Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 144 of 2016
Date of Decision: 13.04.2023
JC-356629 W Nb Sub (Cipher)
Rajib Kumar Sarkar
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. B. Deb, Adv.
: Mr. R. Debnath, CGC.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
From what could be gathered from the contents of this petition, it
is noticed that the petitioner was enrolled in the Assam Rifles on 12.05.1989
as Rifleman/ORL (Operator Radio & Line). Thereafter, he had undergone
basic training course of 6 months at Assam Rifles Training Centre, Dimapur,
Nagaland and a further technical training course of six months at the same
centre whereupon, he was then posted at 9 Assam Rifles, C/o 99 APO.
2.
After four years of service, getting the opportunity for
remusteration/conversion of his trade to Havildar/Cipher
through
departmental selection process, being eligible, he volunteered for the same.
On being selected, he was appointed as Havildar/Cipher on 12.11.1994.
3.
When the 5th Central Pay Commission recommendation came out,
two financial upgradation for all Central Government Employees known as
the Assured Career Progression (ACP) Scheme came into being, which
scheme provides for granting or upgradation of financial benefits to an
employee who has completed 12 years of service and who is stagnant in the
same post and further, on completion of 24 years, if, the same employee is
still at the same post, he is entitled to the 2nd upgradation. This Scheme came
into force from 09.08.1999.
4.
Again, it is the case of the petitioner that he has been recruited as
Havildar/Cipher on 12.11.1994 on being remustered and accordingly, he is
eligible for the 1st ACP on 11.11.2006 after having completed 12 years in the
same post without promotion. However, the department has not granted him
this benefit within the stipulated period.
5.
The petitioner came to know that the Commandant 38 Assam Rifles
Bn. vide letter dated 23.06.2015 had written to Mahanideshalaya Assam
Rifles Directorate General Assam Rifles indicating his observations upon
checking the audited Initial Pay Statement(IPS) of the petitioner that it was
noticed that the petitioner was already granted 2nd ACP w.e.f. 21.05.2008
which is contrary to the relevant rules when in fact he should have been
granted the same only w.e.f. 01.07.2009. It is requested that the same be
rectified.
6.
Accordingly, the Mahanideshalaya Assam Rifles, Directorate
General Assam Rifles in reply to the letter dated 23.06.2015, vide letter dated
28.07.2015 has requested the Commandant 38 Assam Rifles Bn. to make
necessary amendment as regard the pay fixation of the petitioner which was
done so and the Pay slip issued to the petitioner for the month of July, 2015
reflected the changes made, inasmuch as, he was given one step down
increment.
7.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner filed representation dated
09.10.2015 seeking the intervention of the Commandant 38 Assam Rifles Bn.
to rectify the latest pay fixation, but in reply to this, the Commandant
informed the petitioner through letter dated 21.10.2015 that in his case, he
has been promoted to the post of Nb/Sub (Cipher) in the year 2008, that is,
after completion of 14 years in his service and as such, from the date of
remusteration he has been given the First Financial Upgradation and will
therefore not be entitled to the 2nd ACP till he complete 24 years of service
in the same post.
8.
Not being satisfied with the said answer, the petitioner filed another
representation dated 21.11.2015 with the same prayer for proper fixation of
his payscale, but even after a reminder to this by communication dated
18.12.2015, the respondent authorities have failed to reply to the same and
has not taken any positive steps to alleviate the grievance of the petitioner.
Hence this petition.
9.
Mr. B. Deb, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that
the petitioner having been remustered as Hav/Cipher on 12.11.1994, he was
never granted any promotion or financial up gradation under the ACP
Scheme till 2006. However, he was granted 2nd ACP on 21.05.2008.
10.
It is submitted that the reason why the petitioner was not granted
the 1st ACP was because the respondent authorities has taken the view that at
the time when he was remustered as Hav/Cipher, that was considered as
promotion and as such, his case does not come within the scheme of the ACP.
11.
In reply to this, the learned counsel has submitted that it has been
held by this Court in the case of Ashim Deb Roy v. Union of India & Ors:
WP(C) No. (SH) 412 of 2010 that changing of trade in Cipher category, that
is, Havildar/Cipher through remusteration is not a promotion and also not a
financial up gradation. Extracts of para 4 of the same was referred to in this
regard.
12.
The learned counsel has also pointed out that the respondents have
filed an additional affidavit dated 05.12.2019 before this Court bringing on
record an order issued by the Directorate General Assam Rifles, dated
15.02.2019, wherein the Assam Rifles in course of implementation of this
Court’s order dated 23.03.2017, has sanctioned the grant of 1st and 2nd
Financial up-gradation under ACP Scheme.
13.
