Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
BEFORE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV
+
CS(OS) 1481/2013 & CC 57/2014
MRS. PUNAM SETH
W/O MR. UTTAM SETH
R/O 42, WHITE SWAN ROAD,
MT. ROSKILL, AUCKLAND, NEW ZEALAND.
.....PLAINTIFF
(Through: Mr. Jitendra Singh Bhasin, Ms. Rashmi Priya, Mr. Nishant
Shokeen, Mr. Manoj Rajan Sinha, Mr. Anand Singh, Ms. Kritika Anand and
Mr. Yash Bhardwaj, Advs.)
Versus
MS. SWATI TANDON
D/O LATE PUNEET TANDON
R/O 142-E, POCKET-IV, MAYUR VIHAR,
PHASE-I, NEW DELHI.
....DEFENDANT
(Through:
Mr. Amiet Andlay and Mr. Arun K. Sharma, Advs.)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------%
Reserved on:
15.12.2025
Pronounced on: 27.02.2026
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT
The present suit has been filed on behalf of Mrs. Punam Seth
(hereinafter referred to as the “plaintiff”) against Ms. Swati Tandon
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
(hereinafter referred to as the “defendant”), principally, for permanent
injunction restraining the latter from dealing with the property bearing no.
„A-6, Nav Bharat Times Apartments, Mayur Vihar-I, Delhi, (hereinafter
referred to as the “suit property”) and for possession of the same. Further,
the plaintiff also prays for consequential reliefs of mesne profits, interest on
the decretal amount, damages, and costs of the suit. It is pertinent to note
that the plaintiff resides in New Zealand, and the suit has been filed on her
behalf by her duly constituted attorney, Mrs. Anju Seth (hereinafter referred
to as the “attorney”).
2.
The plaintiff is the paternal aunt of the defendant. The plaintiff‟s
brother, late Mr. Puneet Tandon and his wife, late Mrs. Abha Dayal, who are
the defendant‟s parents, passed away on 23.10.2002. The plaintiff‟s father,
late Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon passed away on 04.01.2012, and her mother,
late Mrs. Rama Tandon, passed away on 22.01.2013. The relevant family
tree is extracted below, for reference:
Late Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon--- Late Mrs. Rama Tandon
Mrs. Punam Seth
(plaintiff)
Late Mr. Puneet Tandon ------ Late Mrs. Abha Dayal
Ms. Swati Tandon
(defendant)
3.
The case set up by the plaintiff is as follows:
3.1.
The suit property was „purchased‟ by her parents vide Special Power
of Attorney, General Power of Attorney, Will, Receipt, etc., all dated
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
31.03.1989. Further, Share Certificate dated 29.08.2007, in respect of the
suit property, was issued in the names of late Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon and
late Mrs. Rama Tandon by the Nav Bharat Times Residents Welfare
Association. At the request of late Mr. Puneet Tandon, in the year 2000, he
was permitted to reside in the suit property along with his family, and use it
additionally as a studio. Late Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon executed Will dated
15.12.2006, bequeathing the suit property to his wife, late Mrs. Rama
Tandon. Subsequently, the latter executed registered General Power of
Attorney dated 27.02.2012 and also Will dated 04.04.2012 in favour of the
plaintiff. Subsequent to the death of Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon, the plaintiff
locked the suit property and returned to New Zealand with her mother.
3.2.
Late Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon also owned farm land bearing no. 4045
khet no. 174 M, situated at village Nangli Nangla, Pargna and Dadri, District
Gautam Budh Nagar, Uttar Pradesh, measuring approx. 1099 sq. yds.
3.3.
The parents of the defendant had invested in property bearing no. D-
502, 7th Floor, Su-Swagatham Cooperative Group Housing Society, C-58/7,
Sector-62, Noida (hereinafter referred to as the “Su-Swagatham property”),
financed by a loan from the Bhagyodaya Urban Cooperative Bank Ltd.
Upon their demise, late Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon repaid the aforesaid loan.
3.4.
Pursuant to the demise of the defendant‟s parents when she was a
minor, she resided with and was taken care of by late Mr. Onkar Nath
Tandon and late Mrs. Rama Tandon. However, the defendant developed
unsavoury habits to the dismay of her grandparents, leading to certain
disagreements between them. Upon attaining majority in the year 2006Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
2007, the defendant, on her own accord, shifted to another property owned
by late Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon, bearing no. 142-E, Pocket-IV, Mayur
Vihar, Delhi (hereinafter referred to as “Flat No. 142-E”). Further, the
defendant issued a legal notice dated 27.07.2007 to her grandparents seeking
possession of the Su-Swagatham property. Late Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon
refused the demands in the said legal notice and replied to the same vide
letter dated 07.08.2007, stating that a substantial part of the cost of the
property had been borne by him. The defendant, thereafter, instituted a suit
against her grandparents for possession of the suit property, claiming to be
an indigent person.
3.5.
After the demise of Mrs. Rama Tandon in the year 2013, the plaintiff
returned to India and came to know that the suit property had been occupied
by the defendant. Thereafter, she demanded that the defendant vacate the
suit property. Upon the defendant‟s refusal to do so, the plaintiff filed a
complaint with the police on 23.04.2013, which was not acted upon by
them. Therefore, the present suit came to be filed.
4.
The defendant has denied the plaint averments and has claimed that
the attorney of the plaintiff does not have personal knowledge of the facts of
the case and is not competent to institute the suit on behalf of the plaintiff.
She further claims that the plaint has not been signed and verified in
accordance with law. Disputing the case set up in the plaint, the defendant
has taken the following position:
4.1.
Prior to the death of her parents, the defendant‟s grandparents resided
in Uttar Pradesh. It was only thereafter, that they came to Delhi to take care
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
of her. They did not have cordial relations with the defendant‟s parents as
they had objections to their marriage. They asserted control over the
properties left behind by late Mr. Puneet Tandon and late Mrs. Abha Dayal.
4.2.
Late Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon did not bear any financial burden
towards clearing the loan on the Su-Swagatham property, and the funds for
repayment of the same were derived from the assets left behind by the
defendant‟s parents. Thereafter, on 19.10.2004, the defendant‟s grandparents
sold the Su-Swagatham property and misappropriated the money received in
consideration of the said sale. Further, Flat No. 142-E was not owned by Mr.
Onkar Nath Tandon as alleged by the plaintiff, but belonged to the
defendant‟s mother.
4.3.
