Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
W.P.A. No. 25431 of 2024
Propello Innovations Private Limited & Anr.
Vs.
South India Bank Limited & Anr.
Mr. Deepan Sarkar
Mr. Shahrukh Raja
Ms. Deepti Priya
....For the petitioners.
Mr. Prabal Mukherjee, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Anirban Pramanick
Mr. Punarbasu Nath
Ms. Bhagyasree Dey
…. For the respondent bank.
Mr. Dilip Kumar Kundu
Mr. Arjun Basu
…. For R.B.I.
Hearing Concluded On : 02.02.2026
Judgment On
: 26.02.2026
Krishna Rao, J.:
1.
The petitioners have filed the present writ petition challenging an e-mail
dated 5th July, 2024 and the notice dated 8th July, 2024, wherein and
where under the bank has declared the account of the petitioner as
Non-Performance Assets hereinafter referred to as “NPA”.
2.
The petitioner company is a Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises
hereafter referred to as “MSME”. In the year 2013, the petitioners
availed credit facilities from the respondent bank for expansion of their
business. On 7th March, 2020, the loans taken by the petitioners were
restructured by the respondent bank and the pre-existing credit
facilities in the accounts of the petitioner company were renewed. Soon
after restructuring the whole world suffered due to COVID-19
pandemic, the petitioners could not revive its business despite of
restructuring. In the meantime, several correspondences were made
between the petitioners and the respondents.
3.
On 19th June, 2024, the bank has issued an e-mail to the petitioners
informing that the accounts of the petitioner company will be declared
as NPA on 24th June, 2024, due to credit shortfall and also
continuously overdrawn and pending overdue in respect of the four
bank accounts of the petitioner company.
4.
Mr. Deepan Sarkar, Learned Advocate, representing the petitioners
submits that on 28th June, 2024, the petitioners received a WhatsApp
message from the bank instructing the petitioners to deposit Rs.
40,000/- by the same day and an additional amount of Rs. 5,80,000/by the next day so that the bank accounts of the petitioner company
are not declared as NPA. As per instructions, the petitioners
immediately deposited the said amount.
5.
Mr. Sarkar submits that despite of depositing the said amount, on 30th
June, 2024, an amount of Rs. 14,58,063/- was debited from the CCOL
account of the petitioner company without any prior notice to the
petitioners.
The
bank
has
further
debited
an
amount
of
Rs.
1,03,287.56/- without any prior notice to the petitioners. He submits
that when the petitioners enquired from the bank with regard to the
deduction of the said amount, the bank informed the petitioners that
the same was deducted as penal charges for delayed payment.
6.
Mr. Sarkar submits that on 5th July, 2024, the petitioners received an
e-mail wherein the bank has declared the account of the petitioners as
NPA on 30th June, 2024. On 8th July, 2024, the petitioners also
received a registered letter from the bank declaring the account of the
petitioners as NPA. He submits that the bank has illegally deducted
penal interest and additional interest without giving any prior
intimation to the petitioners.
7.
Mr. Sarkar submits that on 11th July, 2024, the petitioners have
submitted new plan for restructuring but without considering the
request of restructuring, the bank has issued a recall notice and
guarantee invocation letter to the petitioners on 22nd July, 2024,
demanding payment of Rs. 92,017,526.20/-. On 7th August, 2024, the
bank has also issued a notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act,
2002 to the petitioner no. 1, thus the petitioners have filed the present
writ petition.
8.
During the pendency of the writ petition, the petitioners have sent an
increased offer of compromise for One Time Settlement (OTS) and the
same was accepted by the bank on 30th August, 2025 but the
petitioners were some issues with regard to the conditions of the OTS.
The petitioners have deposited an amount of Rs. 5,00,000/- on 31st
August, 2025 and submitted a request for modification of the
conditions in the OTS. The petitioners failed to pay the next instalment
and due to which the bank has cancelled the OTS on 2nd January,
2026.
9.
Mr. Sarkar has relied upon the judgment in the case of Olive Tree
Retail Pvt. Ltd. and Another Vs. South Indian Bank Ltd. and
Another reported in 2023 SCC OnLine Cal 2397 and submits that
appropriate stage to move Tribunal having not yet been reached and it
would be too early to move the Tribunal and the writ petition is the
appropriate remedy. He submits that the bank has illegally classified
the accounts of the petitioners as NPA and thus the same is not
amenable to Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act, 2002.
10. Mr. Sarkar submits that the Reserve Bank of India circulars have
statutory force and are binding upon the constituent banks and the
financial institutions who are under the statutory obligation to comply
with the provisions of the circulars.
