Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed
by
SHAYNA
KADRI
2026:CGHC:1034
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 8597 of 2023
1 - Punaram Sahu S/o Late Govind Sahu Aged About 64 Years R/o
Haldi, Ward No. 51, Post Office Mohara, Police Station Lalbagh, Tahsil
And District Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
... Petitioner
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Collector, District Rajnandgaon
(C.G.)
2 - Chief Executive Officer Janpad Panchayat, Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
... Respondent(s)
(Cause-title is taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
:
Mr. J. K. Gupta, Advocate
For State
:
Mr. Hariom Rai, Panel Lawyer
SB- Hon'ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order on Board
07/01/2026
1.
The petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking following reliefs :-
“10.1- That the Hon'ble Court may be kind enough
to call the record of the petitioner.
10.2- That the Hon'ble Court may be kind enough to
issue a writ of mandamus and to command
the respondents to comply the circular dated
05.03.2008.
10.3- That the Hon'ble Court may be kind enough to
grant regularization to the petitioner from 138-2008 till the date of retirement 30.06.2021
and to direct the respondents to pay the
regular pay scale to the petitioner from 13-82008 till the age of 62 years i.e. 30.06.2021.
10.4- That the Hon'ble Court may be kind enough to
direct the respondents to pay the gratuity and
pension with interest.
10.5- That the Hon'ble Court may be kind enough to
pass any appropriate writ, order or direction in
the circumstances of the case.”
2.
Facts of the case, as projected in the writ petition, are that, the
petitioner was initially engaged by the respondent Department as
a daily-wage Tractor Driver prior to 31.08.1987. The petitioner has
been in continuous service under respondent No. 2 since his
initial engagement and has been discharging his duties diligently
and without interruption. His salary has regularly been paid by the
respondents and credited into his bank account, thereby
acknowledging the continuity and subsistence of his service.
Subsequently, vide order dated 31.08.1987, the post of Tractor
Driver held by the petitioner was abolished. However, without any
break in service, respondent No. 2 appointed the petitioner on
casual/contingency wages with effect from 01.09.1987 and
assigned him duties as a Vehicle Driver. Thereafter, the petitioner
continued to perform duties of driving departmental vehicles,
including LMV vehicles, and was formally assigned such duties
vide order dated 03.11.2007. Thus, from 01.09.1987 till his date of
superannuation on 30.06.2021, the petitioner continuously worked
as a Driver under the respondent Department.
The State
Government, through the General Administration Department,
issued a circular dated 05.03.2008, followed by another circular
dated 16.08.2012, providing for regularization of daily-wage, workcharged, and contingency-paid employees who were appointed
prior to 31.12.1988. Clause ‘A’ of the circular dated 05.03.2008
specifically mandates regularization of such employees and does
not prescribe any requirement of educational qualification for
those appointed prior to 31.12.1988.
Despite the petitioner
squarely falling within the ambit of the said circular, the
respondents failed to regularize his services. On the contrary,
several similarly situated employees junior to the petitioner were
granted the benefit of regularization by the respondents, thereby
violating the principle of parity and equality enshrined under
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Aggrieved by the
inaction of the respondents, the petitioner approached this Court
by filing W.P.(S) No. 6080/2018. The said writ petition was
disposed of on 17.09.2018 with a direction to the respondents to
scrutinize the petitioner’s claim and decide the same in light of the
circular dated 05.03.2008. However, when the respondents failed
to comply with the said order within the stipulated period, the
petitioner was constrained to file Contempt Petition No. 198/2019.
In the contempt proceedings, the respondents submitted a reply
stating that the petitioner’s claim could not be considered due to
non-availability of sanctioned vacant posts, while simultaneously
stating that steps were being taken to increase the number of
posts. Thereafter, the petitioner again approached this Court by
filing W.P.(S) No. 6166/2019 challenging the respondents’ order
dated 03.04.2019. The said writ petition was disposed of on
14.08.2019 with a direction to the respondents to take an
appropriate decision in accordance with the State Government
policy dated 05.03.2008. Despite repeated judicial directions, the
respondents again failed to comply, compelling the petitioner to
file Contempt Petition No. 173/2020. During the pendency of the
contempt proceedings, the respondents passed the impugned
order dated 14.10.2019 rejecting the petitioner’s claim for
regularization on the sole ground that he did not possess the
requisite educational qualification for the post of Tractor Driver.
