Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
WP(C) No. 492 of 2026
Pravas Kumar Pradhan
.....
Petitioner
Mr. U.C. Mohanty, Advocate
State of Odisha & Ors.
-versus.....
Opposite Parties
Mr. S.P. Das, ASC
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
ORDER
30.01.2026
Order No. 03
1. This matter is taken up through hybrid mode.
2. Pursuant to order dtd.12.01.2026, learned Addl. Standing Counsel
produced the instruction provided by the Department vide letter
dtd.22.01.2026 with service of copy on the learned counsel appearing
for the Petitioner in Court. The same be kept in record.
3. Heard Mr. U.C. Mohanty, learned counsel appearing for the
Petitioner and Mr. S.P. Das, learned Addl. Standing Counsel
appearing for the Opp. Parties.
4. The present writ petition has been filed inter alia with the following
prayer:“In the aforesaid circumstances, it is humbly prayed that this
Hon'ble Court may graciously be pleased to admit this writ
application and issue a RULE NISI calling upon the Opposite
Parties to show cause as to why this writ application shall not
be allowed and if the Opposite Parties failed to show cause or
show insufficient cause, the said Rule may be made absolute
and on hearing the parties through their counsel, this Hon'ble
Court be further pleased to:Page 1 of 6.
i) Issue appropriate Writ/Writs in holding that the Part of the
Office dated 11.09.2025 under Annexure-8 issued by the Opp.
Party No. 2 in posting him as Additional Director, Canal,
Bhubaneswar/S.E instead of C.C.E/Additional Chief
Engineer/Director is illegal, arbitrary, unreasonable &
violative of principle of natural justice as well as the Article311 of Constitution of India as such quash the same and direct
the Opp. Parties to take necessary steps for issuance of fresh
Order appointing the Petitioner as C.C.E/Additional Chief
Engineer/Director.
ii) This Hon'ble Court be further pleased to pass such other
appropriate Writ/Writs, direction/directions, order/orders as
would be deem fit and proper in favour of the petitioner.
And for which act of kindness the Petitioner as in duty bound
shall ever pray.”
5. It is contended that even though Petitioner on being recommended
by the DPC was found eligible to get the benefit of promotion and
accordingly notification dtd.31.07.2024 under Annexure-2 was
issued by the Department, but prior to his relieve and joining in the
promotional post in terms of such notification, Petitioner since was
arrested in a vigilance proceeding on 3rd August, 2024, he could not
join in the said promotional post. Not only that because of his arrest
and remaining in custody in the vigilance proceeding on 03.08.2024,
Petitioner vide office order dtd.12.08.2024 under Annexure-3 was
placed under suspension w.e.f.03.08.2024.
5.1. However, it is contended that Petitioner subsequently was
released on bail and basing on the clearance issued by the vigilance
department,
Petitioner
though
was
reinstated
vide
order
dtd.11.09.2025 under Annexure-8, but he was never allowed to join
in his promotional post in terms of notification dtd.31.07.2024.
5.2. It is contended that Petitioner claiming such benefit of joining in
the promotional post though made various representations under
Page 2 of 6.
Annexure-9 & 10, but the same when were not considered, the present
writ petition was filed inter alia with the prayer as indicated
hereinabove.
5.3. Learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner contended that since
by the time the DPC recommended his claim with issuance of the
notification dtd.31.07.2024, there was no proceeding pending in the
eye of law and he was only arrested in a vigilance proceeding on
03.08.2024, where no charge sheet has yet been filed, there was no
bar on the part of Opp. Party No. 1 in allowing the Petitioner to join
in the promotional post in terms of notification dtd.31.07.2024. It is
contended that Petitioner since is going to retire tomorrow
(31.01.2026), unless he is allowed to join in the promotional, he will
suffer irreparable loss and injury. In support of his submission
reliance was placed to a decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
case of Union of India & Ors. Vs. Doly Loyi (Civil Appeal No(s).
8387 of 2013. Hon’ble Apex Court in Para 24 to 28 of the said
judgment has held as follows:
“24. Considering the above position, the disciplinary/criminal
proceedings can be said to be initiated against the employee only
when a charge memo is issued to the employee in a disciplinary
proceeding or a charge-sheet for a criminal prosecution is filed in
the competent Court. The sealed cover procedure is to be resorted
to only after issuance of the charge-memo/charge-sheet is issued.
The pendency of investigation and grant of prosecution sanction
will not be sufficient to enable the authorities to adopt the sealed
cover procedure.
25. In view of the aforesaid legal position, the crucial aspect
requiring examination is as to whether the prosecution for criminal
charge was pending against the respondent when the DPC meeting
was held.
26. It is not in dispute that the sanction to prosecute the
respondent was granted on 2nd June, 2006 and the charge sheet
was filed by CBI, after completion of investigation on 25th
Page 3 of 6.