The assets left behind by the defendant‟s parents were also used for
payment towards the share certificate, property tax, and other expenses in
respect of the suit property. Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon was never the owner of
the suit property and could not have executed the alleged Will dated
15.12.2006. Further, even the documents purportedly executed by Mrs.
Rama Tandon in favour of, purportedly bequeathing the suit property upon
the plaintiff, could not have been executed by her, as she could neither read
nor understand English, and was also not in her senses at the time of the
purported execution. The same was done under undue influence and
pressure exerted by the plaintiff, subsequent to the death of Mr. Onkar Nath
Tandon. The plaintiff had been residing in the suit property since prior to the
demise of Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon. Upon the plaintiff‟s return to India
following the demise of Mrs. Rama Tandon, she tried to force the defendant
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
to vacate the suit property and threatened to use force in case of any
resistance to the same.
5.
In her counter claim, the defendant seeks, inter alia, declaration that
she is the sole owner of the Nav Bharat property, rendition of accounts and
recovery of the movable properties left behind by her parents, rendition of
accounts and recovery of the sale consideration received for the SuSwagatham property, and partition of the immovable properties of late Mr.
Onkar Nath Tandon. She has set up the following case in the counter claim:
5.1.
The defendant‟s parents were renowned filmmakers/journalists and
had set up a private limited company in the name and style of M/s Swati
Visuals Private Limited.
5.2.
Upon their death, the Government of State of Andhra Pradesh had
also granted an ex-gratia of Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh only), which
was received by Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon. Further, a payment of Rs.
4,03,200/- (Rupees Four Lakh Three Thousand and Two Hundred only) to
M/s Swati Visuals Private Limited was also made by another third-party
entity for work executed by her parents. Further, the defendant believed that
both her parents had subscribed to accident insurance policies which were
encashed by the grandparents.
5.3.
In the month of June, 2006, the defendant‟s grandparents forced her to
leave the suit property after which, she moved to Flat No. 142-E, which had
been rented out to an acquaintance of her parents. Upon attaining majority
and issuing the aforementioned legal notice to her grandparents seeking
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
rendition of accounts and claiming her parents‟ property, the defendant
made inquiries and found out that her parents had purchased the following
properties during their lifetime:
i.Flat No. A-6, Navbharat Time Apartments, Mayur Vihar, PhaseI, Delhi.
ii.Flat No. 142-E Pocket IV, Mayur Vihar, Delhi.
iii.Flat No. D-502, 7th floor, Su-Sawagatam Coop. Group Housing
Society in Plot No. C-58/7 Sector 62, NOIDA.
iv.Farm land bearing no. 4045 khet no. 174 M, situated at village
Nangli Nangla, Pargna and Dadri, Distt Gautam Budh Nagar
(U.P) measuring apporx. 1009 Sq. Yds.i.e., 843.52 Sq. Mtrs.
5.4.
The defendant‟s father had purchased the following movable
properties:
a. One Final Cut Pro editing machine
b. One PD 150 DV Camera & accessories
c. Two 537 Beta Camera with reflectors
d. One Tripod 501
e. One Cinetech
f. One Porta Kit with lights
g. Contessa car
h. Shares in M/s Swati Visuals Pvt. Ltd. A-6, Navbharat Times
Apartments, Mayur Vihar Phase-I, New Delhi 110091.
i. Bank account no. 1856 in the Nainital Bank, Patparganj, Delhi.
5.5.
The defendant‟s mother owned the following movable properties:
a. Jewellery stored in Locker No. 140 in Nainital Bank,
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Patparganj, Delhi.
b. Shares in M/s Swati Visuals Pvt. Ltd. A-6, Navbharat Times
Apartments, Mayur Vihar Phase-I, New Delhi 110091.
c. Bank account no. 812 in the Nainital Bank, Patparganj , Delhi.
d. Bank account no. 320446927 in the American Express Bank.
e. Bank account no. 01204371964 in ICICI Bank, Connaught
Circus as proprietor of NGO 'Call for Communications'.
5.6.
Further, they jointly held the bank account bearing no. 10101295 in
the Bhagodaya Bank.
5.7.
The defendant‟s grandparents have misappropriated the movable
properties of her parents, and also sold the Su-Swagatham property to thirdparties on 19.10.2004 for a total consideration of Rs. 22,50,000/- (Rupees
Twenty-Two Lakh Fifty Thousand only). The said consideration amount
too, has been misappropriated by them. The plaintiff is in knowledge and
custody of all details of the movable properties held by late Mr. Onkar Nath
Tandon and late Mrs. Rama Tandon.
5.8.
The suit property was purchased by her father from one Mr. A.K.
Bahl, vide Agreement to Sell, General Power of Attorney, etc. Mr. Onkar
Nath Tandon did not have any source of income apart from his meagre
pension and did not possess sufficient funds to purchase the suit property as
claimed by the plaintiff.
5.9.
Late Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon was in possession of the following
ancestral immovable properties:
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
(i) Shop no. 2/88,2/89,2/109 Nehru Road, Farukhabad, U.P
(ii) Shop no. 2/1,2/2,2/2/4,2/5,2/6 and 2/7 Girdhar Lai Street, Loha
Bazar, Farukhabad, U.P
(iii) House no. 2/103,Nehru Road, Farukhabad, U.P
6.
The plaintiff, in her written statement to the counter claim, has denied
all the averments in the counter claim. She has also raised a preliminary
objection to the prayer for partition of the ancestral properties on the ground
that the same are situated outside the jurisdiction of this Court, and hence is
not maintainable.
7.
After completion of pleadings, following issues were framed in civil
suit:
“(i) Whether the suit is not maintainable for being filed by an
unauthorized and incompetent person?
OPD
(ii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of permanent injunction?
OPP
(iii) Who is entitled to possession of the suit property?
OPP
(iv) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to mesne profits @ Rs. 25000/- per
month w.e.f. March, 2013, till the date of possession of the suit property?
OPP
(v) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to interest @ 18% p.a. on the decreed
amount?
OPP
(vi) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to damages against the defendant?
OPP
(vii) Relief, if any.”
8.
The issues in a counter-claim are framed as under:
“(i) Whether the defendant is entitled to declaration that the defendant is
the sole and exclusive owner of the Flat No. A-6, Navbharat Times
Apartments, Mayur Vihar, Phase I, New Delhi?
OPD
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
(ii) Whether the defendant is entitled to a decree of rendition of accounts
and recovery in respect of the amount received as the sale consideration of
property bearing No. D-501, Su-Swagatam Co-operative Housing Society
Ltd., Sector 62, Noida as per prayer (b) of the counter claim?
OPD
(iii) Whether the defendant is entitled to a decree of rendition of accounts
in respect of the properties as mentioned in prayer (c) of the counter
claim?
