Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED: 1st August, 2018
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
:
Appellant
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia,
Son of late Thendup Bhutia,
Resident of Sribadam,
West Sikkim.
[At present State Central Prison, Rongyek, East Sikkim]
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
Appeal under Section 374(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mrs. Laxmi Chakraborty, Advocate (Legal Aid Counsel)
for the Appellant.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Additional Public Prosecutor and
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee, Additional Public Prosecutor for the
State-Respondent.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, ACJ
1.
Dissatisfied with the impugned Judgment dated
26.05.2016 in Sessions Trial Case No. 12 of 2014 of the
Sessions Judge, West Sikkim, at Gyalshing, and the Order on
Sentence dated 30.05.2016, the Appellant has preferred this
Appeal.
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
2.
State of Sikkim
On Conviction under Section 304-Part I, Section
324 and Section 323 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short
„the IPC‟), the impugned Sentence was as follows;
(i) Rigorous imprisonment of 10(ten) years and fine of
Rs.30,000/- (Rupees thirty thousand) only, under
Section 304 Part-I of the IPC, with a default
stipulation.
(ii) Simple imprisonment of 2(two) years under Section
324 of the IPC.
(iii)Simple imprisonment of 6(six) months under Section
323 of the IPC.
The Sentences were ordered to run concurrently setting
off the period of detention already undergone. The fine
amount if recovered was to be handed over to the family
members of the deceased as compensation under Section 357
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short „the
Cr.P.C.‟).
3.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant, before this
Court contended that the impugned Judgment and Order on
Sentence were flawed as no materials existed for convicting
the Appellant, a supporter of the opposition political party
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha (for short „SKM party‟) under any of
the
Sections
charged.
Raising
contradictory
arguments,
learned Counsel then submitted on the one hand that there
were no independent witnesses as PW-1 to PW-14 were
interested witnesses being supporters of the ruling Sikkim
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
Democratic Front political party (for short „SDF party‟), while
PW-17 is the sister of the deceased and PW-18 his Uncle, their
evidence
therefore
ought
to
be
considered
with
circumspection. In the same breath, it was expostulated that
despite the availability of independent witnesses at the place
of occurrence, viz; the local residents and one Duryo Dhan
Pradhan, Head Constable, they remained unexamined as
Prosecution witnesses. That Pema Choda Lepcha PW-30, a
Constable of the Indian Reserve Battalion, was declared
hostile as he testified that neither could he witness the
incident due to darkness nor he did see any one picking up
any person lying on the ground or hear any man or woman
crying out that a person had been killed. It is also the next
contention of learned Counsel that the assigning of the case to
the Criminal Investigation Department police (for short „CID‟)
from the Kaluk Police Station for investigation, reveals the
unwarranted interest of the State in the matter, leading to a
bias against the Appellant.
4.
In the second leg of her arguments, learned
Counsel for the Appellant contended that there are serious
discrepancies in the medical reports of the victim/deceased, as
PW-22, Dr. A.S. Subba, found only a single haematoma of 4 x
4 inches over occipital region, while Exhibit-21, the report
from Dr. Chhang‟s Super Speciality Hospital Pvt. Ltd. prepared
by Dr. S. Bol PW-26, indicated that the patient was admitted
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
with multiple injuries due to physical assault. PW-29 Dr. Rumi
Maitra, who conducted the autopsy, also found several injuries
on the deceased, while PW-28, the Sub-Inspector of Police
who conducted inquest on the dead body, found an injury on
the right side of the head but not on the left side. The
anomalies raise serious reservations about the Prosecution
case. That, one of the weapons of offence allegedly a „khukuri‟
was never recovered, while MO-II, the wooden beam alleged
to have been used for assaulting the Victim, was not
forwarded for forensic evaluation. That in fact, the case is one
of medical negligence on the part of PW-22 Dr. A.S. Subba,
Medical Officer at Rinchenpong Primary Health Centre, who
first
attended
to
and
examined
the
deceased.
It
was
strenuously contended that despite learning that the patient
was in a critical condition, he advised the patient to be moved
for higher medical facilities in a private vehicle leading to
contributory negligence.
