original DVR, other documents, and manipulation in the
CD tendered, has to be decided during the course of
trial. This Court is not making any observation upon the
same. As the trial Court has also rejected the
application looking to the stage of the charges in the
trial, the petitioner would certainly be free to file an
appropriate application for the same at an appropriate
stage, which shall be considered in accordance with
law.”
(8 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:22563]
6.
[CRLMP-9341/2022]
The instant criminal misc. petition stands allowed and the
impugned order dated 02.09.2022 passed by the Court of Special
Judge,
Prevention
of
Corruption
Act
Cases
No.
1,
Jaipur
Metropolitan-II stands quashed and set aside to the extent of
refusing to supply the clone copy of the record.
7.
The Trial Court is directed to supply the clone copy of the
recording to the petitioner forthwith.
8.
Stay application and all pending application(s), if any, also
stand disposed of.
(ANOOP KUMAR DHAND),J
Ashu/44
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review