Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: September 29th, 2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC010447932025
+
W.P.(C) 10083/2025 & CM APPL. 41867/2025
RAJIV KUMAR RISHI & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Ms. Jyoti Verma, Advocate
(through VC).
versus
CENTRAL BOARD OF INDIRECT TAXES AND
CUSTOMSCENTRAL BOARD OF INDIRECT TAXES AND
CUSTOMS & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Anurag Ojha, CGSC.
Mr. Devvrat Yadav, SPC with
Mr. Kartik Sharma, GP and Mr.
Mauhan Chawla, Advocates for
UOI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
AMIT MAHAJAN, J. (Oral)
1.
By the present petition, the petitioner seeks direction to the
respondent authorities to consider issuance of license to all the
petitioners to act as a custom broker under the Custom Brokers
Licensing Regulations, 2018.
2.
Succinctly put, the petitioners had appeared for the Customs
Brokers Licensing Examination conducted as per Regulation 6 F
Category Examination, 2025 on 18.03.2025. The said examination is
governed by Regulation 6 of the Customs Brokers Licensing
Regulations, 2018. The grievance of the petitioners, in substance, is
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 10083/2025
KAUR
17:29:36
that the examination paper departed from the pattern followed for the
preceding two decades and there was an allegedly disproportionate
number of questions from Allied Acts. It is also the grievance of the
petitioners that certain questions were erroneous or ambiguous and
that the questions travelled beyond what could be reasonably expected
of an aspirant.
3.
Consequently, the petitioner seeks issuance of a direction to the
respondents to issue license to the petitioners to act as a custom broker
or seeks relaxation in the six attempts limit that is provided in the
Custom Brokers Licensing Regulations, 2018.
4.
The learned counsel for the petitioner urges that the question
paper broke the pattern of the preceding past twenty years. She
submits that previously the structure of the question paper focussed on
‘major acts’ that include the Customs Act, 1962, the IGST Act, 2017,
the Excise Act 1944, the Finance Act, 1994 along with its rules,
regulations, notifications, circulars, and policies. She submits that for
the past 20 years, the majority of questions pertained to the major acts
and only 5%-10% questions were asked from the Allied Acts. She
submits that in the examination conducted on 18.03.2025 as many as
65 out of the 150 questions were drawn from the Allied Acts.
5.
Per contra, the learned CGSC for the respondent submits that
the framing of the question conformed strictly to the prescribed
procedure. He submits that the syllabus of the examination as
prescribed under Clause 7 and sub clauses (a) to (r) of Regulation 6 of
the Custom Brokers Licensing Regulations, 2018 expressly includes
not only major acts but also allied acts relevant to the import and
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 10083/2025
KAUR
17:29:36
export clearance process.
6.
He submits that the inclusion of the questions from Allied Acts
was made in full conformity with the statutory framework and the
allegation that the same was out of syllabus is completely unfounded.
He submits that the question paper for the year 2025 was prepared by
qualified experts and were also duly vetted by the Committee
constituted for the said purpose.
7.
Having heard the counsel and perused the record, at the outset,
it must be noted that the scope of judicial review in matters relating to
competitive examinations is extremely limited. The Court does not sit
in appeal over the decision of an examining body nor does it substitute
its own opinion for that of subject experts. Judicial review is confined
to examining the decision-making process and interference is
warranted only when the process is vitiated by mala fides,
arbitrariness, or patent illegality.
8.
In the present case, the bone of contention stems from the
assertion that there was a substantial deviation in the examination
conducted on 18.03.2025 from the pattern followed for the past two
decades. The petitioners contend that previously, the paper
concentrated predominantly upon questions from major acts, however,
the paper for the year 2025 increased the number of questions from
the Allied Acts.
9.
Having taken note of the arguments raised by the parties, this
Court is not persuaded by the stance taken by the petitioners for the
following reasons.
10.
Firstly, merely because a stipulated pattern and proportion of
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 10083/2025
KAUR
17:29:36
questions was followed for a prolonged period does not tantamount to
mean that the concerned expert authorities are bound to follow the
same in all subsequent years. The petitioners have failed to
demonstrate any specific provision in the Custom Brokers Licensing
Regulations, 2018 that prescribes a numerical ceiling on the questions
to be asked from the major acts and allied acts.
11.