5.
In
the
third
leg
of
her
arguments,
it
was
canvassed that the Appellant neither had the intention nor the
knowledge that the injury inflicted would cause death. In fact,
even assuming but not admitting that the Appellant had struck
the deceased, it was in a sudden fight in the heat of passion
and at the spur of the moment to save himself from being
assaulted by a mob consisting of more than 18(eighteen)
people. The act of the Appellant was merely a rash and
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
negligent act falling within Exception 4 of Section 300 and
thereby under Section 304A of the IPC, which was overlooked
by the learned Trial Court.
6.
The final argument raised was that contradictions
existed in the FIR lodged by PW-1 Sangay Chopel Bhutia with
his Statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. as well as his
testimony in the Court. As per his Section 161 Cr.P.C.
Statement, he had gone to Jorethang to attend the SDF
Foundation Day programme, contrary to which in his evidence
before the Court he has stated that in fact he had gone for
medical treatment and stayed on at Jorethang to hear the
Chief Minister‟s speech. Exhibit-1 too does not reveal that he
had gone for medical treatment. The Court should thus be
circumspect while accepting the evidence of this witness. That,
the evidence of PW-17 the sister of the deceased, is contrary
to the evidence of PW-30, inasmuch as according to PW-17,
when the Appellant came from behind the victim and hit him
on the head with the wooden beam, she cried out that her
brother was killed but PW-30 present at the place of
occurrence heard no such cry. That in fact, even the Appellant
was subjected to assaults as evident from Exhibit-12, his
medical report. The evidence on records fail to inspire
confidence and the Judgment of the learned Trial Court is
based on surmises and hypothesis which deserves to be set
aside.
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
7.
State of Sikkim
Repelling the arguments of learned Counsel for the
Appellant, learned Additional Public Prosecutor would canvass
that the evidence of PW-20 and PW-21 establishes the seizure
of MO-II (wooden beam) by the Investigating Officer (for short
„the I.O.‟). That, in fact, nine Prosecution witnesses have
deposed that when the deceased turned his back to the
Appellant he was assaulted on his head by the Appellant with
MO-II, which is duly substantiated by the medical evidence of
PW-22, PW-26 and PW-29, who on examining the Victim
opined that the cause of death was the injuries found on the
deceased. That, although the Prosecution opted not to
examine Duryo Dhan Pradhan, Head Constable, on account of
the witness being unreliable, departmental proceedings having
been initiated against him, the Appellant too failed to examine
him despite citing him as a witness which thereby leads to an
adverse inference. Although, the Appellant has contended that
according to PW-30 there was no light at the place of
occurrence, the evidence of PW-2, PW-3 and PW-13 would
indicate that the street lights at the spot sufficiently lit the
area and the Appellant having been identified was rightly
convicted. Attention of this Court on this count was drawn to
Gurmeet Singh vs. State of U.P. .
Refuting the arguments of
learned Counsel for the Appellant, it was contended that
merely because the witnesses comprised of SDF supporters
and kin of the deceased, would not make them unreliable
(2005) 12 SCC 107
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
witnesses. This argument was fortified with reliance on State of
Haryana vs. Shakuntla and Others
and Govindaraju alias Govinda
vs. State by Srirampuram Police Station and Another ,
8.
Rebutting the contention that the statement of
PW-1 Sangay Chopel Bhutia, in the FIR Exhibit-1 is contrary to
his deposition in Court, it was pointed out that FIR cannot be
deemed to be an encyclopaedia, duly buttressing his argument
with the ratio in Mahesh and Another vs. State of Madhya
Pradesh . Further, while submitting that evidence before the
Court being substantive evidence is to be considered and not
the statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C., attention was drawn
to the decision in R. Shaji vs. State of Kerala5. That, the
Prosecution evidence being cogent and consistent clearly
establishes that the Appellant had chosen an opportune
moment to assault the Victim from behind, on his head
intentionally to cause death. The question of the incident
arising out of the heat of passion and the spur of the moment
is devoid of merit. Thus, no infirmity accrues in the impugned
Judgment and Order on Sentence of the learned Trial Court
and a dismissal befits the Appeal.