OPD
(iv) Whether the defendant is entitled to a decree of partition in respect of
the movable properties as mentioned in prayer (d) to the counter claim?
OPD
(v) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of rendition of accounts and
recovery in respect of the rents and payments received in respect of the
immovable properties as mentioned in prayer (e) of the counter claim?
OPD
(vi) Whether the defendant is entitled to interest, if so at what rate
and at what period?
OPD
(vii) Relief, if any.”
9.
Thus, the disputed property in the suit and the counter-claim is Flat
No.A-6, Navbharat Times Apartments, Mayur Vihar, Phase-I, New Delhi,
and rendition of accounts and recovery of the amount received as sale
consideration are sought for the property bearing D-501, Su-Swagatam Cooperative Housing Society Ltd., Sector 62, Noida.
10.
On behalf of the plaintiff, following witnesses were examined:
PW-1
Mrs. Punam Seth
Plaintiff
PW-2
Mrs. Anju Seth
Attorney
PW-3
Mr. Sanjiv Tandon
Acquaintance
of the plaintiff
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
11.
On behalf of the defendant, following witnesses are examined:
Witness no. 1
12.
Name
DW-1
Ms. Swati Tandon
Defendant
DW-2
Mr. Ajay Seth
Branch
Manager,
Nainital Bank,
Patparganj
Branch
DW-3
Mr. Pradeep Kumar
Deputy
Manager, SBI,
Mayur Vihar-I
DW-4
Mr. Sudhir K. Mehra
Chief
Executive
Officer,
National Urban
Cooperative
Bank
DW-5
Ms. Savita Razdan
Assistant
Manager, SBI,
Mayur Vihar-I
DW-6
Mr.
Sinha
Resident at the
society
Madhurendra
On behalf of the plaintiff, following documents were exhibited:
Document no.
Particulars
Date
Exhibit PW-1/1
Special Power of Attorney
executed by the plaintiff in
favour of the attorney
09.04.2013
Exhibit P-1
(Colly)
Death certificates of Mr.
Puneet Tandon and Mrs.
Abha Dayal
23.10.2002
Exhibit P-3
Special Power of Attorney
dated 31.03.1989 executed
by Mr. A.K. Bahl in favour
of Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon
31.03.1989
Exhibit PW-1/2
General Power of Attorney,
31.03.1989
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Particulars
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
(colly)
Will and receipt executed
by Mr. A.K. Bahl in favour
of Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon
Exhibit P-4
Death Certificate of Mr.
Onkar Nath Tandon
16.01.2012
Exhibit PW-1/3
Death certificate of Mrs.
Rama Tandon
12.02.2013
Exhibit PW-1/4
Letter by Mr. Onkar Nath
Tandon addressed to SuSwagatham Co-operative
Group Housing Society
27.12.2002
Exhibit PW-1/5
Certificate issued by
Bhagyodaya Urban Cooperative Bank Ltd.
12.01.2003
Exhibit PW-1/6
(colly)
Receipts issued by SuSwagatham Co-operative
Group Housing Society
31.01.2003 and
06.03.2003
Exhibit PW-1/7
Surviving members
certificate in respect of Mr.
Puneet Tandon and Mrs.
Abha Dayal
21.01.2003
Exhibit PW-1/8
Receipt issued by Nav
Bharat Times Apartments
Residents' Welfare
Association
08.08.2005
Exhibit PW-1/9
Receipt issued by Nav
Bharat Times Apartments
Residents' Welfare
Association
10.07.2007
Exhibit PW-1/10
Share Certificate in respect
of suit property
29.08.2007
Exhibit PW-1/11
Cheque no. 416802
23.06.2010
Exhibit PW-1/12
NOC issued by Delhi Cooperative Housing Finance
Corporation Ltd. for
conversion of suit property
to freehold.
06.08.2010
Exhibit PW-1/13
Letter issued by Delhi Cooperative Housing Finance
Corporation Ltd.
06.08.2010
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
13.
Exhibit PW-1/14
Order in IPA 38/2007
23.11.2007
Exhibit PW-1/15
Order in IPA 38/2007
15.07.2009
Exhibit PW-1/16
Will of Mr. Onkar Nath
Tandon
15.12.2006
Exhibit PW-1/17
General Power of Attorney
executed by Mrs. Rama
Tandon
27.02.2012
Exhibit PW-1/18
Will of Mrs. Rama Tandon
04.04.2012
Exhibit PW-1/19
Receipt issued by the
society
22.01.2013
Exhibit PW-1/20
Electricity receipt in respect
of the suit property
22.01.2013
Exhibit PW-1/21
Police Complaint filed by
the plaintiff
23.04.2013
On behalf of the defendant, following documents were exhibited:
Document no.
Particulars
Date
Exhibit DW-1/1
(Colly)
Newspaper clippings qua
the work of Mr. Puneet
Tandon and Mrs. Abha
Dayal
N.A.
Mark-A
Memorandum and Articles
of Association of M/S
Swati Visuals Pvt. Ltd.
27.11.1991
Exhibit D-6
Identity Card of Mr. Onkar
Nath Tandon
N.A.
Mark E/DX-1
Letter written to Food
Inspector, Delhi
31.08.2003
Exhibit DW-1/2
(Colly)
School report cards of the
defendant
1995-2004
Mark-A/DX-1
Deed of Agreement
executed between Mr.
Onkar Nath Tandon and
Mr. Anshu Vijay Rode
28.07.2005
Mark-B
Share Certificate issued by
31.05.2000
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Su-Swagatham Cooperative Group Housing
Society Ltd.
Mark-C
Loan sanction letter issued
by Bhagyodaya Bank in
favour of Mr. Puneet
Tandon and Mrs. Abha
Dayal
October, 2001
Mark K/DX-1
and Mark/DX-4
Receipt issued by SuSwagatham Co-operative
Group Housing Society Ltd.
20.04.2001
Mark K/DX-3
and Mark K/DX4
Receipts issued by SuSwagatham Co-operative
Group Housing Society Ltd.
26.04.2001 and
31.05.2000
Mark K/DX-5
and Mark K/DX6
Receipts issued by SuSwagatham Co-operative
Group Housing Society Ltd.
19.11.2001 and
12.10.2001
Mark K/DX-7
and Mark K/DX8
Receipts issued by SuSwagatham Co-operative
Group Housing Society Ltd.
20.06.2000 and
10.06.2000
Mark K/DX-9
and Mark K/DX10
Receipts issued by SuSwagatham Co-operative
Group Housing Society Ltd.
