Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC010204322019
2026:GAU-AS:5237
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7006/2019
PIYARUN NESSA
D/O- LT ABDUL NOOR, W/O- LT ABDUL SUKUR, R/O- VILL- MARJONG
PATHAR, P.S. MURAJHAR, DIST- HOJAI, ASSAM
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 6 ORS.
REP. BY THE SECY. MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, GOVT. OF INDIA, NEW
DELHI-1
2:THE STATE OF ASSAM
REP. BY THE COMM. AND SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
HOME DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY-6
ASSAM
3:THE ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
NEW DELHI
INDIA
4:THE FOREIGNERS TRIBUNAL
NAGAON
LANKA
HOJAI
ASSAM
5:THE STATE COORDINATOR
NRC
ASSAM
BHANGAGARH
Page No.# 2/8
GHY-5
6:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (B)
HOJAI
ASSAM
7:THE ELECTION OFFICER
HOJAI
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. S BORA, MS J RAJKUMARI
Advocate for the Respondent : ASSTT.S.G.I., SC, NRC,SC, ELECTION COMMISSION.,SC, F.T
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHAMIMA JAHAN
ORDER
Date : 06.04.2026
(K.R. Surana, J)
Heard Mr. S. Bora, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. H.
Gupta, learned CGC; Mr. N. Kalita, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Mr.
A.I. Ali, learned standing counsel for the ECI; Mr. J. Payeng, learned standing
counsel for the FT matters and NRC; and Ms. R.B. Bora, learned Govt.
Advocate for respondent.
2.
By filing this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the petitioner has assailed the impugned opinion dated 24.05.2019,
passed by the learned Member, Foreigners’ Tribunal, Nagaon No. 7 th at Lanka,
Hojai, in F.T./L/Case No. 1448/2017, arising out of SP’s Case No. 104/17, by
which the petitioner was declared as an illegal migrant of post 25.03.1971
stream.
Page No.# 3/8
3.
Having examined the Tribunal’s records, the Court is of the
considered opinion that this is a fit case for remand of the matter at the stage
of either cross-examination of the DW’s and/ or for the witnesses to answer
the query of the Court under Section 165 of the Evidence Act, 1872
corresponding to Section 168 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.
4.
On a perusal of the Tribunals records, it is noticed that the petitioner
had examined herself as DW-1 by filing an evidence-on-affidavit on
04.01.2019. The said order dated 04.01.2019, reads as follows:“4.1.19: The proceedee appears today along with her counsel filed the evidence-inchief with some documents in support and is accordingly cross-examined. Evidence
resumed. Fixed on 17.1.19.”
5.
However, the Tribunals records disclosed otherwise. In the back
page of page-1 of the evidence-on-affidavit of DW-1, the learned Tribunal has
recorded as follows-“Answer to some relevant queries of the Tribunal by OP/
DW-1 on oath in the absence of the Govt. Pleader.” Thus, while the statement
is shown to have been recorded as questions by the Tribunal, which is the
power of the Tribunal under Section 165 of the Evidence Act, 1872 but in the
order sheet it has been reflected as if the petitioner as DW-1 was crossexamined and discharged. However, the order is silent as to who had done
the cross-examination.
6.
The petitioner had also examined her projected mother, Nurun
Nessa @ Nurun Nessa Choudhury as DW-2 by filing her evidence-on-affidavit
on 04.01.2019. The receipt of the said evidence-on-affidavit is not recorded in
the order dated 04.01.2019, as extracted hereinbefore. The learned Tribunal,
without recording the receipt of evidence-on-affidavit of DW-2, had passed
Page No.# 4/8
the following order on 17.01.2019:“17.1.19: The proceedee is absent today. The ld. Counsel filed a petition 6158/19
stating OP’s absence due to illness. However, the mother of her OP namely, Nurun
Nessa is present and deposed her statement as DW-2 on oath. Evidence resumed.
Fixed on 5.2.19.”
7.
From the deposition of DW-2, as recorded by the learned Tribunal on
17.01.2019, there can be no conclusion other than that the Tribunal had led
the examination-in-chief. The order passed on 17.01.2019, does not disclose
that the learned counsel for the petitioner had done the examination-in-chief.
Therefore, the order to the effect that the DW-2 was present and her
statement was recorded as DW-2, is highly questionable because of the fact
that the DW-2 had already filed her evidence-on-affidavit and there was no
requirement of DW-2 to face examination-in-chief when the same was not
conducted by the counsel for the petitioner. As evident from the order dated
17.01.2019, the examination-in-chief was definitely not done by the learned
counsel for the petitioner.
8.
The records further reveal a very disturbing manner in which the
evidence of the witnesses were recorded. For that it would be appropriate to
extract the order dated 05.02.2019 and 26.02.2019:“5.2.19: The proceedee appears today alongwith her counsel engaged and the govt.
gaonburah. The OP also filed a petition no. 6190/19 praying to call for evidence
Gaonburah against Ext.19 who denied to present without Court order.
Prayer allowed.
Fixing the next date for further evidence/ witness on 26.2.19.”