(2012)5 SCC 171
(2012) 4 SCC 722
(2011) 9 SCC 626
(2013) 14 SCC 266
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
9.
State of Sikkim
The rival submissions made at the Bar were heard
at length and given careful consideration. The evidence and
documents on record have been meticulously examined by
me. Would the impugned Conviction and Order on Sentence
warrant any interference, is the question that falls for
consideration herein.
10.
To gauge this, it would be appropriate to briefly
walk through the facts of the case. On 04.03.2014 at around
2100 hours, PW-1 lodged Exhibit-1, the FIR, at the Kaluk
Police Station informing therein that the Complainant along
with party workers of the SDF party arrived at Sribadam (West
Sikkim) at 8 p.m. after attending the party meeting at
Jorethang (South Sikkim). When they were parting company
to return home, a discussion ensued between the Appellant, a
supporter of the SKM party and one Dawa Gyatso Bhutia, SDF
supporter, during which the Appellant‟s younger brother,
Jigmee Dorjee Bhutia, interfered and started attacking the
SDF supporters.
On the advice of the Victim/deceased,
Narendra
Gurung,
Kumar
who
was
the
Vice-President,
Constituency Level Committee (CLC) of the SDF party, not to
quarrel, they started dispersing when suddenly the Appellant
struck the deceased on his head from behind and injured him.
Pursuant
thereto,
the
deceased
was
evacuated
to
the
Rinchenpong Primary Health Centre, on his condition being
serious, he was referred to Siliguri thereafter. Hence, strict
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
legal action was sought against the Appellant and his younger
brother, Jigmee Dorjee Bhutia. The FIR was duly registered as
Kaluk Police Station Case being FIR No. 06/2014 dated
04.03.2014, under Section 307/34 of the IPC, against the duo
and endorsed for investigation to PW-31, Police Inspector
Kesang D. Bhutia. On receiving information that the patient
had succumbed to his injuries at Siliguri, the case was
converted
to
one
under
Section
302/34
IPC.
After
investigation commenced, the matter was transferred to the
CID, Gangtok, on 11.03.2014 and endorsed to PW-32, Dy.S.P.
K.B. Gadaily, for investigation. The formalities of investigation,
such as arrest, interrogation and medical examination were
carried out, the weapons of offence were recovered from the
place
of
occurrence
and
seized,
all
relevant
witnesses
examined and their statements recorded. The inquest and
post mortem report of the deceased were also obtained from
the concerned police station at Siliguri. It transpired on
investigation that on 04.03.2014 at around 7:30 p.m. about
20(twenty)
people,
including
the
deceased,
returned
to
Sribadam via Soreng after observing the SDF Foundation Day
at Jorethang. En route, they were obstructed by SKM party
activists
at
Singling
where
the
Soreng
Police
however
intervened. On arriving at Sribadam, the SDF supporters
reprimanded the Appellant who was loitering there, regarding
the said obstruction. The Appellant retaliated leading to a
scuffle between him, one Dawa Gyatso Bhutia and Phurba
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
Bhutia. On the intervention of police patrolling party, the
Appellant was sent home but soon returned to the spot
swinging a „khukuri‟ threatening to kill everyone and was
joined by his younger brother. On being over powered by the
police, the „khukuri‟ was disengaged from the Appellant. As
the crowd started dispersing, the Appellant picked up a
wooden beam from a pile of building materials lying nearby
and attacked the Victim fatally on his head from behind,
causing him to fall on the ground. He was evacuated to the
Rinchenpong Primary Health Centre and thereafter to Dr.
Chhang‟s Super Speciality Hospital, Matigara, Siliguri, where
he was declared “brought dead”. Hence, Charge-Sheet was
submitted under Section 302/324 IPC against the Appellant
while his brother, Jigmee Dorjee Bhutia and another suspect,
Kharga Bahadur Gurung, were discharged on account of
insufficient evidence. Later the Court would implead them as
accused but vide the impugned Judgment acquit them on
evidence lacking of their involvement.
11.
