Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:961
Serial No.06
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 393 of 2018
Date of Order:28.10.2024
____________________________________________________________
Shri. Phillony R. Marak
Vs. 1. The Garo Hills Autonomous.
Widow of (L) henry Sangma,
District Council, represented by its
R/o.Gangbanga Village
Secretary, Executive Committee,
P.O Barengapara, P.S. Dalu
West Garo Hills, Tura.
West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya.
2. The Chief Executive Member,
Garo Hills Autonomous District
Council, Tura.
3. The Executive Memebr, I/C
Revenue & Land, Garo Hills
Autonomous District Council,
Tura.
4.Smti. Nikme D. Sangma,
W/o.(L) Saljing Ch. Marak,
R/o. Magupara Village.
P.O. Barengapara, P.S. Dalu,
West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
….Petitioner.
….Respondents.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. P. T. Sangma, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Dey, Adv. R: 1 – 3.
Mr. S. P. Mahanta, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L. M. Sangma, Adv. R: 4.
2024:MLHC:961
ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. P. T. Sangma, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner
and Mr. S. Dey, learned Counsel appearing for the respondents No.1 – 3
also Mr. S. P. Mahanta, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. L. M.
Sangma, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent No.4.
1.
This writ petition relates to a dispute about the land known as
Adugachol. While the petitioner claims that Adugachol is a separate and
independent Akhing, the respondent No.4 contends that Adugachol is a
village falling within Magupara Akhing.
2.
The order dated 28-12-2017 passed by the Executive Member, I/C
Land & Revenue, Garo Hills Autonomous District Council (GHADC), Tura
in Case No.GHADC – Rev. A.C No. 35 of 2016 and the order dated 12-102018 passed by the Chief Executive Member in GHADC REV. APPL. No.
1 A/C of 2018 are under challenged in this writ petition. By the aforesaid
orders, the Adugachol was held to be a part of Magupara Akhing.
3.
Mr. P. T. Sangma, learned Counsel for the petitioner vehemently
argued that Adugachol Akhing was never a part of Magupara Akhing and
the same could not have been included in the Magupara Akhing by treating
it as a village. It is also the contention of the learned Counsel that the
Executive Member, I/C Land & Revenue, GHADC, Tura, while deciding
the dispute between the parties, has not taken into consideration the
established legal norms and gone ahead to decide the matter without
framing any issue, examining any witness and also without considering the
relevant documents on record. The learned Counsel has heavily relied on
the decision reported in (1988) 2 GLR 120, Smti. Dore Sangma & Ors.
2024:MLHC:961
Versus The Chief Executive Member, Garo Hills District Council, Tura &
Ors. (para – 20) and submitted that the directions made therein with regard
to the framing of issues, recording of evidence and consideration of
documents have been totally overlooked by the Executive Member, I/C
Land & Revenue, GHADC, Tura. He submitted that non-adherence to the
mandate of law led the said authority to come to a wrong finding. It is
further submitted by the learned Counsel for the petitioner that the Chief
Executive Member, GHADC, Tura, while deciding the appeal, has also
acted mechanically and wrongly upheld the decision of the Executive
Member, I/C Land & Revenue, GHADC, Tura in utter disregard of the
established norms of law. The learned Counsel submits that since both the
authorities of GHADC have not discharged their duty in deciding the
matter strictly in accordance with law, the orders dated 28-12-2017 and 1210-2018 are liable to be set aside and quashed.
4.
Per contra, Mr. S. Dey, learned Counsel for the respondents No.1 – 3
refuted the submission of the learned Counsel for the petitioner and
submitted that all the norms and procedures were followed by the GHADC
authorities while deciding the matter. The learned Counsel has taken this
Court to the relevant record of the GHADC and pointed out that the order
dated 17-12-2014 of the Executive Member reflected that the issues were
duly framed. The learned Counsel has further drawn attention of this Court
to certain statements submitted by some witnesses on their respective letter
heads and contended that the requisite evidences were also recorded in the
matter.
He further submitted that all the necessary documents were
considered by the authorities of the GHADC before passing the impugned
orders and, hence, the writ petition is devoid of merit and liable to be
dismissed.
It is also the submission of the learned Counsel that the
directions contained in the order of this High Court dated 26-08-2016
2024:MLHC:961
passed in WP(C) No. 215 of 2016 was strictly complied with while passing
the impugned orders, and, as such, the impugned orders do not suffer from
any illegality requiring interference of this Court.
5.
Mr. S. P. Mahanta, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
respondent No.4 submitted that the orders of the Executive Member, I/C
Land & Revenue as well as the Chief Executive Member, GHADC, Tura
were passed strictly in accordance with law and the said authorities have
meticulously taken into consideration all the evidences and documents
which were made available before them. The learned Senior Counsel has
taken this Court to the order dated 28-12-2017 of the Executive Member,
I/C Land & Revenue, GHADC, Tura and pointed out that the petitioner has
miserably failed to produce any relevant document before the said
authority. It is also the submission of the learned Senior Counsel that the
decisions rendered by the authorities of the GHADC were entirely based on
the evidences adduced by the parties and also the official documents
available on record. The learned Senior Counsel further contended that
Adugachol was never a separate Akhing at any point of time and all along
has been treated as a village falling within the Magupara Akhing. It is the
submission of the learned Senior Counsel that the contention of the
petitioner before this Court is devoid of any merit and the writ petition
deserves to be dismissed forthwith.
