Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3518 ]
IN THE HIGH COURTfOR THE STATE
AT HYDERABAD
OF TELANGANA
THURSDAY, THE SEV-ENTEENTH
DAY OF SEPTEMBER
TWo THoUSAND AND rwrr.riv
ix
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
APARESH KUMAR SINGH
rHE HoNouRABLE sRr rr.r,tl?o^r,
RAMAKRTsHNA REDDy
WRIT APPEA L NO: 101 3 0F 2026
writ Appear under crause 15 0f the Letters patent preferred
Against order
Dated 10/06/2026 in Wp.No.11 78t
ot 2020, iitf," niu'ot ilr" High Court.
Between:
Piska Sagar, Sio Raohuoathj, Aged_ about
42 years,
" Occ: Agriculture, R/o
lVedinpurViilage, KonJpai<a vanoil, siooipet
Di.fii
...APPELLANT/PETITIONER
AND
o_
B
The State of Telangana, rep. by its principal
Secretary, Revenue Department,
Secretariat, Hyderabad.
The District Coilector, Siddipet District,
Siddipet.
The Revenue Divisional Officer, Gajwel,
Siddipet District.
The Tahsildar, Jagdevpur lvlandal, Siddipet
District.
Bandakinda Savithri Devi, Wo lale Narayana,
Aged
Uppa Ravinder, S/o Narsara!, Aged 52 years,
R/o Timmapur Village,
68 years, Occ.
Housewife, Rl/o Teeguila Viilage, Jagdevp;r"ffiil;i,
Jooipet District.
Bandakinda Srinivas, S/o late Narayana,
rv years, Rl/o Teegulla Village,
- Aged
rvv 49
Jagdevpur IVlandal, Siddipet District.
'vur'.
Srikant, S/o late Naravana Aged 4g years,
Rt/o Teegulla Village, Jagdevpur
Mandat, Siddipet Distrtt.
Jagdevpur A/andal, Siddipet District.
9. Kontham Venkataiah, S1o
Aged 76 years, R/o Timmapur Viilage,
Jagdevpur [V]andal, SiddipetfV3gajafr,
District.
10. Kontham Yadagiri, S/o Narsa
Swamy, Aged 69 years, R/o Timmapur Village,
Jagdevpur Mandal, Siddipet District.
ll.Kontham Saitu, S/o Nrlr".
Aged 65 years, Ri/o Timmapur Viilage,
Jagdevpur Mandal, Siddipet lygTy,
Districi.
l2.Kontham Prabhakar, S/o Ramaiah, Aged 56 years, F/o Timmapur Village,
Jagdevpur [,4andal, Siddipet District.
...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section '1 51 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to coNDoNE
the day of 32 days in liling the writ Appeal against the orders Dt. 10i6l2026 passed
in W.P. No. 11781 of 2020.
l.A. NO: 2OF 2026
Petition under se:tion 151 cPc praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to sUSpEND
the orders D|. 101612026 passed in w.p. No. 1179i of 2o2oby Hon'ble sri. Justice
Laxmi Narayabna Alishetty, till the disposal of the writ appeal.
Counsel for the Appellant: SRI CH. MADHAVA RAMAN REPRESENTING FOR
SRI K. RAVIKANTH
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 to 4: SRt MURALIDHAR REDDy KATRAM,
GP FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondent No.5 to 7: SRI C.M.R. VELU
Counsel for the Resp,rndent No.8 lo 12: - - - The Court delivered tlre following: JUDGMENT
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT ITYDERABN)
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE VAXITI RAMAKRISHNA R.EDDY
WRIT APPEAL No. 1013 of 2026
(CNR No.HBHco 10629 27 2O26i
Dete:17.09.2O26
Between:
Piska Sagar, S/o. Raghupathi
Appellant
And
The State of Telangana represented by its
Principal Secretary, Revenue Department,
Secretariat, Hyderabad and others
Respondents
JUDGMENT:
This writ appeal, preferred under Clause 15 of the Letters
Patent, is directed against the order dated 10.06.2026 passed by
the learned Single Judge in W.P.No.11781 of 2O2O, whereby the
writ petition filed by the appellant, calling in question the
proceedings of respondent No.3 / Revenue Divisional Officer,
Gajwel, in Case No. B/328/79 dated 13.01.2020, was dismissed.
2.
