Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ.
---------------------------------------------------------------------Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay),
S/o Kalu Singh Tamang,
R/o Singling Busty, Soreng,
West Sikkim.
versus
State of Sikkim.
… Appellant.
… Respondent.
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung,
S/o Late Motilall Gurung,
R/o Below Housing Colony,
6th Mile, Tadong,
East Sikkim.
versus
State of Sikkim.
… Appellant.
… Respondent.
------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. K. T. Bhutia, Senior Advocate with Ms. Bandana
Pradhan, Mr. D. K. Pradhan and Ms. Sarita Bhusal,
Advocates for the Appellant in Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chettri
and Ms. Malati Sharma, Advocates for the Appellant in
Cr. A. No. 02 of 2017
Mr. A. Mariarputham, Advocate General with Mr.
Karma Thinlay, Addl. Public Prosecutor, Mr. N. P.
Sharma, Mr. A. J. Sharma, Public Prosecutors, Mr.
Santosh K. Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai, Asstt. Public
Prosecutors for the State.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
JUDGMENT
(28.06.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
Both the appeals are directed against the common
judgment and order of sentence dated 28.12.2016 in Sessions
Trial (Vig.) Case No.02 of 2009 (05 of 2013), whereby and
whereunder the appellant in Crl. A. No.01 of 2017 (hereinafter
referred to as
“A – 1”) was convicted of the offences under
Section 403; Section 120B (2) read with Sections 403/406 of the
Indian Penal Code, 1860 (in short, “IPC”) (in regard to cheque
Nos.208236 and 208249) and Section 13(2) read with Section
13(1)(d)(ii) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (in short,
“PC Act”) (in regard to the amounts concerning with the said
cheques and other cheques encashed through PW-40). A-1 was
sentenced to undergo SI for a period of one year and to pay a
fine of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees Ten thousand) only, in default to pay
fine to further undergo further SI for a period of six months for
the substantive offence committed under Section 13(2) read with
Section 13(1)(d)(ii) of the PC Act. Further he was sentenced to
undergo SI for a period of one year under Section 403 IPC and
he was also sentenced to undergo SI for a period of six months
under Section 120B(2) read with Sections 403/406 of the IPC.
The appellant in Crl. A. No.02 of 2017 (hereinafter referred to as
“A – 2”) was convicted of the offences under Section 406 IPC (in
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
respect of cheque No.208249); Section 403 IPC (in reference to
cheque No.208236) and Section 120B(2) read with Section
403/406 IPC/Section 13(1)(d)(ii)/(2) of the PC Act.
He was
sentenced to undergo SI for a period of one year and to pay a
fine of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees Five thousand) only for an offence
committed under Section 406 IPC.
In default to pay fine
amount, to further undergo SI for a period of three months. A-2
was further sentenced under Section 403 IPC to undergo SI for a
period of eight months and for offence under Section 120B(2)
read with Sections 403/406 IPC/Section 13(1)(d)(ii)/(2) of the
PC Act to undergo SI for a period of six months. Thus, both the
appeals are being considered together.
2.
The provenance of filing of charge-sheet against A - 1
and 2 for allegedly having committed offences under Sections
468/120B(2)
IPC;
Sections
420/120B(2)
IPC;
Sections
403/120B(2) IPC; Sections 409/120B(2) IPC; and Sections
13(1)(d)(ii)/13(2) of the PC Act and other persons, namely,
Keshu Agarwal (A - 3), Subash Tamang (A - 4) and Sanjay
Agarwal
(A
-
5)
for
committing
offences
under
Sections
468/120B(2) IPC; Sections 420/120B(2) IPC; and Sections
403/120B(2)
IPC,
was
in
pursuance
of
the
order
dated
04.03.2003 passed by this High Court in Writ Petitions No.03/98,
05/98, 03/99 & 06/99, wherein the Vigilance Department was
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
permitted to register a regular case for alleged irregularities
committed in respect of the purchase and distribution of milch
cows by the Animal Husbandry & Veterinary Services (AH&VS)
Department, Government of Sikkim.
A Sikkim Vigilance Police
Station (SVPS) Case No.RC-1/2003 was registered by the
Vigilance Police on 12.03.2003 for the offences as afore-stated
against A - 1 and 2 along with other three persons.
3.
The
learned
trial
Judge,
on
examination
and
appreciation of several witnesses produced by the Prosecution,
held as under:“ 62.
Resultantly, the Prosecution case partly
succeeds so far as the accused Nos. 1 & 2 are
concerned.
The accused No. 1 is, accordingly,
convicted of the offences under Section 403; Section
120B(2) read with Sections 403/406 of the IPC, 1860
(with regard to the amounts concerning cheque Nos.
208236 & 208249); and Section 13(2) read with
Section 13(1)(d)(ii) of the PC Act, 1988 (with regard
to the amounts concerning the above cheques and the
other cheques encashed through PW 40). The accused
No. 2 is convicted of the offences under Section 406
(with regard to amount concerning cheque No.
