Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No.2834/2025
Reserved on: 28.01.2026
Pronounced on: 05.02.2026
Uploaded on: 06.02.2026
Priyanka Rakwal D/o Mr. Suresh Kumar W/o Mr. Sunil Manhas
R/o Village Rehari Jangalwar,
Tehsil and District Doda-182202, aged 28 years.
....Petitioner(s)
Through:- Mr. D.S.Chauhan, Advocate with
Ms. Damini Singh Chauhan, Advocate
Versus
1.
Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir
Through its Secretary, High Education Depaprtment, J&K
Government, Civil Secretariat, Jammu-180001
2.
Chairman, Jammu & Kashmir Public Service Commission,
Resham Ghar Colony, Jammu-180001.
3.
Secretary, Jammu & Kashmir Public Service Commission,
Resham Ghar Colony, Jammu-180001.
4.
Arun Kumar Khajuria S/o Mr. Sudershan Khajuria
R/o Barwal, Kathua-184143
...Respondent(s)
Through:- Mr. Ravinder Gupta, AAG for R-1
Mr. M.Y.Akhoon, Advocate vice
Mr.F.A.Natnoo, Advocate for R-2 & 3
Mr. Amit Gupta, Advocate for R-4
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
WP(C) No.2834/2025
JUDGMENT
Sanjeev Kumar J
1.
The petitioner is aggrieved and has challenged an order and
judgment dated 11th July, 2025 passed by the Central
Administrative Tribunal, Jammu Bench, Jammu [“the Tribunal”]
in OA No.1483/2024 titled Ms. Priyanka Rakwal v. Union
Territory of J&K and others by invoking the extraordinary writ
jurisdiction vested in this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
2.
In terms of judgment impugned, the Tribunal has dismissed an
OA filed by the petitioner seeking inter alia a direction to
respondent Nos. 1 to 3 to select and appoint her as Assistant
Professor in the discipline of Botany under EWS category.
3.
Before we advert to the grounds of challenge urged by
Mr. D.S.Chauhan, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner,
we deem it appropriate to sketch briefly the factual antecedents
leading to the filing of this petition.
4.
The Department of Higher Education vide communication dated
5th July, 2021 followed by communication dated 13.04.2022
referred four posts (Open-02, RBA-01 and SC-01) of Assistant
Professor, Botany to the Jammu and Kashmir Public Service
Commission [“the PSC”] for selection. These posts were notified
by the PSC vide notification No. 06-PSC(DR-P) of 2023 dated
WP(C) No.2834/2025
01st March, 2023. While the selection process pursuant to the
aforesaid notification was pending, the department of higher
education vide communication dated 24th March, 2023 referred
19 more posts (OM-09, SC-01, ST-02, ALC/IB-01, SLC-01,
SBA-02, PSP-01 and EWS-02) of Assistant Professor, Botany to
the PSC for making selection. These posts were notified for
selection by the PSC vide advertisement notification No.17PSC(DR-P) of 2023 dated 15.05.2023.
5.
The PSC conducted a common written examination in respect of
both the notifications on 27.08.2023 and declared the result vide
notification No.PSC/Exam/S/2023/53 dated 18.09.2023. The
petitioner as well as respondent No.4, who were the candidates
under EWS category, also participated in the selection process.
Both qualification the examination and were declared shortlisted
for interview/viva-voce, which was held on 26th to 28th
September, 2023. On conclusion of interview process, a
provisional select list for the post of Assistant Professor, Botany,
was issued vide Notification No.74-PSC(DR-S) of 2023 dated
17.10.2023 and two candidates’ namely, Mr. Abbu Zaid (61.65
points) and petitioner (49.10 points) were shown provisionally
selected against the two posts of Assistant Professor under EWS
category. Respondent No.4, who, too had participated in the
process of selection under EWS category, on the strength of
EWS certificate dated 31.05.2023 issued by the Tehsildar,
WP(C) No.2834/2025
Kathua, though having better merit, did not figure in the EWS
list as provisionally selected candidate for the reason that the
EWS certificate dated 31.05.2023, which was submitted by
respondent No.4 before the cut-off date, was not on the
prescribed format and that he submitted EWS certificate in UT
format only on 06.08.2023 i.e. after the cut-off date prescribed in
the advertisement notification.
6.
Be that as it may, the respondent No.4, feeling aggrieved of his
exclusion from the selection, submitted a representation on
20.10.2023 enclosing therewith a clarification issued by the
Tehsildar, Kathua vide letter dated 20.10.2023 and claimed that,
as per the clarification issued by the competent authority, EWS
certificate dated 31.05.2023 was not only genuine but was also in
conformity with the UT format i.e. Form-XIV-A appended with
the J&K Reservation Rules, 2005 [“the Rules of 2005”]
7.