Heard Sri Ch. Madhava Raman, learned counsel
representing Sri K. Ravikanth, learned counsel for the appellant,
Sri Muralidhar Reddy Katram, learned Government Pleader for
Revenue appearing for respondent Nos.1 to 4, and Sri C.M.R. Ve1u,
learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos.s to 7. With the
consent of the l€arned counsel appearing on either side, the appeal
is taken up for lnal disposal at the stage of admission.
FACTU AL BACIIGROUND
3.
The subjr:ct matter of the dispute is agricultural land
admeasuring A.c.4-O4 guntas situated at Timmapur Village,
Jagdevpur Mantlal, erstwhile Medak District and presently Siddipet
District. It is not in dispute that the land is Government land and
tJ.at it came to be assigned to one Bandakindi Narayana, also
referred to in t.te records as Military Narayana, he being an exserviceman, anC that his name stood recorded in the revenue
records as pattldar and possessor in Sy.I{o.78/5I from the year
lg72-73 onwards. The said Narayala died on 26'lO 1'992'
Respondent Nos;.S to 7 are his widow and his two sons'
4.
The case of the appellant, as pleaded in the writ pelihon, is
that Bandakindi Narayana, during his lifetime, alienated an extent
of Ac.3.03 guntas i.n favour of one Kontham Pochaiah and the
remaining Ac. 1 .O 1 guntas in favour of one Uppala Narasaiah, in
both cases b,v-, way of "sadabainamas" , that is to say, by
unregisterecl sale deeds; that these alienaLions came to be
regularised unrler Section 5-A of the Andhra Pladesh Rights in
Land and Pattadar Pass Books Act, 1971 (for short, "the Act,
1471") in prcceedings bearing File Nos. G1402211989 and
l
G /50251
1989 on the frle of the Mandal Revenue Officer,
Jagdevpur; and that 13-B certificates came to be issued in favour
of the two purchasers in the year 1989.
5.
It is further pleaded that Uppala Ravinder, the son of Uppala
Narasaiah, who is arrayed as respondent No.S, sold the land
purchased by his father; that on the demise of Kontham pochaiah
his cousins, namely respondent Nos.9, 11 and 12, succeeded to
the extent of Ac.3.O3 guntas; and that respondent Nos.9 to 12 in
turn sold the entire extent of Ac.4.04 guntas to the appellant under
a registered sale deed of the year 2007. Consequent upon the said
purchase, the name of the appellant came to be mutated in the
revenue records in proceedings bearing File No. B/1443/2OO7
dated 21.06.2007 and pattadar pass book and title deeds were
issued in his favour.
6.
Respondent Nos.5 to 7, claiming to be the legal heirs of the
assignee, applied to the Tahsildar, Jagdevpur Mandal for certilied
copies of the 13-B certificates said to have been issued in File Nos.
c/402211989 and c/502511989. The Tahsildar issued
Endorsement No. D/ 153/2011 dated 26.05.2017, stating that the
records had been searched but that the said hles could not be
traced out and that, as such, certihed copies could not be issued.
Thereafter, respondent Nos.S. to 7 preferred an appeal under
(
l
Section 5(5) of the Act, 1971 before the Revenue Divisional Officer,
Siddipet on 21.O7 2011, questioning the said proceedings and the
consequent entrie s. Upon reorganisation of districts, the sr-rbject
land came within the territorial Surisdiction of the Revenue
Dirnsional Officer, Gajwcl, before whom the appeal came to be re-
numbered as Casr: No. Bl32Al20 19 and was heard and disposed
of
ORDER OF THE T\PPELLATE AUTHORITY
7.
By order da:ed 13.01.2020, respondent No.3 - the Appellate
Authority and R(:venue Divisional Ofhcer, Gajwel, allowed the
appeal. The authority recorded that the land in Sy.No.78151 is
Government assigred land; that the name of Bandakindr Narayana
stood recorded in the pahanies as pattadar and possessor from
1972-73; that the Tahsildar, Jagderpur had issued an
endorsement in F'ile No. DlI53l2Ol1 dated 26.05.2011 stating
that File Nos. G1a02211989 and Gl5025l1989 werc not traceable;
that the registerec sale deeds relied upon by the appellant, as well
as the mutatiorL effected in File No. B I 1,44312OO7 dated
21.06.2007, relat€d to land in Sy.No.78/53 and not to the lzrnd in
Sy.No.78/51 r,r'hic h alone was assigned to the ex-servicemall; and
that Government land assigned to an ex-serviceman could not have
been Lransferred rvithout obtaining zL no objection certificat(] from
the District Collector concemed. On these findings, the authority
set aside the 13-B certihcates in File Nos. G/4O22179a9 and
G I 5025 /
1989 and the mutation proceedings in File No.
