The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. Accordingly, this Court holds that the prayer for quashment of the impugned advertisement and for direct regularisation/absorption of the petitioners cannot be granted, as the same would be contrary to the settled principles of service jurisprudence and statutory recruitment framework. However, this Court cannot be oblivious to the fact that the petitioners have served in EMRS institutions for a considerable period, imparting education to tribal students in remote areas. Their experience, familiarity with the EMRS system, and contribution to the functioning of the schools cannot be brushed aside lightly. Though the petitioners do not possess an enforceable legal right to regularisation, equity demands that their experience be given due consideration. It would be unjust to completely ignore the long years of service rendered by them while undertaking regular recruitment. Therefore, while upholding the authority of the Central Government/NESTS to conduct regular recruitment, this Court deems it appropriate to issue a balanced and equitable direction in the interest of justice.
17. Consequently, it is directed that the Central Government as well as the State Government/NESTS shall reconsider the cases of the petitioners, who have served in EMRS institutions for a considerable period, and their experience shall be given due weightage/preference, as permissible under the applicable recruitment rules or policy, while considering them for re-appointment or engagement, subject to fulfillment of eligibility conditions. It is clarified that this Court has not directed regularisation or automatic absorption, but has only directed reconsideration of the petitioners’ cases by giving due importance to their experience, so that the services rendered by them are not rendered meaningless.”
5. Since the grievance of the petitioners is identical to the one considered in WPS No.7753 of 2023 (Saroj Kumar Gupta and Others vs. Union of India and Others) and the petitioners in the present case are also seeking the same relief, the writ petition is accordingly disposed of in terms of and in line with the observations made in the aforesaid order. Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad) Avinash
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:8917
NAFR
AVINASH
SHARMA
Digitally
signed by
AVINASH
SHARMA
Date:
2026.02.23
15:09:21
+0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 9538 of 2023
1 - Preeti Mishra D/o Parmeshwar Mishra Aged About 30 Years
Presently Posted As Trained Graduate Teacher (English) At Eklavya
Model Residential School Bandhawa, Block Lormi District Mungeli
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Yashwant Kumar Sinha S/o Roopchand Sinha Aged About 31 Years
Presently Posted As Trained Graduate Teacher (Maths) At Eklavya
Model Residential School Bandhawa, Block Lormi District Mungeli
Chhattisgarh.
3 - Khemlata Dhruw D/o Lakhan Singh Shruw Aged About 33 Years
Presently Posted As Trained Graduate Teacher (Social Science) At
Eklavya Model Residential School Bandhawa, Block Lormi District
Mungeli Chhattisgarh.
4 - Tanuja Ratnakar D/o S. R. Ratnakar Aged About 29 Years Presently
Posted As Trained Graduate Teacher (Science) At Eklavya Model
Residential
School
Kosambuda,
Block
Lormi
District
Mungeli
Chhattisgarh.
5 - Indrani Rathore W/o Arvind Singh Aged About 32 Years Presently
Posted As Trained Graduate Teacher (Hindi) At Eklavya Model
Residential School Kosambuda, , Block Lormi District Mungeli
Chhattisgarh.
6 - Satyam Kumar Anant S/o Shriram Anant Aged About 32 Years
Presently Posted As Trained Graduate Teacher (Hindi) At Eklavya
Model
Residential
School
Jamthan,
Block
Bharatpur
District
Manendragarh Chirmiri Bharatpur Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioners.
versus
1 - Union Of India Through Its Secretary Ministry Of Tribal Affairs
Rajendra
Prasad
Road,
Shashtri
Bhawan
New
Delhi.
2 - National Education Society For Tribal Student Through Its
Commissioner Ministry Of Tribal Affairs, Ground Floor, Gate No. 3a,
Jeevan
Tara
Building,
Parliament
Street,
New
Delhi-110001.
3 - State Chhattisgarh Through Secretary Scheduled Caste Schedule
Tribe Development Department Of School Education Mantralaya
Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar,, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh C.G.
4 - Eklavya Vidyalaya Sangathan Samiti Through Its Commissioner Cum-Secretary
Scheduled
Caste
Schedule
Tribe
Development
Department Block -D Ground Floor, Indrawati Bhawan, Atal Nagar,
District Raipur Chhattisgarh.
... Respondents.
For Petitioners
: Shri Mateen Siddiqui, Advocate.
For State/Respondent : Shri Arpit Agrawal, Panel Lawyer.
(Hon'ble Shri Amitendra Kishore Prasad, Judge)
Order on Board
19/02/2026
1.
This Writ Petition has been filed against the impugned
advertisement issued by the National Education Society for Tribal
Students (NESTS), Ministry of Tribal Affairs, for recruitment of
teaching and non-teaching staff in Eklavya Model Residential
Schools (EMRS). The petitioners are permanent residents of
Chhattisgarh and are duly qualified TGT teachers who were
appointed between 2016 and 2022 in various EMRS institutions
through
orders
issued
by
the
Collector
and
Assistant
Commissioner, Tribal Welfare, and whose services have been
continuously extended for several years. Despite their long and
uninterrupted service against vacant posts, the respondent
authorities issued a fresh centralized advertisement inviting
applications
from
candidates
across
the
country,
without
considering the existing teachers or safeguarding their livelihood.
