Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 244 of 2019
Date of Decision: 05.12.2022
Prem Singh & 632 Ors.
Vs.
Union of India & 3 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. P. Mahanta, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. D. Dkhar, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. R. Debnath, CGC
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
1.
Heard Mr. S. P. Mahanta, learned Sr. counsel for the petitioners who
has submitted that the Gauhati High Court, Shillong Bench (as this Court then
was) vide order dated 23.08.2012 in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 dealing
with a case of prayer for parity in rank structure in the Assam Rifles vis-à-vis
the various Central Police Organisations (CPOs)/ Central Para Military Forces
(CPMF) like the Border Security Force, Central Reserve Police Force, Indo-
Tibetan Border Police Force etc., has allowed the prayer of the petitioners
therein, the operative portion being found at para 14 of the same reads as
follows:
“14. In the result, this writ petition stands disposed of with the
direction to the respondent No.2, the Director General of Assam Rifles
to take up the matter again with the respondent No.1, i.e. the Secretary
to the Govt. of India, Ministry of Home Affairs to bring parity in
respect of rank structure and pay of the Assam Rifles clerical cadre at
par with other CPOs by introducing rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector
(Warrant Officer) at the entry grade w.e.f. 1.1.1986 in the scale of pay
of Rs.1320-2040 (revised Rs.4000-6000) w.e.f. 1.1.1996 or any other
date as the authority deem it fit and proper with all consequential
service benefits in the light of the Government of India, Ministry of
Finance resolution dated 20.9.1997 communicated through MH letter
bearing No.2701-02/1/97 PC Cell/Pef-1 dated 10.10.1997. The whole
exercise would be completed within a period of 6 (six) months from
the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment and order.”
2.
That being aggrieved therewith, the respondents therein had preferred
an intra-court appeal before this Court numbered as WA (SH) No. 40 of 2012
which was disposed of vide order dated 30.04.2013 whereby the order of the
learned Single Bench was modified to the extent that the financial benefit
directed to be given to the petitioners would be w.e.f. January 2010 notionally.
3.
Again, being aggrieved by the said order dated 30.04.2013 the
respondents in WA (SH) No. 40 of 2012 had approached the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Civil Appeal No. 13445 of 2015 and the same was disposed of vide
order dated 17.11.2015. The Hon’ble Supreme Court while deciding the
matter had restored the judgment and order dated 23.08.2012 passed by the
Single Bench with a slight modification to the same that the words “or any
other date as the authority deem it fit and proper” appearing at para 14 of the
said judgment be deleted.
4.
In compliance with this Court’s order dated 23.08.2012 in WP(C) No.
277 (SH) of 2010 the Directorate General Assam Rifles vide Order No.
A/Pers/II-04/Clk/2016/774 dated 28.06.2016 on being approved by the
Ministry of Home Affairs vide their U.O. 27013/2/2016.PF.IV dated
22.06.2016 has conveyed sanction of the competent authority to bring parity
in rank structure and pay of the Assam Rifles clerical cadre at par with other
CPOs by introducing rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector (Warrant Officer rank
in the Assam Rifles) at the entry grade wef 01-01-1986 in the scale of pay of
Rs. 1320-2040/- (revised 4000-6000/- wef 01-01-1996), to all personnel of the
Clerical cadre who were in service as on 01-01-1986 and who were enrolled
thereafter upto 28-10-2002.
5.
While putting into action the said sanction order dated 28.06.2016,
according to the petitioners herein at para 24 of their petition, it has been stated
that 1232 numbers of the original writ petitioners were accorded the benefits
thereof, while 87 of the original writ petitioners who admittedly were enrolled
in the clerical cadre after 29.10.2002 were denied such benefits.
6.
The said 87 personnel then approached this Court by instituting
contempt proceedings being numbered as Cont. Case (C) No. 21 of 2016
arising out of WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010. On 13.11.2018 when the matter
was listed for consideration before this Court, the contemnors therein has
informed the Court that the judgment referred to would be implemented visà-vis the contempt petitioners within six weeks. As a result, the contempt
proceeding was closed. Consequently, the Directorate General Assam Rifles
vide order No. Rec (Adm-I)/WO Clk/2019/319 dated 12.04.2019 has ordered
implementation of the related order dated 23.08.2012 passed by this Court in
WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 to the remaining 89 original petitioners who are
now also covered by the administrative order No. A/Pers/1104/Clk/2016/774
dated 28.06.2016.
7.
The learned Sr. counsel has further submitted that the petitioners
herein are employees under the Government of India, Ministry of Home
Affairs and are working in the Assam Rifles as Havildar (Clerks), which is a
cadre post in the clerical grade of Assam Rifles in different units. They were
also enrolled as Assam Rifles personnel at the same time as those petitioners
in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 and as such has a legitimate expectation that
the respondent-authority would extend the same benefit to them, but the same
was not done so. A representation dated 22.04.2019 in this regard was
presented before the competent authority with a prayer to extend the benefit
of such judgment and order dated 23.08.2012 but to no response. Hence this
petition.