24.07.2002 and
03.01.2002
Mark K/DX-11 to
Mark K/DX-12
Receipts issued by SuSwagatham Co-operative
Group Housing Society Ltd.
11.05.2002
Exhibit D-1
Share Certificate of Mr.
A.K. Bahl in respect of the
suit property
15.08.1985
Exhibit D-2
Allotment letter in favour of
Mr. A.K. Bahl in respect of
the suit property
01.08.1988
Exhibit PW1/DX-4
Receipt cum Agreement
executed between Mr. A.K.
Bahl and Mr. Puneet
Tandon
24.03.1987
Exhibit PW1/DX-5
Receipt cum Agreement
executed between Mr. A.K.
Bahl and Mr. Puneet
Tandon
03.03.1989
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Mark-Z
Letter issued by Mr. A.K.
Bahl addressed to the
Secretary of the society
31.03.1989
Exhibit DW-1/4
Statement of account issued
by the society in favour of
Mr. A.K. Bahl
28.02.1995
Mark-B/DX-1
Receipt issued by Europe
Forces Services
08.07.2001
Mark C/DX-1
Covering letter
Undated
Mark-D/DX1(Colly)
Cheques bearng no.
069786, 069787, 069788
21.08.2001
Exhibit D-3
Copy of legal notice issued
by the defendant to Mr.
Onkar Nath Tandon
27.07.2007
Exhibit D-4
Copy of reply to legal
notice dated 27.07.2007
07.09.2007
Exhibit PW1/DX-2
Chequebook counter foil
record of account no. 51105
with Bank of Saurashtra
N.A.
Exhibit DW-1/31
Certified copy of pauper
report filed by the SubDivisional Magistrate in
IPA No. 38/2007
08.05.2018
Submissions
14.
Mr. Jitendra Bhasin, learned counsel for the plaintiff, has made the
following submissions:
14.1. The objection raised by the defendant with respect to the institution of
the suit by the attorney is meritless and devoid of proof;
14.2. The suit property was purchased by Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon on the
basis of General Power of Attorney, Will and Receipt, all dated 31.03.1989.
Each payment made by him towards the same is supported by original
receipts and acknowledgments issued by the society;
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
14.3. The defendant‟s claim that her parents had paid the consideration
amount towards the acquisition of the suit property is unsubstantiated by
evidence, as the documents on which reliance is placed came into existence
subsequent to their death. Further, the affidavit filed by the Secretary of the
society in compliance with the order dated 05.02.2015 conclusively affirms
that the plaintiff‟s parents were the recorded shareholders of the suit
property. Therefore, the plaintiff is entitled to possession and permanent
injunction against the defendant in respect of the suit property;
14.4. After the defendant had moved out of the suit property, she returned
as a trespasser in the plaintiff‟s absence, sometime in the year 2012/2013,
upon the demise of Mrs. Rama Tandon. The defendant was occupying the
suit property illegally and without authorisation and the plaintiff became
aware of the same upon her return to India after the demise of Mrs. Rama
Tandon. For her unauthorised occupation of the suit property, the defendant
must be held liable to pay mesne profits at the rate of Rs. 25,000/- (Rupees
Twenty-Five Thousand only) per month, which is the prevailing market rate
of monthly rent at the location of the suit property. Further, for her acts of
deliberate trespass into and encroachment of the suit property, the defendant
ought to be made liable to pay exemplary damages.
14.5. The plaintiff‟s parents had contributed substantially towards clearing
the outstanding loans in respect of the Su-Swagatham property. Further, the
share certificate in respect of the same also stood transferred in their names.
Therefore, it was well within their rights to sell the same, if they did do so.
14.6. Furthermore, the plaintiff cannot be held liable for rendition of
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
accounts in respect of the sale consideration purportedly received by her
parents towards the Su-Swagatham property.
14.7. As far as the defendant‟s prayer for rendition of accounts of the
movable properties purportedly left behind by her parents is concerned, the
defendant has made only vague and unsubstantiated allegations regarding
the same having been misappropriated by her grandparents;
14.8. Further, so far as the prayer for partition of the ancestral properties is
concerned, there does not exist any property in the joint ownership of the
plaintiff and defendant;
14.9. The defendant has not produced a shred of evidence to show that the
plaintiff has derived any rent or benefit from any property mentioned in the
counter claim. No rent receipts, bank credits, tenancy documents, or
statements have been filed. Further, the plaintiff has neither collected any
rent nor possessed any of property other than the suit property.
15.
Mr. Ameit Andley, learned counsel for the defendant, has opposed
the said submissions and contended as follows:
15.1. The suit is not maintainable as the same has been filed on behalf of
the plaintiff by the attorney despite not being competent to do so. The
statements of the plaintiff (PW-1) and the attorney (PW-2), in their crossexamination, disclose that the latter was not personally conversant with the
averments in the plaint, despite having signed and verified it.
15.2. The suit property was, in fact, purchased by the defendant‟s father and
used as the place of residence for his family. His purchase of the same is
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
evidenced by the Special Power of Attorney dated 31.03.1989 executed in
his favour by Mr. A.K. Bahl, who was its original allottee and the receipts
cum agreements dated 24.03.1989 and 03.03.1989. Further, other documents
such as the letter dated 31.02.1989 issued by Mr. A.K Bahl authorising Mr.
Puneet Tandon to do acts in respect of the suit property and also the receipt
issued by a water purifier company for payment by him in respect of
servicing of a water cooler installed in the suit property substantiate the
defendant‟s case.
15.3. The defendant‟s grandparents came to the suit property only after the
demise of her parents. Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon was a retiree at the relevant
time, and his only source of income was his meagre pension and rental
income. Therefore, he could not have had the funds to purchase the suit
property.
15.4. Soon after shifting to the suit property, ostensibly to take care of the
defendant who had become orphaned, they started behaving in a hostile
manner towards her and even made it clear that they had intentions to usurp
the properties left behind by her parents.
15.5. Further, Will dated 15.12.2006 vide which Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon is
purported to have bequeathed the suit property to his wife, Mrs. Rama
Tandon has not been duly proved in accordance with Section 68 of the
Evidence Act, 1872. Will dated 04.04.2012 and the General Power of
Attorney dated 27.02.2012 could not have been executed by Mrs. Rama
Tandon in favour of the plaintiff as she was suffering from Parkinson‟s
disease at the said point of time and also was not conversant in the English
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
language. The said Will too, has not been duly proved in accordance with
Section 68 of the Evidence Act, 1872. Therefore, the plaintiff has failed to
establish her title over the suit property.
Analysis
16.
First, the issues for adjudication in the main suit are taken up for
consideration.
