Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:7020-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 1869 of 2025
Rahul Choubey @ Nitin S/o Late Ramesh Kumar Choubey Aged About
39 Years R/o House No.1134, Road No.21, Shanti Nagar, Bhilai, Police
Station Vaishali Nagar, District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
... Appellant(s)
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through Police Station Vaishali Nagar, District :
Durg, Chhattisgarh
...Respondent(s)
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant
For Respondent/State
:
:
Mr. Syed Majid Ali, Advocate.
Mr. S.S. Baghel, Government Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
09.02.2026
Digitally
signed by
BRIJMOHAN
BRIJMOHAN MORLE
MORLE
Date:
2026.02.19
10:20:19
+0530
1.
Heard Mr. Syed Majid Ali, learned counsel for the appellant. Also
heard Mr. S.S. Baghel, learned Government Advocate, appearing for
the State/respondent.
2.
This criminal appeal is preferred under Section 415 (2) of the
Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short, ‘BNSS’) is directed
against the impugned judgment dated 23.08.2025 passed by the
learned 8th Additional Session Judge, Durg, District Durg (C.G.) in
Session Trial No. 230 of 2021, by which the appellant has been
convicted and sentenced as under:
Conviction under Section
Sentence
Section 302 of the Indian
Rigorous imprisonment (for short,
Penal Code (for short, ‘IPC’),
‘R.I.’) for life and fine of Rs. 500/-, in
amended Section 103 of the
default of payment of fine, 02
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (for
months R.I. more.
short, ‘BNS’)
3.
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that on 25.05.2021, the
complainant, Utpal Taunk (PW-1), lodged a First Information Report
(FIR) at Police Station Vaishali Nagar, District Durg, stating that at about
03:18 PM, the accused, Rahul Choubey, called him over the phone and
asked him to come to his house. After some time, the complainant went
to his house. The accused, Rahul Choubey, opened the lock of the
channel gate, and when the complainant entered the house, he saw
Shabbir Ahmed lying unconscious in a blood-soaked condition in the
front room. He had been attacked with a pickaxe (gaiti) on his head with
the intention to kill him. The pointed end of the pickaxe was embedded
in his head and there was heavy bleeding. The accused, Rahul
Choubey, was sitting inside the house after assaulting him and
appeared very frightened.
4.
On the report of complainant Utpal Taunk (PW-1), information
regarding unnatural and accidental death was registered at Police
Station Vaishali Nagar vide report Ex.P/30, and intimation of the merg
was sent to the SDM. An FIR (Ex.P/1) was registered against the
accused under Section 302 of the IPC, and the investigation was taken
up. During the investigation, a spot map (Ex.P/2) of the place of
occurrence was prepared. The inquest report (Ex.P/9) of the dead body
was prepared. The dead body was sent for postmortem, and the
postmortem report (Ex.P/20) was obtained. In the presence of
witnesses, seizure memos of the CCTV (Ex.P/18) and air conditioner
(Ex.P/19) were prepared.
5.
After interrogating the accused, a memorandum statement
(Ex.P/11) under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act was recorded.
From the accused, Rahul Choubey, the jeans pant, underwear, and Tshirt worn at the time of the incident were seized. From the spot, bloodstained cotton, plain cotton, a plastic container containing plain soil (tile
pieces), and blood-stained tile pieces were seized, and a seizure memo
(Ex.P/12) was prepared. One McDowell No. 1 whisky bottle, half-filled
with liquor, four glass tumblers, a 16 GB pen drive, T-shirt, 14
photographs, an Onida company CCTV camera, an air conditioner, and
the sharp-edged pickaxe used in the incident were seized vide seizure
memos Exs.P/13 to P/19 and P/31. The accused was arrested in the
presence of witnesses, and an arrest memo (Ex.P/17) was prepared.
6.
In the present case, the clothes worn by the deceased at the time
of the incident, underwear and T-shirt seized from the accused, Rahul
Choubey, blood-stained cotton, plain cotton, tile pieces, plain tile pieces,
pickaxe, underwear, jeans, and T-shirt were sent to the Forensic
Science Laboratory (FSL) by preparing the necessary draft, and the
same were deposited at the FSL Office, Raipur. The FSL report (Ex.C/1)
was received.
7.
Statements
of
the
witnesses
were
recorded.
After
due
investigation, the police filed a charge-sheet against the appellant under
Sections 307 and 302 of the IPC before the jurisdictional criminal court,
and the case was committed to the Court of Session for trial. Thereafter,
the learned 8th Additional Sessions Judge, Durg, District Durg (C.G.),
received the case on transfer for trial, hearing, and disposal in
accordance with law.