208249); Section 403 (with regard to amount
concerning cheque No.208236); & Section 120B(2)
read with Section 403/406 IPC/Section 13(1)(d)(ii).(2)
of the PC Act, 1988. They be taken into custody
forthwith.
63.
The accused Nos. 3, 4 & 5 however stand
acquitted of the respective charges against them
under
Sections
468/120b(2),
420/120B(2)
&
403/120B(2) of the IPC, 1860.
They are also
discharged from the respective bail bond(s).”
4.
It is pertinent to state here that the defence has not
examined any witness in their favour, but all the alleged accused
were
examined
by
the
trial
Court.
Proper
sanction
for
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
prosecution of A - 1, who happened to be Minister-in-Charge at
the time of alleged commission of offences, was obtained from
the Governor vide Sanction Order (Exhibit 2).
The sanction in
respect of A - 2, being a Government employee, was also
obtained by the State Government vide Sanction order (Exhibit
3). The allegation in the charge-sheet was, in total, for a misappropriation of the amount to the tune of Rs.50,39,500/(approx.).
5.
Mr. K. T. Bhutia, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the A - 1, would contend that the case of the Prosecution rests
solely on the statements made by one Bikram Lama (PW-40) and
also by Bimal Tamang (PW-8), who are interested witnesses.
Bikram Lama was working with A - 1 and was suspended from
service in March, 2000. Bikram Lama has deliberately implicated
A - 1 out of vengeance for his suspension by A - 1.
Bimal
Tamang had also implicated falsely both the A - 1 & 2, and he,
without there being any substantive proof of authorization on
behalf of accused, accepted the cheque and got it encashed and
also gave false undertaking. The charge-sheet was filed against
A - 1 on account of affiliation to other party, due to political
vendetta.
PW-8 and PW-40 were treated as star witnesses for
being the supporters of the opposite ruling party.
Thus, their
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
statements are unworthy of any credit and deserve to be
rejected outright.
6.
It was further contended that the opinion/report dated
24th July, 2006 (Exhibit 240) was rejected, thus, the signatures
and handwritings of the witnesses could not be held as proved.
It is further urged that the deposition of PW-40 is not
creditworthy in respect of various letters (Exhibits - 105, 109,
115, 117, and 119) for the reasons that the witness, at one
stage, stated that he has not seen the letters as the letters were
in the sealed envelopes, but on the said letters being shown to
him, he stated that the said letters were issued to the Managing
Director, Sikkim Milk Union. The statement made by PW-40 was
contradictory, thus, not capable of being trustworthy. The
prosecution has not produced a list of suppliers of milch cows,
which goes against the prosecution in the light of the provisions
of Section 114 (g) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The witness
(PW-40) has constructed a 5 ½ storied RCC building when he
was earning a meager amount of Rs.4000/- to Rs.5000/- per
month, that itself goes to show that he was supported by the
ruling party to implicate the A - 1.
Mr. Bhutia would next urge
that there was no loss to the exchequer, as PW-3 had clearly
admitted
that
subsequently.
a
sum
of
Rs.20,10,000/-
was
received
It is also submitted that the alleged A - 1 was
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
discharging his official duty and as such learned trial Judge
committed an error in holding that no sanction to prosecute A - 1
under the provision of Section 19 (1) of the PC Act and also
under Section 197 of the Cr. P.C., was required.
7.
Mr. N. Rai, learned Senior Counsel appearing for A - 2,
would contend that the accused was working as Managing
Director, Sikkim Co-operative Milk Producers’ Union Ltd.
was the Minister-in-Charge.
A - 1
A - 2 had signed the cheques
prepared by other officers without his direction, under command
of the Head of the Department, i.e. A - 1. Prosecution has failed
to establish that A - 2 has misappropriated funds to his benefit.
It is well established that even if there is violation in codal
conduct on the part of the subordinate officers, that would not
come within the mischief of criminal offence.
come
on
record that
No evidence has
cheques were made and delivered to
unauthorized persons in complicity with A - 1.
Thus, no
conspiracy was proved and, as such, granting benefit of doubts,
the A – 2 be acquitted.
8.
the
It is further urged that no instructions were issued by
Secretary,
Animal
Husbandry
&
Veterinary
Services
Department, fixing the mode of disbursement of fund for supply
of milch cows, as is evident from the deposition of the Head of
Department of concerned Department.
There was no rule or
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
executive circular for sanction and payment of money to the
suppliers of the milch cows.
The trial Court has held that A – 2
was not in Government service, as such conviction under Section
13 (1) (d) (ii)/(2) of the PC Act was misplaced.
9.
Alternatively, it is submitted that A - 2 is an old man
of 81 years, having deserted daughter with two kids.
At this
stage, if A - 2 is convicted, the other dependent members of the
family would suffer irreparable loss.
