Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.323/2015
Date of Order: 05.03.2024
….. Petitioner
No.G/134688 Rfn (GD) R. Ramu
Vs.
1. Union of India, represented by the Secretary to the Government of
India, Ministry of Home Affairs, North Block, New Delhi Pin110001.
2. The Director General Assam Rifles, Mahanideshalaya,
(The Directorate General Assam Rifles) Shillong, Meghalaya-793011.
3. The Commandant, 13th Battalion, the Assam Rifles, C/o 99 APO,
Pin-932013.
….. Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice S.Vaidyanathan, Chief Justice
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
: Mr. R. Jha, Adv
For the Respondents
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. A. Pradhan, Adv
i) Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
ORDER
Yes
The petitioner was appointed as Rifleman (GD) in Assam
Rifles on 03.07.1994, Meghalaya, Shillong and on completion of basic
training, he was posted to 13th Assam Rifles on 17.09.1995. The case of
the petitioner is that while serving at Assam Rifles Administrative Unit,
Shillong, he was sent on deputation to Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel National
Police Academy, Andhra Pradesh for a period of three years w.e.f.
13.12.2005. On completion of three years of service in the Police
Academy, the petitioner made a representation to the Police Academy
expressing his willingness to absorb him on regular basis in the
Academy and the Academy sought for consent from the Assam Rifles to
extend the tenure of deputation and requested for issuance of No
Objection Certificate (NOC) for his transfer to the Police Academy.
2. It is the case of the petitioner that the Assam Rifles has
declined to issue NOC and he questioned the action of the Assam Rifles
in declining to grant NOC to him and also filed Writ Petition in
W.P.No.21144 of 2009 and W.P.M.P. No.58 of 2010 in the High Court
of Andhra Pradesh for a direction to continue him in the Police
Academy, in which, there was an interim order passed by the High Court
of Andhra Pradesh on 18.02.2010, directing the Respondent No.4 to
permit the petitioner to continue in service as Constable in the Police
Academy. Thereafter, by an order dated 08.06.2010 passed in W.P.M.P.
No.58 of 2010, the High Court of Andhra Pradesh vacated the interim
order dated 18.02.2010. Against the order dated 08.06.2010, the
petitioner preferred an appeal in WA No.717 of 2010, in which, a
Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court, by an order dated
29.11.2010, disposed of both W.A.No.717 of 2010 and WP No.21144 of
2009 and passed the following order:
“Accordingly, the Writ Appeal and the Writ Petition are
disposed of. However, we make it clear that in the event of the
appellant-petitioner still insisting any exigency for further
extension, he can file a representation before the authorities
concerned within a period of two (2) weeks from today and the
same shall be considered on merits and disposed of in
accordance with law within a period of six (6) weeks
thereafter. It is needless to mention that till the representation
filed by the appellant-petitioner is considered and disposed of,
he shall not be disturbed. No costs.”
3. Subsequently, the petitioner filed two representations on
08.12.2010 and 23.12.2010, which were considered and rejected by the
Assam Rifles. The petitioner thereafter preferred another writ petition
for rejection of his representation before the High Court of Andhra
Pradesh being WP No.7646 of 2011, wherein the Court passed the
following order:
“The petitioner is the permanent member of the 2nd respondentorganization. It was on his representation, that he was sent on
deputation to the 4th respondent-organization for a period of
three years. That period expired long back. The petitioner
stated several reasons in support of his claim for permanent
absorption in 4th respondent-organization. However, unless the
principal employer gives consent for absorption of such nature,
it would not be possible. The 2nd respondent has stated the
reasons on account of which, the request of the petitioner
cannot be acceded to.
A member of para-military force does not have a right to insist
on no objection, for being absorbed in another organization.
This Court cannot sit as an Appellate Authority, nor the
reasons stated by the 2nd respondent can be said to be irrelevant
or untenable.”
4. Since the writ petition filed by the petitioner being WP
No.7646 of 2011 was dismissed, the petitioner by way of an appeal
approached the Division Bench and the said Writ Appeal was also
dismissed on 19.09.2011. According to the petitioner, the Police
Academy had informed him vide proceedings dated 14.11.2011 that the
Service Book, LPC and other documents, pertaining to the petitioner had
been dispatched to the parent organization, namely, Assam Rifles and
that he is no longer in the rolls of the Police Academy.
5. Challenging the said proceedings, the petitioner filed another
writ petition being WP No.31563 of 2011, wherein it has been stated that
he was not paid salary from 09.10.2009 by the Academy and that the
Academy may be directed to pay the entire wages from that date. It was
stated by the Police Academy before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh
that the Assam Rifles have not given NOC for further continuation of the
petitioner in the Academy and that the petitioner failed in several
attempts in seeking relief before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh and
that the petitioner would not be entitled to any relief. The writ petition
was disposed of by the Andhra Pradesh with the following directions:
“Accordingly, the Writ Petition is disposed of directing the 4th
respondent to issue movement order to the petitioner within a
period of one week from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order. On receipt of such movement order, the petitioner shall
report to the 2nd respondent within a week thereafter. The 2nd
respondent is directed to consider the case of the petitioner for
regularization of his service for the period from 9.10.2009 till
date, in accordance with law, as he was pursuing legal
remedies during that period. No costs.”
