The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. 03.2016 and after agreement of salc datcd 06.08.2014. The learned trial Court has lost sight of thc survey conducted by the Survey al:rd Land Records, Nizamabad on 2l.12.2O I5 in respect of survey Nos.28, 88O, 898 and also lost sight of para No.5 of the ) \ affidavit in IA.No.264 of 2023 and u,ronglf arrivccl at a conclusion that there is no serious prejudice or inlury r.t'hich rvould cause to the petitioners-responde nt Nos.I and 2 plaintrfls. As the suit is filed for specifrc performancc o[ contract, it is t ]ic l)ctitioners who have to prove their case and morcover, appoilltrrlcnt of Advocate Commissioner came to be filed on 22.08.2023 $,hen thc suit is coming up for defendant's further et,idcncc. The rcasoning of ttre learned trial Court is improper and pen ersc rvhich requires interference of this Court and the order passed thercon is tiable to I I be set aside and is accordingly set asidc,
20. CRP No.3129 of 2023 is allos.cd and the ordcr passed by the learned t Additional District Judge at Kamarcddf in tA.No.264 of I { BItMR,.,I 14/14 cRr, 3129 2023 2023 in OS.No-S of 2016, dated 25.09.2023 is s:t aside and consequently thc petilion stands dismissed. Interim Orders if any shall stands vacated. ,4iscellancous apPlication / s stands closed. iD/- MOHD.ISMAIL )UTY REGISTRAR ,p- \ //TRUE COPY// To, { I 'l the lAdditronal Drstrict Judge at Kamareddy District 2 ()ne CC to Sr D fMadhava Rao, Advocate [OPUC] 3 One CC to Sn K Ravi Mahender, Advocate [OpUCl 4 Two CD Copres I S.\,I'SI I DATED: 3010112026 I, liiE S 14 o (J I ? ,t !spere CRP.No.3129 of 2023 as a )n rfi *
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
r[ 34481
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE THIRTIETH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO:3129 OF 2023
PetitionunderArticle22TofConstitutionoflndiaaggrievedbytheorderdated
25.og.2o23passedinl.A,No264of2023ino.S.No.5of2016onthefileofthe
Court of the I Additional Distrrct Judge at Kamareddy District'
Between:
I
R/o
Punna Rajeshwar, S/o Late Balaiah aged about 56 years' Occ: Business'
H. No. 5-3-435, Vidya Nagar Colorry, Kamareddy Town and Dist'
R/o
Mohd. Sohail, S/o tr4ohd Nayeem. aged about 29 years' Occ- Business'
H. No. 1-3-1 17, Old Bus Stanci Kamareddy Town and Dist.
... Petiti oners/Respondents/Plai
ntiffs
AND
Smt. G. Swaroopa Rant. W/o Rarra Krishna Reddy' Aged
about 61 years' R/o
FlatNo.301/B,FortuneExotrcaHUDAEnclave,JubileeHillsHyderabad
36 years' Occ:
G. Abhilash Reddy, S/o G Rama Krishna Reddy Aged about
Exotica'
Private Employee, Permanent resident of Flat No 301/B Fortune
Sri G
HUDA Enclave, Jubilee Hills, tlyderabad Rep by his GPA holder
years' Occ:
Rama Krishna Reddy S/o Narayana Reddy, Aged about 62
Jubilee Hills
Business, R/o Flat No. 301/8, Fortune Exotica, HUDA Enclave'
Hyderabad-
Responden ts/Petitioners/Defendant No'1 and 2
M/s. VedKiran lnfra Prolccts. having its office at 901' Amsri
Secunderabad, rep
Apartments'
try lts Director NallaSudhakar' S/o Late
NallaVenkatesham
NallaSudhakar'S/oLateNallaVenkatesham'agedabout55yearsocc.
901' Amsri
Director of M/s VedKiratr lnfra Projects' havrng its office at
Apartments, Secunder abaci
...Respondents/Respondents/Defendant No' 3 and 4
I.A. NO: 5 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circ i nstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may b( l)leased to extend the
orders passed by this court in lA No 1 of 2023 in CRp tJ r 3129 of 2023 dated
20 10.2023.
