Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
ATJAMMU
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
Reserved on: 04.08.2026
Date of pronouncement: 18.08.2026
Date of uploading: 18.08.2026
Rajinder Sharma, aged 69 years,
S/o Sh. Dwarka Nath,
R/o Quarter No. 174-A, Rehari Colony,
Jammu-180005
.....Applicant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through :- Mr. Amit Gupta, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Abhay Tandon, Advocate &
Mr. Gaurav Sadotra, Advocate
v/s
1. UT of J&K through
Principal Secretary to the Government
Finance Department, Civil Secretariat,
Jammu.
Email: psfinance-jk@nic.in
2. Excise Commissioner,
Excise Department, Excise and Taxation
Complex,
Rail Head Complex, Panama Chowk,
Jammu-180012.
3. Deputy Excise Commissioner (Executive)
Jammu.
4. Excise & Taxation Officer,
Excise Range, Samba.
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG with
Ms. Nazia Fazal, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The respondents issued a Notice Inviting Tender (NIT) for allotment of
liquor vends through e-auction. Pursuant thereto, the petitioner participated
in the e-auction conducted on 26.02.2026 in respect of the liquor vend
falling underExcise Range Samba-10 (Panchayat Chak Nazar Nandpur).
According to the petitioner, the bid log reflects that the final H1 bid of Rs.
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
1,16,50,000/-was accepted at timestamp 18:24:59:096, whereas another bid
of Rs. 1,15,50,000/- came to be accepted subsequently at timestamp
18:24:59:467. On the strength of the aforesaid entries, the petitioner alleges
an apparent inconsistency in the sequencing and processing of the bids,
inasmuch as a lower bid appears to have been processed subsequent to the
acceptance of an earlier higher bid, albeit within a span of milliseconds.
2.
The case set up by the petitioner is that the e-auction process conducted by
the respondents suffered from technical glitches. It is pleaded that
immediately upon being declared the H1 bidder, the petitioner brought the
alleged technical discrepancy to the notice of the respondents through emails dated 26.02.2026 and 06.03.2026. In the said communications, the
petitioner asserted that he had intended to bid only up to Rs. 55.00 lakhs
and that, in terms of the applicable policy, successive bids were required to
be enhanced in increments of Rs. 1,00,000/-. According to him, his last
intended bid was Rs. 55.00 lakhs; however, within a short span of time, the
bid amount displayed against him abruptly escalated to Rs. 1.155 crore,
which, according to the petitioner, indicated a discrepancy in the
sequencing and acceptance of bids during the closing moments of the
auction. The petitioner further pleaded that he was not financially capable
of operating the vend at such an enhanced amount and that the bid
ultimately reflected by the system did not correspond to the bid intended to
be submitted by him.
3.
On the aforesaid premise, the petitioner asserted that the final bid attributed
to him was the consequence of a technical/system error occurring during
the concluding seconds of the bidding process. He, accordingly, requested
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
the respondents to cancel the bid attributed to him and to allot the vend to
the H2 bidder. The grievance of the petitioner, however, is that the
respondents declined to accede to his request and informed him that, in the
event of his failure to honour the bid, his Earnest Money Deposit (EMD)
amounting to Rs. 50.00 lakhs would be forfeited and he would also be
liable to be blacklisted from participating in future auctions. Faced with the
aforesaid consequences, the petitioner claims to have deposited the
requisite bid amount under protest, which protest, according to him, was
also recorded in his communication dated 09.03.2026 submitted at the time
of deposit.
4.
The petitioner further claims that the bid log was enclosed with the
aforesaid communications and that he repeatedly apprised the respondents
of his inability to operate the liquor vend at the bid amount reflected by the
system, maintaining that the escalation to such an exorbitant amount was
attributable to a technical/system error in the e-auction process. As his
representations failed to yield the desired result and the respondents
proceeded with the allotment, the petitioner invoked the writ jurisdiction of
this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
5.