B/1443/2OO7 dated 21.06.20O7, and directed the Tahsildar,
Jagdevpur to take necessar5r action as per the provisions of the Act
and the Rules in respect of the said Government assigned land.
THE ORDER UNDER APPEAL
8.
The appellant carried the said order to this Court in
W.P.No. 11781 of 2O2O. The learned Single Judge, by the order
under appeal dated 10.O6.2O26, dismissed the writ petition. The
iearned Single Judge held that the endorsement of the Tahsildar
merely recorded that the iile had not been traced out and
contained no observalion that the documents had been destroyed
in a naxalite attack, and that the plea of destruction was therefore
untenable; that in the absence of primary evidence in support of
the claim of regularisation and of the issuance of 13-B certificates,
a serious doubt arose as to the genuineness of the documents
relied upon by the appellalt, and that where the title of the
predecessors-in-title is
per se doubtful, the subsequent
transactions, including the sale deed rn favour of the appellant and
the mutation of entries, would not confer valid title upon him.
6-
9.
The learn,:d Single Judge further held that the land assigned
to Military Narayana was situated in Sy.No.78/51, as borne out by
the supplementary sethwar of the year 1970 and the pahanies of
the years 7972'73, 198i-82 and 1989-90, whereas the sale deed
executed in favrtur of the appellant, the sale deeds in favour of his
vendors and thcse in favour of the vendors' vendors, all clescribed
the land as siLlated in Sy.No.78/53, and thal the appellant had
utterly failed to explain this discrepancy; that the "SadabzLinamas"
said to have been executed by Military Narayana had not been
placed on recold at al1; ald that, in the result, the appellant had
farled to establish ownership over the land in Sy.No.78/51 On the
plea of limitati :n, the learned Single Judge held that the appeal
frled before the Revenue Divisional Officer, Siddipet on 27 'O7 '2Oll
had not been transferred to the new jurisdictional station at Gajwel
upon reorganir;ation of districts, which constrained respondent
Nos.S to 7 to h1e another appeal, and that the allegation of two
independent appeals and of abuse of process was, therefore,
incorrect. lt r.r'zrs further observed. following Kiran Singh and others
u. Chamon Pastuan and. othersl, that after reorganisation of
districts the subject property fell within the jurisdiction of the
Revenue Divisional Officer, Gajwel, and that any order passed by
rAIR 1954 SC 340
ttte Revenue Divisional Officer, Siddipet would have been a nullity,
he being ousted ofjurisdiction.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEIIALF OF THE APPELLANT
10. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the entire
controversy hrnges upon the genuineness or otherwise of the
'sadabainamas' said to have been executed by late Military
Narayana in favour of Kontham Pochaiah and Uppala Narasaiah,
and that respondent Nos.s to 7 having specihcally pleaded that
their predecessor never sold the land during his lifetime, a
disputed question of fact arose, namely whether a document of
transfer was in fact executed by a particular indiwidual. Such a
question, it was urged, can be adjudicated only by a competent
civil court upon a properly instituted suit with the benefit of oral
and documentary evidence and cross-examination of witnesses,
and lies wholly outside the summary jurisdiction of the revenue
authorities under Section 5(5) of the Act, 1971, as also outside the
jurisdiction of tJ.is Court under Article 226 of t}re Constitution of
India.
. It was next submitted that the Revenue Divisional Officer,
while purporting to exercise jurisdiction under Section 5(5) of the
Act, 7977, which is confined to the correction or amendment of
entries in the record of rights, tra-ielled far beyond that limited
IJ
jurisdiction anct effectively set at naught a private transaction and
the consequent regularisation proceedings which had attained
hnality more. than three decades earlier, in the year 19891 that the
impugned order is therefore without jurisdiction and void ab initio;
and that the proper and law{ul course open to the authority,
having found that a serious dispute as to the genuineness of the
'sadabainama' had been raised, r,'"'as to decline to adjudicate upon
it and to rek:gate the parties to a civil court, as has been
consistently ht:ld by this Court in matters arising under similar
enactments, irrcluding the decrsion rendered under the Andhra
Pradesh (Telangana Area) Abolition of Inams Act.