The learned Trial Court framed Charge against the
Appellant under Sections 302/34, 307 and 323 of the IPC and
against Jigmee Dorjee Bhutia and Kharga Bahadur Gurung
under Section 302/24 of the IPC. On their plea of “not guilty”,
the Prosecution examined 32 witnesses. The Appellant was
examined under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. thereafter and on
his plea afforded an opportunity to examine one Duryo Dhan
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
Pradhan, who he however failed to produce before the Court.
On arguments being heard and the evidence being considered,
the
impugned
Judgment
and
Order
on
Sentence
were
pronounced.
12.
While addressing the argument of learned Counsel
for the Appellant that the FIR, the Section 161 Cr.P.C.
statement of PW-1 and his evidence before the Court were
inconsistent, we may briefly consider the provisions of Section
154 of the Cr.P.C. which deals with information in cognizable
cases. The first information of the commission of a cognizable
offence is sufficient to constitute the first information report.
The object of the FIR is to set the criminal law in motion and it
nowhere envisages a narration of the entire details of the
offence. In Mahesh and another (supra), while considering the
arguments of the Appellant therein, that, when the first
information report which was filed by PW-1 after the incident,
the role attributed to the Appellants was not mentioned at all,
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed that
“10. ...... Besides, it is an established law that
so far as the first information report is concerned, it
is only a report submitted informing the police about
the commission of the crime. It is not required that
the said first information report should contain a
detailed and vivid description of the entire incident.
Further, it cannot be expected from the informant,
especially, when the informant is a relative of the
injured/deceased to give each and every minute
detail of the incident in the first information report.
.....................................................................”
[emphasis supplied]
It emanates therefore that the FIR is for the purpose of
promptly reporting an incident to set into motion the criminal
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
justice system, it does not necessarily have to be an
encyclopaedia of the events that unfolded.
13.
That having been said, we may now consider what
Section 161 Cr.P.C. statement pertains to. Under this Section,
the police investigating the matter can examine witnesses
acquainted with the facts of the case and reduce them to
writing without oath or affirmation. However, merely because
a particular statement made by the witness before the Court
does not find place in the statement recorded under Section
161 Cr.P.C., does not merit the evidence being thrown out.
[See Alamgir vs. State (NCT, Delhi)6]. Later in time, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in A. Shankar vs. State of Karnataka7, held that;
“17.
In
all
criminal
cases,
normal
discrepancies are bound to occur in the depositions of
witnesses due to normal errors of observation,
namely, errors of memory due to lapse of time or due
to mental disposition such as shock and horror at the
time of occurrence. Where the omissions amount to a
contradiction, creating a serious doubt about the
truthfulness of the witness and other witnesses also
make material improvement while deposing in the
court, such evidence cannot be safe to rely upon.
However, minor contradictions, inconsistencies,
embellishments or improvements on trivial matters
which do not affect the core of the prosecution case,
should not be made a ground on which the evidence
can be rejected in its entirety. The court has to form
its opinion about the credibility of the witness and
record a finding as to whether his deposition inspires
confidence. "Exaggerations per se do not render the
evidence brittle. But it can be one of the factors to
test credibility of the prosecution version, when the
entire evidence is put in a crucible for being tested on
the touchstone of credibility." Therefore, mere
marginal variations in the statements of a witness
cannot be dubbed as improvements as the same may
be elaborations of the statement made by the witness
AIR 2003 SC 282
AIR 2011 SC 2302
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
earlier. "Irrelevant details which do not in any way
corrode the credibility of a witness cannot be labelled
as omissions or contradictions." The omissions which
amount to contradictions in material particulars, i.e.,
materially affect the trial or core of the prosecution's
case, render the testimony of the witness liable to be
discredited. ............................................”
14.
In R. Shaji vs. State of Kerala8, the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court would hold that;
“61. ....... when the statement is recorded in
Court and the witness speaks under oath after he
understands the sanctity of the oath taken by him
either in the name of God or religion, it is thus left to
the Court to appreciate the evidence under Section 3
of the Evidence Act, 1872. The Judge must consider
whether a prudent man would appreciate evidence
and not appreciate the same in accordance with his
own perception. ............................................”
