Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
! "# $!%&'&"( ) *
,
,,
.**
*
+
--
.
***
)
Present:
/ -
*
-
Mr. Sukesh Kumar Jindal, Advocate
for the appellant.
****
-0 *
1.
Defendant No. 2–appellant has preferred the present second appeal,
being aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated 10.11.2021 passed by the Civil
Judge (Junior Division), Gurugram, whereby the suit filed by the plaintiffs for
specific performance of the agreement dated 25.11.2015 and for permanent
injunction was decreed, as well as by the judgment and decree dated 02.09.2025
passed by the Additional District Judge, Gurugram, whereby the first appeal
preferred by the appellant–defendant No. 2 was dismissed.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are being referred to as they
were before the Court of first instance.
3.
The plaintiffs, in their suit for specific performance of the agreement
dated 25.11.2015, asserted that defendant No. 1 had agreed to sell his house/shop
bearing No. 440, measuring 40′ × 10′ (i.e. 44 square yards), situated within the
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.01.19 18:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
limits of the Municipal Corporation, Gurugram, duly bounded and fully described
in the plaint, for a total sale consideration of ₹50,00,000/ . A sum of ₹48,00,000/
was paid as earnest money. It was agreed that the balance sale consideration would
be paid at the time of registration of the sale deed. The defendants duly executed
the agreement to sell and receipt in the presence of witnesses. It was further agreed
that the sale deed would be executed and registered on or before 31.12.2016. The
plaintiffs alleged that they approached defendant No. 1 on several occasions for
execution of the sale deed, but he kept putting them off on one pretext or the other.
In the second week of October, 2016, when the plaintiffs again requested
defendant No. 1 to execute the sale deed, they were informed that defendant No.
1 had already executed a sale deed in favour of defendant No. 2 on 16.09.2016.
Thereafter, upon making inquiries, the plaintiffs came to know that defendant No.
1 had dishonestly and illegally sold the suit property, which was the subject matter
of the agreement, vide sale deed No. 16781 dated 16.09.2016, in favour of
defendant No. 2 for a sale consideration of ₹8,00,000/ . It was asserted that
defendant No. 2 had full knowledge of the agreement to sell executed by
defendant No. 1 in favour of the plaintiffs and that the sale deed so executed was
illegal, null and void, ineffective, and not binding on the rights of the plaintiffs. It
was further asserted that the plaintiffs had always been ready and willing to
perform their part of the contract and to pay the balance sale consideration.
4.
The suit was contested by defendant No. 1 by raising preliminary
objections. Execution of the agreement to sell and the receipt of earnest money
were not denied, however, it was contended that the plaintiffs, along with
defendant No. 2, had approached defendant No. 1 in the first week of September,
2016 and requested him to execute the sale deed in favour of defendant No. 2,
who was stated to be their nominee. The defence of defendant No. 1 was that the
sale deed in favour of defendant No. 2 was executed at the request of the plaintiffs
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.01.19 18:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
and that the amount of ₹48,00,000/ paid at the time of the agreement to sell was
duly adjusted towards the sale consideration. It was further pleaded that although
the actual sale consideration was ₹50,00,000/ , the sale deed was registered for
₹8,00,000/ on the basis of the Collector rates and that, despite objections raised
by defendant No. 1, the plaintiffs and defendant No. 2 got the sale deed registered
at the said value to avoid payment of stamp duty.
5.
Defendant No. 2 also contested the suit by raising several preliminary
objections and claimed himself to be a bona fide purchaser for valuable
consideration, thereby seeking dismissal of the suit. In the present case, insofar as
the agreement to sell and the receipt evidencing payment of earnest money are
concerned, the same have been rightly held to be proved by both the Courts below
in view of the specific stand taken by defendant No. 1 in his written statement,
wherein he duly admitted the execution of the agreement to sell as well as receipt
of ₹48,00,000/ as earnest money as well evidence led by plaintiffs.
6.
The case set up by defendant No. 1 was that defendant No. 2 was the
nominee of the plaintiffs and that the sale deed dated 16.09.2016 was executed in
favour of defendant No.2 at the asking of the plaintiffs. On this premise, the
defence of defendant No. 1 was that the agreement to sell dated 25.11.2015 stood
fully complied with and, therefore, no cause of action survived in favour of the
plaintiffs. On the other hand, defendant No. 2 claimed to be a bona fide purchaser
for consideration. In these circumstances, the issue regarding due execution of the
agreement to sell and the receipt acknowledging payment of earnest money stood
proved and could not be doubted.