6. The High Court of Andhra Pradesh, while disposing of the
writ petition being WP 31563 of 2011, vide order dated 29.08.2018,
directed the Assam Rifles to consider the case of the petitioner for
regularization of his services from 09.10.2009 in accordance with law.
7. The case of the petitioner was that inspite of the orders of
the Andhra Pradesh High Court, he was not put back in service and
granted relief and that he has been asked to appear in the enquiry and
there was no enquiry conducted at all.
8. The case of the respondent Assam Rifles herein was that the
facts narrated by the petitioner supra are not in dispute. The respondents
would submit that the petitioner did not evince any interest in joining the
service and wanted to continue in the Police Academy at Andhra
Pradesh. Even after the order of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh dated
29.08.2018 passed in WP No.31563 of 2011 mentioned supra, the
petitioner was asked to report for duty and that the petitioner did not join
service after seeking leave, which was initially granted. Since the
petitioner did not join the duty, he was declared as deserter and his name
was struck off from the rolls of Assam Rifles. This resulted in the
petitioner filing a writ petition before this Court being WP (C) No.72 of
2013. On 05.05.2015, this Court passed an order that the petitioner was
not given an opportunity before passing the order of desertion dated
22.08.2010 and interfered with the same and directed the Assam Rifles
to conduct a fresh enquiry.
9. According to the respondents, a fresh enquiry was fixed on
10.06.2015 and the petitioner was asked to report to the Presiding
Officer to make statement before the Court of Inquiry on 02.07.2015 and
the Court of Inquiry recorded the statement of the petitioner and also
submitted a written representation. In another writ petition being WP (C)
No.31563 of 2018, the Court directed issuance of movement order which
was stayed in Writ Appeal No.1562 of 2018 on 03.12.2018. Finally, the
Division Bench had allowed the Writ Appeal No.1562 of 2018 and set
aside the order of the learned Single Judge, which means that the
petitioner is not entitled to seek for a movement order.
10. Learned counsel for the respondents fairly stated that the
enquiry has not been completed and the petitioner has not shown any
interest to join duty. There is no objection in conducting the enquiry and
complete the proceedings at the earliest point of time. Since the
petitioner is a Rifleman (GD) who joined services on 03.07.1994 is
expected to be fit for duty and should be consistent. The petitioner
cannot blow hot and cold i.e., namely, after joining the services and went
on deputation to the Police Academy and wanted to continue there. For
various reasons, the petitioner’s services could not be continued at Police
Academy and the Court observed that there was no NOC issued.
Learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the petitioner has not
joined duty inspite of asking him to report for work. Though he has been
initially called as deserter, which was interfered with by this Court, the
petitioner has to cooperate in the enquiry. Learned counsel further
submitted that since the petitioner has not reported for duty, he is not
entitled to any wages on the ground of “No Work No Pay”. Since the
order of this Court dated 05.05.2015 passed in WP (C) No.72 of 2013
has attained finality and binding on the parties, the petitioner has no right
to demand anything except participating in the enquiry.
11. There is a dispute with regard to reporting of work and this
Court is not inclined to make any comment on that or to make any
observation as to whether the petitioner will be entitled to wages from
09.10.2009 as per the order of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh. The
payment of wages and other benefits will depend upon the outcome of
the order that may be passed by the Disciplinary Authority after
completion of the enquiry. It is open to the respondents either to reinstate
the petitioner and conduct the enquiry or place him under suspension and
conduct the enquiry. In case the respondents decide to conduct the
enquiry after suspending him from service, it is open to the respondents
to take a decision in respect of payment of subsistence allowance in
terms of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of State of
Maharashtra vs. Chandrabhan Tale, reported in (1983) 3 SCC 387.
Non-payment of subsistence allowance violates Article 21 of the
Constitution of India. In case a person is placed under suspension
without payment of subsistence allowance or paid full wages with or
without reinstatement, the enquiry would be vitiated. The petitioner is
expected to cooperate with the enquiry and the respondents are directed
to conduct the enquiry on day to day basis without adjourning the matter
beyond seven working days at any point of time and bring the issue to a
logical conclusion within a period of four months from the date of
receipt of the order, preferably on or before 15.08.2024. In the enquiry,
the petitioner is expected not to seek any adjournment on any score.
After the enquiry proceedings are completed, depending upon the order
that may be passed by the Disciplinary Authority, the other relief based
on the order of the Disciplinary Authority or the Appellate Authority
will follow, if it attains finality.
12. With the above observation and direction, the writ petition
stands disposed of.
(S. Vaidyanathan)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
05.03.2024
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review