Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC010174232024
2026:GAU-AS:13788
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/4584/2024
PRAMOD KUMAR TIWARI
S/O- LATE BADRI PRASAD TIWARI, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- GURPUR, P.O.
GHURPUR, P.S. GHOORPUR, DISTRICT- ALLAHABAD, UTTAR PRADESH,
PIN- 212107 PHONE NO. 8294528041, 9455195185
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 2 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS,
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, NORTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI- 110001
2:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL
SASHASTRA SEEMA BAL
BLOCK-V
EASTERN
R.K.PURAM
NEW DELHI- 110066
3:THE COMMANDING OFFICER
06 BN
SSB
RANIGHULI
KOKRAJHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 78337
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. R J SARMA, MR U PANDEY,MR. K LAHKAR,A
MISHRA,MR. A TARAFDAR
Advocate for the Respondent : DY.S.G.I., MR. A K DUTTA(R-1 TO 3))
Page No.# 2/12
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 15-09-2026
Heard Mr. K. Lahkar, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. A.K. Dutta,
learned CGC appearing for the respondents.
2.
The petitioner by way of instituting the present writ petition has presented a
challenge to a communication dated 30-06-2023, by which the prayer of the petitioner for
withdrawal of his resignation, was rejected.
3.
As projected in the writ petition, the petitioner was enrolled as a Constable in
Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB), on 02-04-2006. The petitioner continued in his services and
was subsequently, promoted as Head Constable. While the petitioner was posted with the
6th Bn. SSB at Ranighuli, Kokrajhar, he had received information from his family that their
land was being tried to be grabbed by some land mafia basing on the strength of forged
and fabricated documents.
3.1.
The petitioner, accordingly, lodged an FIR before the jurisdictional Police Station.
However, the police had not proceeded to take steps in the matter and provide justice to
the petitioner. It is projected that pursuant to the FIR lodged by the petitioner, on
conclusion of the investigation, a Final Report was submitted by the police in the matter
and the petitioner had filed an objection, thereto, before the Judicial Magistrate,
Allahabad. The Judicial Magistrate, thereafter, on consideration of the objection submitted
by the petitioner, had proceeded with the trial of the case, which is presently pending
Page No.# 3/12
disposal.
3.2.
In view of the said developments taking place, the petitioner projects that his
family was being constantly harassed by the persons against whom the petitioner had
raised allegations and the said aspect of the matter was also communicated by the
petitioner to the higher authorities of the Force. It is further projected that the
Commandant of the Unit, wherein, the petitioner was posted, had also taken up the
matter with the Superintendent of Police as well as the jurisdictional District Magistrate of
the native village of the petitioner, however, no action was taken. The steps taken by the
petitioner, had no effect and the harassment meted out to his family being continued, the
petitioner proceeded to submit his resignation on 24-05-2023. The said resignation was
accepted by the concerned authorities on 26-05-2023 and the petitioner was relieved
from his services, on 27-05-2023. The petitioner, on 27-05-2023, submitted an application
for withdrawal of his resignation and therein, inter alia, had contended that his mental
condition, at the time of submission of his application for resignation, was not good.
3.3.
It was further contended that the petitioner had prayed for grant of leave
considering the problems faced by his family and had 240 days of Earned Leave in his
leave account, however, the petitioner was not granted leave and asked to resign from his
service. The said application submitted by the petitioner was considered by the
Commandant of the Battalion, to which the petitioner was posted in the light of the OM
dated 10-06-2019. Upon such consideration, vide communication dated 30-06-2023, the
prayer of the petitioner for withdrawal of his resignation was rejected on the ground that
the family problems faced by the petitioner would not permit him to continue his active
Page No.# 4/12
duty in the Force efficiently and on account of his personal problems he would not be
meeting the requirement of the job.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner has instituted the present writ petition.
4.
