The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
96. 21-01-2026 WPA 25295 of 2025 CAN 1 of 2025 Ct. 19 Jhuma Mukherjee Versus The State of West Bengal & Ors. sg With WPA 27281 of 2025 Prateek Jain Versus The State of West Bengal & Ors. Mr. Aniruddha Chatterjee, Sr. Adv. Mr. Suddhasatva Banerjee Mr. Shashwat Nayak Mr. Rajeep Mantha Mr. Ajit Keshari …for the petitioner in WPA 25295/2025 For the respondent no.6 in WPA 27281/2025 Mr. Soumya Majumdar, Sr. Adv. Mr. Siddhartha Banerjee Ms Debjani Sengupta Mr. Rajib Mullick Ms. Divya Agarwal …for the petitioner in WPA 27281/2025 Mr. Vivekananda Bose Mr. Priyamvada Singh …for the State in WPA 25295/2025 Mr. Chandi Charan De, AGP Ms. Chandana Ghosh …for the State in WPA 27281/2025 Mr. Majumdar, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner in WPA 27281 of 2025, prays for leave to file a supplementary affidavit. Such leave is granted. The supplementary affidavit filed in Court is taken on record. A copy of the said supplementary affidavit has been served upon the learned Advocates for the respective parties in course of hearing of these petitions. A plot of land being Plot No. 70 in Block AD, in Sector-I, Salt Lake City, was leased out by an indenture of lease dated October 13, 1976 in favour of Biswanath Lahiri and Swapna Lahiri, both since deceased, by the Governor of West Bengal. By virtue of the last will and testament dated
18. 03.2024 executed by the original lessees, the leasehold property was bequeathed in favour of two daughters of the original lessees. The petitioner in WPA 27281 of 2025 claims that undivided 1/3rd share of leasehold right, title and interest of the land being plot no. 70, in Block AD, Sector-I, Salt Lake City, was assigned in his favour by virtue of a deed of assignment of lease dated 17th April, 2025 executed by and between Smt. Ruma Bhattacharya, one of the daughters of the original lessee, being the assignor and the Prateek Jain, the petitioner in WPA 27281 of 2025 as the assignee. Alleging that Prateek Jain was carrying on a restaurant-cum-hukka bar in the ground floor of the premises, being AD-70, Sector-I, Salt Lake, a writ petition was filed being WPA 25295 of 2025. When WPA 25295 of 2025 came up for hearing on November 12, 2025, this Court directed the Land Manager, Department of Urban Development and Municipal Affairs, Government of West Bengal, to file a report stating in detail the steps taken by such authority pursuant to the complaint lodged by the petitioner in WPA 25295 of 2025. On 14th November, 2025, this Court, after considering the report filed by the third respondent in the said writ petition, passed an interim order to the following effect: “There shall be an order of injunction restraining the respondent nos.4 to 6 from running any CAFÉ-cum- Restaurant and/…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Items95 &
96.
21-01-2026
WPA 25295 of 2025
CAN 1 of 2025
Ct. 19
Jhuma Mukherjee
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
sg
With
WPA 27281 of 2025
Prateek Jain
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Aniruddha Chatterjee, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Suddhasatva Banerjee
Mr. Shashwat Nayak
Mr. Rajeep Mantha
Mr. Ajit Keshari
…for the petitioner in WPA 25295/2025
For the respondent no.6 in WPA 27281/2025
Mr. Soumya Majumdar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Siddhartha Banerjee
Ms Debjani Sengupta
Mr. Rajib Mullick
Ms. Divya Agarwal
…for the petitioner in WPA 27281/2025
For the private respondents in WPA 25295/2025
Mr. Vivekananda Bose
Mr. Priyamvada Singh
…for the State in WPA 25295/2025
Mr. Chandi Charan De, AGP
Ms. Chandana Ghosh
…for the State in WPA 27281/2025
Mr. Majumdar, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the petitioner in WPA 27281 of 2025, prays for leave to file a
supplementary affidavit.
