Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:SHC:25
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Petitioners
:
Puspa Mishra and Others
versus
Respondents
:
State of Sikkim and Others
Application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Mr. Ranjit Prasad, Ms. Neha
Kumari Gupta and Ms. Laxmi Khawas, Advocates for the Petitioners.
Mr. Aarohi Bhalla, Additional Advocate General with Mr. Thinlay
Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate for the Respondents No.1 to
10.
Mr. Hissay Gyaltsen and Mr. Lahang Limboo, Advocates for the
Respondent No.11.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing
Judgment reserved
Judgment pronounced
Judgment uploaded
:
:
:
:
06-03-2026
06-03-2026
06-04-2026
07-04-2026
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioners numbering a total of 101, are by birth
Sikkimese women, married to non-Sikkimese men, who are
citizens of India.
They are aggrieved in the first instance, by
Notification No.08/LR&DMD/R/2018, dated 07-06-2018, of the
Land Revenue and Disaster Management Department, Government
of Sikkim, which provides that any document regarding transfer of
property, presented for registration by a Sikkimese woman,
married to a non-Sikkimese, may ordinarily be registered.
The
sentence is however qualified by the words that follow viz., that,
“………… ownership of her property, on her demise, shall be
governed as per the existing rules and regulations prevailing in the
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
State”. As per the Petitioners, “the existing rules and regulations”
referred to in the impugned Notification is the “Married Women‟s
Property Regulation, 1962” (Regulation of 1962), which provides
that a Sikkimese woman married to a non “Sikkim Subject”, shall
have no right to acquire any immoveable property or any interest
in such property, in the territory of Sikkim, subsequent to her
marriage.
The Regulation of 1962, it is averred, was never
enforced in the State and despite being only an executive order,
seeks to debar the children of Sikkimese women married to nonSikkimese, from holding property in the State of Sikkim, which is
thereby, discriminatory, mala fide and arbitrary.
They are also
aggrieved by the non-issuance of Certificate of Identification (COI)
to their progeny, on account of the Petitioners‟ marriage to nonSikkimese, thereby depriving their children of all facilities and
rights available to COI holders, including their right to obtain
Government employment in the State.
2.
The Petitioners seek the following reliefs;
“……………………………………………………………………………………
i.
…………………………………………………………………………...
ii.
A writ or order or direction or declaration that
on the death of a Sikkimese woman, married to
a non-Sikkimese, her property shall devolve
upon and owned by her children (sic.) duly
quashing the part of the notification dated
7/6/18 namely “The ownership of the property
on her demise shall be governed as per the
existing rules and regulations prevailing in the
State.”
iii.
iv.
A writ or order or direction or declaration that
the children of Sikkimese women marrying to
non-Sikkimese (sic.) shall not be debarred from
getting employment under the Government of
Sikkim;
A writ or order or direction or declaration that,
the offsprings of the Sikkimese women
marrying to non-Sikkimese (sic.) shall be
issued with Certificate of Identification and
other similar documents with right of
inheritance of immovable properties and all
other benefits receivable from the Government
like all other Sikkimese persons.
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
………………………………………………………………………...
…………………………………………………………………………
A writ of mandamus and/or any other
appropriate writ/order/direction or declaration
that husband‟s SSC/COI so far claimed by the
Respondents from Sikkimese women shall no
longer be claimed from them for procurement
of employment and for other purposes under
the Government of Sikkim or in any region
whatsoever.
viii.
A writ of mandamus and/or any other
appropriate writ/order/direction directing the
state respondents in particular the Land
Revenue & Disaster Management Department
as well as District Collectors/ Registrar/ SubRegistrar of four districts to register any deed
of sale, gift, lease or will and/or any instrument
of transfer of immovable properties from the
names of Sikkimese women married to nonSikkimese men to the names of their children.
ix.
.………………………………………………………………………...
x.
…………………………………………………………………………...
xi.
…………………………………………………………………………...
…………………………………………………………………………………….”
v.
vi.
vii.
The other prayers of the Petitioners have not been extracted
supra as they are in pith and substance a repetition of the prayers
above.
3.
The contesting parties filed their respective returns and
rejoinder thereto was filed by the Petitioners.
4.
The submissions of Learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioners are summarized as follows;
(i)
All “Sikkim Subjects” as defined in the Sikkim Subject
Regulation of 1961, became Indian citizens on the 26th day of April,
1975 (the appointed day), consequent thereto, the Petitioners
cannot be discriminated on grounds of gender, as males of
Sikkimese
origin,
marrying
non-Sikkimese
women,
including
foreigners are beneficiaries of all facilities in the State, such as
inheritance rights, education, employment and COI. However, the
Petitioners, being women married to non-Sikkimese are deprived of
all such facilities, including their right to marry persons of their
choice and their children‟s right to inherit property.
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
The Home Department, Government of Sikkim, on 15-
(ii)
05-2015, issued a Notification pertaining to issuance of Residential
Certificate (RC), to persons falling in categories as enumerated
therein, which includes “non-Sikkimese Indian citizens”. They are
permitted to acquire land in Municipal areas of Sikkim and
admittedly encompasses children of the Petitioners.
Under the
Notification they can also avail of other facilities available to
Sikkimese. It is therefore unfathomable as to why the State would
stop short of granting COI to progeny of a mother of Sikkimese
origin, merely on account of her marriage to a non-Sikkimese.
Such a stand is arbitrary and violative of Articles 14, 15, 16, 19
and 21 of the Constitution of India, more especially since the
Sikkim Subject Regulation of 1961 was repealed on 26-04-1975.
In further discrimination of women, the State also
(iii)
requires an unmarried woman of Sikkim to furnish a certificate
regarding her „marital status‟, renewable every six months, in
gross violation of the human rights of all Sikkimese women.
Strength in this context was garnered from the Convention on
Elimination of all forms of discrimination against Women (CEDAW).
Referring to the decision of this Court in Padma Kumari
(iv)
Ganesan vs. The State of Sikkim and Others , Learned Senior Counsel
argued that, it is held therein, that, immovable properties of a
Sikkimese woman married to non-Sikkimese is transferable and
they can also inherit the property of their parents and therefore
ought to be complied with.
That, in Nil Kumar Dahal and Another vs. Indira Dahal and
(v)
Others , this High Court has opined that, in the absence of a law of
WP No.10 of 1991, decided on 16-09-1991, by a Division Bench of this High Court.
SLR (2020) SIKKIM 815
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
inheritance in Sikkim, the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, as amended
in 2005 is applicable.