October,
2008, whereas the DPC to consider the promotion of Additional
Commissioners of Income Tax was convened on 22nd February,
2007, wherein the sealed cover procedure was adopted qua the
respondent. It is thus clear that the charge sheet against the
respondent was filed well after the meeting of the DPC was
convened. Hence, it could not be said that the prosecution for a
criminal charge was pending against the respondent when the DPC
was convened. Therefore, the move on the part of DPC to resort to
the sealed cover procedure was unjustified and unsustainable on
facts and in law.
27. Resultantly, we have no hesitation in holding that the
impugned judgment of the High Court dated 26th April, 2013 is
based on apropos consideration of facts and law and hence the
same does not warrant interference.
28. The ‘Sealed Cover’ wherein the assessment of the respondent
was considered by the DPC was presented to the Court by learned
counsel for the appellant and was opened. The letter shows that
the DPC assessed the respondent to be ‘FIT’ for promotion.
Consequential steps in light of the above recommendations shall
follow.”
6. Basing on the instruction learned Addl. Standing Counsel
contended that though there is no dispute that Petitioner was
recommended by the DPC to get the benefit of promotion, which was
notified vide notification dtd.31.07.2024 under Annexure-2, but prior
to his joining in the promotional post, since Petitioner was implicated
in a vigilance proceeding and was arrested on 03.08.2024 in relation
to Balasore Vigilance P.S. Case No. 9 dtd.03.08.2024, Petitioner vide
order dtd.12.08.2024 under Annexure-3 was placed under suspension
w.e.f..03.08.2024.
6.1. It is contended that subsequently a disciplinary proceeding has
also been initiated against the Petitioner vide Memorandum
dtd.10.03.2025 for his involvement in the aforesaid Vigilance P.S.
Page 4 of 6.
Case. It is further contended that after his release on bail and taking
necessary clearance from the G.A. (Vigilance) Department, Cuttack
and upon obtaining views of the G.A. & P.G. Department, the
suspension Review Committee in its meeting held on 13.06.2025,
allowed the Petitioner to join in his former post. Petitioner
accordingly was reinstated vide order dtd.11.09.2025 under
Annexure-8. It is contended that since prior to his joining in the
promotional post in terms of notification dtd.31.07.2024 Petitioner
was implicated in the vigilance proceeding and a disciplinary
proceeding has also been initiated against him on 10.03.2025,
Petitioner is not eligible and entitled to get the benefit of notification
dt.31.07.2024.
7. Having heard learned counsel appearing for the Parties and
considering the submission made, this Court finds that Petitioner
while in service, vide notification dtd.31.07.2204 was promoted to the
rank of Addl. Chief Engineer (Civil) basing on the recommendation
made by the DPC. It is found that prior to his joining in the
promotional post, since Petitioner was arrested on 03.08.2024 in
relation to Balasore Vigilance P.S. Case No. 9 dtd.03.08.2024,
Petitioner could not join in the promotional post.
7.1. However, because of his arrest and remaining in custody,
Petitioner was placed under suspension w.e.f.03.08.2024 vide office
order
dtd.12.08.2024
under
Annexure-3.
Subsequently,
a
departmental proceeding has also been initiated against the Petitioner
vide memorandum dtd.10.03.2025 under Annexure-4. But on the face
of such pendency of the vigilance proceeding as well as the
departmental proceeding, basing on the no objection issued by the
G.A. (Vigilance) Department, Cuttack on 08.04.2025, the Suspension
Page 5 of 6.
Review Committee held on 13.06.2025 decided to reinstate the
Petitioner. Accordingly, Petitioner was reinstated vide order
dtd.11.09.2025 under Annexure-8.
7.2. However, claim of the Petitioner to get the benefit of joining in
his promotional post in terms of notification dtd.31.07.2024 was not
entertained and accordingly the present writ petition was filed with
the prayer to allow the Petitioner to join in his promotional post.
7.3. Considering the facts involved in the present case and the
decision Doly Loyi so cited (supra), it is the view of this Court that by
the time the DPC recommended the claim of the Petitioner with
issuance of the notification dtd.31.07.2204 under Annexure-2, since
no proceeding was pending against the Petitioner in the eye of law, it
is the view of this Court that there is no difficulty on the Party No. 1
in allowing the Petitioner to join in his promotional post in terms of
said notification. Therefore, this Court while disposing the writ
petition, directs Opp. Party Nos. 1 & 2 to allow the Petitioner to join
in his promotional post prior to his retirement, which falls due on 31st
January, 2026 in terms of notification dt.31.07.2024.
7.4. Learned Addl. Standing Counsel is also directed to intimate the
authority with regard to passing of the present order for its
compliance.
8. The writ petition accordingly stands disposed of.
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SNEHANJALI PARIDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa,
Cuttack
Sneha
Date: 30-Jan-2026 16:27:27
(BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY)
Judge
Page 6 of 6.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review