6.
Upon hearing the learned Counsels appearing for the parties and on
perusal of the materials on record, it is evident that the learned Executive
Member, I/C Land & Revenue, GHADC, Tura, during the course of
adjudication, by order dated 17-12-2014 has recorded that both the parties
were present and had filed suggested issues and the issues were accordingly
framed. It further appears that the learned Executive Member, I/C Land &
Revenue, GHADC, Tura in its order dated 28-11-2017 recorded that
2024:MLHC:961
witnesses of both the parties were examined by his predecessor in office.
However, a perusal of the record reveals that no oral statement of any
witness was recorded by the Executive Member, I/C Land & Revenue,
GHADC, Tura. The statements in writing which are pointed out by the
learned Counsel for the GHADC are not record of oral evidence. In fact,
those are all statements in writing submitted in the form of certificate on
the respective letter heads of the witnesses.
7.
The decision of Smt. Dore Sangma & Ors. (supra) at paragraph 20
lays down the following: “20. For all these reasons, we would hold that the Revenue
Member alone has jurisdiction to decide the types of disputes
at hand. But then while doing so, the Revenue Member has to
follow the fundamental principles of judicial procedure; these
being: (1) framing of issues which has been regarded as
necessary for courts to get the grip of the case.(See Vindeo V.
Ziakrwool, (1983) 1 GLR (NOC) 34). (2) Opportunity to lead
evidence on the issues framed – the evidence given could be
recorded in full or summary of the same could be noted; and
(3) hearing of the parties themselves or through their lawyers
if engaged. This apart, some other accepted principles of
sound judicial procedure like not allowing a document to be
used in a case without the other side having been given
opportunity to rebut the same should also be followed when
the case is taken up by the Revenue Member in the first
instance or by the Chief Executive Member on appeal.
Thus, it emerges from the above that the Revenue Member has to
follow fundamental principle of judicial procedure by framing issues which
have been regarded necessary to get the grip of the case. The Revenue
Member also has to provide opportunity to the parties to lead evidence on
the issues framed.
8.
In the present matter, there is nothing on record to show that parties
were given opportunity to lead evidence. Although, the impugned order
dated 28-11-2017 of the Executive Member, I/C Land & Revenue,
2024:MLHC:961
GHADC, Tura recorded that witnesses were examined, the relevant case
record does not show that any witness was examined. Further, the details of
the listed witnesses of the respective parties are also not traceable in the
record. The statements in writing pointed out by the learned Counsel for the
GHADC cannot be considered as oral evidence as those are not recorded by
the Executive Member, I/C Land & Revenue, by securing the physical
presence of the witnesses before him. Hence, it is clear that the Executive
Member, I/C Land & Revenue, GHADC, Tura has not decided the matter
by following the mandate of law laid down in the decision of Smti. Dore
Sangma and Ors. (supra) case.
9.
Further, perusal of the order dated 12-10-2018 of the Chief Executive
Member, GHADC, Tura in GHADC-REV Appeal No.1 A.C. of 2018 also
does not show that the appellate authority has dealt with the issues of
recording of evidence in the matter. Since, it is the mandate of law that the
Executive Member, I/C Land & Revenue, GHADC, Tura should decide the
matter only after providing opportunity to the parties to adduce evidence,
the order of the appellate authority also cannot be sustained in law.
10.
For the above reasons, the order dated 28-12-2017 passed by the
Executive Member, I/C Land & Revenue, GHADC, Tura in GHADC-REV
Appeal No.1 A.C. of 2018 and the order dated 12-10-2018 passed by the
Chief Executive Member, Garo Hills District Council, Tura are hereby set
aside and quashed.
Resultantly, the matter is remanded back to the
Executive Member, I/C Land & Revenue, GHADC, Tura for taking a
decision afresh strictly in accordance with the mandate of law laid down in
Smti. Dore Sangma and Ors. (supra) case. Needless to say that the parties
will have liberty to seek remedy available in law, in the event, if there
remains any grievance consequent to the decision taken by the Executive
Member, I/C Land & Revenue, GHADC, Tura.
2024:MLHC:961
11.
It is made clear that this Court has not gone into the merits of the
matter. It will be open for the Executive Member, I/C Land & Revenue,
GHADC, Tura to assess the merit of the case and decide the matter in
accordance with law.
An endeavor shall be made by the Executive
Member, I/C Land & Revenue, GHADC, Tura to dispose of the matter at
the earliest.
12.
With the aforesaid, this writ petition stands disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
28.10.2024
“Biswarup PS”
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.10.28 19:28:38 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review