That, Notification bearing No.1520/H, dated 03-01-
(vi)
1963, “Rules to provide for registration and solemnization of a form
of marriage in Sikkim”, does not restrict Sikkimese women from
marrying non-Sikkimese Indian citizens, hence, children born from
such marriages should be extended all benefits of the COI.
It is also contended that Revenue Order No.1 of 1917,
(vii)
issued by an executive authority, does not prohibit transfer of
agricultural land from Bhutias and Lepchas to a “plainsman”. The
circumstance applicable to a “plainsman” thus ought to apply to the
Petitioners as well.
Merely because Sikkimese society is patriarchal, the
(viii)
Petitioners cannot be denied their legitimate rights, as they
continue to be COI holders.
Hence, in view of the grounds advanced, the reliefs sought
be granted.
5.
Learned
Additional
Advocate
General
for
the
Respondents No.1 to 10, resisting the grounds raised by the
Petitioners contended that;
(i)
The Writ Petition is devoid of necessary details,
regarding the religion of the Petitioners, their caste/tribe.
Such
details are imperative in light of the provisions of Section 2(2) of
the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, which excludes Scheduled Tribes
from its application. The name of the father of the children, the age
of the children have also not been mentioned in the Petition. The
children may well be adults now and if aggrieved on account of the
restrictions imposed on them from registering their mother‟s
property in their names, they ought to be the Petitioners.
The
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Petition is thus not maintainable as the Petitioners lack locus
standi. Reliance on this facet was placed on Jasbhai Motibhai Desai
vs. Roshan Kumar, Haji Bashir Ahmed and Others .
It was next urged that should the reliefs prayed for, be
(ii)
granted, it would tantamount to legislating, which is dehors the
mandate of the Constitution of India.
In this context, reference
was made to Union of India and Others vs. K. Pushpavanam and
Others .
(iii)
That, Prayer (iv) in the Writ Petition, according to the
Learned Additional Advocate General is the main prayer but the
Petition is neither a Public Interest Litigation nor filed in a
representative capacity, it is but an emotional prayer of mothers,
in an effort to set aside the mandate of Article 371F of the
Constitution.
(iv)
The Learned Additional Advocate General elucidated,
that male lineage, in terms of the Sikkim Subject Regulation
promulgated vide Notification dated 03-07-1961 (Regulation of
1961), decides which person falls within the category of Sikkim
Subjects. Regulation 6 of the Regulation of 1961, then, provided
for the status of women married to Sikkim Subjects, allowing even
women of foreign origin married to Sikkim Subjects to register as a
Sikkim Subject, provided she renounced her former nationality.
Regulation 7(b) however provides that a Sikkimese woman,
married to a non-Sikkim Subject, shall not be entitled to Sikkim
Subject, thereby drawing a distinction between Sikkim Subjects
and others.
(v)
The Regulation of 1961 makes it evident that status of
“Sikkim Subjects” flows from the male lineage as the nature of
(1976) 1 SCC 671
(2023) 20 SCC 736
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
society in Sikkim is patriarchal, and the COI introduced in the year
1995 is in a similar vein.
(vi)
The Government of India did not issue a fresh
citizenship order dehors the Regulation of 1961 and the Sikkim
(Citizenship) Order, 1975, dated 21-06-1975, in fact has saved the
Regulation of 1961 in its entirety.
(vii)
That, in R. C. Poudyal vs. Union of India and Others5 the
Supreme Court has held that the provisions contained in Article
371F are not such as to negate the fundamental principles of
democracy
and
do
not
violate
the
basic
features
of
the
Constitution.
(viii)
On Sikkim becoming a State of the Union by the 36 th
Amendment Act, 1975, on 26-04-1975, a special provision for the
State, being Article 371F, was inserted, which commences with a
non-obstante
clause, overriding the
other
provisions of the
Constitution.
This was for the safety and demographics of the
State, duly incorporating terms and conditions deemed necessary
to meet the special circumstances of Sikkim.
(ix)
Under Section 7 of the Citizenship Act of 1955, which
was enforced in Sikkim on 16-05-1975, the Government of India
issued a Sikkim (Citizenship) Order, 1975, which provided that,
every citizen who was immediately before 26-04-1975 a Sikkim
Subject, under the Sikkim Subject Regulation, 1961, shall be
deemed to have become a citizen of India on that day.
The
“Adaptation of Sikkim Laws (No.1) Order 1975” repealed the
Regulation of 1961 but under Clause 2(b), explained the term “law
in force” in the context of Sikkim.
Thus, despite the application of
the Act of 1956 to the State of Sikkim, a distinction continues to
1994 Supp (1) SCC 324
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
exist between Sikkim Subjects and non-Sikkim Subjects, the test
being the Regulation of 1961, to arrive at such a conclusion. This
is crucial, as Rule 4(4) of the Establishment Rules, 1974, gives a
preference to “Sikkim Subjects” to apply for employment in the
State.
That, on this aspect the Supreme Court in State of
(x)
Sikkim vs. Surendra Prasad Sharma and Others
observed that the
reason why Article 371F begins with a non-obstante clause
obviously is that, the matters referred to in the various clauses
immediately following, required a protective cover, so that, such
matters were not struck down as unconstitutional.
Unless such
immunity was granted the “laws in force” would have to meet the
test of Article 13 of the Constitution.
Reference was also made to the Revenue Order No.1,
(xi)
dated 17-05-1917, issued under the instructions of the then
Chogyal of Sikkim, imposing restrictions on sale, mortgage or
subletting of land, belonging to the Bhutia-Lepcha community, to
persons other than Bhutias or Lepchas.
This law being one
protected by Article 371F(k) of the Constitution, non-Sikkimese are
debarred from holding and registering land in Sikkim.
Office Order bearing No.105/LR, dated 25-02-1961
(xii)
another “law in force”, provides that non-Sikkimese are not entitled
to acquire any immovable properties in Sikkim and Notification
No.28/LR, dated 21-04-1969, clarifies that woman follows the
nationality and community of her husband.
The impugned Notification bearing No.8/LR&DMD/R/
(xiii)
2018,
dated
(1994) 5 SCC 282
07-06-2018,
upholds
the
spirit
of
the
afore
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
enumerated Notifications, which continue to be protected by virtue
of Article 371F of the Constitution.
The
(xiv)
contradictory
as
submissions
it
is
of
averred
the
on
Petitioners
one
hand
are
that
also
Sikkim
Subjects/COI induces discrimination between the Sikkimese and
Indian citizens, while on the other hand they seek issuance of COI
for their children.
Hence, the Writ Petition being without merit deserves to be
dismissed.
