Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:116
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 30th JULY, 2016
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------S.B. : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Petitioner
Mr. Phigu Tshering Bhutia,
S/o Late Dozi Tshering Bhutia,
Aged about 41 years,
R/o Simick Lingzey,
East Sikkim.
:
versus
Respondents
:
1.
The State of Sikkim
through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
The State Election Commissioner,
Amdo Golai, Tadong,
Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
3.
The Special Secretary,
Urban Development and Housing Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
Petition under Article 226
of the Constitution of India
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Chewang Norbu Bhutia, Advocate for the Petitioner.
Mr. J. B. Pradhan, Additional Advocate General with Mr. Karma
Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate, Mr. S. K. Chettri and Mrs.
Pollin Rai, Assistant Government Advocates, for the StateRespondents.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
By filing this Writ Petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, the Petitioner seeks a direction from this Court
to the Respondents to provide reservation of seats for the BhutiaLepcha (for short “B-L”), as an independent Community and LimbooTamang (for short “L-T”) as Scheduled Tribes, in the Municipal
Elections (held on 09-10-2015) to the Municipal Corporation/
Municipal Councils and Nagar Panchayats in the State.
2.
The Petitioner’s case is that in the previous Municipal
Elections held in 2010, seats had been reserved for the B-L as an
independent Community and for the L-T as Scheduled Tribes. Vide
the assailed Notifications bearing Nos. M(63)/GOS/UD&HD/MUN
/2015/23 and M(63)/GOS/UD&HD/MUN/2015/24 both dated 0109-2015, the reservations so made were withdrawn for the Sikkim
Municipal Elections of 2015.
The Petitioner also assails two
Notifications dated 09-09-2015 vide which details of process of
nomination and date for election respectively were fixed as “09-102015” for all Wards of the Municipal Corporation/Municipal
Councils/Nagar Panchayats in the State. The Petitioner avers that the
main inhabitants, i.e., the only ethnic Communities of Sikkim as per
its history, are the Lepchas, the Bhutias and the Nepalese.
Tracing
the history of Sikkim from 1947 when Sikkim was a British
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Protectorate and thereafter a Protectorate of India under the Treaty of
1950, reference was made to the Royal Proclamation of 28-12-1952 and
the provisions for reservation of seats for the B-L and the Sikkimese
Nepali. That the State Council set up, in 1952 provided for twelve
elected Members of which six were to be from the B-L Community
and the other six, from the Sikkimese Nepalese. By the State Council
and Executive Council Proclamation, 1953, dated 23-03-1953, a State
Council of eighteen Members, consisting of twelve elected Members,
five nominated Members and a President to be appointed by the
Maharaja was constituted.
The twelve elected Members were to
comprise of the B-L and Sikkimese Nepalese. In 1958, the strength of
the Council was increased to twenty, where the parity between B-L
and the Sikkimese Nepalese was maintained. By the Representation
of Sikkim Subjects Regulation, 1966, dated 21-12-1966, promulgated
by the then Chogyal, the State Council was to consist of Territorial
Constituencies of which seven comprised of B-L and seven were for
Sikkimese Nepalese, apart from one seat for the Sangha, one seat for
the Scheduled Castes, one for Tsong, one General seat and six to be
nominated by the Chogyal.
3.
Reference was also made to the Tripartite Agreement of
08-05-1973 which envisaged the rights of the people of Sikkim to
Elections on the basis of adult suffrage.
It also contemplated the
setting up of a Legislative Assembly in Sikkim to be reconstituted by
election every four years.
Clause (5) of the Tripartite Agreement
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
envisaged that the system of elections shall be so organised as to
make the Assembly adequately representative of the various sections
of the population. The size and composition of the Assembly and of
the Executive Council was to be such as may be prescribed from time
to time, care being taken to ensure that no single section of the
population acquired a dominating position due mainly to its ethnic
origin, duly protecting the rights of the B-L, Sikkimese Nepali, Tsong
and Scheduled Caste. Under The Representation of Sikkim Subjects
Act, 1974 the reservation of seats under this dispensation, inter alia,
was that the Assembly was to constitute of thirty two elected
Members of which sixteen Constituencies were reserved for
Sikkimese of B-L origin from which one was to be for Sangha. The
remaining sixteen Constituencies were to be reserved for the
Sikkimese Nepali including one for Tsongs and another for the
Scheduled Castes. The Sikkim Assembly was elected and constituted
and passed the Government of Sikkim Act, 1974. By the Constitution
(35th Amendment) Act, 1974, by inserting Article 2A of the
Constitution of India, Sikkim was given the status of an Associate
State. The Petitioner also averred to the abolishment of the Institution
of Chogyal of Sikkim by the Assembly in 1975 pursuant to which the
Constitution (36th Amendment) Act, 1975, came to be passed, giving
Statehood to Sikkim, duly repealing Article 2A of the Constitution.
