The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. Since the main petition has been dism dismissed, pending application, n, if any, is rendered ered in infructuous. (MA
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRM-M-67911--2025 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH
H
COURT OF PUNJAB
JAB A
AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
ARH
(135)
CRM-M-67911-2025 (O&M)
M)
Date of decision : 24.03.2026
RAHUL CHHIK
HIKARA
... Petitioner
oner
Versus
STATE OF HARYANA
HAR
AND ANR.
...Respondentss
CORAM: HON'BLE
HON
MRS. JUSTICE MANIS
ANISHA BATRA
Present:
Mr. Deepender Singh, Sr. Advocate
cate w
with
Mr. Dharamvir
D
Singh, Advocatee for tthe petitioner
Mr. Neeraj
N
Poswal, AAG, Haryana
****
MANISHA BATR
BATRA, J. (ORAL)
1.
The instant one is the second petitio
petition preferred by the petitioner
ioner
under Section
on 48
483 of Bharatiya Nagarik Surak
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short
“BNSS”) forr gran
grant of regular bail in casee arisi
arising out of FIR No.076 dated
ated
23.03.2025 registered
regist
under Sections 103(1)
(1) and 3(5) of Bharatiya Nyaya
yaya
Sanhita, 2023
23 (for short “BNS”) (Section 103(1) & 3(5) of BNS were deleted
leted
and Section 105 of BNS was added) at Polic
Police Station Sadar Bahadugarh,
garh,
District Jhajjar.
jjar.
His first bearing CRM-M-34
34698-2025 was dismissed
d as
withdrawn.
2.
The aforementioned FIR was initia
initially registered under Section
ction
103(1) read with Section 3(5) of BNS, onn the basis of a written complaint
laint
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.25 13:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-67911--2025 (O&M)
submitted by
y the complainant
c
Sunita allegingg there
therein that her brother Pawan,, her
02 sisters and
nd she herself owned some agricultur
ricultural land in Village Kanaunda.
nda.
Her brother was interested
i
to sell his house
se in tthe village and the above-said
said
land. For this
is purpose,
pur
some deal was goingg on w
with a co-villager-Rahul i.e.. the
present petitioner.
tioner. The petitioner alongwith one yyouth and her brother had come
ome
to her matrimoni
rimonial house at Village Bakner
ner aabout 15-20 days back.
The
complainantt had ttold her brother to firstly offer
ffer to sell their property to somee of
their family members
memb
and suggested that iff none was interested only then the
same could be so
sold to anyone else. The petitio
petitioner felt offended at this and
started telling
g her brother that he had back-tracke
tracked from his promise to sell
ll his
land to him.. He insisted for making payment
ent of some earnest money butt her
brother refused
sed to do so and then by extending
ing thr
threats and hurling abuses to
o her
brother, the petitioner
petitio
had left. Her brotherr had sstayed with her and went back
to his village
ge about
abo 2-3 days thereafter. In the morning of 23.03.2025,, she
received informat
ormation that her brother had been ddrowned in a well existing
g in
their agricultural
tural lland. On reaching there shee foun
found the dead body of her brother
other
floating in the
he wel
well. There were marks of injuries
juries on his head. The complainant
inant
alleged that she had
ha made inquiries at her level
evel and had come to know thatt the
petitioner alongwi
ongwith her brother and Amit were
ere pr
present at the spot at the timee of
occurrence. By fur
further alleging that her brother
ther ha
had been killed by the petitioner
ioner
and the above-sai
said Amit and then was drowned
rowned in the well, she prayed
d for
taking action
n in th
the matter.
3.
After registration of FIR, investigatio
stigation proceedings were initiated.
ated.
The post-mortem
ortem of the dead body of the
he vic
victim was conducted.
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.25 13:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
During
uring
CRM-M-67911--2025 (O&M)
investigation,
n, the statement of Amit under Sectio
Section 183 of BNSS was recorded.
rded.
The petitioner
ner was
w arrested on 27.03.2025.
25.
O
On interrogation, he suffered
fered
disclosure stateme
tatement admitting his involvement
ment in the crime. Offence under
nder
Section 103(1)
(1) wa
was deleted during the course
se of in
investigation and offence under
nder
Section 105 of BNS
BN was added. Investigation
on now stands concluded.
4.
