Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
1.
2.
1.
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.66 of 2020
======================================================
Radhey Shyam Agrawal son of Late Ram Kumar Agrawal resident of Siwani
House, Road No. 12, Rajendra Nagar, P.S. Kadamkuan, District/ TownPatna (800016).
Subhash Kumar Agrawal son of Late Ram Kumar Agrawal resident of
Siwani House, Road No. 12, Rajendra Nagar, P.S. Kadamkuan, District/
Town- Patna (800016).
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
The Bihar State Housing Board having its office at, 6, Sardar Patel Marg,
Patna Through its Managing Director.
2.
The Managing Director, Bihar State Housing Board, 6, Sardar Patel Marg,
Patna- 800001.
3.
The Revenue Officer, Bihar State Housing Board, 6, Sardar Patel Marg,
Patna- 800001.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s
For the Respondent/s
For the BSHB
:
:
:
:
:
Mr. Ashok Kumar Chaudhary, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Mohit Agarwal, Advocate
Mr. Mukesh Prasad Singh, Advocate
Mr. Pawan Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Dr. Anand Kumar, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV ROY
ORAL ORDER
16-07-2026
Heard Mr. Ashok Kumar Chaudhary, learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioners and Dr. Anand Kumar, learned
counsel
representing
the
Bihar
State
Housing
Board
(henceforth for short ‘the Board’).
2. The present petition has been preferred for the
grant of following relief(s):
“for issuance of writ in the nature of writ of
certiorari
for
quashing
the
letter
dated
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
2/13
05.08.2014 (Annexure-12) and letter dated
30.07.2018 (Annexure 15) issued by the Deputy
Revenue Office and Revenue Officer, Bihar
State Housing Board by which a demand for
Rs.1,04,42,938.77 by 31.10.2014 has been
raised against the petitioner's Plot No. DS-24D
at Lohianagar, Patna which was allotted to the
petitioners in an auction sale and the petitioners
have already deposited the entire bid amount
with applicable interest in terms of agreement
dated 13.04.1985 (Annexure-3) by 19.12.1995
(Annexure -6); and when the petitioners raised
objection
regarding
calculation
and
applicability of interest, then the Board vide
letter dated 30.07.2018 (Annexure-15) has
communicated that "as per Board's decision
compound interest is chargeable" (although the
Hire Purchase Agreement stipulates for simple
interest on account of delay in payment of
installments).
And further for issuance of writ in the
nature of writ of mandamus directing the
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
3/13
respondents - Board to calculate the demand on
the basis of applying simple interest on delayed
payment of installments if any, and thereafter to
execute Lease Deed in favour of the petitioner
on payment of fresh demand.
And
for
issuance
of
writ/order/direction for which the petitioners
may be found entitled in the facts and
circumstances of the present case.”
3. The matter relates to a piece of land [Plot No. DS24D situated at Lohianagar, Patna] which belong to ‘the
Board’.
4. ‘The Board’ auctioned series of lands (which
included the aforesaid land) under the signature of its
Managing Director dated 31.01.1984. The terms of auction
read as follows:
“1. In addition to 10% already paid on or
before 9.2.84, a sum equivalent to 15% (fifteen
percent) of the bid amount shall have to be paid
to the credit of the Board by the highest bidder
by 27.3.84, Failure to deposit the aforesaid
amount
by
the
aforesaid
date
shall
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
4/13
automatically result in forfeiture of the security
amount of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand) as
also the amount equivalent to 10% of the bid
amount and his application and bid shall stand
rejected.
2. Allotment order will be issued only after
the aforesaid amount equivalent to 25% (Twenty
five percent) of the bid money has duly been
deposited and credited to the Board's accounts.
3. The balance amount of the bid money for
the concerned residential/commercial plot will
have to be deposited and credited to the Board's
account by the successful bidder in six equated
half yearly installments beginning from the date
of issue of the allotment order with interest at
the rate of 14% (fourteen percent) per annum.
In case of first default in depositing any
installment, the interest shall be charged at 18%
(eighteen percent) per annum of the total
amount due but in cases of default in depositing
two consecutive installments, the allotment shall
stand cancelled and all deposits, payments
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
5/13
security amount etc. made so far shall stand
forfeited and the allotment cancelled.