6.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent No.11 endorsed
the submissions canvassed by Learned Additional Advocate General
for the Respondents No.1 to 10 and submitted that the four
primary prayers, being Prayers No. (ii), (iii), (iv) and (viii) in the
Writ Petition face hindrances and even if the impugned Notification
of 2018 was to be partly quashed, in terms of the prayers of the
Petitioners, they would still be hindered by the provisions of the
Office Order bearing No.105/LR, dated 25-02-1961.
(i)
That, although the Petitioners seek rights of Sikkimese
for their children, however none of them have filed any documents
before this Court to indicate that they also derive any such rights
from their mothers.
All Petitioners have filed documents derived
from their fathers, to claim their rights, revealing the Patriarchal
nature of Sikkimese society. Most of the Petitioners, in any event,
are not even identifiable as the same persons who appear in the
documents filed by them.
(ii)
It was canvassed that, the impugned Notification of
2018 does not provide any rights.
It is through the COI that
Sikkimese assume their rights. The issuance of COI however has
not been challenged by the Petitioners, besides they are not
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
eligible under any category of the relevant rules for issuance of COI
to them. Hence, the Petition deserves a dismissal.
7.
In rebuttal, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners
put forth the view that, property and citizenship rights are
independent of each other and the issues involved herein is the
right of inheritance of the offspring of women married to outsiders.
Reference was made to the provisions of Section 2(2) of the Hindu
Succession Act, 1956 and urged that it is not applicable in the
instant case as most of the Petitioners are Hindus, while the rest
are Buddhists following the Hindu law. Hence, the prayers be
granted.
8.
The rival contentions of the parties have been heard in
extenso,
the
pleadings
perused
as
also
the
accompanying
documents and citations made at the Bar.
9.
The question germane to the instant matter is whether
the non-issuance of COI to the Petitioners progeny, by virtue of the
Petitioners having married non-Sikkimese is discriminatory and
violative of their rights under Articles 14, 15, 16, 19 and 21 of the
Constitution of India.
10.
It is essential to briefly lay out the background of the
State to comprehend the import of the Petitioners case. Sikkim is
the 22nd State of the Indian Union, with an approximate area of
7,096 square kilometers and a population of 6,10,577 as per the
Census of 2011.
Prior to the 36th Amendment Act to the
Constitution of India by which Sikkim became a part of the Indian
Union, the erstwhile Kingdom of Sikkim was a protectorate of India
with Defence, External Affairs and Communications under the
Government of India.
The then Monarch, known as the Chogyal,
promulgated the Sikkim Subject Regulation, 1961, finding it
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
expedient at that time to define clearly the status of Sikkim
Subjects and to make provision for the acquisition and loss of such
status. The Regulation inter alia provided that;
“…………………………………………………………………………………
3.
Certain persons domiciled in Sikkim Territory at
the commencement of the Regulation to be Sikkim
Subjects –
(I)
Every person who has his domicile in the
territory
of
Sikkim
immediately
before
the
commencement of this Regulation shall be a Sikkim
Subject if he ─
(a)
was born in the territory of Sikkim and is
resident therein, or
(b)
has been ordinarily resident in the
territory of Sikkim for a period of not less
than fifteen years immediately preceding
such commencement :
Provided that in counting the said
period of fifteen years any absence from
the said territory on account of service
under the Government of India shall be
disregarded ; or
(c)
is the wife or minor child of a person
mentioned in clause (a) or clause (b)
……………………………………………………………………………………
7.
Certain persons not to be Sikkim Subjects –
(a)
………………………………………………………………
(b)
Any Sikkimese woman who marries a
person who is not a Sikkim Subject; or
(c)
………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………”
[emphasis supplied]
(i)
On the Sikkim Congress deciding to put an end to the
monarchial rule, the Government of Sikkim Act, 1974, was
consequently passed on 10-04-1975, by the Sikkim Assembly for
progressive realization of a fully responsible Government in Sikkim
for furthering its relations with India.
This led to the Constitution
35th Amendment Act of 1974, which provided that Sikkim would be
an “associate State”, and was brought within the framework of the
Indian Constitution by inserting Article 2A and the 10th Schedule in
the Constitution. As the Indian Constitution did not envisage any
“associate State”, this amendment was followed by the 36th
Amendment Act, 1975, omitting both Article 2A and the 10 th
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Schedule (supra).
The 36th Amendment Act, 1975, was given
retrospective effect from 26-04-1975 (the appointed day) and
Sikkim was admitted into the Union of India as its 22nd State.
Article 371F was inserted to make special provisions relating to the
administration
of
Sikkim
to
meet
the
special
needs
and
circumstances of the State while respecting its historical and local
contexts.
(ii)
The Adaptation of Sikkim Laws (No.1) Order, 1975,
dated 13-09-1975, at 2(b) and 2(c) defines the following;
“……………………………………………………………………………………………..
In exercise of the powers conferred by Clause
(I) of Article 371F of the Constitution, the President
hereby makes the following order, namely:I.
(I)
This Order may be called the Adaptation
of Sikkim Laws (No.I) Order, 1975.
(2)
It shall be deemed to have come into
force on the 26th day of April, 1975.
2.
(I)
In this Order -
2.
(a)
“appointed day” means the 26th day of
April, 1975.
(b)
“existing law” means any law in force
immediately before the appointed day in
the whole or any part of the territories
comprised in the State of Sikkim.
(c)
“law”
includes
any
enactment,
Proclamation,
Regulation,
rule,
notification or other instrument having,
immediately before the appointed day,
the force of law in the whole or any part
of the territory now comprised in the
State of Sikkim.”
[emphasis supplied]
At Paragraph 5 it is stated as follows;
“5.
(iii)
The laws mentioned in the Second Schedule to
this Order shall until altered, repealed or
amended by a competent Legislature or other
competent authority, have effect subject to the
adaptations and modifications directed by that
Schedule.”
[emphasis supplied]
With this background in place, while addressing the
argument of Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners that all
Sikkim Subjects have become Indian citizens on 26-04-1975, and
cannot be discriminated on grounds of gender and thereby violate
the provisions of Articles 14, 15 and 16, it is relevant to notice that
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Article 371F, the special provision for Sikkim, begins with a nonobstante clause viz., the introduction to the provision is with the
words “Notwithstanding anything in this Constitution ……”. A nonobstante clause as per Black’s Law Dictionary, 10th Edition, at Page
No.1218,
is “a phrase used in documents to preclude any
interpretation contrary to the stated object or purpose”.
