Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 75 of 2018
Date of Decision: 09.04.2024
Shri. Prakash Momin,
son of (Late) Marcella Momin,
resident of Upper Chandmary,
Tura, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
:::: Petitioner.
Vs.
1.State of Meghalaya
Represented by the Chief Secretary
Government of Meghalaya,
2.The Deputy Commissioner/Collector,
East Garo Hills District,
Williamnagar, Meghalaya.
3. The Deputy Commissioner/Collector,
North Garo Hills District,
Resubelpara, Meghalaya.
4. The North-Eastern Frontier Railway,
Represented By its Secretary,
Head Quarter Maligaon, Guwahati,
Assam.
::::
Respondents.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. T. T. Diengdoh, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. C.C.T. Sangma, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K. Khan, AAG with
Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl. Sr. GA.
Ms. S. Shyam, GA. (R: 1 – 3)
Ms. L.M.D. Sangma, Adv. (R: 4)
i)
ii)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
By this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioner has raised his grievance against the inaction on the part of
the respondents, particularly the respondent No.2, to consider his
written application seeking reference of the matter pertaining to the
acquisition of his land under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) to the Reference Court.
1.
The brief fact of the case is that a portion of the petitioner’s
land situated at Mendipathar, East Garo Hills District (now North
Garo Hills District), was acquired by the Government for construction
of a new railway line from Dudhnoi to Mendipathar. The acquisition
proceeding was initiated by issuance of notification dated 24-11-2009
and public notice dated 30-11-2009 under Section 4 of the Act. In
view of the emergency of the project, the provision of Section 17 (4)
of the Act was invoked and the petitioner was paid the initial
compensation of 80 % on 30-08-2011 and the remaining 20 % on 1710-2012. The petitioner received the aforesaid compensation under
protest and subsequently by a written application made a request to
the respondent No.2 for referring the matter to the Reference Court as
the amount of compensation paid was not adequate. Since no action
was taken by the respondent No.2, the petitioner having no other
option approached this Court for a direction to the respondent to refer
the matter to the Reference Court for determination of adequate land
compensation.
2.
Against the claim made in the writ petition, the respondent No.2
and the respondent No.4 filed two separate affidavit-in-opposition.
The respondent No.2, the Collector, in his affidavit-in-opposition,
apart from refuting the claim of the writ petitioner for enhancement of
the amount of compensation, has taken a stand that the application of
the petitioner for reference of the matter was not considered as the
same was filed on 07-12-2012 beyond the statutory period of 6 (six)
weeks from the date of final award on 17-10-2012. Subsequently, by
an additional affidavit filed on 28-04-2023, the respondent No.2 stated
that the petitioner has received an amount of Rs. 17,70,820/- as land
compensation which is reflected in the Award Statement dated 14-112011.
3.
Mr. T. T. Diengdoh, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
petitioner submits that though the petitioner has received the final
amount of compensation on 17-10-2012, he was not made aware of
the date of the award and the contents thereof by the respondents. He
submits that the petitioner was not present or represented when the
award was made by the Collector and no notice was served on him
under Section 12 (2) of the Act. He further submits that even the
reason for non-consideration of the request of the petitioner for
reference of the matter was made known to him only after filing of the
affidavit-in-opposition by the respondent No.2. The learned Senior
counsel submits that as per the affidavit-in opposition of the
respondent No.2, the date of final award is 17-10-2012 whereas the
additional affidavit dated 28-04-2023 filed by the respondent No.2, in
clear contradiction of the affidavit-in-opposition, indicates that the
Award Statement was prepared on 14-11-2011. He contends that the
date of award cannot be determined solely by reference to the time
when the award is signed by the Collector or delivered by him in his
office, it must involve the consideration of the question as to when it
was known to the petitioner. The knowledge of the party affected by
the award being an essential requirement of fair play and natural
justice, the word ‘date of award’ used in the proviso to Section 18(2)
of the Act, must mean the date when the award is either
communicated to the petitioner or is known by him. He submits that
in absence of any such proof showing that the petitioner had the
knowledge of the date of award, the non-consideration of the
application of the petitioner for reference by the respondent No.2 on
the ground of delay is not tenable in the eye of law. He further
contends that the date of receipt of compensation has no bearing in
determination of date of award and hence, it is a fit case where a
direction be issued to the respondent No.2 to refer the matter to the
Reference
Court
for
determination
compensation to the petitioner.
of
amount
of
adequate
In support of his argument, the
learned Senior counsel places reliance on the decisions of the Apex
Court reported in (2012) 5 SCC 250, Premji Nathu Vs. State of
Gujarat & Anr. (paras 12 – 16), (2009) 16 SCC 1, Steel Authority of
India Limited Vs. Sutni Sangam & Others. (Paras 40 – 43) and (2018)
8 SCC 266, Vijay Mahadeorao Kubade Vs. State of Maharashtra
Through the Collector (paras 9 & 11).
4.
