Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 4142/2017
R.P. SAXENA
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Shanker Raju and Mr
Nilansh Gaur, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Sangita Rai, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE OM PRAKASH SHUKLA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
15.05.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
The issue before us is the entitlement, or otherwise, of the
petitioner to non-functional upgradation1 in terms of Office
Memorandum dated 24 April 2009 issued by the Department of
Personnel and Training2. The claim of the petitioner to NFU stands
rejected by the Central Administrative Tribunal3 vide judgment dated
29 November 2016 rendered in OA 371/20164. The petitioner has
challenged the said decision before us in the present proceedings.
1 “NFU”, hereinafter
2 “DOPT”, hereinafter
3 “the Tribunal”, hereinafter
4 R P Saxena v. UOI & Ors.
W.P.(C) 4142/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ANUBHAV TRIPATHI
13:00:08
2.
We have heard Mr. Shanker Raju, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Ms. Sangita Rai, learned counsel for the respondents, at
length.
3.
The issue is short and purely legal.
4.
The relevant Clauses of DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009 read as
under:
“No. AB.14017/64/2008-Estt.(RR)
Government of India
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions
Department of Personnel and Training
New Delhi, the 24th April, 2009
Office Memorandum
Subject:-
Non-Functional upgradation for Officers of
Organised Group 'A' Services in PB-3 and
PB-4
*****
Consequent upon the acceptance of the recommendations of
the Sixth Central Pay Commission, the following orders are
issued:(i)
Whenever an Indian Administrative Services
Officer of the State of Joint Cadre is posted at the Centre to a
particular grade carrying a specific grade pay in Pay band 3 or
Pay Band 4, the officers belong to batches of Organised Group
A Services that are senior by two years or more and have not
so far been promoted to that particular grade would be granted
the same grade on non-functional basis from the date of
posting of the Indian Administrative. Service Officers in that
particular grade at the Centre.
(ii)
Grant of higher scale would be governed by the
terms and conditions given in Annex-I.”
W.P.(C) 4142/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ANUBHAV TRIPATHI
13:00:08
*****
2.
Grant of higher scale (i.e. pay band and/or grade-pay) under
these instructions would be w.e.f. 1.1.2006, wherever due and
admissible.
*****
Annexure I
TERMS AND CONDITIONS FOR GRANT OF HIGHER PAY
SCALE ON NON-FUNCTIONAL BASIS TO OFFICERS OF
ORGANISED GR.' A' SERVICES
1.
The non functional up-gradation granted under these orders
will be based on empanelment and posting of particular batch of
IAS officer in the Centre. Such up-gradation would not be linked to
the vacancies in the grade.
*****
3.
All the prescribed eligibility criteria and promotional norms
including 'benchmark' for up-gradation to a particular grade pay
would have to be met at the time of screening for grant of higher
pay-scale under these orders.
*****
6.
Orders will be issued with the approval of the competent
authority. Grant of higher pay scale on the non-functional basis
would be from the date of posting of the first officer belonging to
the particular batch of IAS officer at the centre.
*****
8.
As and when the normal vacancies in the grade arise, the
officer will be considered for regular promotions as per the normal
DPC guidelines, based on the provisions of the recruitment rules.
UPSC will be consulted wherever the rules provide for the same.
However at the time of promotion, the pay in the grade will not be
fixed again for officers who have been granted up-gradation under
these orders.
*****
W.P.(C) 4142/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ANUBHAV TRIPATHI
13:00:08
11.
ILLUSTRATION:- If officers of 1987 batch of IAS are
empanelled as Joint Secretary in the grade pay of Rs. 10,000/in PB4 and an officer of the batch gets posted in the Centre ( under
Central Staffing Scheme) on 15th January 2008, all the officers of
the 1985 batch of organized Gr. A Central Services who have not
been promoted to the Joint Secretary or equivalent grade and who
are eligible for the same on 1/1/2007 for the panel year 2007-08,
would be appointed to the same grade on non-functional basis
under these instructions w.e.f. 15/1/2008. Same would be the case
in the event of posting of an officer of particular batch as Deputy
Secretary/ Director under Central Staffing scheme.”
5.
The petitioner was promoted to the Senior Administrative
Grade5 on 27 April 2006. He retired, on attaining the age of
superannuation, on 31 October 2009, still drawing pay in the SAG.
The petitioner belongs to the Central Water Engineering Class-I
Service6, which he joined on 24 September 1975. He was, therefore, a
1975 batch officer of the CWES.
