Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND
LADAKH AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on: 10.09.2026
Pronounced on: 18.09.2026
Uploaded on: 19 .09.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced:
Full
OWP No.779/2006
QAWAM-UD-DIN SHAH & ORS.
...PETITIONER(S)/APPELLANT(S)
Through: -
Mr. Molvi Ajaz Ahmad, Advocate.
Vs.
STATE OF J&K & ORS.
…RESPONDENT(S)
Through: -
Ms. Rahella Khan, Assisting Counsel, vice
Mr. Mohsin Qadiri, Sr. AAG.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1)
Before adverting to the main writ petition, it is deemed
proper to observe that during pendency of this petition, the
petitioner No.7, Zahoor-ud-Din Shah, came to demise and his
LRs, namely, Nissar Ahmad, Gazi Ahmad, Zulufkar Ahmad
and Parvaiz Ahmad, were brought on record. However, as they
didn’t choose to appear, the writ petition was dismissed qua
legal heirs of petitioner No.7. Consequently, this petition
survives only regarding petitioner Nos.1 to 6, as is evident
from order dated 11.09.2026 and henceforth the petitioners
shall refer to petitioner Nos.1 to 6 only.
OWP No.779/2006
2)
The petitioners have filed this petition for grant of
following reliefs:
3)
I)
By issuance of a writ of certiorari or any other appropriate
writ, order or direction, the impugned notification dated
12-01-1989, order dated 25-09-1989 issued by
respondent no.3 and the notice dated 05-09-2006 issued
by respondent no.6 be quashed.
II)
By issuance of a writ of mandamus or any other
appropriate writ, order or direction, respondents be
directed not cause any interference with the possession
of the petitioners over land measuring 4 kanals 7 marlas
bearing survey No.13 and Khasra No.133 situate at village
Yar tehsil Pulwama and land measuring 4 Kanals 03
marlas comprising of survey Nos.82/1, 388/1, 391/1 &
Khasra No.191 (0.13 marlas) and survey Nos.388, 391,
156 and 266 & Khasra No.192 (3 Kanals 10 marlas) situate
at village Drubagam, tehsil Pulwama, or dispossess them
there from in any manner whatsoever.
It is stated that on the death of Habibullah Shah alias
Haba Shah, his property came to be mutated in the name of
his son Jalal-ud-Din Shah vide mutation No.237 dated 13th
Magh, 1997. As Jalal-ud-Din Shah was minor, therefore, he
was represented by his uncle Mubarak Shah.
4)
It is stated that Jalaluddin Shah lived at Drubgam,
Tehsil Pulwama, for
quite some
time and
thereafter
disappeared in the year 1942. His relatives, including some of
the petitioners, did their best to find out his whereabouts, but
could not succeed. Accordingly, it was presumed by them that
he might have met with some kind of mishap and died. After
the disappearance of Jalaluddin Shah, who, as per the
petitioners, was issueless, all his holdings came into the
OWP No.779/2006
hands of his uncles i.e. the predecessors-in-interest of the
petitioners, and they continued to enjoy the property without
any interference from any quarter from the year 1942
onwards. It was only in the month of May, 2006 that the
petitioners received a summon from respondent No.6 for
causing their appearance before him on 09.05.2005. They
accordingly appeared before him, where they came to know
that somewhere in the year 1989, respondent No.7 had filed
an application before respondent No.3 for allotment of land
measuring 04 kanals and 07 marlas comprising Survey
Nos.13 and 133, situated at Village Yar, Tehsil Pulwama, and
land measuring 04 kanals and 03 marlas comprising Survey
Nos.82/1, 388/1 and 391/1 and 191 (0.13 marlas) and
Survey Nos.388, 391, 156, 266 and 192 (03 kanals 10 marlas)
situated at Village Drubgam, Tehsil Pulwama. It is stated that
the said land was declared as evacuee property by the
Custodian Department
in
terms
of
notification
dated
12.01.1989 at the back of the petitioners and without any
notice to them. The petitioners also came to know that
respondent No.3, at their back, had passed an order dated
25.09.1989, whereby the aforesaid land was allotted in favour
of respondent No. 7 under Section 9 of the J&K State
Evacuees (Administration of Property) Act, 2006 (for short
“the Act of 2006”) as the respondent No.7 had allegedly
OWP No.779/2006
obtained a power of attorney from Jalaluddin Shah in the year
1988 for managing his property. The respondent No.3 also
directed Tehsildar to resume possession of the said property
from the unauthorized occupants i.e. the petitioners and to
deliver the same to respondent No.7.