Mr. K. Khan, learned AAG, appearing for the State-
respondents, on the other hand submits that the petitioner was present
at the time of preparation of the award and has the full knowledge of
the final award. By referring to the provision of Section 12 (2) of the
Act, he submits that the question of issuing notice would arise only
when the petitioner is not present or is not represented at the time of
making the award. He submits that in the entire writ petition, the
petitioner has not made any averment that he was not present when the
award was made and that he did not receive any notice under Section
12(2) of the Act. The learned AAG refers to the paragraph-2 of the
reference application of the petitioner addressed to the respondent
No.2 and submits that there is a specific statement made by the
petitioner that an award of Rs. 17,70,820/- has been made and the
same has been accepted by the petitioner. He contends that the fact
that the petitioner has received the amount of compensation would
undoubtedly indicate that the petitioner had the knowledge of
preparation of the final award in the matter. He submits that the
contention raised by the petitioner is totally misconceived and the writ
petition being devoid of merit is liable to be dismissed.
5.
For proper adjudication of the rival contentions, it is necessary
to take into consideration some of the relevant factual aspects of the
matter.
6.
The petitioner in his writ petition stated that consequent to the
public notice dated 30-11-2009, notice dated 13-10-2010 under
Section 9 of the Act was issued to him and he has taken part in the
hearing conducted by the respondent No.2 on 09-11-2010, 02-12-2010
and 14-12-2010 and raised objection as to the rate of compensation.
Thereafter, on 17-12-2010 the petitioner received a letter informing
that a payment of 80 % as advance payment had been approved by the
Government. The petitioner received the said advance payment of
80% compensation on 30-08-2011 under protest.
The respondent
No.2 in his affidavit-in-opposition stated that the rate of compensation
was revised and a modified statement of assessment/calculation of
compensation on the basis of the objection of the petitioner was
prepared by raising the value of land as well as the rate for rubber
trees. The above uncontroverted facts would go to show that the
petitioner was present throughout the process till the stage of Section
11 of the Act.
7.
The writ petition does not make any disclosure as to the date on
which the petitioner submitted his application to the respondent No.2
seeking reference of the matter to the Reference Court though a copy
of the same has been annexed with the writ petition. The respondent
No.2 in his affidavit-in-opposition has also annexed a copy of such
application dated 27-11-2012 received by the concerned office on 0712-2012. A bare perusal reveals that the copy of the application
brought into record by the respondent No.2 is not identical to the copy
annexed with the writ petition. However, the petitioner has not raised
any dispute with regard to the copy of the written application brought
into record by the respondent No.2 though it is difficult to
comprehend how there exists two different copies of the same
application.
In his application for reference submitted to the
respondent No.2, the petitioner has categorically stated as under: “2. That an award of Rs. 17,70,820/- (Rupees
seventeen lakh seventy thousand eight hundred and
twenty) only has been made and the same has been
accepted, has been taken by me on behalf of my
mother Mrs. Marcella Ch. Momin under protest as
permitted under Section 31 of Land Acquisition
Act, 1894. Connected assessment papers are
enclosed as Annexures-A&B.
3.
That my under-protest acceptance of the
award is based on my objection to and
dissatisfaction with both measurement of the
acquired land as also the then standing rubber
trees, and the amount of compensation paid in
exchange. In anticipation of having to represent
my mother Mrs. Marcell Ch Momin before the
Honorable Reference Court due power of attorney
has been executed and the same enclosed as
Annexure-C.”
8.
In addition, the material on record reveals that a power of
attorney dated 26-11-2012 was executed by the mother of the
petitioner during her life time authorizing the petitioner to act on her
behalf, a copy whereof is annexed with the affidavit-in-opposition.
The clause 3 of the said power of attorney reads as under: “3. That the Government of India has awarded
me a total compensation amount of Rs. 17,70,820/(Rupees seventeen lakh seventy thousand eight
hundred and twenty) only for acquisition of my
said land;”
9.
The above noted contents of the written application and the
power of attorney make it amply clear that the petitioner all along had
the knowledge of the preparation of the final award in the matter
pertaining to the acquisition of his land. Section 18 of the Act lays
down that any person who has not accepted the award may, by written
application to the Collector, require that the matter be referred by the
Collector for the determination of the Court.
The law does not
contemplate that even before an award is made, a general or vague
objection can be made. The fact that the petitioner has filed a written
application seeking reference of the matter to the Court by itself
would establish that the petitioner was well-aware about the award.
Moreover, the petitioner in his written application nowhere stated that
he has no knowledge of the award and that he has not received any
notice under section 12 (2) of the Act.
10.