However, the petitioner’s name appeared at Sl. No. 366 of the
annexed list showing the names of those personnel who have either received
the 1st or due to get the 2nd ACP indicating that the petitioner was deemed to
have been granted the 1st Financial Upgradation on being promoted to the
rank of Warrant Officer (Cipher) on 03.06.2000.
14.
To this, the response of the petitioner is that in terms of the common
judgment and order dated 23.03.2017 passed in WP(C) No. 403 of 2014 and
WP(C) No. 311 of 2016 in the case of Digamber Datt & Ors v. Union of India
& Ors has directed the respondents therein to give appropriate rank and pay
scales to the petitioners therein as per the Fifth Central Pay Commission and
Office Memorandum dated 22.01.1998. Nowhere in the said Office
Memorandum was it mentioned about any promotion to the post of the
petitioner herein, submits the learned counsel. Therefore, the assertion of the
respondents that the fact that the petitioner was promoted as Warrant Office
(Cipher) w.e.f. 03.06.2000 vide order dated 15.02.2019, the same is taken as
the 1st financial upgradation, cannot be accepted.
15.
Mr. R. Debnath, learned CGC arguing on behalf of the respondents
has submitted that it is an admitted fact that the petitioner was enrolled as a
Rifleman/ORL (Operator Radio & Line) on 12.05.1989 and was remustered
as Havildar (Cipher) on 12.11.1994. At the time of preference of this petition,
the petitioner has already been promoted as Nb/Sub (Cipher) from
01.01.2008.
16.
It is submitted that the petitioner has already earned two financial
upgradation, first when he was remustered as Havildar(Cipher) which post
carries a higher payscale than Rifleman, and secondly, on being promoted as
Nb/Sub (Cipher) on 01.01.2008 after completion of 19 years of service.
Therefore, he will now be eligible for the next financial upgradation only on
promotion to the next higher post, or after completion of 30 years of service
from the initial date of enrollment, or if he is stagnant at the same post for 10
years. This is in accordance with the terms of the Modified Assured Career
Progression (MACP) Scheme.
17.
As to the claim of the petitioner that he was never granted financial
upgradation or promotion at the time when he was remustered as Havildar
(Cipher), the learned CGC has submitted that remusteration is a method of
appointment which is counted as financial upgradation as per the relevant
recruitment rules. To this effect, the import of the letter No. A/Pers/II01/ACP/MACP/2011/1202 dated 28.11.2011 was referred to, wherein it was
indicated that “Remusteration is a method of appointment in Recruitment
Rules and it would be counted as financial upgradation for the purpose of
ACPs/MACPs”.
18.
Another aspect of the matter that was raised by the learned CGC is
the alleged reduction of pay of the petitioner by one increment and the
direction for recovery of the same.
19.
In this regard, the learned CGC has submitted that as per policy in
vogue, an incumbent who is promoted between 2nd January to 30th June of a
particular year is due to get the next increment in the month of July of the
next year. This is as per Rule 10 of the CCS (RP) Rules 2008.
20.
With reference to the Ministry of finance letter No. 10/02/2011-
E.III/A, dated 19.03.2012 (however copy of the same is not annexed herewith
or found in these records), it is seen that there is authorization for grant of
increment on 01.01.2006 to all employees whose increment is due in the prerevised scale from 02.01.2006 to 30.06.2006. This petitioner was promoted
on 21.05.2008, he had opted to continue in the pre-revised payscale till
20.05.2008 vide option dated 04.10.2008. One increment was wrongly
granted to the petitioner on 01.07.2008 when he is to get the same only on
01.07.2009. Therefore, the revised payscale and necessary deduction as
recovery is an exercise in due course and no prejudice is caused to the
petitioner submits the learned CGC.
21.
Finally, the learned CGC has submitted that the respondents would
rely on the following decisions in support of the contention set forth herein,
being;
i)
Union of India & Ors v. M.V. Mohanan Nair: (2020) 5 SCC
421, para 30, 31, 34, 37 & 26;
ii)
Union of India & Ors v. Ex. HC/GD Virender Singh: 2022
SCC Online SC 1058, para 10, 12, 13 &14.
22.
From the submission and contention of the rival parties noted
above, what can be understood is that the main or core issue to be decided is
whether the remusteration of the petitioner from Rifleman (ORL) to Havildar
(Cipher) can be taken to be a promotion and admittedly, the difference in the
payscale, the rank of Havildar (Cipher) carrying a higher payscale than that
of a Rifleman (ORL), whether this can be taken to be a financial upgradation
as far as the petitioner is concerned.
23.
It is the consistent stand of the respondents that remusteration is to
be counted as financial upgradation for the purpose of ACP/MACP and as
such, the petitioner on his remusteration as Havildar(Cipher), is counted as
the 1st ACP given to him.