Article 371F introduced by the 36th Constitutional Amendment with
effect from 26-04-1975 envisaged certain special conditions for the
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
admission of Sikkim as a new State in the Union of India of which the
Petitioner draws emphasis to Article 371F(f) of the Constitution which
provides as under;
“(f)
4.
Parliament may, for the purpose of protecting
the rights and interests of the different sections
of the population of Sikkim make provision for
the number of seats in the Legislative Assembly
of the State of Sikkim which may be filled by
candidates belonging to such sections and for
the delimitation of the Assembly constituencies
from which candidates belonging to such
sections alone may stand for election to the
Legislative Assembly of the State of Sikkim;”
It was further averred that the Election Laws (Extension
to Sikkim) Act, 1976, sought to extend, with certain provisions, The
Representation of the People Act, 1950 (for short “1950 Act”) and The
Representation of the People Act, 1951 (for short “1951 Act”), to
Sikkim.
Section 25A of the 1950 Act provides for conditions of
registration as elector in Sangha Constituencies, in Sikkim. By the
Representation of the People (Amendment) Ordinance, 1979,
amendments were introduced to the above two Acts to enable fresh
elections to the Sikkim Assembly on certain basis considered
appropriate to and in conformity with the historical evolution of
Sikkim’s political institutions. The Ordinance was later replaced by
The Representation of the People (Amendment) Act, 1980, by which
Sub-Section (1A) was inserted in Section 7 of the Representation of
the People Act, 1950, which provided for seats in the Legislative
Assembly to the various Communities of Sikkim and the Sangha.
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
5.
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
In 1982, vide in a Writ Petition transferred to the Hon’ble
Apex Court from this Court being R. C. Poudyal vs. Union of India
and Others1 the Petitioner assailed the constitutionality of the
provisions for reservation of seats in favour of B-L and the Sangha.
The Hon’ble Apex Court formulated certain points for discussion in
the matter as extracted below;
1. 1994 Supp (1) SCC 324
“(a)
Whether the questions raised in the petitions
pertaining as they do to the terms and conditions
of accession of new territory are governed by
rules of public international law and are nonjusticiable on the ‘political questions doctrine’?
(b)
Whether clause (f) of Article 371-F of the
Constitution of India, introduced by the
Constitution (Thirty-sixth Amendment) Act,
1975 is violative of the basic features of
democracy?
(c)
Whether Section 7(1-A) and Section 25-A of the
Representation of the People Act, 1950 [as
inserted by Election Laws (Extension to Sikkim)
Act, 1976 and Representation of the People
(Amendment) Act, 1980 respectively] and
Section 5-A(2) of the Representation of the
People Act, 1951 [as inserted by the
Representation of the People (Amendment) Act,
1980] providing for reservation of 12 seats, out of
32 seats in the Sikkim Legislative Assembly in
favour of Bhutias-Lepchas, are unconstitutional
as violative of the basic features of democracy
and
republicanism
under
the
Indian
Constitution ?
(d)
Whether the aforesaid provisions and the
reservations made thereunder are violative of
Articles 14, 170(2) and 332 of the Constitution ?
Whether they violate ‘one person one vote’ rule?
Or are these differences justified in the historical
background of Sikkim and are incidental to the
political events culminating in the cession of
Sikkim ?
(e)
Whether the reservation of 12 seats out of 32
seats reserved for Bhutias-Lepchas is ultra vires
of clause (f) of Article 371-F in that while that
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
provision enabled the protection of the rights
and interests of different sections of population
of Sikkim and for the number of seats in the
Legislative Assembly which may be filled by the
candidates belonging to such sections, the
impugned provisions provide for one section
alone, namely, the Bhutias-Lepchas.
(f)
Whether, at all events, in view of the
Constitution (Sikkim) Scheduled Tribes Order,
1978, declaring Bhutias and Lepchas as a
Scheduled Tribe, the extent of reservation of
seats is disproportionate and violative of
Article 332(3) of the Constitution which requires
that the number of seats to be reserved shall bear
as nearly as may be, the same proportion to the
total number of the seats in the Assembly as the
population of the Scheduled Tribe in the State
bears to the total population of the State.