Based on the said rejection order, the contempt petition was
disposed of with liberty to the petitioner to avail appropriate
remedy. Meanwhile, the petitioner superannuated on 30.06.2021
while still being treated as a daily-wage/contingency-paid
employee and was denied all retiral benefits, including pension,
gratuity, and other consequential benefits, which would have
accrued had his services been regularized.
The petitioner
contends that the impugned order dated 14.10.2019 is wholly
arbitrary, illegal, and contrary to the express provisions of the
circular dated 05.03.2008, particularly Clause ‘A’ thereof, and that
the respondents have acted in blatant disregard of statutory rules,
binding government policy, and repeated directions issued by this
Court.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner was
appointed much prior to the cut-off date of 31.12.1988 and,
therefore, his case is squarely governed by Clause ‘A’ of the
General Administration Department circular dated 05.03.2008. It is
emphatically
contended
that
the
said
clause
mandates
regularization of daily-wage and contingency-paid employees
appointed before 31.12.1988 and does not impose any condition
relating to educational qualification. Hence, the rejection of the
petitioner’s claim on the ground of lack of educational qualification
is ex facie illegal and unsustainable. It is further submitted that
the respondents have completely misapplied the provisions of the
circular dated 05.03.2008 by erroneously invoking conditions
applicable to employees appointed between 01.01.1989 and
31.12.1997, which fall under Clause ‘B’ of the circular. The
petitioner’s appointment being prior to 31.12.1988, the application
of such conditions is wholly misconceived and contrary to the
policy decision of the State Government. Learned counsel further
submits that the petitioner rendered uninterrupted service for
nearly 35 years till his superannuation and that his engagement
was at worst irregular and not illegal. In view of the settled law laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Secretary, State of
Karnataka vs. Umadevi (2006) 4 SCC 1, Jaggo vs. Union of
India, and Dharam Singh & Others vs. State of U.P., the
petitioner is entitled to regularization as a one-time measure,
particularly when he has worked for more than ten years against
sanctioned posts without the protection of any interim court order.
It is also contended that the respondents themselves had
proposed regularization of the petitioner vide proposal dated
04.06.2009,
which
clearly
demonstrates
the
respondents’
acknowledgment of the petitioner’s eligibility. However, the said
proposal was never implemented without assigning any cogent
reason, thereby rendering the respondents’ action arbitrary and
discriminatory.
4.
Learned counsel further submits that under Section 70(1) of the
Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993, the competent
authority is empowered to create and increase posts as per
administrative necessity. The plea of non-availability of sanctioned
posts, therefore, is untenable, especially when similarly situated
employees have already been regularized by the respondents by
exercising the said statutory powers.
It is further argued that
denial of regularization to the petitioner, while extending the same
benefit to similarly placed employees, violates Articles 14 and 16
of the Constitution of India. The petitioner has been deprived not
only of regular pay and service benefits during his tenure but also
of retiral benefits post superannuation, which amounts to grave
injustice. Learned counsel lastly submits that even though the
petitioner has already retired on 30.06.2021, he is entitled to
notional regularization with all consequential benefits, including
fixation of pay, arrears, pensionary benefits, and gratuity, in terms
of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dharam
Singh & Others and Shripal & Another. Accordingly, the
impugned order dated 14.10.2019 deserves to be quashed and
the petitioner’s services deserve to be regularized with all
consequential benefits in the interest of justice.
5.
Learned State Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents
submits that the writ petition is devoid of merit and is liable to be
dismissed. It is contended that the petitioner was never appointed
against a sanctioned regular post and continued only as a dailywage/contingency-paid employee throughout his service tenure.