Counsel for the Petitioners : Sri D Madhava Rao
Counsel for the Respondent No. 2 : Sri. K Ravi Mahender
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON,BLE JUSTICE B.R.MN)HUSUDHAN RAO
CTVIL REVISION PETI TION.NO. 3129 0F 2023
DATED:3oth JANUARY, 2026
BET\IIEEN:
Punna Rajeshwar, S/o.Late Balaiah and Another
... Petitioners-Respondents-Plaintiffs
AND
Smt.G.Swaroopa Rani, W/o'Rama Krishna Reddy'
Aged about 61 years, R/o'Flat No'310/B'
Ffrtune Exotica HUDA Enclave, Jubilee Hills'
I
HyderabadandAnother'
...Respondents-PetitionersDefendant Nos l and 2
M/s.Vedkiran Infra Projects, having its office at 90 i '
alsri Apartments, Secunderabad, rep by its Director
NallaSuihakar, S/o.Late Nalla Venkatesham
and Another.
... Respondents-ResPondents -
Defendant Nos.3 and 4
ORDER
1.
This Memorandum of Civil Revision Petition is liled
under Article
passed by the
227 of the Constitution of India assailing the order
in tA'No 264 of 2023
learned I Additional District Judge at Kamareddy
in OS No.5 of 2016, dated 25'09 '2023'
)
)
BRMR,J
cRP 3 t29 2023
2.
Petitioners are the respondent Nos.1 Lnd 2_ptaintiffs.
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 are petitioners-defendanl
respondent Nos.ll and 4 are respondent Nos.3
\os. i and 2 and
anc 1 in IA.No.264 of
2023 in OS No.5 of 20 t6.
3.1. Respondent Nos.l and 2_petitioners_defendan r Nos.
filed IA No.264 ol 2023 under Order 26 Rule
9 of rl e Civil procedure
code, 19o8 (for short'cpCJ to appoint Advocate
direction to ger rhe land in survey Nos.2g, ggo
Villagc is sun.e.ved and demarcated with
Surveyor and u'ith ar-rthenticated survey
1 and 2 have
Ccr Lmissroner u.ith a
and { 9g of Kamaraddl
the hel r of Government
records, to ocarise the entire
accounted ancl unaccounted land of the petitioners .espondent
and 2 hercin) irr the above said survey numbers
petitioners ro localisc Acs.07_00 guntas
anc rccounted rand of
of land alr:ady, conve_yed to
respondent Nos. 1 and 2-plaintiffs (petitioners
surve_v number under Exs.B4 to
Nos. I
hereir) in the abovc said
86 and a_lso to loc: ise three distinct
preces oI land covered by Ex.A5_Development
I greement, dated
19.03.2016 ancl also to localise suit
and claimed bv
schedule
respondent Nos. I and 2_ptaintiffs (petitioners
hcri in) by preparing
sketch and to fik: report.
3.2. GPA hoider of respondent Nos. 1 and 2_pr:ri
ioners_ de fen dan t
I and 2 br". name G.Ramakrishna Reddy frlec
his affidavit and
Nos.
3lL4
BRMR,J
cRP 3r 29 2023
contended that the respondent Nos'I and 2-petitioners-defendant
Nos.l and 2 filed written statement in the suit on 08 O6'2018 and
categorically pleaded that they are in effective possession and
enjoyment as absolute owners over Acs'27 -2O'06 guntas of contiguous
piece of land in survey Nos.28, 88O and 898 of Kamareddy Village and
out of which Acs. i3.02 guntas comprising Acs'O2-O6 guntas in survey
No.28, Acs.05-24 guntas in survey 88O, and Acs O5-12 guntas in
survey No.898 was accounted in their names in the revenue records
and the balance land is yet to be accounted though they are in
effective possession and enjoyment of the entire land to an extent of
Acs.27 -2O.06 guntas. Petitioners-respondent Nos' i and 2-plaintiffs
are
aware of the said fact and entered into agreement of sale with them
22.Cl6.2013 (Ex.B1) to purchase entire Acs' 13-02 guntas
on
They have
l and
conveyed Acs.O7-OO guntas of land in favour of respondent Nos
2 and their associates out of accounted extent and the balance
Acs.06-O2 guntas in the above said survey numbers are located
three different distinct places i.e., Acs.oo-o6 guntas in survey
Ac.O-24 guntas in survey Nos'880, and Acs 05- 12 gr'rntas
No 28,
in survey
No.898 and survey was conducted in pursuance of Ex'B3 notice
15.12.2015, after the survey and demarcation' respondent
at
dated
Nos' 1 and
2-plaintiffs (petitioners herein) have withdrau'n from the suit
agreement and subsequently filed a false suit'
l
)
4lt4
BRMR,J
cRP 3t29 2023
3'3 Petitioner No. -respondent No. r -praintiff No is examined as
PW.