8.
The learned trial Court framed charges against the appellant for
the offence punishable under Section 302 of the IPC (amended Section
103 of the BNS) and proceeded with the trial. The appellant abjured
guilt and entered a defence stating that he had not committed any
offence and had been falsely implicated.
9.
In order to prove the offence, the prosecution examined as many
as 17 witnesses and exhibited 31 documents in support of its case. The
appellant neither examined any witness in his defence nor exhibited any
document.
10.
The learned trial court, upon appreciation of the oral and
documentary evidence available on record, by its judgment dated
23.08.2025, convicted the accused/appellant for the offence punishable
under Section 302 of the IPC (amended Section 103 of the BNS) and
sentenced him as aforementioned, against which this criminal appeal
has been filed.
11.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the learned trial
Court is wholly unjustified in convicting the appellant for the offence
punishable under Section 103 of the BNS (corresponding to Section
302 of the IPC), as the prosecution has failed to prove the offence
beyond reasonable doubt. He further submits that the conviction and
sentence awarded by the learned trial Court are not proper in the facts
and circumstances of the case. Moreover, the prosecution has failed to
establish its case beyond reasonable doubt. He contends that the
conviction is based on conjectures and surmises, and the seizure
witnesses have also not fully supported the prosecution case. He further
contends that even if the prosecution case is accepted in its entirety, the
appellant is alleged to have caused injuries to the deceased in the spur
of the moment. There was no motive or premeditated intention on the
part of the appellant to cause the death of the deceased, and it was only
on account of a sudden quarrel, in the heat of passion and anger, that
the appellant caused injuries to the deceased, which resulted in his
death. Therefore, the case of the present appellant falls within the ambit
of Exception 4 to Section 100 of the BNS (corresponding to Exception 4
to Section 300 of the IPC), and the act of the appellant would amount to
culpable homicide not amounting to murder punishable under Sections
101 and 102 of the BNS (corresponding to Section 304 Part-I or Part-II
of the IPC). Hence, this is a fit case where the conviction of the
appellant under Section 302 of the IPC (now Section 103 of the BNS)
deserves to be altered to an offence punishable under Sections 101/102
of the BNS. Accordingly, the present appeal deserves to be allowed,
either in full or in part.
12.
On the other hand, learned State counsel supports the impugned
judgment and submits that the present case does not fall within any of
the exceptions contained in Section 100 of the BNS, and the learned
trial Court has rightly convicted the appellant under Section 302 of the
IPC (now Section 103 of the BNS). It is further submitted that this is not
a case where the conviction of the appellant can be altered to an
offence punishable under Sections 101 or 102 of the BNS, and
therefore, the instant criminal appeal deserves to be dismissed.
13.
We have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties,
considered their rival submissions made hereinabove and also went
through the records with utmost circumspection.
14.
The first question for consideration would be, whether death of
deceased was homicidal in nature ?
15.
Dr. Sonika Williams (PW-9), upon conducting the postmortem
examination of the dead body of the deceased, Shabbir Ahmed, stated
that there were 20 stitches between both parietal bones of the head
extending to the right temporal bone. She opined that the cause of
death was cardio-respiratory arrest resulting from the injuries sustained
by the deceased and proved the postmortem report (Ex.P/20), which
bears her signature. Her statements are duly corroborated by the
postmortem report (Ex.P/20). Even in cross-examination, the testimony
of the aforesaid prosecution witness remained unshaken. Thus, from
the testimony of the said witness and the postmortem report produced
by the prosecution, it stands duly proved that the death of Shabbir
Ahmed was homicidal in nature. The learned counsel for the appellant
has not been able to controvert the finding recorded by the learned trial
Court on this aspect. Therefore, we are of the considered opinion that
the finding recorded by the learned trial Court that the death of the
deceased was homicidal in nature is a finding of fact based on the
evidence available on record. The said finding is neither perverse nor
contrary to the material on record. Accordingly, we affirm the said
finding.
16.
The
next
question
for
consideration
is
whether
the
accused/appellant herein is the perpetrator of the crime in question. The
learned trial Court has answered this issue in the affirmative by relying
upon the testimony of Dr. Sonika Williams (PW-9), who conducted the
postmortem examination and opined that the death occurred due to
excessive bleeding from the injuries sustained by the deceased, which
resulted in cardiac arrest and shock, and that the nature of death was
homicidal. From the medical evidence and other evidence available on
record, it is clear that the appellant, on the fateful date and time, caused
grievous injuries to the deceased, which ultimately resulted in his death.
