The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
30. Consequently, our conclusions are that: 1) The sale deed in favour of the claim petitioner/appellant is also after the date of attachment; 2) There is no agreement/contract of sale in favour of the appellant/claim petitioner executed and registered prior to the date of attachment. 3) So, the execution of the sale deed, after the date of attachment, in favour of the claim petitioner, is not pursuant to an agreement of sale in his favour executed and registered prior to the date of attachment. 4) The sale is by the judgment debtor No.2, through the Power of Attorney Holder (i.e. mortgagee, the Finance Company) in the capacity of Power of Attorney Holder; 5) The Power of Attorney(Ex.A7) is also after the date of the attachment; 6) The date of mortgage 30.07.2016, which is prior to attachment is not relevant in the present case, since the sale is not by the mortgagor as mortgagee. 7) Further, the sale deed dated 27.01.2020(Ex.A1)is not by the mortgagee in terms of Section 69 of the T.P.Act; 8) Section 64(1) C.P.C. is attracted. The sale deed (Ex.A1) is void. 9) Section 64(2) C.P.C is not attracted. 10) The impugned order is justified.
31. Consequently, in our view, the learned Principal District Judge has not committed any illegality in passing the impugned order.
32. The Appeal Suit lacks merit and is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. As a sequel, interlocutory applications pending if any, shall stand closed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
* THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
+ APPEAL SUIT NO.696/2025
% Dated: 19.01.2026
……Appellant
# Sri Podilapu Srinivasa Rao
And
Sri Gandreti Ugadi and two others
…….Respondents
! Counsel for the Appellants
: Sri Balu Anil Kumar Palla
^ Counsel for the Respondents
: --
< GIST :
> HEAD NOTE :
? Cases referred :
1. 2022 Livelaw (SC) 345
2. (2012) 1 SCC 656
3. (1977) 3 SCC 247
IN THE HIGH COUR
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
APPEAL SUIT NO.696 OF 2025
……Appellant
Podilapu Srinivasa Rao
And
…….Respondents
Sri Gandreti Ugadi and two others
DATE OF ORDER PRONOUNCED:
19.01.2026
1. Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
Yes/No
may be allowed to see the Judgments?
2. Whether the copies of judgment may be
Yes/No
Marked to Law Reporters/Journals.
3. Whether Their Lordship wishes
Yes/No
to see the fair copy of the Judgment?
____________________
RAVI NATH TILHARI, J
______________________________
MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM, J
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
APPEAL SUIT NO: 696/2025
JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Ravi Nath Tilhari)
Heard Sri Balu Anil Kumar Palla, learned counsel for the
appellant.
2.
The 1st respondent is the decree holder in O.S.No.289 of 2017
on the file of the Principal District Judge, Visakhapatnam. The
respondents 2 and 3 are the judgment debtors.
3.
The suit was decreed on 23.09.2019 and attained finality. The
decree was a money decree based on a promissory note dated
02.07.2016 executed by the respondents 2 and 3.
4.
The decree holder filed E.P.No.56 of 2020 for execution of the
decree. In the said E.P, the appellant filed E.A.No.328 of 2023 as
claim petition under Order XXI Rule 58 of the Code of Civil
Procedure(C.P.C).
5.
In the suit, the subject property was attached vide order dated
25.07.2017 passed by the learned Principal District Judge,
Visakhapatnam. The attachment was effected on 05.08.2017.
6.
The E.A. was filed claiming title to the E.P. schedule
property(the attached property) based on Exs.A1 and A7 as filed in
the Execution Petition.
7.
Ex.A7 is the Photostat copy of the agreement of sale with
General Power of Attorney(G.P.A) dated 11.09.2018. Ex.A7 is
between the judgment debtor No.1 (2nd respondent) and Sri
Gokulam Chits and Finance Company Private Limited(the ‘Finance
Company’).
8.
Ex.A1 is the certified copy of the sale deed dated 27.01.2020.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the Ex.A1 has been
wrongly mentioned in the impugned judgment as sale agreement
dated 27.01.2020. He submits that the appellant purchased the
attached property vide sale deed dated 27.01.2020 (Ex.A1) from the
Finance Company.
9.
The E.A.No.328 of 2023 has been dismissed by the learned
Principal District Judge, Visakhapatnam vide judgment and decree
dated 29.10.2025.
10.
