The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. For the foregoing reasons, this contempt case is closed l[ an amount of Rs.3,7 1,155/- anrl Rs 1,96,875/- are not paid/credited to the petitioner, respondent No.2 is directed to pay or credit the above said amounts either to thc petitioner or to his bank account' within a period of two (2) weeks lrom today and file a Memo before the Registry. ln default, the Registry is directed to post this contempt case after tr,l'o u'er:ks' Miscellaneous appli<:atrons, pending if any' shall stand closed SD/. N.CHANDRA SEKHAR RAO //TRUE COPY// To, ^^ J Two CCs to GP for Services l, High Court of Telangana at Hyderabad [OUTI Sri Hara Gopal, Party in person, R/o. 11-1 3-4'16, Road No 14, Alkapuri' Hyderabad. Two CD Copies The S O., O.S Section (With a direction) ry- GNK/KA DATED: 1010712026 o fj \n /^,, i: $r i, IJ- CC.No.2528 ot 2024 (- ""s 9': ,..]\ lr t tt.i r e P{ i': b I,
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3303 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO
CONTEM PT CASE NO: 2528 OF 2024
Contempt Case filed Under Sections 10 to 12 of Contempt of Courts Act,
1971 to punish the respondents herein for willfully disobeying the final orders of the
'1451 of 2017 High Court dated 06.10.2023 passed in WP(TR) No
Between:
Prof. M.Haragopal Rao, S/o Sri. M. Lakshmi Kanth Rao, Aged about 76 years, Jt'
Director (Retd) Government Junior colleges, on deputation as Professor,
Educational Research and Training Wing, Board of intermediate Education, A.P.
Hyderabad., R/o.1'1-1 3-416, Road No.'14, Alkapuri, Hyderabad.
...Petitioner
AND
1. Sri. Burra Venkatesham, lAS., Principal Secretary to Government of
Telangana, Higher Education (lE '1) Department, Telangana State Secretariat,
Hyderabad.
2. Sri S. Krishna Aditya. lAS, The Commissioner iDirector of intermediate
Education, State of Telangana, Nampally, Hyderabad, Telangana State.
... Respondents
Counsel for the Petitioner: Sri. HARA GOPAL, party in person
Counsel for the Respondents: Sri. S. Sathyanarayana Rao, GP for SERVICES I
The Court made the following: ORDER
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE J. SREENIVAS RAO
CONTEMPT CA SE No.2528 of2024
ORDER:
Thrs contempt case has been filed seeking to punish the
respondents/ con Lemnors for r,,,illful11. disobeying rhe order passed
b.y this Court dateci 06.|0.2023 passed in W.p (TR) No.145t
of
2017, by invoking the provrsions of Sections t0 to 12 of the
Conlempt of Courts Act, 197 1
2.
.
Mr. M. Hara Gopal, lr,ho rs the petitioner in the contempt
case, appeared as a party in_person. Though he has engaged
counsel, he requestcd this Court to permit him to argue
his case
on his or,r. n.
3.
Heard
the
petitioner/ party_in-person,
and
Mr. S. Satyanarayana Rao, learned Government pleader for
Services-[ appearing for the respondents/ contemnors.
4.
Submissions oflearned petitioner/party_in_person:
I-earned pe trtioncr/ partv_in_person submrtre d
Cour1., whiie disposrng oI W.l). (TR) No.l45l
ol 2C17, directecl the
respondents to calculate ancl pay inlerest from
retircment i.e., 3LOg.2006, till the date of
the date of his
realiza tion /@ 9 o/o per
annum, in respect of belarccl disbursement
pensionary beneflts. In spite of the same,
that this
cl. pension and
the responden[s harze
Z
not implemented the said order' He further submitted that
e
he is
ntitled to an amount of Rs.25,48,630/ - towards interest from
date of his retirement i e , 3 1 08'2006 til1 the
9a/o per annum in respect of belated
the
date of realization @
disbursement of pension and
pensionary benefits; and Rs 2,12,625/- towards 9%o
interesL on
gratuity, the total amount PaYable bY the resPondents
1S
Rs.27 ,61 ,255 I '.
4.
