The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. 12.2023 at Annexures 7 is hereby set aside and this writ petition stands disposed of directing the opposite parties to treat the Petitioner as an employee Library Attendant in Nalini Devi Women’s College as on 01.04.1990 & grant all the benefits to the petitioner as due and admissible including the back wages, in consonance with the direction given by the learned tribunal in respect of Bimbadhar Senapati and Ajodhya Narayan Mohanty as well as Pabani Behera mentioned above, as expeditiously as possible, preferably within a period of four months from the date of production of certified copy of this order.
14. Sisir Signature Not Verified The Writ Petition is accordingly disposed of. ( A.K. Mohapatra) Judge Designation: Personal Assistant Reason: Authentication Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT Page 6 of 6.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
WP(C) No.31350 of 2024
.....
Pravat Kumar Pattanaik
Petitioner
Represented by Adv. –
Mr. Manas Pati
-versus1) state of odisha
.....
2) Secy. to Govt., Odisha
3) Director, Teacher Education and
State Council of Education
Research and Training, Odisha
4) Principal, Nalini Devi Womens
College of Education, BBSR,
Khurda
Opposite Parties
Represented by Adv. –
Smt. S. Nayak, ASC
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ADITYA KUMAR MOHAPATRA
ORDER
17.03.2026
Order No.
02.
1.
This matter is taken up through Hybrid Arrangement
(Virtual /Physical Mode).
2.
Heard Mr. Manas Pati, learned counsel for the petitioner
and Smt. S. Nayak, learned Additional Standing Counsel
appearing for the State-Opp. Parties.
3.
This matter was originally filed in the Cuttack Bench of
learned State Administrative Tribunal in O.A. No.1146(C) of
1998 and subsequently on its transfer to the Principal Bench, the
case was renumbered as O.A. No.85 of 2014. After abolition of
the learned Tribunal, the matter on transfer has been re-registered
as W.P.C(OA) No.85 of 2014.
4.
Originally, the matter in O.A. No.1146(C) of 1998 was filed
by the petitioner with the following prayer.
Page 1 of 6.
“ To direct the respondent to accept the applicant as
a member of non-teaching staff (Library Attendant)
of Nalini Devi Women’s College of Education in 1st
April, 1990 and commanding them to absorb her in
Govt. Service inconsonance with Section 7 of Orissa
Act, 24 of 1991 to maintain the inter se seniority of
the applicant and direct to pay all the service
benefits which she is otherwise entitled to with effect
from the date of her appointment.”
5.
It is submitted that learned Tribunal taking into account the
fact that the claim made by the petitioner is similar to the direction
issued in O.A. No.3283 (C ) of 1998 (Pabani Behera Vs. State of
Odisha & Others), disposed of the Original Application vide order
dated 25.8.2016 with the following direction:
“Thus in view of the above discussion, we do not
find any material to deny the claim of the applicant
or to take a view other than the view already taken
in the case of similarly situated persons and
therefore, we hold that the applicant was an
employee of Nalini Devi Women’s College of
Education Bhubaneswar as on 1.4.1990 and hence
he should be treated as government employee.
Accordingly, the respondents are directed to treat
the applicant to be in the employment of the college
as on 1.4.1990 and a government employee and
extend all service and financial benefits as due and
admissible. However, she will not be entitled to
backwage for the period she was out of employment,
but shall only be entitled to such benefit notionally.
The order be complied with as expeditiously as
possible, but within a period of three months from
the date of receipt of a copy of this order.”
6.
It is submitted that the said direction of the learned Tribunal
was challenged before this Court by the State-Opp. Parties in
W.P.(C ) No.19028 of 2017 and this Court vide order dated
12.1.2018 while setting aside the said order, remanded the matter
to the learned Tribunal. It is submitted that this Court basing on
Page 2 of 6.
the order passed on 12.1.2018 in W.P.(C ) No.19028 of 2017, set
aside the order passed by the learned Tribunal for its fresh
adjudication. It is submitted that in W.P.(C ) No.19028 of 2017,
the order passed by the learned Tribunal on 25.8.2016 in O.A.
No.85 of 2014/O.A. NO.1146(C ) of 1998 was assailed by the
State-Opp. Parties and this Court also while setting aside the order
passed by the learned Tribunal remitted the matter with the
following observation/direction:“In view of the inventory made in the institution to take
charge of it and no acquittacne roll was found in such
inventory, which has not been considered by the
Tribunal while passing the impugned order and as the
genuineness of such acquittance roll which was
produced by the applicant is in question this Court sets
aside the impugned order and remits the matter back to
the Tribunal for reconsideration of the Original
Application filed by the applicant giving liberty of
hearing to the parties. It is open to the petitioners to
file those materials before the Tribunal, which shall be
considered in accordance with law, at the time of
hearing of the Original Application.”
7.
It is submitted that since this Court while remitting the
matter for fresh determination by the learned Tribunal observed
that the petitioner is at liberty to file those materials in support of
his continuance as on 1.4.1990.
