The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. Consequently, upon a cumulative assessment of the pleadings, evidence and circumstances appearing on record, this Court finds no perversity, illegality or material infirmity in the judgment and decree passed by the learned Family Court dismissing the application preferred by the appellant/husband under Section 9 of the Act of 1955. The findings recorded by the learned Family Court are supported by the material available on record and do not call for interference in the present appeal. The impugned judgment and decree are, accordingly, affirmed. Appeal is dismissed. Sd/- Sd/- (Parth Prateem Sahu) (Sachin Singh Rajput) Judge Judge Pawan/J
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010406912023
PAWAN
KUMAR
Digitally
signed by
PAWAN
KUMAR
Date:
2026.09.18
17:01:08
+0530
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Judgment Reserved on 18.06.2026
Judgment Pronouncement on 18.09.2026
Judgment full uploaded on 18.09.2026
FA(MAT) No. 5 of 2024
Praveen Kumar Yadav S/o Heeraram Yadav Aged About 26 Years Caste- Mahkul,
R/o Village- Kotba, Tahsil- Pathalgaon, District : Jashpur, Chhattisgarh
... Appellant
versus
Smt. Priyanka Yadav W/o Praveen Kumar Yadav Aged About 22 Years D/o
Nawratan Yadav, R/o - Khuntapani, Post- Kokiyakhar, Tahsil- Pathalgaon, District :
Jashpur, Chhattisgarh
... Respondent
For Appellant
:
Mr. Navneet Kumar Yadav, Advocate
For Respondent
:
Ms. Madhunisha Singh, Advocate
Hon’ble Shri Justice Parth Prateem Sahu
Hon’ble Shri Justice Sachin Singh Rajput,JJ
C A V Judgment
Per Sachin Singh Rajput, J.
This appeal has been filed against the judgment and decree dated
20.11.2023 passed by Family Court, Jashpur, CG in Civil Suit No. 30-A/2023
rejecting the application filed by the appellant/husband under Section 9 of the Hindu
Marriage Act, 1955 (for short “Act of 1955”) for Restitution of Conjugal Rights.
2.
The marriage between the parties took place on 07.02.2022 as per Hindu
Rights and Rituals at Village Khutapani. Till October 2022, the relations between the
two were cordial. Meanwhile, she became pregnant. On 19.10.2022 having received
an information of illness of the mother of respondent/wife, the appellant/husband
dropped her at her maternal home. On 23.10.2022 the appellant/husband went to
take back the respondent/wife and after Diwali festival he returned on 27.10.2022.
The respondent/wife however, refused to accompany him to Kunkuri where he used
to
work.
Thereafter,
on
31.10.2022,
07.11.2022
and
11.11.2022
the
appellant/husband visited the maternal home of the respondent/wife followed by his
parents on 24.11.2022 for taking the respondent/wife back but she refused to get
back and misbehaved with them also coupled with a threat their implication in a
false case.
3.
The appellant/husband also filed an application under Sections 97 and 98 of
CrPC before SDO, Patthalgaon for taking back the respondent/wife but she under
the pressure of her parents refused to return, and for that his application came to be
rejected on 31.03.2023. Registered notice sent by the appellant/husband on
06.03.2023 also did not bear any fruit nor did she make any effort to resume
matrimonial bond, and is living separately without any sufficient reason. Despite
several efforts, the respondent/wife is stated to be unwilling to live with the
appellant/husband though she is obliged to discharge the matrimonial obligations.
4.
The respondent/wife in her written statement has stated that on account of
her being subjected to ill-treatment and manhandling by the appellant/husband and
his parents on 19.02.2022 she had suffered a miscarriage. The Swift four wheeler
given in marriage by her parents was complained to be a cheaper one and just a
week after the marriage the appellant/husband, his parents, brother and maternal
uncle started raising a demand of Creta car and cash of rupees five lacs. She is
stated to be residing in her parents house since 19.10.2022 but nobody bothered to
take her back. Though the appellant/husband had come to her maternal home in
Diwali times, he returned alone in spite of her being ready to accompany him. At
that time, he also picked up quarrel reiterating the aforesaid demand. She had
made a complaint at various places including Sakhi Centre Jashpur regarding her
harassment at the hands of appellant/husband. According to her, the notice issued
by the appellant/husband was duly replied to on 01.04.2023 through an advocate.
She also filed an application in relation to domestic violence as she was harassed
by the appellant/husband and his family members in all possible views which made
it difficult for her to live with the appellant/husband. Not only this, he also kept with
him the Education Certificates, Adhaar Card, Caste Certificate and Bank Passbook
etc. of the respondent/wife. In her report to Women Cell she has made a categorical
allegation that the appellant/husband had an illicit affair with some other girl and she
herself had seen the objectionable photos and messages in his mobile phone.