6.
The CWES, admittedly, is an organised Group A service.
7.
The petitioner contended that, an IAS officer of the 1977 batch
and, therefore, two batches junior to the petitioner, was appointed as
Additional Secretary in the Government of India in the pay scale of ₹
67000-₹ 79000 on 26 December 2007. This, according to the
petitioner, entitled him to grant of NFU in the same scale of ₹ 67000-₹
79000 with effect from 26 December 2007 i.e., the date when he was
posted to the Centre.
5 “SAG” hereinafter
6 “CWES”, hereinafter
W.P.(C) 4142/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ANUBHAV TRIPATHI
13:00:08
8.
Attempts at securing the said scale at the departmental level
having failed, the petitioner approached the Tribunal by way of OA
371/2016. The prayer clauses in the said OA read thus:
“8.
RELIEF SOUGHT:
In view of the facts and submissions as made herein above,
it is most respectfully prayed that this Hon'ble Tribunal graciously
be pleased to:(i)
call for the relevant records of the respondents
dealing with issues raised in the instant OA;
(ii)
declare the order/letter No.15/02/2013-Estt.1/495-96
dated 10th March, 2015 (Annexure-A Impugned) and Office
Memorandum
No.AB.14017/64/2008-Estt.(RR)
dated
24.04.2009 (Annexure-A-1 impugned) to the extent the same
requires fulfillment of the eligibility criteria for regular
promotion applicable for the benefit of non-functional
upgradation in terms of Resolution dated 29.8.2008 as illegal,
arbitrary and discriminatory;
(iii)
declare that the applicant is entitled for upgradation
in HAG pay scale of Rs.22,400-525-24,500 (Pre-revised)
(revised to Rs.67,000-79,000) w.e.f. 26.12.2007 in view of the
conscious policy decision of the Government through Ministry
of Finance and respondent No.2 vide Resolution dated
29.8.2008 (Annexure-A-2);
(iv)
direct the respondents to re-fix the pay of the
applicant in HAG pay scale of Rs.22,400-525-24,500 (Prerevised) (revised to Rs.67,000-79,000) w.e.f. 26.12.2007,
consequently re-fix his pension, etc. and pay the arrears of pay,
pension and retiral benefits thereof with interest @ 12% р.а.;
(v)
order exemplary cost against the respondents and in
favour of the Applicant.
(vi) may also pass any further order(s), direction(s) as be
deemed just and proper to meet the ends of justice.”
9.
By judgment dated 29 November 2016, the Tribunal has
W.P.(C) 4142/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ANUBHAV TRIPATHI
13:00:08
rejected the petitioner’s OA thereby causing the petitioner to approach
this Court by means of the present writ petition.
10.
The stand of the respondent, which has been echoed before us
by Ms. Rai and was accepted by the Tribunal, was that, by operation
of Clause 3 of the Terms and Conditions enlisted in Annexure I to the
DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009, a candidate was required to satisfy
the promotional norms for promotion to the grade in which she or he
sought NFU, in order to be entitled to the benefit thereof. Three years
in the SAG were required for promotion to the HAG. Inasmuch as the
petitioner had been promoted to the SAG with effect from 27 April
2006, he satisfied the requirement of three years in the SAG only on
26 April 2009. His eligibility for grant of NFU, therefore, was
considered on 1 January 2010. However, by that time, he had
superannuated and could not, therefore, be granted NFU.
11.
Defending the impugned order of the Tribunal, Ms. Rai presses
into service Clause (ii) of the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009 read
with Clause 3 of the Terms and Conditions enlisted in Annexure I to
the OM.
12.
She submits that, the petitioner having satisfied the requirement
of three years service in the HAG only on 26 April 2009, his
eligibility for grant of NFU did not arise prior to that date. His case,
was, therefore, required to be considered as on 1 January 2010. Prior
thereto, however, as the petitioner had retired from service, he could
not be granted NFU.
W.P.(C) 4142/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ANUBHAV TRIPATHI
13:00:08
13.
Mr. Shankar Raju, arguing for the petitioner, submits, on the
other hand, that the petitioner’s entitlement to grant of NFU in fact
crystallized on 26 December 2007 when, an IAS officer two batches
junior to the petitioner was posted to the Centre. The requirement of
satisfying the promotional norms for promotion to the HAG as
envisaged in Clause 3 of the Terms and Conditions enlisted in
Annexure I to the OM, could at best defer the date of his entitlement
to 26 April 2009. At least as and from that date, the petitioner was
entitled to grant of NFU. Mr. Raju submits that, therefore, the decision
to deny NFU to the petitioner could not sustain in law or on facts.
