Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
Date of decision: 29.01.2026
1. CR-9449-2025 (O&M)
Rajinder Singh
...Pe00oner(s)
Vs.
Prem Singh Sokhi
...Respondent(s)
AND
2. CR-9451-2025 (O&M)
Rajinder Singh
...Pe00oner(s)
Vs.
Prem Singh Sokhi and others
...Respondent(s)
CORAM:
HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE NIDHI GUPTA
Present:-
Mr. Gurdeep Singh Sherdil, Advocate for the pe))oner
in both the cases appear through VC.
***
NIDHI GUPTA, J.
CR-9449-2025 (O&M)
Present Civil Revision Pe))on under Ar)cle 227 of the
Cons)tu)on of India has been /led by the plain)1 for quashing of the
Impugned Order 28.11.2025 (Annexure P-1) passed by Learned Civil
Judge (Jr. Division), Ludhiana in Civil Suit bearing No. CS 1349/2023;
whereby the applica)on /led by the pe))oner/plain)1 under Order 11
Rule 1 CPC for interrogatories seeking admissions from the
respondent/defendant regarding material facts in issue in the suit, has
been dismissed.
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
-2-
CR-9451-2025 (O&M)
Present Civil Revision Pe))on under Ar)cle 227 of the
Cons)tu)on of India has been /led by the defendant No.1 for quashing
the Impugned Order 28.11.2025 (Annexure P-1) passed by Ld. Civil Judge
(Jr. Division), Ludhiana in Civil Suit bearing No. CS 3462/2023; whereby
the applica)on /led by the pe))oner/defendant under Order 11 Rule 1
CPC for interrogatories seeking admissions from the respondent/plain)1
regarding material facts in issue in the suit, has been dismissed.
2.
Both the above said Civil Revision Pe))ons are being
disposed of by this common order as both emanate from the same order
dated 28.11.2025; and are between the same par)es albeit in di1erent
suits, however in respect of the same issue, same property, and before
the same Court. For the sake of convenience, facts are being drawn from
CR-9449-2025 )tled as “Rajinder Singh vs. Prem Singh Sokhi.”and par)es
are referred to as per their status in CR-9449-2025 emana)ng from the
Civil Suit No. 1349 of 2023 /led by the plain)1/pe))oner herein.
3.
Brief facts of the case are that the pe))oner has /led Civil
Suit No. 1349 dated 23.02.2023 (Annexure P-16) seeking permanent
injunc)on restraining the defendant/respondent No.1 herein, from
demolishing the lintel and suppor)ng walls of the suit property as
described in the plaint; and for mandatory injunc)on direc)ng the
defendant to raise pillars and beams alongwith par))oned wall between
the respec)ve proper)es of the par)es. The respondent No.1 has also
/led Civil Suit No. 3462 of 2023 (Annexure P-16 in CR-9451-2025) for
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
-3-
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
permanent injunc)on restraining the pe))oner from interfering in his
peaceful possession in the suit property; and for permanent injunc)on
restraining
the pe))oner/defendants
therein
from
taking
any
photograph or making any video regarding the suit property.
4.
Facts of the case in chronological order are as follows: -
24.02.2023: In the Civil Suit No. 1349 of 2023 /led by the pe))oner,
exparte ad interim injunc)on was granted and status quo was ordered to
be maintained vide order dated 24.02.2023 passed by the ld. Civil Judge.
10.03.2023: Vide order dated 10.03.2023, the said exparte ad interim
injunc)on was vacated.
20.03.2023: ThereaCer, the respondent had /led an applica)on dated
20.03.2023 (Annexure P-5) under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC read with Sec)on
151 CPC, for appointment of Local Commissioner sta)ng therein that he
is not demolishing any part of the suit property rather he is planning to
construct a new building on the vacant plot.
01.09.2023: Respondent /led wriDen statement (Annnexure P-7) to the
Civil Suit No. 1349 of 2023 /led by the pe))oner.
21.11.2025: On 21.11.2025, pe))oner had moved instant applica)on
(Annexure P-2) for direc)ng the respondent to admit or deny the
interrogatories under Order 11 Rules 1,2 and 4 r/w Sec)on 151 CPC.
27.11.2025: Respondent had /led reply dated 27.11.2025 (Annexure P3) to the said applica)on of the pe))oner.