1 and co-purchaser under Ex.Bl-Agreeme r 1 of Sale, dated
22.06.2013 is examined as pW.2 and they admitr r
guntas claimed by the ptaintifls (petitioners
hereir ) is the same land
what is shown in Ex.A5-Development Agreement,
Acs.06-O2 guntas is locared at three different
C that Acs.O6_02
<
ated 1g.O3.20i6
locatic r s away from each
survey number rvhich is shown in yellow colour
in lx.B7_sketch and
prayed to appoint Advocate Commissioner.
4.
Respondenr Nos_ 1 and 2-plaintiffs (petitior
counter and contcnded that they have led evidence
evidence is in process, while DW. 1 entered
ers herein) filed
r nd the defendant
into the witness box and
was cross-exatlirred at iength the case is posted
for I rrther evidence of
the defendant, at thelt time, appointment of Advocar
t Commissioner is
hled. In a suit for specific performance there is a i
adjudicated, it has to be rvithin the terms
and :onditions of the
agreement of sale. DW. I has firled unauthenticated
the agreed property to be sold to the plaintiffs
nited scope to be
1 lan showing as
is no at one place but
at diflerent places. Thc scope of Advocate Comrr i ;sioner
assist any pany to collect evidence. Responder
petitioners-defendant Nos. I and 2 have
is not to
I Nos. I and 2-
agreed to s r ll the land to the
plaintifls (petirioners herein) with definite bounc
Development Agreement was executed
./-
if
ar5, that a part
subseqr- ( nt
to the suit
BRMR,J
cRP 3129 2023
agreement giving the same boundaries and prayed to dismiss the
same.
5.
The learned trial Court after going through the material on
record has allowed IA.No.264 of 2023 uide order dated 25.O9.2023 and
appointed Sri P. Srinivas Reddy Advocate, Kamareddy to identify the
exact location of the property covered in survey Nos.28/U, 880/U and
898 of Kamareddy town and also hnd out whether the above three
survey numbers are single contiguous (adjoining) piece of land or not
with the assistance of Mandal Surveyor, Tahsildar Office, Kamareddy
with revenue records and the Commissioner fee is lxed at Rs.5,00O/payable by respondent Nos. 1 and 2-petitioners-defendant Nos.l and 2.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the learned trial
Court has not properly appreciated the facts of the case in proper
prospective and reached to an erroneous conclusion and allorved the
application. The learned trial Court failed to see that appointment of
Advocate Commissioner is hled in the suit at the time of further
evidence of the defendants and also ignored the power of the Court
under Section 151 of CPC. The learned Judge failed to appreciare the
fact that the question with respect to the boundaries of three survey
numbers i.e.,28,88O and 898 has never been raised before entering
into the agreement of sale and also failed to recognise the scope of the
\
6/t4
BRMR,J
cllr, 3129 2023
appointment of Advocate Commissioner and prayec to set aside the
order.
7.
Learned counsel for respondent Nos.1 a: I 2-petitioners-
defendant Nos. 1 and 2 contended that PW.1 and P\/ 2 have admitted
that Acs.O6-02 guntas which is claimed by them is tlr same land what
is shown in Ex.A5-Development Agreement, dated 19.03.2016. The
learned trial Court has properly appreciated the fact, of the case and
rightly allowed the application, no interference is czrll <1 for and prayed
to dismiss the ORP.