8.
The learned Sr. counsel has further clarified that the case of the
petitioners herein would derive its strength from the fact that in the array of
petitioners numbering about 1339, about 87 of them were employees who have
entered service in the Assam Rifles after 29.10.2002 and as pointed out above,
initially these 87 petitioners/employees were not given the benefit of the
related order dated 28.06.2016 wherein the Assam Rifles authority have
conveyed sanction for implementation of the Court’s order dated 23.08.2012.
9.
It is only when the said 87 petitioners filed a contempt petition before
this Court that the matter was set at rest by virtue of the order dated 13.11.2018
in Cont. Cas (C) No. 21 of 2016 arising out of WP(C) No. 277 of 2010 wherein
the contemnor/Assam Rifles authority have eventually agreed to implement
the said judgment which was done so. The petitioners herein being similarly
situated in employment to the abovementioned 87 petitioners/employees,
therefore, the same benefit should be accorded to them.
10.
Per contra, Mr. R. Debnath, learned CGC appearing for the
respondent-Union of India would submit that the basic facts are required to be
brought to the notice of this Court, inasmuch as the historical aspect of the
matter pertains to the issue of disparity of rank and pay structure within the
Central Police Organisations (CPO)/Central Para-Military Force (CPMF)
prompting the Ministry of Home Affairs to issue an order dated 10.10.1997
wherein the rank structure and pay scales of non-gazetted CPOs were
rationalised. By the said restructuring, the entry grade in the CPOs starts with
the post of Assistant Sub-Inspector with grade pay of ₹ 1320-2040/- and after
the implementation of the 5th Central Pay Commission Report, the grade pay
of Assistant Sub-Inspector was enhanced to the scale of ₹ 4000-6000/-.
However, as regard the Assam Rifles personnel their pay structure was earlier
modelled on that applicable to Indian Army personnel and as such there
occurred a disparity as regard the rank and pay structure of the Assam Rifle
personnel vis-à-vis their counterpart in other CPOs. To correct this anomaly,
the order dated 23.08.2012 in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 was passed by this
Court.
11.
Mr. Debnath has also submitted that in compliance with the said order
dated 23.08.2012 the sanction order dated 28.06.2016 was passed setting at
rest the issue of rank and pay disparity between the Assam Rifles and the other
CPOs/CPMFs. It is however pointed out that the import of the said sanction
order dated 28.06.2016 is applicable to only those personnel who were in
service as on 01.01.1986 and who were enrolled thereafter upto 28.10.2002.
12.
It is further submitted that to bring uniformity in ministerial cadres in
all CPOs, parity was made in the Assam Rifles by publication of recruitment
rules by way of Gazette Notification No. G.S.R 472 dated 29.10.2002 granting
equal ranks of clerical cadre as Havildar (Clerk) in the Assam Rifle as the
entry grade. Accordingly, all the Assam Rifles personnel who were enrolled
after 29.10.2002 are placed on an equal pedestal as those personnel in the other
CPOs. The benefit of the sanction order dated 28.06.2016 therefore cannot be
made applicable to those personnel who have joined service after 28.10.2002.
13.
The learned CGC has however conceded that it was through oversight
and inadvertence that the names of the 87 petitioners in the original array of
parties in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 could not be detected in course of
proceedings to enable an appropriate prayer of application to be moved before
the Court for necessary orders in this regard. Be that as it may, the fact that as
far as the 87 petitioners are concerned, this Court has settled the matter vide
order dated 13.11.2018 in Cont. Case (C) No. 21 of 2016 and as such to the
extent indicated the issue has become final with the issue of the relevant order
passed by the Director General Assam Rifles being No. Rec (Adm-I)/WO Clk/
2019/319 dated 12.04.2019.
14.
In this instant case, the learned CGC has submitted that if the relief
sought for by the petitioners herein is granted, it would be in violation of the
Assam Rifles Recruitment Rules, 2002 wherein another anomalous situation
would arise inasmuch as granting rank of warrant officer to the petitioners of
Assam Rifles enrolled after 29.10.2002 would upset the equilibrium of the
Assam Rifles vis-à-vis the other CPOs/CPMFs which may result in a flood of
litigation by the aggrieved parties.
15.
As to why the benefit vide order dated 12.04.2019 was given to the 87
petitioners (sic 89) though they are not entitled to the same is only because of
the order of this Court in the said contempt case in Cont. Cas (C) No. 21 of
2016 wherein in the order dated 12.11.2018 the Court, referring to these
petitioners has observed that they have fought a legal battle successfully for a
long time, so they cannot be deprived of a right to reap the fruit of the litigation
and that the respondent cannot be allowed to negate the operation of the
judgment to the disadvantage of the petitioners whereas this case stands on a
different footing and is to be dealt with accordingly.