8.
It is submitted that on such remand of the matter, the Opp.
Parties not only filed a detailed counter but also the petitioner
filed a rejoinder affidavit inclosing therein various documents
showing his continuance as on 1.4.1990 under Annexures-R/1 to
R/4. It is submitted that basing on those documents those are filed
vide Annexures-R/1 to R/4 similarly situated employees like
Bimbadhar Senapati and Ajodhya Narayan Mohanty were allowed
Page 3 of 6.
benefit as prayed for by the petitioner in the present writ petition.
It is contended that one similarly situated employee, namely,
Bimbadhar Senapati had approached the Orissa Administrative
Tribunal by filing O.A. No. 578 of 2005, which was disposed of
vide order dated 14.12.2012, directing the opposite parties to treat
the petitioner therein, namely, Bimbadhar Senapati, as an
employee of Nalinidevi Women’s College of Education,
Bhubaneswar as on 01.04.1990 and allow him to work in the
college as a government servant. The tribunal further directed the
opposite parties to grant all the benefits of a government servant,
which are available to other employees absorbed in that college
after its taken over by the government. The very same judgment
was challenged by the opposite parties-State before this Court in
W.P.(C) No.24850 of 2013 and this Court, vide order dated
15.01.2014, was not inclined to interfere with the order passed by
the tribunal and accordingly dismissed the said writ petition.
Challenging the order dated 15.01.2014 passed in W.P.(C)
No.24850 of 2013, State preferred SLP before the Hon’ble apex
Court and the same was also dismissed. As a consequence thereof,
Bimbadhar Senapati, petitioner in O.A. No. 578 of 2005, was
granted with the benefits as due and admissible to him. It is
further contended that another similarly situated employee,
namely, Ajodhya Narayan Mohanty, approached the learned
Tribunal by filing O.A. No. 417 of 2016 and in turn learned
Tribunal allowed the same vide order dated 13.2.2007. The said
direction though was implemented by providing appointment, but
when financial benefit as due and admissible was not released, he
approached learned Tribunal in O.A. No.141 of 2013. Learned
Tribunal when vide order dated 19.6.2015 directed for grant of
Page 4 of 6.
notional benefit, said A.N. Mohanty challenging the same
approached this Court in W.P.(C ) No.16247 of 2016. State also
filed W.P.(C ) No.7012 of 2016 challenging the order dated
19.6.2015.
9.
It is submitted that this Court vide order dated 7.12.2016
while allowed the claim of the petitioner therein to extend the
financial benefit, dismissed the writ petition filed by the State,
Challenging the said order even though State preferred SLP Nos.
14514- 14515 of 2018, but the same were also dismissed. Thus, it
is contended that the petitioner having been placed in the same
footing, the benefit be extended to him within a stipulated time.
10.
It is further submitted that after confirmation of the order
passed in the case of Bimbadhar Senapati and Ajodhya Narayan
Mohanty, the opp. Parties have already extended the benefit vide
different orders passed by the opp. parties on 24.10.2019 in the
case of Ajodhya Narayan Mohanty and order dated 7.11.2017 in
the case of Bimbadhar Senapati. It is also submitted that the
benefit in respect of Pabani Behera has also been extended vide
order dated 17.4.2017. Making all such submissions, Mr. Pati,
learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that since persons
similarly situated have already been extended with the benefit as
prayed for by the petitioner, the petitioner being similarly situated
is also eligible and entitled to get the same.
11.
Smt. S. Nayak, learned Additional Standing Counsel for
School and Mass Education Department does not dispute the
above position and, as such, it is contended that the petitioner
stands on the similar footing with the petitioners of those cases
Page 5 of 6.
referred to above.
12.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after going
through the records, this Court is of the considered view that since
the petitioner stands on the similar footing with Bimbadhar
Senapati and Ajodhya Narayan Mohanty, mentioned supra and, as
such, the benefit has already been extended to them pursuant to
the orders passed by the tribunal, which were confirmed by this
Court as well the apex Court, the petitioner cannot be
discriminated, otherwise same would be violated of Article 14 of
the Constitution of India.
13.
In the above view of the matter, the impugned order dated
18.12.2023 at Annexures 7 is hereby set aside and this writ
petition stands disposed of directing the opposite parties to treat
the Petitioner as an employee Library Attendant in Nalini Devi
Women’s College as on 01.04.1990 & grant all the benefits to the
petitioner as due and admissible including the back wages, in
consonance with the direction given by the learned tribunal in
respect of Bimbadhar Senapati and Ajodhya Narayan Mohanty as
well as Pabani Behera mentioned above, as expeditiously as
possible, preferably within a period of four months from the date
of production of certified copy of this order.
14.
Sisir
Signature
Not Verified
The Writ Petition is accordingly disposed of.
( A.K. Mohapatra)
Judge
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SISIR KUMAR SETHI
Designation: Personal Assistant
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT
Date: 18-Mar-2026 18:58:18
Page 6 of 6.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review