24.
This logic is flawed as the same is hit by the proposition expounded
in the case of Hav/Ciph Abdul Bari v. Union of India & Ors: 2013 SCC
Online Megh 8, wherein at para 12 of the same this Court has observed as
follows:
“12. This Court for the reasons in above paras had already
been made a clear findings that the changing of trade in Cipher
category i.e. Havildar/Cipher through remusteration is not a
promotion and also not a financial up-gradation and, therefore
counting of continuous service for the financial up-gradation
under the ACP Scheme should be from the date of remusteration
to the lowest rank of the Cipher category i.e. Havildar/Cipher on
20.11.1991, for the petitioner.”
25.
As to the ACP Scheme, what is generally understood is that this
scheme is an incentive to those Central Government employees who are
stagnated at a particular post for 12 years and even for 24 years without any
promotion granted to them, or when the post they occupies have no
promotional avenue. Then, financial upgradation is bestowed upon such
employees, the 1st being if they remained in the same post for 12 continuous
years and if they are still in the same post after 12 years thereafter, then at the
end of the next 12 years or 24 years in all, they are given the 2 nd ACP in the
form of financial upgradation.
26.
If this logic is applied to the case of the petitioner, then even if the
period of his service is counted from the point of initial appointment on
12.05.1989, then he would have received the ACP benefit of financial
upgradation on 13.05.2001. But in the case of the petitioner, he was
remustered as Havildar (Cipher) on 12.11.1994, therefore if the argument of
the respondents is accepted that he was granted financial upgradation or
rather that the 1st ACP was given to him in the year 1994, the same cannot be
accepted on the ground that from 1989 to 1994, the period is only about 5
years or so, hence, not having completed 12 years in the same post, 1 st ACP
could not have been granted to him. Remusteration not being considered a
promotion, he certainly would be entitled to the 1st ACP in the year 2006. He
was then promoted to the rank of Nb/Sub (Cipher) in the year 2008, therefore
if ACP is to be counted, then the year 2008 has to be taken as the year of
reckoning counting 12 years therefrom.
27.
In this backdrop, the petitioner was also aggrieved by the issuance
of the letter dated 23.06.2015(supra), wherein, inter alia, it was observed that
the petitioner was granted the 2nd ACP w.e.f. 21.05.2008 which he actually
should not have been granted since on being promoted as Nb/Sub (Cipher)
on 21.05.2008, his service was only 19 years at that time and not 24 years
and as such, granting of 2nd ACP was a mistake and necessary order was
issued for recovery of excess pay drawn. This reasoning is also flawed, as the
petitioner as have been observed above have not even been granted the 1 st
ACP and as such, there could not have been any grant of 2 nd ACP on
21.05.2008. The grievance of the petitioner is therefore justified. The
observations made vide letter dated 23.06.2015 being Fin/Bill-05/2015/980
was not warranted.
28.
Coming to the Order No. Digamber Datt/Court Case/2019/Adm-
I(Sig)/327 dated 15.02.2019 wherein the respondent authorities have, in
compliance with the common judgment and order dated 23.03.2017 passed
by this Court in the case of Digamber Datt & Ors(supra), conveyed the
sanction of the Ministry of Home Affairs for grant of 1st and 2nd financial
upgradation under ACP Scheme, along with the same, the list of those
personnel who have been granted the financial upgradation, the petitioner
appeared at Sl. No. 366 in the said list, have also been annexed therein.
29.
The petitioner has however pointed out that in the said list, under
column 6, the heading reads as “Granted 1st Financial Upgradation” and
against the name of the petitioner, it was noted that he was promoted as
Warrant Officer (Cipher) on 03.06.00(2000) and is therefore, not entitled for
2nd ACP, which is contrary to the import of the said order dated 23.03.2017
in which the respondents were directed to give appropriate rank and pay
scales to the petitioners(therein) as per the Fifth Central Pay Commission and
Office Memorandum dated 22nd January 1998 including financial
upgradation under Modified Assured Career Progression Scheme of the
Government of India, if any, within a period of three months.
30.
What is now noticed is that the respondent authorities have
contradicted themselves, inasmuch as, vide the impugned order dated
23.06.2015(supra), it is said that the petitioner was already granted the 2 nd
ACP w.e.f. 21.05.2008, whereas in the order dated 15.02.2019(supra), the
annexed list, firstly, shows that the petitioner was granted the 1 st ACP at the
time when he was promoted as Warrant Officer (Cipher) on 03.06.2000 and
therefore is not yet due to be granted 2nd ACP, which is again, as pointed out
above, contrary to the legal proposition that remusteration is not a promotion
and even re-designation is also not considered as promotion.
