Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.41558 of 2021
In the matter of an application under Articles 226 & 227 of the
Constitution of India.
………………
….
Pintu Biswal
Petitioner
-versusMahanadi Coalfields Ltd.,
Sambalpur & Ors.
For Petitioner
:
For Opp. Parties :
….
Opposite Parties
Mr. U.K. Samal, Sr. Advocate
along with
Mr. N. Samal, Advocate
Mr. S.D. Das, Sr. Advocate
along with
Mr. H. Mohanty, Advocate
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing: 10.03.2026 and Date of Judgment: 10.03.2026
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Biraja Prasanna Satapathy, J.
1. This matter is taken up through hybrid mode.
// 2 //
2. Heard Mr. U.K. Samal, learned Sr. Counsel appearing for the
Petitioner along with Mr. N. Samal, learned counsel and Mr. S.D. Das,
learned Sr. Counsel appearing for the Opp. Party Nos. 1, 3 & 4 along
with Mr. H. Mohanty, learned counsel.
3. The present writ petition has been filed inter alia challenging the
rejection of the Petitioner’s claim to get the benefit of appointment on
the death of his father vide the impugned communication issued on
10/11.07.2020 under Annexure-8 so issued by Opp. Party No. 4.
4. Learned Sr. Counsel appearing for the Petitioner contended that
Petitioner’s father was appointed in the year 1991 as a Badali worker and
subsequently was regularized as Mechanical Fitter. It is contended that
while so continuing as a Mechanical Fitter at Lakhanpur Area of MCL,
he died on 25.11.2013. On such death of the deceased employee,
Petitioner being the son, made his claim to get the benefit of
appointment in terms of the provisions contained under the National
Coal Wage Agreement so executed on 19.01.1996.
4.1. It is contended that Petitioner though being the son of the deceased
employee is otherwise eligible to get the benefit of appointment, in terms
of the provisions contained under clause 9.3.0 of the Agreement, but
// 3 //
such claim of the Petitioner was rejected vide the impugned
communication dtd.10/11.07.2020 under Annexure-8 only on the ground
that his claim is not covered under clause 9.3.0 of NCWA.
4.2. It is also contended that prior to issuance of the impugned
communication, on consideration of the Petitioner’s claim, he was
provided with the appointment vide order dtd.13.04.2015 under
Annexure-4. After such appointment of the Petitioner, when he was
asked to undergo the medical examination vide letter dtd.21.04.2015
under Annexure-5, Petitioner also found to be medically fit. But his
joining letter submitted under Annexure-6 when was not accepted,
Petitioner made a grievance challenging such action of the Opp. Parties
in not allowing the Petitioner to join on the face of the letter of
appointment issued under Annexure-4.
4.3. Learned Sr. Counsel appearing for the Petitioner contended that
since Petitioner was found eligible to get the benefit with issuance of the
order of appointment under Annexure-4, the ground on which
Petitioner’s claim has been rejected vide the impugned communication
under Annexure-8, is not sustainable in the eye of law and requires
interference of this Court.
// 4 //
5. Mr. S.D. Das, learned Sr. Counsel appearing for the MCL on the other
hand made his submission basing on the stand taken in the counter
affidavit so filed. Learned Sr. Counsel vehemently contended that after
being provided with the appointment vide order dtd.13.04.2015 under
Annexure-4, when it was found that Petitioner’s father has got the
benefit of appointment by committing fraud and he was never a land
oustee, basing on which he was provided with the appointment vide
order dtd.05.07.1991 under Annexure-A/1, claim of the Petitioner
though was allowed with issuance of the order of appointment under
Annexure-4, but his joining was never accepted. It is contended that
Petitioner’s father was never a land oustee and he was never a nominee
of any land oustee and accordingly appointed order issued in his favour
on 05.007.1991 under Annexure-A/1, cannot be taken as a valid
appointment in the eye of law.
