Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
NAFR
Digitally
VISHAKHA signed by
BEOHAR
VISHAKHA
BEOHAR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 9265 of 2023
1 - Surekha Chandravanshi W/o Narendra Chandravanshi Aged About
52 Years Presently Posted As Head Master, Govt. Primary School
Bano, Block Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh
--- Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, School Education
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal
Nagar, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - District Education Officer Kabirdham, District : Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
4 - Block Education Officer Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham),
Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9285 of 2023
1 - Smt. Indrani Sharma W/o Suresh Sharma, Aged About 48 Years
Presently Posted As Head Master, Govt. Primary School Joratal, Block
Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, School Education
Department, Mantralaya Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur Atal Nagar,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director, Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal
Nagar, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - District Education Officer, Kabirdham, District : Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
-
Block
Education
Officer,
Kawardha,
District
:
Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9282 of 2023
1 - Jagmohan Jangade S/o Bhuvneshwar Jangade Aged About 57
Years Presently Posted As Head Master, Govt. Primary School
Singhanpuri Kala, Block Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham),
Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, School Education
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal
Nagar, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - District Education Officer Kabirdham, District : Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
4 - Block Education Officer Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham),
Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 250 of 2024
1 - Smt. Maina Nirala W/o Uttam Nirala Aged About 48 Years Presently
Working As Head Master (Primary School) At Government Primary
School, Ghoksa, Block - Kawardha, District - Kabirdham, Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of
School Education Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Naya
Raipur, District - Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director, Directorate Of Public Instruction, Indravati Bhawan, Atal
Nagar, Naya Raipur, District - Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - Divisional Joint Director, Treasury Accounts And Pension, Durg,
District - Durg, Chhattisgarh.
4 - District Education Officer, Kabirdham, District - Kabirdham,
Chhattisgarh.
5 - Block Education Officer Kawardha, District - Kabirdham,
Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9267 of 2023
1 - Baba Ram Meravi S/o Hagaroo Ram Meravi Aged About 54 Years
Presently
Posted
As
Head
Master,
Govt.
Primary
School
Raghunathpur, Block Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham),
Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, School Education
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal
Nagar, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - District Education Officer Kabirdham, District : Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
4 - Block Education Officer Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham),
Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9291 of 2023
1 - Madho Das Gop S/o Jhadu Ram Gop, Aged About 46 Years
Presently Posted As Head Master, Govt. Primary School Charbhata,
Block Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, School Education
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director, Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Nava Raipur Atal
Nagar, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - District Education Officer, Kabirdham, District : Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
-
Block
Education
Officer,
Kawardha,
District
:
Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9298 of 2023
1 - Jagmohan Chandravanshi S/o Fekuram Chandravanshi Aged About
48 Years Presently Posted As Head Master, Govt. Primary School
Semo, Block Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, School Education
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal
Nagar, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - District Education Officer Kabirdham, District : Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
4 - Block Education Officer Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham),
Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9333 of 2023
1 - Santosh Jangde S/o Mangla Ram Jangde, Aged About 51 Years
Presently Posted As Head Master, Govt. Primary School Madanpur,
Block Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, School Education
Department, Mantralaya Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar,
District Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director, Public Instructions, Indrawati Bahwan, Nava Raipur, Atal
Naga, District Raipur Chhattisgarh.
3 - District Education Officer, Kabirdham, District : Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
-
Block
Education
Officer,
Kawardha,
District
:
Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9330 of 2023
1 - Vinod Kumar Banjare S/o Sundar Lal Banjare Aged About 47 Years
Presently Posted As Head Master, Govt. Primary School Kodawa,
Block Kawardha, District Kabirdham (C.G.).
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, School Education
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar,
District Raipur (C.G.).
2 - Director Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal
Nagar, District Raipur (C.G.).
3 - District Education Officer Kabirdham, District Kabirdham (C.G.).
4 - Block Education Officer Kawardha, District Kabirdham (C.G.).
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9301 of 2023
1 - Prahlad Vaishnav S/o Narayan Das Vaishnav Aged About 58 Years
Presently Posted As Head Master, Govt. Primary School Barduli, Block
Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, School Education
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal
Nagar, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - District Education Officer Kabirdham, District : Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
4 - Block Education Officer Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham),
Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9272 of 2023
1 - Prabhuram Chandravanshi S/o Basavan Chandravanshi Aged
About 58 Years Presently Posted As Head Master, Govt. Primary
School Dehri, Block Kawardha, District Kabirdham (C.G.).
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, School Education
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar,
District Raipur (C.G.).
2 - Director Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal
Nagar, District Raipur (C.G.).