31.
The issue of whether re-designation is considered as promotion or
not have been dealt with by this Court in the case of Ashim Deb Roy & Ors
v. Union of India & Anr: 2023 SCC Online Megh 18, wherein, inter alia,
while dealing and touching the import of the order dated 15.02.2019(supra),
this Court has answered the question at para 20, 21 and 22 of the same which,
in the respectful opinion of this Court is the correct proposition laid down
and which also has a direct bearing on the issue pertaining to the petitioner
herein. The paragraphs are reproduced herein below as:
“20. The respondents implemented the order passed by this
Court on 23.08.2012, in WP(C) No. 277(H) of 2010, in the case
of other similarly situated personnel, by introducing the rank of
ASI (Warrant Officer), at the entry grade, and the same was
never treated as promotion. However, what emerges in the case
of the petitioners herein, is that, the respondents while
implementing the judgment and order dated 23.03.2017, passed
in WP(C) No. 403 of 2014 and WP(C) No. 311 of 2016, while
introducing the rank of Warrant Officer, which is a redesignation, declared the same to be a promotion by way of
upgradation. This in the considered view of this Court, is not in
consonance with the directions contained in the order dated
23.03.2017, which had specifically directed for grant of
appropriate rank and pay scale to the petitioners, and the same
tantamount to unequal treatment being meted out to the
petitioners from other similarly situated personnel, which is also
not in line with the Office Memorandum dated 22.01.1998.
21. It is also noticed that, in the order dated 23.03.2017, as
submitted by the petitioners, two distinct directions have been
issued that is, firstly, to give appropriate rank and pay scales to
the petitioners as per the 5th Central Pay Commission, and
Office Memorandum dated 22.01.1998, and secondly, for
financial upgradation under the Modified Assured Career
Progression Scheme of the Government of India, if any, within
a period of three months. The directions clearly imply that, the
respondents were to give appropriate rank and pay and it does
not imply that, the same be upgradation of rank and pay.
Similarly, the judgment dated 23.03.2017, had only limited the
direction to financial upgradation under the MACP scheme, and
not with regard to ACP. What follows therefore, is that, the
respondents were to give appropriate rank and pay scale, which
would necessarily be to grant the benefits of being re-designated
as ASI (Warrant Officer). As observed in the preceding
paragraph, there is no direction for grant of promotion to the
petitioners to the rank of Warrant Officer, rather it is but, redesignation of the post, as such, the terming of the same as a
promotion is contrary to the directions of this Court, contained
in order dated 23.03.2017, and also the Office Memorandum
dated 22.01.1998.
22. In this view of the matter, the impugned orders dated
08.02.2019 (Annexure-8), 15.02.2019 (Annexure-9) and
08.03.2019 (Annexure-15) are liable to be interfered with,
inasmuch as, in order dated 08.02.2019, and consequential order
dated 15.02.2019, the order for financial upgradation under
ACPs issued were superseded and in the case of the writ
petitioner No. 1, it was shown that he was promoted to the post
of Warrant Officer (Cipher), w.e.f. 23.01.1999, and therefore
not entitled to 2nd ACP. Consequential effects of the incorrect
implementation of the order dated 23.03.2017, also resulted in
reduction of the basic pay of the writ petitioners, which also
needs correction. In the totality of the circumstances therefore,
the impugned orders are hereby set aside and quashed, and the
respondents are directed to re-visit the matter of implementation
of the judgment and order dated 23.03.2017, for grant of
appropriate rank and pay structure to the writ petitioners, and to
issue fresh orders thereon, taking into account, the observations
made in this order.”
32.
In the backdrop of what has been discussed above, the authorities
cited by the learned CGC are found to be not relevant to the subject matter of
this lis. Accordingly, such authorities are not required to be discussed herein.
33.
In the light of the above findings and observations, this Court is of
the view that the approach of the respondent authorities as far as the case of
the petitioner is concerned is not correct and the same has caused prejudice
to his case of entitlement for grant of ACP/MACP at the relevant period as
well as an arbitrary reduction of his pay also at the relevant period of time.
The same is hereby corrected herein by a direction to the respondent
authorities to embark on a course correction and to ensure that the petitioner
is not deprived of his legally entitled dues and benefits whether in respect of
the grant of ACP/MACP or a proper payscale. This exercise is to be carried
out within a period of 4(four) months from the date of receipt of this order.
34.
Consequently, the impugned orders dated 23.06.2015, 28.07.2015,
21.10.2015 and the order dated 15.02.2019 to the extent it affects the
petitioner are hereby set aside and quashed.
35.
Petition disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
13.04.2023
“D. Nary, PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review