The representation made by respondent No.4 was considered by
the Commission in its meeting held on 25.10.2024 in which it
was decided to withhold the recommendations in respect of one
post of EWS and to consider the representation of respondent
No.4 after affording an opportunity of being heard to the
petitioner, a provisionally selected candidate under EWS
category.
WP(C) No.2834/2025
8.
The PSC considered the representation of respondent No.4 and
provided hearing to the petitioner as well. It was found that
respondent no.4 with merit points 64.08 points was the most
meritorious candidate in the EWS category. It was also found by
the Commission that respondent No.4 did meet the requirements
of obtaining EWS category certificate under the Rules of 2005.
This decision was taken by the Commission in the light of
clarification issued by the Tehsildar concerned. Accordingly, the
PSC in its meeting held on 14.01.2025, approved to recommend
respondent No.4, who had admittedly secured highest points in
EWS category, for appointment as Assistant Professor in Botany.
9.
It seems that before a decision on the representation could be
taken by PSC, the petitioner sensing trouble with regard to her
selection approached the Tribunal by way of OA No.1483/2024.
She, in her petition, called in question notice dated 28.06.2023
issued by the Secretary, PSC, whereby the selection of the
petitioner had been kept on hold till the disposal of the
representation made by respondent No.4. She prayed for a writ of
mandamus to recommend her for appointment as Assistant
Professor in Botany being the candidate at serial No.2 of the
provisional select list of EWS in view of her merit. The writ
petition was contested by the official respondents as well as
respondent No.4.
WP(C) No.2834/2025
10. The Tribunal having considered the relevant contentions and
perused the relevant material on record, framed the following
questions for determination:-
i)
Whether respondent No.4 satisfied the EWS
eligibility as on the cut-off date, and whether the
post-cut-off clarification fatally violates the rules
or the judgments relied upon by the applicant.
ii)
Whether a candidate provisionally shown as
selected acquires a right to appointment overriding
a later, a higher-merit candidate whose eligibility is
clarified.
iii)
Whether
the
impugned
JKPSC
notice
and
subsequent recommendation warrant interference.
11. In respect of point No.(i), the Tribunal concluded that as per Rule
44 (iii) of the JKPSC (Business & Procedure) Rules, 2021, it was
mandatory to possess the requisite category certificate on or
before the last date of receipt of application, which, in the instant
case, was 16.06.2023. The Tribunal found that the respondent
No.4 possessed an Income & Assets Certificate dated 31.05.2023
with the shortcoming that it was written on a Central
Government format. It was, thus, held by the Tribunal that from
the clarification issued by the Tehsildar on 20.10.2023, it was
WP(C) No.2834/2025
demonstrated that the respondent No.4 fulfilled all the eligibility
requirements of getting EWS certificate and, therefore, he would
be deemed to possess a valid category certificate on the cut-off
date.
12. On point No.(ii), the Tribunal relied upon the judgments passed
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court to conclude that inclusion of a
candidate in a provisional select list or even a select list does not
ipso facto create an indefeasible right to appointment. It was
pointed out by the Tribunal that in the instant case, selection of
the petitioner was provisional and subject to the objections from
the candidate/candidates aggrieved. It was, thus, within the
domain of the PSC to consider the objections by the aggrieved
candidates and recommend eligible candidate having more merit
than the petitioner.
13. Regarding point No.(iii), the Tribunal has concluded that in the
instant case, the PSC had acted reasonably, fairly and without
any mala fide. The PSC gave opportunity of hearing to the
petitioner before taking decision on the representation submitted
by respondent No.4.
14. Rendering its opinion on all the three questions framed, the
Tribunal held the OA devoid of merit and dismissed the same in
terms of the judgment impugned.
WP(C) No.2834/2025
15. The impugned judgment is assailed by the petitioner on the
ground that the EWS category certificate submitted by
respondent No.4 in Central Government format was not a valid
category certificate, which could have been considered by the
PSC for conferring the benefit of reservation on respondent No.4.
It is argued that, in the instant case, indisputably, EWS category
certificate submitted by respondent No.4 was not a valid
certificate and, therefore, the PSC had correctly not considered
him under EWS category when it prepared the provisional select
list.
16. Mr. Chauhan further argues that the subsequent clarification and
a valid EWS certificate issued on UT format in favour of
respondent No.4, were produced after the cut-off date and,
therefore, could not have been taken into consideration.
17. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material on record, it is necessary to first notice few admitted
facts.
18. Advertisement Notification notifying 19 posts of Assistant
Professor, Botany, which included two posts earmarked for
EWS, was issued by the PSC on 15th May, 2023. The last date for
submission of application forms was 16th June, 2023. The
petitioner, as well as respondent No.4, was amongst the
candidates, who had put their candidature for consideration under
WP(C) No.2834/2025
the reserved category of EWS. In the selection process that was
conducted by the PSC, respondent No.4 acquired 64.08 points,
which were highest by a candidate in EWS category followed by
Mr. Abbu Zaid (61.65 points). The petitioner having secured
49.10 points was third in the order of merit. Despite the fact that
respondent No.4 had secured highest points in the EWS category,
he was not shown selected and instead Mr. Abbu Zaid and the
petitioner were shown provisionally selected for the two posts
earmarked for EWS category. The PSC did so for the reason that
the EWS certificate dated 31.05.2023 though submitted by
respondent No.4 along with his application form, before the cutoff date, was not in correct format.
19. The provisional select list was indeed subject to objections by the
aggrieved candidates and, accordingly, respondent No.4 raised
objections by way of his representation against the selection of
the petitioner on the ground that she was inferior in merit than
him. He also submitted a clarification issued by the Tehsildar,
Kathua
vide
his
letter
No.Teh/Kth/2023-24/1038
Dated
20.10.2023 in which the Tehsildar had clarified that the EWS
category certificate dated 31.05.2023 was genuine and that the
respondent No.4 did not fall under any of the exclusionary
categories mentioned in Clause (m), (n) and (o) of Section 2 of
the J&K Reservation Act, 2004 [“the Act of 2004”]. It also
deserves to be noticed that the respondent No.4 had obtained a
WP(C) No.2834/2025
fresh EWS certificate as per the Rules of 2005 in FORM XIV-A
on 06.08.2023, which, of course, was after the prescribed cut-off
date. The representation submitted by respondent No.4 was
considered by the Commission in light of the clarification issued
by the Tehsildar, Kathua dated 20.10.2023 and it was found that
on the cut-off date, the respondent No.4 was fulfilling all the
eligibility conditions required for obtaining EWS category
certificate and, therefore, the benefit of reservation envisaged for
EWS could not be denied to respondent No.4. Since merit of
respondent No.4 was admittedly higher than the petitioner, his
name was recommended for appointment and provisional
selection of the petitioner made against the post was not
finalized/confirmed. This is how the controversy landed before
the Tribunal.
20. With a view to appreciating the rival contentions in the light of
admitted factual position, it is necessary to advert to relevant
provisions, which lay basis for claiming the benefit of reservation
envisaged
for
Economical
Weaker
Sections.
The
J&K
Reservation Act, 2004 and the Rules framed thererunder did not
have any provision of reservation for Economically Weaker
Sections of the Society. The Economical Weaker Sections of the
Society were provided such reservation by the Union Territory
after the promulgation of the J&K Reorganization Act, 2019 and
issuance of S.O.2889(E) of 2019 dated 09.08.2019.
WP(C) No.2834/2025
21. Clause (ga) was inserted between Clauses (g) and (h) of Section
2 of the J&K Reservation Act, 2004 and it reads thus:“(ga) “economically weaker sections” means such
categories as may be notified by the Government from time
to time, on the basis of family income and other indicators
of economic disadvantage, other than the classes or
categories defined in clauses (m), (n) and (o)”
Clauses (m), (n) and (o) define “Scheduled Caste” and
“Scheduled Tribe” and socially and educationally backward
classes”. It is, thus, evident that a person claiming the benefit of
reservation envisaged for the category of EWS should be a
person other than the person belonging to Scheduled Caste,
Scheduled Tribe and other Socially and Educationally
Backward Classes.
22. With a view to giving effect to reservation envisaged for EWSs,
Rules of 2005 were also amended. The definition of
Economically Weaker Sections (EWSs) is given in Clause (ixa)
of Rule 2 of the Rules of 2005, which reads as under:“(ixa) “Economically Weaker Sections( EWSs)” means
persons:-(i) Who are not covered under the scheme of reservation for
SCs, STs, and Socially and Educationally Backward classes
as defined under clause (m), clause (n) and clause (o) of
section 2 of the Act;
(ii) Whose family has gross annual income below Rs.8.00
lakh (Rupees eight lakh only) and’
(iii) Whose family does not possess other assets as
specified in proviso to clause (viii) of Rule 21.”