Issue no. (i)
17.
The defendant, in her written statement, has taken the preliminary
objection to the manner in which the suit has been instituted. It is her case
that the attorney who has affixed her signature and verified the plaint on
behalf of the plaintiff could not have been authorised to do so, on the ground
that she was, allegedly, not personally conversant with the facts of the case.
18.
The suit has been filed by the attorney on behalf of the plaintiff, on
the strength of the Special Power of Attorney dated 26.04.2013. Under the
scheme envisaged by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter
referred to as the “CPC”), a holder of a power of attorney may do such acts
on behalf of the party granting power, as they may have been authorised to
do under the power of attorney. The said provision is extracted below, for
reference:
“2. Recognized agents.—The recognized agents of parties by whom
such appearances, applications and acts may be made or done are—
(a) persons holding powers-of-attorney, authorising them to make and
do such appearances, applications and acts on behalf of such parties;
(b) persons carrying on trade or business for and in the names of
parties not resident within the local limits of the jurisdiction of the
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Court within which limits the appearance, application or act is made
or done, in matters connected with such trade or business only, where
no other agent is expressly authorised to make and do such
appearances, applications and acts.”
19.
Next, it would be apposite to refer to the provisions under Order VI
Rule 14 and Order VI Rule 15 of the CPC. The said provisions are extracted
below, for reference:
“14. Pleading to be signed.—Every pleading shall be signed by the
party and his pleader (if any): Provided that where a party pleading
is, by reason of absence or for other good cause, unable to sign the
pleading, it may be signed by any person duly authorized by him to
sign the same or to sue or defend on his behalf.”
(Emphasis supplied)
“15. Verification of pleadings.—(1) Save as otherwise provided by
any law for the time being in force, every pleading shall be verified at
the foot by the party or by one of the parties pleading or by some other
person proved to the satisfaction of the Court to be acquainted with
the facts of the case.(2) The person verifying shall specify, by
reference to the numbered paragraphs of the pleading, what he
verifies of his own knowledge and what he verifies upon information
received and believed to be true. (3) The verification shall be signed
by the person making it and shall state the date on which and the
place at which it was signed.”
20.
A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions indicates that a
recognised agent is empowered under the provisions contained in the CPC,
to institute a suit on behalf of the plaintiff as long as he/she is acquainted
with the facts of the case. There is no requirement under the CPC for the
recognised agent to be personally conversant with the facts of the case, and
the Rule providing for verification also indicates that the pleadings could be
verified on personal knowledge or on the basis of information received and
believed to be true. The aforesaid view finds support from the decision of
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
the Supreme Court in the case of Man Kaur(Dead)By Lrs v. Hartar Singh
Sangha,1 wherein, the Court, while examining the scope of the authority of
a power of attorney holder to lead evidence, has held as under:
“18. We may now summarise for convenience, the position as to who
should give evidence in regard to matters involving personal
knowledge:
(a) An attorney holder who has signed the plaint and instituted the
suit, but has no personal knowledge of the transaction can only give
formal evidence about the validity of the power of attorney and the
filing of the suit….”
21.
Mr. Ameit Andlay, in support of his submission that the suit has been
instituted by an unauthorised and incompetent person, has placed reliance on
the cross-examination of PW-1 (the plaintiff) on 24.03.2017, wherein it is
admitted that the attorney was not personally conversant with the facts of the
case. The relevant portion of the same is extracted below, for reference:
“It is correct that my attorney Anju Seth had no personal knowledge
of the facts stated in the plaint on the date of its institution.
Volunteered: I narrated the facts to Anju Seth prior to intuition of the
suit.”
22.
Further, he places reliance on the cross examination of PW-2 (the
attorney) on 24.08.2017, wherein she has admitted that she had not
instructed the plaintiff‟s counsel for the purpose of drafting any of the
pleadings in the suit and the counter claim. The relevant portion of her
statement is extracted below, for reference:
“The plaintiff and her husband told me that the defendant was living
hedonistic life style. I do not have any personal knowledge about the
same. The plaintiff told me that the defendant harassed Mr. O.N
Tandon for money for her extravagant life style.
I had not given any instruction to the counsel for purpose of drafting
(2010) 10 SCC 512
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
plaint, replication and written statement to the counter claim.
The plaintiff and her husband told me that defendant developed
intimacy with a number of undesirable elements soon begun smoking,
drinking, partying late night. I myself had not seen the defendant
indulged in such activities. Whenever I visited the parents of the
plaintiff they never informed me about the defendant indulging in any
such activity.”
23.
A perusal of the said extracts indicates that the attorney is acquainted
with the „facts‟ of the case as required under Order VI Rule 14 of the CPC,
despite not being personally conversant with the same. Further, merely
because the plaint was not drafted on the instructions of the attorney, does
not invalidate the institution of the suit, considering that the entire
deposition of the plaintiff, as PW-1, is indicative of the fact that the plaint
was drafted on her instructions. An argument could possibly have been
raised if the plaint were drafted on the instructions of the attorney who was
not personally conversant with the facts. However, such is not the case here.
24.
The upshot of the foregoing discussion is that the suit cannot be
deemed to be not maintainable as having been instituted by an unauthorised
and incompetent person. Therefore, issue no. (i) is answered in the negative.
Issue no. (iii)
25.
This issue relates to the prayer for possession of the suit property,
whereas issue no. (ii) relates to a consequential prayer for injunction.
Therefore, this issue is taken up for consideration before issue no. (ii).
26.
The prayer for possession is governed by the provision under Section
5 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 (“SRA”), whereunder, persons entitled to
possession of specific immovable properties, may recover it in the manner
provided by the CPC. It is settled law that entitlement to possession of a
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
specific immovable property, on the basis of title or otherwise, is a prerequisite for succeeding in a claim of recovery. A case of illegal
dispossession, without following the due procedure, is covered separately
under Section 6 of SRA, which is maintainable only on the ground of settled
possession and irrespective of title. However, in the present case, the
plaintiff has failed to fulfil the essential pre-conditions and to establish the
existence of her legal entitlement over the suit property or even prior
possession.
27.
The plaintiff has attempted to set up her claim of possession on the
basis of title as well as prior possession. Her claim on the basis of prior
possession is examined first. The plaintiff has specifically pleaded that
subsequent to the demise of Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon in the year 2012, she
had locked the suit property and informed the concerned persons at the
society in which the suit property is situated before departing to New
Zealand with Mrs. Rama Tandon. She further claims to have paid
maintenance charges to the society and electricity charges in respect of the
suit property through an acquaintance and relies on receipts dated
22.01.2013 thereof, as proof of her possession of the suit property as on the
said date. According to her, thereafter, the defendant illegally trespassed into
the suit property. However, the said receipts (Exhibit PW-1/19 and Exhibit
PW-1/20) are in the names of Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon and Mr. A.K. Bahl
respectively. Therefore, they do not, by any stretch of imagination, establish
her possession of the suit property. Moreover, none of the witnesses on her
behalf have given categorical evidence in this regard. In fact, PW-3, Mr.
