The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
6. In the circumstances the Writ Petition is dismissed in limine.
7. No orders as to costs. Approved for reporting: yes. Internet: yes. to/ Sd/Judge Sd/Chief Justice
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P. (PIL) No. 06 of 2018
Shri Puran Alley vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(CIVIL EXTRA ORDINARY JURISDICTION)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
D.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
W.P. (PIL) No. 06 of 2018
Shri Puran Alley
S/o Shri Govind Prasad Alley
R/o Church Road, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
…. Petitioner
Versus
1.
State of Sikkim
Through Chief Secretary
Government of Sikkim
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
Secretary
Buildings & Housing Department
Government of Sikkim
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
3.
Chief Engineer
Buildings & Housing Department
Government of Sikkim
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
4.
Shri Sonam Topden Bhutia
Class-1 ‘A’ Government Contractor
Regd. No.579/PWD/2008
Lower Tadong, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
…. Respondents
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------Application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Appearance:
Mr.B. Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr. Bholanath Sharma,
Advocate for the Petitioner.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (PIL) No. 06 of 2018
Shri Puran Alley vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
ORDER
(24.05.2018)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
Heard. Mr. Puran Allay, a law graduate but not practicing as
an Advocate has preferred the present petition claiming to be an
unemployed youth and engaged in doing social work for the
upliftment of Sikkim. There are no details of the social works the
Petitioner has been doing in the past. The Petitioner claims that
after his graduation when he came back to Sikkim in the year
2013 he observed that there was no overall development in the
State and the money received from the Center had not been
utilized in the proper place for the upliftment of the downtrodden
people of Sikkim. There is no further clarification to this broad
spectrum allegation. It is his plea that whenever he would visit
remote areas he would notice poor people staying in deplorable
condition and thus was anxious to find out the exact reason as to
why despite the Central Government providing funds the people of
Sikkim have not been proportionately uplifted. Besides the
allegation there are no facts pleaded or proof submitted to
substantiate the allegations. The Petitioner claims that he started
doing research in the matter and came across shortcomings in
the functioning of the Governmental machineries. The Petitioner
claims that those shortcoming were that the funds were utilized
on non productive schemes; there was no proper allocation of
funds to such schemes which would directly benefit the
W.P. (PIL) No. 06 of 2018
Shri Puran Alley vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
downtrodden; the funds were provided for religious matters; funds
were
not
provided
for
construction
of
roads,
electricity,
establishment of specialized hospitals, schools, research work,
technical education, medical facilities etc. which are the basic
requirements of the people. There is not a single document filed
with the Writ Petition to substantiate the statements made about
the Petitioner’s perceptions of the said shortcomings.
2.
It is claimed by the Petitioner that while doing research the
Petitioner came across one Notice Inviting Tender (NIT) published
in Sikkim Herald, Sikkim Reporter and Dainik Mirmiray. The
Petitioner therefore, sought for copy of the “NIT” under the Right
to Information Act, 2005 and the Petitioner was furnished with
copy of the “NIT” published in Sikkim Herald on 25.05.2017 and
30.05.2017, Sikkim Reporter on 26.05.2017 and Dainik Mirmiray
on 26.05.2017. On a perusal of the “NIT”, the Petitioner claims he
was shocked to notice that the publication of the “NIT” was done
in a casual manner. The Petitioner claims that the publication of
the tender has not been done in widely circulated papers or
National dailies in so far as the Petitioner’s knowledge goes but
also states in the same breadth that the publication shows that it
was published in e-tender. It is the perception of the Petitioner
that only a handful of contractors are conversant with computer
knowledge. Yet another grievance of the Petitioner is that the
tender does not disclose the nature of work, schedule of work,
compliance of Sikkim Works Manual, compliance of Sikkim
W.P. (PIL) No. 06 of 2018
Shri Puran Alley vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Financial Rules and other related laws and other details. Mr. B.
Sharma, Learned Senior Advocate for the Petitioner could not
point out any such non-compliance from the records of the case.
