The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. 07. Ct rup FMA 249 of 2024 Pratima Tudu & Ors. Vs The New India Assurance Company Limited & Anr. Mr. Amit Ranjan Ray. … for the appellant. Ms. Sayanti Santra. … for the respondent/Insurance Company. Learned advocates for the parties are present. Heard learned advocates. The appellant before this Court were claimants in a claim case under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 and is aggrieved by the judgment and award dated 04.07. 2023 passed by the Learned Additional District Judge, 2nd Court, Asansol, Paschim Bardhaman in M.A.C. Case No. 01 of 2018. The case of the claimants before the Learned Trial Court may be summed up thus: That on 11-04-2017 at about 06 AM while the victim Puna Tudu alias Majhi was returning home after completion of his duty from his working place at Narsumuda Colliery and proceeding and walking towards B.N. R. side on the way at Asansol to Neanamatpur road near Ranjit petrol Pump he was dashed by a Ambassador Car bearing Regn. No. DL- 1-CN-1712 due to rash and negligent driving by its driver. As a result the victim sustained serious injuries all over his body. Local Police on duty brought him at Asansol District Hospital for treatment but the Attending Doctor declared him brought dead. This accident took place due to rash and negligent driving by the driver the said Ambassador Car. The victim was the only earning member of his family and due to his …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Item
No.
23.07.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Ct
rup
FMA 249 of 2024
Pratima Tudu & Ors.
Vs
The New India Assurance Company Limited & Anr.
Mr. Amit Ranjan Ray.
… for the appellant.
Ms. Sayanti Santra.
… for the respondent/Insurance Company.
Learned advocates for the parties are present.
Heard learned advocates.
The appellant before this Court were claimants
in a claim case under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle
Act, 1988 and is aggrieved by the judgment and award
dated 04.07. 2023 passed by the Learned Additional
District
Judge,
2nd
Court,
Asansol,
Paschim
Bardhaman in M.A.C. Case No. 01 of 2018.
The case of the claimants before the Learned
Trial Court may be summed up thus:
That on 11-04-2017 at about 06 AM while the
victim Puna Tudu alias Majhi was returning home
after completion of his duty from his working place
at Narsumuda Colliery and proceeding and walking
towards B.N. R. side on the way at Asansol to
Neanamatpur road near Ranjit petrol Pump he was
dashed by a Ambassador Car bearing Regn. No. DL-
1-CN-1712 due to rash and negligent driving by its
driver. As a result the victim sustained serious
injuries all over his body. Local Police on duty
brought
him
at
Asansol
District
Hospital
for
treatment but the Attending Doctor declared him
brought dead.
This accident took place due to rash and
negligent driving by the driver the said Ambassador
Car.
The victim was the only earning member of his
family and due to his sudden death his family
members are facing great difficulties and passing their
days with starvation.
Pursuant to the institution of this case, notice
was issued upon the opposite parties. The opposite
party/vehicle owner did not appear and contest the
case.
However,
the
opposite
party
New
India
Assurance Co. Ltd. contested the case by filing written
statement. Issues were framed and evidence was
adduced. Learned Trial Judge upon considering the
evidence and upon hearing the learned advocates for
the parties, was pleased to dispose of the claim case
by observing and directing as follows:
“Hence, it is
ORDERED
that
the
M.
A.
C.
Case.
No.
01/2018
(168/2017), CIS No. MAC 10151/2017 be and the
same is allowed on contest without any cost against
the OP no.2/The New India Assurance Company
Ltd. and ex-parte against the O.P. no. 1 the owner of
the offending Vehicle being no. DL-1-CH-1712
(Ambassador).
The
claimants
do
get
an
award
of
Rs.
13,94,800/- (Rupees Thirteen Lakhs Ninety Four
Thousand Eight Hundred Only) in this proceeding
subject to deposit of deficit court fee.
The
Company
OP
no.2
Ltd.
the
The
New
Insurer
India
Assurance
of
offending
the
Ambassador car being No. DL-1-CH-1712 is directed
to pay the compensation of Rs. 13,94,800/- (Rupees
Thirteen
Lakhs
Ninety
Four
Thousand
Eight
Hundred Only) to the claimants by five (4) account
payee cheques of Rs. 3,48,700/- each to claimant
Nos. 1 to 4 namely 1) Pratima Tudu (Wife of the
deceased),
2)
Disha
Tudu
(Daughter
of
the
deceased), 3) Bishal Tudu (Majhi) (Son of the
deceased) and 4) Kalomuni Mejhian (Mother of the
deceased) through the Tribunal within two months
hereof with the interest at the rate of 6% per annum
on the amount of compensation from the date of
filing of application till realization in full, subject to
deposit of deficit court fees.”
The appellants/claimants being aggrieved by
the judgment and award dated 04.07.2023 passed
by the Learned Trial Judge has come up with the
instant appeal.
Heard
learned
advocates
for
the
appellants/claimants and learned advocates for the
respondent no.1/insurance company. Perused the
evidence adduced and materials on record.
