Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/9
GAHC010268952023
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6951/2023
PRAFULLA KALITA
S/O SRI CHENIRAM KALITA, R/O VILL-MOHIMABORI, P.O.-MOHIMABORI,
BLOCK-TITABOR, DIST-JORHAT, ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL
EDUCATION, GOVT. OF ASSAM, DISPUR, GHY-06
2:THE STATE LEVEL SCRUTINY COMMITTEE
REPRESENTED BY THE DIRECTOR OF ELEMENTARY EDUCATION
KAHILIPARA
GHY-19
KAMRUP (M)
ASSAM
3:THE DISTRICT SCRUTINY COMMITTEE
JORHAT DISTRICT
REPRESENTED BY DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
JORHAT DISTRICT
4:THE DISTRICT ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
JORHAT DISTRICT
ASSAM
5:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
TITABOR BLOCK
JORHAT DISTRICT
6:SURYA BORTHAKUR
HEAD MASTER OF SONARAM SARMA BALYA BIDYAPITH ME SCHOOL
Page No.# 2/9
R/O VILL-MOHIMABORI
BLOCK- TITABOR
DIST-JORHAT
ASSA
Advocate for the petitioner
; Mr. B.K Das
Advocate for the respondent(s) : Mr. P.N Sharma, SC
Ms. D.D Barman, R/No. 3
Mr. Deba Sarmah, R/No. 6
Date on which judgment is
: 02.02.2026
reserved.
Date of pronouncement of
: 23.02.2026
Judgment.
Whether the pronouncement
: NA
is of the operative part of the
judgment?
Whether the full judgment
: Yes
has been pronounced?
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH MAZUMDAR
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Date : 23-02-2026
Heard Mr. B.K Das, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also
heard Mr. P.N Sharma, learned Standing counsel, Department of School
Education, Ms. D.D Barman, learned counsel for the respondent No.3 and
Mr. Deba Sarmah, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No. 6.
2.
This petition has been filed by the petitioner being aggrieved by the
Page No.# 3/9
fact that his case for provincialisation has been rejected by the order dated
07.11.2023 by the Secretary to the Government of Assam, Department of
School Education. The petitioner and the respondent No. 6 are teachers in
Sonaram Sarma Balya Bidyapith School in Jorhat district. The petitioner was
appointed on 01.01.1995 whereas the respondent number 6 came to be
appointed on 06.05.2002. When the petitioner was superseded by respondent
No. 6 during consideration for provincialisation, the petitioner had approached
this Court by filing WP(C) No. 2203 of 2025.
2(a).
Pertinent to mention here that the respondent No. 6 came to be
provincialised by the order dated 5 th of February 2021 under the provisions of
the Assam Education (Provincialisation of Services of Teachers & Re-organization
of Educational Institutes) Act 2017.
3.
The case of the petitioner is that as per the data capture format report
signed by the respondent No. 6 himself, the petitioner was shown to have been
appointed in the year 01.01.1995 and the respondent No. 6 had been allowed to
join as the headmaster of the school on 06.05.2002. The case of the employees
of the school having been taken up for consideration for provincialisation, the
recommendation from the Director of Secondary Education was made in favour
of respondent No. 6 to be provincialised as a tutor. This recommendation was
given effect by the order dated 05.02.2021.
4.
WP(C) No. 2203/2021 filed by the petitioner herein was disposed of on
31.08.2022 requiring the petitioner to file an appeal as provided for under
section 14 of the Act of 2017. The petitioner having done so, the appeal was
considered by the department of school education holding that since the District
Scrutiny Committee, Jorhat did not recommend the name of the petitioner for
provincialisation of service, therefore the petitioner could not be recommended
Page No.# 4/9
for provincialisation under the Act of 2017. Accordingly, the claim of the
petitioner for provincialisation was rejected.
The provincialisation of the
respondent No. 6 as Tutor and the rejection of the case of the petitioner are the
bone of contention in this writ petition.
5.
It is the case of the petitioner herein that the petitioner being the senior
most language teacher and the respond number six, having being appointed as
headmaster and who was teaching English as a language teacher, the
consideration of the respondent No. 6 is not in accordance with law and
therefore the same needs interference of this Court.
6.
It is the case of the respondent No.6 that having been appointed in the
school, since at that point of time, the school did not have a qualified
headmaster. Therefore, since he was the first qualified person to be appointed
in the school, he had a better stake for consideration of provincialisation. The
respondent No.6 does not dispute the seniority position of the petitioner above
him on the basis of the date of joining in the school, but has relied upon the
minutes of the District Scrutiny Committee, Jorhat to emphasize that since the
DSC had resolved to forward the names of the serving Headmasters as social
science teachers, his name has been recommended and thereafter his services
were provinciallised.
7.