12. It was lurther submitted that the learned Single Judge
gravely erred irr drawing an adverse inference against the appellant
solely on the ground that the original frle relating to the 13-B
certihcates w€.s not traceable ',uth the Department; that nontraceabihty of a fi1e in the custody of the Department, several
decades after the event, can never by itself be a ground to
disbelieve or nullify a certificate rvhich was admittedly acted upon;
that the 13-B :ertihcates were in fact given effect to by th'e revenue
authorities tLremselves by muuting the names of Kontham
Pochaiah ancl Uppala Nalasaiah in the revenue records, which
could not havt: taken place unless the certificates had been issued
in the first instance; that mere admlnistrative untraceability of an
old file cannot outweigh the presumption of regularity attaching to
official acts under Section 114, Illustration (e) of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872; and that the burden of proving forgery or
fabrication iies squarely upon the party alleging it, namely
respondent Nos.S to 7, who neither examined any handwriting
expert nor hled any civil suit for a declaration that the
'sadabainamas' or the 13-B certificates are forged or void.
13. It was also submitted that respondent Nos.S to 7 have at no
point of time pleaded that tl:e proceedings in File
Nos.Gl4O22/1989 and Gl5O25l\989 were never issued by the
competent Mandal Revenue Ofhcer, or that the signature appearing
thereon is not tl:at of the offrcer then in office; that the specific
case of the appellant, that the loss of the flIe is attdbutable to
damage caused to the records of the Revenue Department in the
course of a Maoist attack, required serious consideration, since the
appellant cannot be made to suffer the loss of a decades-old title
on account of the destruction of departmental records beyond his
control; and that the appellant and his predecessors-in- title have
been in 1ong, open, continuous and peaceful possession of the
subject land since the year 1989, a period exceeding thirty-five
years, which raises a strong presumption of ownership in his
,10,
favour in terms of the principle underlying
Scction 110 of the
IndianEvidenceACt,TST2,aSagainstpartieswhoarenotand
have never sought
never have been in possession and who
restoration of Possession
14. On the discrepancy in the survey number' it was
submitted
at the time of
that the land traving been recorded as Sy'No 78/ 51
78/53' and its subassignment and thereafter reflected as Sy No
divisions 78l53lA and 78l53/AA, in the pahanies
onwards, consLstently in the names of Kontham
from 1998-99
Pochaiah' Uppala
Narasaiahandthereaftertheappellant,rightuptotheyear20lS,
record and
the discrepancy is manifestly one of revenue or survey
of the changed
not a defect of title; that the uniform appearance
every successive
survey number across every successive pahani'
registered sal': deed and every successive mutation
nearly three tlecad,es demonstrates that it is one
entry over
and the same
parcel of lanrl dealt with under an altered survey
classihcation
carriedoutb].theDepartmentitself;andthatthediscrepancyiS
been
of administrative correction and ought not to have
capable
treated as fat.rl
15. Finally, it was submittcd that the authorities as well as
learned Singl: Judge failed to appreciate the gross'
the
inordinate and
unexplained <lelay and laches on the part of respondent
Nos 5 to 7'
-11-
the 13-B certificates having been issued as far back as in the year
1989 and their predecessor having died on 26.70.7992, whereas
they remained silent for nearly two decades ald moved only in the
year 2Oll; that Section 5(5) of the Act, 1971 prescribes a period of
limitation of sixty days from the date of the order sought to be
appealed against, and the appeal, admittedly presented beyond
that period by several years, ought not to have been entertained at
all, the bar being jurisdictional and not a mere technicality, more
particularly when no application for condonation of the enonnous
de1ay, supported by sufficient cause, was ever considered on
merits; and that settled rights, and third party bona fide
transactions for value intervening thereon, ought not to be lightly
disturbed in summary revenue proceedings.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT Nos.S TO 7
76. Learned counsel for respondent Nos.5 to 7 submitted that
late Military Narayana alias Bandakindi Narayana, the husband of
respondent No.5 and the father of respondent Nos.6 and 7, being
an ex-serviceman, was assigned land in Sy.No.78/51, and that he
never sold the said land during his lifetime; that it was only upon
coming to know, after his death, that 13-B certificates had been
issued in favour of the alleged purchasers, that respondent Nos.5
to 7 applied for certified copies of those certificates; and that the
-
l:-
Tahsildar, by Endorsement No.D/ 153/2011 dated 26.O5.2O11,
informed them that the records had been searched but the frles
could not be t-aced out. It was urged that the non-availability of
the hles clear.y indicates that no such proceedrngs were ever
issued, and that all transactions founded upon such documents
are invalid and incapable of passing title to the appellant.
