Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010557002024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
[3327]
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE 17th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SREENIVASA REDDY
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3075/2024
Between:
1. PULICHERLA SATYANARAYANA, S/O. LATE. PULICHERLA
SUBBA RAO, AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS, OCC TIMBER
BUSINESS, R/O. 14/251, NEAR SAKTHI GUDI TEMPLE,
EDEPALLI, MACHILIPATNAM, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. PULICHERLA VENU BABU, S/O. LATE. PULICHERLA
SUBBARAO, AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS, OCC CARPENTER,
R/O. 14/251, NEAR SAKTHI GUDI TEMPLE, EDEPALLI,
MACHILIPATNAM, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
2. PULICHERLA CHANDRA RAO, , S/O. LATE. PULICHERLA
SUBBARAO, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, OCC UNEMPLOYEE,
R/O. 14/251, NEAR SAKTHI GUDI TEMPLE, EDEPALLI,
MACHILIPATNAM, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
3. AKKIPALLI
VIJAYALAKSHMI,
W/O.
AKKIPALLI
HANUMANTHA RAO, AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS, OCC
HOUSEWIFE, R/O. 31,
AISWARYA ESTATE, KOTTA
PATTU, PONNAMALAI, TIRUCHY, T.N.
4. PULICHERLA DURGA PRASAD, S/O. LATE. PULICHERLA
SUBBARAO, AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS, OCC REAL ESTATE
BUSINESS, R/O. TARA TOWERS, SEETHAPHALMUNDY,
HYDERABAD, T.G.
5. BHATRAJU ANURADHA, W/O. BHATRAJU SRINIVAS,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS, OCC HOUSEWIFE, R/O. 26-124,
MALAKAPATNAM, MACHILIPATNAM, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
(RESPONDENTS NO. 1 TO 3 AND 5 WERE SET EXPARTE
IN THE MAIN SUIT. HENCE THEY ARE NOT NECESSARY
PARTIES)
...RESPONDENT(S):
SRK, J
CRP No.3075 of 2024
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, praying
that in the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High
Court may be pleased to present this Memorandum of Civil Revision
Petition having been aggrieved by the docket order dated 11-112024 passed in lA. No. 768 of 2024 in O.S. No. Ill of 2016, on the
file of Principle Civil Judge (Senior Division), Machilipatnam
IA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to stay all further proceedings in
O.S. No. Ill of 2016 on the file of the Hon'ble Principle Civil 3udge
(Senior Division), Machilipatnam and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. C B ADARSH KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1.
The Court made the following:
SRK, J
CRP No.3075 of 2024
ORDER
The present Civil Revision Petition came to be filed,
challenging the Order dated 11.11.2024 passed in I.A.No.768 of
2024 in O.S.No.111 of 2016 by the learned Principal Civil Judge
(Senior Division), Machilipatnam (for brevity „the trial Court‟),
whereby and whereunder, the application filed under Section 151 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for brevity „CPC‟), to reopen the
matter to file application to issue summons to one Pulicherla
Suribabu, was dismissed.
2.
Petitioner herein is the plaintiff, respondents herein are
the defendants, in O.S.No.111 of 2016 pending on the file of the
learned Principal Civil Judge (Senior Division), Machilipatnam. The
parties hereinafter are referred to, as they were arrayed in the suit
proceedings pending before the trial Court.
3.
Plaintiff filed O.S.No.111 of 2016 against the defendants
pending on the file of the Principal Civil Judge (Senior Division),
Machilipatnam, seeking the Court to pass a Preliminary Decree in
the above suit for Partition and separate possession of suit
properties, into six equal shares with reference to good and bad
qualities, and delivery of possession of one such share to the
plaintiff, and the remaining such shares to the defendants, equally.
SRK, J
CRP No.3075 of 2024
In the said suit, the defendants filed written statement denying the
contents of the plaint.
4.
While the said suit is pending for adjudication, plaintiff
filed I.A.No.768 of 2024 in O.S.No.111 of 2016 under Section 151 of
CPC seeking reopen of the matter, for filing application to issue
summons to one Pulichearla Suribabu and to give evidence before
the trial Court.
5.
