Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:1892-DB
ROHIT
KUMAR
CHANDRA
Digitally signed
by ROHIT
KUMAR
CHANDRA
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 1260 of 2021
Barjesh Pandey S/o Kishan Pandey, aged about 20 years R/o
Premnagar Colony P.S. And District Kondagaon Chhatttisgarh.
--- Appellant
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through - Aarakshi Kendra Kondagaon District
Kondagaon Chhattiagarh.
--- Respondent
CRA No. 1886 of 2022
Rahul Shrivastava S/o Shankarlal Shrivastava, aged about 18 years R/o
Premnagar
Kondagaon,
PS
Kondagaon
District
Kondagaon,
Chhattisgarh
--- Appellant
Versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through Police Station Kondagaon, District
Kondagaon, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent
________________________________________________________
For Appellant in CRA 1260/2021 : Mr. Vikash A. Shrivastava, Advocate
For Appellant in CRA 1886/2022 : Mr. Kamlesh Patel, Advocate
For Respondent/State
: Mr. S.S. Baghel, Govt. Advocate
________________________________________________________
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
13.01.2026
1.
Since both the above-captioned appeals arise out of a common
factual matrix and common judgment, this Court is disposing of
both these appeals by a common judgment.
2.
Both these Criminal Appeals have been preferred under Section
374(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, ‘the
CrPC’) against the impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 06.09.2021 passed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge (F.T.C.) Kondagaon, District – Kondagaon (C.G.)
in Sessions Trial No. 34/2019 and Consolidated Case No. 55/2019
by which both the accused/ appellants have been convicted and
sentenced in the following matter with a direction to run all the
sentences concurrently :Accused - Barjesh Pandey :
CONVICTION
SENTENCE
U/s 449 of IPC
RI for 10 years and fine of Rs. 1,000/-, in
default of payment of fine, additional RI for
U/s 394 of IPC
03 years
RI for 10 years and fine of Rs. 1,000/-, in
default of payment of fine, additional RI for
U/s 302 of IPC
03 years
Life imprisonment and fine of Rs. 1,000/-, in
default of payment of fine, additional RI for
03 years
Accused – Rahul Shrivastava :
CONVICTION
SENTENCE
U/s 449 of IPC
RI for 10 years and fine of Rs. 1,000/-, in
default of payment of fine, additional RI for
U/s 394 of IPC
03 years
RI for 10 years and fine of Rs. 1,000/-, in
default of payment of fine, additional RI for
U/s 302 of IPC
03 years
RI for 20 years and fine of Rs. 1,000/-, in
default of payment of fine, additional RI for
03 years
3.
The prosecution case, in brief, is that the complainant Parasram
Sinha appeared at the Kondagaon police station on 02.02.2019
and lodged an oral report that Roshan Yadav, Supervisor of the ECom Courier Service Centre office, was murdered by unknown
persons on the night of 01.02.2019 and they fled after looting the
daily collection of the Courier Centre amounting to Rs. 1 lakh 50
thousand and other items. On the information of the complainant,
the inquest report of the death of Roshan Yadav and FIR No.
35/2019 under sections 450, 394, 302 of the Indian Penal Code
was registered at the Kondagaon police station vide Ex.P-1 and
Ex.P-4 respectively.
4.
Investigating Officer left for scene of occurrence and after
summoning the witnesses vide Ex.P-5, inquest over the dead body
of deceased Roshan Yadav was prepared vide Ex.P-6 and
thereafter the dead body was sent to RNT District Hospital,
Kondagaon for conducting postmortem vide Ex.P-18, wherein
Dr.Sanjay Basak (PW-5) conducted postmortem over the dead
body of deceased and on external examination, he found following
injuries :
(i)
A ligature mark, clearly and consistently caused by
the tightening of a cable wire, was found above the hyoid
bone on the upper neck, measuring 1.5 inches x 1/2 inch.
(ii)
A ligature mark was present on both wrists,
measuring 8 inches x 1/2 inch.
(iii)
A ligature mark was present on both ankles,
measuring 10 inches x 1/2 inch.
He removed the cable wire from all three ligature
marks, sealed it, and handed it over to the police.
(iv)
A cut wound was present on the front of the head,
measuring 1 inch x 1/2 inch.
(v)
A blood clot was present on the right ear.
(vi)
A swelling was present on the right shoulder,
measuring 1 inch in circumference.
(vii) Two cut wounds were present on the back of the
head, in the occipital region. The bone in the occipital
region was fractured and bleeding.
(viii) Three small swellings were present on the head, one
above the temple. Abrasion marks were also found on the
right neck.