Such leave is granted.
The supplementary affidavit filed in Court is taken
on record.
A copy of the said supplementary affidavit has been
served upon the learned Advocates for the respective parties
in course of hearing of these petitions.
A plot of land being Plot No. 70 in Block AD, in
Sector-I, Salt Lake City, was leased out by an indenture of
lease dated October 13, 1976 in favour of Biswanath Lahiri
and Swapna Lahiri, both since deceased, by the Governor of
West Bengal. By virtue of the last will and testament dated
18.03.2024 executed by the original lessees, the leasehold
property was bequeathed in favour of two daughters of the
original lessees.
The petitioner in WPA 27281 of 2025 claims that
undivided 1/3rd share of leasehold right, title and interest of
the land being plot no. 70, in Block AD, Sector-I, Salt Lake
City, was assigned in his favour by virtue of a deed of
assignment of lease dated 17th April, 2025 executed by and
between Smt. Ruma Bhattacharya, one of the daughters of the
original lessee, being the assignor and the Prateek Jain, the
petitioner in WPA 27281 of 2025 as the assignee.
Alleging that Prateek Jain was carrying on a
restaurant-cum-hukka bar in the ground floor of the premises,
being AD-70, Sector-I, Salt Lake, a writ petition was filed
being WPA 25295 of 2025. When WPA 25295 of 2025 came
up for hearing on November 12, 2025, this Court directed the
Land Manager, Department of Urban Development and
Municipal Affairs, Government of West Bengal, to file a
report stating in detail the steps taken by such authority
pursuant to the complaint lodged by the petitioner in WPA
25295 of 2025. On 14th November, 2025, this Court, after
considering the report filed by the third respondent in the said
writ petition, passed an interim order to the following effect:
“There shall be an order of injunction restraining
the respondent nos.4 to 6 from running any CAFÉ-cum-
Restaurant and/or as a Hookah Bar in the ground floor
of the premises being AD-70, Sector-I, Salt Lake City,
Kolkata 700064 till the end of the month of December,
2025 or until further orders whichever is earlier.
As prayed for by Mr. Mukherjee, learned senior
advocate, the private respondents will be at liberty to
file an affidavit-in-opposition on or before November
20, 2025 after serving an advance copy of the same to
the learned advocate for the petitioner. Reply thereto, if
any, be filed by 25th November, 2025 after serving an
advance copy of the same to the learned advocate for
the private respondent.
The Inspector-in-Charge, Bidhannagar North
Police Station being the added respondent is directed to
ensure compliance of this order as well as the
directions passed by the Land Manager as indicated in
the report filed in Court today.”
At this stage, it would be relevant to note that on 13th
November, 2025, a show cause notice was issued to the
petitioners of both the writ petitions directing them to show
cause within the time limit indicated in the said notice as to
why necessary action shall not be taken against them for
violation of clause 2(10) of the Lease Deed read with clause 4
of the Lease Deed. The respective writ petitioners claim to
have replied to the show cause notice dated November 13,
2025, but till date, no decision on such show cause notice has
been taken by the concerned authority.
Mr. Dey, learned Additional Government Pleader,
submits that since the writ petitions are pending before this
Hon’ble Court, the respondent authorities did not take any
further steps on the show cause notice issued by the Land
Manager, Bidhannagar.
Mr. Majumdar, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the petitioner in WPA 27281 of 2025, places reliance upon
various notifications issued by the Government of West
Bengal, Urban Development Department dated April 5, 2010;
August 22, 2014 and April 28, 2015 and submits that though
initially, the Government decided to lease out the plots in Salt
Lake City only for residential purpose but subsequently
decided to allow such properties to be utilized for nonresidential purposes also. By relying upon the said
notifications, Mr. Majumdar would contend that the
respondent authorities were under an obligation to permit the
petitioner in WPA 27281 of 2025 to run the restaurant
business from a portion of the property in question in the light
of the policy decision taken by the Government.