The learned Principal District Judge has taken the view that
the sale deed is after the date of the attachment. The agreement of
sale-cum-G.P.A dated 11.09.2018(Ex.A7) did not relate to the claim
petitioner. He is the third party. Besides, Ex.A7 is after the date of
attachment. The rejection of the E.A is on the ground of Section
64(1) of C.P.C that, where an attachment has been made, any
private transfer or delivery of the property attached or of any interest
therein and any payment to the judgment debtor of any debt,
dividend or other monies contrary to such attachment, shall be void
as against all claims enforceable under the attachment.
11.
Challenging the judgment and decree dated 29.10.2025, the
appeal has been filed by the claim petitioner/appellant.
12.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the property
under attachment was initially mortgaged on 30.07.2016 with the
Finance Company by the judgment debtor No.1(2nd respondent).
The date of the mortgage is prior to the date of the attachment. The
sale deed in favour of the claim petitioner was executed in
pursuance
of
the
pre-attachment
mortgage
contract,
dated
30.07.2016. So in view of Section 64(2) C.P.C, the sale deed would
not be void but is saved. The rejection of the appellant’s E.A
therefore, is not justified.
13.
We have considered the aforesaid submissions of the learned
counsel for the appellant and perused the material on record.
14.
Section 64
C.P.C deserves reproduction, which reads as
under:
“1)Where an attachment has been made, any private
transfer or delivery of the property attached or of any
interest therein and any payment to the judgment debtor
of any debt, dividend or other monies contrary to such
attachment, shall be void as against all claims
enforceable under the attachment.
2) Nothing in this section shall apply to any private
transfer or delivery of the property attached or of any
interest therein, made in pursuance of any contract for
such transfer or delivery entered into and registered
before the attachment.”
15.
Sub-section(2) of Section 64 C.P.C provides that nothing in
Section 64(1) shall apply to any private transfer or delivery of the
property attached or of any interest therein, made in pursuance of
any contract for such transfer or delivery entered into and registered
before the attachment.
16.
A perusal of Section 64 C.P.C makes it evident that to attract
sub-section (2) of Section 64 C.P.C, the private transfer or delivery
of the attached property or of any interest thereon must have been
made pursuant to any contract of transfer entered into and
registered before the attachment.
17.
There is no dispute on the dates i.e. the date of attachment
(25.07.2017), date of sale deed(27.01.2020) and the alleged
agreement of sale-cum-G.P.A(11.09.2018). The date of mortgage
deed is 30.07.2016.
18.
The agreement of sale-cum-G.P.A is dated 11.09.2018
(Ex.A7). The sale deed is dated 27.01.2020. Ex.A7 is clearly after
the date of attachment in the suit made on 25.07.2017. It cannot
also be said that the transfer vide sale deed dated 27.01.2020 is
made pursuant to any contract for such transfer entered into and
registered before the attachment as any such contract for sale in
favour of the claim petitioner/appellant has neither been pleaded nor
brought on record.
19.
In Dokala Hari Babu v. Kotra Appe1, the Hon’ble Apex Court
held that to get the benefit of sub-section(2) of Section 64 of the
CPC, the objector and/or subsequent purchaser has to plead and
prove that he is the bona fide purchaser, who has entered into the
transaction prior to the order of attachment.
2022 Livelaw (SC) 345
20.
In the present case, the claim petitioner has not entered into
the transaction prior to the order of attachment. The sale deed is
after the date of attachment and there is no agreement of sale in
favour of the claim petitioner of a date prior to the order of
attachment, pursuant to which it can be said that the sale deed was
executed.
21.
In Om Prakash Garg v. Ganga Sahai and others 2, the
property was mortgaged and was sold in execution and was
purchased on September 4, 1963. The sale was confirmed in favour
of the decree holder on May 24, 1965.
respondent/decree holder brought
Afterwards, the
a suit for redemption and
obtained a decree on October 14, 1967.
The appeal of the
mortgagee, Narain Prasad was dismissed on January 22, 1971.
The appellant therein, Om Prakash Garg claimed to be the
mortgagee’s tenant. It was his case that the property was leased in
his favour by the mortgagee sometime in March/April 1965 during
the subsistence of the attachment. The Hon’ble Apex Court held
that the alleged lease was, affected by Section 64 C.P.C. and that
being so, the said appellant could not claim the status of a tenant
against the respondent/mortgagor.