Mere long continuance in service does not confer any vested or
enforceable right upon the petitioner to claim regularization as a
matter of course, particularly in the absence of compliance with
the prescribed recruitment rules. Learned State Counsel further
submits that the regularization policy of the State Government,
including the circular dated 05.03.2008, cannot be applied
mechanically and is subject to fulfillment of eligibility conditions,
availability of sanctioned posts, and suitability of the employee. It
is
argued
that
the
petitioner
was
found
unsuitable
for
regularization as he did not possess the requisite educational
qualification prescribed for the post of Tractor Driver/Driver, and
therefore the competent authority rightly rejected his claim by
passing the order dated 14.10.2019 after due consideration. It is
further submitted that the respondents have acted strictly in
accordance with law and policy, and no arbitrariness or illegality
can be attributed to the impugned order. The respondents have
also taken bona fide steps for creation and enhancement of posts,
which necessarily involves a multi-stage administrative process,
and delay in such process cannot be a ground to compel
regularization contrary to statutory rules. Learned State Counsel
submits that the judgments relied upon by the petitioner, including
Umadevi
and
subsequent
decisions,
do
not
mandate
regularization in every case of long service and, on the contrary,
caution against backdoor entry into public service. Since the
petitioner retired as a daily-wage employee and never held a
regular post, he is not entitled to claim post-retirement
regularization or consequential pensionary benefits. It is lastly
submitted that the petitioner has already been considered multiple
times pursuant to directions of this Court and his claim has been
rejected by a reasoned order. Therefore, no further interference is
warranted in exercise of writ jurisdiction, and the writ petition
deserves to be dismissed.
6.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have also
perused the documents enclosed along with the petition.
7.
The core issue which arises for consideration before this Court is
whether the petitioner, merely on account of long continuance in
service and on the strength of the circular dated 05.03.2008, can
claim regularization with retrospective effect and consequential
monetary
and
retiral
benefits,
particularly
after
his
superannuation.
8.
This Court finds that the circular dated 05.03.2008 is an executive
policy decision which provides a framework for consideration of
regularization subject to fulfillment of conditions such as
availability of sanctioned posts, suitability of the employee, and
compliance with applicable service rules. The said circular does
not confer an automatic or indefeasible right of regularization.
Regularization under such policy remains a discretionary
administrative exercise and cannot be enforced by issuance of a
writ of mandamus unless a clear statutory right is established.
9.
It is evident from the record that the petitioner’s claim was
considered by the respondents on multiple occasions pursuant to
directions issued by this Court in earlier writ petitions and
contempt proceedings. Ultimately, the competent authority passed
a reasoned order dated 14.10.2019 rejecting the petitioner’s claim
for regularization on the ground of non-fulfillment of requisite
eligibility conditions, including suitability for appointment on a
regular post. This Court does not find any procedural illegality,
perversity, or mala fide in the decision-making process adopted by
the respondents.
10.
The contention of the petitioner that Clause ‘A’ of the circular
dated 05.03.2008 completely exempts employees appointed prior
to 31.12.1988 from all eligibility conditions, including educational
qualification, cannot be accepted in its absolute form. The circular
cannot be read in isolation or in derogation of statutory
recruitment rules governing the post. Executive instructions
cannot override statutory rules nor can they compel regularization
in the absence of sanctioned posts or prescribed qualifications.
11.
It is also significant to note that the petitioner is seeking
regularization with retrospective effect from 13.08.2008 and
consequential monetary benefits till his retirement. In this regard,
the law is well settled that retrospective regularization, promotion,
or grant of service benefits is impermissible unless expressly
provided under the rules.