Thus, the case may be
considered with leniency in favour of A - 2 for exoneration from
the conviction.
10.
Resisting the submissions of the learned Senior
Counsel
appearing
for
the
appellants/accused,
Mr.
A.
Mariarputham, learned Advocate General would contend that it is
wrong to say that no method was prescribed, as is evident from
the letter dated 25th May, 1996 (Exhibit – 16), whereunder the
cheques were issued in favour of Sikkim Milk Union, it was clearly
stated therein that no disbursement of any fund may be made
without
prior
formal
approval
Secretary, AH & VS Department.
of
the
Commissioner-cum-
It is further urged that there
were several letters issued by the Deputy Director, AH & VS
Department addressed to the Managing Director, Sikkim Milk
Union (Exhibits – 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29,
30, 31, 32, 33, 34 and 35) whereby the Deputy Director has
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
granted sanction to release a particular sum of amount in favour
of a named person therein, who had supplied number of milch
cows.
The Deputy Director (A/cs) was authorized by the
Commissioner-cum-Secretary, AH & VS Department, vide letter
dated 18th October, 1996 (Exhibit-17). Pursuance of the earlier
letter dated 25th May, 1996 (Exhibit-16), whereby four cheques,
bearing:
1. Cheque No. BSP 003404 dt. 30.03.1996 for Rs. 2,50,000.00
2. Cheque No. BSP 003405 dt. 30.03.1996 for Rs. 8,00,000.00
3. Cheque No. BSP 003402 dt. 30.03.1996 for Rs.37,50,000.00
4. Cheque No. BSP 003403 dt. 30.03.1996 for Rs.37,50,000.00
Rs.85,50,000.00
were transferred to the Managing Director, Sikkim Milk Union, it
was a clear a condition to keep the said money in a new account
in the bank and also that no disbursement of fund may be made
without
prior
formal
approval
of
the
Commissioner-cum-
Secretary, AH & VS Department.
11.
Learned Advocate General would further contend that
after A - 2 assumed the office of the Managing Director in the
month of November 1996, thereafter A – 1 issued several
letters/notes (Exhibit - 105, Exhibit – 109, Exhibit – 115, Exhibit
– 117 and Exhibit – 119) to A – 2, directing to issue cheques in
favour of PW-8 and PW-40.
Exhibit – 105 clearly indicates a
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
noting made by A - 2, wherein it is stated that on discussion with
the Minister, the money be released in favour of PW-8.
PW-8
and PW-40 have deposed in categorical terms that after receipt
of money, he encashed the cheques, and the amount so received
was handed over to A – 1.
A – 2 was very well aware of the
manner in which the amount deposited be disbursed, but,
without verifying as to whether the recipients were actual
suppliers of milch cows or not, it was done to extend benefit to
A – 1. The cheques were issued, vouchers were duly signed and
undertakings were given by PW-8 and PW-40, who were not,
admittedly, suppliers of milch cows.
The entire incidents
cumulatively establish that A – 1 along with A – 2 committed
criminal breach of trust for appropriation of funds. The writings
made in such letters have not been denied by A – 1 and A – 2.
PW – 8 and PW – 40 have clearly admitted their signatures in
vouchers and undertakings given by them.
The bank authorities
have
cheques,
also
produced
the
relevant
vouchers.
Undertakings given by them were also seized and produced in
the Court. There is no reason to disbelieve the testimony of PW8 and PW-40, who have clearly admitted that the amount so
received from the bank, have been handed over to A - 1. It has
further
come
on
record
that
subsequently
a
sum
of
Rs.20,10,000/- was sent to the Sikkim Milk Union in a carton.
The bearer of the carton clearly deposed that the money was
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
sent by A – 1, who happened to be the Minister-in-charge at the
relevant time. Why, A - 1, who happened to be the Minister-incharge, would send cash in such a large sum also establishes the
offence of A – 1. A -2 has committed the criminal breach of trust
in complicity with A – 1. In such factual background having been
recorded by the trial Court and also the conviction recorded by
the trial Court holding A – 1 and A – 2 as guilty of offence and
further sentencing them accordingly is just, proper, legal,
warranting no interference.
12.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties,
perused the impugned judgment and documents annexed as
exhibits, produced before the trial court.
13.
On analysis of the aforestated, it is discernible that
the State Government transferred a sum of Rs.75.00 lakhs vide
letter dated 25th May, 1996 (Exhibit-16) to the Sikkim Milk Union,
vide two cheques bearing Nos. BSP 003402 and BSP 003403
dated 30.03.1996 along with other two cheques meant for other
purpose with a direction to park the said money in a new account
in the bank maintained for the operation of the above fund with a
condition that no disbursement of the said fund may be made
without
prior
formal
approval
of
the
Commissioner-cum-
Secretary, AH & VS Department. Subsequently, on 18 th October,
1996 (Exhibit-17), the Managing Director, Sikkim Milk Union was
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
informed that the Deputy Director (A/cs.) has been authorized to
sign the letter on behalf of the Commissioner-cum-Secretary, AH
& VS Department for the release of payment to the respective
cow suppliers. It is indisputably admitted by all the parties that
the fund was intended for supply of milch cows.