(1987) 2 SCC 553
22.
Learned counsel for the appellant emphasized on the
mortgage deed dated 30.07.2016, to contend that this date is prior
to the attachment. Therefore, the sale deed pursuant to such
mortgage is saved under sub-section (2) of Section 64 of the Act.
23.
The aforesaid contention with respect to the mortgage being
of a date prior to attachment is of no relevance in the present case.
The mortgage is by the judgment debtor No.1 in favour of the
Finance Company(mortgagee). The contention being raised is, as if
the transfer/sale deed has been made by the mortgagee in favour of
the claim petitioner/appellant. But, the fact is that the mortgagee has
not transferred the property to the claim petitioner, vide the sale
deed dated 27.01.2020 (Ex.A1). The mortgagee the Finance
Company has executed the sale deed as a Power of Attorney holder
of the mortgagor (vendor/the judgment debtor No.1). It is so evident
from perusal of Exs.A1 and A7, the G.P.A-cum-agreement of sale
dated 11.09.2018. Ex.A7 is of a date after the attachment and not
before the attachment. It is well settled legal position that G.P.Acum-agreement of sale, does not confer any title to the property with
respect to which it relates. In Suraj Lamp and Industries Private
Limited v. State of Haryana and another3, the Hon’ble Apex Court
(2012) 1 SCC 656
has held that a power of attorney is not an instrument of transfer in
regard to any right, title or interest in an immovable property. The
power of attorney is creation of an agency whereby the grantor
authorises the grantee to do the acts specified therein, on behalf of
grantor, which when executed will be binding on the grantor as if
done by him. So, even based on Ex.A7, in favour of the Finance
Company it could not make the sale as ‘vendor’ but sale could be
made as GPA holder of the vendor/judgment debtor No.1. The sale
deed, Ex.A7 also mentions the same. So, the sale deed, Ex.A7 in
favour of the claim petitioner is by the judgment debtor No.1,
through G.P.A. holder, and there is no agreement/contract of sale,
executed and registered prior to the date of attachment pursuant to
which Ex.A7 has been executed in favour of the claim petitioner.
24.
We shall also consider the legal position regarding transfer
made by a mortgagee, as the contention is that the transfer is by the
mortgagee (Finance Company), though as discussed above we are
satisfied that the transfer (sale deed) is not by the Finance Company
as
mortgagee
but
as
Power
of
Attorney
Holder
of
the
vendor/judgment debtor No.1.
25.
The mortgagee’s power of sell, is dealt with by Section 69 of
the Transfer of Property Act(in short ‘the T.P.Act’). It reads as under:
69. Power of sale when valid.—(1) A mortgagee, or any person
acting on his behalf, shall, subject to the provisions of this section
have power to sell or concur in selling the mortgaged property or
any part thereof, in default of payment of the mortgage-money,
without the intervention of the court, in the following cases and in
no others, namely:—
(a) where the mortgage is an English mortgage, and neither the
mortgagor nor the mortgagee is a Hindu, Muhammadan or
Buddhist or a member of any other race, sect, tribe or class from
time to time specified in this behalf by the State Government, in
the Official Gazette;
(b) where a power of sale without the intervention of the court is
expressly conferred on the mortgagee by the mortgage-deed and
the mortgagee is the Government;
(c) where a power of sale without the intervention of the court is
expressly conferred on the mortgagee by the mortgage-deed and
the mortgaged property or any part thereof was, on the date of
the execution of the mortgage-deed, situate within the towns of
Calcutta, Madras, Bombay, or in any other town11 or area which
the State Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette,
specify in this behalf.
(2) No such power shall be exercised unless and until—
(a) notice in writing requiring payment of the principal money has
been served on the mortgagor, or on one of several mortgagors,
and default has been made in payment of the principal money, or
of part thereof, for three months after such service; or
(b) some interest under the mortgage amounting at least to five
hundred rupees is in arrear and unpaid for three months after
becoming due.
(3) When a sale has been made in professed exercise of such a
power, the title of the purchaser shall not be impeachable on the
ground that no case had arisen to authorise the sale, or that due
notice was not given, or that the power was otherwise improperly
or irregularly exercised; but any person damnified by an
unauthorised or improper or irregular exercise or the power shall
have his remedy in damages against the person exercising the
power.