3 - District Education Officer Kabirdham, District Kabirdham (C.G.).
4 - Block Education Officer Kawardha, District Kabirdham (C.G.).
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9332 of 2023
1 - Meena Devi Sahu W/o Sukhil Sahu, Aged About 55 Years Presently
Posted A Head Master, Govt. Primary School Rabeli, Block Kawardha,
District Kabirdham Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, School Education
Department, Mantralaya Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director, Public Instructions, Indrawati Bahwan, Nava Raipur, Atal
Naga, District Raipur Chhattisgarh.
3 - District Education Officer, Kabirdham, District : Kawardha
(Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh.
4 - Block Education Office, Kawardha, District : Kawardha (Kabirdham),
Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
(Cause-Title is taken from CIS System)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. C. Jayant K. Rao, Advocate and Mr.
Govind Prasad Dewangan, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)/State
: Mr. Yashwant Singh Thakur, Addl. A.G.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order on Board
10/02/2026
1. Since common question of facts and law is involved in these
cases, as such, all these petitions are being disposed of by this
common order.
2. The instant writ petition is directed against the order dated
22.11.2023 passed by respondent No.4, whereby the petitioners
have been directed to deposit an amount of Rs. 4,48,908/-,
alleged to have been paid to them on account of excess payment.
The impugned order of recovery has been passed pursuant to a
notice issued by respondent No.4 without affording any show
cause notice or opportunity of hearing to the petitioners prior to
passing the said order. The impugned notice/order does not
disclose under which head the alleged excess payment was
made to the petitioners. It merely states that for the period from
01.07.2018 to 30.09.2023, excess payment was made while
revising the salary of the petitioners. However, the calculation
sheet annexed to the notice reflects excess payment only from
October, 2020, thereby revealing an apparent inconsistency. The
petitioners were initially appointed as an Assistant Teacher in the
year 1998. Upon completion of 10 years of service, the benefit of
Kramonnat Vetanman was granted to the petitioners vide order
dated 02.10.2013, which increment was duly sanctioned and
recorded in the service book. Thus, the salary paid to the
petitioners was in accordance with the sanctioned pay fixation,
and no illegality can be attributed to the petitioners in receiving
the same. In such circumstances, the impugned notice-cum-order
of recovery, having been issued in violation of principles of natural
justice and without proper basis, deserves to be set aside. Hence,
the present writ petitions.
3. The petitioners have prayed for certain reliefs in the writ petitions.
Though there are some sort of differences in respect of prayer
made by the petitioners in all the petitions, however, in sum and
substance, the reliefs are altogether similar and identical. The
reliefs prayed in WPS No. 9265/2023 (Surekha Chandravanshi
vs. State of Chhattisgarh & others) are quoted hereinbelow in
order to consider these cases and to decide the same.
“10.1. That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to set-aside the impugned order dated
22.11.2023
(Annexure
P/1),
whereby
the
respondent No.4 directed the petitioner to
deposit amount of Rs. 4,48,908/-, which has
been paid to the petitioner on account of excess
payment.
10.2. That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to grant any other relief as it may
deems fit and appropriate.”
4. Brief facts of the case, are that, the petitioners were initially
appointed as an Assistant Teacher in the year 1998 and, upon
completion of ten years of service, were granted the benefit of
Kramonnat Vetanman vide order dated 02.10.2013. Thereafter,
respondent No. 4 directed the petitioners to deposit an amount of
Rs. 4,48,908/- on account of alleged excess payment and issued
an order of recovery without providing any show cause notice or
opportunity of hearing prior to passing the impugned order. The
impugned order does not disclose under which head the excess
payment was made, and while the notice reflects that excess
payment pertains to the period from 01.07.2018 to 30.09.2023,
the calculation sheet indicates the period commencing from
October 2020,
thereby
showing
clear
inconsistency. The
impugned order dated 22.11.2023 along with the calculation
sheet is filed. The increments in question were duly sanctioned
and approved in the service book, and therefore, there is no
illegality in the salary paid to the petitioners, as supported by the
relevant extract of the service book. The petitioners are a ClassIII employee, and as per the law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, recovery from Class-III and Class-IV employees
is impermissible, and moreover, the impugned order dated
22.11.2023, though styled as a notice, is in fact a final order
passed without affording any opportunity of hearing, and is
therefore liable to be set aside.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the impugned
order passed by the respondent authorities is illegal and bad in
law. The said order has been passed in gross violation of the
principles of natural justice, as no notice or opportunity of hearing
was ever afforded to the petitioners before passing the impugned
notice-cum-order dated 22.11.2023. The petitioners were legally
and validly granted the benefit of Kramonnati by the competent
authority, and no excess or erroneous payment was ever made to
the petitioners, nor was any misrepresentation or fraud
attributable to them. Despite this, the respondent authorities,
without substantiating any factual or legal basis, have arbitrarily
issued
the
impugned
notice-cum-order
of
recovery.