The Petitioner states that he also received one Addendum dated
02.06.2017 as well as Corrigendum dated 05.07.2017 through the
process of the Right to Information Act, 2005. The Petitioner
claims
that
on
examining
the
Invitation
for
Bids
dated
23.05.2017, the Addendum dated 02.06.2017 and Corrigendum
dated 05.07.2017 the Petitioner came to learn how public money
from the Government exchequer had been embezzled. It is the
case of the Petitioner that the aforesaid three documents makes it
clear that the entire exercise of the tender process was
undertaken to accommodate Respondent No.4 in order to give him
“favouritism”. It is alleged that the Respondent No.4 did not even
participate in the pre-bid meeting and in spite of that his tender
was accepted. It is the case of the Petitioner that there were as
many as three participants in the tender bid. The Petitioner has
sought to invoke the Public Interest Litigation remedy to ventilate
his perceived grievance and sought the following prayers:“a.
Issue a writ or direction for cancelling the entire tender
process for execution of setting up of Sikkim State Museum,
Gangtok,
East
Sikkim
being
contract
work
No.03/E
Tender/B.HD/2017 holding entire process of tender are
carried out dehors the existing laws of the land.
b)
A writ/order or direction for quashing of the entire tender
process as the entire tender process is actuated by malafide
and due favouritism meted out to respondent No.4.
c)
And after hearing the parties:
W.P. (PIL) No. 06 of 2018
Shri Puran Alley vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
i.
To kindly quash/cancel the entire Tender process and
fund earmarked for this Tender maybe utilised for
other project to meet the basic need of the people and
in alternative, kindly quash, cancel the entire Tender
process, if it is found that Respondent No.4 is not
competent to execute the work. And to cancel the
whole process of contract if other bidders are not
competent to execute the work. If Hon’ble Court find
that this project is also in the Public Interest.
ii.
Kindly pass order/orders restraining the Respondent
No.2 to issue to Work Order in favour of Respondent
No.4.
iii.
3.
Kindly pass any order or orders if found necessary.”
Mr. B. Sharma would submit that although the Invitation for
Bids dated 23.05.2017 required that the contractors who have
experience in the construction of museum/artefacts and consider
themselves capable to undertake execution of the project could
download the details and bidding documents, Annexure-P11
dated 17.06.2016 would show that the contractor who has been
given the contract i.e. Respondent No.4 did not have the requisite
qualification. We have examined Annexure-P11 which is a letter
addressed to the Chief Engineer dated 17.06.2017 written by M/s
Adland Publicity Private Ltd. stating therein that M/s Adland
Publicity Private Ltd. is an old associate agency of Shri Sonam
Topden Bhutia (Class I-A Government Contractor) the Respondent
No.4 herein. It is also stated in the said communication that the
said M/s Adland Publicity Private Ltd. and the Respondent No.4
have been working as a joint venture since 2008. As an annexure
W.P. (PIL) No. 06 of 2018
Shri Puran Alley vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
thereto details of various dimensional creative works & designs
executed by the said M/s Adland Publicity Private Ltd. were also
furnished. Various certificates issued by various authorities have
been attached thereto providing information regarding various
works undertaken by the said M/s Adland Publicity Private Ltd.
The Addendum to the NIT filed by the Petitioner reflect that
preference could be given to such agencies having valid agreement
with
firms/persons
who
have
done
museum
works
at
National/State Level. The Corrigendum merely reschedules the
dates for bid submission and opening of bids to 28.07.2017 and
01.08.2017 respectively.
4.