8.
Heard counsel on record, perused the materia
9.
Now the point for consideration is : Whether tr l order passed by
the learned tnal Court suffers from an.v perversity r illegality? If so,
does it require interference o[ this Court?
10. Petitioners-respondent Nos.1 and 2-plaintifl-s rave filed suit for
specihc performance of contrac[ against responder t ;-defendant Nos. 1
to 4 contending that defendant Nos.1 and 2 (respc r clent Nos.1 and 2
herein) owned Acs- 13-OO guntas and odd in r; rrwey No.28/part,
880/part and 898, they agreed to sell part o[ it ;i rd sold Acs.O7-00
guntas through registcred sale deed in the name ,r' vI/s. Sri Sai Shiva
Developers of r,r'hich the petitioner Nos. I and 2 ar<'. I artngrs apart from
7lt4
BRMR.J
cRP_3129-2023
others and for the remaining extent of land i.e., Acs.06-02 guntas
(Acs.O-O6 guntas in survey No.28/part, 24 guntas in survey No.880
and Acs.05-12 guntas in survey No.898) have entered into agreement
of sale on 06.08.2014 and the total value is Rs.78 [,akhs per acre and
they have paid Rs. 1O Lakhs as part consideration. The relief claimed in
the suit is to declare the Development Agreement, dated 19.O3.2016
entered by defendant Nos.1 and 2 (respondent Nos.l and 2 herein)
with defendant Nos.3 and 4 (respondent Nos.3 and 4 herein) as null,
void and not binding and to direct the defendants (respondents hereinl
to execute registered sale deed in their favour in terms of sale
agreement, dated 06.08.20 14.
1.
Respondent Nos. I and 2-defendant Nos. 1 and 2 h,ave ftled their
writlen statement in the suit and contended that they have executed
three registered sale deeds to an extent of Acs.07-00 guntas in the
name of the nominees of the petitioners-plaintiffs. Petitionersplaintiffs have obtained signatures of these defendants (respondent
Nos. I and 2 herein) on a fresh Agreement of Sale in the name o[ the
plaintiffs (petitioners herein) representing tJ.at it pertains to balance
Acs.06.02 guntas accounted land in Survey No.28/E to an extent o[
Ac.0.O6 guntas; SurveSz No.8SO/U to an extent of Ac.O-24 guntas;
Survey No.898 to an extent of Acs.OS-12 guntas. The delendants
(rgspondent Nos- 1 and 2 herein) have subscribed their signaturcs on
)
8lL4
BRMR,J
cRt) 3129 2023
the Agreement of Sale dated 06.08.2014 in good fai h. It is further
stated in the v,ritten statement that on the itP rlication of the
defendants (respondent Nos. 1 and 2 herein) Inspect,r of Survey Land
Records deputed Assistant Director Land Records, Ir i ramabad and he
has served notice dated 15.12.2015 fixing 9.3O A.M : I 21.12.2015 for
survey and demarcation of the land of these defen,l Lnts (respondent
Nos. I and 2 herein) in Survey Nos.28, 880 & 898 o[ .amareddy. It is
clear from the demarcation that entire unaccountr:rl Acs.2.32 guntas
in Survey No.28 belong to these defendants (respor r ent Nos. I and 2
herein) which is abutting the Ramreddy Road on rti ltast. and rest of
the unaccounted land forming part of Survey Nos.S8i lk 898 Iocated in
the West of it. The plaintiff (petitioner herein) was ) osent during the
said demarcation and was au,are of the localizir i rn made by the
Survey Authorities and has withdra',\'n from tht sale transaction
voluntarily foregoing advance amount paid by them r rd thereafter filed
suit in OS.No.S of 2016.