Through the instant writ petition, the petitioner seeks, inter alia, issuance of
a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the acceptance/allotment
arising out of the e-auction held on 26.02.2026, whereby he was declared
the H1 bidder at Rs. 1,16,50,000/-, primarily on the ground that the said bid
was the result of an alleged technical malfunction and, therefore, the action
of the respondents in acting upon the same is arbitrary and unsustainable in
law. A consequential writ of mandamus is also sought directing the
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
respondents to refund the licence fee amounting to Rs. 76,50,000/-, along
with interest, as also the Earnest Money Deposit. The petitioner has further
prayed for cancellation of the allotment of the vend in his favour and for its
allotment to the H2 bidder. In the alternative, he seeks refund of the licence
fee deposited by him in excess of Rs. 55,50,000/-, together with the Earnest
Money Deposit, or adjustment of the excess amount against the EMD
payable by him in future auctions.
6.
The respondents have resisted the writ petition, inter alia, on the ground
that no constitutional, statutory or legal right of the petitioner has been
infringed so as to warrant interference in exercise of the writ jurisdiction of
this Court. It is pleaded that the e-auction process was conducted strictly in
accordance with the applicable Excise Policy, which, according to the
respondents, stands validated by the judgment of this Court rendered in
LPA No. 11/2017, titled “Sandhya Devi and Others v. State of J&K and
Others.” It is further submitted that, pursuant to the said policy, the
Government has been notifying locations for allotment of JKEL-2 vends
from time to time and, for the Excise Year 2026-2027, as many as 305
JKEL-2 vends were notified for allotment.
7.
The respondents submit that, upon closure of the bidding process, the
petitioner was declared the H1 bidder by the system-generated mechanism
against the final bid amount of Rs. 1,16,50,000/-. Upon receipt of
representations from the petitioner alleging a technical flaw in the e-auction
process resulting in an abrupt escalation of the bid amount within
milliseconds, the matter was taken up with theJ&K Bank authorities, which
were responsible for the technical handling of the e-auction platform. The
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
Bank, vide e-mail dated 05.03.2026, is stated to have confirmed that there
was no technical glitch affecting the integrity of the auction process.
According to the respondents, the petitioner had selected the bid amount
and kept the bid-submission pop-up open without immediately submitting
the bid, thereby leaving the screen idle for approximately five minutes.
During this interval, the prevailing highest bid had already reached Rs.
94,50,000/-, whereas the bid of Rs. 55,50,000/- subsequently submitted by
the petitioner came to be rejected. It is further pleaded that the final bids
were placed during the last one to one-and-a-half seconds of the auction
and that the petitioner submitted two bids in quick succession, within
milliseconds of each other, apparently in an attempt to secure the H1
position and thereby obtain allotment of the JKEL-2 vend.
8.
The respondents further maintain that, though the escalation in the bid
amount was steep, the same was attributable to the petitioner’s own actions
during the bidding process and not to any defect in the e-auction platform.
Their specific stand is that, while the petitioner kept his bid-submission
window idle, the highest prevailing bid continued to increase and had
reached Rs. 94,50,000/-. The allegation of a technical/system error has,
therefore, been specifically denied. It is further contended that, having
accepted the H1 bid amount, deposited the requisite amount and acted upon
the allotment, the petitioner cannot subsequently resile from the
consequences flowing from his own bidding activity by attributing the
same to a technical malfunction, particularly in the absence of any cogent
material establishing such malfunction.
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
9.
The respondents have also disputed the petitioner’s interpretation of the bid
log. According to them, the bid log does not establish the existence of any
technical glitch. Rather, the clarification furnished by J&K Bank, which
monitored and managed the e-auction process at the back end, indicates
that the steep escalation occurred because the petitioner had kept his screen
idle for approximately five minutes, during which period competing bids
continued to be submitted. It is explained that the last two bids submitted
by the petitioner were successfully validated by the system; however, while
updating the corresponding entries in the database, a time gap of a few
milliseconds occurred, resulting in the apparent discrepancy in the bid
history. The Bank is stated to have clarified that such difference in the
timestamps had no bearing either on the determination of the final H1
bidder or on the final H1 bid amount.
10. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, while reiterating the
averments made in the writ petition, has drawn the attention of the Court to
the bid log produced on record. It is submitted that the petitioner initially
placed a bid of Rs. 47,50,000/- at 17:32:35:507, which was thereafter
enhanced to Rs. 48,50,000/- at 17:56:41:206, followed by another
incremental bid of Rs. 49,50,000/- at 17:56:41:822. The petitioner
thereafter submitted a bid of Rs. 53,50,000/- at 18:15:11:232, which was
subsequently enhanced to Rs. 55,50,000/- at 18:24:58:308. According to
learned counsel, the petitioner expected the bidding process to proceed
through corresponding incremental bids; however, after the bid of Rs.
55,50,000/- was submitted, the screen allegedly became unresponsive and
did not reflect the corresponding bids of the competing bidders. It is
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
contended that the petitioner could not reasonably have anticipated that the
bid amount would abruptly escalate to more than Rs. 1.16 crore.
11. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that, although the bid log
records the bid of Rs. 55,50,000/- submitted at 18:24:58:308 as having
been rejected by the system, such rejection was not contemporaneously
reflected on the petitioner’s screen. Referring to the sequence of entries in
the bid log, it is argued that the competing bidder submitted a bid of Rs.
1,14,50,000/-, whereafter a bid of Rs. 1,15,50,000/- came to be processed.
The petitioner lays particular emphasis on the timestamp entries pertaining
to the concluding bids and contends that he was ultimately declared the H1
bidder at Rs. 1,16,50,000/- on the basis of an entry which, according to
him, does not follow the chronological sequence reflected in the bid log.
The apparent incongruity in the timestamps is relied upon to contend that
the e-auction platform suffered from a technical malfunction, the financial
consequences whereof could not legally be fastened upon the petitioner.
The respondents, however, allegedly compelled the petitioner to honour the
bid by informing him that failure to do so would entail forfeiture of his
Earnest Money Deposit and blacklisting from participation in future
auctions. The submission, thus, is that the petitioner ought not to be made
to suffer financially for an error attributable to the technical system
employed by the respondents.
12. Per contra, Ld. Sr. AAG appearing for the respondents, has controverted
the aforesaid submissions and maintained that there was no technical
malfunction in the e-auction process. According to her, the petitioner kept
the bidding screen idle for approximately five minutes and thereafter
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
submitted two bids in quick succession within a span of milliseconds. It is
contended that, by that stage, the competing bidder had already submitted a
substantially higher bid and the petitioner appears to have submitted his
concluding bids upon noticing the prevailing bid position. Learned Senior
AAG submits that the e-auction system operates through a predefined
validation process and, where successive bids are submitted within
milliseconds, some time is necessarily consumed in validation and updation
of the corresponding entries in the database. In the present case, both the
concluding bids were successfully validated; however, a gap of a few
milliseconds occurred at the stage of database updation, which explains the
apparent discrepancy in the bid history. Such discrepancy, it is urged,
neither affected the integrity of the auction nor the determination of the H1
bidder and the final bid amount.
13. Placing reliance upon the terms and conditions of the Excise Policy
governing the e-auction, learned counsel for the respondents submits that
the writ petition is liable to be dismissed. It is contended that the petitioner
voluntarily participated in the auction process, submitted the bids attributed
to him, emerged as the H1 bidder and thereafter deposited the requisite
amount and operated the liquor vend pursuant to the allotment. Having
accepted and acted upon the allotment, the petitioner, according to the
respondents, cannot subsequently approbate and reprobate by seeking a
writ of mandamus for refund of the amount deposited or by seeking to
avoid the consequences of the bid voluntarily submitted by him. It is,
therefore, submitted that the petitioner, having consciously participated in
the bidding process and thereafter acted upon the allotment made in his
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
favour, cannot be permitted to avoid his contractual obligations merely by
attributing the escalation in the bid amount to an alleged technical error
which, according to the respondents, stands specifically negated by the
technical clarification furnished by J&K Bank.