Secondly, the Custom Brokers Licensing Regulations, 2018
expressly contemplate the inclusion of questions from allied acts and
other laws for the time being in force applicable to EXIM trade and
the rules and regulations made under these Acts insofar as they are
relevant to clearance of goods through Customs. In that regard,
Regulation 6(7) of the Custom Brokers Licensing Regulations, 2018
lays down as follows:
“(7) The examination may include questions on the following:
(a) preparation of various kinds of bills of entry, bills of export,
shipping bills, and other clearance documents;
(b) arrival entry and clearance of vessels;
(c) tariff classification and rates of duty;
(d) determination of value of imported and export goods;
(e) conversion of currency;
(f) nature and description of documents to be filed with various
kinds of bills of entry, shipping bills and other clearance
documents;
(g) procedure for assessment and payment of duty including refund
of duty paid;
(h) examination of goods at Customs Stations;
(i) prohibitions on import and export;
(j) bonding procedure and clearance from bond;
(k) re-importation and conditions for free re-entry;
(l) drawback and export promotion schemes including the Special
Economic Zone scheme;
(m) offences under the Act;
(n) provisions of the allied Acts including the Central Goods and
Services Act, 2017 (12 of 2017) and section 5 of the Integrated
Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (13 of 2017), the Indian
Explosives Act, 1884 (4 of 1884), the Destructive Insects and
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 10083/2025
KAUR
17:29:36
Pests Act 1914 (2 of 1914), the Dangerous Drugs Act, 1930 (2 of
1930), the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 (23 of 1940), the
Central Excise Act, 1944 (1 of 1944), the Copy Right Act, 1957
(14 of 1957), the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act 1958 (43 of
1958), the Arms Act 1959 (54 of 1959), the Patents Act, 1970 (39
of 1970), the Narcotics Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act,
1985 (61 of 1985), the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 (29 of
1986), the Foreign Trade (Development and Regulations) Act,
1992 (22 of 1992), the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999
(42 of 1999), the Design Act, 2000 (16 of 2000) and the Food
Safety and Standard Act, 2006 (No. 34 of 2006) and other laws
for the time being in force applicable to EXIM trade and the
rules and regulations made under these Acts in so far as they are
relevant to clearance of goods through Customs;
(o) provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (49 of
1998);
(p) procedure for appeal and revision applications under the Act;
and
(q) online filing of electronic bills of entry and shipping bills vide
the Indian Customs and Central Excise Electronic Commerce or
Electronic data interchange gateway (ICEGATE) and Indian
Customs Electronic data Interchange System (ICES).
(r) knowledge of regulations, rules, notifications, etc. under the
Customs Act and other Allied Acts.”
12.
As is apparent from a reading of the Regulation 6(7) of the
Custom Brokers Licensing Regulations, 2018 as quoted supra, the
same specifically contemplates questions concerning Allied Acts,
however, no specific demarcation on the ratio of questions to be asked
from the Acts is provided.
13.
Consequently, the petitioners’ grievance that as many as 65
questions out of 150 questions were asked from Allied Acts and the
same renders the question paper defective fails to find favour with this
Court. What the petitioners essentially seek is a question-by-question
academic adjudication of the examination paper which is not
permissible.
14.
In addition to this, the petitioners have also sought to impress
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 10083/2025
KAUR
17:29:36
upon this Court that some of the questions in the question paper were
erroneous inasmuch as the said questions were not framed with proper
precision which rendered the answers to those questions ambiguous. It
has also been argued that these questions were out of syllabus and
could not have been reasonably expected by the aspirants. For
instance, the petitioners state that Question ID No. 149 asked “How
many digits are there in a PCIN (Primary Cargo Identification
Number) assigned by Customs to identify a cargo contained in single
Transport Document mentioning Actual Buyer and Seller?”. The
correct alternative to the questions in the answer key was “18 digits”.
It is the petitioners’ contention that the PCIN is generated by the
Customs automated system and that its digit structure was not stated
in the SCMTR provisions relevant to Customs Brokers. The challenge
here thus pertains to the question being out of syllabus and not how
the answer is demonstrably incorrect.
15.
For question IDs 76, 72 and 74, the question provided the
following:
“Question ID 76 What is the Customs Tariff Heading (CTH) of
Mozzarella Cheese?
A. 04061011
B. 04061009
C. 04061010 (Correct Alternative)
D. 04061012
Question ID 72
What is the Customs Tariff Heading (CTH) of Tamarind Kernel
Powder?
(A) 13032910
(B) 13022910
(C) 13023910 (Correct Alternative)
(D) 13033910
Question ID 74
What is the Customs Tariff Heading (CTH) of Sandalwood chips and
dust?
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 10083/2025
KAUR
17:29:36
(A) 12119053
(B) 12119054
(C) 12119048
(D) 12119051 (Correct Alternative)”
16.
For the aforementioned Question IDs 76, 72 and 74, the
petitioners’ principally object to the requirement of the candidates to
be able to recall the precise eight-digit classifications in a closed-book
examination. The grievance, in essence, thus pertains primarily to the
difficulty of the question and not whether the question per se was
erroneous or not.