28.11.2025: Vide the impugned order dated 28.11.2025 (Annexure P-1),
the applica)on of the pe))oner for interrogatories has been dismissed.
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
5.
-4-
It is inter alia submiDed by ld. counsel for the pe))oner that
this Court vide order dated 14.11.2023 passed in CRM-M-56990 of 2023
had directed Assistant Advocate General Haryana to visit the spot and
submit report as to whether any damage has been caused to the house
of the pe))oner. Accordingly, AAG, Haryana visited the site and
submiDed report dated 29.11.2023 (Annexure P-9) before this Court
sta)ng therein that the respondent had damaged the house of the
pe))oner. Learned counsel further points out that in actual fact,
respondent himself has admiDed in his statement dated 20.07.2023
(Annexure P-15) made by him before the police that “A er which on 103-2023 when we started demolishing the house with the help of labour,
Rajinder Singh &led a complaint PGD 128757 dated 10-3-2023 against us
at police sta,on Model Town Ludhiana where we presented out side.” It
is submiDed that therefore, respondent has caused damage to the house
of the pe))oner.
6.
It is pointed out that even in the counter blast Civil Suit No.
3462 of 2023 /led by the respondent against the pe))oner, he had
undertaken vide statement dated 21.03.2023 (Annexure P-6) made
before the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Ludhiana, not to make
any demoli)on of the suit property. It is also submiDed that the
respondent has been taking contrary stand from )me to )me,
some)mes admiGng that he has carried out demoli)on and other
)mes, he is denying the same. It is contended that in the present
scenario, the Respondent/Defendant is repeatedly trying to pull wool
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
-5-
over the eyes of the Hon'ble Court by taking a recourse to the method of
suppression by not disclosing all the material facts fairly and truly and
presen)ng them in a distorted manner by manipula)on and
misrepresenta)on to mislead the court, all of which amounts to playing
fraud with the Court. Accordingly, pe))oner had /led instant applica)on
dated 21.11.2025 (Annexure P-2) under Order 11, Rule 1, 2 and 4 r/w
Sec)on 151 CPC calling upon the respondent to admit or deny
interrogatories submiDed by the pe))oner.
7.
It is submiDed that therefore, in this scenario, the Trial Court
was in error in dismissing applica)on of the pe))oner for
interrogatories. It is accordingly prayed that the impugned order be set
aside.
8.
No other argument is raised by learned counsel for the
pe))oner. I have heard learned counsel and perused the /le. I /nd no
merit in the submissions advanced on behalf of the pe))oner.
The interrogatories submiDed by pe))oner read as under: “a) whether you purchased a vacant plot (the suit property)?
b) If you had purchased a constructed property, disclose the
exact date when you demolished the old construc,on?
c) Disclose the exact date, when you started the
reconstruc,on of the property?
d) Disclose the exact date, when you &nished the process of
reconstruc,on?
e) What are the new property UID numbers and the new plot
No. re-designated to the half por,on (370 yd2) of plot No.
220-L that you purchased in 2016?”
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
9.
-6-
Interrogatories are designed to save the rigour of protracted
trial. However, the same cannot be misused for collec)ng evidence.
Clearly in the facts and circumstances of the case as noted above,
admission or denial by the defendant/respondent, of the above said
interrogatories would amount to giving evidence against himself. It is
established posi)on in law that party cannot be called upon to lead
evidence against themselves and contrary to their interest. It is upon the
plain)1 to prove his own case. In support, reference is made to the
following two judgements of the Delhi High Court passed in Micromax
Media Pvt Ltd v. M/s Hewle@ Packard India Sales Pvt Ltd, (Delhi): Law
Finder Doc Id # 2043299; wherein it is held that: “A. Civil Procedure Code, 1908 Order XI Rules 1 and 5
Interrogatories - Objec,ve of interrogatories is to narrow the
controversy and facilitate framing of issues on disputed facts
- Interrogatories cannot be used to shi the plain,>'s burden
of proof or to compel the defendant to answer ques,ons in
support of the plain,>'s case.”
10.
Reference is made to another judgment passed in Centrient
Pharmaceu0cals Netherlands B.V. v. Dalas Biotech Limited, (Delhi) :
Law Finder Doc Id # 1812872, wherein it is held that “....interroga,ves
by plain,>s to extract something, which it could do so in the cross
examina,on, cannot be allowed.”