14. Heard both the counsels at length.
15. The petitioner claims that his grievance did not receive due and meaningful
consideration at the hands of the respondents. His case is that, after
submitting a bid of Rs. 53,50,000/- at 18:15:11:232 hours, the e-auction
portal became non-responsive, whereupon he waited for the portal to reflect
the competing bids so as to enable him to assess the prevailing bid position
and take an informed decision regarding his further participation in the
auction. According to the petitioner, during the period between
18:15:11:232 and 18:24:58:308 hours, the portal did not reflect any
intervening or competing bids. However, when he subsequently submitted
a bid of Rs. 55,50,000/- at 18:24:58:308 hours, the bid amount, within a
matter of seconds, allegedly escalated to more than twice the amount
intended by him. It is on this basis that the petitioner contends that the final
bid attributed to him was wholly disproportionate to the bid intended to be
submitted. He further claims that, on the very day of the auction itself, he
immediately apprised the respondents that he was not willing to take the
vend at such an exorbitant price and was financially incapable of operating
the same at the escalated bid amount.
16. The principal contention of the petitioner is that the bid amount ultimately
reflected against him did not correspond with the bid intended to be
submitted and that such anomalous escalation appears to have occurred on
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
account of a technical or systemic flaw in the e-auction process.
Significantly, the communications addressed by the petitioner to the
respondents on 26.02.2026, 06.03.2026 and 09.03.2026 indicate that, right
from the date of the auction and until he was called upon to deposit the bid
amount, the petitioner consistently sought withdrawal from the bid and
requested that the liquor vend be offered to the H2 bidder. The grievance of
the petitioner is that these representations were not considered by the
respondents at the relevant point of time. The record further reveals that,
after institution of the present writ petition, this Court, vide order dated
01.04.2026, directed the respondents to accord consideration to the
representations submitted by the petitioner. It was thereafter, during the
pendency of the writ petition, that the respondents proceeded to consider
and reject the petitioner’s claim.
17. At this stage, reference may be made to the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in “National Highways Authority of India v. Ganga
Enterprises and Another”, (2003) 7 SCC 410. In the said case, the bidder
withdrew its bid before expiry of the stipulated validity period of 120 days.
As a consequence of such withdrawal, the performance guarantee was not
furnished and the agreement between the parties did not come to be
executed, whereupon the National Highways Authority of India invoked
the bid security/bank guarantee furnished by the bidder.
18. Aggrieved by the encashment of the bank guarantee, the bidder approached
the High Court seeking refund of the amount. The High Court proceeded
on the premise that, since the offer had been withdrawn before its
acceptance, no concluded contract had come into existence and, in law, it
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
was open to a party to withdraw its offer before acceptance. On that
reasoning, the High Court held the encashment of the bank guarantee to be
illegal. The matter, however, was carried to the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The Apex Court noticed that the bidder was fully aware of the stipulated
bid-validity period of 120 days and, therefore, knew that acceptance of the
bid could take place at any time during the bid period. The contention that
the bidder had been compelled to withdraw its offer on account of alleged
inaction or negligence on the part of the employer and, therefore, could not
be subjected to forfeiture was not accepted. The Supreme Court held, in
substance, that the bid security had been furnished against a specified
contingency, namely, non-withdrawal of the offer during the stipulated
period of 120 days, and once that contingency occurred, the employer
became entitled to invoke the bid security in accordance with the terms
governing the tender.
19. Reference may next be made to “Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. and Others v.
Dev Prabha and Others”, 2020 INSC 307. The dispute therein arose out of
an online e-reverse auction in which it was stipulated that the auction
would automatically conclude if a particular bid remained unresponded to
for a period of 30 minutes. Though the auction had initially proceeded in
the ordinary course, connectivity problems arose during the bidding
process. The employer, being conscious of the technical difficulty, took a
decision to resume/restart the auction process, which thereafter continued
for an extended period. One of the participating bidders subsequently
approached the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi seeking, inter alia, a
declaration that it had emerged as the successful L1 bidder and quashing of
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
the Letter of Acceptance issued in favour of another bidder, while also
relying upon the technical difficulties that had led to resumption of the
auction.
