Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P(C).27890/18
2025:KER:31080
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MOHAMMED NIAS C.P.
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 27890 OF 2018
PETITIONER/S:
PRAKASH SANKAR
AGED 55 YEARS, S/O.SANKARAN NAIR, CHENNOTH RAYAMANGALAM
HOUSE, KEEZHILLAM PO, ERNAKULAM, KOCHI 683541
BY ADVS.
SETHUNATH V.
MANORANJAN (MUVATTUPUZHA) V.R.
RESPONDENT/S:
BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED,REPRESENTED BY ITS
PRINCIPAL GENERAL MANAGER, KOCHI, PIN 682016
ADDL.R2. DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
ERNAKULAM, COLLECTORATE, CIVIL STATION, KAKKANAD, KOCHI682 030
ADDL.R3. DEPUTY TAHSILDAR,
KANAYANNUR TALUK, TALUK OFFICE, KOCHI-682 011
ADDL.R2 & ADDL.R3 ARE IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED 6-219 IN I.A.NO.3/19.
BY ADVS.
SRI.MATHEWS K.PHILIP,SC, BSNL
SRI.SUDHISH R., SC, BSNL
GOVT. PLEADER SRI. DHEERAJ A.S.-ADDL.R2 AND R3
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
02.04.2025, THE COURT ON 10.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
W.P(C).27890/18
2025:KER:31080
“C.R.”
MOHAMMED NIAS C.P., J.
......................................................
W.P(C) No. 27890 of 2018
.............................................................
Dated this the 10th day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
The petitioner, a BSNL consumer, challenged the post-paid mobile
bills issued to him by approaching the Permanent Lok Adalat under Section
22 (c) (1) r/w 22 A (b) (ii) of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, by filing
O.P.No.40/2016, Ext.P1. He contended that he had travelled to Dubai on
30.11.2015 after activating international roaming on his postpaid number
9447703014 and obtaining a separate BSNL SIM for roaming.
2. The respondent-BSNL contended that the petitioner was under
Data Plan 501, which allowed 5 GB of free data on international roaming with
effect from 23.11.2015, and as his usage exceeded 500% of his credit limit, an
automated pre-barring message was triggered on 3.12.2015, leading to the
suspension of services. The detailed billing records showed that he used
Rs.20,209.84 on 30.11.2015, Rs. 55,613.05 on 1.12.2015, Rs. 24,494.88 on
2.12.2015, and Rs. 9,664.48 on 3.12.2015. BSNL clarified that smartphones and
W.P(C).27890/18
2025:KER:31080
high-end GPRS-capable devices continuously consume data due to
background applications, which are likely to lead to high charges. The
consumer has the option to keep these applications enabled/disabled while
on international roaming. International roaming usage is received after two
days, triggering a pre-barring message, with an interim bill issued on
31.01.2016 and the final invoice amounting to ₹1,27,462/-. All charges were
correctly billed as per the tariff, and the contention of the petitioner that he
has not used the BSNL connection while on roaming is baseless.
3. The Permanent Lok Adalat found, after examining the oral and
documentary evidence and that of the expert, that the petitioner could not
prove that the usage claimed by the BSNL was not correct. The detailed
breakdown of Call Data Records provided by the Sub Divisional Engineer of
BSNL showed continuous internet usage and calls made by the petitioner
during the relevant period justified the billing. Accordingly, finding that the
petitioner failed to prove any billing error or overcharge, passed an award
under Section 22C(8) of the Act dismissing the petition.
4. After the dismissal, the petitioner filed a review under Section
22D of the Act, contending that there is an error apparent on the face of the
record, as the forum wrongly held that the petitioner failed to prove the
case. It was urged that the deposition of RW1 reveals that BSNL did not
W.P(C).27890/18
2025:KER:31080
produce key documents, including the intimation document from the
international roaming operator. The petitioner states that BSNL, being the
sole custodian of billing and data usage records, had a fundamental duty to
produce those documents and explain the bill generation process.
Withholding such vital documents amounts to fraud on the court.
5. The Lok Adalat found that the Code of Civil Procedure does not
apply, and as per Section 22D of the Legal Services Authorities Act, it has no
power to reassess the evidence already discussed and concluded. The
Tribunal found that the review petition was an abuse of process and
dismissed it without issuing a notice to the respondent on 04.08.2018. Ext.P4
award rejecting the review is under challenge in this writ petition.
6. Heard both sides.
7. The issue involved in the case is whether any power to review is
conferred under Section 22D of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987.
Section 22D reads as follows:
“Section 22 D: Procedure of Permanent Lok Adalat: The
Permanent Lok Adalat shall, while conducting conciliation
proceedings or deciding a dispute on merit under this Act, be
guided by the principles of justice, and shall not be bound by the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and the Indian Evidence Act, 1892.”