WP(C) No.2834/2025
23. As is evident from a reading of the definition, apart from the fact
that the person claiming benefit of reservation under EWS
category must not be covered by the scheme of reservation for
SC, ST and Socially and Educationally Backward Classes, as
defined in Clauses (m), (n) and (o) of Section 2 of the Act of
2004, but the annual family income of such person must be
below eight lakh and the family must not possess other assets as
specified in proviso to clause (viii) of Rule 21.
24. Rule 4 of the Rules of 2005 provides 10% reservation in favour
of Economically Weaker Sections in the matter of direct
recruitment. Part V of the Rules of 2005 lays down procedure for
issuance of category certificates. So far as EWS category
certificate is concerned, District Magistrate/Additional District
Magistrate/SDM/Tehsildar
etc.
have
been
appointed
as
competent authorities to issue such certificates.
25. Rule 19 deals with the presentation of application in the
prescribed format by the person claiming the benefit of
reservation. Form VII-A appended with the Rules of 2005 is a
format of application for issuance of income and assets certificate
and the certificate is to be issued by the competent authority in
Form XIV-A. It is, however, not forthcoming from the record as
to whether respondent No.4 had submitted his application form
in the prescribed format i.e. Form VII-A or it was an application
WP(C) No.2834/2025
submitted under the Reservation Rules of the Central
Government. However, the fact remains that the certificate dated
31.05.2023, which has been issued by the Tehsildar is not in
Form XIV-A. The certificate dated 31.05.2023 does not bear any
Form number, though it certifies that the annual income of the
family of respondent No.4 is below eight lakh and that he does
not possess the assets specified in proviso to Clause (viii) of Rule
21 of the Rules of 2005. What it omits to mention is that the
respondent No.4 is not covered under the scheme of reservation
for SCs, STs and Socially and Educationally Backward classes,
as defined under Clause (m), (n) and (o) of Section 2 of the Act
of 2004. Instead, it mentions that respondent No.4 is a Brahmin
and does not belong to SC, ST and other Backward classes
(Central List).
26. In essence, the certificate dated 31.05.2023 complies with the
requirements laid down under the Act of 2004 and the Rules
framed thereunder. The omission to make mention of the fact that
respondent No.4 was not covered by the scheme of reservation
for SCs, STs and Socially and Educationally Backwards Classes,
as defined in Clauses (m), (n) and (o) of Section 2 of the Act of
2004 was made good by the competent authority by issuing a
clarification dated 20.10.2023 wherein it was certified by the
Tehsildar, Kathua that respondent No.4, though, issued a
certificate by making reference to OBC categories (central list),
WP(C) No.2834/2025
yet was a person not belonging to any of the categories defined
under Clauses (m), (n) and (o) of Section 2 of the Act of 2004.
27. In the given facts and circumstances narrated above, it can be
said that technically, on the cut-off date, respondent No.4 was not
possessed of a valid EWS category certificate and if that position
is accepted then he was certainly not entitled to the benefit of
reservation envisaged for EWSs. Not only Rule 44 (iii) of the
JKPSC (Business & Procedure) Rules, 2021 but the stipulation in
the advertisement notification also mandates that a category
certificate, relied upon by a candidate, must be a valid category
certificate having been issued by the competent authority on or
before the last date of receipt of application i.e. 16th June, 2023,
in the instant case.
28. It is true that on 16th June, 2023, the certificate of income and
assets relied upon by the respondent No.4 was not in a correct
format. In these circumstances, question arises as to whether a
certificate, which otherwise meets all the requirements of
eligibility for claiming the benefit of reservation meant for EWS,
can be thrown out only on the ground that the issuing authority
has issued it on a wrong format, more particularly, when the
issuing authority, on being approached, clarifies the aforesaid
aspect. The answer to this question has to be in the negative. If
the certificate issued by the competent authority, which is a
WP(C) No.2834/2025
certificate of income and assets, meets the requirements of
Reservation Rules and makes the applicant eligible for obtaining
such certificate, such certificate cannot be held to be invalid only
on the ground that the issuing authority has not issued it on the
proper format. It is the substance and not the form that should
determine the validity of a particular certificate in contention.
29. The PSC as also the Tribunal has arrived at a fair and just
conclusion that respondent No.4, who has obtained highest merit
in the category of EWS, cannot be denied selection and
appointment as Assistant Professor, Botany only the ground that
the category certificate submitted by him, though before the cutoff date, is not valid for the reason that it has not been issued on
proper format. It is not the case of the petitioner that respondent
No.4 had actually applied and got the certificate under the central
format or that he was not entitled to the issuance of such
certificate under the Rules of 2005.