A non-
obstante clause, is therefore, a legislating device, used to give a
provision overriding effect over conflicting laws, to ensure that the
specific rule prevails over contrary provisions, either in the same or
other statutes.
the
relevant
The word “Notwithstanding” gives precedence to
provisions,
over
every
other
provision
of
the
Constitution and thereby ensures the clear operation of the
provisions of law in question. Article 371F which commences with
a non-obstante clause therefore overrides the other provisions of
the Constitution, by virtue of it being a special provision for the
State of Sikkim, to meet the individual needs and circumstances of
its people, in terms of the political commitments and solemn
assurances given to the people of Sikkim, when it became a part of
the Indian Union.
It is a connection between its distinctive and
unique past and its entry at the relevant time into the Indian
Union.
(iv)
In Surendra Prasad Sharma (supra), the Supreme Court
in a Bench comprising of A.M. Ahmedi, J and N. G. Venkatachala, J,
in a Judgment authored by A.M. Ahmedi, J, was considering the
impugned Judgment of the High Court being W.P(C) No.29 of 1982
(Surendra Prasad Sharma vs. State of Sikkim). The High Court inter
alia was of the view that, since the Government of Sikkim
Establishment Rules of 1974, was the subject matter of Adaptation
Order issued by the President of India, vide Establishment
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Department Notification No.202/Gen/Est., dated 17-11-1980, they
ceased to be “laws” within the meaning of clause (k) of Article
371F and therefore the rules did not enjoy the protection of the
non-obstante clause. It was next observed by the High Court that
with the incorporation of Sikkim as a component State in the Union
of India w.e.f. 26-04-1975, Sikkimese nationality ceased to exist
as
a
politico-legal
Sikkimese
nationals
concept,
in
hence
matters
the
relating
preference
to
given
to
employment
or
appointment under the then Government of Sikkim, under Rule
4(4) of the Establishment Rules of 1974 has become ineffective
and unworkable.
(v)
For the sake of clarity the said proviso of the
Establishment Rules (supra) is extracted hereinbelow;
“(4)
Appointment.- (A) …………………………………
(a)
………………………………………………………………
(b)
………………………………………………………………
(B)
………………………………………………………………
Provided these two types of appointment shall
be made having due regard to the exact nature of
specific
duties
and
responsibilities
and
the
qualification required for the post, and further
provided that (i) Non-Sikkimese nationals may be
appointed
only
when
suitably
qualified
and
experienced Sikkimese nationals are available, and
(ii) replacement of such appointees by suitable
Sikkimese candidates may be made as and when
available.
………………………………”
(vi)
[emphasis supplied]
The Supreme Court in Surendra Prasad Sharma (supra)
however was of the view that the entire approach of the High Court
was wrong.
It was of the view that the term “existing law” as
defined in the “Adaptation of Sikkim Laws (No.1) Order 1975”
brought within its fold any enactment, proclamation, regulation,
rule, notification or other instrument having, immediately before
the appointed day the force of law in the whole or any part of the
territory, comprised in the State of Sikkim and held that the
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Establishment Rules of 1974 were promulgated by the Chogyal of
Sikkim as its absolute Monarch, for regulating the appointments to
the Civil Services of the State and as they were undoubtedly in
existence before Sikkim acquired the status of an “associate State”
by the 35th Amendment and a full-fledged State of the Union of
India by 36th Amendment, there can be no doubt that the
Establishment Rules of 1974 which were in force in the territories
comprised in the State of Sikkim prior to 26-04-1975 would stand
covered by the expression all “laws in force”, used in clause (k) of
Article 371F and would continue to be in force even after the
appointed date, as existing laws, until amended or repealed. The
Supreme Court explained as follows;
“16. In the proviso to Rule 4(4) extracted
earlier there is reference to Sikkimese nationals and
non-Sikkimese nationals. The said proviso posits that
non-Sikkimese nationals may be appointed only
when suitably qualified and experienced Sikkimese
nationals are not available and further provides for
replacement of such non-Sikkimese nationals by
Sikkimese candidates as and when the latter become
available. The High Court has refused to construe the
said proviso to mean local residents of Sikkim were to
be preferred to non-residents of Sikkim. The High
Court answers the contentions thus:
“But even with the aid of these
provisions, it is not possible to construe the
expression „Sikkimese nationals‟ as „locals‟ or
permanent residents of Sikkim, as one can be a
national of one country without being a
resident in that country and may in fact be a
permanent resident of another country with his
domicile, whether of origin or of choice, in that
country.”
And caps the same as under:
“I have already noted that the provisions
of Rule 4(4) of the Sikkim Government
Establishment Rules, quoted hereinbefore,
provided
for
preferential
treatment
to
Sikkimese nationals in matters relating to
employments or appointments under the then
Government of Sikkim and that with the
incorporation of Sikkim as a component State
in the Union of India with effect from 26-41975, Sikkimese nationality having ceased to
exist as a politico-legal concept, the preference
sought to be given by Rule 4(4) has become
ineffective and unworkable.”
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
With respect we find it difficult to accept this highly
technical approach. In the first place since this was an
existing law which was continued ", it would naturally
contain expressions which were in vogue before the
appointed day. These expressions had to be
understood in the sense in which they were defined in
the Sikkim Subjects Regulations, 1961. Regulation 3
defines Sikkim subjects and Regulation 7 explains
who shall not be Sikkim subjects. Therefore, if the
expressions „Sikkimese nationals‟ and „non-Sikkimese
nationals‟ used in the proviso to Rule 4(4) are read
and understood in the context of the provisions of the
aforesaid regulations, the difficulty expressed by the
learned Judge in the High Court would appear to be
imaginary.
17. The High Court has then taken the view
that since the Establishment Rules of 1974 were the
subject-matter of Adaptation Orders issued by the
President of India, they ceased to be existing law
within the meaning of clause (k) of Article 371-F and
therefore they did not enjoy the protection thrown by
the non obstante clause. It was further submitted that
this was all the more so because the said Rules were
modified under Article 309 of the Constitution with
effect from 26-4-1975. The High Court's approach in
this behalf is twofold (i) the non obstante clause in
Article 371-F in relation to clause (k) has no efficacy
as the said clause can quite effectively operate, just
like Article 372, without the aid of the non obstante
clause as there is nothing to show that it conflicts
with any other provision in the Constitution and (ii) its
operation in relation to certain clauses like (i) and (j)
would lead to an absurd situation. We are afraid the
entire approach of the learned Judge is, with respect,
wrong. In the first place in relation to clause (k) the
non obstante clause seeks to extend protection to all
existing laws even if they may conflict with any of the
provisions of the Constitution and in the absence of
such protection would be declared ultra vires the
Constitution. Since the laws which were in force
before the appointed day had not to go through the
test of satisfying the requirements of the Constitution,
the possibility of those laws being in conflict with the
provisions of the Constitution could not be ruled out
and hence they had to be protected by the non
obstante clause. ……………………………………………..”