It was also
stated that during Dusserah season, which fell in October, money
was to be released for needy suppliers of milch cows.
14.
Learned counsel appearing for A-2 submitted that to
avoid lapse of the amount in the financial year, the money was
parked with the Sikkim Milk Union, and it is not disputed by the
State as well as A-1. It is further evincible that in the manner
prescribed for disbursement of the amount, several letters
(Exhibits – 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31,
32, 33 and 34 dated 18th October, 1996 and one more letter
dated 28th November, 1996 (Exhibit-35) were issued by the
authorized Deputy Director (A/cs.), AH & VS Department to the
Managing Director, Sikkim Milk Union to release a specified
amount to the named persons in the said letters.
It was found
that the amount was released to the actual suppliers of milch
cows, accordingly. Thereafter, it has come on record that in the
meantime A-2 working as the General Manager since 29th
December 1995, became Managing Director with effect from 26 th
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
November, 1996, and was subsequently confirmed vide order
dated 21st April, 1997.
15.
The mode prescribed for release of fund, on approval
granted
by
the
Commissioner-cum-Secretary,
AH
&
VS
Department through the Deputy Director (A/cs.), was unofficially
modified, as A-1 being the Minister-in-charge, commenced
sending letters/notes under his signature to A-2 vide Exhibits –
105, 117, 115, 119, 109 and 199 dated 15.01.1997, 20.01.1997
06.02.1997,
09.02.1997,
20.02.1997
and
02.05.1997
respectively directing A-2 to release the specified amount in the
name of Bikram Lama (PW-40) and others, thus, the total sum of
Rs.08.50 lakhs was released to PW-40.
The said Bikram Lama
signed respective cash vouchers (Exhibits – 71, 80, 79, 76, 81
and 78) endorsing the receipt of cash and also the undertakings
(Exhibits-197, 241, 201, 242198 and 200) were duly singed by
the said Bikram Lama (PW-40) to make refund of the payment of
the cows or to replace the cows if the committee or the
authorized
Government
Officers
find
that
the
cows
are
unproductive and sterile and not up to the breed specification.
All the cheques, cash vouchers, undertakings, etc. were seized
from the respective authorities and duly analyzed by the trial
court.
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
16.
Bikram Lama (PW-40) was an employee working with
A-1. It is submitted by learned Senior Counsel for A-1 that PW40 is not trustworthy as he was a partisan witness, as he
deposed out of animosity for his suspension by A-1, on account
of allegation of misappropriation, on 31st March 2000.
The
suspension was revoked only after A-1 left the ruling party in the
year 2013, sometimes in 2014. It is further contended that PW40 having a meager means of earning had constructed a 5 ½
storied RCC building with the support of ruling party and the land
was allotted to him on the recommendation of the present Chief
Minister of Sikkim.
17.
Responding to the said submission, it is stated by the
prosecution that sufficient evidence has come up on record to
establish
the
fact
that
PW-40
has
received
money,
as
aforestated, and paid to A-1. PW-40 had ancestral property and
allotment of plot was made as a routine allotment to several
persons.
PW-40 had sufficient source to construct alleged
premises.
18.
I have examined the aforestated letters/notes written
by A-1 to A-2 and the cheque dated 15.01.1997 (Exhibit - 104)
for Rs.1.00 lakh;
the second cheque (Exhibit – 116) dated
24.01.1997 for Rs.1.00 lakh; the third cheque dated 07.02.1997
(Exhibit – 114) for Rs.2.00 lakhs; the fourth cheque dated
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
10.02.1997 (Exhibit – 108) for Rs.2.00 lakhs; the fifth cheque
dated 20.02.1997 (Exhibit – 118) for Rs.2.00 lakhs and the sixth
cheque dated 10.05.1997 (Exhibit – 112), all in the name of
Bikram Lama for Rs.50,000/- and as such in total six cheques in
favour of Bikram Lama (PW-40) for Rs.8.5 lakhs was issued,
which was encashed vide cash vouchers (Exhibits – 71, 80, 79,
76, 81 and 78) by him and also undertakings vide Exhibits – 197,
241, 201, 242, 198 and 200 were given by PW-40. Bikram Lama
(PW-40) in his deposition has clearly stated that he was
appointed as Lab Attendant but was assigned the duty to attend
the works of A-1 in the office as well as in his residence.
He
used to carry files, documents etc. from the office and residence.
Further, he stated that he was not one of the cow suppliers under
the
Milch
Cow
Distribution
Government of Sikkim.