Sanjiv Tandon, who is stated to be an acquaintance of the plaintiff‟s
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
husband, in his cross-examination on 20.04.2018, has explicitly stated that
he could neither admit nor deny that the suit property was the permanent
residence of the defendant. The relevant portion of his statement is extracted
below, for reference:
“Q: Can you tell the date of your visit at the suit property as mentioned in para-3
of Ex.PW3/X?
A: I do not remember the date, time or the year but I visited the suit
property and found defendant there.
I was informed by the plaintiff or her husband Uttam Seththat
defendant is visiting the suit property. It is incorrect to suggest that I
never met the defendant at the suit property and giving false evidence
to that effect. Neither plaintiff nor her husband had told me the actual
residence of defendant. I cannot admit or deny that the defendant was
permanently residing in the suit property.”
28. Most importantly, having averred that upon the demise of Mr. Onkar
Nath, she had locked the suit property and informed the members of the
society before leaving for New Zealand, the plaintiff could have examined
the said members as witnesses in support of her claim. However, no such
evidence has been led. Therefore, the plaintiff has not established her prior
possession of the suit property.
29.
Consequently, the plaintiff‟s claim for entitlement to possession rests
solely on her purported title over the same, allegedly, having been derived
from her parents.
30.
Her case is that her parents had „purchased‟/‟acquired‟ the suit
property by virtue of registered General Power of Attorney and registered
Will, both dated 31.03.1989, executed in their favour by one Mr. A.K. Bahl,
its original „allottee‟.
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
31.
However, it is trite law that a power of attorney is not an instrument
of transfer of any right, title, or interest in a property, but is a contract of
„agency‟, whereby the „power of attorney holder‟ or the ‟agent‟ is authorised
to act as the „attorney‟ on behalf of the executant of the document or the
„principal‟. A power of attorney neither results in transfer of title nor
conveyance thereof.
32.
Transfers of immovable property are governed by the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882. The term „transfer of property‟ is defined under Section
5 thereof as under:
“5. “Transfer of property” defined.—In the following sections
“transfer of property” means an act by which a living person conveys
property, in present or in future, to one or more other living persons,
or to himself, or to himself and one or more other living persons; and
“to transfer property” is to perform such act.
In this section “living person” includes a company or association or
body of individuals, whether incorporated or not, but nothing herein
contained shall affect any law for the time being in force relating to
transfer of property to or by companies, associations or bodies of
individuals.”
33.
A perusal of the aforesaid provision indicates that for a transfer of
property to take place, conveyance of a right, title, or interest is sine qua
non. Unless a transaction involves „conveyance‟, no transfer of property
could be deemed to have been made.
34.
The said aspect has been considered by the Supreme Court in its
decision in Suraj Lamps Industries v. State of Haryana,2 wherein it has
held as under:
(2012) 1 SCC 656
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
“13. A power of attorney is not an instrument of transfer in regard to
any right, title or interest in an immovable property. The power of
attorney is a creation of an agency whereby the grantor authorizes the
grantee to do the acts specified therein, on behalf of grantor, which
when executed will be binding on the grantor as if done by him (see
section 1A and section 2 of the Powers of Attorney Act, 1882). It is
revocable or terminable at any time unless it is made irrevocable in a
manner known to law. Even an irrevocable attorney does not have the
effect of transferring title to the grantee. In State of Rajasthan vs.
Basant Nehata - 2005 (12) SCC 77, this Court held :
"A grant of power of attorney is essentially governed by Chapter X of
the Contract Act. By reason of a deed of power of attorney, an agent is
formally appointed to act for the principal in one transaction or a
series of transactions or to manage the affairs of the principal
generally conferring necessary authority upon another person. A deed
of power of attorney is executed by the principal in favour of the
agent. The agent derives a right to use his name and all acts, deeds
and things done by him and subject to the limitations contained in the
said deed, the same shall be read as if done by the donor. A power of
attorney is, as is well known, a document of convenience.
Execution of a power of attorney in terms of the provisions of
the Contract Act as also the Powers-of-Attorney Act is valid. A power
of attorney, we have noticed hereinbefore, is executed by the donor so
as to enable the donee to act on his behalf. Except in cases where
power of attorney is coupled with interest, it is revocable. The donee
in exercise of his power under such power of attorney only acts in
place of the donor subject of course to the powers granted to him by
reason thereof. He cannot use the power of attorney for his own
benefit. He acts in a fiduciary capacity. Any act of infidelity or breach
of trust is a matter between the donor and the donee."
An attorney holder may however execute a deed of conveyance in
exercise of the power granted under the power of attorney and convey
title on behalf of the grantor.”
35.
Further, the Supreme Court, considering that a large number of
transactions had been entered into by virtue of such documents, has also
held that the explicit declaration in the said decision, of the position of law
as it existed ever since the enactment of the TPA, would not affect any
mutation entry that may have been made by the Municipal or revenue
authorities. The Court also made it clear that the said documents could be
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
relied on to apply for regularisation of allotments/leases. The relevant
portion of the decision is extracted below, for reference:
“18. We have merely drawn attention to and reiterated the well-settled
legal position that SA/GPA/WILL transactions are not `transfers' or
`sales' and that such transactions cannot be treated as completed
transfers or conveyances. They can continue to be treated as existing
agreement of sale.
Nothing prevents affected parties from getting registered Deeds of
Conveyance to complete their title. The said `SA/GPA/WILL
transactions' may also be used to obtain specific performance or to
defend possession under section 53A of TP Act. If they are entered
before this day, they may be relied upon to apply for regularization of
allotments/leases by Development Authorities. We make it clear that if
the documents relating to „SA/GPA/WILL transactions' has been
accepted acted upon by DDA or other developmental authorities or by
the Municipal or revenue authorities to effect mutation, they need not
be disturbed, merely on account of this decision.”
36.
The plaintiff has relied on Share Certificate dated 19.08.2007 in the
name of Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon in respect of the „Nav Bharat Times
Cooperative Housing Society‟, which is the original allottee of the land on
which the suit property exists, to assert that the allotment in name of Mr.