(g)
Whether the reservation of one seat for Sangha
to be elected by an Electoral College of Lamaic
monasteries is based purely on religious,
distinctions and is, therefore, unconstitutional as
violative
of
Articles 15(1) and 325 of
the
Constitution and as violative of the principle of
secularism ?”
The Hon’ble Apex Court supra while deciding the aforesaid
points held as under;
(i)
the questions raised in the petitions pertaining
to the terms and conditions of accession of new
State are justiciable.
(ii)
Clause (f) of Article 371-F of the Constitution of
India, is not violative of the basic features of
democracy.
(iii)
That impugned provisions providing for
reservation of 12 seats, out of 32 seats in the
Sikkim Legislative Assembly in favour of
Bhutias Lepchas, are neither unconstitutional as
violative of the basic features of democracy and
republicanism under the Indian Constitution
nor are they violative of Article 14, 170(2) and
332 of the Constitution.
The impugned
provisions are also not ultra vires of clause (f) of
Article 371-F.
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
(iv)
The extent of reservation of seats is not violative
of Article 332(3) of the Constitution.
(v)
The reservation of one seat for Sangha to be
elected by an Electoral College of Lamaic
monasteries is not based purely on religious
distinctions
and
is,
therefore,
not
unconstitutional as violative of Article 15(1) and
325 of the Constitution.
Thus, the Hon’ble Apex Court specifically held that reservation of
seats in favour of the B-L independently is not unconstitutional.
6.
That, in the year 2007, the Sikkim Municipalities Act,
2007, was enacted which provided for Municipal Governance in the
State of Sikkim and for the first time in 2010, elections were held in
the
Municipal
Corporation,
Municipal
Councils
and
Nagar
Panchayats in the State. In exercise of powers conferred by Section 15
of the Sikkim Municipalities Act, 2007, the State Election Commission
reserved seven seats separately for the B-L and four seats for the L-T
Communities in consonance with the Judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in R. C. Poudyal’s1 case (supra). The reservation of the seats for
L-T Communities was extended in view of the fact that the said
Communities were notified as a Scheduled Tribes under Articles
243D, 243T and 332 of the Constitution of India in 2003.
Vide the
assailed Notifications dated 01-09-2015, no such separate provisions
have been made for the B-L Community in a departure from its
earlier Notification dated 10-03-2010. That, in 2015 election, the total
number of seats have increased to fifty-three as against forty-seven in
the 2010 elections.
That, in view of the aforesaid facts and
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
circumstances and the legal position with respect to Article 371F of
the Constitution in the Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in R.
C. Poudyal’s1 case (supra) a direction be issued to the Respondents to
make provision for reservation of seats for the B-L Community
independently and for the L-T Community as Scheduled Tribes for
the Municipal Elections.
7.
The Respondents No.1 and 3 filed a joint Counter-
Affidavit while the Respondent No.2 filed a separate CounterAffidavit. Denying and disputing the claims of the Petitioner, the
Respondents No.1 and 3 submitted that Part IXA of the Constitution
deals
with
the
Municipalities,
while
the
Constitution
(74th
Amendment) Act, 1992, introduced Articles 243P to 243ZG.
That
Article 243T provides for reservation of seats in every Municipality
and provides as follows;
“243T. Reservation of seats.−(1) Seats shall be
reserved for the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled
Tribes in every Municipality and the number of seats
so reserved shall bear, as nearly as may be, the same
proportion to the total number of seats to be filled by
direct election in that Municipality as the population of
the Scheduled Castes in the Municipal area or of the
Scheduled Tribes in the Municipal area bears to the
total population of that area and such seats may be
allotted by rotation to different constituencies in a
Municipality.
..............................................................”
The same Article also provides for reservation of women
belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, etc. That
Article 243ZG of the Constitution debars the Courts from interfering
in electoral matters and provides as follows;
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
“243ZG. Bar to interference by courts in
electoral matters.−Notwithstanding anything in this
Constitution,−
(a)
the validity of any law relating to the
delimitation of constituencies or the allotment of
seats to such constituencies, made or purporting
to be made under article 243ZF shall not be
called in question in any court;
(b)
no election to any Municipality shall be called in
question except by an election petition
presented to such authority and in such manner
as is provided for by or under any law made by
the Legislature of a State.”
It is averred that in view of the provisions contained in Article
243T, as per the Constitutional Scheme for the Municipalities the
reservation of seats are provided only to Scheduled Castes and
Scheduled Tribes. Further, Clause (6) of Article 243T also empowers
the Legislature of the State to make provisions for reservation of seats
in any Municipality or Offices of Chairpersons in the Municipality in
favour of Backward Class of citizens.