11. Mr. Prabal Mukherjee, Learned Senior Advocate, representing the
respondent bank submits that the petitioners have deposited certain
amounts in each cash credit account but it was not within the limit of
Rs. 06.50 crores till 28th June, 2024. He submits that on 29th June,
2024 and 30th June, 2024, interest were debited as a result the balance
in the cash credit account as on 30th June, 2024, stood at Rs.
6,65,61,350.56 and the account was classified as NPA on 30th June,
2024.
12. Mr. Mukherjee submits that the Reserve Bank of India had issued
directions to levy of penal interest, which was laid down in para 5 of the
Master Direction dated 3rd March, 2016. He submits that subsequently
the said penal interest was deleted by way of an amendment on Fair
Lending Practice–Penal Charges in Loan Accounts dated 18th August,
2023 and the directions were replaced.
13. Mr. Mukherjee submits that as per Circular on Fair Lending PracticePenal Charges in Loan Accounts dated 18th August, 2023, whenever
reminders for non-compliance of material terms and conditions of loan
are sent to
borrowers, the applicable penal charges shall be
communicated. Further, any instance of levy of penal charges and the
reason therefor shall also be communicated.
14. Mr. Mukherjee submits that as per Circular dated 29th December,
2023, REs shall ensure that the instructions contained in circular
dated 18th August, 2023, are implemented in respect of all the fresh
loan availed from 1st April, 2024 onwards, and in the case of existing
loans, the switchover to new penal charges regime shall be ensured on
the next review/ renewal date falling on or after 1st April, 2024, but not
later than 30th June, 2024.
15. Mr. Mukherjee submits that if the petitioners believe that their account
has been wrongly classified as NPA, the petitioners can approach the
RBI Ombudsman Scheme, 2021, which came into effect on 12th
November, 2021.
16. By an e-mail dated 5th July, 2024, the bank has informed the
petitioners that the account of the petitioners became NPA on 30th
June, 2024 and the petitioners were advised to regularize the account
at the earliest. On 8th July, 2024, the bank by a registered letter also
informed the petitioners about the classification of the account of the
petitioners as NPA as on 30th June, 2024. In the said letter, it was also
informed to the petitioners that since the status of the account is
downgraded as NPA, the applicable effective rate of interest from the
date of NPA along with additional penal interest will also be applicable.
After classification of the account of the petitioners as NPA, the bank
also issued a notice under Section 13(2) of the SERFAESI Act, 2002.
17. The petitioners have relied upon WhatsApp massages between the
official of the bank and the petitioners dated 28th June, 2024, wherein
as per the advice of the bank official, the petitioners have deposited the
amount of Rs. 40,000/- and Rs. 5,80,000/- in between 28th June, 2024
and 29th June, 2024. After depositing the said amount, the bank has
deducted an amount of Rs. 14,58,063/- on 30th June, 2024, being
interest from 1st June, 2024 to 30th June, 2024 and Rs. 1,03,287.56/on 30th June, 2024, being interest from 31st May, 2024 to 28th June,
2024. It is the contention of the petitioners that as per advice of the
bank, the petitioners have deposited the said amount but without any
prior notice to the petitioners, the bank has withdrawn the amount
from the account of the petitioner company. The bank has verbally
informed to the petitioners that the amount was deducted from the
bank account of the petitioner company as the penal interest against
the delay in payment.
18. Clause 2 of the Master Circular dated 1st April, 2022, reads as follows:
“2. Non-performing Assets (NPA)
2.1 Classification of Assets as Non-Performing
2.1.1 A non-performing asset is a loan or an
advance where:
(i) Interest and/or installment of principal
remain overdue for a period of more than 90
days in respect of a Term Loan.
(ii) The account remains ‘out of order’, in
respect of an Overdraft/Cash Credit (OD/CC)
and all other loan products being offered as
an overdraft facility, including those not meant
for business purposes and/or which entail
interest repayments as the only credits.
(iii) The bill remains overdue for a period of
more than 90 days in the case of bills
purchase and discounted.
(iv) In the case of direct agricultural advances
as listed in Annex 1, the overdue norm
specified at para 2.1.3 would be applicable. In
respect of agricultural loans other than those
specified in Annex 1, identification of NPAs
would be done on the same basis as nonagricultural advances.
(v) Any amount to be received remains overdue
for a period of more than 90 days in respect of
other accounts.