12.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Government of
West Bengal & Ors. vs. Dr. Amal Satpathi & Ors., 2024 SCC
OnLine SC 3512, has categorically held that no retrospective
service benefits can be granted from a date when an employee
was not borne in the cadre, as such action would disturb settled
rights and is contrary to service jurisprudence and it was held
thus:-
“19. It is a well settled principle that
promotion becomes effective from the
date it is granted, rather than from the
date a vacancy arises or the post is
created. While the Courts have
recognized the right to be considered
for promotion as not only a statutory
right but also a fundamental right, there
is no fundamental right to the promotion
itself. In this regard, we may gainfully
refer to a recent decision of this Court
in the case of Bihar State Electricity
Board v. Dharamdeo Das, wherein it
was observed as follows:
“18. It is no longer res integra that a
promotion is effective from the date
it is granted and not from the date
when a vacancy occurs on the
subject post or when the post itself
is created. No doubt, a right to be
considered for promotion has been
treated by courts not just as a
statutory right but as a fundamental
right, at the same time, there is no
fundamental right to promotion
itself. In this context, we may
profitably cite a recent decision in
Ajay Kumar Shukla v. Arvind Rai10
where, citing earlier precedents in
Director, Lift Irrigation Corporation
Ltd. v. Pravat Kiran Mohanty and Ajit
Singh v. State of Punjab12, a threeJudge Bench observed thus:
41. This Court, time and
again, has laid emphasis on right to
be considered for promotion to be a
fundamental right, as was held by
K. Ramaswamy, J., in Director, Lift
Irrigation Corpn. Ltd. v. Pravat Kiran
Mohanty in para 4 of the report
which is reproduced below:
‘4…….
There
is
no
fundamental right to promotion, but
an employee has only right to be
considered for promotion, when it
arises, in accordance with relevant
rules. From this perspective in our
view the conclusion of the High
Court that the gradation list
prepared by the corporation is in
violation of the right of respondentwrit petitioner to equality enshrined
under Article 14 read with Article 16
of the Constitution, and the
respondent-writ
petitioner
was
unjustly denied of the same is
obviously unjustified.’
42. A Constitution Bench in Ajit
Singh v. State of Punjab, laying
emphasis on Article 14 and Article
16(1) of the Constitution of India
held that if a person who satisfies
the eligibility and the criteria for
promotion but still is not considered
for promotion, then there will be
clear
violation
of
his/her's
fundamental right. Jagannadha
Rao, J. speaking for himself and
Anand,
C.J.,
Venkataswami,
Pattanaik, Kurdukar, JJ., observed
the same as follows in paras 22 and
27: ‘Articles 14 and 16(1) : is right
to be considered for promotion a
fundamental right
22. Article 14 and Article 16(1)
are closely connected. They deal
with individual rights of the person.
Article 14 demands that the ‘State
shall not deny to any person
equality before the law or the equal
protection of the laws’. Article 16(1)
issues a positive command that:
‘there shall be equality of
opportunity for all citizens in matters
relating
to
employment
or
appointment to any office under the
State’. It has been held repeatedly
by this Court that clause (1) of
Article 16 is a facet of Article 14 and
that it takes its roots from Article 14.
The said clause particularises the
generality in Article 14 and
identifies, in a constitutional sense
“equality of opportunity” in matters
of employment and appointment to
any office under the State. The word
“employment” being wider, there is
no dispute that it takes within its
fold, the aspect of promotions to
posts above the stage of initial level
of recruitment. Article 16 (1)
provides
to
every
employee
otherwise eligible for promotion or
who comes within the zone of
consideration, a fundamental right
to be “considered” for promotion.
Equal opportunity here means the
right to be “considered” for
promotion. If a person satisfies the
eligibility and zone criteria but is not
considered for promotion, then
there will be a clear infraction of his
fundamental right to be “considered”
for promotion, which is his personal
right. “Promotion” based on equal
opportunity and seniority attached
to such promotion are facets of
fundamental right under Article
16(1).
*
*
*
27. In our opinion, the above
view expressed in Ashok Kumar
Gupta [Ashok Kumar Gupta v. State
of U.P.13, and followed in Jagdish
Lal [Jagdish Lal v. State of
Haryana14, and other cases, if it is
intended to lay down that the right
guaranteed to employees for being
“considered”
for
promotion
according to relevant rules of
recruitment by promotion (i.e.
whether on the basis of seniority or
merit) is only a statutory right and
not a fundamental right, we cannot
accept the proposition. We have
already stated earlier that the right
to equal opportunity in the matter of
promotion in the sense of a right to
be “considered” for promotion is
indeed
a
fundamental
right
guaranteed under Article 16(1) and
this has never been doubted in any
other case before Ashok Kumar
Gupta [Ashok Kumar Gupta v. State
of U.P.], right from 1950.’