Mr. K. Lahkar, learned counsel for the petitioner after reiterating the facts noticed,
hereinabove, has submitted that the rejection of the application of the petitioner for
withdrawal of his resignation was considered under the provisions of the OM dated 10-062019. By referring to the provisions of the OM dated 10-06-2019, Mr. Lahkar has
submitted that the withdrawal of a resignation is permissible even after the acceptance of
the same by the competent authority, provided the conduct of the person concerned was
in no way improper. Mr. Lahkar further submits that there is no material brought on record
by the respondents to demonstrate that the conduct of the petitioner was in any manner
improper during the period when he had submitted application for resignation from his
service and/ or during the period the same was considered and accepted. Mr. Lahkar
further submitted that the reason assigned for rejection of the application of the
petitioner, in the communication dated 30-06-2023, to be clearly perverse, inasmuch as,
the said ground which relates to the suitability of the petitioner to continue in his services,
could not have been raised by the Commandant, while considering the matter as to
whether the application for withdrawal of resignation was to be accepted or not. Mr.
Lahkar submits that the said matter would have been so permissible to be raised only in
the event a due departmental proceeding was instituted against the petitioner. Mr. Lahkar,
accordingly, submits that the provisions of the OM dated 10-06-2019, having permitted
the acceptance of the application submitted by the petitioner for withdrawal of his
Page No.# 5/12
resignation, the non-consideration of the application for withdrawal submitted by the
petitioner, by the respondent authorities, in its proper perspective has caused prejudice to
the interest of the petitioner and accordingly, he submits that the order of rejection dated
30-06-2023, along with the order dated 27-05-2023, issued towards acceptance of the
resignation of the petitioner, would mandate interference from this Court.
5.
Mr. A.K. Dutta, learned CGC appearing for the respondents has submitted that the
petitioner after he had submitted his application for resignation from his service, was
counseled by his superiors. It is only when the petitioner had continuously pressed for
acceptance of his resignation, the respondent authorities had proceeded to issue the
order dated 27-05-2023, accepting the resignation of the petitioner. Mr. Dutta submits
that the conduct of the petitioner as borne out from his service records, is not proper,
inasmuch as, the petitioner was awarded minor punishment as well as had around 05
(five) cases pertaining to overstay of leave. It is further projected that during the year
2022, the petitioner had availed 196 days of leave in 05 (five) spells and during the year
2023, he had availed 60 days of leave in 02 (two) spells, till his release from service on
27-05-2023.
5.1.
Mr. Dutta, further submits that the petitioner, prior to submission of his application
for resignation from service, had submitted an application praying for proceeding on
voluntary retirement. However, the petitioner not having completed the mandated service
period, his such application could not be accepted. Thereafter, the petitioner had
submitted application for resignation from his service. Mr. Dutta submits that considering
the personal/ family problems faced by the petitioner, he was found to be not
Page No.# 6/12
concentrating on the job required to be performed by him and accordingly, the competent
authority while considering the application of the petitioner for withdrawal of his
resignation, had also in the interest of the Force, considered the manner in which the
petitioner was discharging his duties and had accordingly, came to the conclusion that the
petitioner is not fit for further continuation in his service on account of his domestic
problems, which had prevented him from discharging his duties in the Force. Accordingly,
Mr. Dutta submits that there is no error on the part of the respondent authorities, in
rejecting the application submitted by the petitioner, for withdrawal of his resignation. Mr.
Dutta submits that the claims made in the present writ petition would not mandate
acceptance from this Court.
6.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have also perused the
materials available on record.
7.
The petitioner, in the present proceeding, on account of certain personal as well as
family problems faced by him had submitted an application on 24-05-2023, praying for
resignation from his service. The petitioner had in his said resignation letter highlighted
that on account of certain land dispute and false litigation initiated in the matter at his
native village and also his mother not keeping well; the petitioner being the sole care
taker of the family, he was required to submit his resignation in the matter. The
respondent authorities had counseled the petitioner after receipt of the said application
dated 24-05-2023 and the petitioner having insisted for the acceptance of his resignation,
the competent authority vide the order dated 27-05-2023, relieved the petitioner from his
services, w.e.f. 27-05-2023, on the acceptance of his resignation, on 26-05-2023. The
Page No.# 7/12
petitioner, thereafter on 27-05-2023, submitted an application for withdrawal of his
resignation and therein, had projected that on account of his mental condition, at the
time of submitting his application for resignation from his services, the application
submitted be permitted to be withdrawn. The respondent authorities vide communication
dated 30-06-2023, on consideration of the prayer of the petitioner for withdrawal of his
resignation, had proceeded to reject the same.