The proposition of laws laid down in the decisions relied upon
by the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner apply to a situation
where the person interested in the acquisition proceeding has no
knowledge of the preparation of the award and the contents of the
award. In the case of Premji Nathu (supra), at para 19, the Apex Court
reiterated the law laid down in Bhagwan Das v. State of U.P., (2010) 3
SCC 545 as under: “19.The Court in Bhagwan Das5, then held: (SCC p.554,
paras 30-31)
“30. When a person interested makes an application for
reference seeking the benefit of six months’ period from
the date of knowledge, the initial onus is on him to prove
that he (or his representative) was not present when the
award was made, that he did not receive any notice under
Section 12(2) of the Act, and that he did not have the
knowledge of the contents of the award during a period
of six months prior to the filing the application for
reference. This onus is discharged by asserting these
facts on oath. He is not expected to prove the negative.
Once the initial onus is discharged by the
claimant/person interested, it is for the Land Acquisition
Collector to establish that the person interested was
present either in person or through his representative
when the award was made, or that he had received a
notice under Section 12(2) of the Act, or that he had
knowledge of the contents of the award.
31. Actual or constructive knowledge of the contents of
the award can be established by the Collector by proving
that the person interested had received or drawn the
compensation amount for the acquired land, or had
attested the mahazar/panchnama/proceedings delivering
possession of the acquired land in pursuance of the
acquisition, or had filed a case challenging the award or
had acknowledged the making of the award in any
document or in statement on oath or evidence. The
person interested, not being in possession of the acquired
land and the name of the State or its transferee being
entered in the revenue municipal records coupled with
delay, can also lead to an inference of constructive
knowledge. In the absence of any such evidence by the
Collector, the claim of the person interested that he did
not have knowledge earlier will be accepted, unless there
are compelling circumstances not to do so.”
11.
The petitioner in his writ petition has not discharged his initial
onus by making an assertion that he was not personally present or was
not represented at the time when the award was made and that he has
no knowledge of the award. He has also not made any statement that
he did not receive any notice under Section 12(2) of the Act and that
he did not have a knowledge of the contents of the award during a
period of six months prior to the filing the application for reference.
Since the petitioner has not made any such assertion in his writ
petition, it cannot be inferred that the petitioner has no knowledge of
the award.
12.
The Apex Court in the case of Steel Authority of India Limited
(supra) at para 42 has held:“42. The law does not contemplate that even before an
award is made, a general or vague objection can be
entertained by the Collector. Objection to the award,
therefore, must be specific. When a reference is made,
the court shall ordinarily be bound by the terms of the
reference. The Reference Court does not have a plenary
jurisdiction. It does not have any original jurisdiction to
entertain an application directly from the Collector or
from the landholders.”
13.
It follows from the above that a valid objection can be raised
only after an award is made. A general or vague objection cannot be
entertained in law. In the matter in hand, the petitioner has not made
any specific statement as to whether he has raised his objection
without having a copy of the award or after obtaining a copy of the
award. If he has filed the objection without getting a copy of the
award, his application seeking reference cannot be entertained in law.
On the other hand, if he has filed the objection after getting a copy of
the award, then it is incumbent upon him to disclose as to when and
how he received a copy of the award. The aforesaid disclosure is
imperative in the event petitioner desires to avail the benefit of time
limit prescribed in Section 18 (2) (a) or Section 18(2) (b) of the Act.
In absence of any such disclosure, the petitioner cannot contend that
non-consideration of his reference application on the ground of delay
is not tenable in law.
14.
A careful scrutiny of the averments made in the writ petition
does not throw any light as to whether the petitioner filed his
application for reference after having a copy or without having a copy
of the award. However, there appears to be no dispute between the
parties with regard to the date on which the petitioner received the
final amount of compensation. As per the available documents on
record, the petitioner received the final payment on 17-10-2012 and
hence it can be construed that the petitioner had the knowledge, either
actual or constructive, of the contents of the award on that date.
Though, there appears to be some confusion with regard to the date of
the award in view of the contradictory stand of the respondent No.2,
the same is immaterial as there exists no dispute concerning the date
of receipt of final payment by the petitioner. The petitioner also does
deny that his reference application was received by the office on 0712-2012 which is beyond the period of six weeks from 17-10-2012.
Since the petitioner has failed to make out a case to attract application
of Section 18(2)(a) or Section 18(2)(b) of the Act, the nonconsideration of the application by the respondent No.2 on the ground
of delay cannot be termed as improper.
15.
Another noticeable fact is that the petitioner has preferred this
writ petition on 11-04-2018, almost after the lapse of five and half
years from the date of filing his application for reference. There is
nothing on record to show that the petitioner had ever tried to procure
a copy of the award made in the acquisition proceeding till the filing
of the writ petition. There is only one statement at paragraph 12 of the
writ petition which speaks of information given to the petitioner on
16-11-2012 under the Right to Information Act, 2005 with regard to
the quantum of compensation awarded to him. If the petitioner wanted
to avail the benefit of law prescribed under Section 18(2)(b) of the
Act, it was necessary on his part to apply and obtain a copy of the
award before filing the application for reference.
16.
For the reasons and discussions made above, there is no merit in
this writ petition and the same is dismissed.
17.
There will be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
09.04.2024
“Biswarup-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review