Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:23583
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.M.MANOJ
WEDNESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 28TH PHALGUNA,
WP(C) NO. 24073 OF 2013
PETITIONER:
RADHA VISWANATHAN
W/O. LATE K.R. VISWANATHAN, AGED 67 YEARS,
RESIDING AT RADHA NIVAS, MADIRAPALLY,
KOTAHAMANGALAM - 686 691, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT.
BY ADV SRI.PEEYUS A.KOTTAM
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF
REVENUE (A) DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT
ANNEX, TRIVANDRUM -695 001.
DISTRICT COLLECTOR
ERNAKULAM, COLLECTORATE, CIVIL STATION,
KAKKANAD, COCHIN - 682 030.
REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER
FORT COCHIN, COCHIN - 682 001.
TAHAZILDAR
TALUK OFFICE, COCHIN - 682 001.
VILLAGE OFFICER
VILLAGE OFFICE, PUTHUVYPE, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT
- 682 508.
BY ADV GOVERNMENT PLEADER
SMT.RASHMI.K.M,SENIOR GOVERNMENT PLEADER
WP(C)No.24073/2013
2025:KER:23583
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD ON 19.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED
THE FOLLOWING:
WP(C)No.24073/2013
2025:KER:23583
JUDGMENT
(Dated this the 19th day of March, 2025)
The writ petition is preferred by the daughter in law of
the assignee in Ext.P1, being aggrieved by the rejection of
her application for the assignment of land which was
originally assigned in the name of her Mother-in-Law, Kalyani
Amma. But prior to the completion of assignment, she
expired. Thereafter, her son, the husband of the petitioner
applied for the same, but it was also not completed due to
the failure to follow the procedure as contemplated under the
Rules. In the meanwhile, her husband, the son of the original
assignee was also expired. Now the petitioner has come up
with the contention that, she is entitled for the assignment of
the land which was proposed to be assigned to Kalyani Amma
as per Ext.P1.
2. It is the case of the petitioner that, the petitioner’s
late Mother-in-Law, kalyani Amma was a cultivating tenant in
the property having an extent of 0.40.47 Hectares (34.81
Ares) comprised in Survey No.1689/2 of Puthuvype Village,
Cochin Taluk. Accordingly, the petitioner’s late Mother-in-Law
submitted an application for assignment of the land as per
application No.LA No.57/81. Thereafter, prior to completing
WP(C)No.24073/2013
2025:KER:23583
the formalities as per Rule 9, the assignee expired on
22.07.1986, i.e., ten days prior to issuance of Ext.P1.
3. Under such circumstances, her sole son, K.R
Viswanathan submitted LA CER 8844/94 application for
getting pattayam for this property in his name, being the sole
survivor of the assignee. However, at the time of demise of
the assignee, the petitioner’s husband was in Indian Military
Service. On receipt of the said application, the Village Officer
inspected
08.11.1994.
the
On
property
and
considering
submitted
the
said
report
report,
dated
the
4th
respondent, Tahsildar intimated the petitioner’s husband to
give consent and no objection in paying the existing market
price as per Ext.P2. Since the said direction was not
amenable to the petitioner’s husband, he has preferred
various representations before various Authorities as per
Exts.P3 to P5. During the pendency of those representations,
Sri.Viswanathan also expired on 10.10.2007. Therefore, no
further proceedings were
taken on the representation
preferred by late husband of the petitioner.
4. Under such circumstances, being the legal heir of
the deceased Viswanathan, it is contended by the petitioner
that, the assigned property should devolve upon herself and
her sons- Manoj and Mahesh and daughter Mini. Accordingly,
WP(C)No.24073/2013
2025:KER:23583
the petitioner had preferred a separate application for
effecting the assignment as per Ext.P1 in her name. By
Ext.P6 letter, her application for assignment of the property
pertaining to Ext.P1 has been rejected for the reason that,
she is already having 97 cents of property in her name. More
over, the property in question is required for the
LNG
terminal, development of National Highway, etc.
5. According to the petitioner, the said order is not
sustainable since once the assignment order has been issued
as per Ext.P1, what remains is the
completion of the
formalities as per Rule 9 of the Kerala Land Assignment Rule,
1964. Here what remains is that, as per Rule 9(1) in appendix
1, an order has been issued and the assignee was directed
to pay certain amount. Ten days prior to the same, the
assignee expired.
Thereby, naturally, the officials should
have issued a notice to the legal heirs to remit the amount
for completion of the formalities, which has not been done.
6.
In
response
to
the
contentions,
learned
Government Pleader submitted that, the assignment has not
been completed as contemplated under Rule 1. Going by the
provisions of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules,1964 the
“assignee” is defined under Rule 2(b) which says ‘ a person
to whom land is assigned under these rules and includes his
WP(C)No.24073/2013
2025:KER:23583
heirs or successors
in interest’ and Rule 2(c) defines the
“assignment” which says ‘transfer of land by way of registry
and includes a lease and a grant of licence for the use of the
land’ and Rule 2(d) defines “the family” which ‘includes a
person, his wife or her husband, their children living with or
dependent on them and also the parents who are solely
dependent on such person’. The formalities of assignment
should be completed as per Rule 9(1), Rule 9(2) and Rule
9(7). In the case on hand, though the order under Rule 9(1) is
issued, further proceedings as per Rule 9(2) was not
completed and Rule 2(7) also was not completed. Therefore,
assignment itself is not complete.