[emphasis supplied]
(vii)
The Supreme Court while further considering that the
special provisions may not be entirely in accordance with the other
provisions of the Constitution, observed that;
“20. It may be noticed that even the laws
which were prevailing in India under the British rule
were not expected to accord with the Constitution of
free India. That is why Article 13 provides that all
laws in force in the territory of India immediately
before the commencement of the Constitution, insofar
as they are not consistent with the provisions in Part
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
III thereof, shall, to the extent of such inconsistency
be void. ………………………………………………………………….
………………..……………………………………………………….
22. Article 371-F, is as stated earlier, a special
constitutional provision with respect to the State of
Sikkim. The reason why it begins with a non obstante
clause obviously is that the matters referred to in the
various clauses immediately following required a
protective cover so that such matters are not struck
down as unconstitutional because they do not satisfy
the constitutional requirement. Unless such immunity
was granted „the laws in force‟ would have had to
meet the test of Article 13 of the Constitution. This
being the objective, existing laws or laws in force
came to be protected by clause (k) added to Article
371-F. The said laws in force in the State of Sikkim
were, therefore, protected, until amended or
repealed, to ensure smooth transition from the
Chogyal's rule to the democratic rule under the
Constitution. Inherent in clause (l) is the assumption
that many of such existing laws may be inconsistent
with the Constitution and, therefore, the President
came to be conferred with a special power to make
adaptations and modifications with a view to making
the said rule consistent with the Constitution. Of
course this power had to be exercised within two
years from the appointed day. If any adaptation or
modification is made in the law in force prevailing
prior to the appointed day, the law would apply
subject to such adaptation and modification. It is
thus obvious that the adaptation and modification
made by the President in exercise of this special
power does not have the effect of the law ceasing to
be a law in force within the meaning of clause (k) of
Article 371-F. Therefore, on the plain language of the
said provision it is difficult to hold that the effect of
adaptation or modification is to take the law out of
the purview of „laws in force‟.
23. The next question is whether the insertion
of the introductory clause purporting to convey that
the said rules are made under Article 309 of the
Constitution with effect from 26-4-1975 amounts to
substitution of the Establishment Rules of 1974 to
deny them the immunity conferred by clause (k) of
Article 371-F? We have extracted the introductory
part earlier which shows that the Establishment Rules
were merely „adopted‟ with modification with effect
from 26-4-1975. Rule 4(4) remains as it was and the
Rules continue to be effective from 1-4-1974…………..”
[emphasis supplied]
(viii)
The decision with lucidity thus explains the context of
Article 371F, the immunity granted to “laws in force” in Sikkim,
i.e., the laws immediately existing before Sikkim became a part of
the Indian Union, the protection which thereby was given to Rule
4(4) of the Sikkim Government Establishment Rules, 1974 and
consequently the difference between Sikkim Subjects and others.
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Article 14 of the Constitution provides that the State
11.
shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal
protection of laws within the territory of India. The Article prohibits
discrimination and mandates that all persons shall be treated
equally before the law, it is thus a declaration of equality of all
persons within the territory of India implying the absence of any
special privilege in favour of any individual.
The guarantee of
equal protection of law and equality before the law, nonetheless
does not prohibit reasonable classification.
The State has the
power to have a classification on the basis of rational distinctions
relevant to the particular subject to be dealt with.
However, it
goes without saying that permissible classification must be founded
on intelligible differentia, which distinguishes persons that are
grouped together, from others, who are left out of the group. The
differentia must have a rational relation to the object sought to be
achieved by the legislation. The Supreme Court in Surendra Prasad
Sharma
(supra) has explained Rule 4(4) of the Government of
Sikkim Establishment Rules, 1974, in this context and has
protected the differentiation made between Sikkimese and nonSikkimese.
12.
Now, while addressing the issue of Article 15 of the
Constitution, the said provision prohibits discrimination on grounds
of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth.
The provision
therefore makes room for gender equality, however it does not
tantamount
to
a
bar
on
classification
on
non-arbitrary
considerations. The provisions of Article 15 have to be construed
harmoniously with the provisions of Article 371F bearing in mind
that, the special provision commences with a non-obstante clause.
As pointed out in Surendra Prasad Sharma (ibid) that, it is well
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
settled by a long line of decisions that constitutional provisions
must be liberally construed to the extent the language permits it
and should not be interpreted in a narrow and pedantic manner,
more so in the case of transitory provisions.
Article 16 of the Constitution of India guarantees
13.
equality
of
opportunity
in
public
employment
prohibiting
discrimination on grounds enumerated therein. This aspect in the
context of Sikkim has been dealt with at length in Surendra Prasad
Sharma (ibid) and the issue given a quietus as already discussed in
the
foregoing
paragraphs
it
thereby
does
away
with
the
requirement of any further prolix discussions.
Consequently, the Petitioners ought to have taken note
14.
of the decision in Surendra Prasad Sharma (supra) and adhered to
what has been held by the Supreme Court, the decision having
accepted the differentiation made in the proviso to Rule 4(4) of the
Government of Sikkim Establishment Rules, 1974 and therefore by
implication allowing it to be tested on the anvil of the Regulation of
1961, as, a Sikkimese national can be identified only on the basis
of entries made in the old Sikkim Subjects Register.
The
discussions above quell the arguments regarding discrimination on
various grounds raised by the Petitioners.
In an additional argument, Learned Senior Counsel for
15.
the
Petitioners
reiterating
the
argument
of
gender
based
discrimination while relying on the decision in Association of Old
Settlers of Sikkim and Others vs. Union of India and Another , urged
that Supreme Court has inter alia observed therein that, pursuant
to the merger of Sikkim with India, Sikkim Subjects and all
Sikkimese domiciled in the territory of Sikkim have become Indian
(2023) 5 SCC 717
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
citizens, there cannot be a discrimination vis-à-vis Sikkimese
woman marrying a non-Sikkimese.
In this context, it may be
pointed out here that the view expressed by the Supreme Court
was that, Section 10 (26AAA) proviso of the Income Tax Act, 1961,
should not have discriminated against Sikkimese women, only
because a Sikkimese woman who, though, may have had her name
registered in the Register of Sikkim Subjects, married a nonSikkimese, that too only on or after 01-04-2008, as there is no
justification for such exclusion. In my considered view, this finding
will not support the case of the Petitioners progeny as the
observation is limited to the “Sikkimese woman” whose name is in
the Sikkim Subjects Register and does not in any manner discuss
about whether the children of Sikkimese women, married to a nonSikkimese, would be entitled to such exemption.
