Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr.No.102
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CM(M) No. 49/2026
CM No. 1500/2026
Res Date of order:- 12.03.2026
Cav No.10/2026
Uploaded on:- 25.03.2026
1. Rajeev Gupta, Age 50 years
2. Pardeep Gupta, Age 45 years
Sons of Late Sh. Subash Chander,
R/O Village Tarlokpur (Bagla),
Tehsil Vijaypur, District Samba
….Petitioners
Through :- Mr. R. S. Thakur, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Moti Sharma, Adv.
Versus
1. Principal District Judge, Samba
2. Surinder Kumar
S/O Sh. Chajju Ram,
R/O Village Tarlokpur (Bagla)
Tehsil Vijaypur, District Jammu.
3. Mohd. Saleem
S/O Mohd. Shafi,
R/O Bari Bar, Raya Morh,
Tehsil Vijaypur, District Samba
4. Ram Parshad,
S/O Bal Mukund,
R/O Jakh,Tehsil Vijaypur,
District Samba.
Through :-
….Respondent(s)
Mr. Kapil Sharma, Adv.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
ORDER
12.03.2026
With the appearance of Mr. Kapil Sharma, Adv. on behalf of
caveator/respondent No.4, Cav No.10/2026 stands discharged.
CM(M) No. 49/2026 & CM No. 1500/2026
1.
Petitioners, invoking the supervisory jurisdiction of this Court,
through the medium of this petition, seek to quash orders passed by the
learned District Judge, Samba dated 14.01.2026, whereby allegedly in
CM(M) No.49/2026
misappreciation and ignorance of the observations of this Court made in order
dated 30.12.2025 passed in CM(M) No. 354/2024 titled ‘Rajeev Gupta & Anr.
V. Surinder Kumar & Ors.’, the plea for preservation of the property, the
subject of the suit titled as above, in status quo, and for setting aside the costs
earlier imposed by his order dated 22.12.2025 were rejected; and to direct the
demolition of the structure raised by the respondent No.3 in the suit land,
measuring 8 marlas comprising of Khasra No. 4263/3674, situated at JakhChimnachak road, Bagla, Tehsil Vijaypur, District Samba and maintenance of
status quo ante on the spot pending disposal of the appeal, titled ‘Rajeev Gupta
& Anr. V. Surinder Kumar & Ors’, before the Principal District Judge, Samba.
2.
The petitioners have pleaded that respondent No.2, through
respondent No.3, sold suit land to respondent No.4 vide registered Sale Deed
dated 24.09.2009 and the petitioners’ father Subash Chander filed a civil suit
on 09.03.2009 asserting his preferential rights over the suit property; that the
Court of Ld. Additional Special Mobile Magistrate, Samba (the ‘Trial Court’)
on 06.12.2016, after being satisfied of a prima facie case, passed an interim
order directing all parties to maintain status quo with respect to the suit
property; that the Trial Court, however, dismissed the suit on 13.12.2024
having been abated and also dismissed the application on 19.03.2025 of the
petitioners moved to set-aside the abatement order.
3.
It is further contended that aggrieved of the aforesaid orders passed
by the Trial Court, the petitioners preferred an appeal being Appeal
No.05/2025 before the District Court, Samba; that the Appellate Court was
pleased to stay the operation of both the impugned orders dated 13.12.2024
and 19.03.2025 and on an application moved on 08.11.2025 by the petitioners
CM(M) No.49/2026
for implementation of the status quo order and on appearance by respondent
No.4, through his counsel Mandeep Singh Sambyal, parties were directed to
maintain status quo on spot and that, in view of contravention of the status quo
order by respondent No.4- Ram Parshad, the petitioners moved another
application on 18.12.2025 for implementation of the order dated 06.12.2016
passed by the Trial Court, initiation of contempt proceedings, restoration of
status quo ante and appointment of a local commissioner. However, the
Appellate Court dismissed the application of the petitioners and imposed costs
of Rs.20,000/-.
4.
Aggrieved of the aforesaid order passed by the Appellate Court, the
petitioners challenged the same before this Court on 30.12.2025 and this Court
disposed of the petition on the same day with liberty to the petitioners to file
the appropriate motion before the Appellate Court and for waiving of costs,
with a request to the Appellate Court to consider the same sympathetically in
accordance with law. However, the Appellate Court, vide Order dated
14.01.2026, dismissed the application seeking direction to the respondents for
maintaining status quo with respect to the suit property and for waiving costs
imposed by its order dated 22.12.2025.
5.