The undisputed facts in the present writ petition are that the petitioner
had joined the services of the school on 01.01.1995, whereas the respondent
No. 6 had joined the school on 06.05.2002. As recorded in the order dated
07.11.2023, which is impugned in the writ petition, the District Scrutiny
Committee had admittedly forwarded the name of the respondent No. 6 to the
higher authorities for consideration for provincialisation by considering the
respondent No.6 as an English Teacher. Two other teachers were considered as
Page No.# 5/9
Maths & Science and Hindi teacher respectively. There is also a observation to
the effect that the District Scrutiny Committee had decided to recommend the
Head Master as Social Science teachers. Thus, the name of the petitioner was
not recommended by the District Scrutiny Committee and therefore, by the
order under challenge, the claim of the petitioner came to be rejected.
8.
In Abu Khayer S.K. -Versus- The State Of Assam, in WP(C) No. 5702
of 2021 (Decided On : 09-05-2022), this Court had held thus:
“ 12. This Court further would like to deal as regards the entitlement of
the petitioner vis-a-vis the respondent No. 6. It is an admitted fact even
from materials which have been placed by the Respondent No. 6 that the
petitioner joined his service on 01.01.1986 and taught English Language
whereas the Respondent No. 6 joined on 01.04.2010 and taught
Assamese Language. In terms with Section 19 of the Right of Children to
Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, no school shall be
established, or recognized, under Section 18 unless it fulfils the norms
and standards specified in the Schedule. A perusal of the said Schedule
to the said Act of 2009 would show that for Class VI to Class VIII, there
should be at least one teacher per class so that there shall be at least 1
(one) teacher each for (i) Science and Mathematics, (ii) Social Studies
and (iii) Languages. From the definition of Section 2(za) which is Venture
M.E. School and Section 2(zc) which defines Venture Upper Primary
School, these schools impart education from Class VI to Class VIII and
would come within the ambit of 1(b) of the Schedule to the Act of 2009.
13. Section 3(1)(xi) of the Act of 2017, stipulates that in case of Venture
Upper Primary School there shall be minimum 3 (three) Teachers or
Tutors, at least 1 (one) teacher each for (a) Science and Mathematics,
(b) Social Studies and (c) Languages. The proviso to Section 3(1)(xi)
stipulates that for additional post, which shall be considered in
accordance with the norms and standards stipulated in the Schedule
under Sections 19 and 25 of the Act of 2009. At this stage, a further look
of Serial No. 1(b) of the Schedule to the Act of 2009, it would transpire
from Clause (3) of Serial No. 1(b) that when the number of children for
admission is above 100, there shall be a full time Head Teacher as well
as part time instructors for (A) Art Education; (B) Health and Physical
Education and (C) Work Education.
14. This Court is therefore posed with the question whether the Petitioner
who is otherwise a Senior Language Teacher can be denied the benefit
on the ground that the Petitioner is the Head Master of the School as
Page No.# 6/9
there is no requirement of a Head Teacher on account of the enrollment
being less than 100 in the School in question. This Court is of the opinion
that the Petitioner is first a Language Teacher and by virtue of
his seniority his services ought to have been provincialized. Being the
Head Master of the School, the same would not disentitle the petitioner
for his services from being provincialized. This opinion is based on a
perusal of the provisions of the Act of 2017 as there is no embargo in a
Head Master who is also a teacher and eligible to be provincialized.
15. Therefore, taking into consideration that the petitioner is the senior
Language Teacher, the action of not recommending the petitioner by the
District Scrutiny Committee which was approved by the State Level
Scrutiny Committee on the ground that the petitioner was Head Master
and as such not eligible for provincialization due to non-availability of
required enrollment is on the face of illegal and arbitrary. Consequently,
this Court therefore, interferes with the order of provincialization dated
05.02.2021 made in favour of the Respondent No. 6 thereby setting
aside the same and further directs the respondent authorities to consider
the case of the petitioner for provincialization as a Language Teacher in
Dakhin Bisandai M.E. School.”
9.
Thus this Court has held that a senior language teacher would have the
first opportunity to be considered for provincialisation.
10.
Again in the case of Md. Abul Hasen -Versus- The State of Assam in
WP(C) No. 4881, WP(C) No. 4564 of 2023 (Decided On : 01-08-2024), this
Court had held as follows;
“46. The date of joining of the petitioner as well as the respondent
no. 9 in WP(C)/4564/2023 in the school, as reckoned by the Director of
Elementary Education, Assam, for determining their inter-se seniority in
the order dated 26.06.2023 as well the dates so recorded in the
statement of service particulars submitted by the petitioner, herein as the
Headmaster of the school, is disputed by the petitioner to the extent that
his date of joining has to be so reckoned on 16.03.1993 and that of the
respondent no. 9, on 14.01.1993, respectively.