Learned
advocates
for
the
appellants/claimants submits that Learned Trial
Court erred in law in not taking into consideration
future prospect on the ground that the claimants
have received the death benefits of the deceased.
Learned advocate further submits that the release of
death benefits cannot be ground to deprive the
future prospect with regard to the compensation.
Learned advocate also submits that in terms of
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the Case
of National Insurance Company Limited versus
Pranay Sethi reported in AIR 2017 (SC) 3157 future
prospect is to be considered.
Learned advocate for the respondent no.1/
New India Assurance Company Limited disputes the
submission
of
the
learned
advocate
for
the
appellants and submits that compensation awarded
is just and reasonable.
Upon hearing the learned advocates and upon
considering the facts of the case, this Court is of the
view that the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of Pranay Sethi (supra) should be taken
into
consideration
prospect.
As
with
the
regard
victim
was
to
the
future
working
in
a
government undertaking the future prospect should
be 50%. It is well settled that mere grant of death
benefits to the victim’s family is not a ground for
adjusting the same from the compensation awarded
and for depriving the claimant’s /victim’s family
from compensation but the same may be taken into
consideration
to
decide
as
to
whether
the
compensation calculated is just and reasonable.
However, before coming to the conclusion as to
whether the compensation computed is just and
reasonable at the very out set the compensation
should be computed as per guidelines provided
under the law and different judicial decisions.
Pursuant to the computation of the compensation
and considering the death benefits or any pension
which is received by the victim’s family it has to be
decided
whether
the
compensation
which
is
ascertained by arithmetical calculation is just and
reasonable.
In the instant case, the monthly income is
considered Rs.9000/- per month, the yearly income
comes to Rs.1,08,000/-. 1/3 being deducted the net
yearly income comes to Rs.72,000/-. The multiplier
of 16 being applied, the total dependency loss comes
s. 11,52,000/-.
added
the
Future prospect of 50% being
total
dependency
loss
comes
to
Rs.17,28,000/-. Further the claimants are entitled
to Rs.1,10,000/- on account of consortium, loss of
estate and funeral expenses. Thus, Rs.18,38,000/is the total compensation which is arrived by
arithmetical
calculation
with
regard
to
the
entitlement of the claimants.
However, as Courts are empowered to award
just and reasonable compensation in accordance
with Section 168 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 it is
necessary
to
consider
as
to
whether
the
compensation calculated is just and reasonable. In
the case of National Insurance Company Limited vs.
Indira Shrivastav reported in AIR 2008 S.C 845the
Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as follows:“23. The expression 'just' must also be given its
logical meaning. Whereas it cannot be a bonanza or a
source of profit but in considering as to what would
be just and equitable, all facts and circumstances
must be taken into consideration.”
In the case of T. N State Transport Corporation
Ltd. Vs. Rajapriya and Ors. reported in (2005) 6
SCC 236, the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as
follows:“10. Much of the calculation necessarily
remains in the realm of hypothesis "and in that
region arithmetic is a good servant but a bad master"
since there are so often many imponderables. In
every case "it is the overall picture that matters", and
the court must try to assess as best as it can the loss
suffered.”
As Courts are empowered to award just and
reasonable
compensation
it
should
also
be
considered as to whether the compensation derived
by the arithmetical calculation would be just and
reasonable.
It
is
well
known
that
when
a
government employee dies during service the family
members get either family pension or compassionate
appointment as well as death benefits.
Although
grant of death benefits and family pension is not
ground to deprive compensation to the victim’s
family or to adjust the same from the pension
calculated
but
the
same
can
be
taken
into
consideration to arrive at a reasonable and just
compensation.
In the instant case, as per deposition of PW-1
the application for compassionate appointment is
already made and as per government service rules
family pension or compassionate appointment is
granted in case of died-in-harness cases.
This
Court is thus of the view that it would be just and
reasonable to take this factor into consideration and
award compensation of Rs.16,00,000/-.
Hence, this appeal being FMA 249 of 2024
stands disposed of.
The judgment and award dated 04.07. 2023
passed by the Learned Additional District Judge, 2 nd
Court, Asansol, Paschim Bardhaman in M.A.C. Case
No. 01 of 2018 stands modified to the extent that
the
claimants/appellants
are
entitled
to
Rs.16,00,000/- from New India Assurance Company
Limited along with interest @ 6% p.a from the date
of filing of the claim case till today. The respondent
No.1/New India Assurance Company shall deposit
Rs.16,00,000/- along with interest @ 6% p.a within
a
period
of
eight
weeks
from
the
date
of
communication of this order.
In the event the compensation awarded by the
Learned Trial Court is deposited or paid to the
claimants the balance amount be deposited.
Deficit court fees, if any, be paid within four
weeks.
As it is submitted by the learned advocate for
the claimants/appellants that the compensation
awarded by the Learned Trial Court is already
received the balance amount be deposited.
The appellants/claimants are permitted to
withdraw the balance compensation amount in
equal shares upon compliance of all necessary
formalities.
Urgent photostat certified copy of the order, if
applied
for,
undertakings.
be
given
to
the
parties
on
usual
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review