Learned counsel for the parties submit that appellants and
respondent No.4 are contesting parties and the matter can be head. With the
consensus of learned counsel for both the sides, the matter is taken up for final
consideration.
6.
The learned Senior counsel appearing for the petitioners, submits
that the Trial Court, under a wrong notion that the suit was filed under the
Prior Purchase Act which has been repealed now, ordered the suit dismissed as
CM(M) No.49/2026
abated; that against the dismissal of the suit, the petitioners approached the
Appellate Court against the dismissal order and the Appellate Court admitted
the appeal and on 22.04.2005 while observing that some arguable points have
been raised in the appeal by the appellants, as such, the operation of the
impugned orders dated 13.12.2024, whereby suit of the appellants plaintiffs
was dismissed as abated and 19.03.2025, whereby application for
recalling/setting aside the order dated 13.12.2024 had been dismissed by the
Trial Court, were stayed, subject to objections from the other side.
7.
The learned Senior counsel submits on behalf of appellants that later
while seeking implementation of the status quo order passed by the Trial
Court, the appellate court dismissed the application of the petitioners along
with costs of Rs.20,000/- and on being approached with an application seeking
review of this order in terms of the directions of this court passed in CM(M)
No.354/2025, their application was again rejected. The learned Senior counsel
submits that once an appeal is filed and the order, whereby the suit was
dismissed, is stayed, in legal parlance, the interim orders passed by the Trial
Court also get revived, particularly, when the appeal is admitted to hearing and
otherwise also, it was incumbent upon the appellate court to order the
protection of the suit property, so that no inconvenience is caused to the
parties with the developing changes during the pendency of the litigation and
he has finally prayed that this petition be allowed and the impugned orders be
set aside.
8.
Learned counsel for the respondent no.4, on the other hand, argued
that since the suit of the petitioners filed before the Trial Court had been
dismissed as abated, as such, there could be no question of revival of the
CM(M) No.49/2026
interim direction. He further submits that respondent no.4, being a bona fide
purchaser of the suit land cannot be divested of his right to use the land in the
manner he chooses to use, being owner thereof and that any order to restrain
him from the use of the property shall be detrimental to his legal rights, as
admittedly, he has purchased the land from the rightful owner of the property
which had been challenged by the petitioners as his co-sharers. He further
argued that the petitioners’ case before the court below as projected in their
plaint that they had a right of prior purchase in terms of the Prior Purchase Act
and now they cannot turn around to say that they have this preferential right of
purchase under some other statues governing them, and prayed that the
petition be rejected and the impugned orders be upheld.
9.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the file and
considered the matter.
10.
The suit that had been filed by the father of the petitioners against
respondents 2 to 4 before the Trial Court, was based on a preferential right of
purchase and as per the learned Senior counsel appearing for the petitioners,
the petitioners had a preferential right not only under the Right of Prior
Purchase Act, which is now repealed, but also under the Statues governing the
inheritance among Hindus, as such, the suit of the plaintiff could not have
been defeated on this count that the Right of Prior Purchase Act had been
repealed at the time of the Reorganisation of the State of J&K. The Trial
Court’s dismissal of the suit, having been abated, had been assailed before the
Appellate Court, which had admitted the appeal to hearing, observing that
arguable points for determination have been raised. In such a situation of the
matter, it was incumbent upon the Appellate Court to order for protection of
CM(M) No.49/2026
the suit property and also to ensure that the suit of the petitioners before the
Trial Court, if restored, does not suffer from the multiplicity of litigation due
to developing changes in the suit property.
11.
The impugned orders passed by the Appellate Court, in the aforesaid
backdrop are not sustainable as the Appellate Court was well within its rights
to pass the interim order for the protection of the suit property, the appeal
being continuation of the suit before the Appellate Court. Both the orders
dated 14.01.2026 and 12.12.2025 passed by the Appellate Court are, thus,
quashed for the aforesaid reasons, with a direction to the Court below to hear
the parties afresh with regard to the interim relief sought by the petitioners
with regard to the protection of the suit property.
12.
The parties shall appear before the Court below on the appointed
date and the Court below is requested to consider passing of the appropriate
direction for the interim relief prayed for expeditiously.
13.
The appeal is, accordingly, disposed of along with connected
application(s).
(
) (M.A. Chowdhary)
Judge
Jammu:
12.03.2026
Raj Kumar
Whether the order is speaking?
Raj Kumar
2026.03.25 13:16
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CM(M) No.49/2026
:
Yes.
Whether the order is reportable? :
Yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review