20. The learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition, inter alia, upon
finding that a level playing field had been afforded to all participating
bidders; that a connectivity issue had indeed arisen; and that the subsequent
resumption of the auction was permissible under the terms of the NIT. The
Division Bench, however, reversed the decision and held the consequential
proceedings to be invalid, principally on the ground that the technical glitch
had impaired the sanctity of the auction process and raised concerns
regarding procedural propriety and arbitrariness in the decision-making
process.
21. Upon the matter reaching the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the Apex Court
reiterated the limited scope of judicial review in contractual and tender
matters. It was observed, in essence, that even if there were minor
deviations from the express terms of the NIT, such deviations, by
themselves and in the absence of mala fides or demonstrable arbitrariness,
would not furnish sufficient ground for a constitutional Court to interfere
with and set aside the tender process at the instance of an unsuccessful
bidder. The emphasis was thus placed upon examining the fairness and
legality of the decision-making process rather than substituting the Court’s
view for that of the tendering authority.
22. Of particular relevance to the controversy at hand is the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in “Om Sairam Steels & Alloys Pvt. Ltd. v.
Director of Mines and Geology, BBSR and Others”, 2024 INSC 520. In
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
that case, during the course of an online auction, the bidders progressively
enhanced their bids and, by 06:09 PM, the bid had increased from 84% to
104.05% after as many as 136 bidding attempts. At about 06:13 PM, the
appellant, intending to improve upon the prevailing bid by the prescribed
minimum increment of 0.05%, once again accessed the online portal.
Instead of entering the intended bid of 104.10%, however, it inadvertently
entered 140.10% at the 137th bidding attempt. As no competing bidder
bettered the said bid, the e-auction concluded at about 06:17 PM, with the
appellant’s bid of 140.10% being recorded as the highest bid. Upon
noticing the error, the appellant immediately attempted to bring the mistake
to the notice of the authorities and sought rectification thereof.
23. Subsequently, vide communication dated 24.03.2023, the competent
authority informed the appellant that its bid of 140.10%, being the highest
bid, had been accepted and that it stood declared as the Preferred Bidder,
requiring it to deposit the first instalment of the upfront amount. Aggrieved
thereby, the appellant invoked the writ jurisdiction of the High Court,
asserting that the entry of 140.10% instead of 104.10% was a bona fide and
inadvertent human error. It accordingly sought quashing of the impugned
communication and recommencement of the e-auction process for grant of
the mining lease. The High Court declined to interfere, reasoning that, once
the appellant admitted having entered the bid of 140.10%, it could not
subsequently avoid the consequences thereof by pleading mistake. The
matter was thereafter carried to the Hon’ble Supreme Court, which
examined the controversy in the context of the peculiar bidding pattern, the
immediately preceding bid, the magnitude of the unintended escalation and
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
the conduct of the bidder upon discovering the mistake, and proceeded to
hold as under:
“We can safely conclude, having regard to the trend of rate of
enhancement of bid by the appellant [i.e., the appellant enhanced the
prevailing bid 47(forty seven) out of 137 (one hundred thirty seven)
times and its enhancement ranged between 0.05% and 2.00%] and
the fact that the bidders were playing safe by marginally increasing
the prevailing bid price to test each other leading to increase of the
Floor Price from 84.00% to a highest of 104.05% after 7 (seven)
hours of bidding, the appellant did not intend to enhance the bid by
36.05%. Even otherwise, it seems to make little commercial sense for
any intending bidder to outrun the other bidders by jumping from
104.05% to make an exorbitant bid of 140.10% when, till the
preceding bid, each one of them had evidently been crawling. In
view of the clear nature of error or mistake committed by the
appellant and the disproportionate punishment that awaits it, if
interference is declined by us, we are of the opinion that the path of
rendering justice to the parties has to be treaded carefully to ensure
that the interests of both the respondents and the appellant do not
suffer disproportionately.”
24. Reference may also be made to the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in “Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi and Others v. State of U.P. and
Others”, (1991) 1 SCC 212, wherein the Apex Court emphasized that the
concept of unfettered discretion is fundamentally incompatible with the
exercise of power by a public authority, since every such power is
conferred to be exercised for a public purpose and in furtherance of public
interest. The principle is not confined merely to any particular sphere of
governmental or administrative activity but extends to every field in which
discretion is vested in a public authority for achieving a public purpose.