Scheme
undertaken
by
the
PW-40 has further categorically stated
that he carried letters from A-1 to A-2. Thereafter, cheques, as
aforestated, were issued and the same were encashed. He has
duly signed the cash vouchers and the undertakings, as required
under the Scheme. After collecting the amount from the bank,
he has handed over the same to A-1, the then Minister. Further,
as noticed that the amount was returned subsequently, he said
that he had never returned any amount to the Government
Department
or
Sikkim
Milk
Union
under
the
Milch
Cow
Distribution Scheme received by him from the State Bank of
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
Sikkim, as stated earlier.
In the cross-examination he stated
that letters were issued to the Managing Director, Sikkim Milk
Union by A-1, however, in examination-in-chief, it was stated
that he has received sealed envelopes which he handed over to
A-1. Referring to this minor contradiction, it was contended that
there is a discrepancy in deposition of PW-40, this minor
discrepancy does not demolish the authenticity of the statement
made by PW-40.
19.
In respect of construction of house, it was alleged that
he was paid by the ruling party to implicate A-1.
PW-40 has
clearly stated that he received rent and agricultural produce from
his ancestral land measuring about 4 acres located at Syari,
Gangtok, as his father had 22 acres of land and on his death in
1988, he obtained 4 acres of land as his share. PW-40 strongly
denied that he was making any wrong statement in respect of
handing over of money to A-1 at the instance of some other
political party. He also denied of holding and displaying the flag
of SDF party at any point of time, as alleged by the defence.
20.
On careful examination, I do not find any reason to
disbelieve the statement of PW-40, which is duly supported by
several documents, as the signatures made by him in the cash
vouchers and undertakings, was admitted by him and he has also
identified the signatures made by A-1 on various documents on
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
the ground that since he was working with A-1, he was well awre
of the signature of A-1.
21.
It is next contended that since the money has been
refunded back, the charge of misappropriation come to an end.
The Investigating Officer (PW – 79) namely, R.K. Sundas, in his
statement stated that during investigation, it was found that an
amount of Rs.20,10,000/- was refunded by different individuals
to Sikkim Milk Union in the year 2001, after filing of a Public
Interest Litigation, which resulted into a direction of investigation
in this matter. One Bal Krishna Rai (PW-7) who was working in
the Sikkim Milk Union deposed, referring to a notings (Exhibit5/2), that the notings relate to deposit of an amount of
Rs.20,10,000/- received by him in a carton from an individual
who told him that the said amount was sent by A-1, which, he
had received on a telephonic call from the then Secretary, AH &
VS Department, Mr. D.K. Gajmer and transferred the said
amount to the account of the Department through a cheque. The
then Secretary, AH & VS Department, Mr. D.K. Gajmer, was also
examined as PW-14.
In his deposition, he stated that he had
received a telephonic call from an unknown caller that he was
instructed by the then Minister, A-1, to make refund of certain
amount received by the suppliers for supply of milch cows under
the Scheme.
According to him, he directed the said caller to
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
meet Bal Krishna Rai (PW-7) the then Accountant of Sikkim Milk
Union and deposit the amount. Thereafter, he was informed by
the Managing Director, Sikkim Milk Union that the amount to the
tune of Rs.20,10,000/- was received. It was contrasted by the
learned Senior Counsel for A-1 that Dr. R.K. Tamang (PW-2),
who was posted in March, 2003 as Managing Director, Sikkim
Milk Union, had submitted a report to the Controller and Auditor
General for the year 1999-2000, that an advance to the tune of
Rs.20,10,000/- was recovered from the suppliers and the same
was credited in the respective account of the Sikkim Milk Union,
thus, the amount was received from the suppliers who had taken
advance amount earlier. In his deposition before the Court, PW2 stated that the money was refunded. On perusal of the said
report, (page 1762 of the compilation), it is not clear as to
whether the money was deposited by the individual suppliers or
by one individual as it has come on record from the depositions
of various authorities, that a sum of Rs.20,10,000/- was
deposited in cash on the instruction of A-1, which was duly
received by the then accountant and credited in the relevant
account.
As observed, it is stated by PW-40 that he has not
refunded any money. The money was refunded by A-1, there is
no reason as to why A-1 will refund the money and that too in
cash through some individual person, unless he had received the
amount from PW-40 and PW-8 as stated by them.
This also
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
fortifies the offence committed by A-1, which stand established
on the basis of letters, cheques, cash vouchers and undertakings.
Even otherwise, the subsequent refund of money will not
exonerate A-1 and A-2 from offence of misappropriation and
criminal breach of trust under the provisions.
22.
Coming to the next allegation, another conduit was
Bimal Tamang (PW-8).
Bimal Tamang (PW-8) was given a
cheque of Rs.1.00 lakh for encashment.
PW-8 stated in his
deposition that he was asked by A-1 to meet A-2. On meeting,
he received a cheque for Rs.1.00 lakh, which he encashed and
signed the cash voucher (Exhibit-132). In his cross-examination,
the location of handing over of the cheque in his residence was
denied, but reiterated receipt of cheque, encashment of the said
cheque vide cash voucher (Exhibit-132). He further stated that
no letter was given to him, he was merely asked by A-1 to meet
A-2, he accordingly received the amount, which he handed over
to A-1.
