The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. ln Babu Bhai v. State of Gujarat2, the Honourable Apex Court held that: "The Court has to examine the facts and circumstances giving rise to both the FlRs and the test of sameness is to be applied to find out whether both the FlRs relate to the same incident in respect of the same occurrence, or are in regard to the incidents which are two or more parts of the same transaction and that tf the answer is affirmative, the second FIR is liable to be l quashed.'' \
11. ln the present case, a perusal of the record discloses that both the crimes are regtstered based on different set of allegations. While the case in Crime No.666 of 2025 is under investigation, the petitioners have resorted to another crime and ' lzoor; o scc ror ' (zoto) tz scc 254 \ t^ El t)..1 Cr ( . l5(rl9 ol l(ll i & hil.h beat the de facto complainant and his frienc tnd iscriminately - Thus, it cannot be termed as multiple F.l.Rs be i){l registered on the same set of allegations. When the test r, sameness is , applred, the same is answered in the negative. - fre investigation is still in progress. As a part of investigation, -e police could collect the injury certificate. lt is not just and prc F E,r to scutile the investrgation at this stage. The allegatrons point )L.lt the offences of serious nature. Therefore, the proceeding; n the present crimes cannot be quashed. The Criminal petitic;r I ack merit
12. Accordingly, both the Criminal petitions are lismissed lVliscellaneous Petitions pending, if any, sh a I stand closed Sd/- I SRINIVASA REDDY S //TRUE COPYII To, JE.r,o* oFFrcER 1 The XVll Additional Chief Judicial tVlagistrate at Nampa I 2 The Station House Officer, Police Station Jubilee Hills, - yderabad. 3 One CC to SRI lvl PRATAP S|NGH, Advocate [OpUC;] 4, One CC to SRI, JITHENDER RAO VEERATVALLA, AC, I;ate IoPUCI 5 One CC's to PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, High Court for rt t .jtataof t eljnqana ' t at Hyderabad [OUT]
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
13444 |
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY,THE EIGHTH DAY OF. JANUARY
TWO IHOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVI EADA
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 15039 OF 2025
And
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 15071 OF 2025
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 15039 OF 2025
Between:
1. Polavarapu Sridevi, D/o Late Rama Krishna Rao Aged about 56 Yrs, Occ
Business R/o H No 8 2 293lB2lAl321 A 24, Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad, T S
2 Smt. Varalaxmi Polavarapu, W/o Late Ramakrishna Rao Aged about 75 Yrs,
Occ Housewife Rio H.No 8-2-2931821A1321-A-24, Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad,
Ts
...PETlrtoNER/AccusED No.1 & 2
AND
1 The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Public Prosecutor, High Court of
Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana.
2 Ashish Kr:mar Ahuja, Wo Sunil Kumar Ahuja Aged about 30 Yrs, Occ
Business R/o H No 8-2 293l\2lHl26, Plot No 26, Shaikpet, HUDA Heights,
Banjara Hills' Hyderaba
..RES'.NDENT/..M'LA'NANT
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated
in the Memorandum of Grounds of Crrminal Petition, the High Court may be
pleased to quash the petitroner/accused No.'1 & 2 in Crime No.666 of 2025 on e
file of Jubilee Hills Police Statton, Hyderabadl.A. NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C praying that in the circumstances
stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition,the High Court may be
pleased to sTAY of all further proceedings including the arrest of the petitioners/
accused No.1 & 2 in Crrme No.666 of 2025 on the file of Jubilee Hills Police
Station , Hyderabad.
This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusinil the lVlemorandum of
Grounds of Criminal Petition and upon hearing the argum: rls of Sri lvl.pRATAp
SINGH, Advocate for the Petitioners and Sri Jithender Rao \ e:eramalla, Additional
Public Prosecutor on behalf of the Respondent No.1 and tl i Bala lVlohan Reddy
Advocate for the Respondent No.2.
CRIMINAL PETITION NO 15071 0F 2025
Between:
1. Polavarapl Sr devi, D/o Late Rama Krishna Rao A,l,: I about- 56 Yrs, OccBusiness R/o H. No.B-2-2931821N321-A,24, Jubilee Hrl s Hyderabad, T.S
2. Smt. Varalaxmr Polavarapu, W/o Late Rarnakrishna fl I r Aged about- 75 Yrs,
Occ- Housewrfe R/o H No.B-2-293t821A1321-A-24.
T.S-
J _t't rr:e l-lills, Hyderabad,
...PETITIONET /ACCUSED No.I & 2
AND
.1
. The State of Ielangana, Rep. by its Publrc prosecutor I ;h Court of
r
Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana.