7. It is further stated that, the son of the assignee
had submitted a separate application, which was not
intended for rescuing the process that culminated in Ext.P1
after the demise of the original assignee. Even after the
death of the sole legal heir of the assignee, the wife of the
son of the assignee has approached the authorities. However,
on considering her application, the authorities found that she
was in possession of another extent of land, and the property
in question was required for another government purpose.
WP(C)No.24073/2013
2025:KER:23583
8. I have heard Sri. Peeyus A Kottam, the learned
Counsel for the petitioner and Smt.K.M Rashmi, the leaned
Government Pleader for the respondents.
9. The issues involved in this case revolves around
the sole question whether an assignment made immediately
after the death of the
assignee can be claimed by the legal
heirs of the deceased assignee. As per Ext.P1, the order of
assignment was issued under Rule 9(1) of the Kerala Land
Assignment Rules, 1964. As per Rule 9(2), if the process is
completed, the ‘Patta’ should be issued in Appendix II, i.e.,
after the survey and demarcation of the property are carried
out. On the other hand, Rule 9(7) says, if the assignee does
not remit the land value and arrears of tax due and other
charges within three months from the date of sanctioning,
the registry shall
cancel the assignment. The occupancy
evicted, the land resumed and re assigned to other eligible
families. The patta for the land shall be issued only after the
entire amount is paid within three months. Here it is an
admitted fact that, the amount sought as per Ext.P1 has not
been paid since the assignee expired ten days prior to the
order of assignment as per Ext.P1.
10. At this juncture, it is pertinent to note that
neither the petitioner nor the respondent has a case stating
WP(C)No.24073/2013
2025:KER:23583
that, the petitioner or husband attempted to pay the amount
as per Ext.P1. Now, the respondent has issued a notice due
to the failure of the assignee to pay the amount. Going by
the records it appears that a separate application has been
filed, as evident from Ext.P2, by the sole legal heir, who is the
son of the assignee and the late husband of the petitioner. It
was on considering his application preferred by the late
husband of the petitioner. On considering such application,
an intimation has been given to him wherein it is stated that,
being an employed person, he will have to remit the market
value of the property. However,
he was not amenable to
such conditions and he has preferred many representations
as evident from Exts.P2 to P5. During the period of
consideration of those representations, he also expired.
Therefore, the petitioner, claiming to be the legal heir of both
the deceased son of the assignee and the deceased
assignee, approached the authorities by submitting an
application dated 28.10.2010. This application was rejected
as per Ext.P6.
11. Upon evaluating the order, it appears that no
proper reason was provided for its rejection. However, too
many contentions are raised in the counter affidavit with
respect to the reasons for non assigning the land to the
WP(C)No.24073/2013
2025:KER:23583
applicant and those contentions not found place in the
impugned order. This position is settled way back in 1978 by
the Apex Court in Mohinder Singh Gill and Another v.
Chief Election Commissioner, New Delhi and Others
[(1978)1 SCC 405], wherein it was held that when a
statutory
functionary makes an order based on certain
grounds, its validity must be judged by the reasons so
mentioned and cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons in
the shape of affidavit or otherwise.
12. Under such circumstances, I prefer to set aside
Ext.P6 and remand the matter back to the Government for
fresh consideration. If it is found that the petitioner is not
entitled, a detailed order shall be passed, containing reasons
for such non-entitlement. Accordingly, fresh orders shall be
passed, and the proper reasons for such rejection shall be
included in the order.
Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of.
Sd/-
P.M. MANOJ
JUDGE
AKH
WP(C)No.24073/2013
2025:KER:23583
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 24073/2013
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT-P1
TRUE COPY OF THE LAND ASSIGNMENT
ORDER NO. 57/81 DATED 31/07/1986
ISSUED BY THE TAHZILDAR, TALUK
OFFICE, COCHIN TO UPPIDAMKUZHI
KALYANI AMMA.
EXHIBIT-P2
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS NO. C413567/94 DATED 06/12/1994 ISSUED BY
TAHSILDAR TALUK OFFICE, COCHIN TO
LATE K.R. VISWANATHAN, PETITIONER'S
HUSBAND.
EXHIBIT-P3
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED
11/11/1994 SUBMITTED BY LATER K.R.
VISWANATHAN TO THE FORMER CHIEF
MINISTER OF KERALA
EXHIBIT-P4
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED
22/01/2007 SUBMITTED BY LATE K.R.
VISWANATHAN BEFORE THE 2ND
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT-P5
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED
28/10/2010 SUBMITTED BY THE
PETITIONER AND HER CHILDREN BEFORE
THE RESPONDENTS.
EXHIBIT-P6
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.
63725/A3/10/REV. DATED 10/03/2011
ISSUED BY THE IST RESPONDENT TO THE
PETITIONER.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review