According to Doctor, the cause of death was suffocation and shock
which was caused due to strangulation and rupture of intestine.
The time was within 12 to 24 hours and the mode of death was
homicidal in nature. The postmortem report conducted by him is
Ex.P-7.
5.
In sealed packet containing undergarments of the deceased, 03
Nos. black colour cable wire and red colour towel with blood-stains
on it, one another sealed packet containing black colour jacket and
black cap with blood-stains on it and one another sealed packet
containing hair of the deceased and occipital skin were seized vide
Ex.P-20 and on 02.02.2019 during site inspection of the protest
site, E-com Courier Service Center, Kondagon, by FSL Crime Unit
Team, Jagdalpur, a chair with blue colour cushion was found kept
near the counter table on which the shoe prints of both the feet of
the accused were found was preserved and seized vide Ex.P-28.
6.
During the course of investigation, blood sample of deceased
spilled in floor of the place where the body was found; bloodstained soil and plain soil; one pair of slipper found near the dead
body of deceased; one reliance company SIM card; one blue and
one green colour goggle cover; one JIO DIGITAL LIFE company
SIM cover in which ICCID 89918630400095564123 and IMSI
405863055332405 were written; one pack of courier packing
which contains blood-stained in which Customer’s name is
mentioned as Shiv Shankar and Customer Order ID is mentioned
as 6870887603 were seized vide Ex.P-2 and two Nos. of CPU out
of which one is of ACER company and second one is of LENOVO
company; one 20 liter sky-blue colour plastic tank containing
blood-stains and fingerprints; cover of plastic tank containing
fingerprints over it; one blue cover chair containing footprints of the
accused and empty leather purse of the deceased were seized
vide Ex.P-3.
7.
Accused Brajesh Pandey was taken into custody on 06.02.2019
and his memorandum statement was recorded at SDOP office,
Kondagaon vide Ex.P-7 and at his instance one green colour bag
containing one screwdriver having red handle, one iron cutter
blade, one green colour woolen jacket, which accused Brajesh
Pandey worn at the time of incident containing blood-stains on it,
one black and white spotted full sleve shirt,
which accused
Brajesh Pandey worn at the time of incident containing bloodstains on it, one skyblue colour full sleve shirt containing bloodstains on it, which was taken out from parcel and worn by the
accused Brajesh Pandey after the incident, one blood-stained
black colour woolen jacket which was worn by co-accused Mukesh
Mandavi (juvenile), one stone used during incident containing
blood-stains on it by which the accused hit the head of deceased
Roshan Yadav and Pan Card of deceased in which Account No.
AMIPY00844 is mentioned and driving licence of deceased in
which License No. R/6324/BTR/17 valid upto 18.10.2026 has been
written, one Canara Bank Rupay Debit Card in which Card No.
508925259009440 has been written, one Rupay Debit Card of
C.G. Rajya Gramin Bank with Card No. 6072149902211759 and
one passport photo of deceased Roshan Yadav were seized vide
Ex.P-8 and cash amounting to Rs. 87,500/- and MI Android Mobile
Phone of deceased Roshan Yadav in back side of which IMEI-1 –
869781038078700
and
IMEI-2
–
869781038078718
S.No.
17591/88T104935 has been mentioned, which were produced by
accused Barjesh Pandey from inside of his kept in one plastic sack
and one white golden colour China Mobile containing two SIM (1)
Airtel Mob. No. 9589851577 and (2) Reliance Jio Mob. No.
6262531476 were seized vide Ex.P-9.
8.
On the basis of memorandum statement of accused Barjesh
Pandey, accused Rahul Shrivastava was also taken into custody
and his memorandum statement was recorded vide Ex.P-10 and
at his instance amounting to Rs.14,000/- and one white coloured
full sleve T-shirt with black print containing blood-stains on upper
part of it were seized from the house of the accused Rahul
Shrivastava.
9.
Accused Brajesh Pandey was arrested and arrest memo was
prepared vide Ex.P-12 and information about his arrest was given
to his family member vide Ex.P-23. Accused Rahul Shrivastava
was arrested and arrest memo was prepared vide Ex.P-24 and
information about his arrest was given to his family member vide
Ex.P-25.
10.
During the course of investigation, statements of the witnesses
were recorded, a site map of the crime scene was prepared vide
Ex.P-19, a doctor's query report was obtained regarding the
seized property vide Ex.P-8, the seized property was sent to FSL
Jagdalpur for examination through the Superintendent of Police
vide Ex.P-29 and memo for providing report by conducting
comparative examination of fingerprints obtained from seized
articles and fingerprints taken from accused was sent to Director,
Fingerprint Bureau, Police Headquarters, Raipur (C.G.) vide
Ex.P-30 and report of the Finger Print Expert was obtained vide
Ex.P-16. Certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act was
obtained vide Ex.P-15.