[emphasis supplied]
15.
On careful perusal of Exhibit-1, it is seen that PW-
1 has given information with regard to what transpired
between the SDF party workers, the Appellant and his brother
at Sribadam Bazaar leading to the assault on the deceased by
the Appellant. Thereafter, on meticulous examination of
Section 161 Cr.P.C. Statement of PW-1 as well as his
deposition before the Court, admittedly he has not witnessed
the assault on the Victim. Merely because he has not
elaborated his activities in Exhibit 1 and his Section 161
Cr.P.C.
Statement,
viz;
that he
had gone
for
medical
treatment and on not meeting the concerned doctor, attended
the Foundation Day programme of the SDF party, does not
render the evidence given by him unreliable. In any event,
these facts are not intrinsic or germane to the matter at hand
(2013) 14 SCC 266
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
and do not cause any prejudice to the Prosecution case. There
are no major contradictions in the FIR, the Section 161 Cr.P.C.
Statement and the statement of PW-1 before the Court to
raise any suspicion about the witness or the Prosecution case.
Hence, the above discussions answers the doubts raised by
learned Counsel for the Appellant.
16.
So far as the credibility of the testimony of the
witnesses furnished by the Prosecution goes merely because
they owe allegiance to a particular party while the Appellant
belongs to another party would not render the evidence
unreliable. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court while dealing with this
issue in Mano Dutt vs. State of U.P.9, held as follows;
“24. Another contention raised on behalf of the
appellant-accused is that only family members of the
deceased were examined as witnesses and they being
interested
witnesses
cannot
be
relied
upon.
Furthermore, the prosecution did not examine any
independent witnesses and, therefore, the prosecution
has failed to establish its case beyond reasonable
doubt. This argument is without much substance.
Firstly, there is no bar in law in examining family
members, or any other person, as witnesses. More
often than not, in such cases involving family members
of both sides, it is a member of the family or a friend
who comes to rescue the injured. Those alone are the
people who take the risk of sustaining injuries by
jumping into such a quarrel and trying to defuse the
crisis. Besides, when the statement of witnesses, who
are relatives, or are parties known to the affected
party, is credible, reliable, trustworthy, admissible in
accordance with the law and corroborated by other
witnesses or documentary evidence of the prosecution,
there would hardly be any reason for the court to reject
such evidence merely on the ground that witness was a
family member or an interested witness or a person
known to the affected party.”
[emphasis supplied]
(2012) 4SCC 79
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
17.
State of Sikkim
In Balraje vs. State of Maharashtra10, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court stated that;
“30. ......... When the eyewitnesses are stated
to be interested and inimically disposed towards the
accused, it has to be noted that it would not be
proper to conclude that they would shield the real
culprit and rope in innocent persons. The truth or
otherwise of the evidence has to be weighed
pragmatically. The Court would be required to
analyse the evidence of related witnesses and those
witnesses who are inimically disposed towards the
accused. But if after careful analysis and scrutiny of
their evidence, the version given by the witnesses
appear to be clear, cogent and credible there is no
reason to discard the same. ......”
[emphasis supplied]
18.