The
petitioners being Class-III employees, the proposed recovery is
impermissible in view of the law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, which categorically prohibits recovery from
Class-III and Class-IV employees when the alleged excess
payment is not on account of any fault of the employee. Learned
counsel for the petitioners submits that even though the
impugned order is a notice, it amounts to a final order of recovery
passed without granting any opportunity of hearing, and therefore
the impugned action deserves to be quashed and set aside.
6. Learned State counsel opposes the writ petitions and submits
that the impugned order of recovery has been passed in
accordance with law. It is contended that upon scrutiny of the
service records, it was found that excess payment had been
made to the petitioners, and therefore, the respondent authorities
were justified in issuing the notice and directing recovery of the
said amount. He further submits that the petitioners are not
entitled to retain any amount paid in excess of their lawful
entitlement and prays for dismissal of the writ petitions.
7. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
8. From a perusal of the record and the impugned recovery order
dated 22.11.2023, it appears that a recovery notice has been
issued to each of the petitioners directing recovery of alleged
excess payment for the period from 01.07.2018 to 30.09.2023.
The basis of the notice is an audit/verification conducted by the
Joint Director, Treasury, Accounts and Pension, Durg, wherein it
was opined that the pay scale of the petitioners had been wrongly
calculated and, as a consequence of erroneous pay fixation,
excess salary was paid to them which is sought to be recovered.
However, the excess pay calculation sheet annexed with the
recovery order itself reflects that the alleged excess payment
dates back much earlier. The record further shows that the
petitioners were granted a higher pay scale upon completion of
ten years of service vide order dated 02.10.2013 issued by the
Chief Executive Officers of the respective Janpad Panchayats.
On the basis of the said order, their pay scale was revised and
duly entered in their service books. At the relevant time, the
petitioners were employees of the Panchayat Department serving
as Shikshakarmi Grade-III, whose posts were subsequently
redesignated as Assistant Teacher (Panchayat). Pursuant to the
grant of Kramonnati Vetanman, their pay scale was fixed at Rs.
4500-120-7000 with effect from 01.11.2011.
9. Though learned State counsel submits that the petitioners were
not entitled to the aforesaid pay scale and that the benefit was
wrongly granted, a perusal of the orders dated 02.11.2011 and
02.10.2013 (Annexure P/2) reveals that the petitioners did not
make any misrepresentation or play any role in securing the
higher pay scale. The benefit flowed from a conscious
administrative decision taken by the competent authority and was
uniformly granted to similarly situated employees. Even if the
State subsequently withdrew the circular by another circular
dated 01.05.2013 with retrospective effect, the fact remains that
the petitioners had bona fide accepted the benefit granted to
them and continued to receive salary accordingly for more than a
decade. The State cannot shift the burden of its own
administrative lapse upon the petitioners by issuing recovery
orders after such a long period.
10.
The law on the subject is settled by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer), (2015)
4 SCC 334, and reaffirmed in Thomas Daniel v. State of Kerala,
(2022) 5 SCC 545, wherein it has been categorically held that
recovery of excess payment is impermissible when the employee
has not committed any misrepresentation or fraud and the excess
payment is the result of an error attributable to the employer. The
protection is particularly applicable to Class-III and Class-IV
employees and in cases where recovery is sought after a long
lapse of time. The present petitioners squarely fall within the
protective principles laid down by the Supreme Court. The higher
pay
scale
was
granted
by
departmental
orders,
no
misrepresentation is attributable to the petitioners, and the
recovery is sought after 12–13 years. Such recovery would be
harsh, inequitable and legally unsustainable.
11.
This Court is therefore of the considered opinion that the
impugned recovery orders are arbitrary, contrary to settled law,
and violative of principles of fairness in administrative action. The
petitioners have arranged their affairs on the basis of salary
legitimately paid to them for years, and compelling them to refund
a substantial amount at this stage would result in grave hardship
and injustice. Accordingly, the impugned recovery order dated
22.11.2023 passed against each of the petitioners is quashed and
set aside.
12.
Consequently, the writ petitions are allowed.
13.
However, if any amount has already been recovered from
the petitioners pursuant to the impugned orders, it is directed that
the same shall be refunded to them within a reasonable period.
sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Vishakha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review