2. Ashish Kumar Ahu.ja. Wo Sunrl Kumar Ahuja Aqed abr i t 30 Yrs, fcc-
Busrness R/o H N6.8 2-z93t8ztHtz6, ptot Nb 26: Shai{ ) :1, HLJDA lleights,
Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
.,.RESPONI] :NT/COMPLAINANT
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that
stated in the lVlemorandum of Grounds of Criminal petitrc,r
i
.
r the circumstances
lhe High Court may
be pleased to quash the petitioner/accused No.1 and 2 in Cr r rt-. No.686 ol 2025 on
the file of Jubilee Hills Police Station, Hyderabad.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that ir the circumstances
stateci in the Memorandum of Grounds of criminal petition tr ; Hiqh court may be
pleased to stay of all further proceedings rncluding the a-r. rt of the petitioners/
accused No.1 and 2 in Crime No.686 of 2025 on the file ,r Jubrlee Hills police
Station, Hyderabad.
This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing he Memorandum of
Grounds of criminal Petition and upon hearing the argume-:; of Sri rvl.pRATAp
slNGH, Advocate for the Petitioners and Sri Jithender Rao Vr eramalla, Additional
Public Prosecutor on behalf of the Respondent No. 1 and S - Ilala Mohan Reddy
Advocate for the Respondent No.2.
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
----a-,
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVI EADA
CRIMINAL PETITION N os.15039 AND 15071 0F 2025
DATE:08-01-2026
Between
Polavarapu Sridevr and another
Petitioners
And
The State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad
for the State of Telangana and another
Respondents
COMMON ORDER
Crl.P.No.15039 ot 2025 is filed by the petitioners-accused
Nos,l and 2 seeking to quash the proceedrngs against them in
Crime No 666 of 2025 of Jubitee Hills Potice Station, Hyderabad,
registered for the offences under Sections 329(4), 324(2) and
336(3) read with 3(5) BNS
2.
Crl P.No.1507 1 of 2025 is filed by the petitioners-accused
Nos.1 and 2 seeking to quash the proceedings against them in
Crime No.686 ot 2025 of Jubitee Hills Police Station, Hyderabad,
a
ETD.J
('rl ' i) 15039oi2t25&batch
registered for the offences under Sections 1 18(1 ,, 126(2), 351(2)
and 309(4) read with 3(5) of BNS.
3.
Heard Sri M. Pratap Singh, learned , ounsel for the
petitioners. Sri Jithender Rao Veeramalla, e i rned Additional
Public Prosecutor for respondent l'r ."|-State and
Sri T. Bala Mohan Reddy, learned counsel for res tondent No.2.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners sut nritted that the
matter is purely civil in nature. Responden No.2-de f acto
complainant alleges that the subject property be I r,.1g5 to hrm but
the petitioners are the bona fide purchasers. ,tf the subject
property. Therefore, the allegations made t 1 the de facto
complainant are utterly false. He further submitte I that, in case, if
the de facto complainant has any grievance, he r; rrr approach the
civil Court, but he filed the present complaints vrith an ulterior
motive. He, therefore, prayed to quash the pr: ;eedings in the
present crimes against the petitioners herein
5.
Learned counsel for respondent No.2 submitted that
petitioner No.'l is the vendor and petitioner I'1,,.2 stood as a
witness to the Sale Deed executed by petitioner. h o.1 in favour of
father of lhe de facto complainant. However, suk. r e,quenfly, a Gift
J
-rr,
I- I t).J
Crl.t'.No. I5019 of 2025 & batch
Deed is executed by petitioner No.1 in favour of petitioner No.2
herein in the year 2025. He, therefore, prayed to dismiss the
Criminal Petitions
Learned Additional Public Prosecutor submitted to pass
appropriate orders in the Criminal Petitions
7.