The trial Court vide Order dated 11.11.2024 passed the
following Order in I.A.No.768 of 2024:
“Respondent No.4 reported no counter. Since
I.A.No.769 of 2024 is dismissed, this petition is
dismissed.”
Aggrieved of the said impugned Order, the present Civil
Revision Petition came to be filed.
6.
Learned counsel for the plaintiff contends that even
though the respondent No.4 reported no objection for allowing of
I.A.No.768 of 2024, the trial Court dismissed the subject application,
without discussing the contentions, straightaway passed the
impugned Order without any judicial reasons, and in the absence of
the same, the impugned Order is indefensible and unsustainable.
7.
At the stage of admission, this Court vide Order dated
11.12.2024 permitted the plaintiff to take notice to defendant No.4,
SRK, J
CRP No.3075 of 2024
and accordingly, notice was taken out to 4th defendant, but the same
returned unserved.
8.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner/plaintiff.
Perused the entire material available on record.
9.
A perusal of the contents of the affidavit filed by the
plaintiff in I.A.No.768 of 2024 goes to show that the suit in
O.S.No.111 of 2016 was filed as against the defendants for Partition
of the schedule properties, and to allot one such share to the plaintiff
in the schedule property. The defendant Nos.1 to 4 filed written
statement contending that Ex.B1-Will dated 02.01.2015 was alleged
to have been executed by their deceased father viz. Subba Rao in
their favour, who died on 12.01.2015. In the course of same
transaction, the defendant Nos.1 to 4 got examined 2nd attestor and
scribe of the alleged Will, who are kith and kin, but surprisingly,
avoided to examine 1st attestor. The said factum came to be known,
while the learned counsel for plaintiff was preparing for arguments in
the subject matter. In view of the said reason, the subject application
was filed, seeking the trial Court to reopen the matter to issue
summons to one Pulichearla Suribabu to give evidence before the
Court in the aforesaid matter.
SRK, J
10.
CRP No.3075 of 2024
Irrespective of the same, a perusal of the impugned
Order, dated 11.11.2024 passed by the trial Court in I.A.No.768 of
2024 goes to show that respondent No.4, who is none other than 4th
defendant, reported no counter. Whether the same would amount to
no objection or not, is not known, but going by the impugned Order,
dated 11.11.2024 passed by the trial Court, this Court is of the
opinion that a cryptic order has been passed by the trial Court
without assigning any reason as to why the petition was dismissed,
more so, when respondent No.4/D4 reported no counter.
11.
Time and again, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court and this
Court has consistently held that not only administrative order but
also judicial order, that has been passed, shall contain reasons. It is
needless to mention herein that the Court is bound to give reasons
while coming to a conclusion. Right to reason is an indefeasible part
of sound judicial system. A party must know the reason as to why a
case went against him. The hallmark of Order and exercise of
judicial power by a judicial forum is that the forum has to disclose its
reasons by itself, and giving of reasons has always been insisted
upon as one of the fundamentals of sound administration of the
justice-delivery system. By virtue of the same, it can safely be
inferred that there shall be application of mind while passing a
SRK, J
CRP No.3075 of 2024
reasoned order. In a case rendered by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
in Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin and another1, it was held as
under: (paragraph No.33)
“33.
It is a settled legal proposition that not only
administrative order, but also judicial order must be supported by
reasons in it. Thus, while deciding an issue, the Court is bound to
give reasons for its conclusion. It is the duty and obligation on the
part of the Court to record reasons while disposing of the case.
The hallmark of order and exercise of judicial power by a judicial
forum is for the forum to disclose its reasons by itself and giving
of reasons has always been insisted upon as one of the
fundamentals of sound administration of the justice – delivery
system, to make it known that there had been proper and due
application of mind to the issue before the Court and also as an
essential requisite of the principles of natural justice. The reason
is the heartbeat of every conclusion. It introduces clarity in an
order and without the same, the order become lifeless. Reasons
substitute subjectivity with objectivity. The absence of reasons
renders an order indefensible/unsustainable particularly when the
order is subject to further challenge before a higher forum.