11.
After the entire investigation, charge sheet against accused
Barjesh Pandey bearing No. 67/2019 was prepared on 30.04.2019
and presented before the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Kondagaon, from where the case was received by the Court of
Additional
Sessions
Judge
(FTC)
Kondagaon,
District
–
Kondagoan for resolution and since accused Rahul Srivastava
was a minor at the time of the incident, a separate charge sheet
was filed in the Juvenile Court, Kondagaon. Finding that the
accused Rahul Srivastava should be tried as an adult, his case
was also sent for trial before Court of Additional Sessions Judge
(FTC) Kondagaon, District – Kondagoan, cognizance was taken
and the trial was conducted.
12.
To prove its case, the prosecution has recorded the statements of
PW-1 Parasram Sinha, PW-2 Arun Yadav, PW-3 Vijay Yadav,
PW-4 Deepak Thakur, PW-5 Dr. Sanjay Basak, PW-6 Lady Head
Constable Sagarbati Sori, PW-7 Inspector Kamleshwar Singh,
PW-4 Inspector Hansraj Gautam and PW-9 Head Constable
Naresh Devangan.
13.
The accused were charged with the offences under sections 449,
394, 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code. When the charges were
framed and read out to them and explained to them, they denied
the charges and a trial was claimed. Upon being questioned under
Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the accused
stated that they were innocent and had been falsely implicated.
They expressed their intention not to present any defence
evidence.
14.
The trial Court after appreciation of oral and documentary
evidence available on record, by its judgment dated 06.09.2021,
convicted
and
sentenced
the
accused/appellants
as
aforementioned,
15.
Being aggrieved by the impugned judgment of conviction and
order of sentence dated 06.09.2021 passed by the learned trial
Court,
these
two
appeals
have
been
preferred
by
the
convict/accused.
16.
Mr. Vikash A. Shrivastava, learned counsel for the appellant –
Barjesh Pandey in CRA No. 1260 of 2021, vehemently argued that
though there is no eyewitness of the incident and the case
prosecution is based on the circumstantial evidence, but the
learned trial Court has failed to consider that the chain of
circumstance is not complete, which is a requirement under the
law. The motive of the offence has also not been proved by the
prosecution. He further argued that the learned trial Court has
also failed to appreciate that the conviction cannot be based
merely on the basis of memorandum statement and subsequent
seizures, especially when the motive of the offence has not been
proved and they are merely corroborative piece of evidence and
cannot be the sole basis to convict the appellant.
17.
Mr. Kamlesh Patel, learned counsel for the appellant – Rahul
Shrivastava in CRA No. 1886 of 2022, vehemently argued that the
conviction of appellant Rahul Shrivastava is wholly unsustainable
as the prosecution has failed to prove his guilt beyond reasonable
doubt; the entire case against him rests only on the memorandum
statement of co-accused Brajesh Pandey and an alleged recovery
of Rs.14,000/- and a blood-stained T-shirt, which by settled law is
insufficient to sustain conviction, particularly when there is no eyewitness, no evidence of last-seen, no motive attributed to the
appellant, and no proof of his presence at the place of occurrence
or participation in the alleged offence; the recovered cash has not
been identified as part of the looted amount and the alleged bloodstained clothes have not been scientifically linked to the deceased
through FSL or DNA examination; further, no fingerprint, footprint,
call detail record, or other forensic evidence connects the
appellant with the crime scene, and no overt act or prior meeting
of minds has been established so as to attract Section 34 IPC; in a
case based purely on circumstantial evidence, the chain of
circumstances is completely broken and does not exclude the
hypothesis of innocence; moreover, the appellant was a juvenile at
the time of the incident, requiring stricter scrutiny of evidence,
which the prosecution has failed to satisfy; therefore, in view of the
serious
legal
and
evidentiary
gaps,
the
appellant
Rahul
Shrivastava is entitled to the benefit of doubt, and it is most
respectfully prayed that he be acquitted of all the charges.
18.
