Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 21
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 304 of 2023
Date of Decision: 20.09.2023
Pragati Engineers
Vs.
Union of India & Anr.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. P. Yobin, Adv.
Mr. N. Alam, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Oral:
1.
Yes/No
Yes/No
The brief facts of the case are that the respondent No. 1, had
floated a tender in the Government GeM Portal on 27.06.2023, for
procurement of Lightning Conductor System. The petitioner finding that
there were some discrepancies in the criteria, had preferred a
representation before the respondent No. 2 on 01.07.2023, but however,
as the same was not addressed, had then filed a writ petition being
WP(C) No. 216 of 2023. This Court vide order dated 20.07.2023,
allowed the petitioners the liberty to take further recourse in accordance
with law, with a direction that the respondents consider and dispose of
the representation of the petitioner by 24.07.2023. The petitioner then
filed another writ petition being WP(C) No. 234 of 2023, which was
disposed of by order dated 11.09.2023, inasmuch as, by that time the
technical and financial bids had already been opened. The instant writ
petition has now being filed praying for cancellation of the tender dated
26.07.2023.
2.
The petitioner has contended that, disqualification at the
technical bid stage on the ground that, an invalid authorization had been
submitted and that the test report which was furnished was neither in the
name of the OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) or in the name of
the bidder is motivated, inasmuch as, the Manual For Procurement of
Goods issued by the Ministry of Finance Department of Expenditure,
Government of India, at Clause – 7.3.5, permitted the purchaser to
furnish necessary clarification on the bid, which had not been accepted
to by the respondents. It has been further submitted that, in such
circumstances, the respondents should have been allowed to furnish the
said shortfall of documents by a certain date. It has been strongly argued
that, the tender bid documents had been made to favour certain bidders,
and that the disqualification of the petitioner’s bid was in violation of
the principles of fair competition and natural justice, in view of the fact
that, the petitioner had questioned the criteria and manner of conduct of
the tender process. As such, it has been prayed that, the tender process
being vitiated, the same should be cancelled.
3.
The respondents by their submissions and on affidavit, have
submitted that, all the laid down procedures were followed in the
technical evaluation process by the respondents and there has been no
deviation from the Manual For Procurement of Goods and other relevant
guidelines. It has further been submitted that, the petitioner submitted
false documents, such as the OEM Authorization and had also uploaded
a blank code of integrity pact in the initial submission of documents,
apart from the test report which was also not in order, as the same was
neither in the name of the OEM, nor in the name of the petitioner’s firm.
On these glaring discrepancies, it is submitted, the technical bid of the
petitioner was therefore rejected. Attention of this Court, has been
drawn to the relevant clauses in the tender document, as well as, other
supporting materials such as email communications and other letters, to
demonstrate the fact that, the petitioner inspite of being offered adequate
opportunity and the bid conditions, also modified on representations
made by them, was still an unqualified bidder.
4.
It has been further submitted that, the result of the technical
evaluation of the bid was uploaded on 01.09.2023, with the reasons of
disqualification clearly mentioned therein, and a time of 48 hours was
provided to the petitioner to represent against the disqualification. Even
after the completion of 48 hours’ time period, it is submitted, the
respondents again intimated the reasons for disqualification of the bid of
the petitioner, which however, the reply thereto by the petitioner, did not
clarify the issues raised by the respondents. With regard to clause –
7.3.5, of the Manual For Procurement of Goods, it is submitted that only
documents of historical nature, can be asked for submission at a later
stage, which otherwise were missing during the submission of the initial
bid, and it was on these lines that, the integrity pact of the petitioner was
subsequently accepted, but however, the OEM Authorization not being
a document of historical nature, could not be accepted. It is lastly
submitted, there has been no procedural violation or any illegality in the
bid evaluation process, but rather is a case of an unqualified bidder, who
submitted documents which were false, to somehow make themselves
eligible, which was detected and accordingly informed at the stage of
evaluation of the technical bid itself.
5.