17.
Similarly, Question ID 86 asked the following:
“In the Foreign Trade Policy, 2023 how many categories of items are
there in the SCOMET List?”
(A) 7
(B) 8
(C) 12
(D) 9 (Correct Alternative)
18.
In the question ID 86, the grievance of the petitioners stem from
the fact that the Categories as mentioned in the SCOMET List are
numbered from Category 0 – Category 8, for which reason the correct
alternative ought be to “8” and not “9” as provided in the answer key.
It has consequently been asserted that the question is ambiguous and
defective.
19.
Similarly, Question ID 41 asked which offence punishable
under Section 135 of the Customs Act would be non-bailable. The
petitioners contend that Section 135 does not itself use the expression
“non-bailable” and that the question improperly draws upon Section
104, concerning the power of arrest. The contention of the petitioners
herein, however, does not necessarily demonstrate that the underlying
proposition tested by the question was beyond the statutory
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 10083/2025
KAUR
17:29:36
framework. The mere fact that the term “non-bailable” is not
specifically mentioned in Section 135 does not, without more,
establish that a candidate could not lawfully be tested on the
consequence of the specified offence. The petitioners have therefore,
at most, demonstrated a possible issue concerning the drafting
precision of the question. They have however failed to demonstrate a
patent error in the substantive legal proposition identified by the
answer key.
20.
On the other hand, in the counter affidavit, it has been asserted
that every question and their corresponding answer were verified for
its accuracy by the expert committee constituted for especially for the
said purpose. It has consequently been asserted that since the legality
and veracity of each question and answer was verified by the expert
body, no ground to warrant exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226
of the Constitution is made out.
21.
This Court has considered the case of the petitioners’ in the best
light and in the opinion of this Court, at the very highest, it is the case
of the petitioners’ that certain questions could have been framed with
greater precision. The petitioners have however failed to demonstrate
how the same is marred with glaring discrepancies. It is well settled
that the key answer is to be presumed as correct unless, on the face of
it, the same is demonstrated to be wrong. It is trite that the onus is on
the candidate to not only demonstrate that the key answer is incorrect
but also that the same is marred with a glaring mistake which is
completely apparent and no inferential process or reasoning is
required to show that the answer key is wrong [Ref. Kanpur
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 10083/2025
KAUR
17:29:36
University v. Samir Gupta : (1983) 4 SCC 309]. The petitioners
however have failed to demonstrate any such glaring error in the
present case.
22.
Even otherwise, the manner in which the questions are to be put
to the candidates is a matter which is to be decided by the experts.
Only because some candidates were confused by the manner in which
narration of the situation was put in the question cannot be a ground to
interfere with the opinion of the experts. The mere possibility of
another interpretation, or the fact that the petitioners may have
understood a question differently, does not establish that the answer
accepted by the examining authority is demonstrably incorrect. This
Court, even otherwise, cannot sit in appeal over the opinion of the
experts and substitute its own view by re-examining the questions.
Determination of the nature and standard of questions to be included
in a competitive examination lies primarily within the province of
subject experts, and courts do not possess the institutional competence
to substitute their views for that of duly constituted expert bodies.
Once the expert authority establishes that the paper was prepared
within the notified syllabus and subjected to the prescribed expert
process, the burden shifts heavily upon the challenger to demonstrate
a patent defect [Ref. Chancellor v. Bijayananda Kar : (1994) 1 SCC
169; Sanchit Bansal & Anr v. Joint Admission Board & Ors : 2012
(1) SCC 157].
23.
Mere disagreement with the proportion of questions, without
demonstrating perversity or manifest error, cannot furnish a ground
for judicial interference.
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 10083/2025
KAUR
17:29:36
24.
Further, merely because the question paper was difficult does
not tantamount to mean that the same was illegal or defective and can
also not be a ground to increase the number of attempts provided in
the regulations or to issue a direction to the respondents to issue
license to the petitioners to act as a custom broker. The petitioners
have also unsuccessfully sought to impress upon this Court that the
percentage of candidates succeeding in the examination conducted in
the year 2025 is significantly lower than that of the preceding years.
The same, as well, does not persuade this Court to grant any relief to
the petitioners. The same paper was not only attempted by the
petitioners but also by many others, and merely because only a small
percentage of the candidates could succeed, is no ground to hold the
examination defective or grant license to the petitioners.
25.
In view of the aforesaid, no ground to exercise jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is made out.
26.
The present petition is accordingly dismissed. Pending
application also stands disposed of.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
SEPTEMBER 29, 2026/DU
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 10083/2025
KAUR
17:29:36
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review