4.1
Submissions of learned Government Pleader:
. Learned Government Pleader submitted that pursuant to the
directions issued by thrs Court in W P (TR) No
06.1O.2023, the respondents calculated
1451 of 2O17' dated
interest @ 9ok per annum
fromthedateofretirementofthepetitroneri.e.,on3l'08'2006,till
the date of realization towards the belated
and pensionary benefits As per the said
disbursement of pension
calculation' the petitioner
isentitledtoanamountofRs.3,Tl,l55/-towardsinterest(@9%
2006 to
per annum for the delayed payment from 31 08
21.06.2073. He further submitted that
there was no delay on the
part of the respondents in payment of pension
01.01.2013 to 2l 06'2013 Hence'
the bill for an amount of
I{s.3,71,155/ was Passecl ancl Cheque
23.O3 .2026, was generated
for the pertod from
N<t.26O3776248' dated
Ile further submitted that the
petitloner is also entitled to an amount of Rs.I 96,875l- tov,.ards
interest on gratuity and, in respect of th,t same, Cheque
No.260372O7 60, dated 23.O3.2026, was generatcl.
4.2. Thus, the respondents have implemented the order passed
by lhis Court, dated 06.10.2023, in W.P. (TR) BNo 1,451 of 2017.
'lherefore, the petitioner is not entitled to the alle.ged huge amount
claimed in hrs reply, datccl 1O.O4.2026. Hence, the conrempt case
filed by the petitioner is liable ro be closed.
Analysis:
5.
Having considered the rival submissior: s made by the
respective parties and upon perusal of the material available on
record, it reveals that this Court disposed of W.p. (TR) No.145i of
2077 on 06.70.2023. The operative portion of the order dated
06.1O.2023 reads as follows:
"... Respondents are directed to calculate and
pay interest from the date of his retir:ment i.e.,
31.08.2006 till the date of reaiization (1t,9o/o per annum
to the petitioner in respect of belated drsbr-:rsement of
pension and pensionary benefits. It is madr: clear that
the said exercise shall be completed within a period of
tu,o (2) months from the date of receipt ot'a copy of
this order. "
contemnors
Thereafter, the respondents /
filed a review Petltlon 1n
Court dismissed
I.A.No.2 of 2025 and this
the said application on
16.07.2025.
6.
during
Learned Government Pleader'
dated
placed the written instructions'
stated that respondent
Education, uide
g1 .O3.2026'
31 O3 2026' wherein it
No 2 / the Director
l,r.ltc. No.ClE-StrR 1/ PR/
addressed
a
the course of heanng
is
of Intermediate
1/ 2024-SER-I'
dated
letter dated 19 OA 2025 to
the
this court
to rmplement Lhe order of
steps
take
to
Government
No'2 uide Memo
to the same' respondent
Pursuant
sanction for
l l2|lg dated 04 03'2026' accorcled
annum towards beiated
9%
Per
@
interest
of
payment
No.5657/IE A
and pensionary
disbursement of pension
benefi ts from the date
of
i e ' 3 i 08
retirement of the petltioner
of
2006 ' ti11 the date
the said Memo'
realization. Pursuant to
the office of respondent
No.2
issued
proceedrngs uide
dated 06032026'
SERl/PCH1/ 1/2024-StrR1'
Proc Rc No ClE
The record further
that
the Accounts Officer determined
calculation'
upon
reveals that
towards
to an amount of Rs 3'71'155/entitled
was
the petitioner
'rhe
payment of pension.
derayed
the
for
rnterest @ 9ok per annum
Rs 1'96'875/entitled to an amount of
found
also
was
petitioner
towards interest on gratuity, Accordingly, Cheque bearing
No.2603776248 for an amount of Rs.3,71,155/- dated 23.O3.2026
and Cheque No.2603720760 for an amount of Rs,1,96,g75/ dated
23.O3.2026 were generated.
7.
It is an undisputed fact that the respondents have not
rmplemented the order passed by this Court wit.rin the stipulated
time. It is also not in disputc thar only after lil ng of the present
contempt case, the respondents have filed Review petition in
LA.No.2 of 2023 seeking review of the order passed bv this Court
and this Court on 16.07 .2025 dismissed the sairi Review petition.
Thereafter, the respondents have taken steps r.o implement the
orders of this Court and calculated the amount payable to the
petitioner.
E.
According to the respondcnts, the petitionc: is entitlecl Lo an
amount of Rs.3,71,1 51/ to,*,ards interest @ 9o/o per annum for the
delayed payment of pension and Rs. l,96,g7Sl_ towards interest on
gratuitlr, whereas the petitioner is claiming an amount of
l?s.27,61 ,255/-.
9.