5.1. Placing reliance on Para 10 of the order of appointment issued in
favour of the Petitioner’s late father, it is contended that in the said order
of appointment it was clearly indicated that if any appointment has been
obtained by fraudulent means/fraudulent declaration, services of such
appointee can be terminated without any notice. Clause 10 of the order
of appointment reads as follows:-
// 5 //
“10. If at any time, it is found that you have got the
appointment by fraudulent means, fraudulent declaration
and agreement and/or you are not the real owner of
land/house or direct dependent of the land owner, whose
land has been acquired by the Company, your services are
liable to be terminated without any notice.”
5.2. It is also contended that since Petitioner’s late father got the benefit
of appointment by committing fraud, Petitioner being the son of the
deceased employee is not eligible to get the benefit so allowed in his
favour with issuance of order dtd.13.04.2015 under Annexure-4. In
support of his submission reliance was placed to the decisions of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Union of India & Ors. Vs. Prohlad
Guha etc. reported in 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1865 and another decision
in the case of Bank of India & Anr. Vs. Avinash D. Mandivikar & Ors.
reported in (2005) 7 SCC 690.
5.3. Hon’ble Apex Court in Para 7 & 8 of the judgment in the case of
Prohlad Guha has held as follows:“7. The principle of compassionate appointment, as we
have noticed above, has been put in place to ameliorate
suffering that is cast upon members of a family upon the
sudden death of the earning member. An equally wellrecognized principle is that compassionate appointment
cannot be claimed as a matter of right. It is therefore clear
that a person, claiming an appointment on such ground, has
to demonstrate his relationship to the deceased person and
// 6 //
eligibility for appointment. The same cannot be done without
placing all relevant documents before the competent
authority. The Tribunal as also the authority has recorded a
categorical finding that the respondent-employees had not
submitted any document to establish their claim and
submitted forged and bogus documents.
8. On the aspect of non-compliance of the principles of
natural justice, we find that the authority had issued showcause notices to the respondent-employees, to which they
responded. It was subsequent thereto, upon finding the
responses to be unsatisfactory, they were removed from the
service. On approaching the Tribunal and receiving
favorable orders, their appeals against such dismissal were
heard and acted upon by the authority, with the dismissal
being confirmed. Before the High Court, it was averred that
the respondent-employees were not given an opportunity to
prove their innocence, nor were any documents, on the basis
of which the impugned order of dismissal was passed,
provided to them. All of this, it was submitted, flies against
the
protection
envisaged
under
Article 311 of
the Constitution of India.”
5.4. Similarly, Hon’ble Apex Court in Para 8 & 9 of the judgment in the
case of Avinash D. Mandivikar has held as follows:“8. Stand of Respondent 1 employee is to the effect that he
has put in nearly three decades of service and has about
three years to go before retirement, and in terms of the
High Court's order he has been denied promotion.
Therefore, the order of the High Court is an equitable
order.
9. A similar plea about long years of service was
considered by this Court in R. Vishwanatha Pillai v. State of
// 7 //
Kerala [(2004) 2 SCC 105 : 2004 SCC (L&S) 350] to be
inconsequential. In para 19 it was observed : (SCC pp. 11617)
“19. It was then contended by Shri Ranjit Kumar,
learned Senior Counsel for the appellant that since the
appellant has rendered about 27 years of service, the order
of dismissal be substituted by an order of compulsory
retirement or removal from service to protect the
pensionary benefits of the appellant. We do not find any
substance in this submission as well. The rights to salary,
pension and other service benefits are entirely statutory in
nature in public service. The appellant obtained the
appointment against a post meant for a reserved candidate
by producing a false caste certificate and by playing a
fraud. His appointment to the post was void and non est in
the eye of the law. The right to salary or pension after
retirement flows from a valid and legal appointment. The
consequential right of pension and monetary benefits can be
given only if the appointment was valid and legal. Such
benefits cannot be given in a case where the appointment
was found to have been obtained fraudulently and rested on
a false caste certificate. A person who entered the service
by producing a false caste certificate and obtained
appointment for the post meant for a Scheduled Caste, thus
depriving a genuine Scheduled Caste candidate of
appointment to that post, does not deserve any sympathy or
indulgence of this Court. A person who seeks equity must
come with clean hands. He, who comes to the court with
false claims, cannot plead equity nor would the court be
justified to exercise equity jurisdiction in his favour. A
person who seeks equity must act in a fair and equitable
manner. Equity jurisdiction cannot be exercised in the case
of a person who got the appointment on the basis of a false
caste certificate by playing a fraud. No sympathy and
equitable consideration can come to his rescue. We are of
// 8 //
the view that equity or compassion cannot be allowed to
bend the arms of law in a case where an individual
acquired a status by practising fraud.”