On the other hand, Mr. S.S. Baghel, learned Government
Advocate,
appearing
for
the
State/respondent
vehemently
opposed the submissions advanced on behalf of the appellants
and contended that the learned trial Court has rightly convicted
both the accused after a proper appreciation of oral and
documentary evidence available on record. It was argued that
although the case is based on circumstantial evidence, the
prosecution
has
successfully
established
a
complete
and
unbroken chain of circumstances which conclusively points
towards the guilt of the appellants and excludes every hypothesis
of innocence. The homicidal death of the deceased is fully proved
by the medical evidence, and the manner of assault, strangulation
and robbery clearly demonstrates a pre-planned and conjoint
criminal act. The memorandum statements of the accused have
led to recoveries of incriminating articles including blood-stained
clothes, weapon used in the offence, robbed cash, mobile phone,
ATM cards and other personal belongings of the deceased, which
form a strong and admissible link under Section 27 of the
Evidence Act. The recoveries were made promptly and from the
exclusive possession of the accused, thereby lending credibility to
the prosecution case. The State further submitted that motive,
though relevant, is not sine qua non when there is cogent
circumstantial and forensic evidence establishing guilt, and in the
present case the motive of robbery is clearly borne out from the
recovery of stolen property. It was further contended that common
intention under Section 34 IPC stands proved from the
coordinated acts of the accused before, during and after the
commission of the offence, including joint participation in assault,
robbery and concealment of evidence. The mere fact that the
appellant Rahul Shrivastava was a juvenile at the time of the
incident does not dilute the evidentiary value of the prosecution
case once his active involvement is established beyond doubt.
Therefore, the learned trial Court committed no error in convicting
the appellants, and the appeals being devoid of merit deserve to
be dismissed.
19.
We have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties,
considered their rival submissions made hereinabove and also
went through the records with utmost circumspection.
20.
The first question for consideration would be, whether the
trial Court was justified in holding that death of deceased
Roshan Yadav was homicidal in nature ?
21.
The trial Court relying upon the statement of Dr. Sanjay Basak
(PW-5), who had conducted the postmortem over the dead body of
deceased Roshan Yadav and found aforementioned injuries and
vide its report Ex.P-7 opined that the cause of death was
suffocation and shock which was caused due to strangulation and
rupture of intestine and the mode of death was homicidal in
nature, has clearly come to the conclusion that death of deceased
Roshan Yadav was homicidal in nature. The said finding recorded
by the trial Court is a finding of fact based on evidence available
on record, which is neither perverse nor contrary to record. Even
otherwise, it has not been seriously disputed by the learned
counsel for the appellants. We hereby affirm the said finding.
22.
It is the case of no direct evidence, rather conviction is based on
circumstantial evidence.
23.
We may also make a reference to a decision of the Supreme Court
in C. Chenga Reddy and Ors. v. State of A.P., (1996) 10 SCC
193, wherein it has been observed thus:
“In a case based on circumstantial evidence, the
settled law is that the circumstances from which the
conclusion of guilt is drawn should be fully proved
and such circumstances must be conclusive in
nature. Moreover, all the circumstances should be
complete and there should be no gap left in the chain
of evidence. Further the proved circumstances must
be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of
the accused and totally inconsistent with his
innocence....”.
24.
In Padala Veera Reddy v. State of A.P. and Ors., AIR 1990 SC
79, it was laid down by the Supreme Court that when a case rests
upon circumstantial evidence, such evidence must satisfy the
following tests:
“(1) the circumstances from which an inference of
guilt is sought to be drawn, must be cogently and
firmly established;
(2) those circumstances should be of a definite
tendency unerringly pointing towards guilt of the
accused;
(3) the circumstances, taken cumulatively should form
a chain so complete that there is no escape from the
conclusion that within all human probability the crime
was committed by the accused and none else; and
(4) the circumstantial evidence in order to sustain
conviction must be complete and incapable of
explanation of any other hypothesis than that of the
guilt of the accused and such evidence should not
only be consistent with the guilt of the accused but
should be inconsistent with his innocence.”
25.
In State of U.P. v. Ashok Kumar Srivastava, (1992 Crl.LJ 1104),
it was pointed out by the Supreme Court that great care must be
taken in evaluating circumstantial evidence and if the evidence
relied on is reasonably capable of two inferences, the one in
favour of the accused must be accepted. It was also pointed out
that the circumstances relied upon must be found to have been
fully established and the cumulative effect of all the facts so
established must be consistent only with the hypothesis of guilt.
26.
Sir Alfred Wills in his admirable book “Wills’ Circumstantial
Evidence” (Chapter VI) lays down the following rules specially to
be observed in the case of circumstantial evidence: (1) the facts
alleged as the basis of any legal inference must be clearly proved
and beyond reasonable doubt connected with the factum
probandum; (2) the burden of proof is always on the party who
asserts the existence of any fact, which infers legal accountability;
(3) in all cases, whether of direct or circumstantial evidence the
best evidence must be adduced which the nature of the case
admits; (4) in order to justify the inference of guilt, the inculpatory
facts must be incompatible with the innocence of the accused and
incapable of explanation, upon any other reasonable hypothesis
than that of his guilt, (5) if there be any reasonable doubt of the
guilt of the accused, he is entitled as of right to be acquitted”.