17. It was fr-rrther submitted that the land assigned to Military
Narayana is s;ituated in Sy.No.78/ 51, as is evident from the
supplementary sethwar of the year 1970 and the pahanies of the
years 1972-73, 1981-82 and 1989-90, whereas the sale deed
executed i.n farour of the appellant reflects land in Sy.No 78/53,
and that the a:pellant can therefore claim no title over the land in
Sy.No.78/51. It was also submitted that no appeal was ever hled
twice over; the appeal presented on 21.O7.2071 before the Revenue
Divisional Off,rr:er, Siddipet was, consequent upon reorganisation of
districts, transferred to the office of respondent No.3, where it was
re-numbered, heard and disposed of on 13.01.2020, and the
ailegation to ttr e contrary is incorrect.
SUBMISSIONS, ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT NOS.l TO 4
18. Learned Government Pleader for Revenue supported the
impugned order and the order under appeal He submitted that the
land in Sy.No.78/ 51 is Government land assigned to an ex-
-
l3-
serviceman and continues to bear that character in the revenue
records; that the appellant's documents relate to Sy.No.78/53,
which is also Government land; and that the direction issued to
the Tahsildar to take acLion in accordalce with the provisions of
the Act and the Rules in respect of Government assigrred land calls
for no interference.
19. Respondent Nos.S to 12, who are the vendors of the
appellant and the successors of the alleged purchasers under the
'sadabainamas', have not entered appearance either before the
learned Single Judge or before this Court, and have Iiled no
counter-affidavit. They have thus chosen to remain silent on the
very transactions which they are said to have entered into, and on
the existence of the Sadabainamas said to have been executed in
favour of their predecessors.
POINTS F'OR CONSIDERATION
20. In the light of the pleadings and the rival submissions
noticed above, the following points arise for consideration in this
appeal:
(i)
Whether the appeal preferred by respondent Nos'5 to 7
under Section 5(5) of the Act, I97l was barred by limitation
and ought not to have been entertained by respondent No.3
at all;
-tl-
(ii) Whether respondent No.3, exercising summary
jurisdict.on under Section 5(5) of the Act, 1971, travelled
beyond that jurisdiction in setting aside the 13-B certificates
and the mutation proceedings, and whether the parties
ought instead to have been relegated to a cinl court;
(iiil
Whether the learned Single Judge erred in drawing an
adverse inference from the non-traceability of File
Nos.G/4022/1989 and GlrO25l1989, having regard to the
presumf,tion of regularity of official acts and to the burden of
proof;
(i")
Whether the discrepancy between Sy.No.78l 51 and
Sy.No.7il/ 53 is a mere revenue record discrepancy not
affecting the appellant's title;
(")
Whether the Iong possession asserted by the appellant,
and the delay and laches on the part of respondent Nos.S to
7, entitle the appellant to the relief claimed; and
(vi) To what relief.
ANALYSIS AN]D FINDINGS
21. Before turning to the individual points, it is useful to notice
the scheme of the provisions invoked. The Act, 1971 is an
,l5-
enactment providing for the preparation and maintenance of a
record of rights in land and for the issue of pattadar pass books
and title deeds. Section 5 deals with the amendment of the record
of rights by the recording authority, and sub_section (5) thereof
confers a right of appeal upon an aggrieved party to the Revenue
Divisional Ofhcer against an order of the recording authority
amending or refusing to amend the entries in the record of rights.
Section 5-A provides for regularisaLion of certain alienations or
transfers of land effected otherwise than by a registered document,
upon an application made by the alienee or transferee to the
Mandal Revenue Oflicer, who may issue a certificate declaring such
alienation or transfer to be valid. A certificate issued under Section
5-A, described in practice as a 13-B certificate, is thus the very
foundation of the entries that follow it in the record of rights.