On verification, his signature was duly identified by him
on the reverse side of the cash voucher (Exhibit-132 [a]). The
trial Judge was found him confused as he could not identify the
place, where he had received the cheque.
On this account,
learned Senior Counsel for A-1 submitted that there was no
clarity in the place, he could have been summoned for reexamination, which was not done, thus, the deposition of the
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
witness was untrustworthy and be rejected.
The witness has
also admitted during cross-examination at one place that cash
voucher (Exhibit – 132) does not pertain to the cheque issued to
him by A-2 at his residence.
The deposition of PW-8 was
recorded after about 19 years. On this account, the testimony of
PW-8 cannot be rejected as the voucher alone is enough to
substantiate the payment of Rs.1.00 lakh to PW-8, when
admittedly PW-8 was not a supplier of milch cows under the
Scheme.
There is sufficient reason to establish that a cheque for
Rs.1.00 lakh was issued by A-2 in favour of a person, who was
not a supplier of milch cows, when there was a clear direction
that the fund was given to Sikkim Milk Union for disbursal of cow
suppliers on the basis of prior approval from the Commissionercum-Secretary, AH & VS Department.
The aforestated overall
evidence, which have come on record, proved the case of
prosecution that on the instruction of A-1, A-2 knowing fully-well
that the manner prescribed under the letter whereby the amount
was transferred was not complied with, issued various cheques in
favour of non-suppliers of milch cows. This clearly indicate the
involvement of A-2 also.
Thus, the prosecution has clearly
established
complicity
that
A-1,
in
with
A-2,
have
misappropriated the funds to the tune of Rs.9.50 lakhs illegally
with criminal intent.
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
23.
It is further pleaded by learned Senior Counsel
appearing for A-1 that the handwriting expert, while giving
opinion has not submitted the reasoning therein, as admitted by
Narendra Kumar (PW-77) in his cross-examination.
Thus, the
handwriting expert’s opinion may not be accepted in support and
taken on record. Be that as it may, in certain cheques, which are
not the subject matter of the instant appeal, for want of support
of other evidence, the opinion rendered by handwriting expert
may not be sufficient to establish the charge.
But in the case,
wherein issuance of cheques, cash vouchers and undertakings
have been affirmed by other testimonies, lack of reasons in
support of opinion may not be relevant to prove the case of the
prosecution.
24.
A-1 and A-2 were charge-sheeted along with others.
The trial Judge, after examination and analysis, have not found
issuance of other cheques and encashment of cash subsequent
thereto, in favour of certain other beneficiaries to benefit the A-1
or A-2 as illegal. Thus, the charge in relation to other cheques
were not substantially proved and as such were dropped.
In
such facts and circumstances, this Court is concerned with the
charges in relation to issuance of cheques in favour of Bikram
Lama (PW-40) and Bimal Tamang (PW-8), which I have
discussed at length in the preceding paragraphs, and that clearly
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
go to establish the charges, as found by the learned trial Judge,
proved, are proper, legal and did not warrant interference.
25.
The role of A-2 in the entire criminal offence has also
been established. A-2, who was working as Managing Director,
Sikkim Milk Union during the period, received various letters of
A-1 for payment and also it is evident from the letter/note dated
15.01.1997 (Exhibit-105), where it is recorded by A-2 that he
had discussed with the Minister and it was directed to issue a
cheque of Rs.1.00 lakh in favour of Bimal Tamang (PW-8) of
Chakung constituency.
The cheque was, it appears, issued in
favour of PW-8 on the basis of discussion with A-1.
In such
scenario, it is difficult to hold that A-2 has acted only on the
instruction of his superiors and as such he has not committed
any illegal act.
Thus, A-2 is rightly found guilty of offence of
criminal breach of trust as mentioned in the impugned judgment
rendered by the trial court. A-1 and A-2 were convicted for an
offence under Sections 403/406 read with Section 120 B (2) IPC.
26.
Sections 403 and 406 IPC reads as under: “403. Dishonest
misappropriation of property – Whoever
dishonestly misappropriates or converts to his own use any moveable
property, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for
a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both.
Explanation 1 – A dishonest misappropriation for a time only is a
misappropriation within the meaning of this section.
Explanation 2 – A person who finds property not in the possession of
any other person, and takes such property for the purpose of
protecting it for, or of restoring it to, the owner does not take or
misappropriate it dishonestly, and is not guilty of an offence; but he is
guilty of the offence above defined, if he appropriates it to his own
use, when he knows or has the means of discovering the owner, or
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
before he has used reasonable means to discover and give notice to
the owner and has kept the property a reasonable time to enable the
owner to claim it.