8.
The contents of the communication dated 30-06-2023, being relevant for
adjudication of the issues arising in the present writ petition, the same is extracted, herein-below, for ready reference:“To
Regt No. 060351341 ex. HC (GD) Pramod Kumar Tiwari
S/o Shri Badri Prasad Tiwari
Village & Post-Ghoor Pur
Tehsil-Bara, Distt. Paryagraj
Uttar Pradesh-212107
Sub: Withdrawal of resignation and resumption of Govt. duty.
This is with reference to your letter no. nil dated 28.05.2023 addressed to
the Commandant, 6 Bn SSB, Ranighuli regarding cancellation of withdrawal and
resumption of Government service.
2.
Your request for withdrawal of resignation and resumption of Government
service has been considered by the Commandant, 6 Bn SSB in accordance with the
guidelines issued vide Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Deptt.
of Personnel & Training OM No. 28035/2/2014-Estt. (A) dated 10.06.2019.
3.
After careful examination of the case and going through the
reasons/circumstances under which you tendered resignation, the Commandant, 6
Bn SSB has concluded that you will not be in position to continue such Active Duty'
in Force with your problems efficiently and you would not be meeting the
requirement of job with your personal problem.
Page No.# 8/12
4.
Hence, your request for cancellation of resignation and resumption of
Government service is NOT ACCEPTED by the Commandant, 6 Bn SSB.
5.
This is for your information.
(Lokesh Kumar Singh), 21C
Commanding Officer
6th Bn SSB, Ranighuli”
9.
A perusal of the said communication would go to reveal that the application
submitted by the petitioner for withdrawal of his resignation was considered in the light of
the provisions contained in the OM dated 10-06-2019. Having considered the said
application, the competent authority proceeded to conclude that the petitioner would not
be in a position to continue his active services in the Force, considering the personal
problems faced by him. He was further held to be not meeting the requirement of the job
on account of the personal problems faced by him. Accordingly, the application submitted
in the matter was rejected.
10.
The application for withdrawal of the resignation submitted by the petitioner having
been considered vide the communication dated 30-06-2023, in the light of the OM dated
10-06-2019, the provisions, thereof, would be required to be noticed by this Court. A
perusal of the OM dated 10-06-2019 would go to reveal that the same was issued with
regard to the withdrawal of resignation by central Government servants appointed after
31-12-2003 and covered by the National Pension System (NPS). In the said OM, it was
highlighted that in the matter of withdrawal of resignation of Government servants, of
Central Civil Services/ posts appointed after 31-12-2003, who are covered under the NPS
and for whom the CCS(Pension) Rules, 1972 is not applicable was considered and with
Page No.# 9/12
the approval of the competent authority, the guidelines, i.e. to be followed while
considering the request for withdrawal of resignation of the Government servant was set
out.
11.
Clause 2 of the said OM dated 10-06-2019, being relevant is extracted, here-in-
below:“2. The appointing authority may permit a person to withdraw his resignation in
the public interest on the following conditions, namely
(a) that the resignation was tendered by the Government Servant for
some compelling reasons which did not involve any reflection on his integrity
efficiency or conduct and the request for withdrawal of the resignation has
been made as a result of a material change in the circumstances which
originally compelled him to tender the resignation:
(b) that during the period intervening between the date on which the
resignation became effective and the date from which the request for
withdrawal was made the conduct of the person concerned was in no way
improper:
(c) that the period of absence from duty between the date on which
the resignation became effective and the date on which the person is
allowed to resume duty as a result of permission to withdraw the resignation
is not more than ninety days:
(d) that the post which was vacated by the Government servant on
the acceptance of his resignation or any other comparable post, is available.”
12.