The petitioners, being aggrieved of the notification dated
5)
12.01.1989 and the order dated 25.09.1989, have impugned
the same on the following grounds.
(I)
That the petitioners and their predecessors-ininterest and other relatives of Jalaluddin Shah tried
their best to find out his whereabouts, but could not
succeed and, as such, believing that Jalaluddin Shah
was dead, they continued to enjoy possession of the
property as if the same had been inherited by them.
Respondent No. 7, in fact, on the basis of a
manipulated power of attorney, got a notification
issued by the Custodian Department on 12.01.1989
and thereafter, at the back of the petitioners, filed an
application before respondent No. 3 for allotment of
the evacuee land. Thereafter, respondent No. 3,
without issuing any summons to the petitioners or
their predecessors-in-interest, passed the order dated
25.09.1989. The respondent No. 3 before passing the
OWP No.779/2006
order dated 25.09.1989 did not even bother to
examine as to whether the particulars of the
respondents mentioned in the application were
correct and sufficient and whether the persons who
were in possession of the so-called evacuee land had
been made parties to the proceedings or not.
Precisely, the contention of the petitioners is that the
order dated 25.09.1989 was passed at their back and
that the notification dated 12.01.1989 is an outcome
of fraud and manipulation.
(II)
That once Jalaluddin Shah had gone to Lahore in the
year 1942 and had been living there, he cannot be
declared as an “evacuee’ within the provisions of the
Act of 2006 and, consequently, his property could not
have been declared as “evacuee property”. Therefore,
the Custodian Department had no jurisdiction to
issue the notification dated 12.01.1989.
(III) That the petitioners are in possession of the property
declared as evacuee property by respondent No. 3 in
terms of the notification dated 12.01.1989, before the
year 1942 and thereafter, as such, before issuing the
notification dated 12.01.1989, respondent No.3 was
OWP No.779/2006
required to afford an opportunity of hearing to the
petitioners.
6)
Respondent Nos.2, 3 and 4 have filed their response,
stating therein that the petitioners have not explained as to
why they did not challenge the notification dated 12.01.1989
and order dated 25.09.1989 for nearly two decades, as such,
the present petition deserves to be dismissed. It is stated that
the petitioners have projected wrong facts and made bald
assertions in the writ petition. It is contended that the
property in question was kept hidden by the petitioners, who
had illegally occupied the property of their uncle/co-sharer
and did not declare the same to the authorities. They are, in
fact, blowing hot and cold by stating that respondent No.7
was missing since 1942, while they themselves did not make
any such declaration to the authorities. Besides, Jalaluddin
Shah continued to be recorded as the owner throughout,
which belies the contention of the petitioners. It is further
averred that the evacuee/recorded owner, Syed Jalaluddin
Shah, presented himself before the Custodian during the year
1988 when he visited Kashmir and the property was
discovered as an evacuee property during judicial proceedings
held by the Custodian, and was accordingly declared as
“evacuee property” and it was done after providing an
OWP No.779/2006
opportunity to all concerned to project their cases. It is stated
that the passport and the Visa of the evacuee were checked
in open Court and it was established that he was the real
owner of the property, who was under disability to possess
the property personally and was entitled to protection under
the Act of 2006. His statement was recorded and he wanted
that his property to be protected from illegal encroachment.
Thereafter, during the course of inquiry, it was established
that the property had been illegally grabbed by the petitioners
and the orders for their eviction were issued.
7)
Respondent No.7 has also filed a counter-affidavit,
stating therein that the writ petition has been filed in the year
2006 by a group of persons usurping the evacuee property
unauthorisedly. The land was declared as ‘evacuee property’
by the competent authority and the petitioners are required
to surrender possession thereof in favour of the answering
respondent. In fact, they negotiated the matter and arrived at
a settlement before the Deputy Custodian. Now they are
challenging the Notification dated 12.01.1989 and the order
issued in pursuance thereof dated 25.09.1989, without
tendering any explanation with regard to the delay and
laches.
8)
It is contended that the petitioners, in fact, have no locus
and no cause to prefer the present writ petition. The property
OWP No.779/2006
having been notified as evacuee property cannot be denotified under the provisions of the Act of 2006. In fact, the
petitioners have a remedy provided under the relevant statute
to redress their grievances, if any, and writ jurisdiction
cannot be invoked. It is further stated it was the legal duty of
the petitioners to inform the authorities about the evacuee
property, but they concealed the said fact from the authorities
under the Act.