As such, the learned trial Court has rightly held that it was the
appellant/accused who caused injuries to the deceased, leading to his
death. Accordingly, we hereby affirm the said finding.
17.
The aforesaid finding brings us to the next question for
consideration, whether the case of the appellant is covered within
Exception 4 to Section 100 of the BNS (corresponding to Exception 4 to
Section 300 of the IPC) vis-a-vis culpable homicide not amounting to
murder and his conviction can be converted to under Sections 101 and
102 of the BNS (corresponding to Section 304 Part-I or Part-II of the
IPC), as contended by learned counsel for the appellant ?
18.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Sukhbir Singh v.
State of Haryana1 has observed as under:“21. Keeping in view the facts and circumstances of
the case, we are of the opinion that in the absence of
the existence of common object Sukhbir Singh is
proved to have committed the offence of culpable
homicide without premeditation in a sudden fight in
the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel and did
not act in a cruel or unusual manner and his case is
covered by Exception 4 of Section 300 IPC which is
punishable under Section 304 (Part I) IPC. The
finding of the courts below holding the aforesaid
appellant guilty of offence of murder punishable
under Section 302 IPC is set aside and he is held
guilty for the commission of offence of culpable
(2002) 3 SCC 327
homicide not amounting to murder punishable under
Section 304 (Part I) IPC and sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for 10 years and to pay a fine
of Rs.5000. In default of payment of fine, he shall
undergo further rigorous imprisonment for one year.”
19.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Gurmukh Singh v.
State of Haryana2 has laid down certain factors which are to be taken
into consideration before awarding appropriate sentence to the accused
with reference to Section 302 or Section 304 Part II of the IPC, which
state as under :“23. These are some factors which are required to be
taken into consideration before awarding appropriate
sentence to the accused. These factors are only
illustrative in character and not exhaustive. Each
case has to be seen fro its special perspective. The
relevant factors are as under :
(a) Motive or previous enmity;
(b) Whether the incident had taken place on the
spur of the moment;
(c) The intention/knowledge of the accused
while inflicting the blow or injury;
(d) Whether the death ensued instantaneously
(2009) 15 SCC 635
or the victim died after several days;
(e) The gravity, dimension and nature of injury;
(f) The age and general health condition of the
accused;
(g) Whether the injury was caused without
premeditation in a sudden fight;
(h) The nature and size of weapon used for
inflicting the injury and the force with which the
blow was inflicted;
(i) The criminal background and adverse history
of the accused;
(j) Whether the injury inflicted was not sufficient
in the ordinary course of nature to cause death
but the death was because of shock;
(k) Number of other criminal cases pending
against the accused;
(l) Incident occurred within the family members
or close relations;
(m) The conduct and behaviour of the accused
after the incident.
Whether the accused had taken the injured/the
deceased to the hospital immediately to ensure
that he/she gets proper medical treatment ?
These are some of the factors which can be
taken into consideration while granting an
appropriate sentence to the accused.
24. The list of circumstances enumerated above is
only illustrative and not exhaustive. In our considered
view, proper and appropriate sentence to the
accused is the bounded obligation and duty of the
court. The endeavour of the court must be to ensure
that the accused receives appropriate sentence, in
other words, sentence should be according to the
gravity of the offence. These are some of the
relevant factors which are required to be kept in view
while convicting and sentencing the accused.”
20.
Likewise, in the matter of State v. Sanjeev Nanda3, their
Lordships of the Hon’ble Supreme Court have held that once knowledge
that it is likely to cause death is established but without any intention to
cause death, then jail sentence may be for a term which may extend to
10 years or with fine or with both. It has further been held that to make
out an offence punishable under Section 304 Part II of the IPC, the
prosecution has to prove the death of the person in question and such
death was caused by the act of the accused and that he knew that such
(2012) 8 SCC 450
act of his is likely to cause death.
21.
Further, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Arjun v.
State of Chhattisgarh4 has elaborately dealt with the issue and
observed in paragraphs 20 and 21, which reads as under :“20. To invoke this Exception 4, the requirements
that are to be fulfilled have been laid down by this
Court in Surinder Kumar v. UT, Chandigarh [(1989) 2
SCC 217 : 1989 SCC (Cri) 348], it has been
explained as under : (SCC p. 220, para 7)
“7. To invoke this exception four requirements must
be satisfied, namely, (I) it was a sudden fight; (ii)
there was no premeditation; (iii) the act was done in
a heat of passion; and (iv) the assailant had not
taken any undue advantage or acted in a cruel
manner. The cause of the quarrel is not relevant nor
its I relevant who offered the provocation or started
the assault. The number of wounds caused during
the occurrence is not a decisive factor but what is
important is that the occurrence must have been
sudden and unpremeditated and the offender must
have acted in a fit of anger. Of course, the offender
must not have taken any undue advantage or acted
in a cruel manner. Where, on a sudden quarrel, a
(2017) 3 SCC 247
person in the heat of the moment picks up a weapon
which is handy and causes injuries, one of which
proves fatal, he would be entitled to the benefit of
this exception provided he has not acted cruelly.”