16.
In support of his case the learned CGC has cited the following
judgments:
i.
Union of India & Ors. v. Arulmozhi Iniarasu & Ors.: (2011) 7
SCC 397 para 14, 17 and 26;
ii.
Maharaj Krishan Bhatt & Anr. v. State of Jammu and Kashmir &
Ors.: (2008) 9 SCC 24 para 21;
iii.
Director of Horticulture, Odisha v. Pravat Kumar Das & Ors.:
(2019) 8 SCC 294 para 18;
iv.
Khoday Distilleries Ltd. v. Mahadedeswar SSK Ltd.: (2012) 12
SCC 291 para 7;
17.
In response to the judgments cited by learned CGC, the learned Sr.
counsel for the petitioners has submitted that the aforesaid judgments can be
distinguished as far as the case of the petitioners herein are concerned.
18.
In the case of Arulmozhi Iniarasu (supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has reiterated the well-settled principle of law in the matter of applying
precedents and that the court should not place reliance on decisions without
discussing as to how the fact situations of the case before it fits in with the fact
situation of the decision on which reliance is placed. The case referred to
herein relates to a prayer by part-time casual labourers who sought
regularization as a one-time measure without meeting the basic requirement
of the service rules. The Hon’ble Supreme Court rejected this plea on the
ground that their appointment was purely temporary and they could not be
regularized into service despite the allegation that some similarly situated
persons were regularized. These facts have no similarity to the case of the
petitioners herein, submits the learned Sr. counsel.
19.
In the case of Director of Horticulture Odisha (supra) the case relates
to the claim of certain candidates who have undergone training for the post of
Gardener to be appointed to such post, however the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has held that selection of the candidates for training was not by way of
transparent procedure nor was there any commitment to appoint candidates
who have completed training as gardener. Therefore, even if a candidate has
completed the training, he cannot claim employment as a right thereof without
giving opportunity to all similarly situated candidates. This case too, has no
factual similarity to the case of the petitioners herein, submits the learned Sr.
counsel.
20.
This Court has given due weightage to the argument advanced by the
learned counsels for the parties herein. From the above, what can be discerned
is that prior to 28.10.2002, there exists a situation where personnel of different
CPOs and CPMFs apparently employed in similar area of work and disciplines
are having different rank and pay structure, for example, personnel of Assam
Rifles would not have parity of rank and pay structure with those of either the
Border Security Force or the Central Reserve Police Force etc. In spite of the
issue of the Order dated 10.10.1997 by the Ministry of Home Affairs, the
situation has not improved.
21.
Thus situated, the petitioners in W.P.(C) No. 277(SH) of 2010 have
approached this Court in the year 2010 with a prayer to bring parity in respect
of pay, rank and status of Assam Rifles Clerical cadre at par with other Central
Police Organisation, by introducing the rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector
(Warrant Officer) at the entry level w.e.f. 01.01.1986 in the scale of pay Rs
1320-2040 (revised Rs 4000-6000 w.e.f. 01.01.1996).
22.
It may be noted that at the time the writ petition No. 277(SH) of 2010
was filed, the Recruitment Rules of the Assam Rifles of 28.10.2002 was
already in place, which means that as on 2010, there is already parity of rank
and pay structure in the Assam Rifles vis-à-vis the other CPOs and CPMF, the
entry grade being the rank of Havildar. Therefore, what was urged by the
petitioners in W.P(C) No. 277(SH) of 2010 as far as prayer for rank and pay
parity is concerned would imply that in the case of those petitioners, they have
not been given the benefit of the said rank and pay parity, apparently because
they were all enrolled in the Assam Rifles before the year 2002. For those
personnel who have been enrolled after 29.10.2002, the question of parity does
not arise.
23.
However, as borne out by records, that out of the 1339 petitioners in
WP(C) No. 277(SH) of 2010, 87 of them are personnel who have joined the
Assam Rifles after 29.10.2002 and are therefore governed by the relevant
recruitment rules thereto, it remains a mystery as to how these set of 87
petitioners are entitled to seek parity of rank and pay structure at that point of
time. Be that as it may, since this aspect of the matter escaped the attention of
all concerned and a blanket order passed being order dated 23.08.2012, the
benefit of the same would certainly also cover these 87 petitioners and this
Court, in the contempt case filed by the said 87 petitioners, has rightly passed
the correct order, albeit on concession by the competent authority, that they
should also reap the fruit of their litigation.
24.
Coming to the case of the petitioners herein, the prayer in this writ is
to grant the benefit of rank structure, status and pay scale of Assistant SubInspector (Warrant Officer) in the pay scale of Rs. 1320-2040(4000-6000)
w.e.f. the date of enrolment in terms of judgment and order dated
23.08.2012(supra).