27.
Five golden principles which constitute Panchseel of proof of case
based on circumstantial evidence have been laid down by the
Supreme Court in the matter of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v.
State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116 which state as under :“(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of
guilt is to be drawn should be fully established. The
circumstances concerned “must” or “should” and not
“may be” established;
(2) the facts so established should be consistent only
with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to
say, they should not be explainable on any other
hypothesis except that the accused is guilty;
(3) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature
and tendency;
(4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis
except the one to be proved; and
(5) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as
not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion
consistent with the innocence of the accused and must
show that in all human probability the act must have
been done by the accused.”
28.
The Supreme Court in the matter of Suresh and Another v State
of Haryana, (2018) 18 SCC 654 has observed that cases of
circumstantial evidence, the courts are called upon to make
inferences from the available evidence, which may lead to the
accused's guilt. The court at paras 41 and 42 has observed thus :
“41. The aforesaid tests are aptly referred as
Panchsheel of proof in Circumstantial Cases (refer to
Prakash v. State of Rajasthan). The expectation is
that the prosecution case should reflect careful
portrayal of the factual circumstances and inferences
thereof and their compatibility with a singular
hypothesis wherein all the intermediate facts and the
case itself are proved beyond reasonable doubt.
42. Circumstantial evidence are those facts, which
the court may infer further. There is a stark contrast
between direct evidence and circumstantial evidence.
In cases of circumstantial evidence, the courts are
called upon to make inferences from the available
evidence, which may lead to the accused's guilt. In
majority of cases, the inference of guilt is usually
drawn by establishing the case from its initiation to
the point of commission wherein each factual link is
ultimately based on evidence of a fact or an inference
thereof. Therefore, the courts have to identify the
facts in the first place so as to fit the case within the
parameters of “chain link theory” and then see
whether the case is made out beyond reasonable
doubt. In India we have for a long time followed the
“chain link theory” since Hanumant case, which of
course needs to be followed herein also.”
29.
The Supreme Court in the matter of Sailendra Rajdev Pasvan
and Others vs. State of Gujarat Etc., AIR 2020 SC 180 observed
that in a case of circumstantial evidence, law postulates two-fold
requirements. Firstly, that every link in the chain of circumstances
necessary to establish the guilt of the accused must be
established by the prosecution beyond reasonable doubt and
secondly, all the circumstances must be consistent pointing out
only towards the guilt of the accused. We need not burden this
judgment by referring to other judgments as the above principles
have been consistently followed and approved by this Court time
and again.
30.
In the present case, the prosecution has proved the following
circumstantial evidence against the appellants :(i)
After the incident, the mobile phone of the
deceased Roshan Yadav was being used by the
accused Barjesh Pandey by inserting his own SIM.
(ii)
On the basis of the call details of the accused,
after the incident, the accused was arrested and
interrogated.
(iii)
On the basis of the memorandum of the
accused, the stone, axe, saw, blade, blood-stained
clothes, mobile phone and the cash obtained from the
robbery were seized at the instance of the accused.
(iv)
As a result of the commission of the crime by
the accused Barjesh Pandey along with his other
accomplices, on the basis of the memorandum
statement, the money obtained from the robbery and
other materials used in the crime were seized from
the possession of Rahul Srivastava and Mukesh
Kumar Mandavi, who are in conflict with law.
(v)
The fingerprint of the right palm of the accused
Barjesh Pandey was found at the scene of the
incident, which proves the presence of the accused at
the scene of the incident. Witnesses of the seizure
and memorandum remains undeniable.
31.
The next question for consideration would be, whether the trial
Court has rightly held that the appellants are author of the crime
by relying upon the aforementioned circumstances ?
32.
It can thus clearly be seen that it is necessary for the prosecution
that the circumstances from which the conclusion of the guilt is to
be drawn should be fully established. The Court holds that it is a
primary principle that the accused ‘must be’ and not merely ‘may
be’ proved guilty before a court can convict the accused. It has
been held that there is not only a grammatical but a legal
distinction between ‘may be proved’ and ‘must be or should be
proved’. It has been held that the facts so established should be
consistent only with the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they
should not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the
accused is guilty. It has further been held that the circumstances
should be such that they exclude every possible hypothesis except
the one to be proved. It has been held that there must be a chain
of evidence so complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for
the conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and
must show that in all human probabilities the act must have been
done by the accused.