The petitioners contend that NESTS has no authority or locus to
issue such an advertisement, as under Clauses 9.1(k) and 9.3(e)
& (f) of the EMRS Guidelines, recruitment powers vest with the
competent State authority/Eklavya Vidyalaya Sangathan Samiti,
and no valid entrustment to NESTS has been shown. They,
therefore, challenge the advertisement as arbitrary, illegal,
contrary to the EMRS Guidelines and violative of Articles 14 and
16 of the Constitution of India.
2.
The petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs:10.1 That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to set-aside/ quash the advertisement
(P/1) issued by the National Education Society for
Tribal Student.
10.2 That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to direct the respondent authority to
consider the candidature of the petitioners for
regularization the services of the petitioners on
the post of Trained Graduate Teachers (TGT).
10.3 That, any other relief(s) which the Hon'ble
Court deems fit & proper may kindly be pleased to
granted in favour of the petitioners;
3.
Brief facts of the case are that the petitioners are permanent
residents of the State of Chhattisgarh and possess the requisite
educational qualifications for appointment to the post of Trained
Graduate Teachers (TGT) in Eklavya Model Residential Schools
(EMRS), namely a Bachelor Degree in the concerned subject
along with a B.Ed. Degree & Teacher Eligibility test. Pursuant
thereto, the petitioners were initially appointed as “ Trained
Graduate Teachers (TGT)” during the period 2016 to 2022 in
different EMRS institutions situated across various districts of
Chhattisgarh. Their appointments were made by the competent
authorities, namely the Collector and the Assistant Commissioner,
Tribal Welfare, and since the date of initial engagement, their
services have been continuously extended from time to time. At
present, the petitioners are discharging their duties with sincerity
and dedication. It is further submitted that the petitioners have
been rendering teaching services in EMRS institutions for several
years; some of them have completed more than six years of
uninterrupted service, many have completed more than four
years, and only a few have been engaged more recently, thereby
establishing their long association with the EMRS system in the
State.
The Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Union of India, issued
comprehensive guidelines dated 13.11.2020 governing the
functioning and administration of EMRS institutions. As per
Clause 9.1(k) of the said guidelines, the National Education
Society for Tribal Students (NESTS) may, if the need so arises,
entrust recruitment of teachers for States to an independent
agency, whereas Clauses 9.3(e) and (f) specifically cast the
responsibility of recruitment of teaching and non-teaching staff, in
accordance with prescribed norms and reservation policies, upon
the State/UT EMRS Society. Contrary to the aforesaid framework,
the respondent No.2–NESTS issued the impugned advertisement
(Annexure P/1) inviting applications for recruitment of teaching
and non-teaching posts in EMRS institutions across the country,
including the posts of TGTs presently held by the petitioners. The
recruitment process was opened at the national level, attracting
applications from candidates across India, without disclosing or
placing on record any document to show that recruitment for the
State of Chhattisgarh had been lawfully entrusted to any
independent agency in terms of Clause 9.1(k) of the guidelines.
The petitioners contend that the issuance of the impugned
advertisement by NESTS is without authority and jurisdiction, as
the power of recruitment vests with the State-level EMRS
Society/Eklavya Vidyalaya Sangathan Samiti under Clauses
9.3(e) and (f) of the guidelines. It is further pleaded that State-
level recruitment is essential to ensure proper implementation of
the reservation policy applicable within the State, and that
centralized recruitment would adversely affect the rights of
SC/ST/OBC candidates of Chhattisgarh, for whose benefit EMRS
institutions have been established. The petitioners have also
placed reliance on the fact that similarly situated teachers
approached
the
High
Court
of
Uttarakhand
in
WPSS
No.1414/2023, wherein the selection process pursuant to a similar
advertisement was stayed vide order dated 17.08.2023. It is
further submitted that despite long years of service, experience
certificates, and fulfillment of all eligibility criteria for regular
appointment, the respondent authorities failed to consider the
case of the petitioners for any alternative relief such as
absorption, regularization or continuation on contractual basis on
lines similar to schemes like ‘Vidya-Mitaan’, and instead
proceeded in a casual and arbitrary manner which threatens the
livelihood of the petitioners. The petitioners also rely upon the
circular dated 16.03.2022 issued by the Under Secretary, School
Education Department, Government of Chhattisgarh, wherein it
was directed that no regular appointment, promotion or transfer
shall be made in schools where guest teachers are already
working, as well as the order dated 15.11.2021 issued by the
Mizoram EMRS Society regularizing contractual employees.
Lastly, it is stated that the petitioners, through their union, namely,
Chhattisgarh Eklavya School Guest Teacher Union, submitted a
detailed representation dated 25.07.2023 to the Ex-officio
Secretary,
Eklavya
Vidyalaya
Sangathan
Samiti,
seeking
consideration of their cases for regularization on the post of TGT,
which has remained unattended till date. In these circumstances,
the petitioners assert that the impugned advertisement is illegal,
arbitrary and contrary to the EMRS guidelines, and that denial of
any protective or alternative relief to the petitioners is violative of
principles of natural justice and settled law, compelling them to
invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court.