Besides this provision, there
are no other provisions in the Constitution providing reservation in
the Municipality on the basis of Community.
8.
That, Section 15 of the Sikkim Municipalities Act, 2007,
which was published in the Sikkim Government Gazette No.193 on
09-05-2007 provides that the State Government may by Notification
reserve seats for the Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, the
Backward Class citizen and most Most Backward Class citizen in
every Municipality. Thus, considering the Constitutional Scheme,
providing for reservation of seats in the Municipalities, Notification
dated 01-09-2015 was issued under Section 15 of the Sikkim
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Municipalities Act, 2007, and published in Sikkim Government
Gazette bearing no.330 dated 01-09-2015, notifying the reservation of
seats in the Municipal Corporation, Municipal Councils and Nagar
Panchayats within the State of Sikkim for Sikkim Municipal Elections,
2015. Out of fifty-three Municipal Wards and seats, fifteen seats have
been reserved for Scheduled Tribes and six seats for the Scheduled
Castes, eleven for OBC (Central List) and nine for OBC (State List)
respectively. That the B-L have been declared as Scheduled Tribes by
The Constitution (Sikkim), Scheduled Tribes Order, 1978 and in the
year 2003, L-T were also declared as Scheduled Tribes, hence, the B-L
are eligible to contest from the seats reserved for the Scheduled
Tribes. That Article 371F provides for special provisions with respect
to the State of Sikkim of which Clauses (d), (f) and (m) have been
extracted by the Respondents No.1 and 3.
It is vehemently denied
that in the year 2007 seats were reserved separately for Bhutia,
Lepcha, Limboo and Tamang Communities as per the Judgment
rendered in R. C. Poudyal’s1 case (supra).
That, in view of the
aforesaid facts and circumstances, the Writ Petition is not
maintainable in Law as well as on facts and is liable to be dismissed.
9.
The Respondent No.2 placed reliance on Section 15(1) of
the Sikkim Municipalities Act, 2007 and also relied on the CounterAffidavit of the Respondents No.1 and 3 submitting that the said
Respondents had set out in detail the Constitutional Scheme
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
providing reservation of seats in the Municipalities vide Notifications
dated 01-09-2015.
10.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner and Respondent Nos.
1 and 3, apart from their verbal submissions also submitted their
Written Arguments.
11.
The Petitioner reiterated the facts set out in the Writ
Petition and drew the attention of this Court to the provisions of
Article 371F of the Constitution and emphasised that the Article
begins with a non obstante Clause. That in view of the language used
in the special provision it is evident that Article 371F shall have an
overriding effect over Article 243T and Article 243ZG. That, it is a
settled legal position that in case of conflict between two provisions
under the same Statute the special provision having a non obstante
Clause shall prevail over the other provision.
12.
Inviting the attention of this Court to the decision in R. C.
Poudyal’s1 case (supra) it was held that the Hon’ble Apex Court
upheld the validity of Article 371F(f) inspite of “The Constitution
(Sikkim) Scheduled Tribes Order, 1978”, declaring the B-L as a
Scheduled Tribe and held that the extent of reservation extended to
said Communities is not violative of Article 332 of the Constitution.
That, though Article 243ZG also has a non obstante Clause, conflict in
such cases is resolved by considering the purpose and policy
underlying the enactment and the language used and Article 371F
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
being a later provision shall prevail over the earlier one, i.e., Article
243ZG. Besides, which, it is also relevant to consider whether any of
the two provisions can be described as a special one, in which case the
special provision shall prevail over the general provision.
That,
Article 226 confers extraordinary jurisdiction to the High Court and
the bar contemplated under Article 243ZG is subject to judicial review
under Article 226. That, when the action of the Election Commission
affects the purity and probity of the election, cutting to the very root
of the democratic process a petition under Article 226 is maintainable.
It is urged that Article 371F(f) shall have an overriding effect over
Article 243T, 243ZG of the Constitution and Section 15 of the Sikkim
Municipalities Act, 2007.
13.
The State-Respondents for their part also reiterated the
facts set out in their Counter-Affidavits. Attention of this Court was
once again invited to the provisions of Article 243 of the Constitution
which bars interference by the Courts in electoral matters, while also
referring to the Order of this Court in I.A. No.01 of 2015 dated 06-102015 in the instant Writ Petition, whereby the prayer seeking stay of
the two Notifications dated 01-09-2015 was rejected by this Court. It
was contended that Rule 121 of the Sikkim Municipalities (Conduct of
Election) Rules, 2007, provides that no election shall be called in
question except by an Election Petition in accordance with the
provisions of this part.