The Supreme Court further underscored that, just as unfettered discretion is
antithetical to the rule of law, the notion of an administrative action being
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
wholly immune from judicial review is equally untenable. Irrespective of
the nature of the activity undertaken by the State or its instrumentalities,
their actions must satisfy the constitutional mandate of fairness,
reasonableness and non-arbitrariness embodied in Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. In this context, the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed
as under:“Conferment of the power together with the
discretion which goes with it to enable proper exercise of
the power is coupled with the duty to shun arbitrariness
in its exercise and to promote the object for which the
power is conferred, which undoubtedly is public interest
and not individual or private gain, whim or caprice of
any individual. All persons entrusted with any such
power have to bear in mind its necessary concomitant
which alone justified con ferment of power under the rule
of law. This was apparently lost sight of in the present
case while issuing the impugned circular.
Arbitrariness is writ large in the impugned circular
dated 6.2.1990 issued by the State of Uttar Pradesh. It
gives the impression that this action was taken under the
mistaken belief of applicability of "spoils system" under
our Constitution and the cavalier fashion in which the
action has been taken gives it the colour of treating the
posts of D.G.Cs. as bounty to be distributed by the
appointing authority at its sweet will. Such a change
even by a private party is made keeping in view his own
interest when he finds that the existing lawyer is not
suitable for the assignment and. therefore. without
making the change he incurs the risk of some loss. In the
case of the State, it is the public interest which should be
the prime guiding consideration to judge the suitability
of the appointee but it appears that the impugned State
action was taken in the present case with only one object
in view, that is, to terminate all existing appointments
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
irrespective of the subsistence or expiry of the tenure or
suitability of the existing incumbents.”
25. Keeping in view the principles of law enunciated in the aforesaid judicial
precedents, this Court now proceeds to examine the controversy on its
merits. The respondents have categorically denied the existence of any
technical glitch in the e-auction process. The petitioner, however, during
the course of hearing, invited the attention of this Court to the stand taken
by
the
respondents
themselves
and,
more
particularly,
to
the
correspondence exchanged with theGovernment Digital Initiative, Zonal
Office Jammu-Central, J&K Bank Ltd., which was associated with the
technical management of the e-auction platform. The relevant clarification
furnished by the Bank, in substance, records the following:
i.
The petitioner had selected the bid increment and kept the bidsubmission pop-up ready, but did not immediately submit the bid
and, consequently, kept the screen idle for approximately five
minutes.
ii.
With reference to Bid No. 20, the bid of Rs. 55,50,000/- was
rejected, whereas, at the relevant point of time, the prevailing
H1 bid had already reached Rs. 94,50,000/-.
iii.
At the time when the aforesaid bid came to be rejected, only
about one to one-and-a-half seconds remained before closure of
the auction.
iv.
It was possible that, owing to the limited time available, the
petitioner submitted two bids in quick succession in an attempt to
emerge as the H1 bidder.
v.
Where successive bids are submitted within milliseconds, each
bid first reaches the application server and undergoes
validation. Upon successful validation, the data is stored in the
database and thereafter reflected in the bid history. In this
process, a time gap of a few milliseconds may occur between
validation of the bid and updation of the corresponding database
record.
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
vi.
In the present case, both the bids submitted by the petitioner
were successfully validated; however, a gap of a few
milliseconds occurred at the stage of database updation,
resulting in the discrepancy visible in the bid history.
vii.
The Bank nevertheless maintained that the aforesaid discrepancy
had no impact upon either the determination of the final H1
bidder or the final H1 price, which stood identified at Rs.
1,16,50,000/-.
26. A perusal of the bid history reveals that the petitioner initially laid a bid of
Rs. 47,50,000/- at 17:43:47:003, followed by a bid of Rs. 48,50,000/- at
17:56:41:206 and thereafter another bid of Rs. 49,50,000/- at 17:56:41:822.