33.
It is settled law that the suspicion, however strong it may be,
cannot take the place of proof beyond reasonable doubt. An
accused cannot be convicted on the ground of suspicion, no
matter how strong it is. An accused is presumed to be innocent
unless proved guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
34.
In the light of these guiding principles, we will have to examine the
present case.
35.
PW-6 Sagarbati Sori has stated in her examination-in-chief that
since 2018 she is posted as Women Head Constable in Cyber
Cell, Kondagaon. During his posting in 2019, after endorsing a
letter sent by the Station House Officer (SHO) of Kondagaon to the
Superintendent of Police (SHO) of Kondagaon, the matter was
forwarded to the Cyber Cell of Kondagaon. Following this, the
Station House Officer (SHO) investigated the mobile numbers
9993239240,
7879757927,
6260531476,
and
EMI
number
869781038078700. The accused, Barjesh Pandey, was found to
be using the above-mentioned number on the deceased's mobile
phone, 9589851577. Information regarding the current location
and call details was obtained from Airtel, Reliance, and Jio, and
these numbers were found to be registered in the accused's name.
Upon extraction of the call details, it was revealed that the
accused, Barjesh Pandey, was using a SIM card in his own name
on the deceased's mobile phone. He then emailed a verified copy
of the call details to the Station House Officer (SHO) of
Kondagaon. She issued a certificate containing all information
related to the Cyber Cell under Section 65B of the Evidence Act
and sent it by post to the Station House Officer, Kondagaon.
The certificate is Exhibit P-15, which bears her signatures on parts
A to C.
36.
The above statements of this witness have not been contradicted
and in the cross-examination, no such fact could be brought
forward by the defence that the accused Barjesh Pandey was not
using the mobile cell of the deceased by inserting his SIM.
37.
PW-03 Vijay Yadav stated in his examination-in-chief that on
06.02.2019, in the afternoon, his relative Arun Yadav called him to
the SDOP office at Kondagaon. He went to the SDOP office and
saw that the police had arrested Barjesh Pandey, Rahul
Srivastava, and Mukesh Mandavi. In his presence, the police
interrogated the accused Barjesh Pandey. During the interrogation,
the accused told the police that he had killed Roshan Yadav along
with his two accomplices, Rahul Srivastava and Mukesh Mandavi.
The accused further stated, in his presence, that he had kept the
stone with which he had killed Roshan Yadav by hitting him on the
head, his blood-stained clothes, a screwdriver, and a saw blade in
a bag and had thrown the same into a bersham bush on the road
leading to Dogripara. He also stated that the looted amount of
₹87,500 and the mobile phone of the deceased had been
concealed under the roof of his house.
38.
The same witness further stated in his examination-in-chief that
the police prepared a memorandum of the accused’s statement as
per his disclosure, which is Ex.P-7, bearing his signatures at
places A to C. Thereafter, the accused Barjesh Pandey,
accompanied by the police and Deepak Thakur, went to the place
mentioned in the memorandum and produced a green bag before
the police. The said bag contained a screwdriver, a saw blade, the
clothes of the accused, a jacket, the stone used in the commission
of the offence, and the PAN card, driving licence, debit card, and
photograph of the deceased Roshan Yadav. When the accused
produced the bag from the bersham bush, the police seized the
same and prepared a seizure memo, Ex.P-8, on which his
signatures appear at places A to C.
39.
The witness further stated that thereafter the accused, along with
the police, went to his house at Prem Nagar, from where the
accused took out Rs. 87,500/- from a plastic bag kept in the
corridor of the house, along with the mobile phone of the
deceased and his own mobile phone, and handed them over to
the police. After seizure, a seizure memo, Ex.P-9, was prepared,
bearing his signature at place A. Thereafter, the police took the
accused to the house of Rahul Srivastava, who took out
Rs.14,000/- from under the armrest of his bed and handed it over
to the police. Subsequently, the police went to the house of
Mukesh Mandavi, who took out a bag kept near the door, from
which the police recovered Rs.9,520/-. Thereafter, the police
interrogated him and recorded his statement.
40.