Considering the above provisions in the
Constitution as well as the Sikkim Municipalities (Conduct of
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Election) Rules, 2007, the prayer for quashing the Notifications dated
01-09-2015 is liable to be rejected. That, Article 243T provides for
reservations of seats for Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes and
makes no provision for any specific community within the criteria.
14.
The Respondents also took the assistance of the decision
in Mani Subrat Jain and Others vs. State of Haryana and Others2 by
which a three Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Apex Court held that no
one can seek a mandamus without a legal right, that there must be a
judicially enforceable right as well as a legally protected right before
one suffering a legal grievance can ask for a mandamus.
Moreover,
Clause (f) to Article 371F enables the Parliament to provide for
reservation of seats in the Legislative Assembly of the State of Sikkim
for various sections of the population in order to protect their rights
and interests.
The said Article is not applicable in the facts and
circumstances of the present case which is governed by Article 243T
of the Constitution.
15.
That, with regard to the Judgment of R. C. Poudyal’s1
case (supra) the Petitioner therein, had challenged the provisions of
Sub-Section (1A) of Section 7 of the Representation of People Act,
1950 and Sub-Section (2) of Section 5A of the Representation of People
Act, 1951 vide which separate reservations were provided in the
Legislative Assembly in Sikkim for the B-L Communities and the
2. (1977) 1 SCC 486
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Sangha relying on Clause (f) of Article 371F of the Constitution.
However, in the present case, no such reservation has been provided
under Article 243T of the Constitution. That the law laid down in R.
C. Poudyal’s1 case (supra) is altogether different as the Parliament had
exercised their power and amended
the provisions of the
Representation of People Act to provide for reservation for the B-L
Community and the Sangha.
That, the Petitioner although not
entitled to any reliefs in the Writ Petition, however, it is always open
for him to challenge the election by filing an Election Petition as
provided by Rule 122 of the Sikkim Municipalities (Conduct of
Election) rules, 2007. Hence, the Writ Petition be dismissed.
16.
The contentions of Learned Counsel were heard at length
by me and given due consideration.
17.
The pith and substance that can be culled out from the
submissions and arguments of Learned Counsel for the Petitioner is
that in view of the Judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in R. C.
Poudyal’s1 case (supra), inter alia, upholding the reservation of twelve
seats out of thirty two seats in the Legislative Assembly in favour of
B-L as neither unconstitutional or violative of the basic features of
democracy, the same interpretation be carried over to the Municipal
Elections, thereby granting separate reservation to the Bhutia and
Lepchas, while providing separate reservation for the L-T as
Scheduled Tribes.
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
18.
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Article 371F of the Constitution was inserted by the
Constitution (36th Amendment) Act, 1975, providing for special
provision with respect to the State of Sikkim. The Article consists of
sixteen clauses and commences with a non obstante clause, i.e.,
“Notwithstanding anything in the Constitution”. The nature of
operation and scope of a non obstante clause was explained in Vishin
N. Khanchandaniand Another vs. Vidya Lachmandas Khanchandani
and Another3 as follows;
“11. ........................ There is no doubt that by
non obstante clause the Legislature devices means
which are usually applied to give overriding effect to
certain provisions over some contrary provisions that
may be found either in the same enactment or some
other statute. In other words such a clause is used to
avoid the operation and effect of all contrary
provisions. The phrase is equivalent to showing that
the Act shall be no impediment to measure intended.
To attract the applicability of the phrase, the whole of
the section, the scheme of the Act and the objects and
reasons for which such an enactment is made has to be
kept in mind.”
19.
In Aswini Kumar Ghose and Another vs. Arabinda Bose
and Another4 it was held that “the enacting part of a statute must
where it is clear be taken to control the non obstante clause, where both
cannot be read harmoniously. In South India Corporation (P) Ltd.
vs. Secretary, Board of Revenue, Trivandrum and Another5 the Apex
Court observed as follows;
“(19) ..................... The phrase “notwithstanding
anything in this Constitution” is equivalent to saying
that in spite of other articles of the Constitution, or that
other articles shall not be an impediment to the
operation of Art. 278. ..............”
3. AIR 2000 SC 2747
4. AIR 1952 SC 369
5. AIR 1964 SC 207
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Thus, in the event of a conflict of any of the clauses of Article
371F with the provisions of any other Article of the Constitution the
former will prevail, regardless of the contents of the other provisions.