Onkar Nath Tandon had been regularised. Further, reliance is also placed on
the letter dated 06.08.2010 issued by the Delhi Co-Operative Housing
Finance Corporation Ltd. with which the suit property was mortgaged, to the
Delhi Development Authority for conversion of the suit property from
leasehold to freehold. However, no document evidencing the conversion of
the suit property to freehold, in the name of Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon has
been placed on record. Mr. Jitendra Bhasin, has made only oral submissions
that the suit property was, in fact, converted to freehold, in the name of Mr.
Onkar Nath Tandon. The said assertion does not even find place in the
plaint.
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
37.
So far as registered Will dated 31.03.1989 is concerned, the same has
not been duly proved. It cannot be disputed that a will can confer title on
legatee only upon the demise of the testator. However, the plaintiff in her
cross examination as PW-1 on 14.03.2017, has admitted that she was not
aware of whether the said Mr. A.K. Bahl was alive on the said date.
Therefore, even Will dated 31.03.1989 cannot be of much help to the
plaintiff in this regard. The relevant portion of her statement is extracted
below, for reference:
“I have not found out if Mr. A.K.Behl is alive as on date.”
38.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the plaintiff cannot be held to be
entitled to possession of the suit property, either on ground or prior
possession or title.
39.
Issue no. (iii), being for the purpose of adjudication of the plaintiff‟s
prayer for possession of the suit property, has been incorrectly framed as
“Who is entitled to possession of the suit property?”. It ought to have been
framed as, “Whether the plaintiff is entitled to possession of the suit
property?”. This issue, in its corrected form, is answered in the negative.
Issues no. (ii), (iv), (v) and (vi)
40.
These issues relate to the prayers viz. for injunction against the
defendant in respect of the suit property, for interest on the decreed amount,
and for mesne profits towards the defendant‟s allegedly unauthorised
occupation of the suit property, which are consequential to the relief of
possession.
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
41.
In view of the adjudication of issue no. (iii) in the negative, these
issues too, are answered in the negative.
42.
The issues in the counter claim are now taken up for consideration.
Issue no. (i)
43.
The defendant‟s claim to the suit property, similar to that of the
plaintiff‟s, is based on her purported title derived from her father, Mr.
Puneet Tandon. According to her, her father „purchased‟ the suit property,
by way of Special Power of Attorney dated 31.03.1989, executed by the said
Mr. A.K. Bahl.
44.
Mr. Ameit Andlay, has placed reliance on the decision of a two-judge
bench of the Supreme Court in the case of Maya Devi v. Lalta Prasad,3 to
contend that the decision in Suraj Lamps is only prospective and therefore,
would not affect defendant‟s case. The relevant portions of the said decision
are extracted below, for reference:
“10. In the above judgment, it has been stated that the observations
made by the court are not intended to in any way affect the validity of
sale agreements and powers of attorney executed in genuine
transactions. I am of the view that the power of attorney executed on
12-5-2006 in favour of the appellant by the wife of Prem Chand
Verma is a genuine transaction executed years before the judgment of
this Court. The facts will clearly indicate that the agreement for sale
dated 3-11-2003 was created by none other than the husband of
Nirmal Verma, who had executed the general power of attorney and
possession was handed over to the appellant. That being the fact
situation, in my view, the objection filed by the appellant under Order
21 Rule 58 CPC in execution has to be allowed. I, therefore, hold that
the executing court can execute the decree in Civil Suit No. 407 of
2007, but without proceeding against the property referred to in the
(2015) 5 SCC 588
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
registered power of attorney dated 12-5-2006.
XXXXX
I have perused the judgment [ Set out in paras 1 to 11, above.] of my
learned and esteemed Brother Radhakrishnan, and I entirely and
respectfully agree with his conclusion that the appeal deserves to be
allowed. My learned Brother has succinctly analysed the sterling
judgment in Suraj Lamp and Industries (P) Ltd. v. State of Haryana
[Suraj Lamp and Industries (P) Ltd. v. State of Haryana, (2009) 7
SCC 363 : (2009) 3 SCC (Civ) 126] , which has been rendered by a
three-Judge Bench [Suraj Lamp and Industries (P) Ltd. (2) v. State of
Haryana, (2012) 1 SCC 656 : (2012) 1 SCC (Civ) 351] of this Court. I
completely concur with the view that since general power of attorney
(GPA) in favour of the appellant was executed and registered on 12-52006, it could not be impacted or affected by Suraj Lamp [Suraj Lamp
and Industries (P) Ltd. v. State of Haryana, (2009) 7 SCC 363 : (2009)
3 SCC (Civ) 126] dicta. Furthermore, a reading of the order of the
executing court as well as of the High Court makes it palpably clear
that both the courts had applied the disqualification and illegality
imposed upon GPAs by Suraj Lamp [Suraj Lamp and Industries (P)
Ltd. v. State of Haryana, (2009) 7 SCC 363 : (2009) 3 SCC (Civ) 126]
without keeping in mind that the operation of that judgment was
pointedly and poignantly prospective. This question has been dealt
with by my esteemed Brother most comprehensively.”
45.
On perusal of the said decision, respectfully, this Court is of the view
that it was rendered in the context of the peculiar facts of the case. The
appellant therein had claimed title over the subject property on the basis of a
registered power of attorney, and had filed objections in execution
proceedings for a decree of money recovery, which was sought to be
executed against the subject property. The decree holder had obtained the
subject decree in ex-parte proceedings, which, in the opinion of the Supreme
Court, was collusive and only to defeat the interests of the appellant. The
factual backdrop of the said case has no relation to the facts of the present
case.
46.
Moreover, another two-judge bench of the Supreme Court in its
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
decision in Shakeel Ahmad v. Syed Akhlaq Hussein,4 has rejected the
contention that the decision in Suraj Lamps is only prospective, and held as
follows:
“10. Having considered the submissions at the outset, it is to be
emphasized that irrespective of what was decided in the case of Suraj
Lamps and Industries(supra) the fact remains that no title could be
transferred with respect to immovable properties on the basis of an
unregistered Agreement to Sell or on the basis of an unregistered
General Power of Attorney. The Registration Act, 1908 clearly
provides that a document which requires compulsory registration
under the Act, would not confer any right, much less a legally
enforceable right to approach a Court of Law on its basis. Even if
these documents i.e. the Agreement to Sell and the Power of Attorney
were registered, still it could not be said that the respondent would
have acquired title over the property in question. At best, on the basis
of the registered agreement to sell, he could have claimed relief of
specific performance in appropriate proceedings. In this regard,
reference may be made to sections 17 and 49 of the Registration Act
and section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
13. The argument advanced on behalf of the respondent that the
judgment in Suraj Lamps & Industries (supra) would be prospective is
also misplaced. The requirement of compulsory registration and effect
on non-registration emanates from the statutes, in particular the
Registration Act and the Transfer of Property Act. The ratio in Suraj
Lamps & Industries (supra) only approves the provisions in the two
enactments. Earlier judgments of this Court have taken the same
view.”