W.P(C).27890/18
2025:KER:31080
8. The petitioner also relies on the judgment of the Punjab and
Haryana High Court in Estate Officer v. Charan Kaur and Others [2015 (4)
CivCC 225], which held that the review is maintainable as a more liberal
procedure than what is provided under the Code of Civil Procedure is
enacted under the Legal Services Authorities Act.
9. The Permanent Lok Adalat, established under the Act of 1987, is
not a court with plenary powers and cannot operate outside the Act or
exercise powers not expressly granted by law. The right to seek review is not
a natural or fundamental right, as such power must be explicitly conferred
by legislation. There is no inherent power of review unless provided by law,
and a clear distinction exists between rectification and review, with review
needing statutory authorisation. The Tribunal's power of recall does not
equate to rehearing for errors in judgment or a relitigation of merits but
allows for correction of procedural errors, such as failure to serve necessary
parties or instances of fraud. It is trite that a review on merits requires
specific statutory permission, while procedural review, addressing fairness
issues, is inherent in all adjudicatory bodies. A review on merits, which
involves re-examining the correctness of a decision, can only be exercised if
specifically permitted by law.
10. It is profitable to refer to the judgment of the Apex Court
W.P(C).27890/18
2025:KER:31080
in Kapra Mazdoor Ekta Union v. Birla Cotton Spinning & Weaving Mills
Ltd. & Anr [(2005) 13 SCC 777], relying on the judgment in Grindlays Bank
Ltd. v. Central Government Industrial Tribunal and others [AIR 1981 SC
606] which held as follows:
“19. Applying these principles it is apparent that where a Court or
quasi-judicial authority having jurisdiction to adjudicate on merit
proceeds to do so, its judgment or order can be reviewed on merit only
if the Court or the quasi-judicial authority is vested with power of
review by express provision or by necessary implication. The
procedural review belongs to a different category. In such a review,
the Court or quasi judicial authority having jurisdiction to adjudicate
proceeds to do so, but in doing so commits a procedural illegality
which goes to the root of the matter and invalidates the proceeding
itself, and consequently the order passed therein. Cases where a
decision is rendered by the Court or quasi-judicial authority without
notice to the opposite party or under a mistaken impression that the
notice had been served upon the opposite party, or where a matter is
taken up for hearing and decision on a date other than the date fixed
for its hearing, are some illustrative cases in which the power of
procedural review may be invoked. In such a case, the party seeking
review or recall of the order does not have to substantiate the ground
that the order passed suffers from an error apparent on the face of the
record or any other ground which may justify a review. He has to
establish that the procedure followed by the Court or the quasijudicial authority suffered from such illegality that it vitiated the
proceeding and invalidated the order made therein, inasmuch the
W.P(C).27890/18
2025:KER:31080
opposite party concerned was not heard for no fault of his, or that the
matter was heard and decided on a date other than the one fixed for
hearing of the matter which he could not attend for no fault of his. In
such cases, therefore, the matter has to be re heard in accordance
with law without going into the merit of the order passed. The order
passed is liable to be recalled and reviewed not because it is found to
be erroneous, but because it was passed in a proceeding which was
itself vitiated by an error of procedure or mistake which went to the
root of the matter and invalidated the entire proceeding. In Grindlays
Bank Ltd. vs. Central Government Industrial Tribunal and others
(supra), it was held that once it is established that the respondents
were prevented from appearing at the hearing due to sufficient cause,
it followed that the matter must be re-heard and decided again.
The recall of the Award of the Tribunal was sought not on the ground
that in passing the Award the Tribunal had committed any
procedural illegality or mistake of the nature which vitiated the
proceeding itself and consequently the Award, but on the ground that
some matters which ought to have been considered by the Tribunal
were not duly considered. Apparently the recall or review sought was
not a procedural review, but a review on merits. Such a review was
not permissible in the absence of a provision in the Act conferring the
power of review on the Tribunal either expressly or by necessary
implication.”
11.
In the instant case, as the grounds for seeking the review
suggest, a merit review, or rather a rehearing on merits, was sought, which is
impermissible for the reasons stated above. The view taken by the Punjab and
W.P(C).27890/18
2025:KER:31080
Haryana High Court in the decision referred to above is clearly against all the
relevant principles and cannot be treated as good law.
There is no merit whatsoever in the writ petition, and the same is
hereby dismissed.
Sd/- MOHAMMED NIAS C.P.
JUDGE
okb/
W.P(C).27890/18
2025:KER:31080
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 27890/2018
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF THE O.P NO.40/2016 ON THE FILE
OF THE PERMANENT LOK ADALATH.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE AWARD DATED 21.7.2018
PASSED BY THE PERMANENT LOK ADALATH
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF THE REVIEW PETITION FILED BY
THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE PERMANENT LOK
ADALATH 2016
EXHIBIT P4
THE TRUE COPY OF THE AWARD DATED 4.8.2018
PASSED BY THE PERMANENT LOK ADALATH IN I.A
NO.160/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review