Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
APHC010537872011
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
FRIDAY, THE 25th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 685 OF 2011
Between:
1. POTHURU KALAVATHI AND ANOTHER, W/o. Pothuru Chinna Venkata
Naidu R/o. A.KondapuramPutlur Mandal, Ananthapur District
2.
Poturu
Chinna
Venkata
aidu,
S/o.
Kondaiah
Agril.,
R/o.
A.KondapuramPutlur Mandal, Ananthapur District
...Petitioners
AND
IVEL AND 3 OTHERS, S/o. Mr. Kumar Swamy Gounder No. 7,
1. K PALANIVEL
RCC Complex 206-261
261 S.G.Mutt Road., Chamaraj Peta, Bangalore Owner
of Lorry K.A.01-C-1012
2. The ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co Ltd, by its Manager Legal, Soma
Towers Ground Floor, Opp: Remedy Hospital Himayat Nagar, Hyderabad
3.
K
V
Lakshmi
Kumari,
W/o.
Subbaraju
7-7-11/4,
NarasaiahAgrharamBheemavaram, West Godavari District
4. National Insurance Co LTd, Rep. by its Manager, Anantapur District
(Insurer of Lorry No. AP 37 X 4429)
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
...Respondents
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Courtagainst the
order and decree of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal cum-VIth Additional
District Judge (Fast Track Court), Gooty, dated 20.12.2010 passed in O.P. No.
981 of 2008 for the following, among other grounds
Counsel for the Petitioners: Y BHAGYALAKSHMI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondents: SRAVAN KUMAR MANNAVA Counsel for
the Respondents:GUDI SRINIVASU Counsel for the Respondents:
The Court made the following order:
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 685 OF 2011
JUDGMENT
1. This appeal is preferred by the appellants/claimants, aggrieved by the
award dated 20.12.2010 passed in O.P.No.981 of 2008 on the file of the
Court of the VI Additional District Judge, Anantapur at Gooty, whereby
the Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs.3,80,000/- with interest at 7.5% per
annum from the date of petition till the date of deposit, holding the
owner of the lorry in which the deceased was travelling liable, while
exonerating the owner and insurer of the stationed lorry as well as the
insurer of the goods vehicle.
2. For the sake of convenience, the parties are hereinafter referred to as
they were arrayed before the Tribunal.
3. The averments of the petition in brief are that the petitioners are the
parents of the deceased. The deceased was aged about 22 years and
was stated to be studying MBA at the time of the accident. On
23.06.2008 at about 10.00 p.m., the deceased boarded lorry bearing
No.AP-37-X-4429 at A.Kondapuram to go to Tadipatri along with P.W.2
and others. When the said lorry reached near Yerraguntapalli Village,
Tadipatri Mandal, another lorry bearing No.KA-01-C-1012 was stationed
on the road. According to the petitioners, the driver of the stationed lorry
had not taken proper precautions or displayed any signal or indicator
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
while parking the vehicle on the road. The driver of the lorry in which the
deceased was travelling, while proceeding on the road, dashed against
the stationed lorry. As a result of the accident, the deceased sustained
grievous injuries and while undergoing treatment at Government
Hospital, Tadipatri, died. It is further pleaded that a case in Crime No.98
of 2008 was registered by the Tadipatri Taluk Police and after
investigation, charge sheet was filed against the driver of lorry bearing
No.AP-37-X-4429. The petitioners therefore claimed compensation of
Rs.4,00,000/-.
4. Before the tribunal, Respondent Nos.1 and 3 remained ex parte.
Respondent Nos.2 and 4 filed separate counters disputing the claim.
5. The 2nd respondent/insurer of the stationed lorry denied the manner of
accident and pleaded that the accident occurred due to the rash and
negligent driving of the driver of the lorry in which the deceased was
travelling. It was further pleaded that the deceased was an unauthorized
passenger in a goods vehicle and that there were violations of the policy
conditions.
6. The 4th respondent/insurer of the lorry in which the deceased was
travelling also disputed the claim and pleaded that the deceased was an
unauthorized passenger in the goods vehicle and that there was
violation of the policy conditions. It was further pleaded that the driver
had no valid driving licence and, therefore, the insurer was not liable to
pay the compensation.
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
7. On the basis of the aforesaid pleadings, the Tribunal framed the
following issues:
i.
Whether the accident occurred on 23-6-2008 due to rash and
negligent driving of the Lorry bearing No.KA-01-C-1012 by its
driver and caused the death of the deceased?
ii.
Whether the petitioners are entitled to compensation? If so, to what
amount and from which of the respondents?
iii.
To what relief?
8. During the course of trial, in support of their case, P.Ws.1 and 2 were
examined and Exs.A.1 to A.6 were marked. On behalf of the
respondents, R.Ws.1 to 3 were examined and Exs.B.1 to B.4 were
marked. Ex.A.1 is the FIR, Ex.A.2 is the inquest report, Ex.A.3 is the
post-mortem certificate, Ex.A.4 is the charge sheet, Ex.A.5 is the M.V.I.
report and Ex.A.6 is the rough sketch of the scene of offence. Ex.B.1 is
the insurance policy and Exs.B.2 to B.4 are the notices and related
documents.