16.
Women in Sikkim having to submit “marital status”
before obtaining Government employment in Sikkim, necessarily
flows from the reasons as explained in the Notification dated 2502-1961 which is extracted hereinbelow, Notification of 1969 and
the difference between a “Sikkimese national” and “non-Sikkimese
national” having been explained at length in Surendra Prasad
Sharma
(supra) which needs no further clarity.
The relevant
portion of the Regulation of 1961 has already been extracted
supra, which at Regulation 7(b) provides that a Sikkimese woman
who marries a non-Sikimmese ceases to be a Sikkim Subject. The
Notification of 1961 reads as follows;
“GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
LAND REVENUE DEPARTMENT
O.O.No. 105/L.R.
Dated Gangtok the 25th February, 1961.
It is hereby informed for the general guidance
of all the Darbar Officers dealing specifically with
registration of documents in Sikkim, that the following
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
procedures should be strictly followed and observed in
cases of transaction relating to transfer of immovable
properties.
…………………………………………………………………………
………………………… if she is married, in which case
such other particulars of her husband including the
community to which he belongs, his home address,
what landed property he holds already in Sikkim etc.,
should be enquired into first. In the case of transfer
otherwise than by sale also such as gift etc., similar
particulars of the husband of the woman if she is
married are to be furnished. ………………………..”
The Notification of 1969 provides as follows;
“Land Revenue Department
Notification No.28/LR
Dated Gangtok, the 21st April, 1969.
There has been some doubts about the right of
a woman to purchase or sell land after her marriage
to a person of other community due to restrictions
imposed by Revenue Order No.1 of 1917 and in order
to clarify the position in this regard. It is hereby
notified as follows;
(a)
Women follows the nationality
community of her husband.
and
(b)
Bhutia-Lepcha women marrying a person
of community other than her own
community only if such land was
acquired by her prior to her marriage.
(c)
Land acquired by her after her marriage
to a non Bhutia-Lepcha may be sold to
any community.
(d)
Sikkimese of Tibetan and Bhutanese
origin enjoy all rights and privileges of
Bhutia/Lepcha except that they may not
buy land from the latter community.
…………………………………………………………...”
[emphasis supplied]
On the question of the right of a woman to marry a
17.
person
of
ones
choice,
strength
was
drawn
from
Laxmibai
Chandaragi B. and Another vs. State of Karnataka and Others ,
by
Learned
buttress
his
Senior
Counsel
for
the
Petitioners
to
argument. The decision (supra) pertains to an FIR registered by
the father of a missing girl who had without the notice of her
parents married the Petitioner No.2, in the said matter. The Court
observed that educated adults were choosing their life partners,
(2021) 3 SCC 360
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
which is a departure from the earlier norms of society, where caste
and community played a major role. The FIR was quashed by the
Supreme Court with the expectation that the parents of the
Petitioner No.1 would have better sense to accept the marriage.
For the purposes of the instant matter, no law in Sikkim, restricts a
Sikkimese woman from opting for her choice of partner, however
the existing laws of Sikkim as extracted earlier, are protected laws
and the insertion of Article 371F made with a solemn promise to
the Sikkimese.
The State was just joining the mainstream then
and the population would have been overwhelmed, if no protective
measures were put into place. It was therefore with the intention
of protecting the local populace and the local context that the old
laws were protected and continue to be so.
In the said
circumstances, the laws have to be complied with unless amended
or repealed.
18.
While traversing the arguments of Learned Senior
Counsel for the Petitioners regarding the decision of this Court in
Padma Kumari Ganesan (supra), there were two rounds of litigation
between the Petitioner, a Sikkimese woman married to a nonSikkimese in 1953 and the State. In the first Writ Petition, being
No.02 of 1977 (Mrs. Padma Kumari Ganesan vs. Secretary, Land
Revenue Department, Govt. of Sikkim), the facts pertained to non-
registration of a deed of gift executed by the Petitioner‟s mother in
her favour, in respect of properties situated at Aritar Block,
Rhenock, East Sikkim. The Court passed its Judgment on 17-081977 ordering that;
“11. In view of what has been stated above and the
position clearly emerging from the registration rules it
has been established beyond doubt that the orders of
the Secretary, Land Revenue are wholly without
jurisdiction and have no basis in law.
There is,
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
therefore, no option but to quash these two letters of
the Land Revenue Department dated 7th May, 1974
and 18th April, 1977 and it is ordered accordingly. It
would now be open to the petitioner to approach the
Registrar for the registration of the gift deed and I
have no doubt that he will deal with the matter in
accordance with law and pass appropriate orders
keeping in view the procedure laid down in the Rules
regarding registration.
The petition is, therefore,
allowed as indicated above but the parties are left to
bear their own costs.”
The deed of gift came to be registered in the Petitioner‟s
name on 22-02-1978. Needless to reiterate here that she was a
woman of Sikkimese origin.
(i)
In Writ Petition No.10 of 1991 (Mrs. Padma Kumari
Ganesan vs. The State of Sikkim and Others), the Petitioner‟s
grievance was that the District Registrar-cum-Collector, East
District, Gangtok, had refused to register the deed of gift executed
by the Petitioner on 08-05-1989, in favour of her two sons. The
High Court observed that the Married Women‟s Property Regulation
of 1962 had never been brought into force in the State of Sikkim
as the Respondents not only did not deny the Petitioner‟s assertion
on oath to that effect, but also failed to produce any order or
notification of His Highness the Maharaja of Sikkim bringing the
said Regulation into force.
In view of the above findings, the
larger question whether the Married Women‟s Property Regulation
of 1962 was ultravires being violative of Article 15(1) of the
Constitution was not considered. The High Court finally observed
that;
“6.
……………………….……………………………….
(i) the deed of gift dated 8.5.89 executed by
the petitioner in favour of her two sons, Venugopal
and Nandagopal, the application of the petitioner and
other accompanying documents shall now be
considered afresh by the District Registrar-cumCollector, East District, Gangtok.
(ii) the petitioner or her representative shall
be given an opportunity to be heard in the matter of
registration.
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
(iii) the District Registrar-cum-Collector, East
District, Gangtok shall take a decision in the matter
of registration within two months from the date of
appearance of the petitioner before her, strictly in
accordance with law and without taking into
consideration
the
Married
Women’s
Property
Regulation of 1962; and
(iv) the petitioner as undertaken shall appear
before the District Registrar-cum-Collector, East
District, Gangtok on 23.9.91 to receive directions as
to further proceedings in the matter of registration.