Perused the record
The Criminal Petitions are filed challenging two crimes
registered against the petrtioners herein. Crime No.666 of 2025,
dated 30.10.2025, is registered against the petitioners for the
offences under Sections 329(4), 324(2) and 336(3) read with 3(5)
BNS. ln the said crime, it is alleged that the father of de facto
complainant has purchased a house bearing H.No.B-22931821N3211tu24, situated at Road No 25, Jubilee Hills, vlde
registered Sale Deed bearing document No.2246 of 2009,
daled 20.07.2009, from one Mrs P. Sreedevi (petitioner No.1)
Subsequently, Mrs. P. Sreedevi has created a fraudulent Gift
Deed in favour of her mother i.e., P. Varalaxmi (petitioner No.2),
who is also a witness to the above Sale Deed executed in favour
of the father of the de facfo complainant, and tried to kespass and
damage the subject property. Thus, the de facto complainant
i
ETD..I
C l ' r'r.15 )l9ol l()15&balclr
filed a complaint before the Jubilee Hills polic: iStation and the
same was registered as Crime No.666 of 2025
nd investigated
Subsequently, another attempt was made by tir : petitioners that
on 09.112025 at about 16:00 hours, whrr
the det facto
complainant along with his friend visited the suo t c;t property, they
were threatened by one Sagar, Big TV repc .t:r. and in due
r
course, the petitioners along with their henr,l rnen wrongfully
confined the de faclo complainant and his f ir:nd inside the
subject property and threatened the de facto crr t clainant to give
up the claim over the subject property and wh()r
he tried to dial
100, they snatched away the phone. lt is lleged that the
;
accused confined the de f acto complainant arr,
his friend and
attacked them with rods, knives and other obji:,:, ; Thus, the de
faclo complainant filed another complaint anrl 'he same was
registered as Crime No.686 of 2025 of JuLi e e Hrlls Pohce
Station, for the offences under Sections 118('1 ) 126(2), 351(2)
and 309(4) read with 3(5) BNS. Thus, prima fac.i , allegations are
pointed out against the petitioners herein. The c : ntention of the
petitioners' counsel is that there are two crimes r lgistered based
on the same set of allegations and hence, cor tinuation of the
proceedings against the petitioners is not just anrl p,roper.
---5
LTD.J
Crl.P.No. 15019 of 2025 & balch
9. ln T.T. Antony v. State of Kerala and Othersl, the
Honourable Apex Court dealt with a case, wherein it was held
that
"ln respect of the same cognizable offence and same
occurrence two FlRs had been lodged and held that there
can be no second FIR and no fresh investigation on
receipt of every subsequent information in respect of the
same cognizable offence or same occurrence giving rtse
to one or more cognizable offences."
10. ln Babu Bhai v. State of Gujarat2, the Honourable Apex
Court held that:
"The Court has to examine the facts and
circumstances giving rise to both the FlRs and the test of
sameness is to be applied to find out whether both the
FlRs relate to the same incident in respect of the same
occurrence, or are in regard to the incidents which are
two or more parts of the same transaction and that tf the
answer is affirmative, the second FIR is liable to be
l
quashed.''
\
11. ln the present case, a perusal of the record discloses that
both the crimes are regtstered based on different set of
allegations. While the case in Crime No.666 of 2025 is under
investigation, the petitioners have resorted to another crime and
' lzoor; o scc ror
' (zoto) tz scc 254
\
t^
El t)..1
Cr
( . l5(rl9 ol l(ll
i & hil.h
beat the de facto complainant and his frienc tnd iscriminately
-
Thus, it cannot be termed as multiple F.l.Rs be i){l registered on
the same set of allegations. When the test r, sameness is
,
applred, the same is answered in the negative. - fre investigation
is still in progress. As a part of investigation, -e police could
collect the injury certificate. lt is not just and prc F E,r to scutile the
investrgation at this stage. The allegatrons point )L.lt the offences
of serious nature. Therefore, the proceeding; n the present
crimes cannot be quashed. The Criminal petitic;r I ack merit
12. Accordingly, both the Criminal petitions are lismissed
lVliscellaneous Petitions pending, if any, sh a I stand closed
Sd/- I SRINIVASA REDDY
ASJ TANT REGISTRAR
S
//TRUE COPYII
To,
JE.r,o* oFFrcER
1 The XVll Additional Chief Judicial tVlagistrate at Nampa I
2 The Station House Officer, Police Station Jubilee Hills, - yderabad.
3 One CC to SRI lvl PRATAP S|NGH, Advocate [OpUC;]
4, One CC to SRI, JITHENDER RAO VEERATVALLA,
AC, I;ate IoPUCI
5 One CC's to PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, High Court for rt t .jtataof
t eljnqana
'
t
at Hyderabad [OUT]
6. Two CD Copies
GE/DL
HIGH COURT
DATED:08/01/2026
(
i:r l?
A
,+
J
o
COMMON ORDER
t
CRLP.No.15039 of 2025
u
i
, Dr
And
:|:,y>)
DISMISSING THE CRIMINAL PETITIONS WITHOUT COSTS
\i,
q,
\11
ab
;1826
{
CRLP.No.15071 ot 2025
I
?
Z
o
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review