21. Further in Arumugam v. State [(2008) 15 SCC
590 : (2009) 3 SCC (Cri) 1130], in support of the
proposition of law that under what circumstances
Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC can be invoked if
death is caused, it has been explained as under :
(SCC p. 596, para 9)
“9. …. '18. The help of exception 4 can be
invoked
if
death
is
caused
(a)
without
premeditation; (b) in a sudden fight; (c) without
the offender's having taken undue advantage or
acted in a cruel or unusual manner; and (d) the
fight must have been with the person killed. To
bring a case within Exception 4 all the
ingredients mentioned in it must be found. It is to
be noted that the “fight” occurring in Exception 4
to Section 300 IPC is not defined in the Penal
Code, 1860. It takes two to make a fight. Heat of
passion requires that there must be no time for
the passions to cool down and in this case, the
parties had worked themselves into a fury on
account
of
the
verbal
altercation
in
the
beginning. A fight is a combat between two or
more persons whether with or without weapons.
It is not possible to enunciate any general rule
as to what shall be deemed to be a sudden
quarrel. It is a question of fact and whether a
quarrel is sudden or not must necessarily
depend upon the proved facts of each case. For
the application of Exception 4, it is not sufficient
to show that there was a sudden quarrel and
there was no premeditation. It must further be
shown that the offender has not taken undue
advantage or acted in cruel or unusual manner.
The expression “undue advantage” as used in
the provisions means “unfair advantage”.
22.
In the matter of Arjun (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held that if there is intent and knowledge, the same would be case of
Section 304 Part-I of the IPC and if it is only a case of knowledge and
not the intention to cause murder and bodily injury, then same would be
a case of Section 304 Part-II of the IPC.
23.
Further, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Rambir v.
State (NCT of Delhi)5 has laid down four ingredients which should be
tested to bring a case within the purview of Exception 4 to Section 300
of IPC, which reads as under:
5 (2019) 6 SCC 122
“16. A plain reading of Exception 4 to Section 300
IPC shows that the following four ingredients are
required:
(i)
There must be a sudden fight;
(ii)
There was no premeditation;
(iii)
The act was committed in a heat of
passion; and
(iv)
The offender had not taken any undue
advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual
manner.”
24.
The complainant, Utpal Taunk (PW-1), deposed that on
25.05.2021 at about 3:00 p.m., he had come to his house at Vaishali
Nagar for lunch. At that time, he received a phone call from the
accused, Rahul Choubey, asking him to come to his house. After
finishing lunch, he went to the accused’s house and knocked at the
door, which was opened by the accused. Upon entering the hall, he saw
Shabbir Ahmed writhing in pain with a pickaxe lodged in his head and
blood oozing out. Frightened, he proceeded to Police Station Vaishali
Nagar, Bhilai, and lodged the report (Ex.P/1). The police prepared the
spot map (Exs.P/2 and P/3) and recorded his statement. In crossexamination, he admitted that he did not know how, why, or by whom
the injuries were caused. He further admitted that the accused never
told him that he had assaulted the deceased. He also conceded that in
the FIR he did not state that the accused had killed the deceased and
was present at the spot. He further admitted that the FIR was written by
the police and was neither read over to him nor read by him before
signing. Thus, his testimony does not establish that he witnessed the
accused assaulting the deceased. However, it establishes that upon
being called by the accused and entering his house, he saw the
deceased in an injured condition with a pickaxe embedded in his head.
25.
Arvind Kumar Dubey (PW-2) stated that on the morning of
25.05.2021, at about 9:00–9:15 a.m., the deceased called him to collect
liquor and deliver it to Rahul Choubey’s house. He did so and later also
delivered onions at the deceased’s request. He consumed one drink
and returned to his duty. At about 2:00 p.m., he went home and later
received missed calls from Shabbir and the accused, which he could
not attend. In the evening, he was called to the police station and
questioned. In cross-examination, he admitted that he had no
knowledge of how or by whom the incident was committed. His
testimony only establishes that the deceased was present at the
accused’s house earlier in the day and that they had consumed liquor
together.
26.