14.
Having heard learned Counsel for the parties, we are inclined,
for the following reasons, to hold that the petitioner was entitled to the
benefit of NFU.
15.
Para (i) of the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009 specifically
states that the officer would be entitled to the NFU “from the date of
posting of the Indian Administrative Service Officers in that particular
grade at the centre”. The entitlement of the petitioner to grant of NFU,
therefore, enured on 26 December 2007.
16.
However, as Ms. Rai correctly points out, para (ii) of the first
para in the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009 makes the entitlement to
higher scale subject to the terms and conditions in Annexure I to the
OM. Clause 3 of Annexure I to the OM states that all prescribed
W.P.(C) 4142/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ANUBHAV TRIPATHI
13:00:08
eligibility criteria and promotional norms for upgradation to a
particular pay scale would have to be met at the time of screening for
grant of NFU. This made the requirement of three years in the SAG a
mandatory pre-condition for the petitioner to be entitled to NFU under
the OM dated 24 April 2009.
17.
Admittedly, the petitioner satisfied this requirement on 26 April
2009 when he completed three years in the SAG. Even if one were to
defer the entitlement of the petitioner to grant of NFU, which was
otherwise available under clause (i) of the DOPT OM dated 24 April
2009 on 26 December 2007, the entitlement would nonetheless
fructify on 26 April 2009.
18.
Admittedly, on 26 April 2009, the petitioner was very much in
service.
19.
We are unable, therefore, to justify the respondent’s decision
not to extend him NFU on the ground that, on 1 January 2010, the
petitioner had superannuated.
20.
It is true that the Illustration following the OM does refer to
consideration from the 1st of January of the next year following the
date of entitlement. However, in the absence of any such condition
being present either in the OM or in the Terms and Conditions
annexed to the OM, we cannot treat the petitioner ineligible for NFU
because he had retired by 1 January 2010.
W.P.(C) 4142/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ANUBHAV TRIPATHI
13:00:08
21.
Our conclusion is fortified by the DOPT OM dated 25
September 2009 with respect to point number 5 in para 1 of the OM,
clearly states that even retired officers would be eligible for grant of
NFU as per the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009 provided they were
otherwise eligible as on due date. The relevant part of DOPT OM
dated 25 September 2009 reads as under:
“No. AB. 14017/64/2008-Estt. (RR)
Government of India
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions
Department of Personnel and Training
New Delhi, the 25th September, 2009
Office Memorandum
Subject:-
Non-Functional upgradation for Officers of
Organised Group 'A' Services in PB-3 and
PB-4- Clarifications
*****
This Department vide OM dated 24.4.09 issued instructions
regarding non-functional upgradation for officers of Organised
Group 'A' Services in PB-3 and PB-4. Subsequently vide OM
dated 21.5.09, details regarding the batch of officers belonging
to the IAS and who have been posted at the Centre in various
grades of PB-3 and PB-4 w.e.f. 1.1.2006 as well as the date of
posting of the first officer belonging to the batch were
indicated. In this connection, clarifications have been sought
from this Department by some Ministries/Departments and by
individual representations. The same have been considered by
this Department in consultation with Department of
Expenditure and following clarifications are issued.
*****
Point of doubt
Clarification
*****
W.P.(C) 4142/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ANUBHAV TRIPATHI
13:00:08
5.
Whether
retired
employees are to be
granted the benefit of
non-functional
upgradation
Para 6 of our instructions
provide
that
benefits
would be from due date.
Therefore, even retired
officers who are otherwise
eligible as on due date
would
need
to
be
considered.
*****
(J.A. Vaidyanathan)
Deputy Secretary to the Government of India
Tel. 23092112”
At the highest, therefore, we can treat 26 April 2009 as the due date
when the petitioner was eligible for being granted the benefit of NFU.
Clause 5 of para 1 of the DOPT OM dated 25 September 2009 would
also, therefore, support our conclusion.
22.
For the aforesaid reasons, therefore, we cannot sustain the
decision of the Tribunal to reject the petitioner’s OA.
23.
OA 371/2016 stands allowed in terms of the prayers contained
therein.
24.
The writ petition also stands allowed accordingly with no order
as to costs.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J.
MAY 15, 2026
AR/YG
W.P.(C) 4142/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ANUBHAV TRIPATHI
13:00:08
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review