11.
Furthermore, the respondent has already made known his
stand in his wriDen statement. From the pleadings of the respondent in
the wriDen statement as also documents relied upon by him, it would
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
-7-
appear that the respondent has already answered interrogatories
proposed to be served upon him. The conten)on of the pe))oner that
respondent has some)mes been admiGng and some)mes been denying
demoli)on is misconceived as admiDedly, vide order dated 10.03.2023,
exparte ad injunc)on granted in favour of the pe))oner direc)ng to
maintain status quo was vacated by the learned Trial Court. There is
nothing on record to show that the said order dated 10.03.2023 was
challenged by the pe))oner. Rather it is recorded in the impugned order
that “...the case remained pending for arguments on injunc,on
applica,on but instead of addressing the arguments on the applica,on,
the Ld. Counsel for plain,> su>ered a statement in the court on
02.03.2024 that he does not press the stay applica,on at this stage and
case may be &xed for evidence. Vide order dated 02.03.2024, the said
applica,on was disposed of being not pressed and issued were framed
and case was adjourned for evidence of the plain,>.”
12.
It is further recorded in the impugned order that “despite
availing several opportuni,es, pe,,oner failed to lead any evidence in
support of his conten,on in the suit.” The pe))oner therefore appears to
be deliberately delaying trial. In this regard, the relevant observa)ons of
the learned Trial Court are contained in paras 4 and 5 of the impugned
order dated 28.11.2025, which have not been controverted by learned
counsel for the pe))oner. Further, while dismissing the instant
applica)on, the Trial Court has relied upon the judgments of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in: 1) Transport Corpora0on of India Ltd versus Reserve
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
-8-
Bank of India & Another' 2017 (4) Civil Court Cases 612; 2) M Kishan
Rao versus R. Subramanyam, 2011 (2) RCR (Civil) 317; 3) Thakur Prasad
versus Md. Sohayal and others' Law Finder Doc Id #151818; and 4)
Renu Lamba versus M/s. Sangunity Exim (India), Law Finder Doc Id
#1470829. Learned counsel for the pe))oner is unable to dis)nguish the
above said judgments.
13.
The interrogatories do not even appear to be relevant to the
present suit in view of the following facts. It may be pointed out that the
pe))oner has failed to disclose before this Court in the present Civil
Revision Pe))on that the pe))oner had previously also /led CWP18722-2024 )tled as ‘Rajinder Singh versus State of Punjab and others’
(which is s)ll pending), wherein the pe))oner has challenged the
CLU/Change of Land Use granted by the Punjab government in favour of
the present respondent. In the said writ pe))on CWP-18722-2024,
against the judgment and order dated 13.09.2024 passed by a Division
Bench of this Court, the respondent Prem Singh Sokhi had approached
the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide SLP No. 24783 of 2024 )tled as “Prem
Singh Sokhi vs. State of Punjab and others”. The said SLP was disposed
of by the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide order dated 16.12.2024, as under:
“Heard Mr. Puneet Bali, learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the pe,,oner. The respondent No.7 is
represented by Mr. Charan Pal Singh Bagri, learned counsel.
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
-9-
2. On 09.12.2024, this Court had passed the following order
in IA No. 268040/2024, &led by the respondent No.7 to seek
modi&ca,on of this Court’s interim order dated 22.10.2024:“... 2. The grievance of the respondent No.7, who is
residing in the neighbourhood of the commercial
building, that is being constructed by the pe,,oner is
that, cracks have developed in his residen,al house.
More importantly, the commercial building that is
being constructed, with breakneck speed, does not
ful&l the building norms in the concerned area i.e.,
Model Town, Ludhiana.
3. The submission of the learned counsel for the
respondent No.7 is that if the ongoing construc,on is
allowed to be completed, it will cause serious prejudice
to the applicant, who is residing in the next plot of the
subject building.
4. On the above, Mr. Puneet Bali, learned Senior
Counsel submits that the main maHer is s,ll pending in
the High Court. But to assuage the concerns raised by
the respondent No.7 (applicant), it is submiHed that
the pe,,oner will &le an undertaking with the
assurance that any damage, which occurs in the
building of the respondent No.7, will be repaired
appropriately by the pe,,oner. Secondly, the pe,,oner
also will &le a clear undertaking that he will demolish
the structures, which is already completed up to
Basement + six Joors, in the event, the verdict in the
case is against the pe,,oner.