What are reasonable means or what is a reasonable time in
such a case, is a question of fact.
It is not necessary that the finder should know who is the
owner of the property, or that any particular person is the owner of it;
it is sufficient if, at the time of appropriating it, he does not believe it
to be his own property, or in good faith believe that the real owner
cannot be found.”
x
x
x
“406. Punishment for criminal breach of trust – Whoever
commits criminal breach of trust shall be punished with imprisonment
of either description for a term which may extend to three years, or
with fine, or with both.”
27.
Section 403 contemplates that whoever dishonestly
misappropriates or converts to his own use any moveable
property,
shall
be
punished
with
imprisonment
of
either
description for a term which may extend to two years, or with
fine, or with both.
Section 406 deals with punishment for
criminal breach of trust.
concerned
Department
The A-1, being the Minister of the
has
dishonestly
misappropriated
amount to the tune of Rs.9.50 lakhs to his benefit.
an
A-2 was
entrusted with the amount for the purpose of disbursement to
the suppliers of milch cows under the Scheme. He committed a
criminal breach of trust by issuing the cheques in favour of nonsuppliers of cows knowing fully well that the amount so encashed
was meant for A-1 through PW-8 and PW-40. Thus, necessary
ingredients for both the provisions are available to convict A-1.
Section 120B (2) provides for punishment of criminal conspiracy,
in this case, to commit an offence of misappropriation of property
as well as criminal breach of trust. In so far as conviction under
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
Section 13 (2) read with Section 13 (1) (d)(ii) of the PC Act is
concerned, A-1 was Minister-in-charge and as such indisputably
was a public servant.
The offence committed by him was not
within the ambit of his assignment, as such it was rightly held by
learned trial Judge that no sanction was required and he was
rightly convicted under the provisions of Section 13 (2) read with
Section 13 (1) (d)(ii) of the PC Act. The trial Court has held that
A-2 was not a public servant.
A-2 was held by learned trial
Judge as not a public servant, which is not challenged by the
prosecution in the appeal and as such his conviction under
Section 13 (2) read with Section 13 (1) (d)(ii) of the PC Act was
not justified.
However, conviction under Section 406 IPC,
sentencing him to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of
one year and to pay a fine of Rs.5,000/- was justified.
The
conviction under Section 120 B (2) read with Section 403/406
IPC to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of six months
was also proper.
However, on analysis, it appears that no
evidence has been found to prove that A-2 has misappropriated
the funds or converted a moveable property i.e. money to his
own use and as such conviction under Section 403 IPC was not
proper and justified.
Also since he was held as not a public
servant under Section 13 (2) read with Section 13 (1) (d)(ii) of
the PC Act is not justified and is, accordingly, set aside.
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
28.
Explanation 1 to Section 403 prescribes that a
dishonest misappropriation for a time only is a misappropriation
within the meaning of dishonest misappropriation under Section
403. Thus, even if the money was refunded and the State has
not suffered any loss, misappropriation for a temporary period
also attracts the rigours of provision of Section 403. As such, A1 was rightly held guilty of an offence committed under Section
403 IPC.
Section 405 IPC defines criminal breach of trust. A
person who is entrusted with property or within the dominion
over property, dishonestly misappropriates or converts to his
own use that property, or dishonestly uses or disposes of that
property in violation of any direction of law prescribing the mode
in which such trust is to be discharged, or any legal contract,
express or implied indisputably. In the case on hand the amount
was transferred to Sikkim Milk Union for a specific purpose. A-1
and A-2 have deliberately used the amount (fund) meant for
disbursal to the suppliers of milch cows on prior approval by the
Commissioner-cum-Secretary, AH & VS Department, but A-1 in
complicity with A-2, got the amount encashed through PW-8 and
PW-40 and misappropriated the same to his benefit, as observed
earlier. A-2 was instrumental and has committed criminal breach
of trust being the custodian or having dominion over the said
fund, but it is not established that he has converted or
misappropriated the fund to his benefit.
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
29.
Learned Senior Counsel has further submitted that
non submission of list of suppliers, done deliberately, attract the
provisions of Section 114 (g) of the Indian Evidence Act, to draw
adverse inference.
In support thereof, he made a reference to
the observation made in Chittaranjan Choudhury vs. State of
Bihar1.
In Chittaranjan Choudhury, the accused, a godown
clerk of Food Corporation of India, was prosecuted on charge of
criminal breach of trust on the allegation that the wheat bags in
the truck standing in front of the godown were loaded under the
instruction of the accused clerk but the defence plea was that the
bags were being loaded as per certain release order and the
prosecution failed to produce the release order seized from the
custody of the accused and as such was entitled to be acquitted.
In such fact, adverse inference can be drawn against the
accused, when the release order was seized but not produced.
In the facts of the case, where relevant materials are available,
mere absence of list of suppliers of cows will not vitiate the case
of the prosecution. Thus, the contention deserves to be rejected.