PW-4 Deepak Thakur, in his examination-in-chief, deposed that he
was a partner of accused Barjesh Pandey and Rahul Srivastava
and was acquainted with the deceased, Roshan Yadav. On
02.02.2019, at about 8:00 a.m., he came to know from the local
residents that Roshan Yadav had been murdered at the E-Com
Courier Service Center, Kondagaon. Immediately thereafter, he
went to the said courier service center, where he found a police
officer present. The office shutter was half open and, upon looking
inside, he noticed Roshan Yadav lying on the floor with his hands
and feet tied with wire, with blood oozing from his head. He further
stated that at about 11:30 a.m., police personnel along with the
forensic team reached the spot and the office shutter was fully
opened. He entered the premises along with them and found
Roshan Yadav lying dead. Blood had spread around the body and
there were visible injuries on the face of the deceased. Thereafter,
the police prepared the inquest panchnama of the dead body and
sent it for post-mortem examination. PW-4 further deposed that on
06.02.2019, at about 1:00 p.m., he received a telephone call from
the Station House Officer, Police Station Kondagaon, asking him
to come to the SDOP Office, Kondagaon. On reaching the SDOP
office, he found three persons present there. During police
interrogation, the said persons disclosed their names as Barjesh
Pandey, Rahul Srivastava, and Mukesh Mandavi. He stated that
during interrogation, accused Barjesh Pandey disclosed that he
had worked as a courier boy under the deceased Roshan Yadav
for a period of about three months in the year 2018 and that he
was removed from service due to irregularities in monetary
transactions. He further stated that Barjesh Pandey disclosed that,
owing to personal enmity arising out of his termination by the
deceased, he, along with co-accused Rahul Srivastava and
Mukesh Mandavi, conspired to commit the murder of Roshan
Yadav.
41.
The aforesaid statement shows that accused Barjesh Pandey was
having motive to kill the deceased, with whom he had a personal
enmity as he was fired from the company by deceased Roshan
Yadav due to irregularities in money transactions.
42.
PW-7 Inspector Kamleshwar Singh, in his examination-in-chief,
deposed that he has been serving as an Inspector since
November, 2000. He stated that on 02.02.2019, he received
telephonic information from the Station House Officer, Police
Station Kondagaon, regarding the commission of a murder at ECom Express Courier Service, M.D.K. Flex Road, Bazarpara,
Kondagaon, and was directed to inspect the scene of occurrence.
Pursuant thereto, he visited and inspected the spot on 03.02.2019.
During inspection, he found a steel cupboard, a CPU, a
switchboard, a water bottle, a steel glass, and a twenty-litre jar of
SAI soft water at the place of occurrence. On applying appropriate
developing powder to the said articles, palm impressions marked
as A, B, C, D, E, F, G, and H were detected. He further deposed
that the chalk board impressions marked A, B, C, D, E, F, and G
were found unsuitable for comparison due to illegible and unclear
markings and the absence of sufficient identifiable points, whereas
the palm impression marked H was found suitable for comparison.
43.
PW-7 further stated that the details of the points observed on the
questioned palm impression marked ‘I’ and the specimen palm
impression marked ‘S-3’, sent by the police station in triplicate
enlarged photographs of the right palm (RP), were examined by
him. He described eight ridge characteristics (isopoints), namely
ridge ends, bifurcations, and short ridges, specifying their
respective positions and distances in relation to each other. He
opined that all eight isopoints were identical in their nature and
relative position. On the basis of the said comparison, he
expressed a firm opinion that the questioned palm impression
marked ‘I’ was identical to the specimen palm impression S-3
(RP), which was the right palm impression of accused Barjesh
Pandey. He proved his test report as Exhibit P-16, bearing his
signatures at portions ‘a’ to ‘c’.
44.
Thus, from the testimony of PW-7 and the expert report Exhibit P16, it stands established that the right palm impression of accused
Barjesh Pandey was found at the scene of occurrence, thereby
indicating his presence at the place of incident. The said evidence
remained unshaken during cross-examination, and no explanation
has been offered by the defence to rebut or account for the
presence of the palm impression at the scene.
45.
Upon a comprehensive re-appreciation of the entire oral and
documentary evidence on record, and in light of the settled
principles governing cases based on circumstantial evidence, this
Court is of the considered view that the prosecution has
succeeded in proving its case beyond reasonable doubt against
appellant Barjesh Pandey, whereas it has failed to establish the
guilt of appellant Rahul Shrivastava to the requisite standard of
proof.
46.
So far as appellant Barjesh Pandey is concerned, the prosecution
has established a complete and unbroken chain of circumstances
which conclusively points towards his guilt and is inconsistent with
any hypothesis of innocence. The homicidal death of the deceased
Roshan Yadav stands conclusively proved by the medical
evidence of PW-5 Dr. Sanjay Basak. The presence of appellant
Barjesh Pandey at the place of occurrence is firmly established by
the expert evidence of PW-7 Inspector Kamleshwar Singh, whose
testimony and report (Ex.P-16) conclusively prove that the right
palm impression of the appellant was found at the scene of
occurrence. The said evidence remained unchallenged in crossexamination and no explanation whatsoever was offered by the
appellant as to how his palm impression came to be present at the
scene.