9. Upon consideration of the oral and documentary evidence, the Tribunal
held that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of
the driver of the lorry bearing No.AP-37-X-4429, in which the deceased
was travelling, and that there was no negligence on the part of the
driver of the stationed lorry bearing No.KA-01-C-1012. The Tribunal
further held that the deceased was travelling as an unauthorized
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
passenger in a goods vehicle and consequently exonerated the insurer
of the said vehicle. The Tribunal awarded Rs.3,80,000/- under various
heads.Aggrieved thereby, the present appeal is filed.
10. Heard Smt.Sasikala, learned counsel for the appellants and Sri Gudi
Srinivasulu, learned counsel appearing for the ICICI General Lombard
General Insurance Company and Sri SRavan Kumar Mannava, learned
counsel for National Insurance Company Limited.
11. Having heard the submissions made on both sides and having perused
the material available on record, the following points would arise for
determination:
i.
Whether the finding of the Tribunal with regard to negligence and
liability requires interference?
ii.
Whether the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is just and
reasonable and, if not, to what extent the appellants are entitled to
enhancement?
iii.
To what relief?
POINT No.1:
12.
There is no dispute regarding the factum of the accident and the
death of the deceased in the accident that occurred on 23.06.2008.
The deceased was travelling in lorry bearing No.AP-37-X-4429 along
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
with P.W.2 and others. The said lorry dashed against lorry bearing
No.KA-01-C-1012, which was stationed on the road.
13.
The Tribunal mainly relied upon Ex.A.6-rough sketch and the
evidence of R.W.3, the Investigating Officer, to conclude that there
was sufficient space on the road for the lorry in which the deceased
was travelling to pass the stationed lorry and that the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of lorry
bearing No.AP-37-X-4429. The charge sheet was also filed against
the driver of the said lorry.
14.
However, P.W.2 is an injured eyewitness and was travelling along
with the deceased. His evidence assumes significance. According to
him, the stationed lorry was kept on the road without taking proper
precautions or displaying signal lights. The accident occurred at
about 10.00 p.m. on a highway. The material on record does not
disclose that the driver of the stationed lorry had taken any effective
precaution to indicate the presence of the vehicle on the road.
15.
Though the police investigation resulted in filing of the charge sheet
against the driver of lorry bearing No.AP-37-X-4429, the same by
itself cannot be treated as conclusive proof of negligence, particularly
when the Court has to determine negligence on the basis of the
evidence available before it. The fact that a heavy vehicle was
stationed on the highway at night without sufficient indication or
warning is also a relevant circumstance while determining the manner
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
in which the accident occurred. Therefore, on an overall consideration
of the evidence of P.W.2, Ex.A.6-rough sketch and the other material
available on record, this Court is of the view that the accident cannot
be attributed exclusively to the driver of either vehicle. The driver of
the moving lorry was required to exercise due care and caution while
proceeding on the highway, whereas the driver of the stationed lorry
was equally required to take reasonable precautions while keeping a
heavy vehicle on the road at night.In the circumstances of the case,
the negligence is required to be apportioned equally between the two
vehicles. Accordingly, the liability is fixed at 50% on the owner and
insurer of lorry bearing No.KA-01-C-1012 and 50% on the owner and
insurer of lorry bearing No.AP-37-X-4429.
16.
Coming to the liability of the 4threspondent/insurer of lorry bearing
No.AP-37-X-4429, admittedly, the deceased was travelling in a goods
vehicle as a passenger. The Tribunal found that such travelling was
contrary to the terms and conditions of the insurance policy. The said
finding regarding violation of the policy condition cannot be
completely ignored.However, the object of the Motor Vehicles Act is
to provide just compensation to the victims of motor accidents. Even
where there is a violation of the policy conditions, the insurer can be
directed to satisfy the award in the first instance and thereafter
recover the amount from the owner of the vehicle, in accordance with
law.
17.
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
In the light of the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in National Insurance Company Limited v. Swaran Singh,1, and
the subsequent decisions governing the principle of pay and recover,
the 4th respondent is directed to pay the compensation attributable to
lorry bearing No.AP-37-X-4429 in the first instance and thereafter
recover the same from the owner of the said vehicle.Accordingly,
Point No.1 is answered partly in favour of the appellants.
POINT No.2:
18. The deceased was admittedly unmarried and aged about 22 years at
the time of the accident. The petitioners are his parents. The Tribunal,
in the absence of documentary evidence regarding the educational
qualifications and future employment of the deceased, took his
income at Rs.3,000/- per month and awarded a consolidated sum of
Rs.3,60,000/- towards loss of earnings/loss to estate/love and
affection, besides Rs.10,000/- towards pain and suffering and
Rs.10,000/- towards hospital, transport, funeral and other expenses,
totalling Rs.3,80,000/-.The deceased was aged 22 years and was
stated to be pursuing MBA. Though no educational certificate was
filed before the Tribunal, the absence of documentary evidence
regarding his educational qualification does not, by itself, require his
earning capacity to be assessed at a very low figure. The accident
(2004) 3 SCC 297
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
occurred in the year 2008. Having regard to the age of the deceased,
the nature of the claim and the prevailing economic circumstances,
this Court considers it appropriate to take the notional income of the
deceased at Rs.5,000/- per month.