(4) The money which is received by the mortgagee, arising from
the sale, after discharge of prior encumbrances, if any, to which
the sale is not made subject, or after payment into Court under
section 57 of a sum to meet any prior encumbrance, shall, in the
absence of a contract to the contrary, be held by him in trust to be
applied by him, first, in payment of all costs, charges and
expenses properly incurred by him as incident to the sale or any
attempted sale; and, secondly, in discharge of the mortgage-
money and costs and other money, if any, due under the
mortgage; and the residue of the money so received shall be paid
to the person entitled to the mortgaged property, or authorised to
give receipts for the proceeds of the sale thereof.
(5) Nothing in this section or in section 69A applies to powers
conferred before the first day of July, 1882.”
26.
Under Section 69(1) of the T.P.Act, a mortgagee, or any
person acting on his behalf , shall, have the power to sell or concur
in selling the mortgaged property or any part thereof, in default of
payment of the mortgage-money, without the intervention of the
Court, only in the case given in clauses (a) to (c) of Section 69(1),
and in no other case. As per clause (c), a mortgagee has power of
sale where that power has been conferred by the mortgage deed.
27.
In Narandas Karsondas v. S.A.Kamtam and another4, the
Hon’ble Apex Court held that Section 69 of the Transfer of Property
Act deals with mortgagees' power of sale. Under the said Section
69(1)(c), a mortgagee has power of sale without the intervention of
the Court where power is conferred by the mortgage deed and the
mortgaged property or any part thereof was on the date of the
execution of the mortgage deed, situate within the towns of Calcutta,
Madras, Bombay or in any other town or area which the State
Government, may, by notification in the Official Gazette, specify.
(1977) 3 SCC 247
28.
In the present case, firstly, the sale is not by the mortgagee;
the sale is by the judgment debtor through mortgagee, as the power
of attorney holder.
The transfer is by the vendor, the judgment
debtor and not by the mortgagee and secondly, it could not be
shown to us that there was a power of sale conferred on the
mortgagee in the mortgage deed dated 30.07.2016. Further, subsection (2) of Section 69 of the T.P.Act provides that no such power
of sale shall be exercised by the mortgagee unless and until,
inter alia, notice in writing requiring payment of the principal money
has been served on the mortgagor, or on one of several mortgagors,
and default has been made in payment of the principal money, or of
part thereof, for three months after such service. It is not the case
argued before us by the learned counsel for the appellant that the
requirement of any notice in terms of Section 69(2)(9) was complied
with.
29.
So, the sale deed, Ex.A7 is neither by the mortgagee nor it
could be shown that, even if the argument be taken as accepted for
the time being, it cannot be a sale deed in pursuance of a mortgage
deed executed prior to the date of attachment.
30.
Consequently, our conclusions are that:
1) The sale deed in favour of the claim petitioner/appellant
is also after the date of attachment;
2) There is no agreement/contract of sale in favour of the
appellant/claim petitioner executed and registered prior to
the date of attachment.
3) So, the execution of the sale deed, after the date of
attachment, in favour of the claim petitioner, is not
pursuant to an agreement of sale in his favour executed
and registered prior to the date of attachment.
4) The sale is by the judgment debtor No.2, through the
Power of Attorney Holder (i.e. mortgagee, the Finance
Company) in the capacity of Power of Attorney Holder;
5) The Power of Attorney(Ex.A7) is also after the date of
the attachment;
6) The date of mortgage 30.07.2016, which is prior to
attachment is not relevant in the present case, since the
sale is not by the mortgagor as mortgagee.
7) Further, the sale deed dated 27.01.2020(Ex.A1)is not
by the mortgagee in terms of Section 69 of the T.P.Act;
8) Section 64(1) C.P.C. is attracted.
The sale deed
(Ex.A1) is void.
9) Section 64(2) C.P.C is not attracted.
10) The impugned order is justified.
31.
Consequently, in our view, the learned Principal District Judge
has not committed any illegality in passing the impugned order.
32.
The Appeal Suit lacks merit and is dismissed. There shall be
no order as to costs.
As a sequel, interlocutory applications pending if any, shall
stand closed.
_____________________
RAVI NATH TILHARI, J
______________________________
MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM, J
Date: 19.01.2026
Note:
L.R.copy to be marked.
B/o.
Pab
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
APPEAL SUIT NO: 696/2025
DATE: 19.01.2026
Pab
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review