It is relevant to mention rhat this Court, r.r.hile disposing of
W.P, (TR) No.1451 of 20IT, direcred rhe respond:,ts to calculate
and pay interest from the date of retirement
(1t: 9a/o pet annum
31.08.2006 ti1l the date of re alization
of belated disbursement of pension
Court has not issued any specihc
of the petltloner 1 e '
in respect
and pensionary benefits This
direction to the respondents to
pay any particular amount and only
directed them to calculate and
pay interest @ 9o/o per annum from 31
realization on the belated disbursement
08 2006 ti11 the date of
of pension and pensionary
view that whether
benefits. Hence, this court is of the considered
is true or not' and
the amount determined by the respondents
an amount of Rs 27 '61'2551 -
whether the petitloner is enlitleil to
same
as per his calculations sheet' the
cannot be examined or
as the scope of
proceedings,
adjudicated in the present Contempt
is limited' However' the
present contempt case proceedings
the
petitioner is granted liberty to work
out his remedies in accordance
with law
10.
It is very much relevant to mention that
Court in Jhareswar Prasad Paul
the Hon'ble Apex
and a'lother v' Tarak Nath
No 1 1 , it is held that
canguly and othersl, rn paragraPh
-11.. .... The power to punish for contempt of
'i"
the
special po*ti vested under
under
and also
^
"orra"
Constitution in the courf, of recordancl needs to be
the statute. The power is special
1 [2002) 5 scc 352
exercised with care and caution. It shoukl be used
sparingly by the courts on being satrsfied regarding
the true effect of contemptuous conduct. lt is to be
kept in mind that the court exercising the jr-rrisdiction
to punish for contempt does not func Li,ln as an
original or appellate court for determination of the
disputes betu'een the parties. The contempt
jurisdiction should be confined to the question
whether there has been any deliberate disobedience
of the order of the court and if the cond-rct of the
party u,ho is alleged to have committed such
disobedience is contumacious. The court exercising
contempt jurisdiction is not entitled lo ':nter into
questions lvhich have not been dealt u'ith and
decided in the j udgment or order, violation of which
is alleged by the applicant. The court has to consider
the direction issued in the judgment or order and not
to consrder the question as to what the judgment or
order should have contained. At the cost of repetition
be il stated here that the court excrcising contempt
jurisdiction is primarilv concerned u'ith th,: question
ol contumacious conduct of the party, r,"hich alleged
to have committed deliberate default in complying
with the drrections in the judgment or order. If the
judgment or order does not contain an1- specific
direction regarding a mal[cr or jf thele is any
ambiguity in thc directions jssued therern then it rvil.l
bc better to direct Lhe parties to approach lhe court
rvhich disposed of the matler for clarification of the
order instead of the court exercising contempt
jurisdiction taking upon itself the power to decide the
original proceeding in a manner no[ dealt v'ith by the
court passing the judgment or order,"
1. In lhe above said judgment, the Hon'ble Apex Court
specifically held that the Court exercising conter-rpt jurisdiction is
not entilled to enter into qucstions which have not been dealt with
and de cided in thc audgmen l. or order. In the c.rse on hand, it is
u
already stated supro, this Court has not given any specific
direction to the respondents to pay particular amount or determine
the entitlement of monetary scrvice benefits to the petitioner; and
the calculation and delermination made by the respondents and
the claim made by the petitioncr, cannot be adjudicated or decided
in the present contempt proceedings'
12. For the foregoing reasons, this contempt case is closed l[ an
amount of Rs.3,7 1,155/- anrl Rs 1,96,875/- are not paid/credited
to the petitioner, respondent No.2 is directed to pay or credit the
above said amounts either to thc petitioner or to his bank account'
within a period of two (2) weeks lrom today and file a Memo before
the Registry. ln default, the Registry is directed to post this
contempt case after tr,l'o u'er:ks'
Miscellaneous appli<:atrons, pending if any' shall stand
closed
SD/. N.CHANDRA SEKHAR RAO
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
^^
J
Two CCs to GP for Services l, High Court of Telangana at Hyderabad [OUTI
Sri Hara Gopal, Party in person, R/o. 11-1 3-4'16, Road No 14, Alkapuri'
Hyderabad.
Two CD Copies
The S O., O.S Section (With a direction)
ry- GNK/KA
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1010712026
o fj
\n
/^,,
i:
ORDER
$r
i,
IJ-
CC.No.2528 ot 2024
(-
""s 9':
,..]\
lr t tt.i r
CLOSING THE CONTEMPT CASE
e
P{
i':
b
I,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review