………….…………………”
(ii)
[emphasis supplied]
A careful reading of the Judgment (supra) clearly
falsifies the submissions of Learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioners that the Judgment had held that the immovable
properties of Sikkimese woman married to a non-Sikkimese is
transferable, neither was it propounded that she was also free to
inherit the property of her parents. It is clearly a misinterpretation
of the pronouncement.
The Court only gave directions to the
District Registrar as extracted (supra).
Suffice it to remark that
neither party furnished before this Court the further fate of the said
matter.
19.
Now, turning to the argument of Learned Senior for the
Petitioners pertaining to issuance of Residential Certificates (RCs)
to non-Sikkimese Indian citizens and also the contention that
property rights and citizenship rights are independent of each
other, it is worth remarking that no one has denied the Petitioners
Indian citizenship.
holders.
In addition, the Petitioners are also COI
Relevant
reference
is
made
to
Notification
No.120/Home/2010, dated 26-10-2010, published in the Sikkim
Government Gazette on 01-11-2010, vide which the Government
authorized the concerned authorities to issue RCs to persons falling
in different categories as indicated in the Notification, on the
recommendations
of
Panchayat/Municipality.
the
Gram
Panchayat
or
the
Nagar
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
(i)
In supersession of the Notification of 2010 (supra),
Notification No.23/Home/2015, dated 15-05-2015, was published
in the Sikkim Government Gazette on 18-05-2015, the relevant
portion of the Notification is extracted hereinbelow;
“ …………………………………………………………………………………
No.23/Home/2015
Dated : 15.05.2015
NOTIFICATION
I.
In supersession of Home
Department‟s
Notification
No.120/Home/2010
dated
26/10/2010, the State Government is pleased
to authorize the District Collectors within their
respective jurisdictions and with the prior
clearance of the Secretary, Home Department
and Secretary, Land Revenue & Disaster
Management Department to issue Residential
Certificates to persons falling in the different
categories
as
indicated
below
on
the
recommendation of the Gram Panchayat or the
Nagar Panchayat/Municipality and being duly
satisfied with such recommendation after
proper police verification with immediate
effect:1.
An applicant who has established
beyond all reasonable doubt that the
applicant was a resident of the State of
Sikkim on or before 26th April 1975 and
has been continuously residing in the
State of Sikkim since then, or
2.
An applicant who has established beyond
all reasonable doubt that the applicant is
the natural legal descendent of the
person referred to in category 1 above
and has been continuously residing in
the State of Sikkim since birth.
…………….…………….”
[emphasis supplied]
(ii)
Vide Notification No.12/Home/2018, dated 10-03-2018,
published in the Sikkim Government Gazette on 19-03-2018, the
State Government enumerated the benefits that would accrue to
holders of RC, issued under Home Department‟s Notification dated
15-05-2015 (supra). The Notification dated 10-03-2018 reads as
follows;
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
“…………….…………………………………………………………………….
GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
HOME DEPARTMENT
GANGTOK
No.12/Home/2018
Dated : 10.03.2018
NOTIFICATION
The State Government is hereby pleased to
notify that the following benefits will accrue to the
holders of Residential Certificate issued under Home
Department‟s Notification No.23/Home/2015 dated
15/05/2015, as amended:
1.
Ration Card.
2.
Trade Licence in Municipality
Panchayat jurisdiction.
3.
Purchase/lease of immovable property in
Municipality and Nagar Panchayat jurisdiction
with the prior approval of the State
Government.
4.
Taxi Permits for BPL Residential Certificate
holders.
5.
Driving Licence (NT/T).
6.
Admission
Institutions.
7.
Free Books, Uniforms and Midday Meals in
Government Schools for BPL Residential
Certificate holders.
8.
Exemption of College Fees in Government
Colleges for BPL Residential Certificate holders.
9.
Free medical services in Government Hospitals
for BPL Residential Certificate holders.
10.
Other Social Welfare Schemes as per fulfillment
of scheme specific eligibility for BPL Residential
Certificate holders.
in
Government
and
Nagar
Educational
By order and in the name of the Governor.
S. C Gupta, IAS
Additional Chief Secretary
Government of Sikkim
File No.Home/Confdl/158/2015/01/Vol:III”
[emphasis supplied]
(iii)
RC holders, therefore in light of the afore extracted
Notifications are entitled to benefits inter alia of purchase/lease of
immovable
property
in
Municipality
and
Nagar
Panchayat
jurisdiction with the prior approval of the State Government. The
Government may have stopped short of grant of COI to the
Petitioners progeny, on account of the existing laws which are
protected, however it does not debar them from obtaining RC from
the Government, which by and large offers the same facilities as
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
those extended to COI holders. RC holders are not prohibited from
purchase, lease or sale of immovable properties, as seen reflected
in the Notification (supra), subject to the limitations prescribed
thereof.
(iv)
That having been said, it is now relevant to look at the
provisions of the Revenue Order No.1 of 1917, dated 17-05-1917
to address the argument of the Petitioners regarding this law. The
relevant portion reads as follows;
“REVENUE ORDER NO.1
With reference to Order dated the 2nd January
1897, it is hereby again notified to all Kazis,
Thikadars and Mandals in Sikkim that no Bhutias and
Lepchas are to be allowed to sell, mortgage or sub-let
any of their land to any person other than a Bhutia or
a Lepcha without the express sanction of the Darbar
or officers empowered by the Darbar in their behalf,
whose order will be obtained by the landlord
concerned. If anyone disobeys he will be severely
punished.
………………………………”
[emphasis supplied]
(v)
The 1897 Notification referred to in the Revenue Order
No.1 of 1917 was issued on 2nd January, which provides as follows;
“NOTICE
Is hereby given to all the Kazis and Mondals in
Sikkim, that no Bhutias and Lepchas are to be allowed
to sell or sublet any of their lands without the express
sanction of the Council.
If anyone disobeys this
order, he will be punished severely.
.…………………………………………………………………………”
(vi)
There is an erroneous interpretation of the Revenue
Order No.1 of 1917 by Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners
who in his argument contended that it does not debar the land
from being transferred to a “plainsman”. Revenue Order No.1 of
1917, as extracted above with clarity lays down that the Bhutias
and Lepchas are not permitted to sell, mortgage or sub-let any of
their land to “any person” other than a Bhutia or a Lepcha. The
interpretation that the land in Sikkim can be transferred to a
“plainsman” is not only erroneous but also misleading. Neither
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
party agitated before this Court whether Revenue Order No.1 was
notified in the Sikkim Darbar Gazette at any time.