On the bed rock of the principles so enunciated,
the testimony of the Prosecution witnesses may be examined
to test their credibility or otherwise. PW-2 to PW-7, PW-9, PW11, PW-13, PW-14 and PW-17 were privy to the incident which
unfolded before them at the relevant time. PW-8, PW-10, PW12, PW-15 and PW-16 were tendered by the Prosecution being
repetitive witnesses. PW-19 to PW-32 was witnesses who were
not present at the spot, comprising of police personnel,
doctors and I.Os. PW-1 who lodged Exhibit-1, the FIR, did not
witness the incident as on being attacked by Jigmee Dorjee
Bhutia, he fled to his house and stayed inside until the Police
Inspector of Kaluk Police Station came and took him to the
Police Station. Further, it is his evidence that from inside his
house he heard people shouting that Narendra Kumar Gurung
was killed. The statements of PW-3, PW-4, PW-5, PW-6, PW-7,
PW-9, PW-11, PW-13, PW-14 and PW-17, is categorical that
(2010) 6 SCC 673
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
they witnessed the Appellant striking the deceased from
behind. It also emerges unequivocally from the evidence of
these witnesses that in fact, the deceased was trying to pacify
the disputing factions and advising them to disperse. At that
very moment, PW-17 called out to the deceased who turned to
go home from the place of occurrence. Evidently, finding the
moment to be propitious, the Appellant took the wooden beam
when the deceased turned his back and struck him on the
head leading him to falling on the ground. The evidence of
PW-17, that she was calling out to her brother, the deceased,
who then made to return home is firstly supported by the
evidence of PW-5 Suk Man Subba, according to whom PW-17
came from the other side calling out to her brother. His
evidence also finds support in the evidence of PW-6 Suren
Subba, who also deposed that the deceased was trying to
pacify the accused persons and requesting them to restrain
from such activities. He then saw PW-17 coming from the
opposite side calling out to the deceased. This fact was also
witnessed by PW-7 Dew Bahadur Subba. The fact that PW-17
was present at the spot is also substantiated by the evidence
of PW-9, PW-11 and PW-13. Evidence establishes the fact of a
fight between the supporters of SDF and SKM parties during
which time PW-1 was assaulted by Jigmee Dorjee Bhutia, the
brother of the Appellant leading to PW-1 hiding in the safety of
his home. PW-2 went to the house of PW-1 and telephoned
the police, on returning to the spot, he saw the Appellant and
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
the others shouting therein. According to PW-7, when PW-17
was calling out to her brother, he directed her to where the
deceased was. PW-17 also witnessed the Victim pacifying the
crowd. The deceased evidently was not an assailant. The
evidence so furnished and discussed supra was not decimated
under cross-examination. Merely because the Prosecution
witnesses belong to one political party does not relegate their
evidence to unreliability neither can the truth be attenuated.
Furthermore, the Court is vested with the task of separating
the chaff from the grain and only on such exercise can the
evidence
be
considered
trustworthy
or
otherwise.
The
evidence furnished is cohesive, consistent, inspires confidence
and is therefore reliable and trustworthy.
19.
So far as anomalies on the examination of the
Victim by the doctors is concerned, in the first instance the
argument that the death of the deceased due to the medical
negligence of PW-22 and not on account of the act of the
Appellant is to say the least appalling and incongruous and
merits no consideration. It is clear that PW-22, the Medical
Officer at Rinchenpong Primary Health Centre, examined the
deceased at around 8:40 p.m. After such examination, he
found a single hematoma about size 4 x 4 inches over the
occipital region. The finding of this doctor is supported by the
evidence of PW-29 Dr. Rumi Maitra. She has found the
following injuries on the person of the deceased;
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
“1.
Two liner abrasions 1” each, placed parallel to
each other separately by 1.25 cm, over dorsum(back)
of right hand.
2.
Abrasion 1 cm x 1cm over lateral surface (side
part) of right forearm 4” below the elbow joint.
3.
Abrasion 1cm x 1cm over lateral side of left
knee.
4.
Bruise 1” x 1” at the inner aspect of left arm
near axilla.
The said injuries are bright red in colour and
looked fresh and ante mortem in nature.
In the Cranium and spinal region, the
following injuries were found;Hematoma over both parietal and left occipital
region region. U-shaped depressed fractures 2” x 1”
over left side of occipital bone just above the left
occipital condyle.
Subdural hematoma found over both occipital
lobe and base of brain. The brain and Spinal Cord
were found – Congested.
..............................................................
All injuries noted above are bright red in
colour, fresh and ante mortem in nature. No other
injuries could be detected over body after careful
examination and dissection.
On examination of the dead body I found that
the dead (sic „death‟) was due to the effects above
noted head injury which is anti-mortem (sic „ante‟)
and homicidal in nature. Exhibit-24 already marked is
the post-mortem report prepared by me and Exhibit24(a) is my signature on it.
On being shown MO-II, I can say that the type
of injury found on the occipital region of the deceased
could be caused by MO-II.”
20.