Sunder Singh (PW-3) stated that on the date of the incident, he
arranged mutton at the request of the deceased and accompanied him
to the accused’s house. There, Rahul, Shabbir, Arvind, and he
consumed liquor together. He stated that Shabbir had paid Rs.7,000/- to
Rahul in connection with AC repair. However, he denied that any quarrel
took place between the accused and the deceased regarding the said
amount. He further admitted in cross-examination that no dispute or
fight occurred in his presence and that he had no knowledge of how the
incident occurred. His testimony thus only establishes that the parties
were together earlier in the day and were consuming liquor.
27.
Suyash (PW-4), the AC technician, deposed that he had earlier
repaired the AC at the accused’s house and had removed the PCB for
repair. He further stated that on the following day, the accused
repeatedly called him and used abusive language, due to which he
blocked the number. His testimony establishes prior dealings between
the accused and the deceased in connection with AC repair but does
not directly prove the occurrence of the assault.
28.
Adil Ahmed (PW-5), son of the deceased, stated that his father
had gone to the accused’s house for AC repair work. He later learned
that the accused had assaulted his father with a pickaxe. However, his
knowledge of the incident was based on information received from his
uncle Wakeel Ahmed. His testimony is therefore hearsay insofar as the
actual assault is concerned.
29.
Irshad Ahmed (PW-6) also stated that a dispute had occurred
between the accused and the deceased regarding AC repair, resulting
in the assault. However, in cross-examination, he admitted that no
dispute took place in his presence and that his statement was based on
information provided by others. His evidence, therefore, is also hearsay
regarding the actual occurrence.
30.
Nawabuddin Kaji (PW-7) deposed regarding the seizure of various
articles including blood-stained soil, tile pieces, whisky bottle, glasses,
clothing of the accused, photographs, and CCTV footage. However, in
cross-examination, he admitted that the documentation was prepared at
the police station and not at the spot in his presence, and that he was
unaware when the accused was interrogated. Thus, while seizure of
articles is proved, procedural irregularities weaken the evidentiary value
of the memorandum statement.
31.
Wakeel Ahmed (PW-8), brother of the deceased, stated that a
dispute arose at the accused’s house regarding AC repair, following
which the accused assaulted the deceased with a pickaxe. However, his
knowledge of the actual assault is not based on personal observation.
He reached the hospital after the incident and saw the deceased in a
critical condition with the pickaxe lodged in his head.
32.
Reverting to the facts of the present case, it is evident from the
testimonies of material witnesses that none of them witnessed the
actual assault. The evidence establishes that the deceased and the
accused were together at the accused’s house and had consumed
liquor. The presence of the accused at the scene is established, and the
deceased sustained fatal injuries by a pickaxe inside the accused’s
house. The evidence further suggests that there was a monetary
transaction regarding AC repair and that both parties were under the
influence of alcohol. There is no direct evidence of premeditation. The
circumstances indicate that the incident occurred in the course of a
sudden altercation. Thus, although the act of the accused in inflicting
the injury with a pickaxe is established by circumstantial evidence, the
prosecution has not proved beyond reasonable doubt that the act was
committed with the intention to cause death so as to attract Section 302
IPC. The circumstances rather indicate a sudden quarrel without
premeditation, committed in the heat of passion, without evidence of
undue advantage or cruelty beyond the act itself. Accordingly, the case
would fall within the ambit of Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC (now
Section 101 read with Section 105 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita,
2023), and the offence would be punishable under Section 105 of the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.
33.
Considering the totality of the evidence, the nature of injury, the
surrounding circumstances, and the fact that the appellant-Rahul
Choubey @ Nitin is about 39 years of age and has been in custody
since 25.05.2021, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
conviction recorded under Section 302 of the IPC (now Section 103 of
the BNS) deserves to be modified.
34.
Consequently, the conviction and sentence of the appellant under
Section 302 of the IPC (now Section 103 of the BNS) are set aside.
Instead, he is convicted under Section 105 of the Bharatiya Nyaya
Sanhita, 2023 (corresponding to Section 304 Part-I of the IPC) and
sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 10 years. The fine
amount and default stipulation imposed by the learned trial Court shall
remain unaltered.
35.
The appellant is presently in custody and shall serve out the
remaining sentence as modified hereinabove.
36.
The criminal appeal is partly allowed to the extent indicated
above.
37.
The Registry is directed to transmit a copy of this judgment to the
concerned Superintendent of Jail where the appellant is lodged, for
compliance and for informing him that he is at liberty to prefer an appeal
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court with the assistance of the High Court
Legal Services Committee or the Supreme Court Legal Services
Committee.
38.
Let a certified copy of this judgment along with the original record
be sent to the trial Court forthwith for information and necessary
compliance.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Brijmohan
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review