30.
In Sait Tarajee Khimchand and others2,relied on
by the Senior Counsel for A-1, the documents exhibited were not
---------------------------------1
AIR 1987 SC 856
AIR 1971 SC 1865
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
proved, wherein it was held that “The irresistible inference arises
that the plaintiff’s books would not have supported the plaintiffs.”
The facts of the case, being distinguishable is not applicable to
the instant case.
31.
In Chanan Singh vs. State of Haryana3,referred to
by Mr. Bhutia, wherein the issue was as to whether the conduct
of the witness in running away from the place of occurrence even
though he was not chased or threatened by any one of the
assailants, whether this conduct be treated as abnormal. It was
held that re-examination cannot be allowed for new matters
except with leave of the Court.
In the case on hand, certain
basic questions were not put to Bikram Lama (PW-40) and an
application was made by the prosecution and contested by other
side. The application was made stating that two cheques which
are required to be identified by PW-40 was not done as it forms
part of the record.
The leave was granted vide order dated
18.05.2016. Accordingly, he was re-examined to establish the
charges.
32.
In Pannayar vs. State of Tamil Nadu4, the re-
examination was sought to get clarification of some doubts
created in cross-examination, the Supreme Court held that one
-----------------------------3
AIR 1971 SC 1554
AIR 2010 SC 85
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
cannot
supplement
examination-in-chief
by
way
of
a
re-
examination and for the first time, start introducing totally new
facts, which have no concern with the cross-examination. This is
not of any assistance to the facts of the case on hand.
33.
The
Delhi
High
Court
in
Sudir
Engineering
Company vs. Nitco Roadways Ltd.5 referred to by Mr. Bhutia,
deals with the manner how the documents be exhibited and
approved.
34.
In support of his submission that PW-40 was a
partisan witness, Mr. Bhutia, refers to Ram Ashrit and others
vs. State of Bihar6, wherein the Supreme Court observed that
the material witness of the prosecution who are either related or
otherwise interested in the prosecution, their testimony had to
pass the test of close and severe scrutiny before their testimony
could be safely acted upon.
In the case on hand, PW-40, who
was pleaded by the appellants as partisan witness, was closely
scrutinized and his testimony was accepted as it found support
from various cheques and vouchers.
35.
Facts involved in Mahavir Singh vs. State of
Madhya Pradesh7, relied by Mr. Bhutia are altogether different
--------------------------------5
1995 (34) DRJ 86
1981 Cr.L.J. 484
(2016) 10 SCC 220
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
and as such, ratio laid down therein is not applicable to the case
on hand.
36.
It is further argued by Mr. Bhutia, learned counsel
appearing for A-1 that Bikram Lama (PW-40) was some other
person, who had supplied cows to Dentam constituency. Letter
and cheques were issued in favour of Bikram Lama, supplier of
cows at Dentam constituency and as such PW-40 impersonated
to receive the money and wrongly stated to have handed over
the same to A-1.
Bikram Lama in his deposition had clearly
stated that he was not a supplier of cows at any place including
at Dentam constituency.
However, he was given certain
envelopes containing letters, wherein A-2 was directed to issue
cheques in his favour. Accordingly, cheques were issued and
encashed vide cash vouchers and also undertaking was taken by
him to A-2. A-2 knew very well that Bikram Lama (PW-40) was
the attendant of A-1 and as such he was not a supplier of cow,
still money was released in his favour and it was handed over to
A-1, as it has been noticed that an amount to the tune of
Rs.20,10,000/- was sent by A-1, which has come on record and
proved by deposition of PW-7 and PW-14.
The defence has not
examined the said Bikram Lama of Dentam constituency, as
pleaded hereinabove.
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
37.
As a sequel, conviction and sentencing of A-1 by
learned trial Court is affirmed and upheld.
In so far as A-2 is
concerned, as held aforestated, the conviction under Section 403
and under the provisions of Section 13 (1) (d)(ii)/(2) of the PC
Act is set aside. However, keeping in view the age of the convict
and also the nature of the offence committed by him, the
sentence under Section 406 is reduced to six months and
payment of fine to the tune of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees five thousand)
is affirmed. In default to pay the fine, he shall undergo simple
imprisonment for a period of three months. However, conviction
under Section 120B (2) read with Section 406 IPC to undergo
simple imprisonment for a period of six months is also upheld.
The appellants be taken into custody forthwith.
38.
The appeal preferred by A-2 is allowed to the above
extent. The appeal filed by A-1 is dismissed.
39.
All the sentences shall run concurrently. The period of
imprisonment, if any, already undergone by the convicts/
appellants in connection with this case shall be set off against the
aforestated period(s) of imprisonment.
Chief Justice
28.06.2017
pm/jk
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
Crl. A. No. 01 of 2017
Prem Singh Tamang (Golay) vs. State of Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 02 of 2017
Til Bahadur Gurung vs. State of Sikkim
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review