Subsequently, upon noticing the corresponding incremental increase in the
competing bids, the petitioner raised bid of Rs. 53,50,000/- at 18:15:11:232
hours, followed by a bid of Rs. 55,50,000/- at 18:24:58:308 hours. The
bidding pattern attributable to the petitioner up to that stage, therefore,
indicates that he had ordinarily been enhancing his bids in increments
ranging between Rs. 1 lakh and Rs. 2 lakhs, save for the intervening
progression reflected in the bid history.What assumes significance is that
the petitioner’s bid of Rs. 55,50,000/- is stated to have been rejected by the
system on the ground that, by then, the prevailing highest bid had already
reached Rs. 94,50,000/-. The bid history further reflects that, at
18:24:58:918 hours, the competing bidder submitted a bid of Rs.
1,14,50,000/-. Thus, within the concluding moments of the auction, there
was a substantial escalation in the prevailing bid amount, which forms the
core of the controversy raised by the petitioner.
27. The petitioner has placed considerable reliance upon the sequence reflected
in the bid log. According to him, the bidding history demonstrates that the
bids had initially progressed through relatively modest incremental
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
increases; however, during the brief interval between approximately
18:24:56 and 18:24:59 hours, the amount escalated dramatically, ultimately
reaching Rs. 1,15,50,000/- and Rs. 1,16,50,000/-. His further contention is
that the bid of Rs. 1,15,50,000/-, though shown to have been successfully
accepted, bears a timestamp subsequent to the bid of Rs. 1,16,50,000/-,
which was ultimately treated as the final H1 bid. According to the
petitioner, this apparent inversion in the chronological sequence of the
concluding bids lends support to his allegation that the e-auction process
suffered from a technical or systemic irregularity.
28. The respondents have sought to explain the abrupt escalation by contending
that the competing bidder had submitted a bid of Rs. 1,14,50,000/- at
18:24:58:918 hours, whereupon the petitioner, after noticing the competing
bid, submitted two bids in rapid succession in an attempt to secure the H1
position. The explanation offered by the respondents cannot be said to be
wholly implausible. Nevertheless, when examined in the backdrop of the
bid history and the technical clarification itself, certain aspects remain
insufficiently explained. For the petitioner to consciously respond to the
competing bid of Rs. 1,14,50,000/-, such bid ought necessarily to have
been displayed on his interface in sufficient time to enable him to perceive
the same, determine the next permissible bid and thereafter submit
successive bids before closure of the auction.
29. Significantly, the respondents themselves acknowledge that the petitioner
had kept the screen idle for approximately five minutes. The material
placed before this Court, however, does not satisfactorily explain whether,
during this period, the petitioner’s interface was contemporaneously
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
displaying the intervening bids or the prevailing H1 amount. The
petitioner’s consistent case is that, after submitting the bid of
Rs.53,50,000/- at 18:15:11:232 hours, the portal did not display the
competing bids and that he thereafter submitted the bid of Rs. 55,50,000/at 18:24:58:308 hours under the impression that the auction was
progressing through the incremental bidding pattern previously visible to
him. This circumstance assumes relevance because, had the prevailing H1
bid of Rs. 94,50,000/-, or the subsequent competing bid of Rs.
1,14,50,000/-, been duly and contemporaneously displayed on the
petitioner’s screen, there was no apparent reason for him to submit a bid of
merely Rs. 55,50,000/- at such a late stage of the auction.
30. There is yet another aspect which cannot be altogether ignored. The
respondents, on the basis of the technical clarification furnished by J&K
Bank, themselves acknowledge that the petitioner’s last two bids were
successfully validated but that, owing to a gap of a few milliseconds
between validation and database updation, a discrepancy came to be
reflected in the bid history. Thus, while the respondents deny that there was
any technical glitch affecting the outcome of the auction, the existence of a
discrepancy in the chronological reflection of the concluding bids is not in
dispute. The controversy, therefore, is not founded merely upon an
unsubstantiated assertion of the petitioner but also upon an admitted
anomaly in the manner in which the concluding bid entries came to be
recorded in the bid history.
31. This Court is conscious of the limitations of judicial review in matters
involving specialised technical processes and does not possess the expertise
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
to substitute its own technical assessment for that of the competent agency.
