Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SIDDHANT
TAMRAKAR
Digitally
signed by
SIDDHANT
TAMRAKAR
Date:
2026.03.17
14:41:36
+0530
2026:CGHC:11585
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 2006 of 2019
1. Smt. Laxmi Thakur W/o Late Jai Singh Thakur Aged About 46 Years By
Caste - Kshatriya, R/o Rajapara Kanker, Police Station And Tahsil Kanker,
District North Bastar Kanker Chhattisgarh., District : Kanker, Chhattisgarh
2. Omprakash Thakur S/o Late Jai Singh Thakur Aged About 26 Years By
Caste - Kshatriya, R/o Rajapara Kanker, Police Station And Tahsil Kanker,
District North Bastar Kanker Chhattisgarh., District : Kanker, Chhattisgarh
3. Lokeshwar Singh Thakur S/o Late Jai Singh Thakur Aged About 18 Years
By Caste - Kshatriya, R/o Rajapara Kanker, Police Station And Tahsil
Kanker, District North Bastar Kanker Chhattisgarh. (Claimants), District :
Kanker, Chhattisgarh
--- Appellant(s)
versus
1. Manish Singh S/o Brij Kishore Singh Aged About 22 Years R/o 02/398,
Sarvoday Nagar Rajdhani Road, Shuklaganj Unnav, Police Station
Gangaghat, District Unnav Uttar Pradesh. (Driver), District : Unnao, Uttar
Pradesh
2. Rahul Tarak S/o O.P. Tarak, R/o L.I.C. Colony, Mova Raipur, District Raipur
Chhattisgarh. (Owner)., District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
3. The Oriental Insurance Company Limited Branch Office M.B. Trade Centre,
Second Floor, Near Gandhi Chowk, Dhamtari, District Dhamtari
Chhattisgarh. (Insurer), District : Dhamtari, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
MAC No. 2074 of 2019
Rahul Tarak S/o O.P. Tarak Aged About 47 Years R/o L.I.C. Colony, Mowa,
Raipur , District Raipur Chhattisgarh, Caste Brahman, Address Village
Kapsi, Police Station And Tahsil Doundilohara , District Balod
Chhattisgarh..(Non Aaplicnat No 2) (Registered Owner Of Vehicle Motor
Cycle Bearing Registration No Cg-04-Ct-4652), District : Balod,
Chhattisgarh
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Smt. Lakshmi Thakur W/o Late Jaisingh Thakur Aged About 46 Years
Caste Kshatri , R/o Rajapara, Kanker, Police Station And Tahsil - Kanker ,
District Uttar Baster Kanker Chhattisgarh., District : Kanker, Chhattisgarh
2. Omprakash Thakur S/o Late Jaisingh Thakur Aged About 26 Years Caste
Kshatri , R/o Rajapara, Kanker, Police Station And Tahsil - Kanker , District
Uttar Baster Kanker Chhattisgarh., District : Kanker, Chhattisgarh
3. Lokeshwar Singh Thakur S/o Late Jaisingh Thakur Aged About 18 Years
Caste Kshatri , R/o Rajapara, Kanker, Police Station And Tahsil - Kanker ,
District Uttar Baster Kanker Chhattisgarh., District : Kanker, Chhattisgarh
4. Manish Singh S/o Brijkishor Singh Aged About 22 Years R/o - 02/398,
Sarvoday Nagar , Rajdhani Marg, Shuklaganj, Unnav, Police Station
Gangaghat , District Unnav Uttarpradesh....(Non Applicant No. 01) (Driver
Of Vehicle Motor Cycle Bearing Registration No Cg-04-Ct-4652), District :
Unnao, Uttar Pradesh
5. The Orinental Insurance Company Limited Through Branch Manager ,
Branch Office - M.B. Trade Centre , Second Floor , Near Gandhi Chowk ,
Dhamtari, District - Dhamtari Chhattisgarh...(Non Applicant No 03) ( Insurer
Of Vehicle Motor Cycle Bearing Registration No. Cg-04-Ct-4652), District :
Dhamtari, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
MAC No. 2006 of 2019
For Appellants/Claimants
: Mr. Praveen Dhurandhar, Advocate
For Respective Respondents : Mr. Shivendu Pandya, Advocate
: Mr. Sudhir Agrawal, Advocate along with Ms.
Prerna Agrawal, Advocate
MAC No. 2074 of 2019
For Appellant/Owner
For Respective Respondents
:
:
:
Mr. Shivendu Pandya, Advocate
Mr. Sudhir Agrawal, Advocate along with Ms.