It is argued
a
by learned Senior counse
counsel for the petitioner that hee has
been falsely impl
implicated in this case. The state
statement of eye-witness Amit
it as
recorded under
der S
Section 183 of BNSS clearly
learly shows that during a verbal
erbal
altercation that had
ha taken place between thee peti
petitioner and the victim, he had
only given a fist b
blow to him. The victim,, howe
however, had lost balance and had
fallen in the well. PW Amit had even jumped
ed into the well to save the victim.. It
was the petitioner
tioner who with the help of other
er pers
persons had taken Amit out off the
well. There is total
tota absence of mens rea on the pa
part of the petitioner for causing
sing
death of the victim.
victim The complainant was not
ot an eye-witness to the occurrence.
ence.
The allegations as narrated in the FIR are entire
entirely based on assumptions and
suspicions. He is in custody for a period off almo
almost a year. The trial will take
considerablee time to conclude. He is nott requ
required for further investigation.
tion.
Now challan
n has b
been presented under Section
ion 10
105 of BNS showing that hee did
not have any
y intention
inte
to commit murder of th
the victim. No useful purpose
pose
would be served
erved by detaining him in custody
tody aanymore. His antecedentss are
clean. It is, therefore,
therefo urged that the petitioner
er des
deserves to be released on bail.
5.
Status report has been filed. Learned
earned State counsel has argued that
the petition being a successive one is not maintai
ntainable as there is no change
ge in
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.25 13:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-67911--2025 (O&M)
the circumstances
tances from his previous petition.
n. It iis further argued that theree are
serious allegations
gations against the petitioner. Hee had animus to cause death off the
victim since the latter
la
had refused to sell his
is lan
land to the petitioner a few days
back. The petitioner
petitio
did not make any attempt
mpt to save the victim. The victim
ictim
knew how to swim
wim and could have certainlyy saved himself, if he had fallen into
the well by stumb
stumbling, however, it was not so. S
Several injuries were found
d on
the dead body
dy of the victim which are clearly
early ssuggestive of the fact thatt the
petitioner had
ad firstly
first been assaulted and caused
sed in
injuries and then he was thrown
rown
into the welll by th
the petitioner. The material
al witn
witnesses namely the complainant
inant
and PW Amit
mit are
ar yet to be examined.
There are chances of petitioner’s
ner’s
intimidating them
them. With these broad submission
issions, it is urged that the petition
tition
does not deserve
erve to be allowed.
6.
This Court
C
has heard the rival submis
ubmissions made by learned counsel
unsel
for the parties
es at co
considerable length.
7.
So far
fa as the aspect of maintainabilit
nability of the petition is concerned,
rned,
successive petition
ion for grant of bail is maintainable
ainable, however, the petitioner must
give some lucid aand substantive reasons for fili
filing the same alongwith some
drastic change
ge in the circumstances. The petitio
petitioner withdrew his first petition
tition
on 15.10.2025
25 and
an thereafter this petition had bbeen filed on 29.11.2025. No
substantive or dras
drastic change in the circumstances
tances has also been pointed outt and
on this very ground,
groun the petition cannot be stated to be maintainable. Moreso,
reso,
the petitionerr is alleged
al
to have assaulted thee victi
victim on the fateful night nearr the
well in question.
tion. He had fallen into the well.
ll. The allegations prima facie make
ake
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.25 13:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-67911--2025 (O&M)
out a case for
or commission
com
of subject offencee as ag
against the petitioner who while
hile
knowing thee result
resu of his pushing the victim
tim ne
near the well could be his fall
therein, stilll chos
chose to push him. The allegation
egations against him are serious
us in
nature. The trial is
i at its nascent stage. Thee con
contention that he may intimidate
idate
the witnessess cannot
cann be stated to be unfounded.
nded. There is nothing on record
rd to
show that there
ere would
wo
be any undue delay inn the cconclusion of the trial. Taking
king
into consideration
eration the above discussed facts,
cts, th
this Court is of the considered
ered
opinion thatt the petitioner
p
does not deserve to be extended benefit of bail. No
compelling ground to allow the petition is made oout. Accordingly, the samee is
dismissed.
8.
It is, however, clarified that thee obse
observations made above shalll not
be construed
d as an expression of opinion of this C
Court on the merits of the case
and shall nott influ
influence the outcome of the trial
ial in aany manner.
9.
Since the main petition has been dism
dismissed, pending application,
n, if
any, is rendered
ered in
infructuous.
(MA
(MANISHA BATRA)
JUDGE
24.03.2026
Amit Sharma
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.25 13:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
Whether speaking/reasoned:- Yes
Yes/No
Whether reportable:- Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review