47. Ignoring the other contentions so raised, even reckoning the
date of joining of the petitioner and the respondent no. 9, as contended
by the petitioner i.e., 16.03.1993 and 14.01.1993 respectively, it has to
(be) so held that it is the respondent no. 9, who would be senior to the
petitioner, herein; and accordingly, it is the respondent no. 9 who would
be entitled to have his services provincialised in the said school against
Page No.# 7/9
the post of Language Teacher.”
11.
Thus, in view of the position settled by this Court, the senior most
language teacher would stake a first claim for being considered for
provincialisation. This Court has noted that the respondents has not filed any
affidavit in opposition and the District Scrutiny Committee has also not given
any reason for rejecting the case of the petitioner for recommendation for
provincialisation. Admittedly a resolution was adopted at the District Scrutiny
level to recommend Head Master as Social Science teacher, however, the
respondent No. 6 was admittedly as an English teacher and not a Social Science
teacher. The same is also reflected in the order dated 07.11.2023. The order
dated 07.11.2023 does not reflect that the appellate authority had considered
the projected seniority of the petitioner vis-à-vis the respondent No. 6 and the
only reason given for rejecting the appeal of the petitioner is stated that since it
was observed that the DSC Jorhat did not recommend the name of the
petitioner for provincialisation, hence the petitioner could not be recommended
for provincialisation. No reasons have been recorded as to why the DSC Jorhat
has not recommended the name of the petitioner. The order dated 07.11.2023
does not reflect any reason for rejecting the case of the petitioner by the DSC,
Jorhat. No reasons have been given why as to the respondent No.6 had been
given the benefit of provincialisation as a tutor when he was admittedly a junior
language teacher (English). The order dated 07.11.2023 does not discuss the
legality or otherwise of the suo moto decision of the DSC, Jorhat to recommend
all Headmasters as “Social Science teachers”. Such umbrella decisions, naturally,
would affect Social Science teacher who were senior to the Headmaster.
12.
Thus, in the opinion of this Court, the order dated 07.11.2023 is devoid
of any reason cogent to the issue raised by the petitioner and thus, deserves an
interference at the hands of this Court.
The order dated 07.11.2023 is
Page No.# 8/9
accordingly set aside and quashed.
13.
The respondent No.6 is admittedly junior in service to the petitioner and
therefore, in view of the law settled by this Court, the respondent No.6 could
not have been preferred over and above the petitioner during recommendations
being made by the DSC, Jorhat. It is also not the case of the respondent No.6
that he was a language teacher in the school. In the affidavit in opposition, the
respondent No. 6 has referred to himself as the Headmaster of the School as
well as the “Subject teacher” of the said school. The documents annexed to the
writ petition and also to the affidavit-in-opposition do not indicate the
respondent No.6 to be senior than the petitioner. In such circumstances, there
is no reason before this Court to justify the recommendation for provincialisation
in favor of the respondent No.6 to the exclusion and detriment of the petitioner.
Thus, this recommendation of the DSC, Jorhat being devoid of reasons, is
declared non-est in law and all consequential action of the said illegal order
including the order dated 05.02.2021, does not stand the scrutiny of law and is
accordingly set aside.
14.
The respondent No.6, in his attempt to resist the case put up by the
petitioner, had referred to the eligibility of another teacher, namely Jibon Jyoti
Kakoty, who is not a party to this litigation. No litigation initiated by said Jibon
Jyoti Kakoty is brought to the notice of this Court. The assertion of the
petitioner, that no other teacher except the respondent No.6 had been
provincialised, remained un-rebutted. The controversy is between the petitioner
and the respondent No.6.
15.
The District Scrutiny Committee shall now take up the case of the
petitioner for recommendation for provincialisation, and in case the petitioner is
found eligible in all other aspects, he shall be considered as senior language
Page No.# 9/9
teacher vis-à-vis the respondent No.6, in the event the respondent No.6 is also
considered for provincialisation as a language teacher. This order shall not
preempt the respondent No.6 for being considered for provincialisation as per
his eligibility and seniority in accordance with law. In the event, the petitioner is
found eligible for provincialisation, the consequential steps leading up to the
issuance of the appropriate order by the Director of Elementary Education,
Assam in accordance with the provisions of the relevant Act of 2017 shall be
completed within a period of 6(six) months from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this order. In case the petitioner is not found eligible, the
petitioner shall be informed about the same within a period of 3(three) months
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
16.
The respondent authorities shall take note that this Court has observed
that despite liberty and opportunity being granted by the order dated
28.01.2026, the records on the basis of which the order dated 07.11.2023 had
been passed were not produced before the Court. Rather, a communication
dated 20.03.2025 issued by the District Elementary Education Officer, Jorhat
with regard to the WP(C) No. 4152/2021 and WP(C) No. 6980/2022 had been
placed before the Court.
17.
This writ petition stands disposed of. No cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review