Prerna Agrawal, Advocate
Mr. Saurabh Gupta, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Justice Rakesh Mohan Pandey
Order on Board
11.03.2026
1. In these two appeals, the judgment and award passed by the learned 2 nd
Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kanker District North Bastar
Knaker passed in Claim Case No. 59/2016 dated 20.08.2019 has been
challenged.
2. MAC No. 2006 of 2019 has been filed by the claimants for enhancement of
compensation, whereas, MAC No. 2074 of 2019 has been filed by the
owner of the vehicle challenging liability part.
3. The facts in brief are that on 17.05.2016 while deceased Ku. Pooja Thakur
was going towards Govindpur on a motorcycle bearing registration No. CG
04 CT 4652 as a pillion rider, said bike dashed with the State Bank
signboard. In said accident, Ku. Pooja Thakur sustained injuries and
during course of treatment succumbed to death. Mother and two siblings of
deceased filed a claim case under Section 166 of Motor Vehicle Act,
wherein they pleaded that age of the deceased at the time of accident was
23 years; she was bachelor and earning Rs. 20,000/- per month as she
was working as guest lecturer in Government Bhanupratap Deo College,
Kanker. The driver of the vehicle filed reply to the claim petition and
pleaded that he had valid and effective driving licence at the time of
accident and vehicle was insured with the Insurance Company. The owner
of the vehicle filed separate reply and specifically pleaded that the vehicle
was insured with the Insurance Company.
4. The Insurance Company took a plea that the offending vehicle was being
driven in breach of conditions of Insurance policy. The learned Tribunal
framed issued, parties led evidence, and thereafter, award was passed.
The learned Tribunal granted compensation to the tune of Rs. 8,94,000/with interest at the rate of 7% per annum and fastened liability with the
owner of the offending bike.
5. Mr. Praveen Dhurandhar, Advocate would submit that the learned Tribunal
failed to grant compensation for future prospects and also failed to grant
compensation for loss of consortium to the claimant No. 1 i.e. mother of the
deceased. He would pray for enhancement of compensation accordingly.
Mr. Dhurandhar would submit that the learned Tribunal should have
directed the Insurance Company to satisfy the award and recover it from
owner of the vehicle as the driving licence of driver of the offending vehicle
was not found valid. He has placed reliance on the judgment passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Rama Bai vs. Amit Minerals and
Anr. reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2067 and New India Assurance
Co., Shimla vs. Kamla and Ors. reported in (2001) 4 SCC 342.
6. Mr. Shivendu Pandya, Advocate appearing for owner of the offending
vehicle would submit that Manish Singh was a driver, who was engaged by
the owner of the motorbike after due verification of his driving licence. He
would submit that the driving licence of Manish Singh was examined by the
appellant/owner and it was found valid and effective, and therefore, he was
employed. It is argued by Mr. Pandya that the Insurance Company failed to
establish the fact that on the date of accident, the driver Manish Singh did
not have valid and effective driving licence. He would submit that burden
was on the Insurance Company to establish this fact, and thus, the learned
Tribunal committed error of law while fastening liability with the owner of
the vehicle. He has placed reliance on the judgment passed in MAC No.
1192/2012 in the matter of Mohd. Sajid Meman vs. Smt. Savita Bai and
Ors.
Mr. Shivendu Pandya, Advocate would submit that original driving
licence of Manish Singh has been placed on record as Ex. D/5 bearing
registration No. UP 35/ 2013/ 0090749. He would contend that the
Insurance Company failed to prove the fact that the said driving licence was
forged one. He would further contend that authenticity of driving licence Ex.
D-1C and D-3 were not verified by NAW-3/ Pawan Kumar Tripathi.
7. Mr. Sudhir Agrawal, Advocate appearing for Insurance Company would
submit that Pawan Kumar Tripathi, Assistant Divisional Transport Officer,
Unnav, categorically deposed that the licence number UP35 2008 0090749
was never issued in favour of Manish Singh. He would submit that the
Insurance Company discharged its liability, and therefore, the learned
Tribunal exonerated the Insurance Company and fastened liability with the
owner of the vehicle.
8. Mr. Saurabh Gupta, Advocate would support the award passed by the
learned Tribunal.
9. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record with
utmost circumspection.