“20. In State of Bihar v. Akhouri
Sachindra Nath, it was held that
retrospective seniority cannot be
given to an employee from a date
when he was not even borne in the
cadre, nor can seniority be given
with retrospective effect as that
might adversely affect others. The
same view was reiterated in Keshav
Chandra Joshi v. Union of India16,
where it was held that when a quota
is provided for, then the seniority of
the employee would be reckoned
from the date when the vacancy
arises in the quota and not from any
anterior date of promotion or
subsequent date of confirmation.
The said view was restated in
Uttaranchal Forest Rangers' Assn.
(Direct Recruit) v. State of U.P., in
the following words:
‘37. We are also of the view
that no retrospective promotion or
seniority can be granted from a date
when an employee has not even
been borne in the cadre so as to
adversely affect the direct recruits
appointed validly in the meantime,
as decided by this Court in Keshav
Chandra Joshi v. Union of India held
that when promotion is outside the
quota, seniority would be reckoned
from the date of the vacancy within
the quota rendering the previous
service fortuitous. The previous
promotion would be regular only
from the date of the vacancy within
the quota and seniority shall be
counted from that date and not from
the date of his earlier promotion or
subsequent confirmation. In order to
do justice to the promotes, it would
not be proper to do injustice to the
direct recruits……
38.
This
Court
has
consistently
held
that
no
retrospective promotion can be
granted nor can any seniority be
given on retrospective basis from a
date when an employee has not
even been borne in the cadre
particularly
when
this
would
adversely affect the direct recruits
who have been appointed validity in
the meantime.”
(emphasis supplied)
20. In the instant case, it is evident that
while
respondent
No.
was
recommended for promotion before his
retirement, he could not assume the
duties of the Chief Scientific Officer.
Rule 54(1)(a) of the West Bengal
Service Rules, clearly stipulates that an
employee
must
assume
the
responsibilities of a higher post to draw
the corresponding pay, thus, preventing
posthumous
or
retrospective
promotions in the absence of an
enabling provision.”
13.
The reliance placed by the petitioner on judgments such as
Umadevi, Jaggo, and Dharam Singh does not advance his case.
The judgment in Umadevi clearly cautions against regularization
being treated as a mode of appointment and reiterates that long
service by itself does not create a right to regularization.
Subsequent judgments relied upon by the petitioner are
distinguishable on facts, as they pertain to cases where
employees were working against sanctioned posts or where
statutory provisions enabled such regularization, which is not the
situation in the present case. The plea of parity raised by the
petitioner is also untenable. Parity can be claimed only when
appointments, service conditions, and eligibility criteria are
identical. In the absence of material demonstrating that similarly
situated employees were regularized despite being ineligible or
without sanctioned posts, the petitioner cannot claim equality
under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
14.
This Court further finds substance in the submission of the
learned State Counsel that after superannuation, the petitioner
cannot seek regularization or pensionary benefits as a matter of
right when he was never appointed on a regular post during his
service tenure. Pension and gratuity are statutory benefits flowing
from regular service, and a daily-wage or contingency-paid
employee, in the absence of statutory entitlement, cannot claim
the same through judicial intervention.
15.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the petitioner has failed to establish any legal or
statutory right warranting interference under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India. The impugned order dated 14.10.2019 does
not suffer from any illegality, arbitrariness, or perversity so as to
call for judicial interference.
16.
Accordingly, the writ petition is found to be devoid of merit and is
hereby dismissed.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Shayna
JUDGE
Head-Note
When an employee has already superannuated and is no
longer in service, no claim for grant of service benefits with
retrospective effect is maintainable.”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review