30. In view of the aforesaid, it would not be just and fair to knockout
respondent No.4 only on the ground that the certificate of income
and assets submitted by him before the cut-off of date was issued
by the issuing authority on a wrong format.
31. The judgments relied upon by Mr. Chauhan, learned counsel for
the petitioner, have been rendered in the context of their facts
and, therefore, cannot be taken to have laid down any firm
WP(C) No.2834/2025
proposition of law. In the case of Registrar General, Calcutta
High Court v. Shrinivas Prasad Shah and others, (2013) 12
SCC 364, the certificate submitted by the candidate claiming the
benefit of reservation meant for ST was not issued by the
competent authority as provided under the West Bengal
Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Identification) Act, 1994
and there was a clear stipulation in the notice inviting
applications that the candidate claiming to be SC/ST/BC must
have a certificate from the competent authority specified in the
West
Bengal
Scheduled
Caste
and
Scheduled
Tribes
(Identification) Act, 1994. It is in this context the ST category
certificate produced in the said case was not accepted by the
Commission on the ground that the same had been issued by an
authority not competent to issue such certificate under the West
Bengal Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Identification)
Act, 1994.
It is in these circumstances, the decision of the
Commission not to entertain the certificate, which was not issued
by the competent authority, was upheld and the candidate was
not permitted to submit a fresh certificate issued by the
competent authority after the cutoff date.
32. Similarly, in the case Mohit Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh
and others, 2025 INSC 704, the Supreme Court was confronted
with the situation where the aspirant had not submitted category
certificate in the prescribed format. The Supreme Court took note
WP(C) No.2834/2025
of the eligibility criteria laid down in Clause 5.4(4) of the
advertisement, which clearly provided that if the candidates
belonging to other backward class category, did not submit the
certificate in the prescribed format-I within prescribed period or
if they submited the certificate of Other Backward Class category
valid for the service of Government of India, they will be treated
as candidates of unreserved category. It was, thus, held that in
view of the clear stipulation in the advertisement, certificate
submitted not in the proper format was rightly not entertained
and the aspirant considered under unreserved category.
33. The facts of the instant case are different as there is no similar
stipulation contained in the advertisement notification, which
makes it mandatory for a candidate to submit a category
certificate in a particular format and provides consequences of
not adhering thereto. As a matter of fact, in the advertisement
notification in question, there is no such stipulation. Clause 5 of
the advertisement notification, which deals with reservation.
reads thus:“5. Reservation
(i)
A candidate seeking his/her consideration under a Reserved
Category must ensure that he/she possesses a valid requisite
Category Certificate on the cut-off date.
(ii)
The candidate of the candidates will be provisional till the
genuineness of the Reserved Category is verified by the
Competent Authority.
WP(C) No.2834/2025
(iii)
Candidates may note that in case a claim for reservation is
made on the basis of false/fake/fraudulent certificate, he/she
shall be debarred from the examination(s) conducted by the
J&K Public Service Commission, in addition to any other
peal action as may be deemed appropriate.”
34. From a reading of Clause 5 of the advertisement notification, it is
abundantly clear that it mandates that a candidate claiming the
benefit of a reserved category must ensure that he or she
possesses a valid requisite category certificate on the cut-off date
and that the candidature of such candidate would be provisional
till the genuineness of the reserved category certificate is verified
by the competent authority. The Clause does not provide for
production of category certificate in a particular format not does
it provide consequences, as provided and taken note of by the
Supreme Court in the case of Mohit Kumar (supra).
35. For the foregoing reasons both the judgment relied upon by Mr.
Chauhan are distinguishable and do not, in any manner, advance
the case of the petitioner. The certificate of income and assets
produced by respondent No.4 before the cut-off date read with
clarification dated 20.10.2023 cannot be held to be invalid only
for the reason that the issuing authority has not issued it on
proper format. The position would have been different, had
respondent No.4 acquired the eligibility to obtain the certificate
after the cut-off date.
36. Viewed from any angle, we do not find any infirmity or illegality
in the decision of the PSC as upheld by the Tribunal in terms of
WP(C) No.2834/2025
the impugned judgment that respondent No.4 was eligible and
entitled to the benefit of reservation in EWS category and being
the most meritorious candidate entitled to be selected and
appointed against one of the two posts of Assistant Professor,
Botany notified for selection under EWS category.
37. For the reasons we have given above, we find no merit in this
petition. and the same is, accordingly, dismissed.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
JAMMU
05.02.2026
Vinod, Secy
Vinod Kumar
2026.02.06 10:34
I am the author of this
document
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
Whether the order is speaking : Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review