What follows indubitably, therefore, is that the vires of the clauses of
Article 371F cannot be challenged. The above discussion is warranted
to consider the question as to whether Article 371F being a special
provision for the State of Sikkim will have an overriding effect on
Article 243T and Article 243ZG.
20.
Reverting to the relevant history, by The Constitution
(Sikkim) Scheduled Tribes Order, 1978, the B-L Community were
deemed to be Scheduled Tribes in relation to the State of Sikkim. By
insertion of Clause (1A) in Section 7 of the Act of 1950, the total
number of seats to be reserved for the B-L in the Legislative Assembly
of the State of Sikkim was laid down. For better appreciation of the
matter the Section is quoted hereinbelow;
“7. Total number of seats in Legislative
Assemblies and assembly constituencies.−............
.....................................................................................
(1A) Notwithstanding anything contained in
sub-section (1), the total number of seats in the
Legislative Assembly of the State of Sikkim, to be
constituted at any time after the commencement of the
Representation of the People (Amendment) Act, 1980 (8
of 1980), to be filled by persons chosen by direct
election from assembly constituencies shall be thirtytwo, of which−
(a)
twelve seats shall be reserved for
Sikkimese of Bhutia-Lepcha origin;
(b)
two seats shall be reserved for the
Scheduled Castes of that State; and
(c)
one seat shall be reserved for the Sanghas
referred to in section 25A
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Explanation.−In this sub-section “Bhutia”
includes Chumbipa, Dopthapa, Dukpa, Kagatey,
Sherpa, Tibetan, Tromopa and Yolmo.”
By insertion of Section 5A in the Act of 1951, the qualifications
for membership of Legislative Assembly of Sikkim was detailed. The
Section reads as follows;
“5A. Qualifications for membership of
Legislative Assembly of Sikkim.−(1)Notwithstanding
anything contained in section 5, a person shall not be
qualified to be chosen to fill a seat in the Legislative
Assembly of Sikkim (deemed to be the Legislative
Assembly of that State duly constituted under the
Constitution) unless−
.........................................................”
Section 5A(a) lays down that, in the case of a seat reserved for
Sikkimese of Bhutia-Lepcha origin, he is a person either of Bhutia or
Lepcha origin and is an elector for any Assembly constituency in the
State other than the constituency reserved for the Sanghas. Therefore,
the above legal provisions being self-explanatory and need no further
elucidation.
21.
In R. C. Poudyal’s1 case (supra) it was, inter alia, argued
with the help of certain demographic statistics that the degree of
reservation of seats of 38 per cent for a population of B-L of 20/25 per
cent (Paragraphs 134 and 178) was disproportionate.
As per the
majority Judgment authored by Venkatachaliah, J., it was, inter alia,
held at Paragraphs 133, 134 and 135 that –
“133. ........................... But, in our opinion,
Clause (f) of Article 371-F is intended to enable, a
departure from Article 332(2). .................................
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
134. ................... This again has to be viewed in
the historical development and the rules of
apportionment of political power that obtained
between the different groups prior to the merger of the
territory in India. A parity had been maintained all
through.
135. We are of the opinion that the provisions
in the particular situation and the permissible latitudes,
cannot be said to be unconstitutional.”
As per the Judgment supra of Agarwal, J. (partly dissenting) at
Paragraph 179, inter alia, held as follows;
“179. ...................... The reservation of seats for
Bhutias and Lepchas is necessary because they
constitute a minority and in the absence of reservation
they may not have any representation in the
Legislative Assembly. ............................
180. The second contention relating to the extent
of the reservation of seats for Bhutias and Lepchas is
based on the provisions of Article 332(3) of the
Constitution. Clause (3) of Article 332 postulates that
the number of seats reserved for Scheduled Castes or
Scheduled Tribes in the Legislative Assembly of the
State shall bear, as nearly as may be, the same
proportion to the total number of seats in the Assembly
as the population of the Scheduled Castes or the
Scheduled Tribes in the State bears to the total
population of the State. The said provision has,
however, to be considered in the light of Clause (f) of
Article 371-F which provides:
“(f) Parliament may, for the purpose of
protecting the rights and interests of the different
sections of the population of Sikkim make
provision for the number of seats in the
Legislative Assembly of the State of Sikkim
which may be filled by candidates belonging to
such sections and for the delimitation of the
assembly constituencies from which candidates
belonging to such sections alone may stand for
election to the Legislative Assembly of the State
of Sikkim.”
