The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. (7 of 7) [CW-20025/2025] For the above reasons, this Court is inclined to dispose of the writ petition, directing the respondents that the data with regard to the number of convictions and acquittals cannot per se be made relevant to record adverse entries against the officer. The apprehension with regard to insisting on data relating to the number of witnesses examined and the number of cases entered in the e-portal is based on mere apprehension without any foundation. At this stage, there is no material to show that such data can be used by the respondents to record good or bad performance; therefore, the relief sought in this regard is premature.
12. With the above directions, the writ petition is disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:16848]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 20025/2025
Rajasthan Prosecution Officers Association, Through President
Pratibha Purohit D/o Shri Shyam Sunder Purohit Aged About 48
Years Resident Of B-403, Anukampa Grand, Swej Farm Circle,
Sodala, Jaipur-302019 (Rajasthan)
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary,
Department Of Personnel, Government Secretariat,
Jaipur,
2.
The Additional Chief Secretary,
Government Secretariat, Jaipur
3.
The Additional Chief Secretary, Department Of Personnel,
Government Of Rajasthan, Government Secretariat,
Jaipur.
4.
The Secretary, Home (Law), Government Of Rajasthan,
Government Secretariat, Jaipur.
5.
The Director Of Prosecution, Rajasthan Government,
Government Secretariat, Jaipur.
Home
Department,
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Tanveer Ahamed
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Rajendra Prasad, Senior Advocate
-cum- Advocate General assisted by
Ms. Dhriti Laddha
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MUNNURI LAXMAN
Order
21/04/2026
1.
Heard.
2.
The present writ petition has been filed challenging the
Annual Appraisal Performance Form (Annexure-4).
3.
The case of the petitioner is that certain columns in the
format which is impugned go to show that such data can be used
to assess the performance of the officer while recording the
annual
appraisal
performance
with
regard
to
the
officer’s
performance. The relevant columns are Column 10(C) and 10(D),
[2026:RJ-JP:16848]
(2 of 7)
[CW-20025/2025]
that is, first column, relating to data with regard to acquittals and
convictions of number of cases; second column, data relating to
the number of witnesses examined through videoconferencing;
and third column, data with regard to the number of cases
entered in the e-prosecution portal.
4.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner
submitted that the data which has been sought in the annual
appraisal performance report gives rise to an apprehension that
those columns under which the information is sought can be used
to record the performance as good or bad, which they cannot do.
It is his submission that the data relating to the number of
acquittals or convictions cannot per se be used to determine the
good or bad performance of the officer for the reason that the
conviction or acquittal does not depend upon the officer who is
conducting prosecution; it depends upon the evidence as well as
the appreciation of evidence by the competent court. Conviction or
acquittal cannot be a criterion to rank an officer as good or bad.
4.1. Learned counsel for the petitioner also submitted that the
data with regard to the number of witnesses examined through
videoconferencing cannot be used either, for the reason that there
is no infrastructure available in various prosecution offices as well
as the concerned courts, and without such infrastructure, the
same cannot be taken per se to record good or bad performance.
It is also his contention that similarly, the data sought with regard
to the number of cases entered in the e-prosecution portal is also
irrelevant, for the reason that many prosecution offices have no
infrastructure, and without infrastructure, they cannot be expected
(3 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:16848]
[CW-20025/2025]
to furnish such data, and the same could not be one of the
relevant factors in assessing the performance.
4.2. It is also his submission that data with regard to e-portal
entries is sought for the past five years, when the annual reports
are expected to be for every year. Such information of the past
beyond one year ought not to have been asked for.
5.
Learned Senior Advocate-cum-Advocate General appearing
on behalf of the respondents submitted that the apprehension
entertained by the petitioner is not well-founded. The respondents
are entitled to seek data, and merely because the data is sought,
it cannot per se be said to be arbitrary, and the same cannot be
challenged. It is his argument that though the data of acquittals
and convictions is sought, the authority would not use that data
per se to make entries with regard to good or bad performance;
however, such data can be used to minimize the area of scrutiny in
cases where such conviction or acquittal was on account of the
bad performance of the officer.
5.1. It is also his submission that the data with regard to the
number of witnesses examined through videoconferencing and the
data with regard to the number of cases entered in the eprosecution portal are sought only to maintain transparency.
Though the prosecution officer is not supposed to make entries,
he has a supervisory role to see that such entries are made
wherever such infrastructure is available. If there is no such
infrastructure, the same can be mentioned in the relevant column
for
non-furnishing
of
information
on
account
of
lack
of
infrastructure. Therefore, he submitted that the writ petition is
devoid of merits.
(4 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:16848]
6.
[CW-20025/2025]
Having gone through the contentions and the format of the
annual appraisal report forming part of Annexure-4, this Court
finds that Column 10(C) and 10(D) are relevant, and the same
read as follows:
'10.