4. Possession over the settled plot of land
will be delivered to the successful bidder in
vacant
condition
after
execution
and
registration of the agreement in the prescribed
form and after performing all necessary
formalities as per the equipments of the Bihar
State Housing Board Act, 1982 and rules,
regulations etc. made there under.”
5. Pursuant thereto, the petitioners participated and
were successful bidder for the aforesaid plot. Accordingly,
letter dated 06.06.1984 was issued to this effect by ‘the Board’
and this followed the agreement between the parties on 12 th
April, 1985. It is important to incorporate clause 4 and 8 of the
said agreement signed between the parties and read as under:
“4. That the settlee will pay to the Board
without waiting for any demand the remaining
75% cost of the said plot of land with as interest
@ fourteen per cent (14%) per annum thereon
chargeable from the date of delivery of
possession in six equated half yearly instalment
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
6/13
a sum of Rs.58,534/- (Rs. Fifty eight thousand
five hundred thirty four) only to be paid within
the 15th day of the following month on which the
instalment become due.
8. That interest @ 14% (Fourteen per cent)
per annum shall be charged on all dues,
beginning from the date of the delivery of
possession over the said plot. In case of first
default in depositing any instalment interest
shall be charged @18% eighteen per cent per
annum of the amount due. But in case of default
in depositing two consecutive instalments the
allotment shall stand cancelled, and all
deposits, payments etc. made shall stand
forfeited.”
6. The aforesaid agreement clearly records that from
the date of delivery, the allottee will have to pay the rest of the
amount in six equal half yearly installment at the rate of
Rs.58,534/- only to be paid by 15th day of the following month
which the installment become due. It was also clear that 14%
interest per annum shall be charged beginning the date of
delivery of possession and in case of first default, it will
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
7/13
increase to 18% per annum and in case of default of depositing
two consecutive installments, the allotment shall be canceled
and all the deposits/payments shall be forfeited.
7. The petitioners got the possession of the said land
on 08.03.1989. In that circumstance, the dates on which the
payments that were to be made as per the agreement is/are as
under:
(i) 15.10.1989;
(ii) 15.04.1990;
(iii) 15.10.1990;
(iv) 15.04.1991;
(v) 15.10.1991
(vi)15.04.1992.
8. However, in complete defiance of the agreement
signed between the parties, the petitioners came up with the
first payment of Rs.1,00,000/- only on 09.03.1992, i.e. three
years after they got the possession. They again slept over the
matter
and
two
years
later,
on
22.01.1994,
another
Rs.1,80,000/- was paid.
9. So far as ‘the Board’ is concerned, on 25.04.1990,
it should have issued the letter of annulment of the plot as the
petitioners failed to pay the successive second installment and
also had the right to forfeit the earlier deposited amount.
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
8/13
10. However, it slept over the matter and it was only
on 06.12.1995, that the direction was given to pay Rs.93,134/failing which the allotment shall be canceled. The petitioner
was prompt enough to clear the amount on 18.12.1995.
11. Fourteen years later, vide letter no. 10789 dated
25.11.2009, ‘the Board’ drawing the attention of the petitioners
to earlier letter no. 2765 dated 18.06.2001 informed that they
were supposed to pay Rs.11,61,427/- (calculated on the delayed
payment interest up to 31.07.2001) but they chose not to make
any payment and as such, by 30.11.2009, the total due accrued
was Rs.46,33,530/- which the petitioners were to clear.
12. The petitioners submitted their reply two years
later on 17.11.2011 informing that they were to pay only
Rs.3,51,204/- as per the sixth installment but had actually paid
Rs.3,73,134/-. As such, there is no due against them.
13. Once again and in continuation with the sleeping
mode in which ‘the Board’ has the habit to go, it finally
informed the petitioners to pay Rs.94,10,288.43/- immediately
on 21.03.2014 which followed another letter dated 05.08.2014.
14. The petitioners submitted its reply three years
later on 13.09.2017 asking for the calculation chart else, they
shall be constrained to approach the Court. A petition was also
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
9/13
filed to calculate the amount at the rate of simple interest which
vide letter no.3705 dated 30.07.2018 came to be rejected by
‘the Board’.
15. This followed the filing of the writ petition two
years later in the year 2020.
16. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner submits
that allotment was made, due to some economic reason, the
delayed installment amount was paid, ‘the Board’ never
informed about the payment of the interest amount alongwith
the calculation chart at an earliest and as such, after a long gap,
they cannot be allowed to demand such a huge amount.
17. It is to be noted that ‘the Board’ has filed counter
affidavit. Though, it skipped on why despite the petitioners
having defaulted in making payment of two equal installment
after the delivery of possession was made, the allotment was
not canceled and/or why they were given a long rope as
recorded on 18.06.2001, it recorded that the request was made
to make payment of Rs.11,61,427/- which was ignored by the
petitioners.
18. The said statement has been made in paragraph
no.14 of the counter affidavit filed by ‘the Board’ and reply of
the petitioner to the counter affidavit is in paragraph no.13
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
10/13
wherein they state that the Board’s demand was erroneous and
illegal in nature. However, there is no rebuttal that the notice
of demand made in the year 2001 was not served upon them
and thus it can be construed that they had the knowledge of the
demand of Rs.11,61,.427/- but deliberately chose not to
respond.
19. The most disturbing picture of the entire episode
is that ‘the Board’ which has been constituted to protect the
interest of the State while making allotment, in complete
defiance of the rules and regulations as also the agreement
between the parties, actually treated the State’s property as its
private property as the way they allowed the petitioners to defy
the terms of agreement takes this Court to only the aforesaid
conclusion.
20. The petitioners defaulted for three long years,
however, no step whatsoever was taken to cancel the said
allotment and re-allot it to other needy person in accordance
with law. This also put ‘the Board’ to financial loss for which
those sitting at the relevant time must face music.
21. Certainly, role of ‘the Board’ is questionable and
appropriate enquiry need to be conducted whether it is one off
case of the petitioners herein or ‘the Board’ has resorted to
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
11/13
these practices in several such cases where despite payment not
made by the allottees, no step was taken for canceling the
allotment of the land in accordance with law.
22. So far as the petitioners are concerned, their role
is also condemnable. They took the delivery of plot in the
month of March, 1989 and thereafter slept over the matter
despite signing the agreement assuring payment in six equal
installment which should have come to an end on 15.04.1992.
They actually made the first payment only in the month of
March, 1992, in that background, the petitioners having been
found at fault, cannot be allowed to dictate the terms.
23. At this stage, learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners submit that if a proper calculation chart is handed
over to them, they are ready to make the payment so that the
allotment is regularized. The allotment having been made in
the year 1989, annulment will greatly prejudice their cases.
24. The entire facts have been recorded which paints
‘the Board’ in a very bad frame and a such, as they themselves
have been at fault, they need to amend the things if the
petitioners are ready to pay the amount.
25. This Court thus directs the petitioners to appear
before the Managing Director of ‘the Board’ on 27.07.2026
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
12/13
at 11 AM whereafter the Officer shall be free to fix any
date/time according to his/her own convenience. A proper
calculation chart shall be handed over to the petitioners strictly
in the line with the agreement signed between the parties as
recorded in paragraph nos. 4 and 8 of the agreement.
26. As lots of water has flown down the Ganges and
even four decades later, the parties are fighting the battle, in
that background, this Court further want the entire steps to be
completed within a time frame.
27. The Managing Director of ‘the Board’ shall
ensure that the calculation chart is handed over to the
petitioners latest by 31.08.2026. As the petitioners have made
request to allow them to pay the amount in six months, the
calculation chart must include interest upto the next six months
from the date it is provided..
28. The petitioners shall be making payment within a
period of six months from the date, ‘the Board’ hands them
over the calculation chart. It is further made clear that the
calculation chart must be comprehensive so that it be easily
understandable to any layman and should not be complicated
one.
29. Needless to add, if the petitioners fail to pay the
Patna High Court CWJC No.66 of 2020(6) dt.16-07-2026
13/13
amount within six months from the date they receive the chart,
and/or defaults, ‘the Board’ shall be free to take steps for the
annulment of the plot no. DS-24D, Lohianagar, Patna in
accordance with law. Any laxity this time by ‘the Board’ shall
be construed as contempt of Court.
30. The writ petition is disposed of with the aforesaid
observation.
(Rajiv Roy, J)
vinayak/U
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review