Mr. Chatterjee, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the petitioner in WPA 25295 of 2025, submits that the plot in
question was leased out only for residential purpose and
without obtaining prior permission from the concerned
authority, the said property or any portion thereof cannot be
utilized for non-residential purpose(s).
The dispute is whether the property leased out can be
used for non-residential purposes. One of the parties claim
that such property can be utilized for non-residential purpose,
while the other claims that non-residential user of the
property is not permissible. Decision on such issue requires
interpretation of the clauses in the lease deed and the effect of
the notifications issued from time to time.
After going through the materials on record, this
Court finds that a show cause notice has been issued to the
respective petitioners directing them to show cause as to why
action against them shall not be taken for violation of clause
2(10) of the Lease Deed read with clause 4 of the Lease Deed.
Since a show-cause notice has been issued alleging violation
of certain terms of the lease deed; this Court feels that the
respondent authority should be directed to take a decision of
the issue raised in the show cause notice. It is also not in
dispute that the respective petitioners have replied to the said
show cause notice.
Since WPA 25295 of 2025 was filed alleging that
the private respondent therein (petitioner in WPA 27281 of
2025) was using the property for running a restaurant-cumhukka bar in violation of the terms and conditions of the
Lease Deed and such fact is disputed by the petitioner in
WPA 27281 of 20281, this Court refrains from making any
observation on the issues raised in the respective writ
petitions as the same might prejudice the rights of the
respective parties before the concerned authority in the
adjudication on the show cause notice dated 13th November,
2025.
At this stage, Mr. Majumdar, submits that the interim
order passed by this Court is seriously affecting the livelihood
of the petitioner in WPA 27281 of 2025 and the petitioner
may be allowed to run the restaurant business from the
property in question till the show cause issued by the Land
Manager is adjudicated.
Such prayer is seriously opposed by Mr. Chatterjee.
This Court is not inclined to allow the prayer of Mr.
Majumder pending adjudication on the show cause notice.
This Court is of the considered view, that the interest
of justice would be sub-served if the concerned authority is
directed to decide the show cause notice within a short span
of time.
With the consent of the learned Advocates for the
respective parties, the date of hearing before the Land
Manager is fixed on January 29, 2026 at about 2 P.M.
Since the date and time of hearing is fixed by this
Court in presence of the learned Advocates for the respective
parties, the Land Manager would not be required to issue any
further notice of hearing to the respective parties.
The
Land
Manager,
Department
of
Urban
Development and Municipal Affairs, Government of West
Bengal, is directed to conduct a hearing on the show cause
notice dated 13th November, 2025 on January 29, 2026 at the
time mentioned hereinbefore and shall make an endeavour to
conclude the hearing on that date itself. If for any reason
whatsoever, the hearing cannot be completed by that date, the
hearing shall be again taken up and completed by January 30,
2026.
The adjudication on show cause notice dated 13th
November, 2025 shall be made by the Land Manager by
passing a reasoned order after giving an opportunity of
hearing to the respective writ petitioners or their authorized
representatives. The reasoned order shall be communicated to
the respective parties on or before February 6, 2026.
The interim order passed by this Court on November
14, 2025 shall remain in force till the communication of the
reasoned order to be passed by the Land Manager, to the
respective parties.
With the above observations, both the writ petitions
and the connected application stand disposed of.
It is, however, made clear that this Court has not
gone into the merits of the claims and counter claims made by
the aforesaid parties in the respective writ petitions. All points
are left open to be considered and decided by the Land
Manager.
It is also, made clear that all the observations made
in the order dated November 14, 2025 were only for the
purpose of supporting the interim order passed by this Court
and the Land Manager shall be free to decide the show-cause
notice without being influenced by any of the observations
made in the said order or any other orders passed in these writ
petitions. No costs.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if
applied for, be supplied to the parties upon compliance of all
requisite formalities.
(Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review