181. ........................... The non-obstante clause
in Article 371-F enables Parliament to make a departure
from the ratio contemplated by Article 332(3) within the
limitation which is inherent in the power conferred by
Article 371-F, i.e., not to alter any of the basic features
of the Constitution. ..............................” [emphasis supplied]
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Thus, the Apex Court held that the reservation for the B-L
Community in the Legislative Assembly was not violative of Article
14 of the Constitution in view of the peculiar circumstances as
discussed supra.
The Judgment discusses the disproportionate
reservation of seats for the B-L Community over and above the
provisions of Article 332(3) of the Constitution in the Legislative
Assembly of the State and why a departure from Article 332 is
justiciable in the circumstances that existed.
Therefore, the non
obstante clause of Article 371F(f) had an overriding effect over Article
332 of the Constitution for reservation of seats in the Legislative
Assembly.
22.
At this juncture, it would be appropriate to discuss what
a Municipality is.
“While Panchayats are the institutions of local
self-Government in rural areas called ‘villages’ as
specified in the notifications issued by the Governor of
a State, the Municipalities (Part IX-A) are the
institutions of self-Government in the urban area,
called a ‘Metropolitan Area’ as specified in the
Governor’s notification issued under Art.243P.
A Municipality may be constituted for a
‘municipal area’, which is a part of a ‘metropolitan
area’ as specified by the Governor. In specifying an
area to be a municipal area, the Governor shall take
into consideration its size, the municipal services
provided or proposed to be provided by an industrial
establishment in that area.
Such areas, again, will be divided, having regard
to their populations, the revenue generated for local
administration, the percentage of employment in nonagricultural activities and the like,−into three
categories viz.,−(a) a ‘transitional area’, i.e., an area in
transition from a rural to an urban area; (b) ‘a smaller
urban area’ and (c) ‘a larger urban area’.
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
For the three categories aforesaid, the municipal
institution shall be called−
(a) A ‘Nagar Panchayat’ for a transitional area;
(b) A Municipal Council for a smaller urban
area; and
(c) A ‘Municipal corporation’ for a larger urban
area [Art.243Q].
As in the case of the Panchayats, similar
provisions are made, for election to a Municipality
[Art.243R], reservation of seats for Scheduled Castes
and Tribes and their women [Art.243T]; Finance
Commission [Art.243Y]; State Election Commission
[Art.243ZA].
.........................................................”
[See Shorter Constitution of India, Dr. Durga Das
Basu, Fourteenth Edition 2009, Volume 2, Page 1640]
The above extract clears the air as to the position of the
Municipality. Thus, Municipality by no stretch of any interpretation
can be brought into the ambit of a Legislative Assembly.
23.
Article 371F(f) clearly lays down that the Parliament may,
for the purpose of protecting the rights and interests of the different
sections of the population of Sikkim, make provision for the number
of seats in the Legislative Assembly of the State of Sikkim. This
provision obviously relates to reservation of seats in the Legislative
Assembly and does not envision reservation in the Municipal
Elections.
The decision in R. C. Poudyal’s1 case (supra) was also
confined to reservation in the Legislative Assembly and did not
venture into the field of reservation in local administrative bodies.
When no express provision exists in Article 371F for reservation in the
Municipal Bodies, it is axiomatic that the question of non obstante
clause of Article 371F having an overriding effect on Article 243T of
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
the Constitution pertaining to reservation of seats in the Municipal
Elections, does not arise. Thus, I am of the considered opinion that
the question of having separate reservations for the B-L Community
in the Municipal Elections over and above what has been enshrined in
Article 243T of the Constitution is not tenable. Apart from the above
observations, I find no documents have been placed on record to
substantiate the submission of the Petitioner that the reservation of
seats in the 2010 Municipal Elections were in terms of the Judgment in
R. C. Poudyal’s1 case (supra).
24.
It may also be relevant to point out here that the Statute
is an edict of the Legislature and the conventional way of interpreting
or construing a Statute is to seek the intention of its maker.
The
Courts cannot read beyond what the Statute speaks.
25.
So far as the question of bar to interference by Courts in
electoral matters as provided under Article 243ZG of the Constitution,
while referring to the Order of this Court in I.A. No.01 of 2015, this
Court while considering the application of grant of interim stay of two
Notifications supra both dated 01-09-2015 opined that, these
Notifications had been issued in exercise of powers conferred by
Section 15 of the Sikkim Municipalities Act, 2007 (5 of 2007) declaring
reservation of seats in Municipalities. The Notification No.13/SEC/
2015 dated 09-09-2015 vide which the schedule of election had been
notified was also considered, according to which polling was to take
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
place on 09-10-2015. Refusing to stay the Notification, it was Ordered
that if the effect and operation of the above two Notifications of 01-092015 are stayed, the consequence of that would be staying the
forthcoming election of 09-10-2015. Reference was made to Article
243ZG(b) which provides that no election to any Municipality shall be
called in question except by an election petition presented to such
authority and in such manner as is provided for by or under any law
made by the Legislature of a State. Relying on the decision of the
Election Commission of India Through Secretary vs. Ashok Kumar
and Others6, the application as already stated was rejected.