रिपोर्टिंग वर्ष/अवधि में किये गये कार्यों का विवरण
C. fu.kZ; rFkk vihy
(a) U;k;ky; }kjk fuf.kZr izdj.kksa dk fooj.k
vf/kfu;e
dqy izdj.k
fuf.kZr izdj.k
nks"kfl)
nks"keqDr
nks"kflf) izfr’kr
Hkkjrh; n.M lafgrk
Hkkjrh; U;k; lafgrk
vU;
(b) fo’kq) dUVsLVsM izdj.kksa dk fooj.k
vf/kfu;e
izdj.kksa dk fooj.k
dqy izdj.k
nks"kflf)
izfr’kr
nks"kfl) nks"keqDr
izLrqr
uthjsa
nks"keqfDr
izdj.k ftuesa
vihy dh xbZ
Hkkjrh; n.M lafgrk
Hkkjrh; U;k; lafgrk
vU;
D. inLFkkfir U;k;ky; esa leh{kk vof/k ,oa mlls iwoZ ikWp o"kksZa es fd, x, dk;ksZ
dh rqyukRed fLFkfr
dk;Z
Hkk-n-l-@ch-,u-,l- esa nks"kflf)
izfr’kr
Hkk-n-l-@ch-,u-,l- esa fo’kq)
dUVslVsM dsl esa nks"kflf) izfr’kr
vU; vijk/k esa nks"kflf) izfr’kr
vU; vijk/k esa fo’kq) dUVslVsM dsl
esa nks"kflf) izfr’kr
ifjf{kr xokgku dh la[;k
ohfM;ks dkUQzsfUlx ls djok, x,
xokgku dh la[;k
bZ izkWflD;w’ku esa dh xbZ izfof"V;ksa dh
la[;k
is’k izkFkZuk i=ksa dh la[;k
o"kZ
o"kZ
o"kZ
o"kZ
o"kZ
leh{kk/khu
o"kZ
(5 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:16848]
7.
[CW-20025/2025]
It is also relevant to refer to a similar kind of data with
regard to acquittals and convictions as existed prior to the new
format under Annexure-4. The relevant portion of the old format
reads as follows:
"6.
मुख्य
पारिणामिक कार्यों के लिए निर्धारित लक्ष्य
ों (कृपया विनिदिर्ष्ट
करें ) के अनुसर
स्व
यं द्वार किया गया मुल्यां कन:
Ø- la eq[; ikfj.kkfed fu/kkZfjr
dk;Z
y{;
(Key result
areas)
okLrfor
miyfC/k;ka
(Targets) (Actual
achievements)
1-
izeq[k foHkkxh; dk;ksZ ds HkkSfrd y{; %
2-
izeq[k foHkkxh; dk;ksZa ds y{; %
miyfC/k;ksa esa deh dk dkj.k
¼;fn dksbZ gks rks½ ,oa
fo'ks"k ;ksxnku
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
345-
fujh{k.k %
eq[;ky; ds vfrfjDr {ks= esa jkf= foJke
vU; %
fVIi.kh %& ;fn foHkkxh; y{; ugha gks rks laf{kIr o.kZukRed fooj.k fn;k tk,A "
8.
In the previous format, there was no specific detail contained
under the Annual Assessment Performance Report with regard to
the number of convictions and the number of acquittals; however,
Annexure-5, which contains the representations of the officers,
would show that though there was no specific column in the
annual assessment report, the authorities used to insist on the
percentage of convictions, which was taken as one of the factors
to make an assessment of performance.
[2026:RJ-JP:16848]
9.
(6 of 7)
[CW-20025/2025]
These factual aspects which occurred prior to the present
format were not in dispute. It is needless to say that conviction or
acquittal is not always in the domain of the Public Prosecutor; it
depends upon various factors. There may be instances where
conviction or acquittal could be on account of lapses on the part of
the presenting officer, i.e., the prosecuting officer who represents
the State in presenting its case. The prosecutor is required to act
as an independent court officer and not a representative of the
State. The collection of data per se cannot be said to be an
arbitrary action. If such data is used for recording performance
simply based on the number of acquittals or convictions, it violates
the principles of fair play, and this position was also admitted by
the respondents in their reply. In the reply, they specifically state
that such data per se cannot be used to record the good or bad
performance of the officer.
10.
The requirement of furnishing data with regard to the
number of witnesses examined and the number of cases entered
in the e-prosecution portal, as sought in different columns, i.e.,
Column 10(D), cannot be said to be bad, as such data may be
relevant to apprise the actions taken by the officer. As far as the
entry of data in the e-portal is concerned, it is the primary duty
cast upon the clerk who is working under the prosecution officer,
and it is the duty of the prosecuting officer to ensure that, if the
infrastructure is available, such data is entered; he has a
supervisory role in ensuring such entry. Wherever infrastructure is
not available, the same can be mentioned in the relevant column,
and merely because infrastructure is not available in some offices,
insisting on such data per se is not illegal.
[2026:RJ-JP:16848]
11.
(7 of 7)
[CW-20025/2025]
For the above reasons, this Court is inclined to dispose of the
writ petition, directing the respondents that the data with regard
to the number of convictions and acquittals cannot per se be made
relevant to record adverse entries against the officer. The
apprehension with regard to insisting on data relating to the
number of witnesses examined and the number of cases entered
in the e-portal is based on mere apprehension without any
foundation. At this stage, there is no material to show that such
data can be used by the respondents to record good or bad
performance; therefore, the relief sought in this regard is
premature.
12.
With the above directions, the writ petition is disposed of.
13.
All pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
(MUNNURI LAXMAN),J
138 - BhumikaP/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review