47.
Further, the conduct of appellant Barjesh Pandey in using the
mobile phone of the deceased after the incident by inserting his
own SIM card, as proved by PW-6 Sagarbati Sori and supported
by the call detail records and certificate under Section 65B of the
Evidence Act (Ex.P-15), constitutes a strong incriminating
circumstance.
The
recoveries
effected
pursuant
to
the
memorandum statement of appellant Barjesh Pandey under
Section 27 of the Evidence Act, including blood-stained clothes,
weapon of offence, robbed cash, mobile phone, ATM cards and
other personal belongings of the deceased, further corroborate the
prosecution case. The recoveries were made from places within
the exclusive knowledge and possession of the appellant and
have been duly proved through independent witnesses.
48.
The motive for the commission of the offence has also been
established through the testimony of PW-4 Deepak Thakur, who
categorically deposed that appellant Barjesh Pandey was
terminated from service by the deceased due to irregularities in
monetary transactions and had developed personal enmity against
him. The motive, coupled with the strong forensic, documentary
and recovery evidence, completes the chain of circumstances
against appellant Barjesh Pandey.
49.
On cumulative consideration of the aforesaid circumstances, this
Court is satisfied that the prosecution has proved beyond
reasonable doubt that appellant Barjesh Pandey, in furtherance of
common intention, committed house-trespass, robbery and murder
of deceased Roshan Yadav. The conviction and sentence
recorded by the learned trial Court against appellant Barjesh
Pandey, therefore, warrant no interference.
50.
However, the case of appellant Rahul Shrivastava stands on an
entirely different footing. Against him, there is no evidence of lastseen, no forensic evidence, no fingerprint or footprint evidence, no
call detail record, and no independent evidence establishing his
presence at the place of occurrence or his participation in the
commission of the offence. His implication rests primarily on the
memorandum statement of co-accused Barjesh Pandey and the
alleged recovery of Rs.14,000/- and a blood-stained T-shirt.
51.
It is well settled that the memorandum statement of a co-accused
is not substantive evidence and can only be used to the extent
permissible under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. The recovered
cash has not been conclusively identified as part of the looted
amount, and the alleged blood-stained clothes have not been
scientifically linked to the deceased through FSL or DNA
examination. No overt act or prior meeting of minds has been
proved so as to attract Section 34 IPC against appellant Rahul
Shrivastava.
52.
In a case based purely on circumstantial evidence, each link in the
chain must be proved beyond reasonable doubt. The evidence on
record against appellant Rahul Shrivastava is wholly insufficient to
form a complete chain and does not exclude the hypothesis of
innocence. The benefit of doubt, therefore, must necessarily go to
appellant Rahul Shrivastava.
53.
Consequently, Criminal Appeal No. 1260 of 2021 filed by
appellant Barjesh Pandey is dismissed. The judgment of
conviction and order of sentence dated 06.09.2021 passed by the
learned Additional Sessions Judge (FTC), Kondagaon, District
Kondagaon, so far it relates to appellant Barjesh Pandey are
hereby affirmed. The appellant Barjesh Pandey shall continue to
undergo the sentence awarded to him by the trial Court.
54.
However, Criminal Appeal No. 1886 of 2022 filed by appellant
Rahul Shrivastava is allowed. The conviction and sentence
recorded against him by the learned trial Court are hereby set
aside. Appellant Rahul Shrivastava is acquitted of all the
charges. He shall be released forthwith, if not required in any
other case.
55.
Keeping in view of the provisions of Section 437-A CrPC (now
Section 481 of Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita) appellant
Rahul Shrivastava is directed to furnish a personal bond in terms
of from No.45 prescribed in the CrPC for a sum of Rs.25000/- with
2 reliable sureties in the like amount before the Court concerned
which shall be effective for a period of six months alongwith an
undertaking that in the event of filing of special leave petition
against the instant judgment or for grant of leave, the aforesaid
appellant on receipt of notice thereon shall appear before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court.
56.
The trial court record along with a copy of this judgment be sent
back immediately to the trial Court concerned for compliance and
necessary action.
57.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the
concerned Superintendent of Jail where appellant Barjesh Pandey
is undergoing his jail term, to serve the same on the appellant
informing him that he is at liberty to assail the present judgment
passed by this Court by preferring an appeal before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court with the assistance of the High Court Legal
Services Committee or the Supreme Court Legal Services
Committee.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Chandra
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review