4.
At the outset, learned counsel for the parties submit that the issue
involved in the present writ petition stands squarely covered by
the order passed by this Court in WPS No.7753 of 2023 (Saroj
Kumar Gupta and Others vs. Union of India and Others) and
other connected matters decided on 13.02.2026. It is jointly
prayed that the present writ petition may also be disposed of in
terms of the observations and findings recorded therein. The
relevant paragraphs of the said order are reproduced below:–
“10. The undisputed facts emerging from the record
are that the petitioners were engaged as PGT/TGT
teachers in different Eklavya Model Residential
Schools (EMRS) situated in various districts of the
State of Chhattisgarh between the years 2016 to
2024. Their engagements were made through orders
issued by the Collector / Assistant Commissioner,
Tribal Welfare / District Level EMRS Committees. It is
also not in dispute that the petitioners possess the
requisite educational qualifications prescribed for the
said posts. The petitioners admittedly were engaged
on a temporary/guest basis, and their services were
extended from time to time depending upon the
administrative requirements.
11. Though many of the petitioners have rendered
long years of service, in some cases extending
beyond six years, their engagement continued to
remain temporary in nature and was never converted
into a regular appointment through a process of
selection in accordance with statutory recruitment
rules. Subsequently, after the revamping of the EMRS
Scheme as a Central Sector Scheme, the National
Education Society for Tribal Students (NESTS) was
constituted and empowered to administer, manage,
and regulate EMRS institutions across the country.
Pursuant thereto, the Central Government approved
creation
of
regular
posts
and
framed
EMRS
Recruitment Rules, 2023, followed by issuance of a
centralised
teaching
advertisement
and
for
filling
up
regular
non-teaching
posts
in
EMRS
institutions.
12. The primary issue which thus arises for
consideration before this Court is whether the
petitioners, who were working on a temporary basis
for a long duration, have a legal right to seek
quashment of the centralised advertisement and
claim regularisation/absorption against the said posts.
13. The petitioners have argued that their long and
uninterrupted
service
has
created
a
legitimate
expectation for regularisation and that the recruitment
powers vest with the State EMRS Society under the
EMRS Guidelines. On the other hand, the learned
State counsel and learned counsel for the Union of
India have contended that the petitioners were
engaged purely on a temporary basis as a stop-gap
arrangement
and
that
regular
recruitment
exclusively
within
the
domain
of
the
falls
Central
Government/NESTS after revamping of the scheme.
14. Upon careful consideration of the record, this
Court finds that the nature of engagement of the
petitioners was purely temporary. The engagement
was not made pursuant to any regular recruitment
process nor under any statutory recruitment rules. It is
well settled that temporary or guest employees do not
acquire a vested right to be regularised merely on the
basis of long service, as held by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi
and subsequent judgments.
15. This Court further finds merit in the submission of
the respondents that after declaration of EMRS as a
Central Sector Scheme, the power to create posts
and undertake regular recruitment has been assumed
by
the
Central
Government
through
NESTS,
supported
by
Association,
statutory
and
rules,
Memoranda
Memorandum
of
of
Understanding
executed with the State EMRS Society. Therefore, the
contention
that
the
Central
Government
lacks
jurisdiction to issue the impugned advertisement
cannot be accepted.
16. Accordingly, this Court holds that the prayer for
quashment of the impugned advertisement and for
direct regularisation/absorption of the petitioners
cannot be granted, as the same would be contrary to
the settled principles of service jurisprudence and
statutory recruitment framework. However, this Court
cannot be oblivious to the fact that the petitioners
have served in EMRS institutions for a considerable
period, imparting education to tribal students in
remote areas. Their experience, familiarity with the
EMRS system, and contribution to the functioning of
the schools cannot be brushed aside lightly. Though
the petitioners do not possess an enforceable legal
right to regularisation, equity demands that their
experience be given due consideration. It would be
unjust to completely ignore the long years of service
rendered
by
them
while
undertaking
regular
recruitment. Therefore, while upholding the authority
of the Central Government/NESTS to conduct regular
recruitment, this Court deems it appropriate to issue a
balanced and equitable direction in the interest of
justice.
17. Consequently, it is directed that the Central
Government as well as the State Government/NESTS
shall reconsider the cases of the petitioners, who
have served in EMRS institutions for a considerable
period, and their experience shall be given due
weightage/preference, as permissible under the
applicable
recruitment
rules
or
policy,
while
considering them for re-appointment or engagement,
subject to fulfillment of eligibility conditions.
It is
clarified that this Court has not directed regularisation
or automatic absorption, but has only directed
reconsideration of the petitioners’ cases by giving due
importance to their experience, so that the services
rendered by them are not rendered meaningless.”
5.
Since the grievance of the petitioners is identical to the one
considered in WPS No.7753 of 2023 (Saroj Kumar Gupta and
Others vs. Union of India and Others) and the petitioners in the
present case are also seeking the same relief, the writ petition is
accordingly disposed of in terms of and in line with the
observations made in the aforesaid order.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
JUDGE
Avinash
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review