(L)
Lirnitation
22. The contention that the appeal before respondent No.3 was
barred by limitation proceeds upon the premise that the period of
sixty days prescribed under Section 5(5) of the Act, 1971 must
invariably be computed from the date of the order of the recording
authority, irrespective of the knowledge of the party aggrieved. That
premise cannot be accepted in the facts of the present case. The
alienations in question were effected, if at all, by unregistered_
- l6-
'sadabainamas'; the regulari.sation proceedings of the year 1989
and the mutation of 2I.06.2007 were carried out behind the back
of respondent I'Jos.5 to 7, who were nowhere on record as parties;
and it is not the case of the appellant that any nolice was issued
to, or served tLpon, the assignee or his legal heirs at any stage'
Where an order affecting the rights of a person is passed without
notice to him, the period of limitation for challenging it cannot
begin to run f-om a date anterior to his knowledge of it On the
material on record, the knowledge of respondent Nos 5 to 7 is
traceable to tL.e endorsement of the Tahsildar dated 26 05 201 1,
and the appeal came to be presented on 27.O7 -2011, that is to say,
well within si;<ty days thereafter. The appeal was therefore not
barred by limitation.
23. The further submi.ssion that two independent appeals were
fr1ed, in 20 1 1 and in 20 18, and that the second of them ought not
to have been t ntertained, has been rightly repelled by the learned
Single Judge. The record bears out that the appeal presented on
27.O7 .2071 belore the Revenue Divisional Officer, Siddipet was not
transmitted to the new jurisdictional staLion at Gajwel consequent
upon the reorllanisation of districts, and that respondent Nos.S to
7 were, for that reason, obliged to move the Revenue Divisional
Ofhcer, Gajrvel again. What was numbered as
Case
-17-
No.B/328/2019 is, in substance, a continuation of the appeal of
2011 and not a fresh proceeding. A litigant cannot be visited with
the consequences of an administrative failure to transmit records
upon a terrilorial reorganisation brought about by the State.
Moreover, as the subject land fe1l, after reorganisation, within the
jurisdiction of the Revenue Divisional Oflicer, Gajwel, an order
passed by the Revenue Divisional Ofhcer, Siddipet would have been
of no effect, he having been ousted of jurisdiction. The plea of
abuse of the process of law is wholly misconceived. Point (i) is
answered against the appellant.
(ii)
Scope of the iurisd iction under Sectton 515) and
releoation to a ciuil court
24. The appellant's principal submission is that the genuineness
of the 'sadabainamas' is a disputed question of fact triable only by
a civil court, and that respondent No.3 usurped a jurisdiction not
vested in him. The submission, attractive at first blush, does not
bear scrutiny. The appellate authority under Section 5(5) of the
Act, 1977 was not called upon to declare title, and did not purport
to do so. What it was ca11ed upon to decide was whether the entries
in the record of rights, and the 13-B certihcates upon which those
entries rest, had a law{ul foundation. That is an enquiry squarely
within the province of lhe authority charged with the maintenance
of the record of rights. Indeed, the authority could not have
- t8,
discharged its statutory function at all without examining whether
the certihcates said to have been issued under Section 5-A were in
fact issued and whether the land to which they related was the
land dealt witL in the subsequent transaclions.
25. It is eqttally important to notice what Lhe impugned order
does and what it does not do. It sets aside the 13-B certificates and
the consequert mutation, and directs the Tahsildar to take action
in accordance with the Act and the Rules in respect of Government
assigned 1and. It does not declare respondent Nos.5 to 7 to be the
owners of the subject land; it does not order delivery of possession;
and it does not, and cannot, operate as a judgment on tttle binding
in a civil ac [ion. Findings recorded in summary proceedings
relating to the record of rights are confined to those proceedings. It
is settled beyond controversy that entries in the revenlte records
are made for [rscal purposes and do not by themselves create or
extinguish title. The appellant's apprehension that a qr-restron of
title has been hnally decided against him in a summary proceeding
is therefore unfounded, and his remedy, if he is so advised, is to
establish his t tle in an appropriately constituted civil suit-.
26. There is, besides, an element of inconsistency in the
appellant's s -and. It was the appellant who invoked the
extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of t]:,e
-t9-
Constitution of India, inviting the Court to pronounce upon the
validity of the 13-B certificates and upon his own title flowing from
them; having failed, he cannot now contend that neither the
authority nor the writ court could have examined the matter at all.
Point (ii) is answered against the appellant.
(tii)
.