“26.2.19: The proceedee is represented by her learned counsel. Though today is
fixed for further evidence/ witness but could not produce anything.
Evidence closed.
Fixing the next date for argument on 16.3.19.”
Page No.# 5/8
9.
In the order dated 05.02.2019, the presence of Govt. Gaonburah is
recorded and the learned Tribunal has also recorded the prayer to call for the
Gaonburah against Ext. 19. As per the order dated 26.02.2019, the evidence
of Gaonburah was closed, yet, in Page-55 of the Tribunal is recorded, the
deposition of the Govt. Gaonburah who has exhibited the Gaonburah
certificate dated 24.07.2017 (Ext. 1), is available. Therefore, the recording of
the statement of DW-3, the Gaonburah who had issued Ext.1, is not reflected
in the order sheet. Surprisingly, the date on which the deposition of DW-3 was
recorded is also not entered in the sheet of deposition where the statement of
DW-3 is recorded. Therefore, the manner in which the evidence was allowed
to be led by the learned Tribunal is not only unjust and unfair but amounts to
improper maintenance of Tribunal’s records. This had come to light only after
a careful scrutiny of the record.
10.
In the considered opinion of the Court, it is not open to the learned
Tribunal to maintain a record of proceedings which is not as per the well
established principles of practice in the Tribunals. The recording of
statements of DW-1, DW-2 and DW-3 is inconsistent with the order passed
on relevant dates as stated above. The Tribunal having recorded the
statement of the DW-1, showing it to be a question of the Tribunal could not
have recorded in the order sheet as if the DW-1 was cross-examined and
discharged. Therefore, the manner in which the proceedings were taken up by
the learned Tribunal makes it appear as if the Tribunal had adorned the robe
of prosecutor and a Judge by stepping into the shoes of Govt. Advocate when
there was no presence of Govt. Advocate at all and started to cross-examine
the witness and project as if it was recording examination-in-chief of DW-2,
Page No.# 6/8
record evidence of DW-3.
11.
Therefore, the manner in which the proceedings were conducted,
having not been found in accordance with the Foreigners’ (Tribunals) Order,
1964, the entire proceeding found to be vitiated on account of the manner in
which evidence of DW-1, DW-2 and DW-3 were recorded.
12.
Accordingly, the record of examination and/ or cross-examination of
DW-1, DW-2 as well as the recording of evidence of DW-3 are all hereby
expunged.
13.
The manner in which the proceedings were carried out vitiates the
opinion and therefore, the impugned opinion dated 24.05.2019, passed by the
learned Member, Foreigners’ Tribunal, Nagaon No. 7 th at Lanka, Hojai, is
hereby set aside by remanding the matter back to the said learned Tribunal
for a fresh opinion after granting sufficient opportunity to the petitioner to
bring and examine her witnesses afresh.
14.
At this stage, the learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that DW-2, who was examined in 2019, was then 74 years of age and he does
not know whether the petitioner’s mother who was examined as DW-2 would
be still alive.
15.
In the event, the DW-2 cannot be produced, on a prayer made by
the petitioner, the learned Tribunal would permit the petitioner to examine
some other witnesses as may be deemed fit by the petitioner.
16.
Having noted the manner in which the learned Tribunal has
proceeded, the learned Member, Foreigner’s Tribunal Nagaon No. 7 th at Lanka,
Page No.# 7/8
Hojai is directed as follows:a.
To truthfully record in the order sheet if the witnesses were
examined by the learned Tribunal in exercise of power under
Section 168 of the BSA, 2023 corresponding to Section 165 of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
b.
If the witnesses was cross-examined by the Govt. Advocate,
the same should be truthfully recorded in the order sheet.
c.
If the witness is present, the Court will truthfully record as to
whether the witness has submitted evidence-on-affidavit or by
rejecting the evidence-on-affidavit the witness was ordered to be
orally examined on oath.
d.
The learned Tribunal shall also truthfully record if the cross-
examination was done by the learned Govt. Advocate or if the
witness was put questions by the learned Tribunal.
17.
Having set aside the impugned opinion dated 24.05.2019, the
petitioner, who is represented through her learned counsel, is directed to
appear before the said learned Tribunal on or before 26.05.2026 and by
producing a certified copy of the order, be ready to be cross-examined by the
Govt. Advocate and/ or be questioned by the learned Tribunal in exercise of
power under Section 168 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.
Moreover, the petitioner shall also take steps for production of witnesses, if
required.
18.
The learned Tribunal shall as far as practicable, adhere to the
Page No.# 8/8
timeline as provided under Order 3 (14) in of the Foreigners’ (Tribunals)
Order, 1964 disposing of the reference.
19.
The Registry shall return back the record of the Tribunal along with a
copy of the order to be made a part of the records.
20.
We request the learned standing counsel for the FT and Border
matters to transmit a downloaded copy of this order to the Home and Political
(B) Department, Govt. of Assam, so as to circulate this order to all the
Foreigners Tribunals in the State.
21.
The writ petition stands allowed to the extent as indicated above by
ordering remand.
22.
There shall be no order as to cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review