I have heard learned counsels for the parties. As observed
earlier, this is the third round of litigation, which the petitioner has
resorted to in connection with the tender floated by the respondents on
27.06.2023, and uploaded on the GeM Portal for Procurement of
Lightning Conductor System. In the earlier occasion, the petitioner had
assailed the tender conditions and the respondents in pursuance to
representations that was permitted as per due procedure, had then issued
a corrigendum revising the specifications and conditions. The petitioner
however, was still aggrieved with the revised conditions such as the
testing certificate to be furnished, once again agitated the matter, but as
by that time, the technical bids have since been opened, then filed the
instant writ petition.
6.
In such tenders, as has been submitted by the respondents, the
Manual For Procurement of Goods guidelines, as also the GeM
conditions, in the NIT are to be adhered to in the scrutiny of the bid
documents. From the materials on record, it is noted that the
respondents examined the bid documents of all the bidders, as per the
stipulations and conditions. In this scrutiny, the petitioner firm along
with two other firms, were found to have not met the tender conditions,
and the result of the technical evaluation was uploaded on the GeM
Portal on 01.09.2023, with the reasons for disqualification mentioned
therein, and as per the said procedure of GeM, a window of 48 hours
was given to the prospective bidders to represent against their
disqualification. The petitioner therefore, was allowed the opportunity to
represent, which was availed of, but was found by the respondents to
lack credibility apart from the said documents not being historic in
nature.
7.
In the above context, reference is necessary to be made to Para
– 7.3.5, of the Manual For Procurement of Goods, which provides as
follows.
“7.3.5 Clarification of Bids/Shortfall Documents
During evaluation and comparison of bids, the purchaser
may, at his discretion, ask the bidder for clarifications on the
bid. The request for clarification shall be given in writing by
registered/speed post, asking the tenderer to respond by a
specified date, and also mentioning therein that, if the
tenderer does not comply or respond by the date, his tender
will be liable to be rejected. Depending on the outcome, such
tenders are to be ignored or considered further. No change in
prices or substance of the bid shall be sought, offered or
permitted. No post-bid clarification at the initiative of the
bidder
shall
be
entertained.
The
shortfall
information/documents should be sought only in case of
historical documents which pre-existed at the time of the
tender opening and which have not undergone change since
then. These should be called only on basis of the
recommendations of the TC. (Example: if the Permanent
Account Number, registration with sales tax/ VAT has been
asked to be submitted and the tenderer has not provided them,
these documents may be asked for with a target date as
above). So far as the submission of documents is concerned
with regard to qualification criteria, after submission of the
tender, only related shortfall documents should be asked for
and considered. For example, if the bidder has submitted a
supply order without its completion/performance certificate,
the certificate can be asked for and considered. However, no
new supply order should be asked for so as to qualify the
bidder.”
A perusal of the above noted paragraph, it can clearly be seen
that shortfall documents, that can be provided are only those which are
historical in nature, and which have not undergone change, such as PAN
Number or GST Registration, which have been clarified in Rule 11,
which describes the nature of shortfall documents.
“11. Clarification on Bids/Shortfall Documents: During the
preliminary examination, some minor informality and/or
irregularity and/or non-conformity/shortfall documents/nonsubmission of documents may be found in some bids. Some
minor issues could be missing pages/attachment or illegality
in a submitted document, non-submission of required
number of copies of a document. There has also been cases
where the bidder submitted the amendment Bank Guarantee
but omitted to submit the main portion of bid document. Such
“minor” issues may be waived provided the same does not
constitute any material deviation and financial impact.
Wherever necessary, observations on “minor” issues (as
mentioned above) may be convened by GeM Portal. During
evaluation and comparison of bids, AAI may, at its discretion,
ask the bidder for clarifications on the bid. The request for
clarification shall be given via GeM Portal asking the bidder
to respond by a specific date, and also mentioning therein
that if the bidder does not comply or respond by the date, his
bid will be liable to be rejected. No change in prices or
substance of the bid shall be sought, offered or permitted. No
post bid clarification at the initiative of the bidder shall be
entertained. The shortfall information/documents shall be
sought only in case of historical documents which pre-existed
at the time of bid opening and which have not undergone
change since then. These shall be called only on the basis of
the recommendations of the Competent Authority. (Example:
if the Permanent Account Number, registration with sales
GST has been asked to be submitted and the bidder has not
provided them, these documents may be asked for with a
target date as above). So far as the submission of documents
is concerned with regard to qualification criteria, after
submission of the bids, only related shortfall documents shall
be asked for and considered. For example, if the bidder has
submitted a supply order without its completion/performance
certificate, the certificate can be asked for and considered.