The two laws
extracted above debar the transfer of land of Bhutias-Lepchas to
any other community in the State.
This law is a protected law.
Despite every Sikkimese including a COI holder being an Indian,
the above laws debars transfer of land on the basis of community,
which are apparently discriminatory but the law has to be complied
with as already stated, until amended or repealed.
(vii)
The Sikkim State Rules, Registration of Document,
1930 (hereinafter, the “Registration of Document Rules”), is saved
by the Adaptation of Sikkim Laws (No.1) Order, 1975.
The said
Rule is extracted as follows;
“22. The Registration Officer after satisfying
himself that the contents of the document do not
conflict with the existing land laws and rules
regarding the holding of immovable property in
Sikkim, shall proceed with the registering of the
document in accordance with procedure specified in
paragraph (7).”
[emphasis supplied]
(viii)
These Rules are to be read in tandem in the spirit of
the Regulation of 1961 and Notification No.28/LR, dated 21-041969, as already discussed. In light of the existence of this law,
when the registration of a document is to be made in the State of
Sikkim, it must essentially be of a Sikkimese woman married to a
Sikkimese man.
20.
The argument of Learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioners with regard to the denial of the Petitioners right on
account of Sikkim following the norm of a patriarchal society also
has no legs to stand, in light of the existence of Notification
No.28/LR, dated 21-04-1969 (extracted supra).
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Reliance on C. Masilamani Mudaliar and Others vs. Idol of
(i)
Sri Swaminathaswami Swaminathaswami Thirukoil and Others
by
Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners to urge that the children
of the Petitioners are entitled to inherit their properties is not
applicable to the facts and circumstances of the instant case as
also the decision in Revanasiddappa and Another vs. Mallikarjun and
Others
, which was dealing with Section 16(3) of the Hindu
Marriage Act, 1955, children of voidable marriages and legitimacy
of children from such marriages.
The argument of Learned Senior Counsel for the
21.
Petitioners that this Court has held in Nil Kumar Dahal (supra) that
in the absence of Succession Rights in Sikkim, the Hindu
Succession Act of 1956, as amended, would be applicable, is to be
comprehended in its correct perspective.
has no bearing in the instant matter.
Dahal
That, pronouncement
It was observed in Nil Kumar
(supra), that, in the absence of any statutory provision
dealing with Succession in the State, and as the Hindu Succession
Act, 1956, has not been extended and enforced in the State, but at
the same time considering that the Courts in Sikkim have applied
the provisions of law of the country, where the laws in Sikkim are
inadequate, or do not cover a specific area, it stands to reason that
the provisions of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, can be invoked
and applied for the purposes of determining matters relating to
succession in Sikkim, involving parties to whom the personal law is
applicable, till specific laws occupy the field.
22.
On the question of the Petitioners not having locus
standi, I have perused the decision in Jasbhai Motibhai Desai (supra)
relied on by Learned Additional Advocate General. The ruling lays
(1996) 8 SCC 525
(2011) 11 SCC 1
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
down that as a general rule the Petitioners ought to be aggrieved
by the infringement of some legal right or prejudice caused to
some legal interest inhering in the Petitioner. It goes on to explain
that Article 226 provides that an applicant should “ordinarily” be
one who has a person or individual right in the subject matter of
the application.
The expression “ordinarily”, it was explained, is
not a cast-iron rule, it is flexible enough to take in those cases
where the applicant has been prejudicially affected by an act or
omission of an authority, even though he has no proprietary or
even a fiduciary interest in subject matter.
Having given due
consideration to the arguments advanced and the grievance of the
Petitioners, despite the Learned Additional Advocate General
relegating the case of the Petitioners to one as being an emotional
cry of mothers, in my considered view, it cannot be confined to
such an adjective, by virtue of the fact that, the property that they
own by acquisition or have inherited cannot be registered in the
names of their rightful inheritors. In fact in Jasbhai Motibhai Desai
(ibid), it has even been held that in exceptional cases even a
stranger or a person who was not a party to the proceedings
before the authority but has a substantial and genuine interest in
subject matter of the proceedings will be covered by this rule.
The Petitioners are indeed affected by the existing laws which
prevent them from legally handing over their properties to their
children. Hence, in view of the foregoing discussions, the question
of the Petitioners not having locus standi does not have weight and
is thus disregarded.
23.
It is now
apposite
to
discuss public policy and
legislation. In Gujarat State Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. vs. Union of India
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and Others
, word “policy” was explained and it was observed that
anything that is done contrary to the “public policy” is a harmful
thing, though the concept of what is public good or in the public
interest, or what would be injurious or harmful to the public good
or public interest has varied from time to time. The Learned
Additional Advocate General had drawn strength on this facet by
relying on BALCO Employees’ Union (Regd.) vs. Union of India and
Others
, wherein it was observed that it is not for the Courts to
consider the relative merits of different economic policies and
consider whether a better policy may be evolved.
(i)
In Kirloskar Ferrous Industries Limited and Another vs.
Union of India and Others
, reference was made to a plethora of
decisions of the Supreme Court which held that, policy decisions
are in the domain of the Executive authority of the State and the
Courts should not embark on the unchartered ocean of different
authority nor question the efficacy or otherwise of such policy, so
the same does not offend any provision of the Constitution of
India.
(ii)
Ergo, this Court is of the view that every branch of the
Government be it the Executive, Legislature and the Judiciary, each
has a defined role and is expected to operate within the ambit of
the boundaries set out for them.
essentially
is
to
ensure
that
The separation of powers
there
is
no
overlapping
or
encroachment by one branch into the working of another branch.
24.
In the instant matter, the old laws of Sikkim being
protected laws as clearly laid down in the special provision for
Sikkim viz., Article 371F(k) of the Constitution and duly saved by
AIR 2008 (NOC) 2761 (GUJ.)
(2002) 2 SCC 333
(2025) 1 SCC 695
2026:SHC:25
WP(C) No.45 of 2020
Puspa Mishra and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
the Adaptation of Sikkim Laws (No.1) Order 1975, cannot be
tinkered with by this Court for the reasons which have been
discussed in extenso. In my considered view, it falls in the domain
of the Executive and the Legislature.
The Court surely cannot
arrogate to itself powers that are reserved for the Legislature nor
can it interfere in Executive policy decisions.
25.
In light of the foregoing detailed discussions, the Writ
Petition being devoid of merit stands dismissed and disposed of.
26.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
06-04-2026
Approved for reporting : Yes
sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review