19. The deceased was aged below 40 years. Therefore, following the
principle laid down in National Insurance Company Limited v.
Pranay Sethi, 2 40% of the established income has to be added
towards future prospects. Thus, the monthly income comes to
Rs.7,000/- per month (Rs.5,000/- + 40%). The annual income would
be Rs.84,000/- per annum (Rs.7,000/- × 12).As the deceased was a
bachelor, 50% of the income has to be deducted towards his
personal and living expenses. Thus, the annual contribution to the
family works out to Rs.42,000/- per annum (Rs.84,000/- − 50%).
Applying the multiplier of 18 applicable to the age of 22 years, the
loss of dependency works out to Rs.7,56,000/- (Rs.42,000/- × 18).
20. The parents of the deceased are entitled to compensation towards
loss of filial consortium. In view of the principles laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v.
Nanu Ram,3, each parent is entitled to consortium. Accordingly, a
sum of Rs.40,000/- each is awarded towards parental consortium.
The amount under the conventional heads is liable to be enhanced by
(2017) 16 SCC 680
(2018) 18 SCC 130
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
10% every three years. Accordingly, the applicable amount towards
consortium is taken at Rs.48,400/- to each parent. Thus, the
petitioners are entitled to Rs.96,800/- towards parental consortium.
21. Similarly, the amount towards loss of estate and funeral expenses is
taken at Rs.18,150/- each.Thus, the compensation is reassessed as
follows:
Amount
awarded by
this Court
(Rs.)
3,60,000/-
96,800/-
10,000/-
18,150/-
Funeral expenses
10,000/-
18,150/-
Total
Rs.3,80,000/-
Rs.8,89,100/-
Head of
compensation
1.
3.
Loss of
dependency
Parental consortium
to two petitioners
Loss of estate
4.
2.
22.
Amount
awarded
by the
tribunal
(Rs.)
Sl.
No.
Thus,
the
appellants
are
entitled
to
a
7,56,000/-
total
compensation
of Rs.8,89,100/-. The Tribunal awarded Rs.3,80,000/-. Therefore, the
appellants are entitled to enhanced compensation of Rs.5,09,100/over and above the amount awarded by the Tribunal. The appellants
are entitled to interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum on the enhanced
compensation from the date of petition till the date of deposit.
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
23.
Coming to the apportionment of liability, as already held under Point
No.1, 50% of the compensation shall be borne by the owner and
insurer of lorry bearing No.KA-01-C-1012 and the remaining 50%
shall be borne by the owner and insurer of lorry bearing No.AP-37-X4429.Thus, respondent Nos.1 and 2 are jointly and severally liable to
pay 50% of Rs.8,89,100/-, i.e., Rs.4,44,550/-.Respondent Nos.3 and
are
jointly
and
severally liable
for
the
remaining
50%,
i.e., Rs.4,44,550/-. However, respondent No.4/insurer shall pay the
said amount in the first instance and thereafter recover the same from
respondent No.3/owner of the vehicle, in accordance with law.
24.
In the result, the M.A.C.M.A. is allowed, enhancing the compensation
from Rs.3,80,000/- to Rs.8,89,100/-, with interest at 7.5% per annum
from the date of petition till the date of deposit.The liability shall be
apportioned equally between the two vehicles. Respondent Nos.1
and 2 shall be jointly and severally liable to pay 50% of the
compensation, i.e., Rs.4,44,550/-. Respondent Nos.3 and 4 shall be
jointly and severally liable for the remaining 50%, i.e., Rs.4,44,550/-.
Respondent No.4/insurer shall pay the said amount in the first
instance
and
thereafter
recover
the
same
from
respondent
No.3/owner of the vehicle.The respondents shall deposit the
enhanced compensation, after giving due credit to the amount
already deposited, within a period of two months from the date of
receipt of a copy of this judgment.The appellants are entitled to
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
withdraw the amount in accordance with law.The other terms of the
award of the Tribunal shall remain unaltered.There shall be no order
as to costs.
Interim orders granted earlier if any, stand vacated.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
_________________________________________
Dr. JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
Date: 25.09.2026.
KKV
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO:685 OF
Dt.25.09.2026
KKV
Dr.VJP,J
M.A.C.M.A. No.685 of 2011
HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH:: AMARAVATI
MAIN CASE NO.: MACMA No.685 of 2011
PROCEEDING SHEET
Sl.
Date
ORDER
OFFICE
No.
NOTE
25.09.2026 Dr.VJP,J
The Appeal isallowed.
(Vide Separate Judgment)
_________
Dr.VJP, J
KKV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review