PW-22 and PW-29, both doctors have found
injuries over the occipital region. Minor variance in the
measurement of the injuries or the number of injuries
detected or undetected cannot be said to be fatal to the
Prosecution case. Contrary to the submission of learned
Counsel for the Appellant that Exhibit-21 shows several
injuries, the document records no details of injuries save a
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
head injury. PW-29 has opined that the death was due to the
effects of the head injury. Hence, the collated evidence of the
doctors points to the fact of death due to the head injury on
the Victim. The argument that locus criminus was not
sufficiently lit is belied by the evidence of PW-2, PW-3 and
PW-13. In Gurmit Singh vs. State of U.P. (supra), the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court while upholding the conviction of the appellant
observed that it was a moonlit night and the accused were
known persons being family members, their identification was
upheld. Similarly, the parties herein belonged to the same
village and were familiar with each other. The evidence
undoubtedly leads one to the conclusion that the street lights
provided sufficient illumination to identify the assailant and
the Victim. Even if the evidence of PW-30 is disregarded, the
corroborative evidence of the other PWs with regard to the
adequacy of illumination cannot be wished away.
21.
On the question of the material objects, it is
evident that PW-20 and PW-21 were seizure witnesses to MO-I
and MO-II, iron rods seized from the place of occurrence and
the wooden beam, respectively. It is also evident that these
objects were used at the time of the incident since the
seizures were made by the I.O. at around 10 p.m., the same
evening from the place of occurrence i.e. in front of the house
of PW-1 by PW-31, the first I.O. of the case. The fact of
seizure has not been contradicted. It is no one‟s case that the
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
deceased was struck repeatedly at the same spot on his head
in which event it could be likely that the wooden beam would
contain hair and blood of the deceased but the assault was a
single assault. In the said circumstance, it is possible that no
blood would be found on MO-II, in any event the ocular
evidence
has
withstood
the
cross-examination
and
the
witnesses have in unfailing terms and corroborative evidence
stated that the assailant used the wooden beam. In this
context, we may beneficially turn to R. Shaji vs. State of Kerala
(supra);
“30 It has been argued by the Learned
Counsel for the Appellant, that as the blood group of
the blood stains found on the chopper could not be
ascertained, the recovery of the said chopper cannot
be relied upon.
31. A failure by the serologist to detect the
origin of the blood due to dis-integration of the
serum, does not mean that the blood stuck on the
axe could not have been human blood at all.
Sometimes it is possible, either because the stain is
insufficient in itself, or due to haematological changes
and plasmatic coagulation, that a serologist may fail
to detect the origin of the blood in question.
However, in such a case, unless the doubt is of a
reasonable dimension, which a judicially conscientious
mind may entertain with some objectivity, no benefit
can be claimed by the accused in this regard.
..................................................”
[emphasis supplied]
It would conclude that forensic evidence would not
necessarily be the penultimate to reach a conclusion of the
offence. Even if MO-II was forwarded for forensic analysis, it
cannot be ruled out that the expert could have failed to detect
blood due to several intervening factors.
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
22.
State of Sikkim
The argument that the Appellant was unarmed
does not appear to be truthful as PW-1 has stated that he was
armed, firstly with a „khukuri‟ and divested of it by the police
at the spot. Although, a din was raised about the failure of the
Prosecution to examine Duryo Dhan Pradhan, Head Constable,
thereby leading to adverse inference, Section 114(g) of the
Evidence Act, 1872, would apply with equal rigour to the
Appellant. Having sought to examine Duryo Dhan Pradhan as
his defence witness, he failed to furnish him before the Court
in support of his case with no reason furnished for nonexamination.
23.
The
argument
exhibited
an
exceptional
that
the
interest
State
while
Government
allocating
the
investigation to the CID is bereft of merit as undisputedly a
precious young life has been lost and the State is duty bound
to ensure that the best investigative efforts are made to bring
the culprits to book.
24.
The next argument that needs to be addressed is
that the matter at hand would fall under Section 304A of the
IPC. It would be essential at this juncture to refer to Section
300 of the IPC.
25.