Non-traceo.bilita of the file presumption of regularitu
qnd burden of oroof
The submission founded upon Section 1 14, Illustration (e) of
the Indian Ewrdence Act, 7872 overlooks the sequence in which the
presumption operates. The presumption that judicial and offrcial
acts have been regularly performed attaches to an official act the
existence of which is established; it is not a substitute for proof
that the act was performed at all. A party who rests his title upon a
certificate issued under Section 5-A of the Act, 1971 must first
place the certiflcate, or at the least secondary evidence of it, before
the authority. In the present case the appellant did not produce the
original or a certified copy of the 13-B certifrcates; and, what is far
more telling, the 'Sadabainamas' said to have been executed by late
Military Narayana in favour of Kontham Pochaiah and Uppala
Narasaiah, which are the foundation of the entire chain, have
never been placed on record at any stage, whether before the
appellate authority, before the learned Single Judge, or before this
Court.
-
ta,
i
28. The 'sadabainamas', if they existed, would have been in the
custody of the alibnees and their successorsr that is to say, of the
appellant's own vendors, who are respondent Nos.8 to 12 herein,
and thereafter of the appellant. Their non-production is therefore
not attributablr: to the loss of any departmental record, and it is a
circumstance liom whrch an inference adverse to the appeliant
legitimately fo1..ows. It is also significant that respondent Nos.8 to
12, who alone could have spoken Lo those transactions, have not
chosen to appear or to f11e any counter-affidavit. ln these
circumstances, the learned Single Judge cannoL be sai<1 to have
proceeded merely upon the untraceability of a departmental file.
The hnding of doubt was founded upon a combination of
ci.rcumstances. namely the absence of the Sadabainamas, the
absence of the regularisation hle, and the unexplained discrepancy
in the survey number, to which we now turn.
29. The ple:r that the records were destroyed in a naxali.te attack
on ttre office oI the Mandal Revenue Ofhcer is not supported by any
material. The :ndorsement of the Tahsildar records on15' that the
fi1e could not ce traced ouU it contains no reference to any such
attack or to the destruction of records. A plea of this nature, being
one of fact, had to be established by evidence, such as a report of
lhe incident or a departmental record of the loss of documents. No
-21-
such material was produced. The learned Single Judge was
therefore justihed in rejecling the plea as untenable. As to the
burden of proving fabrication, it is true that a party alleging forgery
must prove it. But that principle presupposes that the document
alleged to be forged is before the Court. Where the document is not
produced at all, no question of shifting any burden arises; the
party asserting a right under the document simply fails to establish
the foundation of his claim. Point (iii) is answered against the
appellant.
(iu) Discreoancu between Sa.No.78/57 and Sa.No.78/53
30. The discrepancy in the survey number is, in our view, the
most serious infirmity in the appellant's case, and it has remained
unexplained throughout. It is admitted that the land assigned to
Military Narayana is Sy.No.78/51, and it is in that survey number
alone that his name stood recorded frort 1972-73. It is equally
admitted that the registered sale deed in favour of the appellant,
the sale deeds in favour of his vendors, a-nd those in favour of the
vendors' vendors, all describe the land as situated in Sy.No.78/53.
The appellant's own averment in the writ affrdavit is that he is the
absolute owner and possessor of land in Sy.No.78/51, tracing his
title to the alleged purchasers of land in that survey number under
sadabainamas lrom Military Narayana. The two positions cannot
stand together.
31. The explzrnation offered, narnely that the parcel carne to be
renumbered by Lhe Department and that the change is reflected
uniformly in thc pahanies from 1998 99 onwards, is an
explanation that was capable ol easy proof and yet was not proved.
Neither any s,ub-division proceedi.ngs, nor any re-sl.irvcy or
renumbering proceedings of the competent authority, nor an]
sethwar or sun/ey record demonstrating that Sy.No.78/51 came to
be renumbererl as Sy.No.78/53. has been placed orl record
Consistencl' of an entry across successive pahanies establishes
only that the e :rtry was carried forward; it does not estat)lish that
the entry had ir la'.r'ful origin, nor does it establish the identity of
the two parce s. On the contrar-v-, the appellate authority has
recorded, upon a perusal of the records, that Sy.No.78/5.3 is itself
Government land of an extent of Ac.4.04 guntas and that the
Tahsildar mut..ted that land in lavtrur of the purchasers without
observing the rules relating to iissignment. On either view,
therefore, the land covered bl the appellant's docu:nents is
Government land, and the identitl' of that land u'ith the land
assigned to Military Narayana remains unestablished. Point (iv) is
answered agair st the appellant.