5. No,ng the above submission, the pe,,oner is
granted ,me un,l 11.12.2024, to &le the appropriate
undertaking on the above two terms. The latest
photographs of the building along with a cer,&cate of
the Architect which will also show the residen,al
building of the applicant in the adjacent plot must be
enclosed.
6. The IA be re-listed on 16th December 2024.”
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
- 10 -
3. Since then, the pe,,oner has &led the Undertaking
AKdavit on 12.12.2024, where the following undertaking is
given on behalf of the pe,,oner.
7. That in compliance of the order dated
09.12.2024 passed by this Hon'ble Court, the Deponent
is giving the following undertaking: a. That the Deponent shall appoint an
Independent Architect to ascertain if any damage has
been caused to the property of Respondent No. 7, Mr.
Rajinder Singh, situated at House No. 220- L,
Gujjarkhan Road, Model Town, Ludhiana due to the
construc,on undertaken by the Deponent. If any
damage is found to have been caused due to the said
construc,on, the Deponent undertakes to carry out
appropriate repairs at the property of Respondent No.
7.
b. That the Deponent further undertakes that, in
case the &nal verdict of CWP No.18722 of 2024, is
against the Deponent, the Deponent undertakes to
carry out demoli,on or abide by any other orders/
alterna,ve direc,ons of the Hon'ble High Court,
subject to the Deponent's right to appeal or pursue any
appropriate legal remedy available to him.”
4. The aKdavit is accompanied by the cer,&cate dated
11.12.2024 of the Civil Engineer, who conducted the survey of
the subject building. The photographs of the current stage of
the construc,on of the pe,,oner’s building along with the
photographs of the neighbouring building of the respondent
No.7, are enclosed in the Undertaking AKdavit. The
pe,,oner undertakes to repair the damage to the property of
the respondent No.7 if the same is caused on account of the
construc,on made by the pe,,oner. The statement is
accepted. The respondent No.7 submits that some damage
has already been caused to his building.
5. On the above conten,on of the respondent No.7, the
learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Bali, in reference to the
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
undertaking in Clause 7(a) extracted above, categorically
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
- 11 -
states that if any damage is caused to the property of the
respondent No.7, on account of construc,on ac,vity of the
pe,,oner, the pe,,oner will carry out proper repairs of the
property of the respondent No.7. He however points out that
neighbouring building of the respondent No.7 is not a new
building but was constructed few decades earlier.
6. Having regard to the above, we deem it appropriate to
order for closure of these proceedings by taking on record the
Undertaking AKdavit &led on 12.12.2024 along with the
appended cer,&cate of the Engineer and the photographs.
The Special Leave Pe,,on along with IA (IA No.
268040/2024) is disposed of in the above terms. The interim
order passed by this Court on 22.10.2024 will con,nue during
the pendency of proceedings before the High Court and will
abide by the &nal verdict in the CWP No.18722 of 2024.
7. Before par,ng, it is made clear that if Rajinder Singh
(respondent No.7) has any concern about damage being
caused to his building by the construc,on undertaken by the
pe,,oner, he may avail services of cer,&ed chartered
Engineer and then make appropriate applica,on before the
High Court, where the maHer is pending. In the event of such
applica,on, the High Court is at liberty to pass appropriate
order in terms of the aforesaid undertaking given by the
pe,,oner.
8. The observa,ons in the present order should not come in
the way of the High Court in deciding the pending maHer on
its own merits.
9. Pending applica,on(s), if any, stand closed.”
14.
Clearly therefore, the impugned order su1ers from no error.
In view of the above discussion, no ground is made out to exercise the
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
- 12 -
CR Nos.9449 and 9451 of 2025 (O&M)
revisional jurisdic)on of this Court. Both Civil Revision Pe))ons stand
dismissed.
15.
Pending applica)on(s) if any also stand(s) disposed of.
29.01.2026
(NIDHI GUPTA)
JUDGE
Divyanshi
Whether speaking/reasoned:
Whether reportable:
DIVYANSHI
2026.02.05 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review