12. On perusal of the agreement of sale dated Ot . )8.2014 executed
in favour of the petltioners by respondent Nos. 1 a r I 2 u,hich shows
the total extent as Acs.06-O2 guntas adjacent to cz ch other and the
schedule of the property with boundarics is as undc r
9/14
BRMR,J
cRP_3129-2023
SCHEDULE OF PROPERfi
1) Land bearing Sy.No.28, extent of Acs.O-06 gts.,
2) Land beating Sy.No.880/ extent ofAcs. 0-24 gts.,
3) Land bearing Sy.No.898, extent ofAcs. 5-12 gts.,
Which includes RCC Cum CT Roof House No.1-5-94,
Grand total extent of Acs. 6-02 ets..
The iength of the said lands comes to 530.O feets
approximately towards Eastern Boundry i.e., facing to
Ramareddy Road, situated at Kamareddy town, Nizamabad
District, the said landed property located in one Boundaqz as
cited below:
North
South
East
West
Land ofVendors sold to M/s.Sri Sai
Shiva Developers
Land of Neighbours
Ramareddy Road
Vendors remaining iald
13. Respondent Nos. I and 2-petitioners-defendant Nos.l and 2
have entered into Deveiopment Agreement on 19.03.2016 with
respondent Nos.3 and 4 in respect of Acs.O6-02 guntas and the
boundaries are as under:
SCHEDULE OF PROPERTY - A
All that parr and parcel of land bearing Sy.No.28/a
admeasuring Ac.0.O6 guntas, bounded by :NORTH: Land of M/s. SRI SAI SHIVA DEVELOPERS
SOUTH :- Land of first party
EAST :- RamareddSr Road
WEST:- Land oI M/s. SRI SAI SHIVA DEVtrLOPERS
)
)
\
BRMR,J
t0/14
cRP 3129 2023
S CHEDULE OF PROPERTY - B
Alt that part and parcel of land bearing Sy.No-ttt'r admeasunng
Ac.O.24 guntas, bounded by :-
NORTH :- Lald of First Party
SOUTH :- Land of First Party
EAST :- Land of M/s. SRI SAI SHIVA DEVELOPF I S
WEST :- Sy.No.880/Part
SCHEDULE OF PROPERTY - (]
AIl that part and parcel of land bearing Sy.No.8! 3 admeasuring
Ac.5.12 guntas, bounded by :NORTH: Land of hrst party
SOUTH :- Residential houses
EAST :- Ramareddy Road
WEST:- Sy.No.894 and Sy.No.897
14. Learned counsel for the respondent Nos. I ;, ,ri 2 has filed
Ex.87 sketch showing the location of sold land, ur: scounted land
and suit Iald in survey Nos.28, 88O and 898 of Kanr ,redd1'Village.
5. The learned trial Court observed in the o r ler that PW, 1
admitted in his cross-examination that the suit sct edule property
as shown in Ex.A1 are not single contiguous pie'ct of lard but it
comprised three distinct pieces of land
The furtht :bsen'ation of
/
the learned trial Court is as under:
/
tu14
BRMR,J
cRP_3 r29_2023
b| Now the core questioD. is whether the suit schedule
property covered in survey No. 28/E, 880 and 898 are single
contiguous piece of land or not?
cl On careful perusal of the e[tire material on record,
one thing very much appears that both the parties are seriously
disputing about the actual and exact location of the suit schedule
property covered in three Survey numbers, therefore, if the
advocate commissioner is appointed for location and
identifrcation of the property covered in the above said suit
suwey numbers, undoubtedly, the truth will come out, whether
the suit schedule property covered in the above said three survey
numbers are contiguous piece of tand or not. Moreover, the
advocate commissioner report ard plan would play vital role to
determine the controversy between the parties. It is therefore, on
proper adjudication of the matter ald to remove controversy
involved in the suit, this Court appoint an advocate
comrnissioner to identify the exact location of the suit schedule
property covered in the said three survey numbers i.e. 2a/U,
880, 898 situated at Kamareddy town. If the advocate
commissioner is appointed for location of the property covered in
three survey numbers, there is no serous prejudice or injury
would cause to the respondents/ plarntiffs.
8. By conslderlng all the aspects and taking into
consideration, this Court inclined to consider the request of the
petitioners. Therefore, the petition desenes to be allowed.