25.
Again, as far as the case of the 87 petitioners are concerned, the learned
CGC has fairly submitted that it was through oversight or inadvertence that
they have been allowed to participate in the proceedings in WP(C) No. 277
(SH) of 2010 and for this, the respondent-Assam Rifles has to pay the price of
extending the benefit of the said order dated 23.08.2012. This benefit,
however, in the considered opinion of this Court would certainly not extend to
the petitioners herein as, firstly, they have not joined issues with their
colleagues in the first round of litigation and secondly, there is no question of
seeking parity of any kind considering the fact that they are enrolled under the
relevant Recruitment Rules of 2002 and these rules have not been challenged
by the petitioners in this lis.
26.
In this regard, even if the authorities cited by the learned CGC on
behalf of the respondents are not taken on board or discussed or even applied
to the fact situation herein, on an overall surmise, the petitioners herein can be
said to be fence-sitters and by the very fact that they have chosen not to align
with the 87 petitioners in the year 2010 when they have approached this Court
in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010, the principle of delay, laches and
acquiescence can be attributed to their action.
27.
The judgment dated 23.08.2012 is a judgment in personam, as could
be evident from the proceedings in Cont. Cas (C) No. 21 of 2016 and the
related order dated 12.10.2018 and 13.11.2018 respectively where relief was
given only to those 87 petitioners specifically.
28.
Relevant in this regard is the case of R. Muthukumar and Others v.
Chairman and Managing Director TANGEDCO and Others: 2022 SCC Online
SC 151, particularly para 25 and 28 which are reproduced herewith as:
“25. The lynchpin of the appellant’s submission was their reliance on
Aravind Kumar Srivastava (supra). In that case, this court after
reviewing several cases cited by the parties, had summarized the
correct approach in matters where concession-based orders could (or
could not) be treated as precedent:
(1) Normal rule is that when a particular set of employees is given
relief by the Court, all other identically situated persons need to be
treated alike by extending the benefit. Not doing so would amount
to discrimination and would be violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. This principle needs to be applied in service
matters more emphatically as the service jurisprudence evolved by
this Court from time to time postulates that all similarly situated
persons should be treated similarly. Therefore, the normal rule
would be that merely because other similarly situated persons did
not approach the Court earlier, they are not to be treated
differently.
(2) However, this principle is subject to well recognized exceptions in
the form of laches and delays as well as acquiescence. Those
persons who did not challenge the wrongful action in their cases
and acquiesced into the same and woke up after long delay only
because of the reason that their counterparts who had approached
the Court earlier in time succeeded in their effort, then such
employees cannot claim that the benefit of the judgment rendered
in the case of similarly situated persons be extended to them. They
would be treated as fence-sitters and laches and delays, and/or the
acquiescence, would be a valid ground to dismiss their claim.
(3) However, this exception may not apply in those cases where the
judgment pronounced by the Court was judgment in rem with
intention to give benefit to all similarly situated persons, whether
they approached the Court or not. With such a pronouncement the
obligation is cast upon the authorities to itself extend the benefit
thereof to all similarly situated person. Such a situation can occur
when the subject matter of the decision touches upon the policy
matters, like scheme of regularization and the like (see K.C.
Sharma v. Union of India (supra). On the other hand, if the
judgment of the Court was in personam holding that benefit of the
said judgment shall accrue to the parties before the Court and such
an intention is stated expressly in the judgment or it can be
impliedly found out from the tenor and language of the judgment,
those who want to get the benefit of the said judgment extended to
them shall have to satisfy that their petition does not suffer from
either laches and delays or acquiescence.”
28. A principle, axiomatic in this country’s constitutional lore is that
there is no negative equality. In other words, if there has been a benefit
or advantage conferred on one or a set of people, without legal basis
or justification, that benefit cannot multiply, or be relied upon as a
principle of parity or equality. In Basawaraj v. Special Land
Acquisition Officer [(2013) 14 SCC 81], this Court ruled that:
“8. It is a settled legal proposition that Article 14 of the
Constitution is not meant to perpetuate illegality or fraud, even by
extending the wrong decisions made in other cases. The said
provision does not envisage negative quality but has only a positive
aspect. Thus, if some other similarly situated persons have been
granted some relief/benefit inadvertently or by mistake, such an
order does not confer any legal right on others to get the same
relief as well. If a wrong is committed in an earlier case, it cannot
be perpetuated.”
29.
In view of the above, this Court finds that the petitioners have not been
able to make out a case fit for consideration and for grant of relief thereof.
30.
This petition is accordingly dismissed as devoid of merits and disposed
of herein. No imposition of costs contemplated.
Judge
Meghalaya
05.12.2022
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review