9)
The respondent No. 7, besides narrating the factual
aspects as pleaded by respondent Nos. 2, 3 and 4 in their
response, has also stated that during the pendency of the writ
petition, the petitioners filed MP No.1 of 2016, informing the
Court about the death of the owner of the property in
question, namely, Syed Jalaluddin Shah, and produced the
death certificate issued in the year 2010. It is also the stand
of respondent No.7 that the petitioners have admitted that the
land which is the subject matter of the dispute is recorded in
the name of Jalaluddin Shah in terms of Mutation No. 237. It
is also averred that the Custodian, Evacuee Property,
appointed respondent No. 7 as an allottee of the land and a
perusal of the order would show that the non-applicants were
summoned, but they chose not to appear before the authority.
Subsequently, they were also summoned through a notice
OWP No.779/2006
published in the daily newspaper “Aftab” on 10.06.1989, but
they still failed to appear, whereafter exparte proceedings
were undertaken. Thereafter, witnesses were examined and
documents were taken on record, including the visa and
passport of the original owner/evacuee. On the basis of the
inquiry conducted and completed by the Custodian, the order
of allotment was made in his favour and the Deputy
Custodian was directed to initiate proceedings against the
unauthorized
occupants.
The
Assistant
Custodian,
thereafter, issued various summons to the petitioners to
appear before him and one of the occupants, namely, Latif
Ahmed and Syed Maqbool Ahmed, presented themselves
before the authority and sought time for entering into a family
settlement/compromise. They were granted time to come up
with their stand on 28.08.2006 and further time was also
granted to all the parties to come up with the compromise on
16.09.2018, failing which the possession of the property was
to be taken over in the presence of the respectable persons of
the village, including the Numberdar and Chowkidar.
However, the petitioners having failed to show as to what is
the basis of their claim and relation to the land grabbed by
them, they are not entitled to any relief.
10)
Learned counsel for the petitioners, Mr. M. Aijaz, has
argued that Jalaluddin Shah was not an evacuee, as such,
OWP No.779/2006
respondent Nos.2 to 4 could not have passed the order dated
12.01.1989 declaring the property as an evacuee property. He
further submits that once the property was not evacuee
property, the same could not have been allotted in favour of
respondent No. 7. He has further argued that the notification
dated 12.01.1989 and also the order dated 25.09.1989 were
issued at the back of the petitioners, without affording them
due opportunity of hearing and, as such, the same cannot
sustain in the eyes of law.
11)
Per contra, Ms. Rahella Khan, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents, submits that as per the own admission
of the petitioners, the property was mutated in the name of
Jalaluddin Shah, who happened to be a minor at the time of
attestation of the mutation and was represented by his uncle,
namely, Mubarak Shah, as his guardian, as such, neither
Mubarak Shah nor anyone else can raise the plea of title or
legal possession of the property in question. Therefore, the
present writ petition deserves to be dismissed. She has
further submitted that despite opportunities having been
afforded, the non-applicants, as mentioned in the order dated
25.09.1989, did not appear before the Custodian, Evacuee
Property, and, accordingly, the order impugned came to be
passed.
OWP No.779/2006
12)
Heard learned and perused the record.
13)
In paragraph 3 of the writ petition, it is admitted by the
petitioners that on the death of Habibullah Shah, his property
was mutated in the name of Jalaluddin Shah vide Mutation
No.237 dated 13th Magh, 1997 by the competent authority
and at the time of attestation of the mutation, Jalaluddin
Shah, being a minor, was represented by his uncle, namely,
Mubarak Shah. The petitioners before this Court claim to be
the relatives of Jalaluddin Shah but the fact remains that they
have no right or title in the property mutated in the name of
Jalaluddin Shah. Even Mubarak Shah or his successors
cannot claim any right in the property owned by Jalaluddin
Shah, as Mubarak Shah had represented the minor and had
been reflected as his guardian in the mutation. A guardian is
legally prohibited from raising any plea that conflicts with the
welfare and interests of the minor.
14)
The
petitioners
have
impugned
the
order
dated
25.09.1989, primarily, on the ground that as Jalaluddin Shah
had disappeared in the year 1942, therefore, his property
could not have been declared as an evacuee property. Section
2(c)(ii) of the Act of 2006 provides complete answer to the
contention raised by the petitioners and the property of
Jalaluddin Shah falls within the definition of “evacuee
property”.