Section 300 of the IPC reads as follows;
“300. Murder. - Except in the cases hereinafter
excepted, culpable homicide is murder, if the act by
which the death is caused is done with the intention
of causing death, or-
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
Secondly- If it is done with the intention of
causing such bodily injury as the offender knows to
be likely to cause the death of the person to whom
the harm is caused, orThirdly- If it is done with the intention of
causing bodily injury to any person and the bodily
injury intended to be inflicted is sufficient in the
ordinary course of nature to cause death, orFourthly- If the person committing the act
knows that it is so imminently dangerous that it
must, in all probability, cause death or such bodily
injury as is likely to cause death, and commits such
act without any excuse for incurring the risk of
causing death or such injury as aforesaid.”
26.
Five Exceptions are provided in the Section which
provides that culpable homicide would not be murder if the
offence is committed under the following;
“Exception 1. – Culpable homicide is not murder if
the offender, whilst deprived of the power of self-control by
grave and sudden provocation, causes the death of the
person who gave the provocation or causes the death of any
other person by mistake or accident.
.............................................................
First.
....
Secondly. ....
Thirdly.
....
Exception 2. - Culpable homicide is not murder if
the offender, in the exercise in good faith of the right of
private defence of person or property, exceeds the power
given to him by law and cause the death of the person
against whom he is exercising such right of defence without
premeditation, and without any intention of doing more
harm that is necessary for the purpose of such defence.
Exception 3. – Culpable homicide is not murder if
the offender being a public servant or aiding a public servant
acting for the advancement of public justice, exceeds the
powers given to him by law, and causes death by doing an
act which he, in good faith, believes to be lawful and
necessary for the due discharge of his duty as such public
servant and without ill-will towards the person whose death
is caused.
Exception 4. – Culpable homicide is not murder if it
is committed without premeditation in a sudden fight in the
heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel and without the
offender having taken undue advantage or acted in a cruel
or unusual manner.
Explanation. – It is immaterial in such cases which
party offers the provocation or commits the first assault.
Exception 5. – Culpable homicide is not murder
when the person whose death is caused, being above the
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
age of eighteen years, suffers death or takes the risk of
death with his own consent.”
27.
In the instant case, it is evident that the Appellant
was in the midst of a crowd of persons where the altercation
was ensuing. Although, the Victim was pacifying the crowd the
perception of the Appellant evidently was that the Victim was
also an aggressor. It is not denied that he had been waylaid
by the SDF supporters with regard to the obstruction at
Singling. It is in these circumstances and the ensuing fracas
that the Appellant has raised MO-II and assaulted the Victim.
The act was committed indubitably without premeditation, in a
sudden fight, in the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel and
without the Appellant having taken undue advantage or acted
in a cruel or an unusual manner. This assumption arises from
the circumstance that he struck the Victim only once on his
head and did not repeat the act. It cannot be denied that the
act of the Appellant was an instinct for self preservation.
Clearly, the offence would fall under Exception-4 of Section
300 of the IPC. The learned Trial Court in the impugned
Judgment has failed to explain in detail her reasons for
arriving at the conclusion that the offence fell under Section
304-Part I of the IPC, however from the circumstances
discussed hereinabove, it is clear that the offence falls under
Exception 4 of Section 300 of the IPC. The Appellant is guilty
of the offence under Section 304-Part II of the IPC as against
the finding of the learned Trial Court that it was under Section
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2016
Phurba Tenzing Bhutia vs.
State of Sikkim
304-Part I. It surely does not fall under Section 304A of the
IPC as learned counsel for the Appellant would have this Court
believe. The impugned Judgment thus stands modified to the
above extent.
28.
Considering
the
entirety
of
the
foregoing
discussions, this Court is of the considered opinion that no
infirmity arises in the conclusion of the learned Trial Court
save to the extent mentioned hereinabove.
29.
The impugned Judgment and Order on Sentence
thereby brooks no interference.
30.
Accordingly, Appeal is dismissed.
31.
Copy of this Judgment be transmitted to the
learned Trial Court for information.
32.
Records be remitted forthwith.
33.
No order as to costs.
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Acting Chief Justice
01.08.2018
Index
Internet
bp
: Yes / No
: Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review