7.
The findings recorded by the learned Courts below on the issue of
due execution of the agreement to sell and the receipt showing payment of earnest
money, therefore, cannot be faulted with. As regards the readiness and willingness
of the plaintiffs, it is evident that a substantial portion of the total sale
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.01.19 18:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
consideration had already been paid by way of earnest money. Out of the total sale
consideration of ₹50,00,000/ , the plaintiffs had paid ₹48,00,000/ , leaving only
₹2,00,000/ to be paid at the time of execution and registration of the sale deed. It
is not the case that the plaintiffs had defaulted in making payment of the balance
amount or that they were not ready to get the sale deed executed prior to the
stipulated date.
8.
As per the agreement, the last date for execution and registration of
the sale deed was 31.12.2016. However, prior to the said date, defendant No. 1
executed a sale deed dated 16.09.2016 in favour of defendant No. 2. In these
circumstances, the learned Courts below have rightly held that the plaintiffs could
not be held to be not ready and willing to perform their part of the contract.
9.
The only issue arising for consideration in the present appeal is
whether defendant No. 2 is a bona fide purchaser for valuable consideration.
Defendant No. 2 appeared as DW 1 and, while deposing, admitted his relationship
with defendant No. 1. He categorically denied any acquaintance with the plaintiffs
or having any knowledge of the agreement to sell dated 25.11.2015 (Ex. P 1). On
the other hand, defendant No. 1 took the stand that defendant No. 2 was a nominee
of the plaintiffs. In view of these contradictory and mutually destructive pleas
taken by defendant Nos. 1 and 2, the Courts below have rightly held that defendant
No. 2 could not be treated as a nominee of the plaintiffs.
10.
Further, it has come on record that though in the year 2015 defendant
No. 1 had agreed to sell the suit property for a consideration of ₹50,00,000/ , the
same property was sold in the year 2016 vide sale deed dated 16.09.2016 for a
consideration of only ₹8,00,000/ . There is no cogent evidence on record to
establish actual passing of consideration from defendant No. 2 to defendant No.
1. The learned Courts below have rightly observed that the close relationship
between defendant Nos. 1 and 2, coupled with the fact that they have taken
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.01.19 18:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
diametrically opposite stands, clearly indicates that defendant No. 2 was not a
bona fide purchaser and that the sale deed was executed in his favour only to
defeat the agreement to sell dated 25.11.2015 executed in favour of the plaintiffs.
11.
The facts and circumstances noticed above clearly establish that
defendant No. 2 had knowledge of the agreement executed in favour of the
plaintiffs and had actively participated with defendant No. 1 in defeating the rights
of the plaintiffs arising therefrom. Furthermore, both the Courts below have
rightly taken note of the prevailing market rates in the locality, as proved by the
plaintiffs by placing on record sale deeds Exs. P 8 and P 9, which show that the
prices of similar properties were much higher than the consideration shown in the
sale deed executed in favour of defendant No. 2. One such sale deed reflects that
similar property was sold for about ₹30,00,000/ , whereas the suit property was
allegedly sold to defendant No. 2 for only ₹8,00,000/ . Even otherwise, defendant
No. 2, while appearing as DW 1, admitted that the prevailing rate of properties in
the locality at the relevant time was approximately ₹1,00,000/ per square yard.
By his own showing, the suit property measuring 44 square yards would be worth
about ₹44,00,000/ . The fact that defendant No. 2 claims to have purchased the
property for nearly one fourth of its market value further demolishes his plea of
being a bona fide purchaser and clearly points towards his prior knowledge of the
agreement in favour of the plaintiffs.
12.
In view of the above, both the Courts below have correctly
appreciated the evidence on record and have rightly rejected the case set up by
defendant No. 2 appellant. Defendant No. 2 appellant has rightly been non suited
on proper appreciation of evidence. No substantial question of law arises for
consideration in the present second appeal. The appeal is devoid of merit and is
accordingly dismissed.
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.01.19 18:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
13.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand(s) disposed
of accordingly.
13.01.2026
-
manoj
Whether speaking/reasoned
Whether reportable
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.01.19 18:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review