A perusal of the circumstances as set out in Clause-2 of the said OM dated 10-06-
2019, reveals that when a resignation is tendered by a Government servant for some
compelling reasons, which did not involve any reflection on his integrity efficiency or
conduct and the request for withdrawal of the resignation has been made as a result of
material change in the circumstances which originally compelled him to tender his
resignation, such application can be accepted. It further provides that during the period
intervening between the date on which the resignation became effective and the date
Page No.# 10/12
from which the request for withdrawal was made the conduct of the person concerned if
in no way improper, such application would be permissible to be considered. It also
provides that period of absence from duty between the date on which the resignation
became effective and the date on which the person is allowed to resume duty as a result
of permission to withdraw the resignation is not more than ninety days. The guidelines
also mandate that the application for withdrawal of resignation would be permissible to be
so considered, provided the post vacated by the Government servant on acceptance of his
resignation or any other comparable post is available for the purpose of providing
resumption in service to such Government servant.
13.
Applying the said guidelines to the facts involved in the present case, this Court
finds that the petitioner had submitted his application being placed in a situation,
wherein, his presence in his home at his native place was mandated. The materials
brought on record does not reveal that the petitioner while discharging his duties had any
allegation levelled against him touching upon his integrity and/ or his conduct.
14.
Further, the efficiency of the petitioner is also not being demonstrated by the
respondents to be of a level which would mandate his invalidation from service. The
petitioner in the present matter is found to have submitted his application for withdrawal
of his resignation on the day when he was released from his services. The post held by
the petitioner is also not projected by the respondents to have been filled up by another
person.
15.
Accordingly, considering the guidelines now put in place vide the OM dated 10-06-
2019, this Court is of the considered view that it was permissible for the respondent
Page No.# 11/12
authorities to consider the application submitted by the petitioner for withdrawal of his
resignation and to permit him to resume his services in the Force. However, as noticed,
hereinabove, the application submitted by the petitioner was not rejected on the ground
that the petitioner had not satisfied the guidelines set out in Clause-2 of the OM dated
10-06-2019, but his application is found to have been rejected on conclusion drawn by
the respondent authorities that the petitioner given his personal problems would not be in
a position to continue with active duty in the Force, efficiently.
16.
This Court on a consideration of the ground assigned for rejection of the
application submitted by the petitioner, finds that the said grounds could not have been
raised by the respondent authorities for the purpose of rejecting the application submitted
by the petitioner, for withdrawal of his resignation, inasmuch as, the said ground would
have been permissible to be so raised only after a disciplinary proceeding, against the
petitioner was instituted and concluded, wherein, the said aspect of the matter, on
examination, stood established. In the said communication dated 30-06-2023, there is no
material disclosed, as regards the basis on which the said conclusion was drawn by the
competent authority for rejection of the application submitted by the petitioner for
withdrawal of his resignation and accordingly, this Court is of the considered view that the
same would not mandate an acceptance. The leaves taken by the petitioner, being
sanctioned by the respondent authorities, the same could not have been held against him
subsequently.
17.
In view of the above discussions and in the light of the guidelines set out in the
provisions of the OM dated 10-06-2019, the order dated 27-05-2023 and the
Page No.# 12/12
communication dated 30-06-2023, stand set aside. Accordingly, the respondent
authorities are directed to reinstate the petitioner, in his services.
18.
On reinstatement in his services, the petitioner shall not be entitled to any salaries,
w.e.f. 27-05-2023 till the date he resumes his services. The OM dated 10-06-2019 having
also stipulated that a member of the Force on being permitted resume on his services on
withdrawal of his resignation, the interruption of his service occasioning in the matter, in
the meanwhile, would also stand condoned, the period of absence of the petitioner from
27-05-2023, till the date of his resumption in service, in terms of the directions passed,
hereinabove, shall be regularized by the respondent authorities, notionally. It is further
provided that the petitioner, in the event, is found after his such resumption in service, to
be not discharging his duties, as required from a member of the Force, the present order
would not hinder, initiation of appropriate proceeding against the petitioner, in the matter.
The respondent authorities are directed to pass appropriate order(s) permitting the
petitioner to resume his services within a period of 01 (one) month from the date of
receipt of a certified copy of this order.
19.
With the above observations and directions, the present writ petition stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review