However no new supply order shall be asked for so as to
qualify the bidder.”
8.
Now coming to the points of disqualification of the petitioner,
the two grounds on which the petitioner was found unfit were as
follows.
Sl
Name of the Bidder
Deficiency/Shortfall
in
the
Technical Bid
(ii) M/s. Pragati Engineers.
(a) OEM Authorization: As per
the instant GeM bid Clause
No. 29 (1) reseller was
required to submit specific
OEM specific certificate
falling which the bid liable to
be rejected. M/S Pragati
Engineers had participated in
the bid as a reseller by taking
authorization from M/S JMV
LPS Ltd. Which the said
OEM denied in their email
dated 11 August 2023. Also
along with the email JMV
LPS Ltd. attached the copy of
their cancellation letter of
authorization which they had
forwarded to M/S Pragati
Engineers dated 01 Sept 2023.
(b) Test report from test lab: As
per
instant
GeM
bid
Condition No. 11 (chapter
one) of the corrigendum
uploaded on 18 July 2023, the
prospective
bidder
were
required to submit test report
of Lightning Terminal from
accredited international test
lab for 100KA of impulse
current as Indian test labs are
capable
of
conducting
impulse current testing upto
70KA only. M/S Pragati
Engineers participated as
reseller taking authorization
from M/S JMV LPS Ltd
(OEM Supplier) however the
test report submitted by M/S
Pragati
Engineers
was
neither on the name of their
OEM nor on the name of
their
own
firm.
A
confirmation email was sent
by the respondents to Dekra
Internation
Lab
to
authenticate the test reports
which was submitted by the
petitioner as part of bid
documents. However the said
lab has explicitly replied that
the test report submitted in
the bid documents are in the
same of Phoenix GmbH and
Co.KG which is neither the
OEM of the petitioner nor it
is the name of the petitioner.
Also the petitioner has made
no mention of the said test
report in the current writ
petition filed by him neither
did he replied on the issue in
his representation to the
disqualification uploaded by
the respondents which shows
that the petitioner wants to
hide crucial fact and mislead
the court in order to achieve
his nefarious designs.
9.
The materials that caused the respondents during scrutiny to
disqualify the petitioner on the technical bid, has been produced and
annexed in the Affidavit, wherein by email dated 11.08.2023, the OEM
supplier of the petitioner firm, had cancelled the authorization. In the
said email, the petitioner firm was clearly informed not to place the
authorization of the OEM supplier namely M/s JMV LPS Limited,
against the said bid. A further correspondence, addressed to the
petitioner firm on the same subject of cancellation of authorization, by
the OEM supplier dated 01.08.2023, has also been annexed to the
affidavit. As such, the finding that the petitioner firm did not possess
valid OEM authorization is correct and justified. On the other ground,
that is, with regard to the test report, the petitioner firm had submitted a
test report certificate, which had not been issued to it, but was one
issued in favour of a certain firm namely one Phoenix Contact GmbH &
Company, by one DEKRA Certification B.V. As such, on both these
counts, the petitioner firm was found to be deficient.
10.
The two conditions, as given in the bid document, that is,
Clause – 29, regarding OEM Authorization and revised bid condition,
given at Para – 11 of the Corrigendum, not having been met by the
petitioner firm, it cannot therefore, be held or even suggested that, the
tender conditions, or the process thereof, suffer from any infirmity. The
respondents who are the owners of the project, as in most cases, are at
liberty to prescribe tender conditions, that will meet the requirements of
the said project, and to that extent interference at the insistence of
prospective bidders, to modify the criteria beyond reasonable limits as
sought to be done by the petitioner firm, will surely warrant no
interference from this Court.
11.
In the fact and circumstances of the case thereof, and in view
of the discussions made herein above, there is no merit in the instant
writ petition, and the same according dismissed.
Judge
Meghalaya
20.09.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review