(o)
.Lons possessi on. and. dela u and laches on the oart of
respond.ent Nos.S to 7
32. The reliance placed upon Section 110 of the Indian Evidence
Act, 7872 is misplaced. The presumption arising from possession
operates in ttre absence of proof of title and must yield where t1.e
nature of the land and the sburce of the possession are known.
Here the land is admittedly Government land assigned to an exserviceman. Possession of assigned Government land, however
long, cannot ripen into tit1e, and no plea of prescription rs available
against the State. The character of the land as assigned land is not
altered by the length of the possession of a transferee, nor by the
number of successive transfers through which the possession has
passed. It is also to be noticed that t}re impugned order does not
disturb the appellant's possession; it sets aside the certificates and
the entries and leaves it to the Tahsildar to take such action as the
Act and the Rules permit in respect of assigned land, which action
must necessarily be taken after notice to the appellant and after
affording him an opportunity of being heard.
33. As regards delay and laches on the part of respondent Nos.5
to 7 , we are conscious of the long interval between 1989 and 201 1.
But delay must be assessed in the light of the manner in which the
entries came to be made. Respondent Nos.S to 7 were never parties
to the regularisation proceedings; no notice was given to them;
their predecessor died in 1992; and the alleged transfers were by
unregistered documents which found no place in any public
register from r'rhich knowledge could be imputed to them. Once
tJley came lo know of the entries, they moved with reasonable
promptitude. Eieyond this, delay cannot confer validity upon an
entry that lacks a law{ul foundation, nor can it convert
Government assigned land into private property. Equally, the plea
that the appelirrnt is a bona fide purchaser for value without notice
cannot avail him, for the revenue records themselves disclosed the
character of the land as Government assigned land recorded in the
name of an ex- ;erviceman, and the appellant's vendors traced their
own rights to unregistered 'Sadabainamas' which were never
produced. Poini (v) is alswered agarnst the appellant.
CONCLUSION
34. The hndings recorded by the Iearned Single Judge are
findings arriverl at upon a consideration of the material placed
before the writ court, and we find no error of 1aw or of approach in
them. In an appeal under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent, this
Court would be slow lo interfere with such hndings unless they are
shown to be llerverse or contrary to the record, and no such
infrrmity fas b:en demonstrated. The appellant failed to establish
that the 'Sade.bainamas' were executed, lailed to produce the
-25-
certificates under Section 5-A upon which his chain of title rests,
and failed to explain the discrepancy in the survey number which
goes to the very identity of the land he claims. The appeal must
I
accordingly fail.
R.BSULT
35. For the foregoing reasons, the wr-it appeal is dismissed,
confirming the order dated 10.06.2O26 passed by the learned
Single Judge in W.P.No.1178I of 2O2O. There shall be no order as
to costs,
36. It is, however, made clear that the findings recorded by
respondent No.3 in Case No.B/3281 19 dated 13.01.2020, by the
learned Single Judge, and by this Court, are rendered in
proceedings relating to the record of rights and shall not preclude
either party from establishing such title as they may have in
respect of the subject land before a competent civil court, in which
event the rights of the parties shall be decided on their own merits
and uninfluenced by the observations made herein. It is further
made clear that any action proposed to be.-taken by respondent
No.4 - Tahsildar, Jagdevpur Mandal, pursuant to the direction
contained in the order dated 13.01.202O, shall be taken strictly in
accordance with the applicable provisions of 1aw and the Rules
'lt
made thereund:r, and only after noti.ce to the appellant :rnd after
affording him a reasonable opportLlnity of being heard.
Miscellansous applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed
SD/- MOHD. ISMAIL
DEPUW RTrsr-ryrR
//TRUE COPY//
/)
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to Sftl K. RAVIKANTH, Advocate IOPUC]
2. One CC to SFtl C.M.R. VELU, Advocate [OPUC]
3. Two CCs to tfP FOR REVENUE, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad [CrUT]
4 Two CD Copi:s
BN
GJP
4b
HIGH COUR-r
DATED: 1710912026
JUDGMENT
WA.No.1013 of 2026
t
,:,7 -t,t STArr o
-'{t
L
li
!l-\
l\{
iQ,
t\ste
s
.5
*
DISMISSING'THE WRIT APPEAL
WITHOUT CC,STS
I
,*lal*
t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review