When she asked him to discontinue all such objectionable activities, he subjected
her to beating and also threatened to eliminate her. Not only this, he never provided
medical treatment when she fell ill. His tortuous attitude towards her for bringing
less dowry was also causing mental cruelty to her. While living at Kunkuri, the
appellant husband used to leave for his workplace by confining her in a room. One
of the relatives of the husband had even made an utterance of giving poison to her
so that nobody would have any suspicion. Her allegation further runs that because
of the ill-treatment coupled with manhandling by the husband led to miscarriage
also, which she was prohibited to disclose to anyone or else she would be done
away with. With these pleadings she has prayed for rejection of the application filed
by the appellant/husband and also for an amount of rupees fifty lacs from him
towards alimony.
5.
The aforesaid pleadings led to framing of three issues which all have been
decided by the learned Family Court eventually culminating in rejection of the suit
filed by the appellant/husband. Hence this appeal.
6.
Learned counsel for the appellant/husband submits that the finding recorded
by the learned Family Court rejecting the application filed by the appellant/husband
under Section 9 of the Act of 1955 are without proper appreciation of the material
available on record. He submits that the allegations of dowry demand, assault and
harassment levelled by the respondent are false, afterthought and unsupported by
reliable evidence. According to him, the appellant has always been ready and willing
to discharge his matrimonial obligations and has made all possible efforts to restore
the matrimonial relationship but it is the respondent/wife who did not turned up. In
these circumstances the judgment impugned needs to be set aside.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent/wife submits that the
respondent/wife did not withdraw from the society of the appellant/husband without
any cause rather she was compelled to reside at her parental home on account of
continuous ill-treatment, physical assault and dowry demands made by him and his
family members. It is submitted that a demand for a Creta vehicle and Rs.
5,00,000/- in cash was made soon after the marriage and that the respondent/wife
had also suffered miscarriage on account of the alleged assault and harassment. It
is further submitted that the respondent/wife had lodged complaints before the
competent authorities, including the Sakhi Centre, Jashpur, and had also initiated
proceedings relating to domestic violence. As regards the appellant's assertion that
he repeatedly made efforts to bring her back, it is contended that his conduct during
the Diwali visit was not conducive to restoration of matrimonial life and being so, the
respondent/wife had sufficient and reasonable cause to live separately. In these
circumstances, the judgment impugned needs no disturbance by this Court.
8.
Heard counsel for the parties and perused the material available on record.
9.
On an overall consideration of the pleadings, evidence and material available
on record, this Court finds that although the respondent/wife has admittedly been
residing separately from the appellant/husband, the appellant has failed to establish
that such withdrawal from his society was without reasonable excuse within the
meaning of Section 9 of the Act of 1955. The question is not merely whether the
respondent/wife has withdrawn from the company of the appellant/husband, but
whether such withdrawal was without sufficient and reasonable cause. In the
present case, the allegations made by the respondent/wife regarding ill-treatment
and manhandling, demand of dowry in the form of a Creta vehicle and cash of
₹5,00,000/-, as well as the circumstances surrounding her miscarriage, assume
significance when considered in the backdrop of the complaints and proceedings
initiated by her in relation to domestic violence and the other circumstances brought
on record. These aspects, taken cumulatively, cannot be brushed aside or treated
as wholly irrelevant to the question of whether the respondent/wife had reasonable
justification for living separately. This Court also finds it material that the
appellant/husband had retained in his custody the educational and other public
documents of the respondent/wife and did not return the same despite her repeated
requests. The learned Family Court had, in this regard, directed the return of such
documents to the respondent/wife, while also observing that, in the event of noncompliance, she would be at liberty to proceed in accordance with law. The
withholding of documents belonging to the respondent/wife, particularly when their
return had been repeatedly sought, constitutes an additional circumstance which
cannot be ignored while assessing the overall conduct of the parties. Viewed in
conjunction with the other material on record, this circumstance lends support to the
respondent/wife's case that the matrimonial relationship had become strained and
that her decision to reside separately was not without justification.
10.
The material available on record, therefore, indicates that the respondent/wife
has succeeded in furnishing a reasonable and plausible explanation for remaining
apart from the company of the appellant/husband. The mere fact that the
appellant/husband made repeated visits to the parental home of the respondent/wife
or issued a legal notice expressing his willingness to resume matrimonial
cohabitation cannot, by itself, establish that her refusal to return was without
reasonable cause. Such subsequent expressions of willingness have to be
considered in the context of the circumstances prevailing between the parties and
the evidence already brought on record. The conduct of the parties, viewed as a
whole, thus does not justify a finding that the respondent/wife had withdrawn from
the society of the appellant/husband without reasonable excuse.
11.
Consequently, upon a cumulative assessment of the pleadings, evidence and
circumstances appearing on record, this Court finds no perversity, illegality or
material infirmity in the judgment and decree passed by the learned Family Court
dismissing the application preferred by the appellant/husband under Section 9 of the
Act of 1955. The findings recorded by the learned Family Court are supported by
the material available on record and do not call for interference in the present
appeal. The impugned judgment and decree are, accordingly, affirmed. Appeal is
dismissed.
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Parth Prateem Sahu)
(Sachin Singh Rajput)
Judge
Judge
Pawan/J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review