6. To the submission made by the learned Sr. Counsel appearing for the
MCL, learned Sr. Counsel appearing for the Petitioner made further
submission contending inter alia that after appointment of the
Petitioner’s father vide order dtd.05.07.1991, no action was ever taken
against him on the ground that such appointment was obtained by
committing fraud. Since Petitioner’s father after being so appointed vide
order dtd.05.07.1991, was not only regularized but also was allowed to
continue till he died on 25.11.2013, the factum of fraud cannot be raised
against a dead person. In support of his submission reliance was placed
to a decision on the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Girijanandini
Devi & Ors. vs. Bijendra Narain Choudhary, reported in 1966 SCC
OnLine SC 236. Hon’ble Apex Court has held as follows to the
following extract of the decision:“The maxim “action personalis moritur cun persona” a
personal action dies with the person, has a limited
application.”
6.1. It is accordingly contended that since Petitioner was duly appointed
vide order dtd.13.04.2015 and he has successfully qualified the medical
// 9 //
test, Opp. Party No. 3 be directed to accept his joining report so
submitted under Annexure-6.
7. Having heard learned counsel appearing for the Parties and
considering the submission made, this Court finds Petitioner’s father
while continuing as a regular employee under the Opp. Parties, he died
on 25.11.2013. On such death of the deceased employee, Petitioner when
raised his claim to get the benefit of appointment, the same was not only
considered but also vide order dtd.13.04.2015 under Annexure-4
Petitioner was appointed as against the pot of Cat-I (Tr.), General
Mazdoor. After being provided with such appointment vide order
dtd.13.04.2015 under Annexure-4, Petitioner was asked to go for
medical examination vide letter dtd.21.04.2015 under Annexure-5.
Thereafter, Petitioner when submitted his joining report under
Annexure-6, the same was never accepted and in the alternate the
impugned order was passed by holding that Petitioner’s claim is not
coming under the provisions contained under clause 9.3.0 of NCWA.
7.1. This Court taking into account the materials available on record and
the provisions contained under clause 9.3.0 of NCWA, is of the view
that since during continuance of the deceased employee under the Opp.
// 10 //
Parties, no action was ever taken against him till he died, on the ground
that the deceased employee got the benefit of appointment by
committing fraud, after such death of the deceased employee, factum of
fraud if any committed by the deceased employee cannot stand legal
scrutiny.
7.2. Since Petitioner was duly appointed vide order dtd.13.04.2015 and
he was declared medically fit after being referred under Annexure-5, it is
the view of this Court that the ground on which the impugned order has
been passed under Annexure-8 is not sustainable in the eye of law.
7.3. It is also the view of this Court that after death of the deceased
employee, factum of fraud cannot be raised in view of the decision in the
case of Girijanandini Devi so cited (supra). Not only that decisions
relied on by the Opp. Parties as per the considered view of this Court is
not applicable to the facts of the present case.
7.4. Therefore, this Court while quashing the impugned communication
dtd.10/11.07.2020 under Annexure-8, directs Opp. Party No. 3 to accept
the joining report of the Petitioner so submitted under Annexure-6 and
allow him to discharge his duty in terms of Annexure-4. However,
Petitioner will not be entitled to get any arrear claim from the date of his
// 11 //
joining as per Annexure-6 till his joining is formally accepted in terms of
the present order. This Court directs Opp. Party No. 3 to pass a fresh
order by allowing the Petitioner to join within a period of two (2) weeks
from the date of receipt of this order.
8. The writ petition accordingly stands disposed of.
(BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY)
JUDGE
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Dated the 10th March, 2026/Sneha
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SNEHANJALI PARIDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 13-Mar-2026 11:04:03
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review