(vi) In addition, an account may also be
classified as NPA in terms of certain specific
provisions of this Master Circular, including
inter alia paragraphs 2.2.7 and clarifications
provided under the frequently asked questions
(FAQs) in Annex-4.
2.1.2 (A) The exact due dates for repayment of a
loan, frequency of repayment, breakup between
principal and interest, examples of SMA/NPA
classification dates, etc. should be clearly specified
in the loan agreement and the borrower should be
apprised of the same at the time of loan sanction
and also at the time of subsequent changes, if any,
to the sanction terms/loan agreement till full
repayment of the loan.”
19. The Reserve Bank of India by a letter dated 18th August, 2023, issued
instructions to all commercial banks and all financial institutions
regarding Fair Lending Practice-Penal Charges in Loan Accounts. As
per the said clarification, penalty, if charged, for non-compliance of
materials terms and conditions of loan contract by the borrower shall
be treated as ‘penal charges’ and shall not be levied in the form of
‘penal interest’ that is added to the rate of interest charged on the
advances. There shall be no capitalization of penal charges i.e. no
further interest computed on such charges. However, this will not affect
the normal procedures for computing of interest in the loan account.
The REs shall not introduce any additional component to the rate of
interest and ensure compliance to these guidelines in both letter and
spirit. It is also provided that the quantum of penal charges shall be
reasonable and commensurate with the non-compliance of the material
terms and conditions of the loan contract without being discriminatory
within a particular loan/ product category. It is also provided that
whenever reminders for non-compliance of material terms and
conditions of loan are sent to borrowers, the applicable penal charges
shall be communicated. Further, any instance of levy of penal charges
and the reason therefor shall also be communicated.
20. On 19th June, 2024, the bank has issued notice to the petitioners
intimating that the accounts of your petitioners will slip to NPA on 24th
June, 2024, due to credit shortfall and subsequently due to
continuously overdrawn and pending over dues. In the said notice, it is
mentioned that the cash credit limit is continuously overdrawn from
31st March, 2024 and has to be within limit by 28th June, 2024. Term
Loan critical amount of Rs. 3.33 Lakhs on 29th June, 2024.
21. The bank has issued a notice to the petitioners on 19th June, 2024,
informing that the accounts of the petitioners will slip to NPA on 24th
June, 2024 and by an email dated 5th July, 2024, it was informed to
the petitioners that the accounts of the petitioners turns NPA on 30th
June, 2024.
22. As per Master Circular, an account should be treated as ‘out of order’, if
the outstanding balance in the cash credit or overdraft account remains
continuously in excess of the sanctioned limit/ drawing power for 90
days.
23. Any amount due to the bank under any credit facility, if not paid by the
due date fixed by the bank, becomes overdue. The bank has issued the
notice on 19th June, 2024, to the petitioners informing the over dues. In
the said notice, it is categorically mentioned that the account of the
petitioners will slip to NPA on 24th June, 2024, inspite of receipt of the
said notice, the petitioners have not regularized the said account. The
notice further reflects that the cash credit account of the petitioners, is
continuously overdue from 31st March, 2024, thus the bank has rightly
classified the account of the petitioners as NPA on 29th June, 2024 i.e.
after 90 days.
24. The petitioners have deposited the amount of Rs. 40,000/- and Rs.
5,80,000/- in the loan account on 28th June, 2024 and 29th June, 2024
and the bank has realized that the said amount as penal interest. In
the notice dated 19th June, 2024, the bank has not informed about the
levy of penal interest. The amount is deducted from the account of the
petitioners as penal interest without any prior notice to the petitioners.
25. As per Clause 3(vii) of the Fair Lending Practice-Penal Charges in Loan
Accounts dated 18th August, 2023, the applicable penal charges, levy of
penal charges and the reason therefor is to be communicated to the
borrowers but in the present case, no such communication is made to
the petitioners for levy of penal charges before deducting the amount
from the account of the petitioners.
26. This Court finds that the bank has violated the guidelines for Fair
Lending Practice–Penal Charges in Loan Accounts by realizing the
amount from the account of the petitioners as penal interest in
violation of Clause 3(vii) of the guidelines issued by the Reserve Bank of
India dated 18th August, 2023.
27. The respondent bank has challenged the maintainability of the present
writ petition but this Court finds that the petitioners have challenged
the act of the bank on the allegation of violation of the conditions for
Fair Lending Practice-Penal Charges in Loan Accounts issued by the
Reserve Bank of India, thus this Court is of the view that the writ
petition is maintainable.
28. W.P.A. No. 25431 of 2024 is disposed of. Interim order is vacated.
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review