Recording of reasons is principle of natural justice and every
judicial order must be supported by reasons recorded in writing. It
ensures transparency and fairness in decision making. The
person who is adversely affected must know why his application
has been rejected. (Vide: State of Orissa v. Dhaniram Luhar, AIR
2004 SC 1794: State of Uttaranchal & Anr. V. Sunil Kumar Singh
Negi, AIR 2008 SC 2026; The Secretary & Curator, Victoria
Memorial Hall v. Howrah Ganatantrik Nagrik Samity & Ors., AIR
2010 SC 1285; and Sant Lal Gupta & Ors. V. Modern
(2012) 8 SCC 148.
SRK, J
CRP No.3075 of 2024
Cooperative Group Housing Society Limited & Ors., (2010) 13
SCC 336).
Further, in a case rendered by the Hon‟ble Apex Court in
Madhyamam Broadcasting Limited v. Union of India2, it was held
as under: (paragraph No.56)
“56.
The principles of natural justice ensure that justice
is not only done but it is seen to be done as well. A reasoned
order
is
one
of
the
fundamental
requirements
of
fair
administration. It holds utmost significance in ensuring fairness;
scholars and courts now term it as the third principle of natural
justice. [See SN Mukherjee v. Union of India (1990) 4 SCC 594;
Seimens Engineering and Manufacturing Company v. Union of
India, (1976) 2 SCC 981; CCI v. SAIL (2010) 10 SCC 744; Kranti
Associates v. Masood Ahmed Khan, 2010 (9) SCC 496] The rule
of a reasoned order serves five important purposes. Firstly, it
ensures transparency and accountability. It places a check on
arbitrary exercise of power. Lord Denning observed that in giving
reasons “lies a whole difference between a judicial decision and
an arbitrary one”. [Sir Alfred Denning, Freedom Under the Law
(Stevens and Sons 1949) p.92.] Justice Bhagwati observed in
Maneka Gandhi (supra) that the rule is “designed to secure the
rule of law and the court should not be too ready to eschew it in
its application to a given case.” Secondly, non-reasoned orders
have the practical effect of placing the decision out of the purview
of judicial review. A non-reasoned order limits the power of the
courts to exercise judicial review because the scope of judicial
review is not limited to the final finding on law or facts but extends
to the reasons to arrive at the finding. A limitation on the right to
appeal necessarily means that the scope of judicial review is
(2023) 10 SCR 595.
SRK, J
CRP No.3075 of 2024
restricted. Thirdly, articulation of reasons aids in arriving at a just
decision by minimalizing concerns of arbitrary state action. [Rani
Lakshmi Bai Kshetriya Gramin Bank v. Jagdish Dharan
Varshney, (2009) 4 SCC 240.] It introduces clarity of thought
[State of West Bengal v. Alpana Roy, (2005) 8 SCC 296.] and
eschews irrelevant and extraneous considerations. Fourthly, it
enhances the legitimacy of the institution because decisions will
appear to be fair. There is a higher probability that the finding
through a reasoned order is just. Fifthly, reasoned orders are in
furtherance of the right to information and the constitutional goal
of open government. Secrecy broods partiality, corruption and
other vices that are antithetical to a governance model that is
premised on the rule of law.
12.
As discussed in the preceding paragraphs, a perusal of
the impugned Order dated 11.11.2024 passed by the learned
Principal Civil Judge (Senior Division), Machilipatnam goes to show
that there is no reason assigned by the learned trial Judge while
passing the impugned Order. Therefore, in view of the aforesaid
facts and circumstances of the case, since no reasons have been
assigned by the trial Court, the impugned Order dated 11.11.2024
passed in I.A.No.768 of 2024 in O.S.No.111 of 2016 by the learned
Principal Civil Judge (Senior Division), Machilipatnam, is set-aside,
and the matter is remanded Court below, with a direction to hear the
matter afresh, by providing opportunity to both parties, and in case,
respondent No.4/D4 reports no objection, the learned trial Judge is
SRK, J
CRP No.3075 of 2024
directed to record the same, and disposed of, the subject application
by passing a reasoned order, within a period of four (04) weeks from
the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
13.
Accordingly, the Civil Revision Petition is disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs of the CRP.
As a sequel, interlocutory applications pending, if any, in the
Revision Petition shall stand closed.
JUSTICE K. SREENIVASA REDDY
th
17 September, 2026.
DNB/ASN
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review