Nevertheless, the Court is required to examine whether the decisionmaking process satisfies the constitutional requirements of fairness,
reasonableness and non-arbitrariness. Viewed from that perspective, the
bidding pattern, the abrupt escalation of the bid amount during the
concluding seconds of the auction, the admitted discrepancy of a few
milliseconds in the bid history and, importantly, the petitioner’s immediate
protest after conclusion of the auction constitutes circumstances which
required meaningful consideration by the respondents. The petitioner’s
assertion that the final bid attributed to him did not represent the bid
consciously intended by him cannot, in the peculiar facts of the case, be
brushed aside merely by stating that both bids stood technically validated
by the system.
32. The petitioner’s conduct subsequent to the auction also assumes
significance. He did not wait for any adverse consequence to ensue before
raising the plea of technical malfunction. Rather, as noticed hereinabove,
he approached the respondents immediately after the auction and
consistently sought withdrawal from the allotment, requesting that the vend
be offered to the H2 bidder. Such contemporaneous conduct, though not
conclusive of the alleged technical malfunction, lends a degree of
credibility to his assertion that the final bid amount did not reflect the bid
he consciously intended to make.
33. Once a substantial and bona fide dispute concerning the integrity of the
concluding bidding sequence had thus been brought to the notice of the
respondents, they were required to examine the petitioner’s grievance
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
objectively and to consider whether, in the peculiar circumstances
obtaining on the record, he could reasonably be compelled to continue with
the allotment at the disputed bid amount. The grievance could not, in these
circumstances, have been rejected merely on the ground that the concluding
bids stood technically validated by the electronic system. What required
examination was whether the final bid represented a conscious and
informed act on the petitioner’s part and whether, having regard to the
circumstances in which it came to be recorded, holding him irrevocably
bound by that bid would entail consequences disproportionate to the
circumstances disclosed by the record.
34. The petitioner was allotted the vend upon being declared the successful H1
bidder and commenced operations thereof with effect from 01.04.2026.
The licence so granted is valid up to 31.03. 2027. In view of the aforesaid
position, the bidding process culminated in a concluded contract between
the parties and, therefore, they cannot now be restored to the position
obtaining prior to the conduct of the bid on 26.02.2026. At the same time, it
cannot be overlooked that the petitioner has not been accorded fair
treatment and that the grievances raised by him have not received objective
consideration at the hands of the respondents. The petitioner has been left
to bear, entirely at his own cost, the consequences of circumstances which
arose during the course of the bidding process itself. The respondents were,
therefore, required to duly consider the specific case set up by the petitioner
that, on account of a technical glitch during the bidding process, he was
constrained to opt for a vend which was beyond his financial capacity and
consequently exposed him to a substantial financial burden.
WP (C) No. 806/2026
CM No. 1827/2026
35. Having regard to the contractual obligations binding upon the parties, and
bearing in mind that the licensing of the vend is also a source of substantial
revenue to the State exchequer, this Court is of the considered view that, in
order to balance the equities between the parties, the financial
consequences flowing from the circumstances noticed hereinabove cannot
justly be made to fall exclusively upon the petitioner. The burden arising
therefrom, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, ought to be
apportioned between the parties in an equitable manner.
36. Accordingly, and for the reasons recorded hereinabove, the present writ
petition is allowed. A writ of mandamus is hereby issued, directing and
commanding the respondents to grant the petitioner a set-off to the extent
of Rs. 50.00 lakhs in respect of the bid amount in question. Since the
petitioner is required, during the subsistence of the licence, to make
advance deposits towards the respondents in respect of the vend from time
to time, the aforesaid amount of Rs. 50.00 lakhs shall be adjusted against
the future dues, if any, payable by the petitioner during the currency of the
licence. It is, however, clarified that the said amount shall not be refunded
or paid to the petitioner, but shall stand adjusted only against the
subsequent liabilities arising under the contract. Disposed of as such.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
JAMMU
18.08.2026
Manik
Whether this order is speaking: Yes/No
Whether this order is reportable: Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review