Mr. B. Sharma, on being asked, could not point out a single
document from the records filed by the Petitioner which would
reflect that joint venture was not permitted contrary to the
Addendum. It is the case of the Petitioner that there were three
bidders in the tender process. The two bidders whose bids were
rejected are not before the Court or aggrieved. The Writ Petition
does not disclose whether the documents filed with it are the
entire documents before the Respondents. A perusal of the
documents
filed
by
the
Petitioner
does
not
disclose
any
‘favouritism’ as alleged. Making wide ranging allegations without
any substance is itself an act which cannot be entertained and
ought to be discouraged. The Petitioner’s allegation that a perusal
of the Invitation for Bids, the Addendum and the Corrigendum
thereto demonstrate that the Department has left no stone
W.P. (PIL) No. 06 of 2018
Shri Puran Alley vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
unturned
to
accommodate
Respondent
No.4
remains
an
unsubstantiated but damning allegation made without any basis
or coherence as even a searching examination of those documents
it could not substantiate the said allegation. In fact, Mr. B.
Sharma could also not point it out to us. There is nothing brought
out in the Writ Petition with discloses that Respondent No.4 did
not have the necessary prerequisites to qualify in the bid. Roving
inquiry merely on the basis of unsubstantiated allegations cannot
be permitted to ventilate a presumed grievance of the Petitioner
who has failed to demonstrate public interest element or point out
a single material to establish even prima facie any act of
favouritism
towards
the
Respondent
No.4.
Public
Interest
Litigation (PIL) remedy cannot be permitted to be used in the
manner sought for. Admittedly the Invitation for bids was dated
23.05.2017 and the date of opening of Tender documents was
01.08.2017. The Writ Petition has been preferred by the Petitioner
on 18.05.2018 after nearly a year. There is no indication in the
petition as to the present stage of the contract. The Petitioner
seeks an order to quash the present tender process and for a
direction to utilise the funds earmarked for this project for other
projects to meet the basic need of the people. The tender is for
setting up of Sikkim State Museum at Gangtok, East Sikkim.
There is not a single reason cited as to why or how setting up of a
museum is not in public interest. It is a policy decision of the
Respondent to set up this museum. Such policies are not open to
W.P. (PIL) No. 06 of 2018
Shri Puran Alley vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Judicial review except when it violates constitutional or statutory
provisions which grounds are not available before us in the
present petition. The executive is tasked with the primary
responsibility for formulating Governmental policies and to carry
out its execution and the Writ Court cannot interfere unless the
policy is opposed to constitutional and statutory provisions or
suffers
from
manifest
arbitrariness,
unreasonableness
or
absurdity. Interference by Courts on mere allegation smelling foul
play at every level of administration is unhealthy and bound to
make governance impossible. A public spirited individual must
not only make such allegations that the act of the Government
smacks of arbitrariness, unreasonableness or illegality but must
necessarily substantiate the said allegations. Unsubstantiated
allegations adversely affect the opposite party and are evidently
unfair. There must be a real and genuine public interest involved
in the litigation and not only an adventure of a law graduate, who
in spite of a professional degree chooses not to practice law and
claims to be unemployed youth instead. Public Interest Litigation
remedy cannot be resorted to unless it is bonafide. The
Petitioner’s evidently irrational perception that setting up of a
museum is non-productive cannot invoke the jurisdiction of this
Court to go roving into the process of the tender. The expression
‘Public Interest Litigation’ means a legal action in a Court of law
for the enforcement of public interest or general interest in which
the public or a class of the community has pecuniary interest or
W.P. (PIL) No. 06 of 2018
Shri Puran Alley vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
some interest by which their legal rights or liabilities are affected.
The Supreme Court in re: Peoples Union for Democratic Rights &
others vs. Union of India & Ors.1 defined ‘Public Interest Litigation’
and observed:
“Public
Interest
Litigation
is
a
cooperative
or
collaborative effort by the Petitioner, the State or public
authority
and
the
Judiciary
to
secure
observance
of
constitutional or basic human rights, benefits and privileges
upon poor, downtrodden and vulnerable sections of the
society.”
5.
We are afraid we cannot agree with the perception of the
Petitioner that setting up of a State museum is not in public
interest and that the funds should be diverted for other public
purposes.
6.
In the circumstances the Writ Petition is dismissed in
limine.
7.
No orders as to costs.
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
to/
(1982) 3 SCC 235
Sd/Judge
Sd/Chief Justice
24.05.2018
24.05.2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review