10. Mr. Praveen Dhurandhar, Advocate appearing for the claimants has not
disputed the income part assessed by the learned Tribunal. Perusal of the
award would show that the learned Tribunal failed to grant compensation
for future prospect. The age of the deceased was 23 years, thus, the
claimants would be entitled to receive 40% additional amount on the
established income under this head. The learned Tribunal further failed to
grant compensation for grant of consortium to claimant No. 1/mother. As
the deceased met with an accident in the year 2016, the claimant No.
1/mother of the deceased is held entitled to receive a sum of Rs. 48,000/for loss of consortium. Thus, the compensation requires reconsideration
and same is being revisited herein-below :-
Sr.
No.
Heads
Compensation
awarded by Tribunal
Compensation
awarded by this
Court
1.
Income
Rs. 8000/- x 12 = Rs. Rs. 8000/- x 12 =
96,000/Rs. 96,000/-
2.
Future Prospect
NIL
3.
Deduction
(-)1/2 Rs. 48,000/Rs. 48,000/-
4.
Multiplier
(x) 18 = 8,64,000/-
5.
Loss of Estate
Rs. 15,000/-
(40%)
=
Rs.
38,400/(-) 1/2 Rs. 67,200/Rs. 67,200/(x) 18 =
12,09,600/Rs. 15,000/-
Rs.
6.
Funeral expenses
Rs. 15,000/-
7.
Loss of consortium NIL
(for appellant No. 1)
Rs. 48,000/-
8.
Loss of consortium(for NIL
appellant No. 2)
NIL
9.
Loss of consortium(for NIL
appellant No. 3)
NIL
TOTAL
Rs. 12,87,600/-
Rs. 8,94,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
11. For the forgoing reasons, the appeal preferred by the claimants for
enhancement of compensation is allowed in part. The amount of
compensation of Rs. 8,94,000/- awarded by the tribunal is enhanced to
Rs. 12,87,600/-. Hence, after deducting the amount of Rs. 8,94,000/-,
the appellants/claimants are held entitled for an additional amount of
Rs. 3,93,600/- with interest at the rate of 7%.
12. The owner of the offending vehicle examined himself as NAW/2. On
affidavit this witness stated that the driving licence of Manish Singh was
examined by him and after due satisfaction motorcycle was handed over. In
cross-examination, this witness stated that he does not recollect licence
number of Manish Singh and he is not aware of the fact that the said
driving licence has been found forged. It is also admitted that he is not
award of the fact that which authority issued the said driving licence.
13. Mr. Shivendu Pandya has placed reliance on the judgment passed in MAC
No. 1192/2012 in the matter of Mohd. Sajid Meman vs. Smt. Savita Bai
and Ors.. It was a case where owner of the vehicle entered into witness
box and stated that he knew driver since long and his driving licence was
checked and was found valid up to particular date. It was also stated that
the driving licence was duly verified by RTO as the driver was taken to RTO
office along with the owner of the vehicle. In the present case, no such
exercise was done by the owner of the offending vehicle. Thus, the facts
are different.
14. In the present case, the Insurance Company examined Assistant Divisional
Transport Officer, Unnao, namely, Pawan Kumar Tripathi (NAW/3) on
commission, who stated that driving licence No. 90749/ UNO 2008 (Ex. D1C) was issued in favour of Shridhar S/o Shri Krishan, which was valid from
21.01.2008 to 31.12.2022. Thus, it is apparent that the driving licence Ex.
D-1C was never issued to Manish Singh/driver of the offending vehicle.
With regard to driving licence Ex. D/3 bearing No. UP 35/ 2013/ 0090749, it
is stated by NAW/3 that said driving licence was never issued to Manish
Singh. Ex. D-5C and its validity was examined by NAW-3 comparing with
the original record. In cross-examination, this witness remained firm.
15. The learned Tribunal considered the evidence of NAW-3 at length and
arrived at conclusion that on the date of accident driver of the offending
motorbike did not have valid and effective driving licence, and therefore,
fastened liability with the owner of the vehicle. The owner of the vehicle
failed to adduce evidence to prove contrary.
16. The documents and evidence discussed above would make it clear that the
owner of the offending vehicle failed to establish that the rider of the
offending bike had valid and effective driving licence on the date of
accident; therefore, in my opinion, the learned Tribunal rightly fastened
liability with the owner of the vehicle. Accordingly, the appeal preferred by
the owner is hereby dismissed.
17. Admittedly, it is a case of fake licence. The Pawan Kumar Tripathi
(NAW/3) has categorically stated that the driving licence Ex. D-5(UP 35/
2013/ 0090749) was never issued from Regional Transport Office,
Unnao, but at the same time, the vehicle was insured with the
Insurance Company.
18. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Kamla (supra) while
dealing with the issued with regard to insurers liability in case of fake
driving licence, held that in such a case, the Insurance Company should
indemnify the award first and recover it from owner of the vehicle, para
12, 25 and 26 are reproduced herein-below :12. As a point of law we have no manner of doubt that
a fake licence cannot get its forgery outfit stripped off
merely on account of some officer renewing the same
with or without knowing it to be forged. Section 15 of
the Act only empowers any licensing authority to
renew a driving licence issued under the provisions of
this Act with effect from the date of its expiry. No
licensing authority has the power to renew a fake
licence and, therefore, a renewal if at all made cannot
transform a fake licence as genuine. Any counterfeit
document showing that it contains a purported order
of a statutory authority would ever remain counterfeit
albeit the fact that other persons including some
statutory authorities would have acted on the
document unwittingly on the assumption that it is
genuine.
25. The position can be summed up thus: The insurer
and insured are bound by the conditions enumerated
in the policy and the insurer is not liable to the insured
if there is violation of any policy condition. But the
insurer who is made statutorily liable to pay
compensation to third parties on account of the
certificate of insurance issued shall be entitled to
recover from the insured the amount paid to the third
parties, if there was any breach of policy conditions on
account of the vehicle being driven without a valid
driving licence. Learned counsel for the insured
contended that it is enough if he establishes that he
made all due enquiries and believed bona fide that the
driver employed by him had a valid driving licence, in
which case there was no breach of the policy
condition. As we have not decided on that contention
it is open to the insured to raise it before the Claims
Tribunal. In the present case, if the Insurance
Company succeeds in establishing that there was
breach of the policy condition, the Claims Tribunal
shall direct the insured to pay that amount to the
insurer. In default the insurer shall be allowed to
recover that amount (which the insurer is directed to
pay to the claimants - third parties) from the insured
person.
26. We may point out that as per the order passed by
this Court on 6.3.2000, the appellant Insurance
Company was directed to pay the award amount to
the claimants. We are told that the amount was paid
by the appellant to the claimants. Now the Claims
Tribunal has to decide the next question whether the
insurance company is entitled to recover that amount
from the owner of the vehicle on account of the
vehicle being driven by a person who had no valid
licence to drive the vehicle. For that purpose we remit
the case to the Claims Tribunal. An opportunity shall
be afforded to the parties concerned for adducing
evidence in that regard. We make it clear that the
claimants shall not be bothered during the remaining
part of the proceedings.
19. Recently, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Rama Bai (supra)
while dealing with almost similar issue held in para 5, 6, 6.1 as under :5. The submission on part of the appellant that the
High Court ought to have applied the “pay and
recover” principle rests on the decision of this Court
in Shamanna1 (supra) and Parminder Singh2 (supra).
In Shamanna1 (supra) this Court dealt with the claim
of compensation by third party victim of the motor
accident. In para 5 of the judgment, this Court
referred to its own earlier decision in National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh and Others3 to
reiterate that the insurer has to pay the
compensation amount payable to the third party and
the insurance company may recover the same
thereafter from the insured.
6. In the present case as stated above, on the date of
accident, the driver had no valid license and the
1[(2018) 9 SCC 650]
2[(2019) 7 SCC 217]
3[(2004) 3 SCC 297]
licence was not renewed. The insurance company
was entitled to take a valid defence in that regard
under Section 149 (2)(a)(ii) as the driver of the
offending vehicle was not duly licensed, to avoid its
liability to pay the compensation. The conditions in
law are satisfied to absolve the insurance company
from the payment of compensation.
6.1 The High Court in the impugned judgment relied
upon the decision in Ram Babu Tiwari4 to find that as
per the specific provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act,
if the driver does not possess a valid and effective
driving licence, it results in a breach of conditions of
the insurance policy, exonerating the insurer from its
liability. But while affirming the order of the High
Court, absolving the liability for breach of conditions
in the policy, this Court refused to interfere with
orders of ‘pay and recover’ as directed by the High
Court.
20. The fall out of above-discussion is that the Insurance Company shall
indemnify the award first and would be at liberty to recover it from
owner of the vehicle. The Insurance Company shall make payment of
compensation along with enhanced amount of compensation to the
claimants within a period of 60 days with interest. Rest of the conditions
of impugned award shall remain intact.
21. Any amount out of award deposited by the owner of the vehicle with the
concerned Claims Tribunal shall be adjusted.
Sd/(Rakesh Mohan Pandey)
Judge
$iddhant
4[(2008) 8 SCC 165]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review