OWP No.779/2006
15)
Otherwise also, the petitioners cannot have any locus to
dispute the declaration of the property as evacuee property.
The locus, if any, vested with Jalaluddin Shah but it was at
the instance of Jalaluddin Shah himself only, who appeared
before the Custodian, Evacuee Property, Srinagar, on
13.12.1988, and the Custodian, Evacuee Property, came to
know about the undisclosed evacuee property of Syed
Jalaluddin Shah. Accordingly, in terms of order dated
13.12.1988,
the
Assistant
Custodian,
Pulwama,
was
requested to furnish the necessary record regarding the
landed property of Jalaluddin Shah situated at villages
Drubgam and Yar, Tehsil Pulwama. Earlier, on 12.02.1988,
Respondent No.7 applied to the Deputy Custodian, asserting
that Jalaluddin Shah had migrated as an evacuee, leaving
behind property in Pulwama. Expressing interest as a close
relative, respondent No.7 urged the Custodian Department to
secure the subject property.
16)
The
record
further
reveals
that
a
report
dated
28.04.1988 was submitted, and it was found that the
property in question was recorded in the name of Jalaluddin
Shah, migrant and, accordingly, the Custodian was requested
to declare the said property as evacuee property.
17)
As already noticed above, in terms of order dated
13.12.1988,
OWP No.779/2006
the
Assistant
Custodian,
Pulwama,
was
requested by the Custodian Department to furnish the
necessary revenue records pertaining to the property of
Jalaluddin Shah. After the necessary records were furnished,
the statements of Jalaluddin Shah and other witnesses,
including father-in-law of respondent No.7, were recorded.
After conducting the inquiry, in terms of sub-section (1) of
Section 6 of the Act of 2006, the land in question was declared
as “evacuee property”. Thereafter, in terms of order dated
04.02.1989, the Deputy Custodian, Evacuee Property,
Kashmir, directed the Assistant Custodian, Pulwama, to
implement the notification in respect of declaration of the
property in question as evacuee property in the revenue
records. It was further directed that, after doing the needful,
the unauthorized occupants be served with notice demanding
surrender of possession of the evacuee property in favour of
the Department. The unauthorized occupants were also to be
informed that one Mohammad Hussain Shah son-in-law of
Peer Mubarak Shah, has made an application for allotment of
the said evacuee property before the Custodian, fixed for
hearing on 16.02.1989, and that if they intended to file any
objection in the matter, they can personally or through their
legal representative present the same before the Custodian,
Evacuee Property, Kashmir.
OWP No.779/2006
18)
Thus, it is evident that the property was declared to be
evacuee property in accordance with the provisions of law
and, therefore, the petitioners cannot raise any objection with
regard to issuance of the notification dated 12.01.1989. The
petitioners, in fact, have no locus at all to assail the
notification dated 12.01.1989. The locus, if any, vested only
with Jalaluddin Shah to object to the declaration of the
property as evacuee property. However, it was at his instance
that the property in question came to be declared as evacuee
property.
19)
It was next contended that before passing the impugned
order dated 25.09.1989, no opportunity was afforded to the
petitioners. The record, however, depicts that repeated
summons was issued to the predecessors-in-interest of the
petitioners and petitioner No.7. Even do-parta summons was
also issued and Notice was also published in daily newspaper
“Aftab” on 10.06.1989 and when even after publication of the
notice, none appeared before the authority, the impugned
order dated 25.09.1989 came to be passed.
20)
The petitioners have no independent right to remain in
occupation of the evacuee property and, once they have no
locus to assail the notification dated 12.01.1989 regarding
declaration of the property as evacuee property, they cannot
OWP No.779/2006
be permitted to remain in possession of the evacuee property
in absence of any authorization from the Custodian
Department.
21)
In view of the above, this Court is of the considered view
that the present petition lacks merit and is, accordingly,
dismissed. However, this Court is sanguine that respondent
Nos.2, 3 and 4 shall proceed strictly in accordance with the
provisions of the Jammu and Kashmir State Evacuees
(Administration of Property) Act while dealing with the
“evacuee property” in question.
22)
The record be returned to learned counsel for the
respondents.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Srinagar,
18.09.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the judgment is reportable: NO
OWP No.779/2006
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review