16. Ex.B3 is the notice issued by lnspector of Survey and Land
Records, Nizamabad for demarcation of survey Nos.28, 88O, 898 of
Kamareddy. On perusal of the said document respondent No. 1petitioner No. l-defendant No. 1 made an application in the month
tzlL4
BRMR,J
cRP 3I29-2023
of August, 2O15 for demarcation of the above said su. t:y numbers.
Survey date is fixcd as 21.12.2015 and the notice ii issucd to all
the stake holders including adjacent lald owners.
17. It is apt to refer para No.S of the afhdavit (i-e. 1A.No.264 of
2023) u,hich reads as under:
"l submit that the said factum was fully once agarr onfirmed
by the sun,ey authority, when the suweyor has i r fact with
the help of auttrenticated survey records in the tr tsence of
Plaintiffs and their associates has conducti I survey
pursuant to Ex.B3 Notice dt.15.12.2015. I submi: that after
the said surwey ald demarcation, the Plaintitfs rnd their
associates having withdrawn from the suit agreer€ rt ol sale,
subsequently taking advantage of steep rise in th,r ;alue, the
Petitioners herein came up with above falsc sllit b]'
suppressing the real facts once aga:n by fa-1scl1, icscribiug
the entire suit larrd in three survey numbers as ( onliguous
piece of lald".
18. As per Ex.B3 coupled with the above said pa - gocs to show'
[hat land in survey Nos.28, 880, 898 is surveyed ar ] clemarcated.
When the land of the respondent Nos. 1 anc 2-petitionersdel'endant Nos.1 and 2 is already surveyed and r , rnarcated, the
question of again appointing an Advocate Commissi ner to localise
Acs.07-0O guntas of land already conveyed to M/; Sri Sai Shiva
Developers and to localise three distinct pieces o1'l, nd covered b1,
t3/ t4
BRMR,J
cRP 3t29_2023
Development Agreement, dated 19.O3.2O16 and to localise the suit
scheduie property by preparing sketch and filing report is
unjustihed.
19. As per Ex.B3, notice dated 15.12.20i5 survey was conducted
oo 21.12.2015 much prior to Developmcnt Agreement dated
19.03.2016 and after agreement of salc datcd 06.08.2014. The
learned trial Court has lost sight of thc survey conducted by the
Survey al:rd Land Records, Nizamabad on 2l.12.2O I5 in respect of
survey Nos.28, 88O, 898 and also lost sight of para No.5 of the
)
\
affidavit in IA.No.264 of 2023 and u,ronglf arrivccl at a conclusion
that there is no serious prejudice or inlury r.t'hich rvould cause to
the petitioners-responde nt Nos.I and 2 plaintrfls. As the suit is
filed for specifrc performancc o[ contract, it is t ]ic l)ctitioners who
have to prove their case and morcover, appoilltrrlcnt of Advocate
Commissioner came to be filed on 22.08.2023 $,hen thc suit is
coming up for defendant's further et,idcncc. The rcasoning of ttre
learned trial Court is improper and pen ersc rvhich requires
interference of this Court and the order passed thercon is tiable to
I
I
be set aside and is accordingly set asidc,
20.
CRP No.3129 of 2023 is allos.cd and the ordcr passed by the
learned t Additional District Judge at Kamarcddf in tA.No.264 of
I
{
BItMR,.,I
14/14
cRr, 3129 2023
2023 in OS.No-S of 2016, dated 25.09.2023 is s:t aside and
consequently thc petilion stands dismissed.
Interim Orders if any shall stands vacated. ,4iscellancous
apPlication / s stands closed.
iD/- MOHD.ISMAIL
)UTY REGISTRAR
,p- \
//TRUE COPY//
I ECTION OFFICER
To,
{
I
'l the lAdditronal Drstrict Judge at Kamareddy District
2 ()ne CC to Sr D fMadhava Rao, Advocate [OPUC]
3 One CC to Sn K Ravi Mahender, Advocate [OpUCl
4 Two CD Copres
I
S.\,I'SI
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 3010112026
I, liiE S 14
o
(J
ORDER
I
?
,t
!spere
CRP.No.3129 of 2023
ALLOWING THE CRP.
as a
)n rfi
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review