26.
In the same vein, the Hon’ble Apex Court while holding
that the High Court ought not to interfere in matters pertaining to
Elections held in Boddula Krishnaiah and Another vs. State Election
Commissioner, A.P. and Others7 observed as follows;
“9. The same principle was laid down in Lakshmi
Charan Sen v. A.K.M. Hassan Uzzaman [(1985) 4 SCC 689 :
1985 Supp (1) SCR 493]. In this case where the election
process was set in motion the High Court granted ad
interim injunction of the further proceedings of the
election to the State Legislature. A Constitution Bench
of this Court had held thus: (SCC pp.708-09, para 30)
“The High Court acted within its
jurisdiction in entertaining the writ petition and
in issuing a rule nisi upon it, since the petition
questioned the vires of the laws of election. But,
with respect, it was not justified in passing the
interim orders dated February 12 and 19, 1982
and in confirming those orders by its judgment
dated February 25, 1982. Firstly, the High Court
had no material before it to warrant the passing
of those orders. The allegations in the writ
petition are of a vague and general nature, on the
basis of which no relief could be granted.
Secondly, though the High Court did not lack
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
the jurisdiction to entertain the writ petition and
to issue appropriate directions therein, no High
Court in the exercise of its power under
Article 226 of the Constitution should pass any
orders, interim or otherwise, which has the
tendency or effect of postponing an election,
which is reasonably imminent and in relation to
which its writ jurisdiction is invoked. The High
Courts must observe a self-imposed limitation
on their power to act under Article 226, by
refusing to pass orders or given directions which
will inevitably result in an indefinite
postponement of elections to legislative bodies,
which are the very essence of the democratic
foundation and functioning of our Constitution.
That limitation ought to be observed irrespective
of the fact whether the preparation and
publication of electoral rolls are a part of the
process of 'election' within the meaning of
Article 329(b) of the Constitution.”
At p. 497 it was further held that: (SCR Headnote p.497)
“Even assuming, that the preparation and
publication of electoral rolls are not a part of the
process of 'election' within the meaning of
Article 329(b), the High Court ought not to have
passed the impugned interim orders, whereby it
not only assumed control over the election
process but, as a result of which, the election to
the Legislative Assembly stood the risk of being
postponed indefinitely.”
10. The same principle was reiterated when the
election to the Gram Panchayat was sought to be stalled
in State of U. P. v. Pradhan, Sangh Kshettra Samiti [1995
Supp (2) SCC 305] . The Court observed thus: (SCC pp.
331-32, para 45)
“What is more objectionable in the
approach of the High is that although Clause (a)
of Article 243-O of the Constitution enacts a bar
on the interference by the courts in electoral
matters including the questioning of the validity
of any law relating to the delimitation of the
constituencies or the allotment of seats to such
constituencies made or purported to be made
under Article 243-K and the election to any
panchayat, the High Court has gone into the
question of the validity of the delimitation of the
constituencies and also the allotment of seats to
them. We may, in this connection, refer to a
6. (2000) 8 SCC 216
7. (1996) 3 SCC 416
2016:SHC:116
WP(C) No.60 of 2015
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
decision of this Court in Meghraj Kothari
v. Delimitation Commission [(1967) 1 SCR 400]. In
that case, a notification of the Delimitation
Commission whereby a city which had been a
general constituency was notified as reserved for
the Scheduled Castes. This was challenged on
the ground that the petitioner had a right to be a
candidate for Parliament from the said
constituency which had been taken away. This
Court held that the impugned notification was a
law relating to the delimitation of the
constituencies or the allotment of seats to such
constituencies made under Article 327 of the
Constitution, and that an examination of
Sections 8 and 9 of the Delimitation Commission
Act showed that the matters therein dealt with
were not subject to the scrutiny of any court of
law. ...............................”
27.
Bearing in mind the decisions hereinabove, no further
discussions are required on this count. As there is a specific bar to
interference by Courts in electoral matters, I would not be inclined to
wade into forbidden waters.
28.
For the aforesaid reasons, the Writ Petition fails and is
accordingly dismissed.
29.
No order as to costs.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
30-07-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review