47.
It is also pertinent to note that just like the plaintiff, the defendant too,
has not produced any document indicating regularisation of allotment of the
suit property in the name of her father by the Delhi Development Authority.
The case of the defendant, insofar as her claim of title is concerned, is
equally vulnerable as that of the plaintiff herein and cannot be termed as a
better case in any case. Therefore, even the aforequoted observations in
2023 INSC 1016
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
paragraph no. 18 of the decision in Suraj Lamps Industries would not be of
much help to the defendant. Therefore, the defendant has not established her
title over the suit property.
48.
In view thereof, issue no. (i) is answered in the negative.
Issues no. (ii) and (iii)
49.
These issues relate to the prayer for rendition of accounts and
recovery of the consideration amount received by Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon
and Mrs. Rama Tandon from the sale of the Su-Swagatham property and in
respect of the movable properties left behind by the defendant‟s parents.
Therefore, they are taken up for consideration together.
50.
A prayer for rendition of accounts would be maintainable only where
the plaintiff has a statutory right to demand the same from the defendant,
where there exists a fiduciary relationship between the parties and the
defendant has received money due to the plaintiff, or where there exist
equitable grounds for the same. Reference may be made to the decision of
the Supreme Court in K. Skaria v. the Government of State of Kerala,5
where it has summarised the legal position as under:
“16. To summarise, a suit for rendition of accounts can be maintained
only if a person suing has a right to receive an account from the
defendant. Such a right can either be (a) created or recognized under
a statute; or (b) based on the fiduciary relationship between the
parties as in the case of a beneficiary and a trustee, or (c) claimed in
equity when the relationship is such that rendition of accounts is the
only relief which will enable the person seeking account to
satisfactorily assert his legal right. Such a right to seek accounts
cannot be claimed as a matter of convenience or on the ground of
(2006) 2 SCC 285
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
hardship or on the ground that the person suing did not know the
exact amount due to him, as that will open the floodgates for
converting several types of money claims into suits for accounts, to
avoid payment of court fee at the time of institution.”
51.
The defendant and her grandparents did, in fact, have a fiduciary
relationship, considering that the latter assumed de-facto guardianship of the
former upon her parents‟ demise. If the Su-Swagatham property belonged to
her parents, any consideration amount received by her grandparents, that
would have been received on her behalf, would have been liable for
rendition of accounts. However, it is pertinent to note that the basis for the
defendant‟s claim against the plaintiff is the assumption that the said funds
would have flown to the latter upon the demise of the grandparents.
Therefore, it is incumbent on the plaintiff to establish that the alleged
misappropriated funds did, in fact, accrue to the plaintiff at any point of
time.
52.
Similarly, as far as the prayer for rendition of accounts in respect of
the movable properties left behind by her parents is concerned, the plaintiff
would be liable for the same only if the said movables came in her
possession. However, the defendant has not established such a fact.
Pertinently, these are foundational facts for constituting the cause of action
and are necessary for showing entitlement to claim a relief from the Court.
In the absence of such facts, the cause of action for claiming such reliefs
could not be termed as complete and existent in the defendant‟s favour.
53.
In this regard, the defendant has examined DW-2, Mr. Ajay Seth,
representative from Nainital Bank, Patparganj Branch, Delhi, DW-3, Mr.
Pradeep Kumar, representative of the State Bank of India, Mayur Vihar
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Phase-I, New Delhi, DW-4, Mr. Sudhir K. Mehra, representative of National
Urban Cooperative Bank Limited Mayur Vihar, New Delhi, and Ms. Savita
Razdan, representative of the State Bank of India Phase-I, New Delhi who
have produced the statements of the defendant‟s parents, her grandparents,
and the plaintiff. None of the said bank statements indicate transfer of funds
left behind by the defendant‟s parents to the plaintiff, either directly or
through her grandparents. They also do not indicate that any sale
consideration in respect of the Su-Swagatham property that the defendant‟s
grandparents may have received, was eventually transferred to the plaintiff.
Therefore, the plaintiff cannot be held as entitled to render accounts in this
regard.
54.
In view thereof, issues no. (ii) and (iii) are answered in the negative.
Issues no. (iv) and (v)
These issues relate to the plaintiff‟s prayers for partition and rendition
55.
of accounts in respect of certain ancestral properties belonging to the
extended family of Mr. Onkar Nath Tandon. Therefore, they are taken up for
consideration together.
56.
At the outset, it is seen that the immovable properties sought to be
partitioned are situated outside the jurisdiction of this Court. The provision
under Section 16 of the CPC expressly provides that suit for partition of
immovable properties ought to be instituted where they are situated. The
relevant portion of the said provision is extracted below, for reference:
“16. Suits to be instituted where subject-matter situate.—Subject to the
pecuniary or other limitations prescribed by any law, suits—
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
XXXXX
(b) for the partition of immovable property,
XXXXXXX
shall be instituted in the Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction
the property is situate:
Provided that a suit to obtain relief respecting, or compensation for
wrong to, immovable property held by or on behalf of the defendant may,
where the relief sought can be entirely obtained through his personal
obedience, be instituted either in the Court within the local limits of whose
jurisdiction the property is situate, or in the Court within the local limits
of whose jurisdiction the defendant actually and voluntarily resides, or
carries on business, or personally works for gain.”
57.
Therefore, these prayers are not maintainable before this Court.
58.
Furthermore, it is the defendant‟s own case in her written statement
that the subject properties are ancestral properties where Mr. Onkar Nath
Tandon lived with his extended joint family. Neither has she pleaded any
particulars regarding any partition of the same in the said extended joint
family, nor are members of the same impleaded as parties to the
suit/counter-claim. These prayers are not maintainable for the said reasons
as well.
59.
In view thereof, issues no. (iv) and (v) are answered in the negative.
Issue no. (vi)
60.
Considering the findings in the other issues and the defendant having
not been held entitled to any amount, issue no. (vi) is answered in the
negative.
Conclusion
61.
In light of the foregoing discussion, the suit, as well as the
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
counterclaim are dismissed for being devoid of merits. Decree of dismissal
be drawn in terms of this judgment.
(PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV)
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 27, 2026
Nc/amg
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
10:52:31
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review